Abstract
Background: Endometriomas are cysts caused by
endometriosis that can impair ovarian function and
fertility. Anti-Müllerian hormone (AMH) is an important
marker for ovarian reserve. This study aimed to determine
the optimal timing of operative management fo r
endometrioma by evaluating the impact of cyst size on
ovarian tissue damage and hormone levels. Methods: The
study included 32 endometrioma patients who underwent
laparoscopic cystectomy between February 2018 and
December 2019 at Women and Children’s YPK Hospital,
Jakarta. Patient characteristics were recorded, including
age, parity, BMI, and cyst diameter. Serum AMH levels
were measured using ELISA before and one month after
cystectomy. Immunohistochemical examination assessed
apoptotic factor gene expre ssion on the inner surface
epithelium of endometriomas. Results: AMH levels
declined post-cystectomy in both endometriomas ≤4 cm
and >4 cm, with significant differences in the latter group.
Additionally, there was increased Bax expression in >4 cm
endometriomas. Correlation tests revealed a strong
positive relationship between TNFR1 and Caspase-3 in
both groups. Multivariate analysis suggested a connection
between apoptotic factor gene expression and reduced
AMH levels. Conclusion: TNF -α appears to initiate
apoptosis in endometriomas through the intrinsic
pathway. It is advisable to perform endometrioma surgery
when the diameter is ≤4 cm and before the age of 30 to
achieve optimal outcomes.
Keywords
AMH, apoptosis, caspase -3, caspase -8, caspase -9, gene
expression, endometrioma, intrinsic pathway, P53, Bcl -2/Bax ratio,
cytokine TNF-α.
Introduction
Endometriosis, a medical disorder characterized by the growth of
endometrial tissue outside the uterus, causes an endometrioma, an
ovarian cyst. Endometriomas, also known as brown cysts, are cysts
in the ovaries that contain menstrual blood or endometrial tissue
(Benagiano et al. 2016). Endometriosis, a disorder characterized by
the growth of endometrial tissue outside the uterus, is the primary
cause of endometriomas. The World Health Organization (WHO)
aims to advocate for and support the adoption of effective strategies
and measures to tackle endometriosis worldwide, with a specific
emphasis on low - and middle-income nations. WHO (2023), will
work together with a range of partners, such as educational
institutions, non -state organizations, and other research -focused
groups, to identify effective approaches for preventing, diagnosing,
treating, and providing care for endometriosis. Roughly 10%
Significance | Early laparoscopic cystectomy for endometriomas,
especially before 4 cm diameter, preserves ovarian function, preventing
significant AMH decline and reducing long-term fertility risks.
*Correspondence. Tanzil al Hair, Department Obstetrics and
Gynecology, Faculty of Medicine Universitas
Indonesia, Indonesia.
E-mail:
[email protected]
Editor Mohamed Khadeer Ahamed Basheer, And accepted by the Editorial
Board May 20, 2024 (received for review Mar 31, 2024)
Author Affiliation.
1 Department Obstetrics and Gynecology, Faculty of Medicine Universitas Indonesia,
Indonesia
2 Department of Anatomical Pathology, Faculty of Medicine Universitas Indonesia
Please cite this article.
Tanzil al Hair et al. (2024). Apoptotic Pathways and Anti-Müllerian Hormone affects the
Ovarian Tissue Damage during Endometrioma Cystectomy , Journal of Angiother apy,
8(5), 1-18, 9690
2207-8843/© 2024 ANGIOTHERAPY, a publication of Eman Research, USA.
This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license.
(http.//creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
(https./publishing.emanresearch.org).
ANGIOTHERAPY RESEARCH
https://doi.org/10.25163/angiotherapy.859690 1–18 | ANGIOTHERAPY | Published online May 20, 2024
Endometriosis and endometriomas, prevalent disorders globally,
affect approximately 10% of women in their reproductive years
(Cardoso 2020). cystectomy is a frequently used surgical technique
in gynecology (Brilhante et al. 2017). The consequences of ovarian
tissue damage resulting from endometrioma cystectomy might be
substantial, particularly for women desiring to conceive (Vercellini
et al. 2014). Endometriosis, as described by Ballard et al. (2008), is a
prevalent condition where endometrial glands grow outside the
uterus, leading to potential health concerns and a detrimental
impact on the patient's lifestyle. The primary symptoms linked to
this uterine -infiltrating ailment include intense pain, which can
significantly affect specific patients, as well as the inability to
conceive (Abrao, Muzii, and Marana 2013) . Dysmenorrhea,
dyspareunia, low back pain, tenesmus, painful bowel movements,
pelvic pain that persists, and urinary dysfunction are among the
common complaints (Andres 2014).
Endometriomas are ovarian cysts caused by endometriosis. These
cysts account for roughly 17 –44% of all cases of endometriosis.
Endometriomas induce pain and infertility by inflicting harm on
the adjacent ovarian tissue (Brosens et al. 2013; Fassbender et al.
2015). Drug administration alone is ineffective in treating
endometrioma; hence, cystectomy surgery is necessary. However,
the use of cystectomy surgery is still a topic of debate (Garcia -
Velasco and Somigliana 2009; Kitajima et al. 2014; Margarida 2017).
Cystectomy can result in the extraction of viable ovarian tissue, as
well as a reduction in ovarian reserve (Barnhart, Dunsmoor-Su, and
Coutifaris 2002; Raffi, Shaw, and Amer 2012; Yeung et al. 2011). In
order to assess the decline in ovarian reserve, the levels of anti -
mullerian hormone (AMH) are evaluated (Brosens et al. 2014;
Gardner 2011; Keyhan et al. 2015; Obstet et al. 2016). The diameter
of an endometrioma increases, leading to a drop in the value of anti-
Müllerian hormone (AMH). The AMH value will also decrease if
the endometrioma remains untreated surgically (Carnahan et al.
2013; Chen et al. 2014) . Postponing surgery exacerbates ovarian
harm (Chen et al. 2014; Gordts et al. 2015; Rosen et al. 2012) . 71–
83% of recurring cases detect endometriosis advancement during a
second laparoscopy (Fassbender et al. 2015; Keyhan et al. 2015) .
Brosens et al. (2014), Kitajima et al. (2011), Obstet et al. (2016), it is
necessary to remove tumor tissue in order to safeguard ovarian
reserve. This should be done early, before the tumor reaches a size
of 4 cm. Endometriosis causes the initiation of inflammatory
responses in the abdominal cavity, which negatively impa ct the
quality and quantity of oocytes. These effects are further intensified
by the presence of endometriomas. Endometriomas serve as an
indicator of the extent of endometriosis disease (Briley et al. 2016;
Matsuzaki 2010). According to Gupta et al. (2008) , endometriosis
patches in the peritoneal area affect 99% of instances with an
established endometrioma, impairing the patient's ability to
become pregnant. It has been mentioned by various researchers
(Brosens et al. 2004; Foti et al. 2018; Koninckx et al. 2021) in their
studies.
The peritoneal fluid of patients with endometriosis has a higher
concentration of macrophages. 22 A measure of inflammation,
tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-α), is produced by macrophages.
Patients with endometrioma exhibit a significant presence of TNF-
α in their blood, peritoneum, and endometrioma fluid, along with
other harmful chemicals. Toxic substances cause harm to the
surrounding healthy tissue of the ovary, resulting in fibrosis. This,
in turn, leads to a decrease in the density of follicles (Isono et al.
2019; Somigliana et al. 2012; Sugita et al. 2013) . It is important to
understand the function of TNF -α in regulating the damage to
healthy ovarian tissue surrounding endometrioma. An
investigation was conducted to examine the TNF -α receptors
present on the surface of endometrioma epithelial cells. We can
assess epithelial damage, which acts as a natural protective barrier,
by examining the expression of specific genes involved in apoptosis.
We can determine apoptosis, a form of programmed cell death, by
comparing the levels of Bax expression, a pro -apoptotic factor, to
the expression of Bcl-2, an anti-apoptotic factor, and by measuring
caspase-3 activity, which executes cell death (Obstet et al. 2016;
Sugita et al. 2013) . In endometrioma patients, it is possible to
prevent harm to ovarian tissue by removing the cyst and its
protective capsule from the ovarian tissue as soon as possible with
a cystectomy (Canis et al. 2001; Celik et al. 2012) . This procedure
can lead to the excision of healthy tissue surrounding the
endometrioma, resulting in the depletion of follicles (Raffi et al.
2012). Granulosa cells in ovarian follicles synthesize Anti-Müllerian
hormone (AMH). A reduction in AMH levels might serve as an
indicator of the remaining egg supply in the ovaries, also known as
the ovarian reserve (Iwase et al. 2010; Somigliana et al. 2012; Sugita
et al. 2013) . The European Society of Human Reproduction and
Embryology, or ESHRE, suggests doing laparoscopic cystectomy
for endometriomas in cysts that are equal to or larger than 3 cm.
Identifying an endometrioma already damages the adjacent healthy
tissue, and delaying the cystectomy will worsen the condition of the
surrounding healthy tissue (Matsuzaki 2010) . Nevertheless, the
intensity of discomfort does not correlate with the extent of ovarian
injury (Porpora et al. 1999; Shi et al. 2011) . As a result, cystectomy
is recommended for endometrioma patients who do not experience
pain. The impact of early cystectomy on ovarian reserve before the
endometrioma reaches a size of 3 or 4 cm is currently uncertain in
terms of its benefits or drawbacks. Furthermore, it remains unclear
how much the endometrioma has affected the healthy tissue
surrounding it before its diameter grows to 3 or 4 cm, particularly
in terms of ovarian tissue apoptotic factor expression (Bast 2011;
Miller, Samec, and Alexander -Bryant 2021; Vercellini et al. 2018) .
We must decide when to perform a cystectomy.
ANGIOTHERAPY RESEARCH
https://doi.org/10.25163/angiotherapy.859690 1–18 | ANGIOTHERAPY | Published online May 20, 2024
The objective of this study is to establish the best time for a
cystectomy while maintaining ovarian reserve by analyzing the
damage to ovarian tissue in endometriomas with dimensions of 4 cm. The research aims to provide evidence for the
benefits of early surgical intervention by comparing AMH values
and the expression of apoptotic genes (p53, Bcl -2, Bax, caspase -8,
caspase-9, caspase -3, and TNF -α receptor) before and after
cystectomy. Because the results may improve ovarian reserve
protection in endometrioma-affected women, lowering the chance
of infertility, they will have important socioeconomic ramifications.
Theoretical implications include a more profound understanding
of the relationship between the growth of endometriomas and the
harm inflicted on ovarian tissue, facilitated by apoptotic pathways.
The study also seeks to innovate by identifying biomarkers that
might predict the optimal timing for cystectomy, which could
potentially result in more personalized and efficient treatment
approaches for individuals with endometrioma.
Material and methods
Research Sample
This quasi- experimental study was conducted to evaluate the
impact of laparoscopic cystectomy on serum Anti -Müllerian
Hormone (AMH) levels in patients with endometrioma. The study
was performed at RSIA YPK Jakarta and RSIA Bunda Jakarta from
February 2018 to December 2019. A total of 44 patients were
initially recruited, but only 32 subjects met the inclusion criteria
and completed the study. Inclusion criteria were women aged 18 to
45 years with endometriomas ≤7 cm in diameter and ≤2 cysts,
regular menstrual cycles, no hormonal treatment or contraceptive
use for three months prior, and no pregnancy or history of
recurrent miscarriages. Exclusion criteria included patients with
malignancies, previous ovarian surgeries, smoking within six
months, or endocrine disorders. AMH levels were measured before
and one month after surgery. Non -probability consecutive
sampling was employed to select participants. The sample size was
calculated using a standard formula with α=5%, β=20%, standard
deviation of AMH (s=0.25), and a clinically significant difference
(Δ=15%), resulting in a minimum of 16 subjects per group, with a
final sample size of 32 accounting for a 10% dropout rate. This
methodological approach ensures the reliability and validity of the
findings regarding the effect of cystectomy on ovarian reserve as
indicated by AMH levels.
Research Variables and Operational Definition
The independent variable in this study is the size of the
endometrioma, while the dependent variables include AMH levels,
and the expression of p53, Bcl-2, Bax, caspase-3, caspase-8, caspase-
9, and TNFR -1. The operational definitions for these variables are
as follows: Endometrioma size is measured via two -dimensional
ultrasound by a specialist, with the result recorded in centimeters
(Nominal). The expressions of p53, Bcl -2, Bax, caspase-3, caspase-
8, caspase -9, and TNFR -1 are assessed through
immunohistochemistry (IHC) by comparing the epithelial cell
responses to negative controls, indicating cellular damage, survival,
apoptosis initiation, and TNF -α induced apoptosis, respectively
(Ordinal). AMH levels, before and one month after surgery, are
measured using ELISA to evaluate ovarian reserve (Ordinal). The
difference in AMH levels pre- and post-operation is calculate d to
observe changes in ovarian reserve (Ordinal). The AMH
normogram is referenced from the Yasmin Clinic 2011 data to
determine normal blood levels based on age (Ordinal). These
precise measurements and definitions ensure accurate evaluation of
the study's outcomes related to endometrioma impact and surgical
effects on ovarian function.
Observation Research Methods
The preparation phase included drafting the research proposal and
obtaining ethical approval and permissions for the study at RSIA
Bunda and RSIA YPK Mandiri Jakarta. The study involved
experienced and trained healthcare professionals, including doctors
and nurses, who managed patients with endometrioma and
performed laparoscopic cystectomy procedures. The researcher,
with the help of these professionals, observed and recorded relevant
patient data. Laboratory staff were responsible for blood sample
collection and immunohistochemistry (IHC) analysis, while a
pathology expert assisted in reading and documenting the IHC
results. The laboratory staff also prepared materials to measure the
expression of p53, Bcl -2, Bax, caspase -3, caspase-8, caspase-9, and
TNFR-1, and conducted AMH testing.
Subjects were consecutively selected based on inclusion and
exclusion criteria. Blood samples were drawn from the antecubital
vein to measure preoperative AMH levels. Endometrioma capsule
tissue samples were obtained via stripping during cystectomy and
immediately transported fresh to the Anatomical Pathology
Laboratory for paraffin block preparation and histopathological
examination. IHC staining was performed, and the expression of
p53, Bcl-2, Bax, caspase -3, caspase -8, caspase-9, and TNFR -1 was
evaluated by three doctors: a general practitioner (research
assistant), the primary researcher, and an anatomical pathology
expert. The staining was assessed using an Olympus CX 21 light
microscope, and results were documented with a Nikon Eclipse E
200 and Indomicro camera. Each variable's immunoexpression was
quantified using the histoscore (H-score) formula;
H-score=∑(i×Pi) (1)
Where 𝑖𝑖i is the staining intensity score and 𝑃𝑃𝑖𝑖Pi is the percentage of
cells with positive staining. The epithelial cells were examined at
three fields of view at 400x magnification. Staining intensity was
categorized as weak (1), moderate (2), or strong (3), and
ANGIOTHERAPY RESEARCH
https://doi.org/10.25163/angiotherapy.859690 1–18 | ANGIOTHERAPY | Published online May 20, 2024
percentages of positive cells were scored as 1 ( 80%). IHC expression was considered weak if
the H-score was 6, based on the
receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve. One month post-
surgery, another blood sample was taken from the antecubital vein
to measure postoperative AMH levels, which are expected to
increase after six months. The initial blood sample was collected just
before entering the operating room.
Data Management and Analytics
The collected data were processed comprehensively. Data entry was
performed using SPSS version 20, including sample characteristics
and the expression levels of p53, Bcl -2, Bax, caspase -3, caspase-8,
caspase-9, TNFR-1, and AMH values before and after surgery. Each
data point was coded according to the endometrioma size groups
(≤ 4 cm and > 4 cm) and entered into tables categorized
accordingly. Rows represented the expression levels and AMH
values, while columns denoted the endometrioma size groups.
Univariate analysis was conducted to describe the characteristics of
the variables in frequency distribution form. For numerical data,
mean and standard deviation were used for normally distributed
data, while median and range were applied for non -normally
distributed data. The Kolmogorov -Smirnov test was used to assess
the normality of numerical data distribution. Bivariate analysis
examined the relationships between the expression levels of p53,
Bcl-2, Bax, caspase -3, caspase -8, caspase -9, TNFR -1, and
endometrioma size. It also explored the relationship between the
change in AMH values before and after surgery and endometrioma
size, as well as changes in preoperative AMH values against age -
adjusted AMH normograms. Independent t -tests were used for
normally distributed data and Mann -Whitney tests for non -
normally distributed data. Bivariate analysis also assessed the
relationship between preoperative and postoperative AMH values
within each endometrioma size group, using paired t -tests for
normally distributed data and Wilcoxon-signed rank tests for non-
normally distributed data. Correlation tests determined the
relationships between the expression levels of p53, Bcl -2, Bax,
caspase-3, caspase-8, caspase-9, TNFR-1, and AMH values before
and after surgery. Multivariate analysis was performed to ascertain
the direction and strength of the relationships between the
expression levels of p53, Bcl-2, Bax, caspase-3, caspase-8, caspase-9,
TNFR-1, and postoperative AMH values. Linear regression was
applied to significant variables (p < 0.2) assuming normal, linear,
and homogeneous data distributions. A significance level of α = 0.05
was used, with p-values < 0.05 considered statistically significant.
The study was conducted after receiving ethical approval from the
Ethics Committee of the Faculty of Medicine, University of
Indonesia. Blood samples were taken from patients before and after
surgery, and tissue samples were obtained during the removal of the
endometrioma capsule and a ccompanying healthy tissue. All
samples and blood materials were recorded and numbered
systematically. All procedures were carried out with the knowledge
and consent of the patients or their families, documented in the
medical records.
Results
Table 1. shows that in the paired t test there is no significant
difference in the decrease in AMH values in endometriomas with a
diameter of ≤ 4 cm. In endometriomas with a diameter of > 4 cm,
analysis with a paired t test found a significant difference indicating
that AMH values were associated with surgery.
Comparison of Delta AMH in the Endometrioma Group
In Table 2. It can be seen that the difference in the decrease in AMH
(delta AMH) before cystectomy with normogram values in groups
≤ 4 cm and > 4 cm (delta AMH 2) unpaired t test does not show
significant differences. In both endometrioma groups, there wa s
also no significant difference in the decrease in AMH before and
after cystectomy (delta AMH 1).
Comparison of Delta AMH in Age Groups
To determine the difference in AMH difference before and after
surgery (delta AMH 1) in endometriomas ≤ 4 cm based on age, an
unpaired t test was conducted and the results showed no significant
difference. The difference between preoperative AMH and normal
values in endometriomas ≤ 4 cm (delta AMH 2) was also not
significantly different in both age groups (Table 3.).
In Table 4. Statistical tests were conducted on the endometrioma >
4 cm group in the age group (< 30 years and ≥ 30 years) on the
difference between AMH before and after surgery (delta AMH 1),
as well as the difference between AMH before surgery and normal
values (delta AMH2).
Statistical test Table 4., there was no significant difference in the
decrease in AMH endometrioma > 4 cm (delta AMH 1) in both age
groups. However, delta AMH 2 of the endometrioma > 4 cm group
found a significant difference (p 0.028) in the age group.
Comparison of TNF-α Receptor p53, Bcl -2 and Bax Expression
In Table 5, with IHK examination, there was an increase in TNFR -
1 expression and an increase in diameter > 4 cm, but not significant.
Statistical tests performed on both endometrioma diameter groups
did not find significant differences in the expression of p53 and Bcl-
2. A significant increase in Bax expression (p 0.010) in the
endometrioma > 4 cm group. Increased Bax expression illustrates
heavier tissue damage in ovarian tissue with endometrioma
diameter > 4 cm.
In Table 6., immunohistochemical examination showed an increase
in the expression of Caspase -8, Caspase -9, Caspase -3. Statistical
tests performed on both endometrioma diameter groups found no
significant differences in overall gene expression.
Correlation of Apoptosis Factor Gene Expression and
Endometrioma Diameter
ANGIOTHERAPY RESEARCH
https://doi.org/10.25163/angiotherapy.859690 1–18 | ANGIOTHERAPY | Published online May 20, 2024
In Table 7, the correlation test of Caspase-3 and Caspase-9 found a
strong positive relationship (r 0.780 and r 0.653) and significant (p
= 0.005 and p = 0.001, respectively) in both endometrioma groups
(≤ 4 cm and > 4 cm), illustrating apoptosis takes pla ce through the
instrinsic pathway and apoptosis is strongly associated with both
endometrioma groups. Moderate positive association of Caspase -9
and p53 (r 0.594) and significant (p = 0.054) in endometriomas ≤ 4
cm. Moderate positive association of Bax and p53 (0.508) was not
significant (p = 0.111) in endometrioma ≤ 4 cm.
In Table 7, the TNFR-1 and Caspase-3 correlation test found a very
strong positive relationship (r 0.859) significant (p = 0.001) in
endometrioma diameter ≤ 4 cm and moderate positive (r 0.425)
significant (p = 0.055) in endometrioma diameter > 4 cm. The
TNFR-1 and Caspase -9 correlation test found a strong positive
relationship (r 0.747) significant (p = 0.008) in the endometrioma ≤
4 cm group and a moderate positive correlation (r 0.495) significant
(p = 0.023) in the endometrioma diameter > 4 cm. Increase d
expression of TNFR -1 and p53, positively related moderate (r
0.595) significant (p = 0.053) in endometrioma ≤ 4 cm and weakly
positively related not significant (r 0.375 and p = 0.094) in
endometrioma > 4 cm.
Comparison of AMH, Apoptosis Factor Gene Expression and
Endometrioma Diameter
In Table 8., a comparison was made of AMH before and after
cystectomy in both endometrioma groups. In AMH before
cystectomy, there was no significant decrease in AMH in both
endometrioma groups (≤ 4 cm and > 4 cm) although AMH was
found to be lower in the endometrioma group > 4 cm. In Table 4.9,
there was an increase in the expression of apoptotic factor genes in
endometriomas > 4 cm except p53. A significant differenc e was
found in the expression of Bax (p = 0.010).
Comparison of AMH, Apoptosis Factor Gene Expression and Age
Groups
In Table 9, AMH before and after cystectomy was higher in the age
group < 30 years compared to age ≥ 30 years but no significant
difference was found. Comparison of apoptotic factor gene
expression in both age groups (≥ 30 years and < 30 years) found no
significant difference. Bax was fou nd to be higher in the < 30 year
old group but not significant.
Expression of Bax, Caspase-9 and Diameter Increase
In this study, it was found that the increase in diameter was followed
by an increase in gene expression, especially Bax. Other parameters
in the 3 cm cyst and 4-5 cm diameter cyst groups were also followed
by an increase in gene expression except in the 6 cm diameter group
where there was a downward trend.
There was an increasing trend in Bax expression values with
increasing cyst diameter, but not in the expression of other genes in
the study. In other gene expressions, the increase occurred up to
diameter 4-5 and decreased at diameter 6.
Percentage of Positive Values of Apoptosis Factor Gene Expression
In Figure 3, it appears that in this study all factors examined showed
positive values or positive.
CPI reactions with the lowest exposure presented by Caspase -8 at
25% and the highest was Bax 97%.
Figure 3. Percentage of Positive Values of Apoptosis Factor
Expression
In Table 10, the number of cysts and age were found to be weakly
negative and not significant, as well as postoperative, there was a
weak negative relationship not significant in more than one cyst and
age after surgery.
Table 10., Correlation between the number of cysts and age
In Figure 4A, there is a decrease in AMH values from normal values
with increasing age of endometrioma patients who have more than
one cyst and AMH values lower than normal before surgery.
Relationship between AMH-post Surgery and Age
In Figure 4B., this study found a decrease in AMH as the number of
cysts increase;
In Figure 4C. it is found that the age of patients with endometrioma
and more than one cyst will have a lower decrease in AMH value
after surgery. The decrease in AMH value in cysts that are more
than one is much lower.
In Table 11, the correlation test found a positive association of
decreased AMH values before surgery with apoptotic factor gene
expression. Increased p53 expression was positively associated very
strongly (r 0.895) and significantly (p < 0.001) with delta AMH-2 in
the endometrioma ≤ 4 cm group. Increased expression of TNFR -1
had a moderate positive relationship and was not significant with
delta AMH-2 in the endometrioma ≤ 4 cm group. A moderate and
significant positive relationship was found for Bax expre ssion, in
the endometrioma > 4 cm group.
In multivariate analysis Table 12. it was found that the expression
of apoptotic factors was significantly positively and strongly
associated with a decrease in baseline AMH levels (before surgery)
in the endometrioma ≤ 4 cm group (R2 = 0.918) and signific antly
positively and strongly associated with the > 4 cm group.
Relationship between Apoptosis Factor and Delta AMH -1 Gene
Expression
In Table 13, the correlation test of AMH difference after before
surgery in the endometrioma group > 4 cm, TNFR-1 expression was
found to have a strong negative relationship (r -0.687) significant (p
= 0.001) and a moderate negative relationship ( -0.506) significant
(p = 0.019) Bax expression.
In Table 13. the endometrioma ≤ 4 cm group, TNFR -1 expression
had a moderate negative relationship and was not significant. A
strong negative relationship (r- 0.654) significant (p = 0.029) was
found in Caspase-9 expression, Caspase-3 expression (r -0.705 p =
0.010) and p53 (r - 0.738 p = 0.010). The expression of these
ANGIOTHERAPY RESEARCH
https://doi.org/10.25163/angiotherapy.859690 1–18 | ANGIOTHERAPY | Published online May 20, 2024
apoptotic factors illustrated a strong association with decreased
AMH after surgery, except for Bcl-2.
In Table 14, there was a very strong relationship (R2 0.957) of
apoptosis factor gene expression to AMH values after surgery in the
endometrioma ≤ 4 cm group. There was a moderate positive
association (R2 0.405) in the endometrioma > 4 cm group in the
decrease of AMH after surgery.
In this study, the gene expression of apoptotic factors was examined
by means of IHK to see the role of pro- inflammatory TNF -𝛼𝛼
inducing cell apoptosis in ovarian tissue damage. TNFR -1
expression was found to be 47% strong intensity, Caspase -8 strong
intensity 25%, p53 expression strong intensity 66% and Bax
expression strong intensity increased 97%. This increase in Bax
expression was found in both groups of endometriomas ≤ 4 cm and
> 4 cm.
Bcl-2 expression (Figure 5A ) was found in 48% of strong positive
reactions and 97% % of cases were found in strong intensity Bax
expression (Figure 5B ). The normal ratio of cells in defending
themselves from exposure is high anti -apoptotic (Bcl -2) and low
pro apoptotic (Bax). Increased expression of Bax followed by high
expression of Caspase -9 (85%) (Figure 5C ) proves mitochondrial
damage which shows a strong positive reaction and high expression
of Caspase -3 (Figure 5D) (56%) as the executor of cell death
indicates apoptosis occurs.
Figure 5. Blue arrows indicate positive CPI values, black arrows
indicate negative CPI values.
Discussion
Laparoscopic Cystectomy for Endometrioma
This study divided the diameter of endometriomas into two groups,
namely ≤ 4 cm and > 4 cm. This grouping refers to the HIFERI
policy on the management of endometriosis pain with
endometriomas. Currently, surgery is performed on large
diameters. In accordance with Chen et al. (2014) Henes and Engler
(2018) because AMH values decrease after 5 cm and 7 cm
endometrioma diameter. In contrast to them, this study showed
that the AMH value of endometriomas ≤ 4 cm had decreased before
surgery. This proves that exposure to toxic substances damages
healthy tissue since small diameters before reaching 4 cm (Rumph
et al. 2020) . In accordance with Feng, Gao, and Peng (2019),
Kitajima et al. (2014), Matsuzaki (2010) , reported high 8 -
hydroxydeoxyguanosine as an indicator of DNA damage due to
oxidative stress and the formation of fibrosis in the tissue around
endometriomas as an indication of chronic inflammatory
processes. It is necessary to perform small diameter surgery to avoid
extensive fibrosis formation...
In endometriomas ≤ 4 cm and > 4 cm, AMH values had decreased
before surgery and worsened significantly after surgery in
endometriomas > 4 cm. However, it was not significant in ≤ 4 cm.
Endometriomas decrease ovarian reserve and the risk increases
with increasing diameter. AMH values falling from normal
preoperatively are in line with (Davies et al. 2019; Uncu et al. 2013).
Delaying surgery is avoided because surgery of small
endometriomas (≤ 4 cm) does not significantly reduce AMH values.
Also to prevent worsening of ovarian reserve due to time, as well as
when cystectomy of endometriomas > 4 cm.
In this study, AMH values after and before surgery for
endometriomas ≤ 4 cm did not differ significantly. In line with
Brosens et al. (2014) , early preventive measures are needed to
maintain fertility. Endometrioma surgery ≤ 4 cm is recommended,
because small endometriomas without surgery have reduced AMH
values. According to Dr. Kasapoglu131, the rate of AMH decline
was greater in endometriom as (26.4%) than in normal ovaries
(7.4%). The rate of decline based on age in normal ovaries was 0.2
ng/mL/year130. In line with Gordts (2017), loss of ovarian reserve
in endometriomas < 4 cm coincides with fibrosis in the ovarian
cortex. Therefore, early detection and removal of endometrioma
toxic substances is necessary to minimize the risk of ovarian tissue
damage with endometrioma surgery before it is > 4 cm in diameter.
Endometrioma Diameter and Age
When compared to unilateral endometriomas, large, bilateral
endometriomas considerably lower AMH values. AMH readings
were much lower in this study due to the age of the individuals and
several endometriomas. Bilateral AMH readings were lower than
unilateral AMH values both before and one month after surgery.
According to research by Busacca and Vignali (2009), Hwu et al.
(2011), Kitajima et al. (2011) , the postoperative AMH value drop
will depend on the cyst's width and bilaterality. Prior to surgery, the
basal AMH value was low, which is a factor that exacerbates the fall
in AMH value and should be taken seriously. In order to prevent
harm early on an d prevent the basal AMH value from worsening
the postoperative AMH value, surgery should be performed before
the diameter reaches 4 cm. 62% of the participants in this study had
AMH readings that were below normal and that dramatically
dropped following su rgery for endometriomas larger than 4 cm.
This shows the possibility of a significant drop in AMH values in
the event that surgery is postponed. Large diameter surgery carries
a higher risk of increased ovarian reserve depletion and decreased
basal AMH lev els. According to Chiu et al. (2022) , there is a
significant correlation between large endometriomas and the high
incidence of recurrence following surgery. Surgery at small
diameters is recommended because to the potential for greater loss
of healthy tissue in larger diameters and the significance of the basal
AMH value prior to surgery (Alammari, Lightfoot, and Hur 2017).
In this study, 77% of the participants were older than 30, and 40%
of the subjects had AMH values less than 1.4 ng/mL. If the embryo
transfer is done at a young age, Iwase et al. (2010), Shi et al. (2011)
states that these low AMH values are strongly linked to the failure
ANGIOTHERAPY RESEARCH
https://doi.org/10.25163/angiotherapy.859690 1–18 | ANGIOTHERAPY | Published online May 20, 2024
Table 1. AMH Values Before and After Cystectomy in Endometriomas ≤ 4 cm and
Endometrioma Sebelum Sesudah p
≤ 4 cm 2,393 (± 1,619) 1,752 (± 1,955) 0,083
> 4 cm 1,656 (± 0,945) 1,276 (± 0,911) 0,023
Table 2. Association of Delta AMH 1 and Delta AMH 2 with Endometrioma ≤ 4 cm versus > 4 cm
Delta AMH ≤ 4 cm (n = 11) > 4 cm (n = 21) p
Delta AMH 1 -1,029 (± 0,710) -0,599 (±0,854) 0,164
Delta AMH 2 -0,971 (±1,951) -0,985 (±1,484) 0,982
Table 3. Delta AMH in Endometrioma ≤ 4 cm by Age Group
Delta AMH ≥ 30 tahun
(n = 7)
4 cm by Age Group
Delta AMH ≥ 30 tahun (n = 13) < 30 Tahun (n = 8) p
Delta AMH 1 -0,512 (± 0,761) -0,738 (± 1,027) 0,570
Delta AMH 2 -0,441 (± 0,950) -1,868 (± 1,817) 0,028
Table 5. Apoptosis Factor Gene Expression in Endometriomas 4 cm (n = 21) p
TNFR-1, Rerata (SB) 5,414 (± 3,350) 5,855 (± 3,387) 0,728
Ekspresi p53, Rerata (SB) 6,831 (± 3,304) 6,127 (± 2,270) 0,483
Bcl-2, Rerata (SB) 5,107 (± 2,328) 5,981 (± 3,691) 0,420
Bax , Rerata (SB) 11,340 (± 4,125) 14,981 (± 3,222) 0,010
Table 6. Expression of Caspase-8, Caspase-9, Caspase-3 in Endometriomas ≤ 4 cm and > 4 cm
Ekspresi Gen ≤ 4 cm (n = 11) > 4 cm (n = 21) p
Caspase-3, Rerata (SB) 5,841 (± 4,096) 7,367 (± 4,675) 0,369
Caspase-8, Rerata (SB) 3,969 (± 2,269) 4,436 (± 4,624) 0,756
Caspase-9, Rerata (SB) 8,353 (± 3,948) 11,245 (± 4,109) 0,065
Table 7. Correlation of Apoptosis Factor Gene Expression on Endometrioma Diameter
Gene Expression ≤ 4 cm (n = 11) > 4 cm (n = 21)
r p r p
Caspase-3 – Caspase-9
Caspase 3 – Bax
Caspase 9 – Bax
0,780
0,607
0,630
0,005
0,048
0,038
0,653
0,380
0,443
0,001
0,089
0,045
Caspase-9 – p53 0,594 0,054 0,078 0,736
TNFR-1 – Caspase-3 0,859 0,001 0,425 0,055
TNFR-1 – Caspase-8 0,467 0,147 0,231 0,313
TNFR-1 – Caspase-9 0,747 0,008 0,495 0,023
TNFR-1 – p53
TNFR-1 – Bax
p53 – Bax
Bcl-2 – Bax
Caspase 8– Bax
0,595
0,586
0,508
0,487
0,160
0,053
0,056
0,111
0,137
0,638
0,375
0,456
0,172
0,407
0,116
0,094
0,038
0,455
0,067
0,617
Table 8. AMH and Apoptosis Factor Gene Expression in Endometrioma Diameter ≤ 4 cm and > 4 cm
AMH dan Ekspresi Gen ≤ 4 cm (n = 11) > 4 cm (n = 21) p
AMH
Sebelum
2,392 (± 1,619)
1,656 (± 0,945)
0,113
Sesudah 1,753 (± 1,955) 1,276 (± 0,911) 0,352
Expression
Expression p53, Rerata (SB)
6,831 (± 3,304)
6,127 (± 2,270)
0,483
Bcl-2, Rerata (SB) 5,107 (± 2,328) 5,981 (± 3,691) 0,420
Bax, Average (SB) 11,340 (± 4,125) 14,981 (± 3,222) 0,010
Caspase-3, Rerata (SB) 5,841 (± 4,096) 7,367 (± 4,675) 0,369
Caspase-8, Rerata (SB) 3,969 (± 2,269) 4,436 (± 4,624) 0,756
Caspase-9, Rerata (SB) 8,353 (± 3,948) 11,245 (± 4,109) 0,065
TNFR-1, Rerata (SB) 5,414 (± 3,350) 5,855 (± 3,387) 0,728
ANGIOTHERAPY RESEARCH
https://doi.org/10.25163/angiotherapy.859690 1–18 | ANGIOTHERAPY | Published online May 20, 2024
Table 9. AMH and Apoptosis Factor Gene Expression by Age Group ≥ 30 Years and < 30 Years
AMH dan Ekspresi Gen ≥ 30 tahun
(n = 20)
< 30 Tahun
(n = 12)
p
AMH
Before
1,747 (± 1,180)
2,180 (± 1,353)
0,349
After 1,350 (± 1,515) 1,590 (± 1,063) 0,635
Expression
Ekspresi p53, Rerata (SB)
6,596 (± 2,403)
5,991 (± 3,065)
0,539
BCL-2, Rerata (SB) 6,340 (± 3,194) 4,581 (± 3,248) 0,144
Bax , Rerata (SB) 13,489 (± 4,207) 14,130 (± 3,494) 0,661
Caspase-3, Rerata (SB) 7,00 (± 3,870) 6,575 (± 5,526) 0,798
Caspase-8, Rerata (SB) 4,806 (± 4,772) 3,392 (± 1,731) 0,333
Caspase-9, Rerata (SB) 10,256 (± 4,146) 10,243 (± 4,546) 0,993
TNFR-1, Rerata (SB) 6,045 (±3,260) 5,133 (± 3,501) 0,461
Table 10. Correlation between the number of cysts and age
Kista r p
Unilateral (pre) -0,052 0,832
Bilateral (pre)
Unilateral (post)
Bilateral (post)
-0,319
-0,104
-0,286
0,289
0,672
0,343
Table 11. Association of Apoptosis Factor Gene Expression with Delta AMH-2 Based on Endometrioma
Gene Expression ≤ 4 cm (n = 11) > 4 cm (n = 21)
r p r p
TNFR-1 – Delta AMH-2 0,569 0,068 0,437 0,048
p53 – Delta AMH-2 0,895 < 0,001 0,181 0,432
Bax – Delta AMH-2 0,455 0,160 0,533 0,013
Caspase-3– Delta AMH-2 0,539 0,087 0,198 0,389
Caspase-8– Delta AMH-2 -0,279 0,406 0,159 0,490
Caspase-9– Delta AMH-2 0,532 0,092 0,170 0,461
BCL-2 – Delta AMH-2 0,648 0,031 0,005 0,984
Table 12. Correlation of Apoptosis Factor Gene Expression to AMH-1 Based on Endometrioma Size
Gene Expression ≤ 4 cm (R 2 = 0,918) > 4 cm (R2 = 0,648)
Koefisien p Koefisien p
TNFR --1 1,390 0,035 -0,620 0,016
p53 -0,989 0,024 0,182 0,386
Bax 0,371 0,127 -0,280 0,191
Caspase-3 -1,069 0,033 0,156 0,544
Caspase-8 -0,581 0,094 -0,090 0,629
Caspase-9 -403 0,180 -0,234 0,368
BCL-2 - - 0,197 0,416
Table 13. Association of Apoptosis Factor Gene Expression with Delta AMH-1 by Endometrioma Size
Ekspresi ≤ 4 cm (n = 11) > 4 cm (n = 21)
r p r p
TNFR-1 - Delta AMH -0,472 0,143 -0,687 0,001
p53 - Delta AMH -0,738 0,010 -0,014 0,953
Bax - Delta AMH -0,313 0,349 -0,506 0,019
Caspase-3 - Delta AMH -0,705 0,010 -0,239 0,296
Caspase-8 - Delta AMH 0,099 0,773 -0,146 0,528
Caspase-9 - Delta AMH -0,654 0,029 -0,484 0,026
BCL-2 - Delta AMH -0,227 0,502 -0,027 0,906
ANGIOTHERAPY RESEARCH
https://doi.org/10.25163/angiotherapy.859690 1–18 | ANGIOTHERAPY | Published online May 20, 2024
Table 14. Multivariate Analysis of Apoptosis Factor Gene Expression on AMH-2 in the Endometrioma Group
Ekspresi ≤ 4 cm (R 2 = 0,957) > 4 cm (R2 = 0,405)
Koefisien p Koefisien p
TNFR-1 0,491 0,286 - -
p53 0,594 < 0,001 - -
Bax -0,114 0,555 0,295 0,184
Caspase-3 -0,318 0,340 0,521 0,031
Caspase-8 -0,319 0,249 - -
Caspase-9 0,055 0,808 - -
BCL-2 0,387 0,074 -0,301 0,165
Figure 1. Theoretical Framework of Ovarian Reserve Damage in Endometrioma
Figure 2. Bax Expression and Endometrioma Diameter Increase.
Figure 3. Percentage of Positive Values of Apoptosis Factor Expression.
0.00
50.00
100.00
TNFR Cas 8 BCL2 BAX Cas 9 Cas 3 P 53
ANGIOTHERAPY RESEARCH
https://doi.org/10.25163/angiotherapy.859690 1–18 | ANGIOTHERAPY | Published online May 20, 2024
A B
C
A B
C D
Figure 4 (A) Relationship between Age and Pre-operative AMH. (B)
Relationship between Post-operative AMH and Number of Cysts. (C)
Relationship between Age and Post-operative AMH Value.
Figure 5 (A) Expression of Bcl-2; Cytoplasm of Moderately
Positive Epithelium by Immunohistochemistry. (B) Bax
Expression; Strong Positive Epithelial Cytoplasm by
Immunohistochemistry. (C) Caspase-9 Expression; Cytoplasm
of Strongly Positive Epithelial Cells by Immunohistochemical
Reaction. (D) Caspase-3 Expression; Strong Positive Epithelial
Cell Cytoplasm by Immunohistochemical Reaction
Figure 6. Proposed Mechanism of Ovarian
Tissue Damage by TNF-α
ANGIOTHERAPY RESEARCH
https://doi.org/10.25163/angiotherapy.859690 1–18 | ANGIOTHERAPY | Published online May 20, 2024
of the embryo transfer process. An estimated 17 –44% of
endometriosis patients also have endometriomas, and 20 –40% of
them will use assisted reproductive technologies. AMH readings
will decline with age, and Briley et al. (2016), Seifer, Baker, and
Leader (2011), state that age is a significant factor in aggravating the
loss of ovarian reserve. It is critical to identify endometriomas as
soon as possible to preserve ovarian reserve. 25% of the individuals
had an AMH value of less than 1 ng/mL when they were brought to
the hospital; this indicated a poor prognosis for a successful
induction of ovulation and a lowered likelihood of becoming
pregnant. The group with the highest severity was composed of 6%
of patients who arrived at the hospital with an AMH result bel ow
0.5 µg/mL, which is the cutoff point for early menopause. The
proportion of patients with low fertility rose following cystectomy.
In that order, 31% (< 0.5 ng/mL), 44% (< 1 ng/mL), and 56% (< 1.4
ng/mL) were found. This is in line with the findings of Celik et al.
(2012), who have indicated that patients with basal or preoperative
AMH concentrations will have worse reproductive outcomes.
Therefore, surgery should be done while AMH readings are still
good in order to prevent more serious harm (Lew 2019; Sugita et al.
2013; Zikargae 2018).
The 30-year restriction used in this study is based on Isono et al.
(2019), who stated that severe endometriosis was managed before
the age of 30 in order to conceive. Atkins' research indicates that
primordial follicles are also strongly impacted by age.49 AMH
readings become basal values prior to surgery as people age,
according to Briley et al. (2016), Seifer, Baker, and Leader (2011).
Age is therefore a factor in this investigation. The deterioration of
healthy ovarian tissue is related to age. Age -related increases in
ovarian tissue damage are marked by elevated Bax expression at 30
years of age and greater attempts by the body to re pair the damage
by markedly raising Bcl -2 at 30 years of age. This study also
indicated that age has an impact on AMH values. Before surgery,
there was a statistically significant difference in the low AMH values
between the age 30 and endometrioma > 4 cm groups. According
to Isono et al. (2019), it is advised that attempts be made to achieve
conception before the age of thirty. The findings of this study
suggest that endometrioma surgery should be performed before to
the age of thirty years and before the endometrioma diameter
reaches four centimeters (Gordts et al. 2015).
Apoptosis Factor and AMH Gene Expression
The study observed a correlation between the growth of
endometrioma and the upregulation of genes associated with
apoptosis. This was demonstrated by the increased expression of
TNF-α receptors, Caspase-8, Bcl-2, Bax, Caspase-9, and Caspase-3,
which are kn own to play a role in cell death. Apoptosis of the
endometrioma epithelium is enhanced, leading to the removal of
natural barriers and causing more harm to the ovarian reserves,
particularly the primordial follicles. According to Gupta's findings,
it has been observed that granulosa cells, which are responsible for
producing AMH, undergo apoptosis. The study observed a rise in
apoptosis, which was subsequently accompanied by a decrease in
AMH levels from their initial normal values before to surgery.
There was no significant difference in the expression of apoptotic
factor genes between the two endometrioma groups, one with a size
of 4 cm or less and the other with a size greater than 4 cm. This
demonstrates that the exposure to hazardous compounds occurs
over a range of dimensions, starting from small (2.5 cm) and
extending to larger (6 cm) sizes. This study demonstrates that the
existence of endometrioma has caused early harm to healthy tissue
and is linked to preoperative exposure to toxic substances. Thi s
study additionally demonstrated that pro -inflammatory cytokines
contribute to the destruction of ovarian tissue.
The expression of caspase increased as the diameter of the
endometrioma increased. The enlargement of endometrioma
diameter to more than 4 cm is indicative of heightened Caspase -9
expression, which signifies mitochondrial impairment. This
process commences with an upregulation of Bax expression,
leading to the creation of apoptosomes that trigger the conversion
of procaspase-9 into active Caspase -9. Elevated levels of Caspase -9
induce the activation of Caspase -3, leading to the initiation of
programmed cell death. This diagram depicts the progressive
deterioration of ovarian tissue as the size of the endometrioma
increases. According to Sanchez et al. (2014), Gene expression alters
the physical barrier separating cyst fluid from healthy ovarian
tissue, allowing reactive oxygen species (ROS) to induce fibrosis by
crossing the cyst wall. This study found that TNF -α stimulated the
expression of genes associated with programmed cell death and was
associated with harm to nearby healthy tissue. Brosens et al. (2004),
Chiu et al. (2022) , provided evidence that smooth muscle
metaplasia, fibrosis of the cortical layer, and the extent of the
endometrioma are associated with a decrease in AMH levels.
Cystectomy is necessary to halt the enlargement of the cyst's
diameter and minimize exposure to harmful substances.
Activation of TNF -α receptors by pro -inflammatory cytokines,
which in turn initiated the process of programmed cell death in the
epithelial cells of both endometrioma groups (≤ 4 cm and > 4 cm).
This aligns with the findings of Vetvicka,11 who demonstrated the
involvement of pro -inflammatory cytokines in triggering the
apoptotic cascade. The IHK's response to TNFR -1 is feeble, which
aligns with the findings of Salmeri's research.The number is 68. An
escalation in the severity of endometriosis leads to a red uction in
the level of TNF -α binding with its receptor (TNFR -1).
Endometriosis is a persistent inflammatory condition. During the
chronic inflammatory process, the M1 phenotype transitions into
the M2 phenotype. M2 is a type of immune cell called a macrophage
that plays a role in tissue regeneration and the development of
fibrosis. As a result, the presence of TNF -α, a pro -inflammatory
ANGIOTHERAPY RESEARCH
https://doi.org/10.25163/angiotherapy.859690 1–18 | ANGIOTHERAPY | Published online May 20, 2024
molecule, is reduced. Hence, it is imperative to halt the
inflammatory process that triggers damage to ovarian tissue and the
development of permanent fibrosis once the diagnosis is
established.
Gene expression is the process by which organisms modify gene
transcription in order to respond to environmental factors such as
hormones, heavy metals, and toxins. This work demonstrates that
cells undergo a process of adaptation in response to the risk o f
mortality, characterized by an upregulation of Bcl -2 expression,
albeit with low intensity. Similarly, studies carried out by
(Dufournet et al. 2006; Korkmaz et al. 2013; Pejovic et al. 2020) .
revealed a low level of Bcl-2 expression in 25% of the analyzed cases.
The Bcl-2/Bax ratio serves as an indicator of the cell's capacity to
withstand exposure to harmful chemicals. The endometrioma
epithelium exhibited a significant increase in Bax expre ssion in
comparison to Bcl -2 expression. Elevated levels of pro -apoptotic
expression are indicative of the intensity of toxicant exposure,
leading to cellular demise. Eliminating exposure to hazardous
substances is a viable strategy to enhance the flexibil ity of the
natural barrier in the ovaries.
The cell membrane contains TNF-α receptors, which are referred to
as death receptors (DRs) or death signals. The correlation analysis
between TNFR -1 expression and apoptosis occurrence revealed a
robust positive association, indicating that the pro -inflammatory
cytokine TNF-α initiates the apoptotic pathway in the epithelium of
endometriomas. Apoptosis occurs via the intrinsic mechanism,
namely including upregulation of Bax, Caspase -9, and Caspase -3.
(Illustration of the proposed mechanism can be found in F igure 6)
This contrasts with the findings of Haupt et al. (2003), Obstet et al.
(2016), Salmeri et al. (2015), propose that the active TNF-α receptor
induces apoptosis via the extrinsic pathway. Specifically, the active
death receptor activates Caspase -8 and Caspase -3. Contrarily, this
work aligns with Bredesen's findings that TNF-α effectively attaches
to death receptors and triggers apoptosis both directly via caspases
and indirectly through mitochondria.
The study found a drop in the balancing ratio of Bcl -2/Bax. The
levels of pro -apoptotic Bax were higher in both endometrioma
groups (≤ 4 cm and > 4 cm) and showed a significant difference.
Elevated Bax expression leads to mitochondrial impairment, which
serves as a vital energy source for cells.Prolonged exposure to
harmful substances will result in cellular apoptosis and irreversible
cellular harm. 121 Activation of death receptors triggers the
production of Bax and p53, which are involved in preserving th e
integrity of the genome (the guardian of the genome).One hundred
eighteen If cell damage cannot be healed, the presence of activated
Bax alters the proportion of Bcl-2 to Bax (Depalo et al. 2009; Haupt
et al. 2003). The investigation revealed a notable increase (66%) in
p53 expression, indicating the presence of significant damage.
Consistent with (Fauvet et al. 2005; Haupt et al. 2003) . Dufournet
et al. (2006) Fauvet et al. (2005), observed that the expression of p53
was elevated in borderline cysts, specifically endometriomas and
ovarian cancers, compared to benign ovarian cysts. Ensuring the
cessation of contact with harmful substances is of utmost
importance after endometrioma is diagnosed. According to
Lincenstein, mitochondrial damage is both permanent and
progressively worsens from a mild to severe state.One hundred
seventeen The study demonstrates a significant upregulation of Bax
and p53, which are indicators of apoptosis, i ndicating the severity
of exposure. The upregulation of p53 in this study is consistent with
the findings of (Chen et al. 2014; Fauvet et al. 2005) . In contrast to
Nezhat's research, which found negative p53 staining in 30 cases of
ovarian endometriosis cysts, this study observed positive Bcl -2
expression that aligns with its own findings. Higher levels of p53
expression serve as a sign of advancing cases that necessitate
immediate intervention, hence it is advisable to refrain from
postponing endometrioma surgery. All instances showed a high
level of Bax expression (97%), suggesting a reduced Bcl-2/Bax ratio.
Cell death occurs as a result of mitochon drial dysfunction caused
by damage to the mitochondrial membrane (Bateman, Blanco, and
Sheffi 2017; Heca et al. 2018) . Apoptosis is observed by the
upregulation of Caspase-3, which acts as the executor of cell death.
This diverges from (Depalo et al. (2009), Giacomini et al. (2017) ,
states that endometrial lesions sustain their survival by evading
apoptosis or enhancing the Bcl -2/Bax ratio. Nevertheless, this
distinction aligns with the viewpoint of Nisolle and Donnez (2019),
who argues that endometrioma, as a cyst caused by endometriosis
in the ovary, is a distinct entity from endometriosis lesions in the
peritoneal cavity and deep infiltrating endometriosis located in the
rectum. Therefore, medicine alone is not a successful treatment for
endometrioma, and surgery is the preferred initial option.
Apoptotic factor gene expression (Bax, Caspase -9, Caspase-3) was
greater in endometriomas larger than 4 cm compared to those that
were 4 cm or less. There was a notable disparity in the expression of
Bax, with a p -value of 0.01. The levels of Caspase -9 and Caspase-3
were elevated in endometriomas larger than 4 cm, however the
difference was not statistically significant. A correlation test was
conducted to examine the expression of apoptotic factor genes in
the endometrioma group with a size more than 4 cm. The results
showed a significant and strong positive association between
Caspase-3 and Caspase -9. The expression of TNFR -1 showed a
modest and statistically significant positive connection with
Caspase-9 (r = 0.495) and Caspase-3 (r = 0.425). This demonstrates
how the intrinsic pathway's apoptotic process is triggered by
proinflammatory cytokines (TNF -α) in both endometrioma
groups. This study demonstrates that gene expression reveals
serious damage when the diameter exceeds 4 cm. Therefore, to
prevent the widespread deterioration of the ovarian natural barrier,
ANGIOTHERAPY RESEARCH
https://doi.org/10.25163/angiotherapy.859690 1–18 | ANGIOTHERAPY | Published online May 20, 2024
it is advisable to undergo surgery prior to the ovarian diameter
reaching 4 cm.
This study observed a rise in the mortality of the epithelial cells in
the endomyoma wall. According to Muzii et al. (2007) out of 40%
of the cyst surface lacks epithelium. The absence of a natural barrier
facilitates the susceptibility of surrounding healthy tissue to damage
from exposure to poisonous substances released by endometrioma.
The injury is identified by a reductio n in the AMH value prior to
the surgical procedure. These findings align with the research
conducted by (Garcia -Velasco and Somigliana 2009; Giacomini et
al. 2017) . They indicate that endometriomas decrease the anti -
Müllerian hormone (AMH) levels in both blood and follicular fluid.
Endometriomas have a detrimental impact on the surrounding
tissue as a result of disruptions in iron metabolism and the
occurrence of oxidative stress. Kitajima et al. (2011), in their study,
observed a higher occurrence of primary follicle degeneration in the
ovarian cortex of endometriomas, along with increased caspase -3
expression and reduced diameter of primordial follicles, as
compared to ovaries without cysts. This study examines how the
absence of the normal protective barrier in the ovaries affects the
harm caused to the surrounding healthy tissue by the
endometrioma. Consequently, it is imperative to perform surgery
promptly upon diagnosing endometrioma in order to pre vent the
spread of harmful compounds from the endometrioma and prevent
more harm.
Consistent with the findings of Khan et al. (2013), Kitajima et al.
(2014), Matsuzaki (2010), our study demonstrates that the absence
of endometrioma epithelium raises the risk of further harm to the
ovarian reserve from additional hazardous substances associated
with endometrioma. Measures must be implemented to safeguard
the quantity and qualit y of oocytes, particularly the primordial
follicles, as well as the ovarian reserve. Consistent with the findings
of Coccia et al. (2014), Nisolle and Donnez (2019), the mesothelium
that covers the ovary might fold inward, causing the primordial
follicles to be displaced towards the rear of the cyst. The study found
that the lack of epithelium allowed hazardous chemicals to directly
access the primordial follicles. T he reduction in the quantity of
primordial follicles will impact the AMH level. Prior to surgery, it
is crucial to assess the basal anti -Müllerian hormone (AMH) levels
in order to prevent any potential ovarian dysfunction. Early surgical
intervention is necessary in order to safeguard fertility and prevent
harm to the adjacent healthy tissue surrounding the endometrioma.
This study revealed that the expression of apoptotic factor genes
influences the ability of free radicals to traverse the natural barrier.
The upregulation of TNF -α receptors marks the initiation of the
apoptotic pathway, leading to ovarian tissue damage and decreased
AMH levels prior to surgery in both groups with endometrioma.
According to Sanchez's research, the AMH value decreases as a sign
of ovarian reserve loss caused by fibrosis surrounding the
endometrioma. ROS, or reactive oxygen species, penetrates the cyst
wall and contributes to the development of ovarian fibrosis,
resulting in a decrease in follicular density. Miller et al. (2021), it has
been observed that reactive oxygen species (ROS) can permeate past
the cyst membrane barrier and cause harm to the surrounding
healthy tissue around the endometrioma. It is crucial to inhibit the
activation of death receptors by pro- inflammatory c ytokines to
prevent extensive damage to the ovaries (Akhtar Muhammad 2021;
Foti et al. 2018).
According to a correlation test, there was a substantial positive link
between TNFR -1 expression and increased expression of Bax,
caspase-9, and caspase -3 with moderate, strong, and very strong
Results
in both endometrioma groups (≤ 4 cm and > 4 cm). This
demonstrates th at apoptosis takes place via the intrinsic
mechanism. The activity of the intrinsic pathway was enhanced by
upregulation of Bax, leading to increased production of caspase -9
and caspase -3, which exhibited a highly significant positive
correlation. Both set s of endometriomas had a significant
correlation between the expression of apoptotic factor genes,
ranging from mild to strong. Unlike Vetvicka's study, TNF -α
triggers apoptosis through the extrinsic mechanism by activating
receptors. This work demonstrate s that exposure to the pro-
inflammatory cytokine TNF-α activates the TNFR-1 receptor in the
epithelium of endometrioma, leading to apoptosis via the intrinsic
pathway. The presence of natural barriers to apoptosis will regulate
the toxic compounds in endom etriomas, particularly the pro-
inflammatory cytokine TNF -α, which stimulates the development
of fibrosis and decreases follicular density. (Illustration of the
proposed mechanism can be found in Figure 6.
Early Detection and Treatment of Endometrioma is Important
A significant positive connection was seen between AMH levels and
the expression of apoptotic factor genes in both types of
endometriomas, those with a size of 4 cm or less and those larger
than 4 cm. A multivariate correlation test was conducted to
examine the relationship between the expression of apoptotic factor
genes and the decrease in AMH values before surgery. The results
revealed a highly significant positive connection (R2 0.918). A
robust and statistically significant inverse correlation was seen in
the expression of TNFR-1 in the group with endometriomas larger
than 4 cm. According to Obstet et al. (2016) , TNF -α is a pro-
inflammatory cytokine that interacts to its receptor TNFR- 1,
leading to the initiation of apoptosis. The detrimental effects of the
endometrioma facilitate the passage of other hazardous substances
beyond the natural barrier, leading to de struction of the
surrounding healthy tissue. This leads to the development of
fibrosis and a decrease in follicular density, resulting in lower AMH
readings prior to surgery. Therefore, it is crucial and paramount to
prevent any additional harm (Baker et al. 2018; Lew 2019;
Somigliana et al. 2012).
ANGIOTHERAPY RESEARCH
https://doi.org/10.25163/angiotherapy.859690 1–18 | ANGIOTHERAPY | Published online May 20, 2024
This study demonstrates a decline in anti -Müllerian hormone
(AMH) levels prior to surgery. In the correlation test conducted on
endometrioma measuring 4 cm or less, there was a robust and
statistically significant positive association between p53 expressio n
and a decrease in AMH value prior to surgery. Similarly, there is a
favorable correlation between the expression of Bcl -2 and a
substantial and statistically significant reduction in AMH levels
prior to surgery in endometriomas that are 4 cm or less. Thi s
suggests that there is an ongoing attempt to compensate cells in
order to adjust to the encountered exposure. In contrast to larger
diameters (> 4 cm), there is no correlation between Bcl-2 expression
and the decrease in AMH readings prior to surgery (Parameswaran
and Patial 2010) . Endometrioma larger than 4 cm is linked to a
notable reduction in AMH levels, which is correlated with a
substantial and meaningful rise in TNFR -1 and Bax expression.
This suggests that the presence of harmful compounds that
stimulate TNF -α receptors lea ds to damage in ovarian tissue,
particularly when the diameter exceeds 4 cm.
This study observed a significant upregulation of Bax expression,
which exhibited a positive correlation with the cyst diameter.
Greater levels of Bax and caspase -9 expression were observed in
endometriomas larger than 4 cm, indicating more extensive
damage. The expression of Bax showed a statistically significant
difference (p = 0.01) between both groups of endometrioma. This
demonstrates that as the diameter of an endometrioma increases,
there is a corresponding increase in damage to the ovarian tissue, as
observed through changes in gene expression. This study
demonstrates that the damage to endometriomas begins with the
lowest diameter (2.5 cm) and progresses to the largest diameter (6.5
cm). This damage is associated with the pro-inflammatory cytokine
TNF-α and is influenced (Molvig 1988; Parsa et al. 2018; Sipak -
Szmigiel et al. 2017) . Therefore, it is crucial to discover
endometriomas early.
Failure to promptly address the presence of endometrioma from the
outset will exacerbate the likelihood of diminishing the patient's
ovarian reserve. This study revealed a significant difference in the
lowering of the AMH value following cystectomy in the group with
endometrioma larger than 4 cm. It is crucial to prevent ovarian
function failure, particularly during reproductive years, as it would
prevent the possibility of using assisted reproductive technologies
in cases where the AMH value is extremely low. This study revealed
that 31% of the total participants experienced a decline in their
AMH readings below 0.5 ng/mL after cystectomy. This decrease
serves as a threshold, indicating that patients with endometrioma
may be at risk of early menopause.
The main finding of this study is that surgery for endometriomas
measuring 4 cm considerably reduces AMH levels. The size of
ovarian cysts directly correlates with the extent of damage to
ovarian tissue, as evidenced by the upregulation of genes associated
with programmed cell death. Bax expression, in particular,
continues to rise as cyst width increases. The expression
upregulation begins with the activation of TNF receptor -α, which
subsequently triggers the intrinsic pathway, le ading to an increase
in the expression of Bax and caspase-9. This ultimately results in the
death of epithelial cells. The presence of caspase -3 indicates
apoptosis in the epithelium of endometrioma, resulting in the loss
of the ovary's natural protective barrier. This process also affects the
exposure of the ovary to harmful substances, which can cause
damage to the healthy tissue. The presence of tissue damage in the
tiny-diameter cyst, measuring 2.5 cm, and the decline in AMH
values prior to surgery are apparent. The drop in anti -Müllerian
hormone (AMH) levels was a result of injury to the ovarian tissue.
Investigators found a positive correlation between this decrease and
the expression of genes related to programmed cell death
(apoptosis). Endometrioma decreases fertility, and the presence of
cyst fluid jeopardizes the progression of ovarian tissue damage. To
save the ovarian reserve, it is advisable to extract the fluid from
endometrioma cysts before they reach a diameter of 4 cm,
particularly in patients who are 30 years of age or younger.
According to this study, 50% of endometriomas have surface
epithelium that has undergone apoptosis due to the pro -
inflammatory cytokine TNF-α. However, given the high expression
of p53 (66%), 97% of endometriomas have Bax, and 56% of them
have caspase-3, it is impossible to rule out the possibility that other
endometrioma-causing toxins are also responsible for seriously
harming epithelial cell mitochondria. ROS, generated by the Fenton
reaction, can permeate the cyst wall in endometrioma fluid
(Scutiero et al. 2017).
Conclusion
Based on the findings, laparoscopic cystectomy for endometriomas
smaller than 4 cm does not significantly reduce AMH levels,
whereas for endometriomas larger than 4 cm, there is a significant
decline in AMH. The increase in endometrioma diameter is
associated with elevated Bax expression, indicating ovarian tissue
damage. Laparoscopic cystectomy of endometriomas larger than 4
cm in women over 30 years significantly decreases AMH and poses
a risk of ovarian failure, with 31% of cases experiencing early
menopause. The expression of apoptosis-related genes shows a very
strong positive correlation with AMH reduction in endometriomas
smaller than 4 cm and a strong correlation in larger
endometriomas. These results suggest that imme diate surgical
intervention for endometriomas is crucial, particularly before the
diameter reaches 4 cm, to preserve ovarian function and prevent
long-term reproductive complications.
ANGIOTHERAPY RESEARCH
https://doi.org/10.25163/angiotherapy.859690 1–18 | ANGIOTHERAPY | Published online May 20, 2024
Author contributions
T.A.H. was the primary researcher and was responsible for the
study design, data collection, data analysis, and manuscript
preparation. Dr. W. H., Dr. S. S., and Dr. P. R. provided supervision,
critical revisions, and guidance throughout the research process. All
authors contributed to the interpretation of the data and approved
the final manuscript.
Acknowledgment
The authors sincerely thanked the staff and medical team at
Women and Children’s YPK Hospital Jakarta for their invaluable
support during this study. Special thanks went to Dr. W.
Hadisaputra, Dr. S. Soebijanto, and Dr. P. Rustamadji for their
guidance and expertise. The y also appreciated the Department of
Obstetrics and Gynecology, Faculty of Medicine, Universitas
Indonesia, for providing essential resources. Lastly, the authors
thanked the patients for their cooperation and trust.
Competing financial interests
The authors have no conflict of interest.
References
Abrao, Mauricio S., Ludovico Muzii, and Riccardo Marana. 2013. “International Journal
of Gynecology and Obstetrics Anatomical Causes of Female Infertility and
Their Management.” International Journal of Gynecology and Obstetrics
123:S18 – 24. doi: 10.1016/j. ijgo.2013.09.008.
Akhtar Muhammad, Kong Yusheng. 2021. Performance , and Profitability.
Alammari, Roa, Michelle Lightfoot, and Hye -Chun Hur. 2017. “Impact of Cystectomy on
Ovarian Reserve: Review of the Literature.” Journal of Minimally Invasive
Gynecology 24(2):247 – 57. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmig.2016.12.010.
Andres, Marina de Paula. 2014. “Endometriosis Is an Important Cause of Pelvic Pain in
Adolescence.” 60(6):560 – 64.
Baker, Valerie L., Clarisa Gracia, Michael J. Glassner, Vicki L. Schnell, Kevin Doody,
Charles C. Coddington, Sanghyuk S. Shin, Lorna A. Marshall, Michael M.
Alper, Arlene J. Morales, Mary Ellen Pavone, Millie A. Behera, Edward A.
Zbella, Bruce S. Shapiro, Joely A. Straseski, and Dennis L. Broyles. 2018.
“Multicenter Evaluation of the Access AMH Antimüllerian Hormone Assay for
the Prediction of Antral Follicle Count and Poor Ovarian Response to
Controlled Ovarian Stimulation.” Fertility and Sterility 110(3) :506-513.e3.
doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fertnstert.2018.03.031.
Ballard, K. D., H. E. Seaman, C. S. De Vries, and J. T. Wright. 2008. “Can Symptomatology
Help in the Diagnosis of Endometriosis? Findings from a National Case -
Control Study - Part 1.” BJOG: An International Journal of Obstetrics and
Gynaecology 115(11):13 82– 91. doi: 10.1111/j.1471 -0528.2008.01878.x.
Barnhart, Kurt, Rebecca Dunsmoor -Su, and Christos Coutifaris. 2002. “Effect of
Endometriosis on in Vitro Fertilization.” Fertility and Sterility 77(6):1148 – 55.
doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0015 -0282(02)03112 -6.
Bast, R. C. 2011. “Molecular Approaches to Personalizing Management of Ovarian
Cancer.” Annals of Oncology 22:viii5 – 15. doi:
https://doi.org/10.1093/annonc/mdr516.
Bateman, Alexis H., Edgar E. Blanco, and Yossi Sheffi. 2017. “Disclosing and Reporting
Environmental Sustainability of Supply Chains.” Springer Series in Supply
Chain Management 4:119 – 44. doi: 10.1007/978 -3-319-29791-0_6.
Benagiano, Giuseppe, Felice Petraglia, Stephan Gordts, and Ivo Brosens. 2016. “A New
Approach to the Management of Ovarian Endometrioma to Prevent Tissue
Damage and Recurrence.” Reproductive BioMedicine Online 32(6):556 – 62.
doi: 10.1016/j.rbmo.2016.03.001.
Briley, Shawn M., Susmita Jasti, Jennifer M. McCracken, Jessica E. Hornick, Barbara
Fegley, Michele T. Pritchard, and Francesca E. Duncan. 2016.
“Reproductive Age -Associated Fibrosis in the Stroma of the Mammalian
Ovary.” Reproduction (Cambridge, England) 152(3):245 – 60. doi:
10.1530/REP -16-0129.
Brilhante, Aline Veras Morais, Kathiane Lustosa Augusto, Manuela Cavalcante Portela,
Luiz Carlos Gabriele Sucupira, Luiz Adriano Freitas Oliveira, Ana Juariana
Magalhães Veríssimo Pouchaim, Lívia Rocha Mesquita Nóbrega, Thaís
Fontes de Magalhães, and Leona rdo Robson Pinheiro Sobreira. 2017.
“Endometriosis and Ovarian Cancer: An Integrative Review (Endometriosis
and Ovarian Cancer).” Asian Pacific Journal of Cancer Prevention : APJCP
18(1):11 – 16. doi: 10.22034/APJCP.2017.18.1.11.
Brosens, I., P. Puttemans, Sy Gordts, R. Campo, S Gordts, and G. Benagiano. 2013. “Early
Stage Management of Ovarian Endometrioma to Prevent Infertility.” FVV In
OBGyn 5(4):309 – 14.
Brosens, Ivo, Stephan Gordts, Patrick Puttemans, and Giuseppe Benagiano. 2014.
“Pathophysiology Proposed as the Basis for Modern Management of the
Ovarian Endometrioma.” Reproductive BioMedicine Online 28(2):232 – 38.
doi: 10.1016/j.rbmo.2013.09.024.
Brosens, Ivo, Patrick Puttemans, Rudi Campo, Stephan Gordts, and Karen Kinkel. 2004.
“Diagnosis of Endometriosis: Pelvic Endoscopy and Imaging Techniques.”
Best Practice & Research Clinical Obstetrics & Gynaecology 18(2):285 – 303.
doi: https://doi.org/10.10 16/j.bpobgyn.2004.03.002.
Busacca, Mauro, and Michele Vignali. 2009. “Endometrioma Excision and Ovarian
Reserve: A Dangerous Relation.” Journal of Minimally Invasive Gynecology
16(2):142 – 48. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmig.2008.12.013.
Canis, M., J. L. Pouly, S. Tamburro, G. Mage, A. Wattiez, and M. A. Bruhat. 2001. “Ovarian
Response during IVF – Embryo Transfer Cycles after Laparoscopic Ovarian
Cystectomy for Endometriotic Cysts of > 3 Cm in Diameter.” 16(12):2583 –
86.
Cardoso, Jéssica Vilarinho. 2020. “Epidemiological Profile of Women with Endometriosis :
A Retrospective Descriptive Study. ” Revista Brasileira de Sa úde Materno
Infantil 20(4):1057 – 67.
Carnahan, Molly, Jennifer Fedor, Ashok Agarwal, and Sajal Gupta. 2013. “Ovarian
Endometrioma: Guidelines for Selection of Cases for Surgical Treatment or
Expectant Management.” Expert Review of Obstetrics and Gynecology
8(1):29 – 55. doi: 10.1586/eog.12.75.
Celik, Hale Goksever, Erbil Dogan, Emre Okyay, Cagnur Ulukus, Bahadir Saatli, Sezer
Uysal, and Meral Koyuncuoglu. 2012. “Effect of Laparoscopic Excision of
ANGIOTHERAPY RESEARCH
https://doi.org/10.25163/angiotherapy.859690 1–18 | ANGIOTHERAPY | Published online May 20, 2024
Endometriomas on Ovarian Reserve: Serial Changes in the Serum
Antimüllerian Hormone Levels.” Fertility and Sterility 97(6):1472 – 78. doi:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fertnstert.2012.03.027.
Chen, Yuqing, Huihui Pei, Yajie Chang, Minghui Chen, Haihe Wang, Hongzhe Xie, and
Shuzhong Yao. 2014. “The Impact of Endometrioma and Laparoscopic
Cystectomy on Ovarian Reserve and the Exploration of Related Factors
Assessed by Serum Anti -Mullerian Hormone : A Prospective Cohort Study. ”
1– 8. doi: 10.1186/s13048 -014-0108-0.
Chiu, Chui -Ching, Teh -Fu Hsu, Ling -Yu Jiang, I. San Chan, Ying -Chu Shih, Yen -Hou
Chang, Peng -Hui Wang, and Yi -Jen Chen. 2022. “Maintenance Therapy for
Preventing Endometrioma Recurrence after Endometriosis Resection
Surgery – A Systematic Review and Networ k Meta -Analysis.” Journal of
Minimally Invasive Gynecology 29(5):602 – 12. doi:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmig.2021.11.024.
Coccia, Maria Elisabetta, Francesca Rizzello, Stefano Barone, Sara Pinelli, Erika Rapalini,
Cristiana Parri, Domenico Caracciolo, Savvas Papageorgiou, Gianpaolo
Cima, and Loredana Gandini. 2014. “Is There a Critical Endometrioma Size
Associated with Reduce d Ovarian Responsiveness in Assisted Reproduction
Techniques?” Reproductive Biomedicine Online 29(2):259 – 66. doi:
10.1016/j.rbmo.2014.04.019.
Davies, Melanie J., Caroline A. Kristunas, Abualbishr Alshreef, Simon Dixon, Helen
Eborall, Agnieszka Glab, Lisa Huddlestone, Nicky Hudson, Kamlesh Khunti,
Graham Martin, Alison Northern, Mike Patterson, Rebecca Pritchard, Sally
Schreder, Bernie Stribling, Jessica Turner, and Laura J. Gray. 2019. “The
Impact of an Intervention to Increase Uptake to Structured Self -Management
Education for People with Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus in Primary Care (the
Embedding Package), Compared to Usual Care, on Glycaemic Contr ol: Study
Protocol for a Mixed Methods Stu.” BMC Family Practice 20(1):152. doi:
10.1186/s12875 -019-1038-0.
Depalo, Raffaella, Aldo Cavallini, Filomenamila Lorusso, Emma Bassi, Ilaria Totaro, and
Andrea Marzullo. 2009. “Article Apoptosis in Normal Ovaries of Women with
and without Endometriosis.” Reproductive BioMedicine Online 19(6):808 –
15. doi: 10.1016/j.rbmo. 2009.09.024.
Dufournet, Charlotte, Catherine Uzan, Raffaèle Fauvet, Annie Cortez, Jean -Pierre Siffroi,
and Emile Daraï. 2006. “Expression of Apoptosis -Related Proteins in
Peritoneal, Ovarian and Colorectal Endometriosis.” Journal of Reproductive
Immunology 70(1):151 – 62. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jri.2005.11.003.
Fassbender, Amelie, Richard O. Burney, Dorien F. O, Thomas D’Hooghe, and Linda
Giudice. 2015. “Update on Biomarkers for the Detection of Endometriosis -
Protein and Contraction.” BioMed Research International 2015.
Fauvet, Raffaèle, Charlotte Dufournet, Christophe Poncelet, Catherine Uzan, Danièle
Hugol, and Emile Daraï. 2005. “Expression of Pro -Apoptotic (P53, P21, Bax,
Bak and Fas) and Anti -Apoptotic (Bcl -2 and Bcl -x) Proteins in Serous versus
Mucinous Borderline O varian Tumours.” Journal of Surgical Oncology
92(4):337 – 43. doi: https://doi.org/10.1002/jso.20424.
Feng, Guohua, Jiti Gao, and Bin Peng. 2019. “An Integrated Panel Data Approach to
Modelling Economic Growth.”
Foti, Pietro Valerio, Renato Farina, Stefano Palmucci, Ilenia Anna, Agata Vizzini, Norma
Libertini, Maria Coronella, Saveria Spadola, Rosario Caltabiano, Marco Iraci,
Antonio Basile, Pietro Milone, Antonio Cianci, and Giovanni Carlo Ettorre.
2018. “Endometriosis : Clinical Features , MR Imaging Findings and
Pathologic Correlation. ” 149– 72.
Garcia -Velasco, Juan A., and Edgardo Somigliana. 2009. “Management of
Endometriomas in Women Requiring IVF: To Touch or Not to Touch.” Human
Reproduction (Oxford, England) 24(3):496 – 501. doi:
10.1093/humrep/den398.
Gardner, David K. 2011. Human Assisted Reproductive Technology.
Giacomini, Elisa, Ana M. Sanchez, Veronica Sarais, Soha Al Beitawi, Massimo Candiani,
and Paola Viganò. 2017. “Characteristics of Follicular Fluid in Ovaries with
Endometriomas.” European Journal of Obstetrics, Gynecology, and
Reproductive Biology 209:34 – 38. doi: 10.1016/j.ejogrb.2016.01.032.
Gordts, Stephan, Philippe Koninckx, and Ivo Brosens. 2017. “Pathogenesis of Deep
Endometriosis.” Fertility and Sterility 108(6):872 -885.e1. doi:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fertnstert.2017.08.036.
Gordts, Stephan, Patrick Puttemans, Sylvie Gordts, and Ivo Brosens. 2015. “Ovarian
Endometrioma in the Adolescent: A Plea for Early -Stage Diagnosis and Full
Surgical Treatment.” Gynecological Surgery 12(1):21 – 30. doi:
10.1007/s10397 -014-0877-x.
Gupta, Sajal, Jeffrey M. Goldberg, Nabil Aziz, Eric Goldberg, Natalie Krajcir, and Ashok
Agarwal. 2008. “Pathogenic Mechanisms in Endometriosis -Associated
Infertility.” Fertility and Sterility 90(2):247 – 57. doi:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fertnstert.2008.02 .093.
Haupt, Susan, Michael Berger, Zehavit Goldberg, and Ygal Haupt. 2003. “Apoptosis – the
P53 Network.” doi: 10.1242/jcs.00739.
Heca, Cancer Cell Line, Meryem İ. Karagül, Derya Yetkin, Gülsen Bayrak, and Didem
Çelikcan. 2018. “P53 , Bcl2 and Bax Expression and Apoptosis in Perifosine
and Vitamin D -Treated Endometrial.” 25:3 – 7. doi:
10.3390/proceedings2251564.
Henes, Melanie, and Engler. 2018. “Ovarian Cyst Removal Influences Ovarian Reserve
Dependent on Histology, Size and Type of Operation.” Women’s Health
14:1745506518778992. doi: 10.1177/1745506518778992.
Hwu, Yuh -ming, Frank Shao -ying Wu, Sheng -hsiang Li, Fang -ju Sun, Ming -huei Lin, and
Robert Kuo -kuang Lee. 2011. “The Impact of Endometrioma and
Laparoscopic Cystectomy on Serum Anti -Müllerian Hormone Levels.”
Reproductive Biology and Endocrinology 9(1):80. doi: 10.1186/1477 -7827-
9-80.
Isono, Wataru, Osamu Wada -Hiraike, Nana Akino, Hiromi Terao, Miyuki Harada, Tetsuya
Hirata, Yasushi Hirota, Kaori Koga, Tomoyuki Fujii, and Yutaka Osuga. 2019.
“The Efficacy of Non -Assisted Reproductive Technology Treatment Might Be
Limited in Infertile Pa tients with Advanced Endometriosis in Their 30s.”
Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology Research 45(2):368 – 75. doi:
10.1111/jog.13826.
Iwase, Akira, Wakana Hirokawa, Maki Goto, Sachiko Takikawa, Yoshinari Nagatomo,
Tatsuo Nakahara, Shuichi Manabe, and Fumitaka Kikkawa. 2010. “Serum
Anti-Müllerian Hormone Level Is a Useful Marker for Evaluating the Impact of
Laparoscopic Cystectomy on Ovar ian Reserve.” Fertility and Sterility
94(7):2846 – 49. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fertnstert.2010.06.010.
ANGIOTHERAPY RESEARCH
https://doi.org/10.25163/angiotherapy.859690 1–18 | ANGIOTHERAPY | Published online May 20, 2024
Keyhan, Sanaz, Claude Hughes, Thomas Price, and Suheil Muasher. 2015. “An Update
on Surgical versus Expectant Management of Ovarian Endometriomas in
Infertile Women.” 2015. doi: 10.1155/2015/204792.
Khan, Khaleque Newaz, Michio Kitajima, Akira Fujishita, Koichi Hiraki, Ayumi Matsumoto,
Masahiro Nakashima, and Hideaki Masuzaki. 2013. “Pelvic Pain in Women
with Ovarian Endometrioma Is Mostly Associated with Coexisting Peritoneal
Lesions.” Human Reproduc tion 28(1):109 – 18. doi:
10.1093/humrep/des364.
Kitajima, Michio, Sylvie Defrère, Marie -Madeleine Dolmans, Sebastien Colette, Jean
Squifflet, Anne Van Langendonckt, and Jacques Donnez. 2011.
“Endometriomas as a Possible Cause of Reduced Ovarian Reserve in Women
with Endometriosis.” Fertility and Sterili ty 96(3):685 – 91. doi:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fertnstert.2011.06.064.
Kitajima, Michio, D. Ph, Marie -madeleine Dolmans, D. Ph, Olivier Donnez, and D. Ph.
2014. “Enhanced Follicular Recruitment and Atresia in Cortex Derived from
Ovaries with Endometriomas.” Fertility and Sterility 101(4):1031 – 37. doi:
10.1016/j.fertnstert.201 3.12.049.
Koninckx, Philippe R., Rodrigo Fernandes, Anastasia Ussia, Larissa Schindler, Arnaud
Wattiez, Shaima Al -Suwaidi, Bedayah Amro, Basma Al -Maamari, Zeinab
Hakim, and Muna Tahlak. 2021. “Pathogenesis Based Diagnosis and
Treatment of Endometriosis.” Frontiers i n Endocrinology 12(November):1 –
13. doi: 10.3389/fendo.2021.745548.
Korkmaz, D., E. Bastu, O. Dural, C. Yasa, E. Yavuz, and F. Buyru. 2013. “Apoptosis
through Regulation of Bcl -2, Bax and Mcl -1 Expressions in Endometriotic
Cyst Lesions and the Endometrium of Women with Moderate to Severe
Endometriosis.” Journal of Obstetri cs and Gynaecology 33(7):725 – 28. doi:
10.3109/01443615.2013.824416.
Lew, Raelia. 2019. “Natural History of Ovarian Function Including Assessment of Ovarian
Reserve and Premature Ovarian Failure.” Best Practice and Research:
Clinical Obstetrics and Gynaecology 55:2 – 13. doi:
10.1016/j.bpobgyn.2018.05.005.
Margarida. 2017. “Endometrioma Em Contexto de Infertilidade.” Angewandte Chemie
International Edition, 6(11), 951 – 952. 5 – 24.
Matsuzaki, Sachiko. 2010. “Oxidative Stress Status in Normal Ovarian Cortex Surrounding
Ovarian Endometriosis.” Fertility and Sterility 93(7):2431 – 32. doi:
10.1016/j.fertnstert.2009.08.068.
Miller, Emily M., Timothy M. Samec, and Angela A. Alexander -Bryant. 2021.
“Nanoparticle Delivery Systems to Combat Drug Resistance in Ovarian
Cancer.” Nanomedicine: Nanotechnology, Biology and Medicine
31:102309. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nano.2020.10 2309.
Molvig. 1988. “Endotoxin -Stimulated Human Monocyte Secretion of Interleukin 1,
Tumour Necrosis Factor Alpha, and Prostaglandin E2 Shows Stable
Interindividual Differences.” Scandinavian Journal of Immunology
27(6):705 – 16. doi: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.136 5-3083.1988.tb02404.x.
Muzii, Ludovico, Antonella Bianchi, Filippo Bellati, Emanuela Cristi, Milena Pernice,
Marzio A. Zullo, Roberto Angioli, and Pierluigi Benedetti Panici. 2007.
“Histologic Analysis of Endometriomas: What the Surgeon Needs to Know.”
Fertility and Sterility 87 (2):362 – 66. doi: 10.1016/j.fertnstert.2006.06.055.
Nisolle, Michelle, and Jacques Donnez. 2019. “Reprint of: Peritoneal Endometriosis,
Ovarian Endometriosis, and Adenomyotic Nodules of the Rectovaginal
Septum Are Three Different Entities.” Fertility and Sterility 112(4):e125 – 36.
doi: 10.1016/j.fertnstert.2 019.08.081.
Obstet, Arch Gynecol, Francesca Maria Salmeri, Vaclav Vetvicka, and Antonio Simone.
2016. “Regulation of Apoptotic Pathways during Endometriosis : From the
Molecular Basis to the Future Perspectives. ” doi: 10.1007/s00404 -016-
4195-6.
Parameswaran, Narayanan, and Sonika Patial. 2010. “Tumor Necrosis Factor -α Signaling
in Macrophages. ” Critical Reviews in Eukaryotic Gene Expression 20(2):87 –
103. doi: 10.1615/critreveukargeneexpr.v20.i2.10.
Parsa, Sepideh, Ian Roper, Michael Muller -Camen, and Eva Szigetvari. 2018. “Have
Labour Practices and Human Rights Disclosures Enhanced Corporate
Accountability? The Case of the GRI Framework.” Accounting Forum
42(1):47 – 64. doi: 10.1016/j.accfor.2018.01.00 1.
Pejovic, Tanja, Sarah Thisted, Michael White, and Farr R. Nezhat. 2020. “Endometriosis
and Endometriosis -Associated Ovarian Cancer (EAOC) BT - Hormonal
Pathology of the Uterus.” Pp. 73 – 87 in, edited by L. Deligdisch -Schor and A.
Mareş Miceli. Cham: Spring er International Publishing.
Porpora, M. G., P. R. Koninckx, J. Piazze, M. Natili, S. Colagrande, and E. V Cosmi. 1999.
“Correlation between Endometriosis and Pelvic Pain.” The Journal of the
American Association of Gynecologic Laparoscopists 6(4):429 – 34. doi:
https://doi.org/10.1016/ S1074 -3804(99)80006 -1.
Raffi, F., R. W. Shaw, and S. A. Amer. 2012. “National Survey of the Current Management
of Endometriomas in Women Undergoing Assisted Reproductive Treatment.”
Human Reproduction 27(9):2712 – 19. doi: 10.1093/humrep/des195.
Rosen, Mitchell P., Erica Johnstone, Charles E. McCulloch, Sonya M. Schuh -Huerta,
Barbara Sternfeld, Renee A. Reijo -Pera, and Marcelle I. Cedars. 2012. “A
Characterization of the Relationship of Ovarian Reserve Markers with Age.”
Fertility and Sterility 97 (1):238 – 43. doi:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fertnstert.2011.10.031.
Rumph, Jelonia T., Victoria R. Stephens, Anthony E. Archibong, Kevin G. Osteen, and
Kaylon L. Bruner -Tran. 2020. “Environmental Endocrine Disruptors and
Endometriosis.” Advances in Anatomy, Embryology, and Cell Biology
232:57 – 78. doi: 10.1007/978 -3-030-51856-1_4.
Salmeri, Francesca M., Vincenza Sofo, Antonio S. Lagana, Onofrio Triolo, Emanuele
Sturlese, Giovanni Retto, Alfonsa Pizzo, Angela D. Ascola, and Salvatore
Campo. 2015. “Behavior of Tumor Necrosis Factor - α and Tumor Necrosis
Factor Receptor 1 / Tumor Necrosis Factor Receptor 2 System in
Mononuclear Cells Recovered From Peritoneal Fluid of Women With
Endometriosis at Different Stages. ” Reproductive Sciences 22(2):165 – 72.
doi: 10.1177/1933719114536472.
Sanchez, A. M., P. Viganò, E. Somigliana, P. Panina -Bordignon, P. Vercellini, and M.
Candiani. 2014. “The Distinguishing Cellular and Molecular Features of the
Endometriotic Ovarian Cyst: From Pathophysiology to the Potential
Endometrioma -Mediated Damage t o the Ovary.” Human Reproduction
Update 20(2):217 – 30. doi: 10.1093/humupd/dmt053.
Scutiero, Gennaro, Piergiorgio Iannone, Giulia Bernardi, Gloria Bonaccorsi, Savino
Spadaro, Carlo Alberto Volta, Pantaleo Greco, and Luigi Nappi. 2017.
ANGIOTHERAPY RESEARCH
https://doi.org/10.25163/angiotherapy.859690 1–18 | ANGIOTHERAPY | Published online May 20, 2024
“Oxidative Stress and Endometriosis: A Systematic Review of the Literature”
edited by V. M. Victor. Oxidative Medicine and Cellular Longevity
2017:7265238. doi: 10.1155/2017/7265238.
Seifer, David B., Valerie L. Baker, and Benjamin Leader. 2011. “Age -Specific Serum Anti -
Müllerian Hormone Values for 17,120 Women Presenting to Fertility Centers
within the United States.” Fertility and Sterility 95(2):747 – 50. doi:
https://doi.org/10.1016/ j.fertnstert.2010.10.011.
Shi, Jinghua, Jinhua Leng, Quancai Cui, and Jinghe Lang. 2011. “Follicle Loss after
Laparoscopic Treatment of Ovarian Endometriotic Cysts.” International
Journal of Gynecology & Obstetrics 115(3):277 – 81. doi:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijgo.2011.07.026.
Sipak-Szmigiel, Olimpia, Piotr Włodarski, Elżbieta Ronin -Walknowska, Andrzej
Niedzielski, Beata Karakiewicz, Sylwia Słuczanowska -Głąbowska, Maria
Laszczyńska, and Witold Malinowski. 2017. “Serum and Peritoneal Fluid
Concentrations of Soluble Human Leukocyt e Antigen, Tumor Necrosis Factor
Alpha and Interleukin 10 in Patients with Selected Ovarian Pathologies.”
Journal of Ovarian Research 10(1):1 – 14. doi: 10.1186/s13048 -017-0320-
9.
Somigliana, Edgardo, Nicola Berlanda, Laura Benaglia, Paola Viganò, Paolo Vercellini,
and Luigi Fedele. 2012. “Surgical Excision of Endometriomas and Ovarian
Reserve: A Systematic Review on Serum Antimüllerian Hormone Level
Modifications.” Fertility and St erility 98(6):1531 – 38. doi:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fertnstert.2012.08.009.
Sugita, Atsuko, Akira Iwase, Maki Goto, Tatsuo Nakahara, Tomoko Nakamura, Mika
Kondo, Satoko Osuka, Masahiko Mori, Ai Saito, and Fumitaka Kikkawa. 2013.
“One-Year Follow -up of Serum Antimüllerian Hormone Levels in Patients with
Cystectomy: Are Different Se quential Changes Due to Different Mechanisms
Causing Damage to the Ovarian Reserve?” Fertility and Sterility 100(2):516 -
522.e3. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fertnstert.2013.03.032.
Uncu, Gurkan, Isil Kasapoglu, Kemal Ozerkan, Ayse Seyhan, Arzu Oral Yilmaztepe, and
Baris Ata. 2013. “Prospective Assessment of the Impact of Endometriomas
and Their Removal on Ovarian Reserve and Determinants of the Rate of
Decline in Ovarian Reserve†.” H uman Reproduction 28(8):2140 – 45. doi:
10.1093/humrep/det123.
Vercellini, Paolo, Paola Viganò, Laura Buggio, Sofia Makieva, Giovanna Scarfone, Fulvia
Milena Cribiù, Fabio Parazzini, and Edgardo Somigliana. 2018.
“Perimenopausal Management of Ovarian Endometriosis and Associated
Cancer Risk: When Is Medical or Surgica l Treatment Indicated?” Best
Practice & Research Clinical Obstetrics & Gynaecology 51:151 – 68. doi:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bpobgyn.2018.01.017.
Vercellini, Paolo, Paola Viganò, Edgardo Somigliana, and Luigi Fedele. 2014.
“Endometriosis : Pathogenesis and Treatment. ” 10(May). doi:
10.1038/nrendo.2013.255.
WHO. 2023. “Endometriosis.” WHO. Retrieved (https://www.who.int/news -room/fact -
sheets/detail/endometriosis).
Yeung, Patrick, Ken Sinervo, Wendy Winer, and Robert B. Albee. 2011. “Complete
Laparoscopic Excision of Endometriosis in Teenagers: Is Postoperative
Hormonal Suppression Necessary?” Fertility and Sterility 95(6):1909 -
1912.e1. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j .fertnstert.2011.02.037.
Zikargae, Mekonnen Hailemariam. 2018. “Analysis of Environmental Communication and
Its Implication for Sustainable Development in Ethiopia.” Science of the Total
Environment 634:1593 – 1600. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2018.04.050.
Text is read by the "Ask this paper" AI Q&A widget below.
Extraction quality varies by source — PMC NXML preserves structure
cleanly, OA-HTML may include some navigation residue, and OA-PDF can
have broken hyphenation. The publisher copy
(via DOI)
is the canonical version.