Author
CT and ITN contributed to project administration, supervision, and resources; ED and YD contributed to methodology; YD, CDA, LR, AC, YA, SD, FG, and CT acquired the data; YD, CDA, ITN, and ED analyzed the data; and CDA, LR, YD, and ED wrote the original draft. All authors reviewed the manuscript for critical intellectual content.
Results
During the inclusion period, 923 patients underwent surgical management for deep endometriosis. Among them, 99 (11%) had urinary tract involvement: 13 (13%) with isolated bladder lesions, 56 (57%) with extensive ureterolysis, and 30% with mixed lesions.
The flow chart (Figure 4 ) displays the distribution of lesions and the procedures performed in our cohort.
Flow chart of the study; *according to stringent criteria afore mentioned.
The main clinical features are displayed in Table 1 . Median age at surgery was 34 years (31–40 years). Most patients were nulliparous (58%). Forty patients (40%) had at least one previous surgery for endometriosis and 42 (42%) were infertile. One‐third of patients experienced lower urinary tract symptoms (34%). Lower urinary tract symptoms were more often associated with bladder involvement (26/34, 76.5%; p < 0.001).
Demographic and clinical characteristics of patients.
a
Abbreviation: BMI, body mass index (calculated as weight in kilograms divided by the square of height in meters).
Data are presented as median (range) or number (percentage).
Indications for surgery were pelvic pain in 68 patients (69%), infertility in three patients (3%), and both in 23 cases (23%). Five patients were completely asymptomatic but required surgery for hydronephrosis.
Sixteen patients (16%) had no sign of deep endometriosis following vaginal examination. Forty‐seven patients (48%) had vaginal or rectovaginal septum involvement, and 12 patients (12%) had rectal involvement (Table 2 ). Patients with clinical parametrial involvement had ureteral lesions significantly more often than those with bladder or mixed lesions (19/56 versus 5/43, p < 0.001).
Deep endometriosis location at clinical examination and on imaging.
a
Abbreviation: USL, uterosacral ligament.
Data are presented as number (percentage).
Pelvic MRI including renal areas was performed in 81 patients (82%). Two patients only had an ultrasound and missing data on the preoperative workup occurred in 17 cases.
Rectal echoendoscopy was performed in 39 patients (39%) when rectal involvement was detected on MRI. A preoperative entero‐MRI to detect multifocal and multicentric bowel endometriosis was performed in 33 patients (33%) with confirmed rectal involvement. Thirty patients (30%) underwent diagnostic cystoscopy. The mean size of bladder nodule endometriosis was 30 mm (25–30 mm). The mean distance between the ureteral meatus and the inferior limit of the bladder nodule was 20 mm (15–30 mm).
Gonadotropin‐releasing hormone agonist treatment was prescribed for 3 months before surgery in 40 (40%) cases.
According to our results, following the review of images from MRI scans by our radiologists: MRI has higher sensitivity (68.4%) and specificity (96.6%) compared with clinical diagnosis (sensitivity 37.9%, specificity 94.4%), with the κ coefficient also being higher for MRI (κ = 0.33) than for clinical diagnosis (κ = 0.26) but remaining limited.
Conventional laparoscopy was performed on 82 patients (83%), 11 robot‐assisted laparoscopy (Table 3 ). Six patients underwent a conversion to laparotomy for severe intraoperative bleeding including two with isolated bladder endometriosis, two with ureteral endometriosis, and two with mixed endometriosis. Hysterectomy was performed in 33 patients, who were older than those who underwent conservative surgery (median 40 years [37–43 years] versus 32 years [29.2–34 years]; p < 0.001): two in the bladder group, 25 in the ureteral group, and six in the mixed group.
Surgical intraoperative data.
a
Abbreviation: USL, uterosacral ligament.
Data are presented as number (percentage).
In our cohort, median operating time was 260 minutes (183–336 minutes) and median intraoperative blood loss was 150 mL (100–400 mL). Five patients required intraoperative blood transfusions.
The distribution of surgical procedures according to the groups is summarized in Table 3 .
The main surgical outcomes are displayed in Table 4 . Median hospital stay was 8 days (5–12 days). In the absence of postoperative complications, the median hospital stay was 6 days (3–8 days) versus 10 days (7–13.5 days) in case of complication ( p < 0.001).
Intraoperative and postoperative data.
a
Data are presented as median (range) or number (percentage).
The overall complication rate was 59% (58/99) including 41 patients with low grade complications and 17 patients with severe complications. The most frequent complications were low grade, including urinary infection (three patients) or pyelonephritis (eight patients).
For the 17 patients experiencing a high‐grade complication, data are summarized in Table 5 . Among them, the rate of Grade IIIa complication or greater was higher in patients with previous surgery for endometriosis (64.7% versus 35.4%, p = 0.024). A trend for an association between obesity and the risk of severe postoperative complications was noted ( p = 0.084).
Summary of data from patients with Clavien‐Dindo complications ≥3a.
35 years old
BMI: NA
History of laparotomy (ovariectomy)
Symptoms: Pain, metrorrhagia
Hysterectomy
Torus, USL
Rectal shaving
Parametrectomy
Partial bladder resection
Ureterolysis
Bladder suture failure resulting in pelvic peritonitis 1 month postoperative
Surgical revision by laparoscopy: bladder suture and peritoneal washing
33 years old
BMI: NA
History of laparoscopy for endometriosis (cystectomy for endometrioma) and appendicectomy
Symptoms: pain, infertility
Torus, USL
Rectal shaving
Endometrioma fenestration
Mixed endometriosis
Ureterolysis
Partial bladder resection
Perioperative JJ stent
Parametrectomy
Salpingectomy
Perioperative complication: left external iliac vein injury
Operative time: 390 min
Estimated blood loss: 400 mL
Length of hospital stay: 18 days
Discharge with urinary catheter
Pelvic abscess
Replacement of JJ stents and abscess drainage
43 years old
BMI: 36.6
History of laparoscopy (cholecystectomy) and cesarean section
Symptoms: Dysmenorrhea, dyspareunia
Torus, USL
Discoid resection
Endometrioma fenestration
Hysterectomy
Ureteral endometriosis
Ureterolysis
Perioperative JJ stent
Parametrectomy
Estimated blood loss: 250 mL
Length of time before removal of urinary catheter: 5 days
Self‐catheterization learning
Length of hospital stay: 12 days
Vesicovaginal fistula
Surgical revision by laparoscopic
36 years old
BMI: 28.3
History of laparoscopy for endometriosis (excision of rectovaginal septum lesion and colpectomy)
Symptoms: Dyspareunia
Torus, USL
Colorectal resection
Ileocecal resection
Colpectomy
Hysterectomy
Ureteral endometriosis
Ureterolysis
Perioperative JJ stent
Parametrectomy
Protective stomia
Estimated blood loss: 500 mL
42 years old
BMI: 16.9
History of laparoscopy for endometriosis (torus, USL and colorectal resection)
Symptoms: pelvic pain
Torus, USL
Colorectal resection
Discoid resection
Hysterectomy
Ureteral endometriosis
Ureterolysis
Perioperative JJ stent
Parametrectomy
Estimated blood loss: 300 mL
Length of time before removal of urinary catheter: 6 days
Length of hospital stay: 8 days
33 years old
BMI: NA
History of laparoscopy for endometriosis (ethanol sclerotherapy endometrioma)
Symptoms: pelvic pain, infertility
Torus, USL
Colorectal resection
Colpectomy
Ureteral endometriosis
Ureterolysis
Perioperative JJ stent
Parametrectomy
Protective stomia
Estimated blood loss: 700 mL
Length of time before removal of urinary catheter: 5 days
Postoperative voiding dysfunction, learned self‐catheterization
Length of hospital stay: 12 days
31 years old
BMI: 26
Smoking
History of laparotomy for endometriosis (salpingectomy)
Symptoms: pelvic pain and uretero‐hydronephrosis
Torus, USL
Colorectal resection
Hysterectomy
Ureteral endometriosis
Ureterolysis
Ureteral reimplantation
Perioperative JJ stent
Parametrectomy
Protective stomia
Operative time: 480 min
Estimated blood loss: 500 mL
Length of time before removal of urinary catheter: 5 days
Length of hospital stay: 14 days
30 years old
BMI: 20.8
Symptoms: infertility
USL
Rectal shaving
Ureteral endometriosis
Ureterolysis
Perioperative JJ stent
Douglassectomy
Estimated blood loss: 50 mL
Length of time before removal of urinary catheter: 1 days
Length of hospital stay: 7 days
30 years old
BMI: 18.4
History of laparoscopy for endometriosis
Symptoms: dysmenorrhea, dyspareunia
Torus, USL
Colorectal resection
Colpectomy
Mixed endometriosis
Ureterolysis
Partial bladder resection
Perioperative JJ stent
Parametrectomy
Protective stomia
Estimated blood loss: 500 mL
Length of time before removal of urinary catheter: 15 days
Postoperative voiding dysfunction, learned self‐catheterization
Length of hospital stay: 21 days
Sepsis complicated pyelonephritis
Change of JJ stent at postoperative day 6
43 years old
BMI: 28
History of laparoscopy for endometriosis (hysterectomy, colorectal resection, parametrectomy, colpectomy) and laparotomy (myomectomy)
Symptoms: pelvic pain
Laparotomy:
Mixed endometriosis
Ureterolysis
Ureteral reimplantation
Partial bladder resection
Perioperative JJ stent
Operative time: 270 min
Estimated blood loss: 200 mL
Length of time before removal of urinary catheter: 14 days
Length of hospital stay: 10 days
Readmission
Sepsis complicated pyelonephritis due to misplaced JJ stent
Cardiogenic shock due to septic myocarditis
30 years old
BMI: 20.6
History of laparotomy (appendiceal peritonitis with right colectomy and upper genital tract infections with adnexectomy) and laparoscopy (ovarian cystectomy)
Symptoms: pain
Torus, USL
Rectal shaving
Colpectomy
Ureteral endometriosis
Ureterolysis
Perioperative JJ stent
Parametrectomy
Estimated blood loss: 150 mL
Length of time before removal of urinary catheter: 9 days
Length of hospital stay: 9 days
Readmission
31 years old
BMI: 27.2
History of laparoscopy for endometriosis (cholecystectomy and ovarian cystectomy)
Symptoms: pain, infertility
Laparoconversion
Torus, USL
Colorectal resection
Colpectomy
Ureteral endometriosis
Perioperative JJ stent
Parametrectomy
Protective stomia
Operative time: 419 min
Estimated blood loss: 700 mL
Perioperative transfusion
Duration before removal of urinary catheter: 7 days
Postoperative voiding dysfunction, learned self‐catheterization
Length of hospital stay: 13 days
Sepsis complicated pyelonephritis
Change of JJ stent at postoperative day 2
28 years old
BMI: 30.4
History of laparoscopy for endometriosis (hysterectomy, partial colpectomy, parametrectomy, rectal shaving, JJ stent)
Mixed endometriosis
Ureterolysis
Ureteral reimplantation
Partial bladder resection
Perioperative JJ stent
Parametrectomy
Operative time: 480 min
Estimated blood loss: 250 mL
Surgical revision on day 1 for incisional hernia.
Day 3: vesicovaginal fistula, installation of ureteral stent
Day 13: change ureteral stent by JJ stent
Readmission for pyelonephritis
33 years old
BMI:33.1
History of laparoscopy for endometriosis (endometrioma fenestration, rectal shaving, douglassectomy)
Symptoms: Pain
Torus, USL
Colorectal resection
Partial colpectomy
Ureteral endometriosis
Ureterolysis
Perioperative JJ stent
Parametrectomy
Protective stomia
Operative time: 242 min
Estimated blood loss: 150 mL
Length of time before removal of urinary catheter: 4 days
Length of hospital stay: 10 days
Ureteral fistula with ureteral stenosis with downstream stenosis
Day 1: nephrostomy
Ureterovesical reimplantation simultaneous with stoma closure
Incisional hernia 8 months postoperative
33 years old
BMI: 22.7
History of laparoscopy and laparotomy for endometriosis ovarian cystectomy, salpingectomy, peritoneal endometriosis
Symptoms: pain, metrorrhagia
Torus, USL
Discoid resection
Hysterectomy
Ureteral endometriosis
Ureterolysis
Perioperative JJ stent
Parametrectomy
Length of time before removal of urinary catheter: 6 days
Length of hospital stay: 8 days
Readmission in urology to change JJ stent
29 years old
BMI: 23.8
History of JJ stent placement
Symptoms: sciatica
Torus, USL
Discoid resection
Ureteral endometriosis
Ureterolysis
Perioperative JJ stent
Operative time: 260 min
Length of time before removal of urinary catheter: 7 days
Length of hospital stay: 12 days
38 years old
BMI:27.3
Symptoms: pain
Torus, USL
Colorectal resection
Hysterectomy
Partial colpectomy
Ureteral endometriosis
Ureterolysis
Ureteral reimplantation
Perioperative JJ stent
Parametrectomy
Protective stomia
Operative time: 420 min
Estimated blood loss: 250 mL
Length of time before removal of urinary catheter: 15 days
Length of hospital stay: 17 days
Abbreviations: BMI, body mass index (calculated as weight in kilograms divided by the square of height in meters); NA, not available; USL uterosacral ligament.
Five patients (5%) had anastomosis (vesical or ureteroneocystostomy) related complications—four patients (4%) needed a postoperative change of the JJ stent and one patient (1%) required bladder blood clot removal. Five patients required surgical revision: three patients (3%) had bleeding and two patients (2%) had intra‐abdominal abscesses drained by laparoscopy.
Seventeen patients (78%) experienced postoperative voiding dysfunction requiring self‐catheterization, including seven with persistent voiding dysfunction of longer than 1 month. Data were missing for two patients.
At the 1‐month postoperative visit, 85% of the patients had no need to take painkillers and were completely relieved. Among the remaining patients, two still required level 2 analgesics (morphine equivalent).
During follow up (median 6 months [1–12 months]), three patients experienced recurrence of their endometriosis (3%): two at 1 year and one at 5 years postoperatively.
Discussion
The present study on UTE from an expert center in endometriosis confirms that isolated bladder involvement is rare, whereas ureteral involvement is often associated with deep endometriosis lesions. Conventional or robot‐assisted laparoscopy are feasible and safe approaches to manage UTE, but expose women to severe complications. Given the high rates of peri‐ and postoperative complications, our study highlighted the risk factors of complications contributing to a better decision making process.
In our cohort, using stringent criteria, urinary endometriosis was observed in 11% of women, suggesting that the incidence of UTE is probably underestimated. This rate could be explained by the recruitment being at an expert center. However, similar rates of UTE were reported by Knabben et al. Indeed, in their experience, among the 213 patients with deep endometriosis, ureteral involvement was described in 49.8% of cases and bladder involvement in 7.5%. In the cohort of Froc et al., 150 patients (64.6%) had ureteral involvement associated or not with bladder involvement and 106 patients (45.7%) presented with bladder involvement associated or not with a ureteral involvement.
11
The discrepancy across studies could also be explained by recruitment bias.
For management of UTE, a comprehensive pretherapeutic evaluation is required. Our results underline both the low sensitivity of physical examination and MRI despite a high specificity. These considerations underline the crucial contribution of multidisciplinary endometriosis committees to planning surgery and informing patients on the surgical risks.
In the present study, most patients (94%) underwent conventional or robot‐assisted laparoscopy and 6% underwent a laparotomy conversion. In contrast, in 2021, the FRIENDS group published data from 31 French centers involving 232 patients with UTE.
42
Laparotomy was chosen as the initial surgical approach in 26% of cases, particularly in situations involving mixed locations ( p = 0.007), when ureteral resection was required ( p = 0.02), or when the procedure was performed jointly with urologists ( p = 0.004). In our series, no conversion was related to the presence of a urologist, likely due to the high level of experience of our urologists in both laparoscopy, robotic surgery, and endometriosis. Our rate of laparotomy conversion is in agreement with previous studies (1.4%–3.9%) with a nine‐fold increase in the case of associated bladder and ureteral lesions.
16
,
42
,
43
Our laparotomy conversion is in agreement with previous studies (1.4%–3.9%) with a nine‐fold increase in case of associated bladder and ureteral lesions.
16
,
42
,
43
Regarding the robotic approach, Raimondo et al. comparing conventional and robot‐assisted laparoscopy underlined the discrepancies between series depending on the experience of the center and the sample size.
44
Di Maida et al. reported the largest series comparing robotic and conventional laparoscopy in UTE, showing a lower complication rate in the robotic group ( p = 0.02) with similar functional and recurrence rates ( p = 0.70).
45
Another crucial issue is to determine the risk of postoperative complications. In our cohort, using Clavien‐Dindo classification, Grade I–II and Grade III and above complications occurred in 41% and 17% of patients, respectively. Complications requiring revision surgery or interventional radiology were observed in 17 patients (17%). Among them, the rate of Grade IIIa or above complications was higher in patients with previous surgery for endometriosis (64.7% versus 35.4%, p = 0.024). Five patients (5%) had an anastomotic complication imposing a change of JJ stent in four patients and one undergoing bladder clot evacuation. In addition, a second surgery was required for bleeding in three patients and for pelvic abscess in two patients. In our series, the rate of postoperative voiding dysfunction was 17.2%, and 7% lasted more than 1 month. The rate of voiding dysfunction varied according to surgery; 7.7% in the bladder group and 16.3% in the ureteral and mixed groups. Our rate of voiding dysfunction is consistent with previous studies,
46
depending on the presence of parametrial involvement and history of surgery for endometriosis.
To predict the risk of postoperative complications, recently the dPEI (Deep Pelvic Endometriosis Index) classification has been proposed and subsequently validated.
47
The dPEI is a standardized classification system that assesses the extent and severity of deep pelvic endometriosis based on MRI findings to help predict surgical complexity and guide clinical decision making. This classification correlates disease extension with the risk of severe complications (Clavien‐Dindo Grade IIIa or above). Patients with severe disease (deep endometriosis detected in more than five compartments) are 3.6 times more likely to experience severe complications according to the Clavien‐Dindo classification ( p = 0.004).
A crucial concern in UTE is to determine which surgical procedure to perform. In this work, deep infiltrating urinary endometriosis referred to lesions that extended to the urinary system or complicating central lesions. For bladder endometriosis, a consensus exists on recommending a partial bladder resection.
15
In our cohort we limited the risk of bias as patients requiring a bladder shaving were excluded. Indeed, under the term bladder shaving, some authors refer to the excision of the serosa alone whereas other refer to partial or total excision of the muscular layer without opening the mucosa. Similarly, the comparison of different cohorts reporting on ureteral endometriosis is complex as no consensus exists on the definition of extensive ureterolysis, posing also an issue on surgical fees. Hence, in the current study, we voluntarily defined extensive ureterolysis when endometriosis lesions imposed a ureter dissection with at least the requirement of a JJ stent. Indeed, simple ureterolysis is a systematic procedure during deep endometriosis excision, even in cases of lesions restricted to uterosacral ligaments, which is the most frequent location of deep endometriosis.
33
As in the present study, although no clear definition of extensive ureterolysis is propose Donval et al.,
43
in their retrospective study of 920 patients with deep endometriosis that included 307 patients (42.4%) with a complex ureteral procedure, observed that the main risk factors for a complex ureteral procedure were older age ( p = 0.036), a previous surgery for endometriosis ( p < 0.01), the presence of rectosigmoid involvement ( p < 0.001), rectovaginal septum endometriosis ( p < 0.01), and a ureteral dilation on MRI ( p < 0.001). However, in their work, complex ureteral procedures included patients with ureteral “shaving” up to the adventis, leading to a high incidence of complex ureteral procedures up to 30%. To overcome the challenge to compare surgical UTE reports, we propose a new definition of ureteral surgery to better inform patients, hence contributing to a better decision making process.
Another unresolved issue on UTE persists, such as the absence of consensus on the best surgical option between ureterolysis and ureteral resection according to ureteral stricture length as well as the location on the various ureteral segments. Moreover, a debate exists on whether a remaining stricture on the ureter at the end of the surgical gesture could be tolerated. We propose an algorithm for the management of patients with urinary endometriosis (see Figure 5 ). Patients with confirmed urinary endometriosis should be managed in tertiary referral centers where complementary examinations such as cystoscopy or renal scintigraphy could be performed.
Algorithm for the management of patients with urinary endometriosis.
Some limits of the current study deserve to be underlined. First, the retrospective nature introduces potential bias, especially due to missing data. In particular, preoperative workup data were missing. According to Barra et al.,
14
MRI had a sensitivity of 91% (95% CI 59%–99%) and a specificity of 59% (95% CI 39%–78%). For detection of bladder endometriosis, Maggiore et al.,
12
reported that pelvic MRI had a pooled sensitivity of 0.64 (95% CI 0.48–0.77) and a pooled specificity of 0.98 (95% CI 0.96–0.99). Second, although our series is large, the sample size remains limited, representing a potential bias. Finally, the long‐term outcomes especially concerning recurrence rate and fertility were lacking because of the limited follow up, necessitating further studies.
In conclusion, our results highlight that UTE can be successfully managed in an experienced center with an acceptable complications rate. Our results highlight the crucial role of the multidisciplinary committee. Finally, our study raises issues on a consensual definition of procedures for deep endometriosis surgery to better evaluate the true complication rates and to improve decision processes.
Introduction
Endometriosis is characterized by the presence of endometrial‐like tissue outside the uterus.
1
The prevalence of endometriosis in the general female population is estimated to 3%–10%
2
and can reach 35%–50% in infertile women.
3
,
4
Three endometriosis phenotypes are classically distinguished; the peritoneal superficial phenotype, the endometrioma, and the deep endometriosis affecting about 20% of women with endometriosis and representing the most severe form of the disease.
5
As defined by Koninckx et al., deep endometriosis refers to endometrial tissue penetrating deeply into organs, and urinary tract endometriosis (UTE) could be considered either as a complication or extension of the lesions.
6
Among deep endometriosis lesions, UTE alone remains rare, observed in 1%–5.5% of cases mainly involving the bladder (85%), and the ureter (10%), while kidney (4%), and urethra (2%) involvement is less frequent.
7
,
8
,
9
,
10
Bladder endometriosis is more often localized on the bladder dome (66% of cases).
11
,
12
Whereas, the impact of deep endometriosis on ureteral anatomy and function is observed in up to 100% of patients with colorectal endometriosis, representing the most severe form of deep endometriosis.
13
Serious complications can occur such as hydronephrosis and loss of renal function, often asymptomatic or during surgery, with ureteral injury requiring at least a JJ stent.
8
,
9
,
14
,
15
,
16
In 2017, Cavaco‐Gomes et al. produced a systematic review of 18 cohort studies analyzing the laparoscopic management of ureteral endometriosis.
16
Among the 700 patients, 32 patients were treated by radical surgery (laparoscopic ureteroneocystostomy) and 579 patients were treated by simple or extensive ureterolysis.
17
,
18
,
19
,
20
,
21
,
22
,
23
,
24
,
25
,
26
,
27
,
28
,
29
Despite surgical morbidity, their review highlighted the resolution or improvement of symptoms observed in 343 of 379 patients (90.5%). Persistent or recurrent symptoms were observed in 3.9% (95% confidence interval [CI] 0.5%–7.3%) in the ureterolysis group and 0% in the radical surgery group.
16
The scarcity of data in the literature and the variety and non‐consensual status of UTE management lead to each team developing their own protocols. Persistent or recurrent symptoms were observed in 3.9% (95% CI 0.5%–7.3%) in the ureterolysis group and 0% in the radical surgery group.
16
In view of the incomplete knowledge on this subject, the present study aims (1) to report the incidence of UTE among patients with deep endometriosis, (b) to analyze the surgical procedures, (c) to report the rate of intra‐ and postoperative complications, and (4) to report the recurrence rate in a French expert center of endometriosis.
Coi Statement
The authors have no conflicts of interest.
Materials And Methods
Data were collected from a prospective monocentric database covering a 6‐year period (January 2016 to December 2022), and then retrospectively analyzed at the Tenon Hospital Endometriosis Expert Center (C3E, AP‐HP, Paris, France).
All patients with deep endometriosis undergoing surgery during the study period were screened based on their surgical and pathologic reports. Deep endometriosis referred to lesions infiltrating the peritoneum deeper than 5 mm (not superficial).
Ureteral endometriosis was recently defined by Talreja et al.
30
as endometriotic lesions involving the overlying peritoneum, uterosacral ligament, or ovary resulting in extrinsic compression of the ureteral wall as well as lesions involving the ureteral mucosa or muscularis. The following definitions were used to describe the urologic procedures. Simple ureterolysis described when the ureter was spotted and dissected to remove endometriosis lesions at distance from the ureter. Difficult ureterolysis described when ureter dissection was mandatory to separate endometriosis lesions from the ureter but without catheterization. Extensive ureterolysis described when a catheterization was required or resection of ureteral segment. The indication was dependent on the aspect of the ureter following the dissection (severe stenosis).
In the present work, patients selected were those requiring at least a partial bladder resection, extensive ureterolysis, and ureterocystoneostomy. Patients included often had associated deep endometriosis lesions such as colorectal endometriosis or large ovarian endometrioma. Patients who underwent solely superficial bladder shaving were not included and patients under 18 years old were excluded.
The research project was approved by the Comité d'Éthique pour la Recherche en Obstétrique et Gynécologie (number 2023–GYN–0904).
31
The diagnostic strategy include an interview to determine symptoms as well as previous treatments and surgeries, followed by a physical examination including speculum and digital vaginal examination.
32
Preoperative digital rectal examination was performed in the case of suspicion of rectal or parametrial deep endometrioisis.
All patients underwent systematic imaging including transvaginal ultrasonography (TVUS) or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) with systematic preoperative review during the multidisciplinary endometriosis committee meetings. The multidisciplinary team consisted of gynecologists specialized in gynecologic surgery and assisted reproductive technology, as well as radiologists and urologists. The need for complementary examinations was always discussed in these sessions if appropriate.
On TVUS, bladder involvement was defined by a thickening of the bladder detrusor muscle, which appears hypoechoic or isoechoic, and can be linear or nodular and associated with the presence of hyperechoic spots or small cysts indicative of an endometriotic lesion (Figure 1 ).
Ultrasound appearance of anterior subperitoneal endometriosis in the vesicouterine pouch. Sagittal (a) and axial (b) endovaginal ultrasound slices showing a 19 × 18 × 9‐mm nodule, isoechoic to the vesicouterine pouch in a 30‐year‐old patient (white arrow). Ultrasound appearance of anterior bladder subperitoneal endometriosis. Sagittal (c) and axial (d) endovaginal ultrasound slices showing a 21 × 14‐mm iso/hypoechoic nodule infiltrating the bladder muscle in a 38‐year‐old patient (white star).
On MRI, bladder endometriosis was diagnosed by the presence of a nodule or mass located in the superior, posterior, or lateral bladder wall, appearing in hypo‐ or isointense T2 signal with hyperintense spots in T1 with fat suppression.
33
Regarding bladder involvement, the extent is reported according to three different levels within the bladder wall: (1) anterior two‐thirds of the dome; (2) the posterior third of the dome at the level of the vesicouterine pouch; and (3) the bladder base
34
(Figure 2 ). Ureteral involvement was assessed in the lateral compartment, especially in cases of lateral parametrial involvement associated with ureteral compression, ureterohydronephrosis, or even renal destruction
35
(Figure 3 ). All MRI examinations included slices of kidney using axial T2‐weighted lumbo‐pelvic imaging to evaluate an associated dilatation of pyelocaliceal cavities. For patients with a suspicion of bladder endometriosis, a preoperative cystoscopy was recommended to evaluate the size and the location of endometriosis as well as the distance between the lower limit of the nodule and the ureters.
Magnetic resonaonce imaging (MRI) correlation of anterior subperitoneal involvement in the vesicouterine pouch with three‐dimensional (3D) sagittal T2‐weighted sequences (a) and 3D sagittal T1 DIXON WATER‐weighted sequences (b), showing the vesicouterine pouch nodule in T2 hypointensity with hyperintense T1 WATER spots indicative of involvement in the vesicouterine pouch and detrusor in the same 30‐year‐old patient (white arrow). MRI correlation of anterior subperitoneal involvement in the bladder dome with 3D sagittal T2‐weighted sequences (c) and 3D sagittal T1 DIXON WATER‐weighted sequences (d), showing the bladder dome nodule in T2 hypointensity with hyperintense T1 WATER spots indicative of involvement of the detrusor in the vesical dome in the other 38‐year‐old patient (white star).
A 32‐year‐old patient with endometriosis involving lateral subperitoneal structures. 3D T2‐weighted magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) sequences, sagittal slices (a) showing ureteral involvement (white arrow) with an intraluminal JJ stent, adjacent parametrial involvement (white star), and bladder involvement (white circle). Notably, an adjacent endometrioma (white arrowhead) with hyperintense signal corresponding to the T1 WATER‐weighted MRI sequences, sagittal slices (b) (white arrowhead). Corresponding involvement in 3D T2‐weighted sequences, axial slices (dotted white arrow) (c), and dilation of the pyelic cavities of the upstream left kidney (white rectangle) (d).
In case of severe ureterohydronephrosis, renal scintigraphy was performed to decide between conservative surgery and nephrectomy.
Based on national and international guidelines, surgery was recommended in cases of failure of the initial medical treatment, recurrence, or multiorgan involvement and hydronephrosis.
36
,
37
All surgical procedures aimed to completely remove the disease.
36
All surgeries were performed using a laparoscopic approach and from 2019, most procedures were robotically assisted by the Da Vinci Xi (Intuitive).
38
Preoperative ureteral JJ stenting is commonly performed to reduce the risk of intraoperative ureteral injury and to facilitate the surgical procedure. The stent is placed in the ureter between the kidney and the bladder under endoscopic and radiographic control. This procedure was not systematic and was left to the discretion of the surgeons. Urologists were always involved during surgery and assessed the necessary procedures for the patients (JJ stent, ureterocystostomy).
Postoperative complications were assessed using the Clavien‐Dindo classification system as low grade (Grade I–II) or high grade (Grade IIIA and IIIB–IV).
39
,
40
Major complications were those requiring either radiologic or surgical drainage or the need for surgical revision Radiologic drainage refers in our work to the use of imaging techniques to guide the placement of a catheter for draining fluids or abscesses from the body.
In the postoperative setting, voiding dysfunction was defined as the need for self‐catheterization following surgery.
41
Databases were managed using Excel (Microsoft Corporation, Redmond, WA, USA) and statistical analyses were performed using R software (3.3.1 version, available online).
Differences between the main categorical variables were assessed using the χ 2 test or Fisher exact test, depending on the number of participants. Quantitative variables were compared using Student t test, the Wilcoxon rank‐sum test, analysis of variance, or the Kruskal‐Wallis test. For all analyses performed, a value of p < 0.05 was considered significant.
In the present study, we distinguished three groups based on the location of endometriosis in the urinary tract. Bladder endometriosis refers to isolated bladder lesions. Ureteral endometriosis refers to patients requiring extensive ureterolysis with JJ stent or ureterocystoneostomy. Mixed endometriosis involves patients with both bladder and extensive ureterolysis.
Text is read by the "Ask this paper" AI Q&A widget below.
Extraction quality varies by source — PMC NXML preserves structure
cleanly, OA-HTML may include some navigation residue, and OA-PDF can
have broken hyphenation. The publisher copy
(via DOI)
is the canonical version.