Results
Phen ot ypic as soc iat ion bet we e n end omet riosis and i m mune condit ions
The phenotypic association between endometriosis and immunological conditions was
investigated in the UK Biobank (UKBB) using both cross-sectional and retrospective cohort study
designs, with the latter assuming endometriosis as a diagnostic risk factor preceding an
immunological disease diagnosis (see Methods). For the cross-sectional analysis, 8,223
endometriosis cases vs. 265,181 female controls without known endometriosis were included; and
64,620 immunological disease cases vs. 208,784 female controls without known immunological
diseases. Supplementary Table 1 shows factors that were determined as potential confounders or
mediators in the association analyses between endometriosis and immunological diseases. Adding
factors significantly associated with both endometriosis and immunological diseases in a logistic
regression model with endometriosis as exposure and any immunological disease as the outcome
(see Methods), none were found to be confounders or mediators that significantly affected the
effect size of association (>5% change). However, genetically determined ancestry and age at
recruitment were included a-priori as potential confounders.
In both the cross-sectional and retrospective cohort analyses (Table 1), females with
endometriosis vs. those without had a significantly increased risk for all immunological diseases
combined (OR: 1.32 (1.25-1.39); HR: 1.32 (1.20-1.45)), classic autoimmune diseases (OR: 1.24
(1.13-1.36); HR: 1.41 (1.15-1.74)), aut oinflammatory diseases (OR: 1.33 (1.26-1.41); HR: 1.29 (1.17-
1.43)), and mixed-pattern diseases (OR: 1.23 (1.10-1.52); HR: 1.88 (1.25-2.81)).
Immunological diseases significantly associated with endometriosis in both cross-sectional and
cohort analyses were: rheumatoid arthritis (OR:1.22 (1.04-1.41), P = 0.011; HR: 1.57 (1.18-2.10), P
= 0.002); coeliac disease (OR: 1.35 (1.06-1.70), P = 0.011; HR: 1.99 (1.30-3.07), P = 0.002); and
osteoarthritis (OR: 1.35 (1.27-1.43), P < 0.001; HR: 1.31 (1.19-1.44), P < 0.001). In addition, in the
‘gold standard’ cohort analyses, p soriasis (HR: 1.67 (1.05-2.65), P = 0.030) was significantly
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
associated with endometriosis. One immunological condition significantly associated with
endometriosis in cross-sectional analysis, systemic lupus erythematosus (OR:1.62 (1.14-2.24),
P=0.005), myasthenia gravis ( OR: 2.55 (1.30-4.49), P=0.003) and gout (OR:1.66 (1.18-2.26),
P=0.002), could not be tested in a cohort study design due to insufficient case numbers. Overall,
females with endometriosis compared to females without known endometriosis exhibited a 14%
increased risk for at least having one immunological disease (OR = 1.14 (1.08-1.21)), a 21%
increased risk for at least having two immunological diseases (OR = 1.21 (1.05-1.39)), and a 30%
increased risk for having at least three immunological diseases (OR = 1.30 (0.92-1.78)) at any point
in their lifetime (P < 0.001) (Supplementary Table 2).
When stratifying by menopausal status, gynaecological surgery (hysterectomy/oophorectomy), or
hormone replacement therapy (HRT) use, effect sizes for the association between endometriosis
and overall immunological disease risk remained largely unchanged (Supplementary Table 3).
G en etic c or relatio n between e n dom etr iosis and imm unological dis ease s
For a total of eight immunological diseases associated with endometriosis either in cross-sectional
or cohort analyses (ankylosing spondylitis, coeliac disease, inflammatory bowel disease, multiple
sclerosis, osteoarthritis, psoriasis, rheumatoid arthritis, and systemic lupus erythematosus), we
conducted female-only and sex-combined European ancestry GWAS analyses in UKBB (Table 2,
See Methods). To achieve the greatest power to detect variants associated with each disease, sex-
combined UKBB GWAS results were meta-analysed with existing GWAS summary statistics based
on the largest sample sizes where available (Table 2), using the inverse vari ance weighted fixed-
effects method as implemented in METAL (Supplementary Figures 1-8).
Utilising the GWAS meta-analysis summary results for the immunological diseases and the largest
published endometriosis GWAS meta-analysis result s (excluding UKBB GWAS results to achieve
sample independence)
16 , we applied linkage disequilibrium (LD)-score regression (LDSC)
analysis 17,18 to estimate the genetic correlation (rg) between endometriosis and the eight
immunological diseases. Osteoarthritis (rg=0.29, p=3.25x10 -15 ), rheumatoid arthritis (rg=0.26,
p=1.54x10 -5 ) and multiple sclerosis (r g=0.09, p=4.00x10 -3 ) showed significant (p<6.25x10 -3 , see
Methods) positive genetic correlations (rg) with endometriosis, suggesting a shared genetic
component (Table 3).
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
M en delian rando mis at ion (MR) anal yse s
MR analyses using genetic instrumental variables (IVs) were conducted to further investigate a
potential causal relationship between endometriosis (exposure) and the increased risk of
osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis, and multiple sclerosis (outcomes) observed in the phenotypic
association and genetic correlation analyses. Table 4 shows the results from the main MR-IVW
model, with weighted median MR and MR-Egger regression provided as sensitivity analyses to test
the robustness of the results. Analyses were conducted utilising 39 genome-wide significant
(p<5x10
-8 ) endometriosis associated LD-independent autosomal variants as IVs. Summary statistics
for the IVs were extracted from UKBB female-only and meta-analysed sex-combined GWAS results
to represent the outcomes of the three immunological diseases (see Methods).
For endometriosis vs. rheumatoid arthritis, utilising the 39 IVs illustrated a suggestive causal
relationship between endometriosis vs. rheumatoid arthritis in females-only (OR [95%CI] = 1.16
[1.02-1.33], p-value=0.028). For endometriosis vs. osteoarthritis, and vs. multiple sclerosis, the MR
analysis did not identify a significant causal relationship in either sex-combined or female-only
analyses (Table 4).
M u lti-tr ait analysis of endom et riosis and im munological diseases: oste oar thrit is , r heumat oid
art hr it i s and mu ltiple sc ler os is
To leverage the genetic sharing of association signals between endometriosis and osteoarthritis,
rheumatoid arthritis, and multiple sclerosis for the discovery of additional endometriosis risk
variants, we conducted a multi-trait analysis of GWAS (MTAG). MTAG capit alises on the genetic
correlation between diseases to boost statistical power for detecting associations in genome-wide
analyses
19 . The MTAG analysis was conducted for all four diseases simultaneously and identified
42 genome-wide significant lead SNPs for endometriosis (Supplementary Table 4), 6 of which were
not reported previously 16 (Supplementary Figure 9a-f). These 6 genetic variants are eQTLs for
various genes across multiple tissues including MS RA and PO N 2 protecting and repairing cells from
oxidative stress in blood 20,21 , BLK and ZAP70 encoding enzymes belong to Tyrosine kinase family
with roles in cell proliferation and differentiation in particular B-cell and T-cell development and
adhesion 22,23 , ATRAID , S LC35F6, TMEM214 and XKR6 involved in apoptosis-related pathways 24,25
and, TRPS1 encoding a transcription factor that represses GATA-regulated genes involved in
progesterone resistance and endometriosis progression in the pelvis 26 (Supplementary Table 5).
The MTAG analysis for osteoarthritis yielded 27 significant variants (Supplementary Table 6), for
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
rheumatoid arthritis yielded 28 significant variants (Supplementary Table 7) and for multiple
sclerosis, it identified 64 genome-wide significant variants (Supplementary Table 8).
Functional ann otatio n of ide nt ified g enome- wi d e s ignificant var iants and path way a nalysis
We mapped genome-wide significant asso ciations from each MTAG analysis for endometriosis,
osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis, and multiple sclerosis to the genes whose expression they are
associated with, using GTEx V8 (54 tissues) and eQTLGen (31,684 blood datasets). We identified
439 genes regulated by 42 genome-wide significant endometriosis associated variants; 379 genes
by 27 genome-wide significant osteoarthritis associated variants (Supplementary Table 6); 490
genes by 28 genome-wide significant rheumatoid arthritis variants (Supplementary Table 7); and
1,113 genes by 64 genome-wide significant multiple sclerosis associated variants (Supplementary
Table 8). Of the 439 genes regulated by endometriosis risk variants, 192 were also regulated by a
genome-wide significant risk variant of one or more of the other immune diseases (Figure 1).
Pathway analysis (see Methods) based on the identified genes per disease identified numerous
canonical pathways enriched with these genes (Supplementary Table 9-12). Among the top
enriched pathways for endometriosis was ‘ s ignalli ng by receptor t y r os ine kinases’, a major class of
cell surface proteins involved in signal transduction which triggers many downstream signalling
pathways including NF k B , MA PK and AKT. These pathways are activated in endometriosis and
have been suggested to harbour potential targets for non-hormonal therapeutics
27 .
Investigating the overlap of enriched genetically driven pathways between endometriosis,
osteoarthritis, multiple sclerosis, and rheumatoid arthritis, we discovered that 45 out of the 79
enriched pathways for endometriosis were also enriched in the other immune conditions (Figure
2). In total 7 enriched pathways were shared across all four conditions, including ‘ signalli ng by
receptor t yrosi ne kin as e s ’, ‘innate im mune s y stem’ , ‘adaptive immune syst em’ , ‘ extr ac ellular
matr ix or ganis at ion ’ , ‘leuk ocyte tr ans- endot helia l migration’ , ‘l ipi d me t abo lis m’, and ‘a rachidonic
aci d metabo lis m’ (Supplementary Figure 10). Within these overlapping enriched pathways, there
are genes shared between conditions and also genes specific to each condition contributing to the
pathway. For example, of the 21 genes enriched from endometriosis in ‘ signa l l ing by reception
tyrosine kinas e ’, 8 are shared with osteoarthritis, including N CF4 , LAMB2, RHOA, MS T1, MST1R,
MA PKAPK3, D O CK3 , and P TK2 B, and 3 are shared with multiple sclerosis including IT GB3 , PRK CA ,
and MM P9 (Supplementary Figure 10a). Another enriched pathway across the 4 conditions is
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
‘ arachidonic ac i d met abo lis m’ ; of the 5 endometriosis genes enriched in this pathway, 4 are
shared with the other 3 immune conditions, namely, D P EP3 , G P X1, D PE P2 , and PON2 ( Figure 2i) .
Ident ification of shar ed ge netic v a r iants betw een e ndom et riosis and im mune dis eas e s
A total of 12 osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis and multiple sclerosis gen ome-wide significant
lead SNPs were mapped within 1Mb of endometriosis genome-wide significant lead SNPs, with
four of them tagging the same signal (r
2 >0.5) (Table 5, Supplementary Figure 9a-f). Three of these
were shared with osteoarthritis ( BMPR2/2q33.1, BSN /3p21.31, and ML L T10 /10p12.31), and one
with both osteoarthritis and rheumatoid arthritis ( XKR6/8p23.1). MTAG association results of the
12 genome-wide significant endometriosis SNPs for osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis and
multiple sclerosis are provided in Supplementary Table 13.
At the BMPR 2/ 2q33.1 locus, the lead SNPs rs72928925 for endometriosis and rs72928605 for
osteoarthritis are both eQTLs for BMP R2 in blood and oesophagus muscularis (Supplementary
Table 14). BMP R2 encodes a member of the BMP receptor family of transmembrane
serine/threonine kinases. The ligands of this receptor are members of the TGF-beta superfamily.
The TGF-beta signalling pathway, involved in diverse cellular processes including cell proliferation,
differentiation, apoptosis, and migration invasion, was also one of the pathways enriched with 10
eQTL genes regulated by endometriosis, osteoarthritis and multiple sclerosis associated variants
(Figure 2, Supplementary Tables 9-12).
At the BSN /3p21.31 locus, the lead SNP rs6774202 associated with endometriosis and rs6809879
with osteoarthritis are both eQTLs for a diverse set of overlapping genes (Table 5) that are part of
pathways enriched between endometriosis and the other three immune conditions
(Supplementary Tables 9-12). In particular, RH O A is part of the ‘ leukocy t e trans-endot hel i al
migrat io n’ pathway that was enriched across all four conditions.
A thir d sh ar ed locus i s XKR6 / 8p 23.1 , where the lead endometriosis SNP rs12542037 is in strong LD
with the lead genome-wide significant osteoarthritis and rheum atoid arthritis SNPs (Table 5). This
locus is involved in the regulation of multiple genes, namely BLK, CT S B , and MTM P9 , which play
roles in innate and adaptive immune system pathways
28 . In addition, FD F T1 , regulated by the
correlated genetic risk variants, encodes for squalene synthase that is involved in cholesterol
biosynthesis. The ‘ lipid metabol ism pathway’ is also enriched with genes r egulated by genetic
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
variants in each of the investigated 4 conditions (Supplementary Tables 9-12, Figure 2 and
Supplementary Figure 10f).
The fourth locus previously implicated and described for endometriosis and osteoarthritis is
MLLT10 /10p12.31, which harbours genes such as MLLT10 associated with pain perception and
maintenance in multiple tissues
16 .
D iscu s sion
Our study of UKBB data reveals a significant increase in the risk of auto-immune and auto-
inflammatory diseases among endometriosis patients, particularly in rheumatoid arthritis (HR:
1.57 (1.18-2.10), P = 0.002), coeliac disease (HR: 1.99 (1.30-3.07), P = 0.002), osteoarthritis (HR:
1.31 (1.19-1.44), P < 0.001), and psoriasis (HR: 1.67 (1.05-2.65), P = 0.030). Given the age at
recruitment into UKBB (40-69 years, in 2006-10) and changes in awareness of endometriosis over
time, the proportion of diagnosed females in UKBB (8,223 cases in 273,404 females = 0.03%) is
relatively low compared to population prevalence estimates (up to 10%
1 ) . This would have
resulted in the undiagnosed females driving effect sizes for associations towards the null 29,30 .
Nevertheless, our results are consistent with evidence from previous case/control and cohort
studies which showed significant association between endometri osis rheumatoid arthritis (RR:1.46
(0.70-3.03), coeliac disease (RR:1.39( 1.14-1.70)), multiple sclerosis (OR:7.1 (4.4-11.3)) 14 and
psoriasis (RR:1.75 (1.10-2.78)) 31 . For systemic lupus erythematosus, cross-sectional evidence
showed significant evidence (OR: 1.62 (1.14-2.24)) but we didn’t have enough cases to carry out
the cohort study analysis. However, there is previous longitudinal evidence showing increased risk
of systemic lupus erythematosus (HR:2.03 (1.17-3.51))
32 . Moreov er, endometriosis patients
compared to females without endometriosis were at increased risk of suffering from multiple
immunological diseases which was most pronounced for autoinflammatory diseases
(Supplementary table 2). This trend was observed in an early adulthood cohort study which we
now expand to a broader age range.
Our genetic correlation analysis suggests that genetic factors contribute to the association
between endometriosis and the increased risk of rheumatoid arthritis (rg=0.27, P=1.54x10
-5 ),
osteoarthritis (rg=0.28, P=3.25x10 -15 ), and to a lesser extent, multiple sclerosis (rg=0.09,
P=4.00x10 -3 ). The significant genetic correlation between endometriosis and an immunological
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
condition can be attributed to multiple mechanism s as investigated through MR analyses: (1)
endometriosis causally leads to the subsequent development of the immunological condition; (2)
endometriosis and the immunological condition share a common genetically driven cause; or (3)
endometriosis and the immunological condition share multiple common causes, and the direction
of effect between them can be complex
33 . Genetic correlation analyses are more powerful when
the genetic architecture between conditions is polygenic involving many causal SNPs of small
effect to l everage their aggregated effects, which is the case for endometriosis and the
immunological conditions we studied here.
The MR analyses yielded no robust evidence of causal relationships between endometriosis and
genetically correlated immunological conditions, except for a suggestive causal effect of
endometriosis on rheumatoid arthritis in females-only (OR=1.16, 95% CI=1.02-1.33, p=0.028). MR
analysis provides insights into whether the association between two complex conditions is causal
by utilising genetic variants associated with the exposure (endometriosis). However, it is assumed
that the genetic variants utilised as IVs have strong predictive power of the exposure, and the
recommendation is to limit these to genome-wide significant (GWS) associated variants. However,
even GWS variants as instruments often modestly predict the exposure, which can limit the power
of MR an alysis
34 . The 39 endometriosis associated variants included as IVs in our MR analyses
explain <2% of heritable variation (5% of stage III/IV disease 16 ) which has implications for the
interpretation of non-significant MR results. Our MR instruments would have been weighted
towards risk for stage III/IV disease, in particular ovarian endometrioma
16 . Previous studies
associating risk of auto-immune and inflammatory conditions with endometriosis included
predominantly stage I/II cases
32,35 , although some of this evidence was based on adolescents who
may have been genetically predisposed to develop stage III/IV disease later in li fe 35 . Another
Limitation
we encounter is a lack of available female-specific immunological disease GWAS meta-
analysis results, which is surprising given that many immunological conditions exhibit higher
prevalence in females. We conducted female-specific GWAS analyses in the UK Biobank, however,
sample sizes were limited compared to sex-combined GWAS meta-analysis for these conditions in
the literature.
The suggestive causal effect of endometriosis on rheumatoid arthritis is intriguing and warrants
further exploration in the future, with IVs that explain a greater proportion of the genetic
variability for endometriosis. This will require larger endometriosis GWAS to uncover m ore genetic
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
variants contributing to the polygenic component of endometriosis. A large-scale female-specific
rheumatoid arthritis GWAS meta-analysis should also result in a more relevant dataset to explore
its potential causal basis with endometriosis. While power limitations hamper the interpretation
of causal relationships between endometriosis and osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis, or multiple
sclerosis, results of the genetic correlation analyses highlight a shared genetic basis.
Understanding the basis of genetic sharing regardless of causality is important, as shared
biological mechanisms of pathogenesis and pathophysiology could open new avenues for
treatment development.
The MTAG analyses, leveraging genet ic correlations between endometriosis, osteoarthritis,
rheumatoid arthritis and multiple sclerosis, identified 42 genome-wide significant loci for
endometriosis, 6 of which were not identified before: AB H D 1 / 2p23.3, TMEM131/ 2q11.2,
XRCC4/ 5q14.2, PP P1R9 A/ 7q21.3, XK R 6 / 8p23.1 and TR PS1/8p23.3. These variants were eQTLs for
various genes involved in protecting and repairing cells from oxidative stress, in B-cell and T-cell
development, apoptosis-related pathways and regulation of progesterone resistance. The MTAG-
derived 42 GWS lead endometriosis-associated variants were mapped to 439 genes, 27 GWS lead
osteoarthritis SNPs to 379 genes, 28 GWS lead rheumatoid arthritis SNPs to 490 genes and 64
GWS lead multiple sclerosis variants t o 1113 genes. When we considered the overlap between
these genes, 43.7% of endometriosis eQTL genes were shared with at least one of the three
immunological conditions; the majori ty with osteoarthritis (33%) followed by multiple sclerosis
(11.6%) and rheumatoid arthritis (7%). Pathway analysis revealed that 50.6% of pathways enriched
in gene lists for endometriosis were also enriched in multiple sclerosis, 26.6% in osteoarthritis and
16.5% in rheumatoid arthritis. Seven pathways were enriched across endometriosis and all three
immune conditions, including large, general immune regulatory pathways ‘ i nn ate immune system’
(1100 genes) and ‘adaptive immune sy stem’ (807 genes). A more specific shared pathway was
‘ si gn al ling by receptor tyrosine k inase s ’. Receptor tyrosine kinases are a large family of cell-surface
receptors that involved wide-variety inter and intra-cellular signalling. Previous studies have
su ggested the involvement of kinase signalling pathways and potential non-hormonal treatment
targets therein for endometriosis
27 , which our analyses support. Another shared pathway,
‘ extracellular matr ix or g anisatio n’, included MMP9, PRKCA and ITGB3 . MMP9 encodes for a
metalloproteinase that has a purported role in the progression of invasion in endometriosis as
well as angiogenesis and fibrosis
36 , has involvement in a variety of inflammatory autoimmune
diseases, and has been suggested to be a therapeutic target for autoimmune conditions 37,38 .
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
PRKCA is involved in immune cell trafficking and ITG B 3 is coding for integrin beta3 expression of
which is associated with autoimmune conditions including multiple sclerosis 39 .
Intriguingly,‘ ar ac hidonic aci d metabo l ism’ was another shared pathway, including four genes
shared between endometriosis and osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis and multiple sclerosis
(D PEP 3, G P X1, D PE P2 and PON2). Arachidonic acid is an essential fatty acid ingested through diet.
Arachidonic acid derived prostaglandins contribute to inflammation through their role as
intercellular pro-inflammatory mediators, and promote excitability of the peripheral
somatosensory system contributing to pain exacerbation 40 .
Among the GWAS loci and effectors genes we identified through MTAG and eQTL analyses, three
were shared between endometriosis and osteoarthritis ( BMPR2/2q33.1, BS N /3p21.31, and
MLLT10 /10p12.31), and one, XKR6 /8p23.1, between endometriosis and rheumatoid arthritis.
MLLT10 has been associated with pain perception and maintenance across multiple tissues and
has been previously described 16 . BMPR2 encodes a member of BMP receptor family of
transmembrane serine/threonine kinases, acting as receptor for the TGF-beta superfamily. SNP s at
the BSN/ 3p21.3 1 locus are eQTLs for various genes in cluding RH O A , part of the ‘ leukoc yte t rans-
endothel ial mi grat io n’ pathway that is enriched across all four conditions. Leukocytes migrate
from blood into tissues as part of inflammation and immune surveillance. During this process
leukocytes bind to cell adhesion molecules and migrate across the vascular endothelium. Another
interesting eQTL gene asso ciated with variants at BS N/3p21.31 is HY A L 3 , which is involved in the
hyaluronan/hyaluronic acid metabolism and glycosaminoglycan degradation pathways. Hyaluronic
acid is a naturally occurring glycosaminoglycan most abundant in the extracellular matrix involved
in various physiological processes including wound healing, tissue regeneration and joint
lubrication. It is also used for relief of joint pain, wound healing and various other applications,
and has been shown to reduce production of proinflammatory mediators, reduce sensitivity
associated with osteoarthritis pain
41,42 . Recent in-vivo and in-vitro studies suggest that hyaluronic
acid may have the ability to reduce endometriosis lesion size in mice but that it may also promote
inflammation when administered acutely 43 , suggesting further research into mechanism of action
and therapeutic potential in endometriosis is needed.
XKR6/8p23 .1, shared between endometriosis and rheumatoid arthritis, was asso ciated with the
regulation of multiple genes including BLK, CTSB, and MTM P9 - which play roles in innate and
adaptive immune system pathways
28 – and FDFT1 , involved in cholesterol biosynthesis.
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
Cholesterol is a precursor of steroid hormones and essential part of plasma membranes. It is also
enriched in lipid rafts which play an important part in many cellular processes including signal
transduction pathways, membrane trafficking, cytoskeletal organisation, apoptosis, cell adhesions
and migration
44 . In the context of inflammatory conditions, lipid metabolism has been suggested
to harbour targets for reducing inflammation without the undesirable side-effects of anti-
inflammatory therapies 45 .
As mentioned, our analyses were limited by the lack of large-scale female-specific GWAS meta-
analyses for immune conditions, particularly those exhibiting higher prevalence in females. It is
well established that sex-specific genetic signatures are present for conditions showing variability
by sex
46 , and female-specific GWAS r esults for immunological conditions may offer increased
genetic correlations with endometriosis and opportunities for discovery and shared genetic
signals. Future genetic comorbidity analyses should also explore results for different
endometriosis subtypes. Recent GWAS analyses have suggested that ovarian endometriosis has a
different genetic basis to peritoneal disease
16 , but the sample sizes for which summary statistics
were generated did not allow for sufficiently powered inclusion in the present analyses. Similarly,
future analyses should explore signals for different subtypes of immunological diseases, such as
osteoarthritis
47 , once larger GWAS datasets become available. Lastly, genetic analyses were
limited to European ancestry individuals and larger GWAS across more diverse ancestry groups are
needed.
In conclusion, our results show that females with endometriosis are at a modestly (30-40%)
increased risk of both auto-immune and auto-inflammatory conditions, and that comorbidity with
osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis, and to a more limited ex tent multiple sclerosis, is biologically
underpinned. In terms of clinical relevance, we suggest awareness among treating physicians of
this increased risk of comorbidity, in order to spot early symptoms of immunological conditions
among females with endometriosis, and vice versa. While current clinical action is limited to
increased vigilance, the results offer a wide range of novel avenues and targets for exploring
mechanism s and potential cross-condition treatment development or repurposing.
Me t h o d s
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
Phen ot ypic an alysis s t ud y pop ulatio n and disea s e a sc er tainme nt
The UK Biobank (UKBB) is comprised of 500K individuals aged 40-69 at time of recruitment (2006-
2010) from across the UK. The biobank was approved by the North West M ulti-Centre Research
Ethics Committee (MREC). In the UKBB, information was collected from participants during
recruitment using questionnaires on socioeconomic status, behavioural, family history and
medical history. Participants were also followed up for cause-specific morbidity and mortality
through linkage to disease registries, death registries, hospital admission records and primary care
data. In addition, a range of biological samples including blood, urine and saliva were collected
from the participants. A more detailed description of the UKBB can be found in the UK Biobank
protocol
48 .
Given that endometriosis is a gynaecological condition affecting those assigned female at birth,
only the individual’s assigned female at birth (N=273,404) were included in the phenotypic
association analysis with the immunological conditions. From this point onwards we will refer to
those assigned female at birth as females in this manuscript. Endometriosis was identified based
on self-reported data from questionnaires and/or hospital records (ICD10/9: N801-809 and 617.1-
9). A total 31 immunological conditions were identified from self-reported data and/or hospital
records (ICD 10/9) that were classified into three groups (94) as following: (1) autoinflammatory
conditions: Acne (ICD10/9: L70* and 7060, 7061), acute respiratory distress syndrome (ICD10/9:
J80, P220, 769, 769.9), erythema nodosum (ICD10/9: L52, 6952) , giant cell/Takayasu arteritis
(ICD10/9: M314, M315, M 316, 4465, 4467), gout/pseudogout (ICD10/9: M10*, M11*, 274, 2740,
2741, 2748, 2749, 712, 7120, 7121, 7122, 7123, 7128, 71280, 71281, 71282, 71283, 71284, 71285,
71286, 71287, 71288, 71289, 7129, 71290, 71291, 71292, 71293, 71294, 71295, 71296, 71297,
71298, 71299), total inflammatory bowel disease (ICD10/9: K50, K500, K501, K508, K509, K51,
K510, K511, K512, K513, K514, K515, K518, K519, 555, 5550, 5551, 5552, 5559, 556, 5560, 5569),
Crohn’s disease (ICD10/9: K50, K500, K501, K508, K509, 555, 5550, 5551, 5552, 5559) Ulcerative
colitis (ICD10/9: K51, K510, K511, K512, K513, K514, K515, K518, K519, 556, 5560, 5569),
osteoarthritis (ICD10/9: M15, M150, M1500, M151, M152, M153, M154, M158, M159, M1599,
M16, M160, M161, M162, M163, M164, M165, M166, M167, M169, M17, M170, M171, M172,
M173, M174, M175, M179, M18, M180, M181, M182, M183, M184, M185, M189, M19, M190,
M1900, M1911, M1912, M1913, M1914, M1915, M1916, M1917, M1918, M1919, M192, M1920,
M1921, M1922, M1923, M1924, M1925, M1926, M1927, M1928, M1929, M198, M1980, M1981,
M1982, M1983, M1984, M1985, M1986, M1987, M1988, M1989, M199, M19990, M 1991, M1992,
M1993, M1994, M1995, M1996, M1997, M1998, M1999, 715, 7150, 7151, 71510, 71511, 71512,
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
71513, 71514, 71515, 71516, 71517, 71518, 71519, 7152, 71520, 71521, 71522, 71523, 71524,
71525, 71526, 71527, 71528, 71529, 7153, 71530, 71531, 71532, 71533, 71534, 71535, 71536,
71537, 71538, 71539, 7158, 7159), sarcoidosis (ICD10/9: D860, D861, D862, D863, D868, D869,
135, 1359), (2) classical autoimmune conditions: Addison’s disease (ICD 10/9: E271, E272, 25540,
25542), autoimmune gastritis(ICD10/9: D510, 2810), autoimmune thyroid disease (ICD10/9: E050,
E063, 2420, 2452), Graves’ disease (ICD10/9: E050, 2420), Hashimoto’s disease (ICD10/9: E063,
2452), coeliac disease (ICD10/9: K900, 5790), dermatomyositis/polymyositis (ICD10/9: M33*,
M360, 7103, 7104), multiple sclerosis (ICD10/9: G35, 340), myasthenia gravis (ICD10/9: G70, G700,
G701, G702, G708, G709, 358, 3580, 35800, 35801, 35809, 3581, 3582, 3588, 3589),
pemphigus/pemphigoid (ICD10/9: H133, L10, L100, L101, L102, L103, L104, L105, L108, L109, L12,
L120, L121, L122, L123, L128, L129, 6944, 6945, 6946), primary biliary cirrhosis (ICD10/9: K743,
5716), rheumatoid arthritis (ICD10/9: M05*, M06*, 714, 7140, 71400-71409, 7141, 71410-71419,
7142, 71420-71429), Sjögren's syndrome (ICD10/9: M350, 7102), systemic lupus erythematosus
(ICD10/9: M32*, L90*, 6954, 7100), systemic sclerosis (ICD10/9: M34*, 5172, 7101), type 1
diabetes (ICD10/9: E10*, 25001, 25011, 25021, 25091), vitiligo (ICD10/9: L80, 70901), (3)
Combination of autoinflammatory and autoimmune condition categories: Ankylosing spondylitis
(ICD10/9: M081*, M45*, 7200), Behcet’s syndrome (ICD10/9: M352, 1361, 7112), reactive arthritis
(ICD10/9: M023*, 0993, 7111), psoriasis/psoriatic arthritis/psoriatic arthropathies (ICD10/9: L40*,
M070*, M073*, 6961, 6960). A common control set was defined as females without
endometriosis diagnosis excluding anyone with diagnoses of any of the 31 immunological
conditions.
Potential confounding or mediating factors were determined including age of recruitment,
genetically determined ancestry, menopause status, age at menarche, parity, body size, BMI and
fat distribution
49 , alcohol consumption, smoking, infertility and disease such as ovarian cancer 50
and cardiovascular disease 51 , which h ave been illustrated to be associated with endometriosis and
some immunological conditions. Age at recruitment (which represents potential age-related
cohort effects) and ancestry were considered a-priori variables to be included in the models. Many
of the other factors were assessed only at baseline recruitment into UKBB, which for most females
would have followed rather than coincided with, or preceded, an endometriosis diagnosis, and
therefore the potential for confounding vs. mediation effects could not be accurately assessed.
Nevertheless, to assess their potential impact on the associations, factors associated both with
endometriosis and immunological disease were include in a logistic regression model with
endometriosis as exposure and immunological disease as outcome. None of these factors either
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
showed >5% change in effect (potential confounders) or removal of effects (mediators), and
therefore only a-priori variables age at recruitment and genetically determined ancestry were
included in the models.
Phen ot ypic as soc iat ion analysis
Phenotypic association analysis between endometriosis and immune conditions was conducted
utilising two different analysis methods: (1) a cross- sectional analysis to test for a simple
association between risk of an immunological disease diagnosis with a diagnosis of endometriosis
at any point in time, including all fem ales in the UKBB; (2) a ‘gold standard’ cohort study design to
incorporate temporality between diagnoses, where entry time was defined as the recruitment
date into UKBB. Cross-sectional analysis was conducted for 26 immunological disease that had at
least 100 female cases in UK Biobank. A total of 5 immune conditions were excluded from analysis
due to number of cases <100: Reactive arthritis (N=4), Behcet’s syndrome (N=27), acute
respiratory distress syndrome (N=79), erythema nodosum associated disease (N=79),
pemphigus/pemphigoid (N=95). Cohort analysis was conducted for 9 immunological diseases with
a minimum of 1,500 female cases to allow enough number of immunological disease cases after
excluding prevalent immunological diseases diagnosed before cohort entry time or before the
endometriosis diagnosis. The majority of females had immunological diseases diagnosed after
endometriosis (66.8%, 1,275 out of 1,909 females with both diagnoses, had an immunological
disease diagnosis after their endometriosis diagnosis). Therefore, endometriosis was treated as
the exposure and immunological disease as the outcome in the cohort analyses. This also fits with
the observation that many individuals with endometriosis have symptom onset in their teens or
twenties, often many years before their ultimate diagnosis
52 . Females with an endometriosis
diagnosis at the time of recruitment were classified as exposed, whereas those who had not had
an endometriosis diagnosis at the time of recruitment were classified as unexposed. Those
individuals who received an endometriosis diagnosis during follow-up, prior to any immunological
disease diagnosis, contributed person-time to the unexposed group until the occurrence of
endometriosis diagnosis, if any, and subsequently to the exposed group after diagnosis. For each
immunological disease, females who had the respective immunological disease diagnosed before
endometriosis or those who had the respective immunological disease diagnosed before cohort
entry time or had immunological disease diagnosis time missing were excluded from cohort
analysis (Table 1).
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
In the cross-sectional study analysis, the prevalence of each specific and categorized
immunological diseases in females with and without a history of endometriosis diagnosis was
investigated using logistic regression models with odds ratios (ORs) as risk measure. Cross-
sectional study analysis for each specific and categorized immunological diseases was conducted
with adjustment of age and genetically determined ancestry. In the cohort study, the risk of
incident immunological diseases in females with and without endometriosis history was
investigated using Cox proportional hazards regression models with calculated hazard ratios (HRs).
The proportional hazards assumption was tested by function of “cox.zph” in the “survival” R
library. In the cohort analysis, time to event was formulated from entry to the cohort until the end
of follow-up time. The follow-up time (rather than age) is used as the underlying time variable,
since the date of assessment is described in more detail with information on the exact date and
months participants attended the assessment centre (to be used as the index date) in the UK
Biobank. The end of follow-up time is the date of incident immunological diseases, death, loss to
follow-up or end of follow-up (end date of follow-up is the date of last download of the dataset,
which is 8
th Jan. 2019), whichever occurred first. Cohort analysis for each specific and categorized
immunological diseases was conduct ed with adjustment of age (categorical: =60) and
genetically determined ancestry (categorical: white, non-white). All risk estimates were reported
with 95% confidence intervals (CIs) and two-sided P-values. Person- years and mean follow-up time
for each cohort analysis were calculated. All analyses were carried out using R software.
G en om e-wide as s o c iat ion s t ud y (G WA S) and met a-analys is for immune c ondit ions
Only genetically determined European ancestry individuals were included in the analysis. GWAS
was conducted using UKBB data for females-only and sex-combined study population for 8
immune conditions: inflammatory bowel disease (N = 2,869 females; N = 5,751 sex-combined),
osteoarthritis (N = 39,866 females; N = 68,878 sex-combined), ankylosing spondylitis (N = 547
females, N = 1,493 sex-combined), psoriasis (N = 3,036 females, N = 6,591 sex-combined), coeliac
disease (N = 1,706 females, N = 2,640 sex-combined), multiple sclerosis ( N = 1,314 females, N =
1,883 sex-combined), rheumatoid arthritis (N = 4,662 females, N = 7,153 sex-combined) and
systemic lupus erythematosus (N = 545 females, N = 673 sex-combined). Controls were defined as
a common control set without any diagnosis of immunological diseases or endometriosis within
UKBB. The linear mixed model (LMM) implemented in BOLT
53 was utilised for GWAS analysis to
take into account relatedness in the data and to increase power of analysis by a linear mixed
effects model. GWAS results were adjusted for a binary variable denoting the genotyping chip (the
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
UKBB Axiom array or the UK BiLEVE array), for SNPs with minimum MAF filter of < 1% and included
SNPs with ≤ 60% missingness.
Furthermore, published largest European ancestry GWAS results on these 8 immunological
conditions were identified through literature
47,54-60 and downloaded for meta-analysis with UKBB
GWAS results. Before meta-analysis, GWAS study-level QC was performed and markers absent in
the 1000G reference panel, large missing values (≥ 60%) or lack beta/odds ratio estimates were
excluded. GWAS meta-analysis for each immunological disease was carried out using METAL
software using an inverse variance weighted fixed effect meta-analysis method 61 . GWAS meta-
analysis results were filtered and excluded those with MAF
90), present < 50% effective sample size (Neff; Neff = 4NCases*NControls/( NCases + NControls).
All genetic analyses were done on genome reference of homo sapiens (human) genome assembly
GRCh37 (hg19). Genetic information on chromosome X was excluded. MHC region of
Chr6:24000000-35000000 was excluded as it has a dense clustering of imm une-relevant genes
with extreme polymorphism and very strong long-range linkage disequilibrium, which complicates
the determination of the exact genes and alleles that are responsible for signals of disease
association in the region
62 .
G en etic c or relat i o n analys is
In genetic correlation analysis, for endometriosis, the GWAS meta-analysis results from the
International Endometriosis Genome Consortium (IEGC) were used including 52,350 cases and
504,157 controls from 20 GWAS studies excluding UKBB to prevent overlapping study
population
16 . Then genetic correlation analysis was conducted between endometriosis and
immunological diseases GWAS meta-analysis results via linkage disequilibrium score regression
(LDSC) analysis
17,18 . The LD-score was calculated using software available at
(http://github.com/bulik/ldsc), which was based on the 1000 Genomes Eur opean population and
estimated within 1-cM windows, the significan ce threshold was set as p-value=0.00625 to account
for multiple testing of eight immunological diseases.
M en delian rando mis at ion analysi s
The potential causal relationship between endometriosis, as exposure, and those genetically
correlated immunological disease, as outcome, were investigated by two-sample Mendelian
randomisation (MR) using the TwoSampleMR software
63 . As instrumental variables (IVs) we
utilised the 39 established genome-wide significant LD-independent lead autosomal SNP s
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
associated with endometriosis to assess whether endometriosis causally affects those genetic
correlation immune conditions namely, osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis or multiple sclerosis.
Inverse variance weighted MR (MR-IVW) was applied as the initial method to detect causal
effect
64 . As sensitivity analysis, other two-sample MR methods including weighted median MR 65
and MR-Egger regression 66 were impl emented in case the assumption of valid IVs was violated.
Weighted median MR was shown to have lower Type 1 error rates than the inverse-variance
weighted method in a simulation analysis
65 . MR Egger provides a sensitivity analysis to detect
evidence of heterogeneity and pleiotropy of IVs 66 . To detect IVs with effect of heterogeneity and
pleiotropy, MR PRESSO was applied to identify outliers 67 . Also, scatter plots 68 were generated to
present the SNP-outcome association estimates versus the SNP-exposure associations in
investigating the causal relationship using the MR models, including IVW, weighted median MR
and MR-Egger regression
67 .
Furthermore, the strength of the 39 IVs used in this analysis was evaluated by calculating R-
squared statistics using the “add_rsq()” function in the TwoSampleMR software and the total R-
squared statistics for all 39 IVs is 0.298%. F statistics were calculated for all 39 IVs (a sum of Z
statistics for each SNP squared) as 1656.30. Although the F statistics is relatively large for the 39
IVs, given a low R
2 statistics for the 39 IVs used in the MR analysis, the set of IVs used for the MR
analysis in this study is limited in power to assess if endometriosis is causal to certain
immunological diseases.
M u lti-tr ait analysis of G WA S (MTA G)
The input files for MTAG are the GWAS meta-analysis summary results files which were pre-
processed by filtering out: 1) SNPs with MAF ==20% among
datasets; 2) restricting all analyses to a common set of SNPs present among dataset s; 3) multiple
SNPs that were mapped to an identical chromosomal position among datasets; 4) SNPs with
conflicting alleles among datasets. Z scores (log(OR/SE)) were computed for all SNPs. After variant
filtering, a total of 3,873,419 common SNPs between endometriosis, osteoarthritis, rheumatoid
arthritis, and multiple sclerosis were included in the MTAG analysis. MTAG is a generalization of
the standard inverse variance weighted meta-analysis framework. Here endometriosis,
osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis and multiple sclerosis pre-processed GWAS summary statistics
were included in a single MTAG analysis. Within MTAG, bi-variate LD score regression is employed
to account for possibly unknown sample overlap between GWAS results of different traits. In the
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
results, MTAG outputs trait-specific effects estimated for each SNP, and the resulting p-value can
be interpreted and used like those in single-trait GWAS 19 .
Ident ification of shar ed ge netic v a r iants and th eir functio nal annotat ion and pat hwa y
enrichme nts
For each disease, genome-wide significant lead SNPs were identified based on (1) achieving a
genome-wide significant P-value (P<5×10 −8 ), (2) being 500kb distant from each other and (3) being
independent (r 2 <0.1). Then, the genome-wide significant lead SNPs associated with respective
diseases that sit within 1Mb were identified and LD between them was checked. If the LD between
lead SNPs of respective disease was r
2 >=0.5, they were considered shared loci between those
diseases. The identified shared lead S NPs were looked-up in (1) Genotype-Tissue Expression
(GTEx) portal to identify whether they are eQTLs for genes across 49 human tissues from 838
donors with 15,201 samples 69 , and (2) eQTLGen to identify blood eQTLs from 31,684 individuals 70 .
Pathway enrichment analysis was conducted in FUMA based on MTAG results for endometriosis,
osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis, and multiple sclerosis where pathways were limited to
canonical pathways 71 .
D at a a va ilab il it y
The GWAS meta-analyses for immunological conditions made use of data from the UK Biobank
(Application Number 9637) and publicly available GWAS summary statistics for immunological
conditions [expand on sources]. GWAS data for endometriosis was based on the latest analyses of
International Endogene Consortium: summary statistics excluding 23andMe data is available from
EBI GWAS Catalog Stud y Accession GCST90205183; endometriosis GWAS summary statistics from
23andMe, Inc. were made available under a data use agreement that protects participant privacy.
Please contact dataset-request@23andme. com or visit research.23andMe.com/collaborate for
more information and to apply to access the data.
Aut hor Co ntribution s
Car r ied out d ata analys is: N.S., N.R.
D ra ft e d t h e m a nu s c r i p t: N.R., K.T.Z.
Super v is ed th e p hen otyp ic dat a a n al y sis: K.T.Z., C.B., N.R., S.A.M., H.R.H., J.K., H.F.
Super v is ed th e gen etic d ata analy s is: K.T.Z., C.B., N.R., A.P.M., C.C., J.K., H.F.
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
All authors contributed and discussed the results and commented on the final version of the
manuscript.
Acknowledg eme nts
We thank all the UK Biobank and 23andMe participants. Part of this research was conducted using
the UK Biobank Resource under Application Number 9637. N.R. was supported by a grant from
Wellbeing of Women UK (RG2031) and the EU Horizon 2020 funded project FEMaLe (101017562).
A.P.M. was supported in part by Versus Arthritis (grant 21754). H.F. was supported by National
Natural Science Foundation of China (grant 32170663). N.R., S.A.M and K.T.Z. were supported in
part by a grant from CDMRP DoD PRMRP (W81XWH-20-PRMRP-IIRA). S.A.M. and K.T.Z. gratefully
acknowledge funding provided by the Nezhat Family Foundation on behalf of Worldwide
EndoMarch to their research programmes.
Comp eting Inte rest s
K.T.Z. and C.M.B. reported grants in three years prior, outside the submitted work, from Bayer AG,
AbbVie Inc, Volition Rx, MDNA Life Sciences, PrecisionLife Ltd, Roche Diagnostics Inc. S.A.M.
reports grants in the three years prior, outside this submitted work, from AbbVie Inc. N.R. is a
consultant for Endogene.bio.
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
Figure 1. Overlap o f g en es a s soc iat ed w it h GW AS le ad S NPs in e Q TL ana lys e s fo r e ndometri o s i s (42
genom e- wid e sig ni fican t l ead S N Ps ar e e QTL s for 43 9 gen e s), o s teo arth r i t i s (27 g enome- w ide signi fic ant
lead SN Ps a r e e Q T Ls for 379 g ene s), mult iple scl er o s i s (64 g enom e- wi d e signi fic an t lea d SN Ps a re e QTLs for
1,113 genes ) and rhe uma toid ar thri ti s (2 8 genome - w ide signi f i cant l e ad SN Ps ar e e QTL s f or 490 gene s) in
various ti s s ue s in G T Ex.
Figure 2. Overlap o f pathways enriched with eQTL genes that are regulated by GWAS lead SNPs
associated with endometriosis, osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis and multiple sclerosis.
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
Table 1. Immunological diseas e ri sks among female s with vs. wi thout endomet ri osi s in U K Biobank utili sing two dif ferent study designs : C ross - sectional st udy
design (N=26 immunological dis ease with >100 femal e cas es) and cohort s tudy design (N=9 immunol ogical di s ease with >1500 female c ases)
Imm u nol ogic al D is ease
C ross-s ection a l stud y des ign a C oho rt stud y d esign b
T o tal f ema le s End o cas e s
(8,2 2 3 )
Fe m al e c o n t r ol s
( 2 65 , 1 8 1) OR ( 95 % C I) P-va l ue Tot a l Endo
ca se s
Female
contro ls
Follow-
up tim e,
Ye a r s
H R ( 95%C I ) P -v alue P er son
ye a rs
Overa l l 646 2 0 ( 23.6 4 % ) 2 0 64 (2 5.1 0 %) 62 556 ( 23. 59%) 1.3 2 (1 .25-1. 39) <0.001 * 14 , 248 4 7 2 13 , 776 9 . 43 1 . 31 (1. 1 9- 1 . 4 4 ) < 0 .0 0 1* 5 , 75 0 . 9 0
Cl a ssic autoimmune
di s eas e 147 6 4 ( 5 .40%) 505 ( 6. 14%) 142 5 9 (5 .38%) 1.2 4 (1 .13-1. 36) <0.001 * 2 ,6 27 9 8 2 ,5 29 9 . 78 1 . 42 (1. 1 6- 1 . 7 5 ) < 0 .0 0 1* 6 ,98 2 . 9 9
S yst e mic l u p u s
e r ythem atosus 7 8 0 (0.2 9 %) 36 ( 0 . 4 4%) 7 4 4 (0 . 2 8 % ) 1.62 ( 1.14-2. 2 4) 0 . 005* -- -- -- -- -- - - --
Sjo g ren’ s sy n drome 8 0 3 (0.2 9 %) 23 ( 0 . 2 8%) 7 8 0 (0 . 2 9 % ) 1.07 ( 0.68-1. 5 9) 0. 7 6 -- -- -- -- -- - - --
Sys t emic sc l e ro s i s 2 5 5 (0.0 9 %) 10 ( 0 . 1 2%) 2 4 5 (0 . 0 9 % ) 1.60 ( 0.79-2. 8 6) 0. 1 5 -- -- -- -- -- - - --
M u ltip le sclerosis 1 5 71 ( 0 . 57%) 61 ( 0 . 7 4%) 151 0 ( 0 . 57%) 1.23 ( 0.93-1. 5 8) 0. 1 3 1 4 9 9 1 4 0 9 . 8 3 1 . 84 ( 0 . 9 3- 3 . 61 ) 0 . 08 7 , 309.1 6
R h e u m ato id art hri t is 5 8 18 ( 2 . 13%) 187 (2 .27%) 563 1 ( 2 . 12%) 1.22 ( 1.04-1. 4 1) 0 . 011* 1 , 2 6 2 4 8 1 , 214 9 . 8 1 1 . 57 ( 1 . 1 8- 2 . 10 ) 0. 0 0 2 * 7 , 207.0 5
Coeli a c d ise as e 2 0 23 ( 0 . 74%) 76 ( 0 . 9 2%) 194 7 ( 0 . 73%) 1.35 ( 1.06-1. 7 0) 0 . 011* 3 9 1 2 2 3 6 9 9 . 8 2 1 . 99 ( 1 . 3 0- 3 . 07 ) 0. 0 0 2 * 7 , 299.3 7
V i ti li g o 1 74 ( 0 . 06 % ) 6 (0 .07 % ) 1 68 ( 0. 06 %) 1 . 2 9 ( 0. 5 1 - 2 . 6 8 ) 0 .5 4 - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Primary bi l ia ry cirrhosis 2 6 3 (0.1 0 %) 8 ( 0 . 1 0 %) 2 5 5 (0 . 1 0 % ) 1.17 ( 0 .53-2.21) 0. 6 7 -- -- -- -- -- - - --
Addi s on' s disea s e 1 8 0 (0.0 7 %) 6 ( 0 . 0 7 %) 1 7 4 (0 . 0 7 % ) 1.21 ( 0.47-2. 5 0) 0. 6 5 -- -- -- -- -- - - --
Ty p e 1 d ia be tes 1 6 03 ( 0 . 59%) 57 ( 0 . 6 9%) 154 6 ( 0 . 58%) 1.26 ( 0.95-1. 6 4) 0. 0 9 5 11 17 4 9 4 9. 8 2 1. 3 8 ( 0. 8 5-2. 2 5) 0 . 1 9 7 0 74.59
M ya stheni a grav i s 1 7 3 (0.0 6 %) 11 ( 0 . 1 3%) 1 6 2 (0 . 0 6 % ) 2.55 ( 1.30-4. 4 9) 0 . 003* -- -- -- -- -- - - --
Aut o imm une ga stritis 1 4 66 ( 0 . 54%) 48 ( 0 . 5 8%) 141 8 ( 0 . 53%) 1. 2 0 ( 0.88-1. 5 8) 0. 2 2
Derma tomyositi s ,
P olym yo s i t is 1 1 5 (0.0 4 %) 3 ( 0 . 0 4 %) 1 1 2 (0 . 0 4 % ) 0.97 ( 0 .24-2.59) 0. 9 6 -- -- -- -- -- - - --
Gra ve s' d ise as e 5 4 5 (0.2 0 %) 23 ( 0 . 2 8%) 5 2 2 (0 . 2 0 % ) 1.28 ( 0.80-1. 9 3) 0. 2 7 -- -- -- -- -- - - --
Has h imo to' s d i se as e 2 4 4 (0.0 9 %) 6 ( 0 . 0 7 %) 2 3 8 (0 . 0 9 % ) 0.89 ( 0.35-1. 8 4) 0. 7 9 -- -- -- -- -- - - --
Au t oi m m u n e thyroid
di se ase 7 8 8 (0.2 9 %) 29 ( 0 . 3 5%) 7 5 9 (0 . 2 9 % ) 1.17 ( 0 .79-1.69) 0. 4 2 -- -- -- -- -- - - --
Au toin fla mmatory
di s eas e 520 2 7 ( 19.0 3 % ) 1 6 38 (1 9.9 2 %) 50 389 ( 19. 00%) 1.3 3 (1 .26-1. 41) <0.001 * 13 , 710 4 4 3 13 , 267 9 . 46 1 . 28 (1. 1 6- 1 . 4 1 ) < 0 .0 0 1* 6 ,08 0 . 8 1
Cro h n' s di se ase 1 3 82 ( 0 . 51%) 48 ( 0 . 5 8%) 133 4 ( 0 . 50%) 1.18 ( 0.87-1. 5 8) 0. 2 7 -- -- -- -- -- - - --
Ulce rativ e co l itis 2 3 65 ( 0 . 87%) 82 ( 1 . 0 0%) 228 3 ( 0 . 86%) 1.24 ( 0.98-1. 5 5) 0. 0 6 4 3 0 13 4 1 7 9 . 8 2 1. 0 4 ( 0. 5 8-1. 8 4) 0. 9 0 7,0 52. 21
Inf la mma t o ry b owel
di se ase 3 5 27 ( 1 . 29%) 129 (1 .57%) 339 8 ( 1 . 2 8 %) 1.28 ( 1.06-1. 5 3) 0 . 009* 3 1 6 1 2 3 0 4 9 . 8 2 1 . 40 ( 0 . 7 9- 2 . 50 ) 0 . 25 4 , 247.0 5
Oste o a rth ritis 476 4 2 ( 1 7 . 4 3 % ) 1 4 93 (1 8 . 16 %) 4 6 149 ( 1 7 .40%) 1.35 ( 1.27-1. 4 3) <0.0 0 1 * 13, 3 7 1 4 1 6 12, 9 5 5 9 . 4 8 1 . 31 ( 1 . 1 9- 1 . 44 ) <0. 001* 6 , 196.1 3
Gia nt c ell, Ta ka yas u ce l l 3 6 6 (0.1 3 %) 10 ( 0 . 1 2%) 3 5 6 (0 . 1 3 % ) 1.35 ( 0.67-2. 4 0) 0. 3 5 -- -- -- -- -- - - --
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
arte ri tis
Sa rco id o sis 7 4 1 (0.2 7 %) 26 ( 0 . 3 2%) 7 1 5 (0 . 2 7 % ) 1.39 ( 0.91-2. 0 1) 0. 1 0 -- -- -- -- -- - - --
Ac ne , a c ne fo r m
as s o c i a t ed d i s ea s e 2 8 7 (0.1 1 %) 8 ( 0 . 1 0 %) 2 7 9 (0 . 1 1 % ) 0.78 ( 0.35-1. 4 8) 0. 5 0 -- -- -- -- -- - - --
G o ut , ps e ud o g o ut ,
crystal arthr o pa thy 1 1 17 ( 0 . 41%) 41 ( 0 . 5 0%) 107 6 ( 0 . 41%) 1.66 ( 1.18-2. 2 6) 0 . 002* -- -- -- -- -- - - --
M ix ed -Pattern d is e a se 4 3 79 (1. 60%) 156 ( 1. 90%) 422 3 (1. 59 %) 1.2 3 (1 .10-1. 52) 0 . 0 0 2* 5 2 7 2 7 5 0 0 9 . 82 1 . 81 (1. 2 1- 2 . 7 1 ) 0. 004 * 723 7 .37 3
An k ylo s i ng s pon d y l it is 6 7 6 (0.2 5 %) 28 ( 0 . 3 4%) 6 4 8 (0 . 2 4 % ) 1.59 ( 1.06-2. 3 0) 0 . 019* 9 6 4 9 2 9 . 8 3 1 . 66 ( 0 . 6 1- 4 . 52 ) 0 . 32 7 , 332.2 2
Psori a sis 3 6 97 ( 1 . 36%) 121 (1 .47%) 357 6 ( 1 . 35%) 1.18 ( 0.97-1. 4 1) 0. 0 8 4 2 7 1 9 4 0 8 9 . 8 2 1 . 67 ( 1 . 0 5- 2 . 65 ) 0. 0 3 0 * 7 , 254.4 0
C o nfou n ders inc luded i n t he ana ly se s are age at rec ru itme n t a n d g enetica ll y dete rmin e d a n c estry.
-- Insuf fic ient num ber of c ase s to ge n e rat e m ea n ingfu l risk estima tes.
a C ross-s e ctio n al d e sign i n c lu ded 8, 223 en d ome tri o sis ca ses a n d fe ma l e co ntr ol s.
b C o hort d e sign: F or ea ch imm un o l ogica l co ndi tio n , fem ales who ha d the re sp e ctiv e imm un ologica l di se ase d iag n ose d befo r e end ome trio sis o r th o se who h a d t he resp ec ti v e immun olo g ica l disea s e
d ia g no se d before cohort entry t i m e or ha d i m m u nologica l disea s e di a g no sis time m i ss i ng we re e x clu ded f rom c oh o rt a na lysis. Her e a re the num ber of exclud e d i ndivi duals fo r ea ch d isea s e and
d ise as e cate gory: Ov era ll imm unol ogical dise as e N= 5 0,67 6 7 , Cl a ssica l a ut oi m m u n e d isea s e N=12, 5 1 1 , m ult iple sc l e ro sis N=1,8 1 5, r h e u m ato i d art hrit i s N=4,94 6 , coel iac di se ase N =2, 0 2 6 , ty p e 1
d ia b e tes N=1,4 8 6 , Aut oinfl a mm a tory d ise as e N= 3 8, 661, ulce rative c o lit i s N= 2 ,32 6 , I n fla m mat ory b owe l d isea s e N=11 5, 4 0 4, o ste oart hri t is N=34,5 68, mixe d -patt ern i mm un ologica l di se as e N=42 4 0 ,
An k ylo sing s p o n d y l it is N = 9 7 6 , p s o rias i s N= 3 , 662.
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
Table 2. N u mber of case s and contr ol s of UKBB based female only and s ex- combined GWAS for
immunological c o nditions a n d s umm ary of their me ta-analysi s with the lar g est pub l icl y available
Europ e an ancestr y GW A S r e s ult s .
Im m un o l o g ic al
di s e as es
UK B B GWAS (Cases : C ontr o ls)
P u blis hed s e x -co m b in e d
GWA S (C a s e s : Co ntrols )
Fina l sex-c om bine d
G W A S m et a -an a l y s i s
(C ase s : Controls )
Femal e -o nly S ex - c ombi ned
Anky l osin g
spon dy l i tis
5 47 : 162,4 03 1,4 93 : 3 1 9, 532 N /A 1 ,49 3 : 319,5 32
Co e lia c di seas e 1 ,70 6 : 162,4 03 2,6 40 : 3 1 9, 532 4 ,53 3 : 10, 7 50 72 7 ,17 3 : 330,2 82
Infl a m mato ry
bo w e l d is eas e
2 ,86 9 : 162,4 03 5,7 51 : 3 1 9, 532 25 ,04 2 : 3 4 ,91 5 54 3 0,7 93 : 3 5 4,4 47
M ultiple
s c l e r o si s
1 ,31 4 : 162,4 03 1,8 83 : 3 1 9, 532 14 ,49 8 : 2 4 ,09 1 56 1 6,3 81 : 3 4 3,6 23
Os teoa rt hritis 39 ,86 6 : 1 6 2,4 03 68, 878 : 319 ,53 2 77 ,05 2 : 3 78 ,16 9 73 77 ,05 2 : 3 7 8,1 69 *
P sorias i s 3 ,03 6 : 162,4 03 6,5 91 : 3 1 9, 532 15 ,96 7 : 2 8 ,19 4 59 2 2,5 58 : 3 4 7,7 26
Rheuma toi d
a r th ritis
4 ,66 2 : 162,4 03 7,1 53 : 3 1 9, 532 14 ,36 1 : 4 3 ,92 3 57 2 1,5 14 : 3 6 3,4 55
S y s t e m ic L up u s
eryt he m a tos u s
5 45 : 162,4 03 673 : 3 1 9 ,53 2 5, 874 : 3 2 8 ,59 8 74 6 ,54 7 : 648,1 30
* Pub l i she d G W AS m et a - a na l y s is in c lu ded UK BB h en c e , s u mm a ry st at i st i c s f ro m T a c hm z ido u l e t a l . 73 w e re use d i n th e
an a l ys e s .
Table 3. G en e t ic cor relations from LDSC a n al y si s bet w een en dometr i o s is and immunol ogical
dis ease. Mult iple-testing correction f or number o f diseas e included in the analy s is i s applied
(0.05/8=6.2 5x10 -3 ) to det e rmine signific ant c or relations . UKBB end o met r io si s G W AS re sult s we re
ex clude d from e ndome trio si s met a- anal y s i s to a void ov e rlap i n LDS C a naly si s wi t h i mmunolog ical
c ondition s f or whic h we have analy s e d t his da ta s e t . H 2: He r it abi lity, S E: S tand a r d err or , RG: Gen etic
co r r e lat i o n.
UK BB fem ale -o n ly GW AS U KBB se x - com b i ned G WAS
Se x - com bi n e d GW AS me t a -
an a l ys is
I m muno l o g ic al
dise a s e s
H 2 ( S E ) RG ( S E) P -v al u e H2 ( SE) RG ( S E) P-v al u e H2 ( SE) RG ( SE ) P-v a lu e
A nky l o si ng s pon d y l itis
0 .006
(0 .003)
0 .308
(0 .124)
0.0 1 3
0.0 0 3
(0.001)
0 .300
(0 .124)
0. 01 6 N/ A N /A N/A
C o el i a c d is e a s e
0 .013
(0 .003)
0 .215
(0 .083)
0.0 1 0
0.0 0 9
(0.002)
0 .154
(0 .068)
0. 02 4
0 . 07 7
(0.0 0 5)
0.0 7 6
( 0.054)
0. 16 1 9
Inflam m a tor y b owe l
di s e as e
0 .014
(0 .003)
0 .054
(0 .085)
0.5 2 1
0.0 1 3
(0.002)
0 .007
(0 .063)
0. 91 0
0 . 27 7
(0.0 2 8)
-0. 04 1
( 0.035)
0. 23 7
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
M u l t ipl e s cle r o s is
0 .004
(0 .003)
0 .247
(0 .139)
0.0 7 5
0.0 0 3
(0.001)
0 .273
(0 .116)
0. 01 8
0 . 07 9
(0.0 0 5)
0.0 8 8
( 0.031)
4. 0 0 x 10 -3
O ste oa rt hrit is
0 .051
(0 .004)
0 .322
(0 .042)
1.7 6 x10 -14
0.0 4 2
(0.002)
0 .278
(0 .038)
2.4 6 x10 -13
0 . 04 6
(0.0 0 2)
0.2 7 8
( 0.035)
3.2 5 x10 -15
Psori a s i s
0 .012
(0 .003)
0 .043
(0 .084)
0.6 0 5
0.0 1 2
(0.002)
0 .049
(0 .061)
0. 42 0
0 . 23 9
(0.0 2 7)
0.0 6 6
( 0.037)
0. 07 6
Rh eu m a to id a r th r i t is
0 .013
(0 .003)
0 .277
(0 .079)
0.0 0 1
0.0 1 1
(0.002)
0 .284
(0 .068)
2. 6 5 x 10 -5
0 . 06 4
(0.0 0 9)
0.2 6 6
( 0.062)
1. 5 4 x 10 -5
S ys t em i c l upu s
e r y th em ato su s
0 .003
(0 .003)
0 .154
(0 .154)
0.3 1 6
0.0 0 2
(0.001)
0 .190
(0 .165)
0. 24 8
0 . 33 2
(0.0 4 8)
0.1 2 7
( 0.071)
0. 07 4
Table 4. Mend e lian Rando mis at i o n ( MR) r es u l t s fo r endome t riosis vs. o s t eoar thr i tis , r heumatoid
arth rit is and multipl e sc ler os i s.
I mm u nol o gic al dis e ase s SN P s
I n v e rs e va r i a n c e w e igh te d We i g ht ed m ed i an M R Egg e r MR E gg e r ( P -va l u es )
O R ( 95% C I) P - va lu e O R ( 95% C I) P - v a lu e O R ( 95 % C I ) P - va l u e H e t a P l e i o t r o p y b
Os te oa rt h r i t i s (3 9 IVs )
F ema l e-o nly U KB B 39 1.0 4 ( 0 . 9 7-1. 11 ) 0 . 282 1 . 05 ( 0 . 9 7-1. 13) 0.2 6 7 0.8 9 ( 0. 72 -1. 07 ) 0.2 03 0.0 02 0 . 084
Fe m ale - o n l y UK BB ( ou t lie rs
re m o ve d )
35 1.0 3 ( 0 . 9 8-1. 09 ) 0 . 287 1 . 05 ( 0 . 9 7-1. 13) 0.2 5 0 0.9 5 ( 0. 79 -1. 15 ) 0.5 95 0.5 72 0 . 387
S ex-c o mb in ed meta-a n al y s i s 39 1.0 2 ( 0 . 9 6-1. 07 ) 0 . 533 1 . 02 ( 0 . 9 7-1. 08) 0.4 0 0 1.0 8 ( 0. 92 -1. 26 ) 0.3 53 1.5 6x 1 0 -5 0 . 229
S ex-c o mb in ed meta-a n al y s i s
( o utl i e r s r e mo ve d ) 36 1.0 1 ( 0 . 9 7-1. 06 ) 0 . 495 1 . 03 ( 0 . 9 8-1. 09) 0.2 8 1 1.0 3 ( 0. 90 -1. 18 ) 0.6 55 0.1 59 0 . 800
Rh e uma t o id Ar th r it is ( 3 9 IVs )
F ema l e-o nly U KB B 39 1.1 6 ( 1 . 0 2-1. 33 ) 0 . 028 1 . 15 ( 0 . 9 4-1. 40) 0.1 6 9 1.1 5 ( 0. 78 -1. 70 ) 0.4 94 0.7 56 0 . 959
S ex-c o mb in ed meta-a n al y s i s 31 1.0 6 ( 0 . 9 6-1. 17 ) 0 . 220 1 . 09 ( 0 . 9 4-1. 26) 0.2 6 1 1.0 8 ( 0. 76 -1. 53 ) 0.6 82 0.6 11 0 . 435
M ulti ple S cler osi s ( 39 I V s)
F ema l e-o nly U KB B 39 1.1 2 ( 0 . 8 7-1. 43 ) 0 . 376 1 . 23 ( 0 . 8 7-1. 73) 0.2 4 3 1.7 5 ( 0. 84 -3. 64 ) 0.1 43 0.8 15 0 . 211
S ex-c o mb in ed meta-a n al y s i s 39 1.0 6 ( 0 . 9 4-1. 21 ) 0 . 343 1 . 03 ( 0 . 8 9-1. 20) 0.6 9 2 1.2 4 ( 0. 84 -1. 84 ) 0.2 80 0.0 12* 0 . 145
S ex-c o mb in ed Met a-an al ysi s
( o utl i e r s r e mo ve d ) 38 1.0 4 ( 0 . 9 3-1. 18 ) 0 . 484 1 . 02 ( 0 . 8 8-1. 2) 0.7 5 9 1.2 0 ( 0. 84 -1. 73 ) 0.3 25 0.0 63 0 . 202
a Tes t for H ete rogeneit y , b Tes t f or Pleiotr opy, c O u tlier IVs were ident ified by M R PRE SS O
so f t w a r e 67 (See m etho ds and Supplemen tary Table 15).
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
Table 5. G en ome-wide s ignificant lead SNP s a ssociated with endom etr iosis ( EN D O ) and
rheum atoid a rt hr itis (RA) , o s teo a rthr i tis ( O A ) or multiple sclerosis (M S) tha t ar e located wit h in
1Mb, with LD between them. Chr : Chro mos o me, AE: Effective alle le, Fr q: Effective al lel e
freq uenc y, LD: Linka ge dis equilibr i u m, eQ TL: Expre s s ion quant itative tr ai t l oc i.
Locus Tra its S N P Chr P ositi on E A ( Frq ) OR ( 95 % CI) P-v al u e LD (r 2) eQTLs r e s ul t s*
GR E B 1 /
2 p25.1
E ND O r s 12 0 305 76 1 115 8 172 21 G ( 0 . 65 ) 1 . 02 ( 1 .01 - 1 .03 ) 1 .94 x10 -1 4 0 .0 02 TS P A N 2
RA r s 66 7 967 7 1 114 3 038 08 C (0 .1 0) 0 . 85 ( 0 .84 - 0 .87 ) 1 .61 x10 -92 A P4B 1, A PBA2, CD 247, C D 5, C D 6 ,
CT LA4, D C LR E 1B, FB L N2, F O XP3,
GZ MB, I L 10RA, I L2 R A , M A F , ME D1 5 ,
P H TF1, R N F2 1 4, RT K N2, SLA MF 1,
S T8S IA1, STA P1, WLS, ZN F 8 3 1
DNM 3/
1 q24.3
E ND O r s 24 2 198 5 1 172 0 991 36 T ( 0 .52 ) 0 . 98 ( 0 .97 - 0 .98 ) 1 .94 x10 -1 4 0 .0 001 M E TT L 13
OA r s 55 6 981 00 1 174 2 274 33 T ( 0 .73 ) 1 . 01 ( 1 .01 - 1 .02 ) 7 .97 x10
-1 0
C A CY B P , DA R S 2, G PR 52 , K IAA 0 0 40 ,
KLHL 20, M R P S 1 4 , P R D X6,
R A B G A P1L, RC 3H1, S E RPI N C1
ET A A1/
2p 1 4
E ND O r s 11 1 261 43 2 678 6 540 8 C (0 .3 2) 1 . 02 ( 1 .01 - 1 .02 ) 6 .08 x10
-1 0
0 .0 1 None
M S r s 12 6 226 70 2 686 4 653 6 C (0 .4 6) 0 . 96 ( 0 .98 - 0 .99 ) 1 .56 x10 -9 C NR IP1 , P LEK , PP P3 R 1
BM P R 2/
2 q33.1
E ND O r s 72 9 289 25 2 203 5 543 24 A (0 .82 ) 1 . 02 ( 1 .02 - 1 .03 ) 9 .61 x10 -1 0 BM P R2, CA R F, R A M11 7B, I CA 1 L,
NB E AL 1
OA r s 72 9 286 05 2 203 8 321 20 A (0 .87 ) 1 . 02 ( 1 .01 - 1 .02 ) 4 .33 x10 -8 0 .5 3 BM P R2, CA R F, C Y P 2 0A 1, FA M117 B,
ICA 1L, N BEAL 1, NO P58
RA r s 30 8 724 3 2 204 7 389 19 G ( 0 . 45 ) 1 . 03 ( 1 .02 - 1 .04 ) 2 .39 x10
-9
0 .0 01 CT LA4, I CO S
BS N /
3 p21.31
E ND O r s 67 7 420 2 3 496 8 777 9 T ( 0 .17 ) 1 . 03 ( 1 .01 - 1 .03 ) 9 .70 x10 -12 0 .9 7 A MT, A RI H2, A P EH, C 3orf62 ,
C A C NA 2 D2 , CCDC3 6 , C CDC7 1 ,
CD HR4, DA G 1, D A L RD3 , FA M 2 12 A ,
GM PP B , G P X 1 , HE M K1, HYA L3,
I M PD H 2 , I P 6 K 1, K LH D C 88 ,
M A P K A PK3 , M ON 1 A, M ST 1R , NAT 6 ,
N CKI PS D, N D U FAF3, N I CN 1 , P4 H TM,
PR K A R2A , Q RI CH 1, RB M6, R H OA,
R N F1 23 , TC T A , TR AIP , U B A7 , WDR6
OA r s 68 0 987 9 3 499 3 610 2 G ( 0 . 18 ) 1 . 02 ( 1 .01 - 1 .02 ) 7 .71 x10 -9 A MT, A PEH, A RIH 2 , BSN , CA CNA 2D 2,
C A M KV , CD HR 4 , CTD - 2 33 0K9 .3 ,
DO C K 3, FAM 212A, G M P PB, G PX 1,
HEMK 1, H Y A L3 , I P6 K1, KLH D C8B ,
M A PKAP K 3 , MO N1A , MS T1, MS T 1 R ,
NAT 6, N I CN 1, P4H T M , RASSF1,
RB M5, RB M 6 , RHOA , RN F1 2 3,
S E MA3F , T RAI P, U BA7, WD R 6
EBF 1/
5 q33.3
E ND O r s 29 6 448 5 5 157 9 048 39 G ( 0 . 22 ) 0 . 98 ( 0 .97 - 0 .99 ) 1 .11 x10 -8 0 .0 01 None
M S r s 25 4 689 0 5 158 7 599 00 A (0 .52 ) 1 . 05 ( 1 .04 - 1 .07 ) 7 .71 x10
-13
UB LCP1
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
PP P 1 R9A /
7 q21.3
E ND O r s 34 7 510 86 7 945 9 269 1 C (0 .8 7) 1 . 02 ( 1 .02 - 1 .03 ) 3 .23 x10 -8 0 .0 3 A SB 4 , C A SD 1, PEG 10 , P ON 1, P O N 2 ,
PP P1R 9 A
OA r s 69 6 654 0 7 957 2 796 7 T ( 0 .63 ) 0 . 99 ( 0 .98 - 0 .99 ) 1 .46 x10 -9 DY N C1I 1 , S L C25A1 3
XK R6 /
8 p23.1
E ND O r s 12 5 420 37 8 107 5 849 6 A (0 .45 ) 1 . 02 ( 1 .01 - 1 .02 ) 7 .02 x10 -11 BL K, C TSB, FAM 167A, F DF T 1, MSRA,
MT M R 9, N EI L2, R P11- 297N 6, R P 1 L 1,
S LC3 5 G5 , X KR6
OA r s 42 4 067 3 8 107 8 761 2 T ( 0 .45 ) 1 . 01 ( 1 .01 - 1 .02 ) 2 .24 x10 -12 0 .9 BL K, C TS B , FAM 167A, F DF T1 , MSRA,
MT M R 9, N EI L2, R P11- 297N 6. 4,
RP 1L1, S LC3 5 G 5 , SO X7, X KR6
RA r s 27 3 634 0 8 113 4 397 3 C (0 .2 6) 0 . 97 ( 0 .96 - 0 .98 ) 2 .78 x10 -9 0 .3 A RG2, BL K, CTS B, F A M16 7 A , F D FT1,
GGA 2 , M T MR 9, N E I L2, RP1 1 -2 97N 6 ,
SL C 3 5G 5, X K R 6
MLLT 10/
10 p 12 .31
E ND O r s 11 0 127 32 10 218 3 010 4 A (0 .66 ) 0 . 98 ( 0 .97 - 0 .98 ) 3 .84 x10 -1 6 0 .7 C A SC 10 , M L LT10 , N EB L
OA r s 12 3 573 21 10 217 9 047 6 G ( 0 . 68 ) 0 . 99 ( 0 .98 - 0 .99 ) 3 .28 x10
-9
C A SC 10 , M L LY10 , N EB L
VEZ T/
12 q 22
E ND O r s 12 3 201 96 12 956 4 538 5 A (0 .52 ) 0 . 98 ( 0 .98 - 0 .99 ) 5 .37 x10
-12 0 .0 03 F G D6, N D UFA 1 2, N R2 C1 , V EZ T
OA r s 21 7 112 6 12 941 6 722 0 C (0 .4 9) 0 . 99 ( 0 .98 - 0 .99 ) 2 .88 x10
-9
SO CS 2
DLE U 1/
13 q 14 .2
E ND O r s 10 2 886 2 13 510 5 513 4 G ( 0 . 86 ) 0 . 98 ( 0 .97 - 0 .98 ) 9 .63 x10 -1 0 0 .0 005 None
M S r s 95 9 132 5 13 508 1 122 0 T ( 0 .93 ) 1 . 09 ( 1 .06 - 1 .12 ) 1 .59 x10
-1 0
C OR O1C , DLE U1 , EB PL , KPN A 3 ,
PH F 1 1
SKA P 1 /
17 q 21 .32
E ND O r s 67 4 467 70 17 462 3 574 5 A (0 .41 ) 0 . 98 ( 0 .98 - 0 .99 ) 8 .37 x10 -1 0 0 .0 02 CB X1, CD K 5 RA P 3 , HO XB2 , H O XB 3,
HOX B4, L RR C4 6, M R PL1 0 , NF E2 L 1,
S C R N 2, S KA P1 , S N X 1 1
M S r s 11 0 797 84 17 457 0 228 0 T ( 0 .49 ) 0 . 96 ( 0 .94 - 0 .97 ) 1 .97 x10 -1 0 C OPZ2 , EFC A B 13 , HOXB 2 , IT GB 3 ,
N PEP PS , S CR N2, SKA P 1, T B KB P 1
* F ull e Q T L re s u l ts fr o m 54 G T E x t i s s u e s a nd eQ TLGe n bl o o d t iss ue a re pr ovi d e d i n Su p pl e ment ary T able 14.
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
References
1. Zondervan, K.T ., Bec ker, C .M . & M is s mer, S.A. Endom etriosis . N Engl J Med 382, 1244- 12 56
(2020).
2. Sampson, J.A. M etas t atic o r Embolic Endometr ios is, due to t he Menstrual D issemination of
Endomet rial Ti ssue into the V enous C i r culation. Am J Pa t hol 3 , 93-110 43 (1927) .
3. Halme, J., H am mond , M .G ., H ulka, J. F ., Raj, S. G. & Talber t, L.M. Retr ograde menstr uation in
healthy women and in patien t s with endo metri o s is. O b stet G ynec ol 64, 15 1-4 (1 984).
4. Cramer , D.W. & M i ssmer, S.A. The ep idem i o l ogy of en dometr i os is. Ann N Y A c ad Sci 955,
11-22; dis cu ssion 34-6, 396-40 6 (20 0 2).
5. Bulun, S.E. et al. Role of estr ogen receptor -be ta in end ometriosis . Semin Reprod M ed 30,
39-45 (2012) .
6. Han, S.J. et a l . Estr ogen Receptor bet a Modulates Apopt osi s Complexes an d the
Inflammasome to D r ive the Pat hogenes is of Endomet riosis . Ce l l 163, 96 0-74 (2015) .
7. Symon s, L. K. et al. The Immu nopatho ph ysiology of Endomet riosi s. Trend s Mol Med 24,
748-762 (20 18).
8. Zondervan, K.T . et al. Endom etriosis . Nat Rev Dis Primer s 4 , 9 (201 8) .
9. Mat a r es e, G ., De Pla cido, G ., Nikas , Y. & A lviggi, C. Pathogenesi s o f endometr ios is: natur al
immunit y dysfunction or autoimmu n e dis ease? Tr ends M ol Med 9 , 2 23-8 (2003) .
10. G leicher, N., el-Roeiy, A., Conf ino, E. & Friber g, J. I s endo metriosis an aut oimmune diseas e?
O b s tet G ynecol 70 , 1 15- 22 (1987).
11. Eis enb erg, V.H., Zolt i, M . & Sor iano, D. Is there an as s o ciation bet w een autoimmuni t y and
endomet r iosis ? Aut oimmun Rev 11, 806-14 (2012) .
12. La u danski, P. e t a l . Aut oan tibody sc r e ening of plas m a and per itonea l flu id of p a t ien ts wi t h
endomet r iosis . H um Reprod 38, 629- 6 43 ( 2023).
13. htt ps ://www.auto i m muneinstitut e.or g/dis ea se s _list/ en dometr ios is/ .
14. Shiges i , N . e t al. The as so c iat i o n betw een endome t riosis and auto i m mune disea se s: a
sy stemat i c review and meta - anal ysi s . H um Reprod Up date 25, 486- 503 (20 19).
15. Mc Gonagl e, D . & M c D ermo tt, M .F . A proposed clas sific at ion of the immu n ologic al
dis ease s. PL o S M e d 3 , e297 (20 06) .
16. Rahmioglu, N. et al. The genetic b asis of endome tr ios is and comorbidit y wit h other pa in
and inflamma t ory conditions. Na t Ge n e t 55, 423-4 36 ( 202 3).
17. Bulik-Sullivan, B . e t a l . An a tlas o f genetic cor relations ac r os s human disea ses and tr ai t s .
Na t Ge n e t 47 , 123 6- 41 (2015).
18. Bulik-Sullivan, B .K. et al. L D S cor e regress ion d istinguishe s confo unding fro m poly genicity in
genome-wide ass o ciation studies. Na t G e n e t 47, 29 1-5 ( 2015).
19. Turley, P . et al. Mult i- tr a i t anal ysi s of g en ome-wide as so cia t ion s u mmary statistics u sin g
MTA G . Nat Genet 50, 229-23 7 (2018) .
20. Manco, G. , P orzio, E . & Caru s one, T. M . Human Par a o x on a se-2 (P ON 2): Pr ot ein Func t ions
and Modu l at ion. Anti oxid ant s (B as el) 10(2021 ).
21. Shin, S.H. et al. Ar rest def ective 1 regulates the oxidativ e s t ress r e s pon se in human cells
and mice by a cetylating met hionine s ulf ox ide reductas e A . Cell D eath Dis 5 , e1490 (201 4).
22. Ichik a wa-Tom ik aw a, N., Sugimot o, K., Kas h i wa gi, K . & Chiba , H. The Src-Fa mily Kinas e s S R C
and BLK Contr ibute to t he CLDN6-Ad h e sion Signaling. Cel l s 12(20 23).
23. W ang , H . et al. ZAP-70: an es s ent ial kinase i n T- c ell si g n a ling. Cold Spring Harb Per s pe ct Biol
2 , a0022 79 (2010).
24. Li , C . e t a l . Tr ans m embrane Pr otein 214 (TM EM2 14) mediat es endoplasmic reticulum
s t res s - i n duc ed ca spa s e 4 enz yme a ct ivation and apo pt osis . J B i ol Chem 288, 179 08-17
(2013).
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
25. Stelzer, G . et a l . The GeneCard s Suite: From Gene Dat a Mining to D i sease G enome
Sequence Analy s es. Curr Protoc Bioinf or matics 54, 1 30 1-1 30 3 3 (20 16).
26. Dy son, M. T. et al. Genome-wide D N A m e t hylation analys is predict s an epigenet ic switch
for GATA f ac t or express ion in end om etr i o s is. PL oS Genet 10, e100 4158 (20 14).
27. McKinnon, B. D., Kocbe k, V ., N ir gi anak is, K. , Bersinger, N.A. & M ueller, M.D . Kinas e
s ignalling pathwa y s in end ometriosis: potent i a l t a r gets for non-hormo na l therapeut ic s.
Hum R eprod U pdate 22, 382-403 (20 16) .
28. Milacic , M . et al. The Reac t ome Path way Knowledgeba s e 2024. Nucle ic Ac ids Res 52, D6 72-
D678 ( 2024).
29. Shafrir , A.L . e t al . R is k for an d c onseq uences of endometr ios is: A critical epidemiol ogic
review. Bes t Pract Res Clin Obstet Gy naec ol 51, 1-15 (2 018).
30. Zondervan, K.T ., Car don, L.R . & Kenn ed y , S.H . What m a ke s a g o od c a se-co ntr ol s tu dy?
Design i ssues f or complex traits su c h as endometr ios is. Hum R eprod 17, 14 15-23 (2 002).
31. Har ris, H .R. et al. Endometriosis , P sor iasis, and P soriatic Ar thritis : A P rospe c t ive Co hort
Study. Am J Epi d e m iol 191, 105 0-106 0 (2022).
32. Har ris, H .R. et al. Endometriosis and t he ris k s of s ystemic lupus erythem a t os u s and
rheum atoid a rt hr itis in the Nurses ' H ealt h S t udy II. Ann Rheum D is 75, 127 9-84 ( 2016).
33. Kraft , P., Chen, H. & Linds t rom, S. The Us e Of G enet ic Co rrelation A nd Men delian
Randomization Stud i es To Increase Our U nder s t anding of Relati onships B etween Complex
Traits. Curr Epidemiol Rep 7 , 104-112 (2020).
34. Burges s, S . Sample si z e and power cal culations in M endelian randomi zatio n with a single
ins t rumen tal variable and a bina r y o utcome. Int J Epidemio l 43, 922- 9 (201 4).
35. Shafrir , A.L . e t al . C o-occurrence of imm une-m ediated conditions and endo metri o s is
among adolesc ent s and adult wom en. Am J Repr od Immuno l 86, e13404 (2 021) .
36. Ke, J., Ye, J. , Li, M. & Z h u, Z. The Role of Matr i x M e tallop rot e inas es in Endo metr ios is: A
Potent ial Tar get. Biomolecu les 11(20 21) .
37. Li u , Y. et a l . Incr ea sed Serum M atrix Met allopr ot ei n as e-9 Leve ls are A s so ciat ed wi t h An t i -
Jo1 but not Ant i -MD A5 in Myositis P a tients. Agi ng Dis 10, 746-755 (2 019) .
38. Ram, M., Sher er, Y. & Sho enfeld, Y. Matr ix met a ll o pr ot ei n a se-9 and aut o im mune diseas e s.
J Clin Immunol 26, 299-3 07 ( 2006).
39. Du, F. et al. Inflamm atory Th17 Cells Ex pr ess Integr i n alphavbet a3 f or Patho ge n i c Fun ction.
Cell Rep 16, 1339-1351 (2 016) .
40. Jang, Y. , Kim, M. & Hwan g, S.W. M olec u l ar mechanis m s under l ying th e a ctions of
arachidonic a c id-d erived p rostaglandins on peripher al no c iception. J Neuroinf lamma tion
17, 30 (20 20).
41. Migliore, A . & Pr oc o pio, S . Ef fec t iven ess and utility of hyaluronic acid i n o steo a r thritis . Cl i n
Cases Miner Bone Metab 12, 31- 3 ( 20 15).
42. Kobaya s h i , T., Chanm ee, T. & Itano, N . Hyaluro nan: Metabo l ism and Function.
Biomolecules 10(2020 ).
43. Yu, P .H., Ch ou, P.Y. , L i, W . N ., T sai , S.J . & Wu, M .H . Th e p ro-infla mm atory a nd ant i -
inflamma t ory role o f hyalur onic acid in endomet r iosi s. Taiwan J Obs t et G yn ecol 60 , 71 1-
717 (2021).
44. Simons, K. & Toom re, D. Lipid raft s and signal t ransdu ction. Nat Rev Mol Ce ll Bio l 1 , 31 -9
(2000).
45. Robinson, G., P i n e d a-Torr a , I. , Ciur tin, C. & Jur y, E. C. Lipid metabolism in au toimm une
rheum atic disease : im pli cation s for modern and convent i o nal t herapi es. J Clin Inve st
132(2022) .
46. Vos kuhl, R. Sex diff erences in aut oim mune diseas e s. Biol S ex Diff er 2 , 1 (2011).
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
47. Boer, C .G . et al. D ec ipher ing os t eoarthr itis genet ic s a c r os s 826, 690 individuals f rom 9
populations. Cell 184, 6003-60 05 (20 21) .
48. Sudlow, C. et al. U K biob a n k : an op en ac cess re source for i d entifying the caus e s of a wide
range of complex dise ase s o f middle and old age. PL oS M e d 12, e1001 7 79 ( 2015).
49. Rahmioglu, N. et al. G enom e-wi d e en richment analys i s between endom etr iosis and
obesity-related t ra its reveals no v el suscept i b i lit y loci. Hum M ol G enet 24 , 1 18 5-99 (2015).
50. Kvaskoff , M. et al. Endomet riosis : a high-r i sk population f or major chr onic diseases? Hum
Reprod Upda te 21, 500- 16 (2015).
51. Atsma, F., Bart eli n k , M .L ., Grobb ee, D .E. & van der Schouw, Y.T . Po stmenop a u s al s t atus
and early menopause as independ ent risk fac t or s for cardiovas c u l ar dis ea s e: a m eta-
analysis. Menopause 13 , 26 5-79 (200 6).
52. Surr ey , E. , Soliman, A.M ., Trenz , H., Blauer -Peterson, C. & Slui s , A. Im pac t o f Endometr i osi s
Diagnostic Dela y s on H ealthcare Resource U t iliz ation and C os t s . Adv Ther 37 , 1087- 10 99
(2020).
53. Loh, P.R. et al. Efficient Bayesia n m ix ed- model ana ly si s incr ease s a sso c iation p ower in large
cohort s . Nat Ge n e t 47 , 284-90 (2 015) .
54. de La n g e, K.M . et al. G en ome-wide asso cia t ion s t udy implic at es immun e ac tivation of
multip le integ r in genes in inflamm a to ry bowel disease. Nat G enet 49, 25 6- 261 (2017).
55. Inter nationa l G en etic s of An k ylo sing S p ondylitis , C . et a l . Iden tification of mult ip le ris k
variants for ankylosin g spond ylitis thr ough high-density genotyping of immune- rela ted loci.
Na t Ge n e t 45 , 730 -8 (20 13).
56. Inter nationa l Multiple Sclerosis Genetics, C . Multiple sc ler os i s genomic map implic at es
peripher al i m mune cell s and microglia in s us ceptibility. Sc ience 365(201 9).
57. Okada, Y. et al. Genetic s of r heumato id ar thri t is contr ibutes to biol ogy and drug dis cover y.
Na t u r e 506, 376-81 ( 201 4).
58. Ricano-Ponce, I . et al. Immunochip m et a-analys is in European and Ar gentinian populati o ns
identif ies two novel genetic loc i ass o c iated with celiac diseas e. Eur J Hum Genet 28, 313-
323 (2020).
59. Stuart , P.E. et al. Tran sethnic analysi s of p s or ia sis su s c ept ibility i n Sou th Asians and
Europ e an s enhance s f ine-mapping in the M HC and genomewide. HG G A d v 3 (2022).
60. W ang , Y. F. et al. Identif i cation of 38 novel loci fo r s y stemic lupus er ythemato s us and
genetic hetero
g en ei t y between ance s tr al gr oups. N at Commun 12, 772 (20 21).
61. W iller , C .J., Li , Y. & Abeca s is , G .R. M E TAL: fas t and efficient me ta- a n a lysis of geno mewi d e
asso ciation s can s. Bioinform atic s 26, 2190-1 (2 010).
62. Trowsdale, J. & K nig h t, J. C. Major his t oc o mpatibili ty complex g en omics and human diseas e.
Annu Rev Ge n omics Hum Genet 14, 3 01-23 (2 013).
63. Hemani, G. et al. The MR- Bas e platf o r m suppor ts sy stematic c au sal inferen ce acro s s t he
human pheno me. Eli f e 7 ( 2018).
64. Burges s, S ., But terwor th, A. & Thomp s on, S . G. Mendelian random i zation a naly sis with
multip le genetic variants using summar iz ed dat a. Genet Epidemiol 37, 658- 65 (201 3).
65. Bowden, J., D avey Smith , G., Hay co c k, P.C . & Bur ge ss, S . C on s istent E stimat ion in
Mendelian Randomiz at i o n w it h S o m e Invali d In s tr ument s Us ing a W eight e d Median
Es t imator . G enet Epidemiol 40, 304-1 4 (201 6).
66. Bowden, J., D avey Smith , G. & Burge s s , S. Mendelian r a n domiz at ion wi th in v ali d
ins t rumen ts : ef fect es t imation and b i as detection thr ough Eg ger regr ession. Int J Epidemiol
44, 512-25 (2 015) .
67. Verb anc k , M. , C hen, C. Y., N eale, B. & Do, R. D etection of widespread horiz ont al p l ei o tropy
in c au s al relationships inferr ed from M endelian rando m i zation be t ween c om plex t ra its and
dis ease s. Nat Genet 50, 69 3-698 (20 18 ).
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
68. Bowden, J. & Holm es , M .V. Meta- anal ysi s and M endelian randomization: A r evi ew. Res
Sy nt h Methods 10, 48 6-496 ( 2019).
69. Consort ium, G . T. et al. Genetic effects on gene ex pr ession a cros s hum a n t issue s . Natur e
550, 20 4-213 (2017 ).
70. Vosa, U . et al. Large-s ca le ci s - a n d trans-eQTL anal yse s identif y t housa n d s of genet i c loci
and polygenic s cores that r eg u l at e blood gene ex pr es sion. Nat Ge net 53 , 1 300-1310
(2021).
71. W at anabe, K. , Tas ke s en, E. , van Boch oven, A. & Posthuma, D . F un c t i o nal m apping a n d
annotat ion o f genetic associa t ions wi th FUMA . N at C ommun 8 , 1826 (2 017 ).
72. Dub ois , P. C. et al. M ultiple c o mmon variants for c eliac dis ea se i n fluenci n g imm une gene
express ion. Nat G enet 42, 295-30 2 (2 010) .
73. Tac h ma z idou, I. et a l . Iden tification of new ther apeutic target s for os t eoart h ritis throu g h
genome-wide analys e s of UK Biobank data. Na t Ge n e t 51 , 230- 236 (2 019).
74. Benth a m , J. et a l. G enet ic as s o ciation analy ses implicate aberr ant regulatio n o f innate and
adaptive im munit y genes in the path o ge n es i s of sy stemic lupus er ythemat os u s. Na t Ge n e t
47, 145 7-1464 (201 5 ).
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint
. CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted July 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.08.24310092doi: medRxiv preprint