The five common conditions encountered in patients with chronic pelvic pain (CPP) consist of endometriosis, interstitial cystitis, pelvic floor dysfunction, irritable
bowel syndrome and pudendal nerve entrapment. The most unrecognised cause of CPP is the latter which affects only 4% of patients.
A thorough work up of patient’s pain is necessary prior to subjecting patients to any intervention including surgery as over 40% of gynaecological laparoscopies are
performed for long standing pelvic pain. CPP is of multi-source origin which makes it difficult in formulating a plan of care for patients with this condition. If one
source of the pain is detected, it is important to rule out other conditions that may also be contributing.
All practitioners treating patients with CPP have to be knowledgeable about all of the potential causes of pelvic pain and addressing only the commonest cause like
endometriosis is not adequate.
*Correspondence to: Ibrahim I Bolaji, Department of Obstetrics and
Gynaecology, Hull Y ork Medical School Diana, Princess of Wales Hospital,
NLaG NHS Foundation Trust, Scartho Road, Grimsby DN33 2BA, UK, Tel: 01-
472-874-111; Fax: 01-472-875-452; E-mail:
[email protected]
Key words: Chronic pelvic syndrome, endometriosis, bladder pain syndrome,
interstitial cystitis, pelvic floor dysfunction, irritable bowel syndrome and pudendal
nerve entrapment
Received: August 23, 2018; Accepted: September 20, 2018; Published:
September 24, 2018
Sources and Selection Criteria
We performed a Medline and Embase search using the MeSH
terms, evidenced based guidelines and published consensus statements
from 1992 to date, limited to publications in English and to chronic
pelvic pain in women. Our search strategy was very broad using a
combination of MeSH, text-words and appropriate word variants of
causes of chronic pelvic pain including chronic pelvic pain syndrome,
endometriosis, bladder pain syndrome, interstitial cystitis, pelvic floor
dysfunction, irritable bowel syndrome and pudendal nerve entrapment
or pudendal neuralgia.
What is chronic pelvic pain?
Pain is defined by the International Association for the Study of
Pain as ‘an unpleasant sensory and emotional experience associated
with actual or potential tissue damage [1]. Understanding the impact of
pain has to acknowledge both the stimulation of the sensory receptors
by a harmful stimuli and other factors acting centrally and contributing
to pain perception. Chronic pelvic pain (CPP) is regarded as a symptom
and not a diagnosis and its definition encompasses three parameters of
location, severity and duration. It is most commonly defined as pain
located in the lower abdominal or pelvic cavity or buttocks which
can be continuous or intermittent, cyclical or non-cyclical in nature.
It imposes functional limitation in activities of daily living (ADLs),
leading to poorer quality of life [2] (severity). The pain must have been
persistent for at least 6 months [3] (duration).
The pelvis is a complex region of the body and its geography and
complicated neuroanatomy makes diagnosis of pain in the region
extremely challenging. There is a very heavy economic and social
implication for patients living with chronic pelvic pain. Hence, it
is of paramount importance that accurate diagnosis and effective
management of this condition be implemented very early in the
presentation. CPP is of multi-source origin which makes it difficult in
formulating a plan of care for patients with this condition. If one source
of the pain is detected, it is important to rule out other conditions that
may also be contributing. For example, Howard [4] estimated that
approximately 65% of women with endometriosis have coexistence of
interstitial cystitis which may account for some patients failing to have
a remission of their symptoms as only one condition is being addressed.
How common is this condition?
The estimated worldwide prevalence of CPP ranges from 2.1–24%
[1]. It is more prevalent in females and its prevalence in women of
reproductive age in the USA and the UK has been reported as 14.7%
and 24% respectively [5,6]. The direct costs of CPP has been estimated
to be as high as $2.8 billion [4,5]. In gynaecology, endometriosis is
perceived by many to be the main source of CPP and it has been cited
as being the cause of CPP in 30-87% of patients [7].
What are the possible causes of chronic pelvic pain?
The aetiology of CPP is multifactorial and incompletely understood
and it can arise from pathologies involving various organ systems [8]
(Figure 1). Pain disorders may coexist with CPP and intensify the
overall pain symptoms via mechanisms of cross-organ sensitisation,
leading to viscero-visceral or viscerosomatic hyperalgesia [9]. The
complex innervation of the pelvis further complicates the diagnosis of
pelvic pain [1].
Pain can generally be classified into visceral, somatic or neuropathic.
Visceral pain originates from internal organs and is transmitted
through sympathetic fibers of the autonomic nervous system. It is
thus poorly localised, dull and aching in nature and associated with
autonomic dysfunction (e.g. nausea, vomiting, sweating) [10].
Bolaji II (2018) An odyssey through chronic pelvic pain in women
Front Womens Healt, 2018 doi: 10.15761/FWH.1000154
Volume 3(4): 2-9
On the other hand, somatic pain originates from muscles, skin,
bones and joints and is transmitted along somatic sensory afferents.
Hence, this pain is well localised and sharp or burning in nature [2,11].
Pain as a result of changes in the nerve itself is referred to as
‘neuropathic pain’. This pain is characteristically, but not exclusively
burning, aching or shooting in nature and presents as hyperaesthesia,
dysaesthesias and allodynia [2]. It arises as a result of an injury to the
peripheral or central somatosensory nervous system. CPP is thought
to originate from a disease state that damages a particular organ
giving rise to either somatic or visceral pain, which then develops into
neuropathic pain over time.
In cases where no precise pathology can be identified, CPP is
thought to be due to abnormal pain perception in the central nervous
system (CNS) in the absence of acute injury [12]. Janicki [13] proposed
that CPP is a form of complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS), resulting
in hypersensitization of the CNS and hence decreased pain thresholds
and augmented normal pain intensities [15]; such that normally non-
noxious stimuli (e.g. the sensation of a full bladder) would be perceived
as painful.
What is the approach to assessment and making a clinical
diagnosis?
The triad of thorough history, clinical examination and utilisation
of laboratory and imaging studies are essential to arrive at an accurate
diagnosis. The signs and symptoms of CPP are very variable in terms of
location and intensity. Initial assessment of women with CPP is the most
important and this must be performed thoroughly and meticulously
without haste. Patients must be allowed to narrate their story with
attentiveness so as to explore their ideas about the cause of pain and
use the opportunity to reinforce some of their thoughts and discard
misconception regarding the pain. McGowan et al. [15] and Price et
al. [16] found that patients presenting with CPP want their history to
be heard and validated and they want to receive individualised care to
improve their understanding and management of their pain.
The initial detail history should capture information about the
pattern of the pain, associated problems including urinary, bowel or
psychological problems and the effect on posture and movement. One
acronym that the authors found useful for assessment of chronic pelvic
pain and used by many healthcare professionals is SOCRATES (Table 1).
In history, it is critical to ask not only about pain but also to explore
other systems including urologic, gastrointestinal, musculo-skeletal
and reproductive systems. Although there are many contributory
factors but the problem of CPP must be considered as a whole by the
physician and their clients. A pain/menstrual chart may be helpful in
tracking symptoms or activities associated with this pain. Where pain
is cyclical in the absence of any other finding, a therapeutic trial of
down regulation may be more helpful than a diagnostic laparoscopy.
Nickel et al. [17] championed the use of UPOINT (urinary,
psychosocial, organ-specific, infection, neurologic/systemic and muscle
tenderness) [18] system (Table 2) to structurally classify and improve
management of patients with CPP. This enables the appropriate
diagnostic investigation to be carried out to identify the underlying
cause of pain, so that more effective treatment can be recommended by
targeting on the particular aetiology. The UPOINT approach appears
to be a valid initial assessment of a patient’s pain complaints [19,20]
and more commonly used by the urologists. The full diagnostic criteria
of different causes of CPP are explored in the differential diagnosis.
Clinically, palpation of the bladder and pelvic floor muscles are
very important and often ignored due to lack of training. Bladder pain
may be elicited in BPS/IC and there are two highly predictive physical
examination for pelvic floor dysfunction [21]. These are the Pelvic
floor muscle palpation (PMP) and the forced Flexion, Abduction, and
External Rotation (fFAER) tests. They may help to identify those that
have musculoskeletal disorders contributing to chronic pelvic pain and
who would benefit from referral to a physiotherapist.
Endometriosis-related lesions may be palpated during early part of
menstrual flow as the implants are most likely large and tender at this
Figure 1. Aetiology of chronic pelvic pain
Bolaji II (2018) An odyssey through chronic pelvic pain in women
Front Womens Healt, 2018 doi: 10.15761/FWH.1000154
Volume 3(4): 3-9
phase of the menstrual cycle. A common physical finding is cul-de-sac
tenderness, with multiple tender nodules palpated along the cul-de-sac
or uterosacral ligaments. Adnexal masses or adhesions are palpated
bimanually, while deep infiltrated lesions involving the rectovaginal
septum are palpated rectovaginally.
Investigations vary according to history and examination findings
as shown in Table 3. In gynaecology, diagnostic laparoscopy appears
to be the most frequent and the best investigation for CPP [22,23]. The
laparoscopy must be comprehensive exploring the upper abdomen,
chest as well as the pelvic cavities (Figure 2). However, it is important
to bear in mind that a negative laparoscopy, (present is up to 90% of
women with CPP [24] is not synonymous with no diagnosis or no
disease). Laparoscopy is only one of the many possible methods of
evaluation of CPP. It has its limitations and pitfalls. More discriminative
use of laparoscopy based on the patient’s history, clinical examination,
laboratory and imaging findings might decrease the rate of negative
laparoscopies from 39–40% [23].
Frequently, the diagnosis of CPP is assigned to a painful condition
dependent on the initial specialist who evaluated the patient, i.e.
gynaecologists assign gynaecologic diagnoses, whereas urologists
assign urologic diagnoses. It is prudent for clinicians from all specialties
to assess the multiple aetiologies that are possible in causing CPP.
What are the common causes of chronic pelvic pain?
In gynaecological population, the five prevalent conditions
encountered in patients with chronic pelvic pain include endometriosis,
bladder pain syndrome/interstitial cystitis (BPS/IC), irritable bowel
syndrome (IBS), pelvic floor dysfunction (PFD) and pudendal nerve
entrapment (PNE) (Table 4). The most unrecognised cause of CPP
is the PNE which affects only 4% of patients with chronic pelvic
pain. Pelvic congestion syndrome refers to a condition in which
characteristic symptoms of shifting location of pain, deep dyspareunia,
post-coital pain, and exacerbation of pain after prolonged standing
are associated with radiological findings of pelvic varicosities (dilated
uterine and ovarian veins) that display reduced blood flow [25]. The
existence of pelvic venous congestion as a cause of chronic pelvic
pain remains controversial. A recent systematic review of diagnosis
and management of this condition found no valid diagnostic tests,
although ovarian suppression was effective in treating pelvic pain
symptoms. Pelvic inflammatory disease (PID) is a common cause of
CPP in settings with a high prevalence of sexually transmitted disease.
However, the underlying reason that PID often leads to CPP has not
been clearly established. In one study of 780 predominantly black urban
women with recently diagnosed PID, those most likely to develop CPP
were smokers, women with a history of two or more episodes of PID,
and women with a low composite mental health score on standardized
tests [26].
Endometriosis
Endometriosis refers to ectopic implantation and growth of
endometrial mucosa, glands and stroma, commonly involving the
ovaries, uterosacral ligaments, Pouch of Douglas and uterovescial
peritoneum [27,28]. Since these extrauterine implants are under
cyclic influence of ovarian hormones, they grow and break down
with each menstrual cycle. The symptoms of endometriosis vary in
their presentation and severity; however, the commonest symptom is
premenstrual pelvic pain and dyspareunia [29-61]. The pain usually
begins one or two days before expected menstruation, and it may be
unilateral or bilateral, and lasts until the end of menses. However, some
women may experience a constant, debilitating pain that interferes
with functional activities of daily living. Curiously, the severity of pain
does not correlate well with severity of the condition and, therefore,
severe disease may go undiagnosed [30].
This pain can be attributable to several factors, namely inflammation
secondary to cyclic slough of endometrial glands; release of neurokinins
and adhesions causing pressure and traction on surrounding tissues
[61]. However, it is important to note that endometriotic pain has little
correlation with the location and extent of disease, in other words,
some patients with endometriosis may be completely asymptomatic
[60,61]. If the bladder is involved, patients may also complain of
dysuria, hematuria and urinary frequency [31].
The pathophysiology of endometriosis remains unknown. Although
many theories have been proposed, the most accepted theories include
retrograde menstruation (Sampson’s theory), coelomic metaplasia,
vascular and lymphatic spread and altered immunosurveillance.
Endometriosis is clinically graded into four stages of advancement
according to the American Society of Reproductive Medicine
classification (ASRM) [32] to assist with diagnosis, prognosis,
treatment, subsequent progress and communication among medical
professionals. They are Stage I (minimal), Stage II (mild), Stage
III (moderate) and Stage IV (severe). Staging is based on the extent
S Site Where is the pain? Chest, abdomen, head, pelvis, etc. Is there
a pattern of involvement?
O Onset
When did it start? How did it start? What started it? Was it
a sudden onset or more gradual? Has there been any change
over time?
C Character
What does pain feel like now?
Type of pain - burning, shooting, stabbing, crushing, dull
Pattern of pain - colicky, constant
R Radiation Where does it move to? Into back, arm, down a leg, etc.
A Associations
Are any other signs or symptoms associated with pain? E.g. is
there any neurological deficit (e.g. numbness where the pain
is felt?) Does it cause nausea, light-headedness, inability to
lie flat, etc
T Timing
Time course – does the pain follow any pattern? Is the pain
worse at any time of the day? Is the pain associated with any
particular activities, e.g. movement, urination, eating, passing
stool, coughing, is It constant / intermittent, how long does it
last when it’s there?
E Exacerbating /
relieving factors
What makes it better or worse? does anything change the
pain?
S Severity
How bad is it now?
- Pain intensity: none, mild, moderate or severe; rank on a
scale of 1-10 scale
- Any interference with sleep or usual activities
- Pain relief: none, slight, moderate, good or complete
Table 1. Socrates
Urinary A post-void residual measured by ultrasound
Psychosocial Ask about clinical depression and catastrophizing
(helplessness, hopelessness)
Organ specific Pain improvement with bladder emptying and tenderness
Infection Culture for myocoplasma and ureasplasma, urine culture
Neurologic/Systemic Ask about pain outside the pelvic and diagnosis of other pain
syndromes
Tenderness Palpate the abdominal and pelvic skeletal muscles (via rectum
or vagina) and check for spasm and trigger points
Additional tests Female Urologic Pelvic Pain Index
Table 2. UPOINT system for Clinical Phenotyping of Chronic Pelvic Pain: minimum
investigations recommended [19]
Bolaji II (2018) An odyssey through chronic pelvic pain in women
Front Womens Healt, 2018 doi: 10.15761/FWH.1000154
Volume 3(4): 4-9
A
B
C
Figure 2A. Normal looking perihepatic space. 2B) Type 1 Fitz-Hugh Curtis syndrome. 2C) Chronic PID with hydrosalpinx.
BPS/IC IBS PFD PNE Endometriosis
Pain Pain worsens as bladder fills and
improves after voiding
Rome criteria:
-Continuous/recurrent abdominal
pain, relieved with defaecation/
associated with change in frequency/
consistency of stool
-+/- disturbed defaecation (2 or
more of: altered stool frequency/
consistency/ passage of stools
(straining/ urgency/tenesmus)/
passage of mucus
-Usually with bloating
Exclude red flag symptoms:
(significant weight loss, nocturnal
symptoms, bloody diarrhoea, family
history of colon cancer, new onset of
symptoms in patients >50 years)
More commonly suffers from
concomitant chronic fatigue
syndrome, fibromyalgia, depression,
anxiety
Well-localised, aching
and deep in nature,
focal point tenderness
Associated with obesity,
menopause, pregnancy,
childbirth and inherited
collagen deficiency
Pain is positional
(worsened by sitting,
relieved by standing,
absent when recumbent
More common in
competitive cyclists, after
pregnancy, trauma, surgery
due to scarring
Perimenstrual lower
abdominal pain
Associated
symptoms
Urgency, hesitancy, frequency,
dyspaurenia (Pelvic Pain and Urgency/
Frequency (PUF) patient symptom
scale to act as a screening test for IC)
Pseudo-weakness of the
involved muscles and
reduced range of motion
Genital numbness, urinary/
faecal incontinence
dyspareunia
dysuria, haematuria, urinary
frequency (if bladder
involvement)
Signs Tenderness at bladder base Normal examination
Levator muscle spasm,
myofascial pain elicited
by pelvic floor muscle
palpation (PMP) and the
forced flexion, abduction
and external rotation test
(fFAER)
Palpation of the ischial
spine may produce pain
tender retroverted uterus,
tender nodules and masses
in pelvis, implants in
uterosacral ligaments
Investigations
24 hr voiding diary, To detect infection/
haematuria: Urinalysis, urine culture
To exclude bladder cancer or carcinoma
in situ: urine cytology
To establish diagnosis:
Cystoscopy with hydrodistention of
bladder
Intravesical anaesthetic challenge
Diagnosis of exclusion,
(investigations to rule out organic
causes e.g. lactose intolerance
(Hydrogen breath test), coeliac
disease (coeliac serology), small
bowel bacterial overgrowth (stool
microscopy+ culture), colorectal
cancer: colonoscopy + biopsy for
patients over 50 years or <50 with
red flag symptoms)
--
EMG: to measure
motor latency along the
pudendal nerve (a greater
than normal conduction
delay indicates nerve
entrapment)
MR neurography:
asymmetrical swelling
and hyperintensity in
the affected pudendal
neurovascular bundle
Laparoscopy +biopsy for
visualisation of lesions +
histological confirmation
(false +: endosalpingiosis,
malignancies, carbon
deposits from previous
ablations)
Treatment Table 4
Dietary modification (high-fibre diet,
increase fluid intake)
Psychotherapy (CBT, stress
management)
Antispasmodics
Tricyclics or SSRI
Physiotherapy e.g.
Pelvic floor exercise,
muscle relaxants,
electrical stimulation to
increase muscle tone,
biofeedback
Behavioral modification,
physical therapy
(stretching exercises),
analgesics, medication
for neuropathic pain
(gabapentin, amitriptyline),
pudendal nerve block,
surgical decompression,
pulsed radiofrequency
Medications: Analgesics:
NSAID
HRT (COCP), progestins
Danazol,
GnRH
Surgery: laparoscopy +
ablation of endometriosis or
hysterectomy with bilateral
salpingo-oorphorectmy
Table 3. Summary of findings in history (pain characteristics, associated symptoms), examination, investigation and treatment for five common aetiologies of chronic pelvic pain
CBT: Cognitive behavioural therapy is a talking therapy that can help patient to manage their problems by changing the way they think and behave, COCP: combined oral contraceptive
pills, EMG: electromyography, GnRH: gonadotropin-releasing agonist, IBS: irritable bowel syndrome, IC: interstitial cystitis, MPS: Myofascial pain syndrome, NSAID: nonsteroidal anti-
inflammatory agents, PFD: Pelvic floor dysfunction, PNE: pudendal nerve entrapment, PUF: Pelvic Pain and Urinary/Frequency patient symptom scale.
Bolaji II (2018) An odyssey through chronic pelvic pain in women
Front Womens Healt, 2018 doi: 10.15761/FWH.1000154
Volume 3(4): 5-9
of the spread of lesions, density of pelvic adhesions, involvement of
pelvic organs and degree of fallopian tube occlusion. It’s important to
remember that the stage of endometriosis is not reflective of degree of
pain, risk of infertility or predictive of the patient’s ability to conceive
after therapy.
On examination, tender nodules and masses in the pelvis, a
tender, retroverted, fixed uterus or implants in the POD or uterosacral
ligaments are suggestive of endometriosis. The gold standard diagnostic
investigation for endometriosis is laparoscopy with confirmation by
biopsy [60,61]. However, false positives can occur with malignancies,
endosalpingiosis, carbon deposits from previous ablations and even
with normal peritoneum. Walter et al. [33] investigated the accuracy
of solely using laparoscopic visualization in diagnosing endometriosis
and found that only 67 out of 138 (49%) sites visually positive were also
histologically positive.
Management options include medical, surgical or a combination
of both (Table 3), depending on the patient’s age and their desire for
fertility augmentation and pain relief and also the stage of disease.
Mild, premenstrual endometriotic pain responds well to non-steroidal
anti-inflammatories (NSAIDs) [34]. Hormonal therapy suppresses
oestrogen production and promotes atrophy of endometrial tissue
implants. Low dose, continuous, monophasic combined oral
contraceptives (COC) is the first-line hormonal therapy [67].
Progestins (e.g. medroxyprogesterone acetate, norethindrone acetate),
gonadotropin-releasing (GnRH) agonists (e.g. goserelin, leuprolide)
and danazol are alternative hormonal therapies [67]. GnRH agonists
and COCs have been shown to be beneficial for patients with IBS, BPS/
IC and pain disorders associated with perimenstrual flare-ups [35].
Interestingly, a phase II randomised controlled trial in Brazil showed
that oral therapy with melatonin 10mg/d was more effective than
placebo in improving daily pain, dysmenorrhea, dysuria, dyschezia
and sleep in women with biopsy-proven endometriosis and CPP [36].
Surgery may be considered in older patients or those who
suffers from moderate or severe endometriosis unresponsive to
pharmacologic treatment. Conservative surgery eradicates visual signs
of endometriosis and adhesions. Residual microscopic implants which
cannot be surgically removed contribute to symptom recurrence and
disease progression. For women with severe persistent endometriosis,
more invasive surgeries may be considered e.g. hysterectomy with
bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy. Patients who undergo a bilateral
oophorectomy should be treated with hormone replacement therapy
as the benefits outweigh the risk of endometriosis recurrence (ASRM).
The recurrence rate of endometriotic lesions after five years is 19%
with laparoscopic removal of lesions and 10% with hysterectomy and
bilateral oophorectomy, this is compared with 53.4% with medical
treatment (ASRM). However, this doesn’t reflect the recurrence rate of
pain as many women have a recurrence of pelvic pain [37].
Irritable bowel syndrome (IBS)
IBS is the commonest bowel disorder, affecting over 10% of the
population and it is 3 times more prevalent in women than men, mostly
affecting women aged between 15 and 45. Although IBS is a chronic
problem, it is however a benign disorder, and does not progress to, or
increase the risk of any other disease. It has no known cure yet and its
treatment remains symptomatic relief.
Although the underlying pathophysiology remains unclear,
emerging literature suggests that IBS arises as a result of intestinal
inflammation which emerges from hyper-responsiveness of the
neuronal, immune and endocrine signalling pathways within the
intestines, the peripheral and the central nervous system [38].
Consequently, the hypersensitive bowel muscles go into spasm, causing
pain. Certain foods may trigger an attack. Stressful life events are
reported by up to 60% of IBS patients, which can exacerbate symptoms.
The cardinal symptoms of IBS consist of a triad of abdominal pain,
abdominal bloating and a change in bowel habit [39] and attempts to
refine this clinical approach into guidelines have resulted in several
diagnostic criteria being created including the Manning criteria and
Rome I-III criteria. The Rome criteria, initially introduced in 1988 and
subsequently modified twice to yield the Rome III criteria, have become
the research-standard definition of constipation and IBS [40]. The
Rome III criteria for the diagnosis of irritable bowel syndrome require
that patients have had recurrent abdominal pain or discomfort at least 3
days per month over the last 3 months that is associated with 2 or more
of the following: improvement with defecation, change in frequency of
evacuations and variations in the form (appearance) of stool (criteria)
[42]. The NICE guidelines however recommend assessment of IBS in
patients with symptom lasting longer than six months [41].
The Roman criteria have proved useful for research purposes by
ensuring homogeneity of patient populations, but their applicability in
clinical practice is extremely limited and they are seldom used [42]. The
diagnosis of IBS is usually made more often intuitively with remarkable
reliability and safety.
IBS often exhibits the following subgroups: Constipation
predominant IBS, which is more prevalent in females and is
characterised by alternating hard (> 25%) and soft stools ( 25%) and hardened stools (< 25%)
and IBS with mixed habits [39] .
Most gynaecologists have difficulty recognising bowel symptoms
and, therefore, do not establish a diagnosis of IBS [43-45]. The difficulty
of the diagnosis is further increased by the fact that symptoms of IBS are
based on subjective accounts of patients and lack organic explanations.
The treatment of first choice is usually a dietary modification
by increasing fibre and fluid intake. Drug therapy is not usually
recommended for the routine treatment of IBS. However,
antispasmodics, tricyclics or selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors
(SSRI) might be beneficial. Psychotherapy including cognitive
behavioural therapy (CBT) and stress management might also be
helpful in controlling symptoms (Table 3).
Bladder pain syndrome
Formally referred to as interstitial cystitis, the nomenclature
for this condition has changed several times. There is currently no
consensus regarding the nomenclature and sometimes both titles have
been combined as BPS/IC. BPS is the most widely used term in the
UK and Europe whilst BPS/IC is the preferred term by the American
Association of Urologist (AUA). The prevalence in the female
population in the United States ranged from 3–6% [46].
Endometriosis
Irritable Bowel Syndrome
Bladder Pain Syndrome/Interstitial Cystitis (BPS/IC)
Pelvic Floor Dysfunction
Pudendal Nerve Entrapment
Table 4. The evil quintuplet
Bolaji II (2018) An odyssey through chronic pelvic pain in women
Front Womens Healt, 2018 doi: 10.15761/FWH.1000154
Volume 3(4): 6-9
BPS is defined as “an unpleasant sensation (pain, pressure,
discomfort) perceived to be related to the urinary bladder” that is
associated with urinary symptoms, in the absence of infection or
other identifiable causes [47]. BPS/IC was defined by the International
Continence Society in 2002 as suprapubic pain related to bladder
filling after exclusion of a urinary tract infection, along with 1 or 2 of
increased daytime frequency and or increased night time frequency
[48]. The classic features include urinary urgency and frequency,
nocturia, dyspareunia and pelvic or lower abdominal pain [49].
The European Society for the Study of Interstitial Cystitis (ESSIC)
proposed the term BPS to be used in parallel with or instead of IC in
accordance to the following criteria [50]: chronic pelvic pain lasting >
6 months, pressure or discomfort perceived to be related to the urinary
bladder and accompanied by at least one other urinary symptom like
urinary urgency or frequency.
The aetiology of BPS/IC is still undetermined but possible causes
include infection, toxins, bladder wall defects, pelvic floor dysfunction
and autoimmune disorders [51]. The most likely primary cause seems
to be a defective urothelium or glycosaminoglycan (GAG) layer [52].
Clinical BPS/IC, according to Keay et al. [53] is initiated by exposure to
noxious stimuli causing injury to the bladder or epithelium, commonly
following an episode of bacterial cystitis, pelvic surgery, childbirth
or urologic instrumentation. In contrast to the healthy population,
normal uroepithelial repair in BPS/IC patients is retarded or prevented
as a result of elevated anti-proliferative factor and diminished epithelial
growth factors [54]. Over time, the GAG layer becomes defective
and urinary metabolities e.g. potassium ions (K+) leak through the
bladder wall into the submucosal space, triggering an inflammatory
reaction marked by proliferation and activation of submucosal mast
cells [55]. Penetration of urinary constituents into the bladder wall
causes C-fiber activation, mast cell activation, and histamine release.
The resulting smooth muscle contraction, neurogenic inflammation,
and hypersensitivity translate into the urinary urgency and frequency
and chronic pelvic pain that are characteristic symptoms of several
chronic bladder conditions. Mast cell degranulation not only releases
histamine and other inflammatory mediators, eliciting local tissue
damage and vasoconstriction [56], but also stimulates neurogenic
inflammation [57] by activating capsacin-sensitive nerve fibers and
releasing neuropeptides such as substance P which leads to further
injury and fibrotic changes within the bladder. If left untreated, the
bladder will shrink in size, compromising its functional capacity.
Chronic inflammation fuels neural up-regulation and neural changes
within the spinal cord which ultimately develops into neuropathic
pain, manifesting as allodynia and hyperalgesia of the bladder and
adjacent pelvic organs [58]. This up-regulation explains the reason for
patients with chronic BPS/IC to have persistent vaginal or pelvic pain
even after cystectomy.
Without a thorough investigation, BPS/IC can be easily
misdiagnosed as vaginitis, vulvodynia or pelvic floor dysfunction
in female patients. The diagnosis of BPS/IC can be confirmed
via cystoscopy, with or without biopsy and hydrodistention. On
cystoscopy, Hunter’s ulcers may be present in 10% of patients [39].
Hydrodistention may reveal petechial haemorrhages (glomerulations)
in symptomatic patients which are indicative of disease state [59].
Histological examination may show signs of neurogenic inflammation,
evidenced by marked oedema and injury to nervous tissues and blood
vessels in the muscularis layer [39].
There are a large number of therapies available to treat BPS/IC.
The majority of patients respond well to a multidisciplinary approach
consisting of dietary modification, behavioural modification and other
medical interventions (Figure 3, Table 5).
Pelvic floor dysfunction
Pelvic floor dysfunction is a well-known musculoskeletal cause of
CPP. It occurs when pelvic floor muscles are either too weak or too
tight. The major contributing factors include obesity, menopause,
pregnancy and childbirth. Some women are more likely to developing
pelvic floor dysfunction as a result of an inherited collagen deficiency.
Keane et al. [60] found that women with congenitally weak connective
tissue and fascia are at risk of stress urinary incontinence and pelvic
organ prolapse.
Pelvic floor muscle palpation (PMP) is a useful physical examination
technique to determine whether CPP is of musculoskeletal origin. The
test is considered to be positive if firm transvaginal digital palpation
of the right and left pelvic floor muscles elicits pain [61]. The forced
Flexion, Abduction and External Rotation test (fFAER) is considered
to be positive when pain is elicited by flexion, abduction and external
rotation of either leg from the supine position [49]. The presence
of both findings correctly identifies patients with musculoskeletal
disorders contributing to CPP in 85% of the time while the absence of
both findings has 100% specificity [49]. Physiotherapy is typically
beneficial in relieving symptoms of the musculoskeletal origin
(Table 3).
Pudendal nerve entrapment
Pudendal nerve entrapment or pudendal neuralgia is a disabling
form of genital pain resulting from inflammation, compression or
entrapment of the pudendal nerve (S2,3,4), affecting 4% of patients
presenting with CPP. It has been associated with childbirth, pelvic
surgery, intense cycling, sacroiliac skeletal abnormalities or age-related
changes. Post-menopausal women have especially high risks since
pudendal neuralgia has been shown to be related to urogenital atrophy
as a result of decreased oestrogen level and hence collagen support as
women age [62].
Clinical features include pelvic pain with sitting which worsens
throughout the day and decreases with standing or lying down. This
condition is thus very common in current society since many people
have office jobs and make frequent, long journeys [63]. Similar to other
causes, pudendal neuralgia is also associated with sexual dysfunction
and difficulty in urination and defaecation, consequently, the diagnosis
is often difficult to manage with a reported delay ranging from 2 to 10 years
[64]. There are 5 essential diagnostic criteria (Nantes criteria) [65] that are
recommended for the diagnosis of pudendal neuropathy (Table 6).
There must be no symptoms of exclusion criteria. Patients with
solely coccygeal, gluteal or hypogastric pain with imaging abnormalities
that may explain the symptoms generally do not have pudendal
neuralgia. The diagnosis should be confirmed with electrophysiological
and imaging studies such as colour duplex scanning and magnetic
resonance neurography. Electromyography with a greater than normal
conduction delay may suggest pudendal nerve entrapment in Alcock’s
canal.
Pudendal neuralgia can be managed with either conservative
or surgical approaches (Table 3). Conservative treatment includes
behavioural modifications, pelvic floor physiotherapy, analgesics,
pudendal nerve block (transacral block at S2-S4) and botox injections
(in case of muscle spasms) [66-68]. In case of failed conservative
treatment, surgical decompression via the transperineal, transgluteal
Bolaji II (2018) An odyssey through chronic pelvic pain in women
Front Womens Healt, 2018 doi: 10.15761/FWH.1000154
Volume 3(4): 7-9
Pentosan
polysulfate Antihistamines Antidepressants Neuroleptics Supplementary oral
therapy Intravesical therapy
Mechanism
of action
Re-establish
endothelial lining
[71]
Mast cell stabiliser
Modify pain, improves
insomnia, anticholinergic
effect
Decrease neurogenic
inflammation
Decrease bladder
discomfort
Decrease bladder discomfort,
control bladder spasm
Example -
Hydroxyzine [72]
(sedating)
Cetirizine [73]
(non-sedating)
Tricyclics – amitriptyline,
trazodone, doxepin,
nortriptyline
SSRI – paroxetine,
fluoxetine, citalopram,
venlafaxine, sertraline
Gabapentin, phenytoin,
carbamazepine,
valproate
Urinary analgesics,
antiseptics, alkalizers, e.g.
Phenazopyridine, Uromax,
Urised
FDA approved: -Dimethyl
sulfoxide (DMSO); [74]
-Oxybutynin (5-10 mg
crushed and suspended in
10cc of water);
-Pentosan polysulfate/ heparin
(daily) [75]
Non-FDA approved:
-Hyaluronidase [76]
-Bacillus Calmette-Guérin
(BCG) [77]
Dose 100-300 mg 25-75 mg 25-100 mg 100-800 mg
-
50cc
Route Oral Oral Oral Oral catheterisation
Frequency 3 times/day Once at night Once at night 3 times/day Once/week for > 6 weeks
Side effects Headache, alopecia,
GI upset
Visual disturbance, low
blood pressure, GI upset Sympathomimetic effect Sedation, liver
impairment Bladder irritation
Others
Full effect may not be
seen for 6-9 months.
Compliance is
necessary as
benefit of therapy
is dependent on
length of time under
treatment.
In spring and fall, when
many IC patients suffer
from seasonal allergies, an
additional 10-25 mg every
6 hours may be required.
Imipramine should be
avoided as this agent
exacerbates dysfunctional
voiding.
For patients who fail to
respond to oral therapy
Table 5. Treatment of painful bladder syndrome/ interstitial cystitis (pbs/ic)
GI: gastrointestinal
SSRI: Selective Serotonin Re-uptake Inhibitors
Dose, frequency, route stated in the table is of the underlined drug.
Key:
Factors predisposing to bladder injury
Pathological mechanism of interstitial cystitis
Mechanism of action of pharmacological agents for interstitial cystitis
Mode of conservative and medical treatment of interstitial cystitis
‘+’ Stimulates
‘-‘ Inhibits
Figure 3. Multifactorial aetiology of Bladder pain syndrome/Interstitial cystitis (BPS/IC) and the role of multimodality therapy.
*Bladder pain Syndrome/Interstitial cystitis (BPS/IC) diet involves avoidance of coffee, tea, soda, alcohol, citrus juices, and cranberry juice, foods and beverages containing artificial
sweeteners, hot peppers and spicy foods, which may exacerbate BPS/IC.
Bolaji II (2018) An odyssey through chronic pelvic pain in women
Front Womens Healt, 2018 doi: 10.15761/FWH.1000154
Volume 3(4): 8-9
or transischiorectal approach), computed tomography-guided pulse-
dose radiofrequency of the pudendal nerve or spinal cord stimulation
of the monus medullaris may be considered [54,69,70].