Abstract
Background: Immune system disturbances have an important role in endometriosis
which may lead to infertility. It seems that inflammatory cytokines specially tumor
necrosis factor alpha (TNF- α) which were produced by activated macrophages have an
important role in pathology of endometri osis. Based on this theory, anti TNF- α drugs
like pentoxifylline (PX) are suggested as new drugs for Endometriosis.
Objective
This experimental study has been done on female rats to determine the
effect of PX on the endometrial implants and leukocytes in serum.
Material and methods
In proestrous phase, one horn of rat’s bicorn uterus was
removed surgically and the endometrium was im planted to different places as follows:
subcutaneous, peritoneum and near ovaries. After two months observation, female rats
divided into two groups randomly. In treate d group (n=10) PX (5mg/kg twice a day)
and in control group (n=10), normal saline (same dose) were injected subcutaneously.
Then, via second laparotomy and in the same phase of the cycles, the size of implants
and the amount of leukocytes in serum were measured.
Results
In treated group compared with contro l, the size of implants was decreased
significantly in right subc utaneous (8.05mm vs 13.50mm) p<0.01, left subcutaneous
(7.64 mm vs 14mm) p<0.01, right ovary ( 6.64 mm vs 15.22mm) p<0.001 and left ovary
(7.18 mm vs 14.56 mm) p<0.005. In treated gr oup, the total leukocyte count (5259.54 ±
178.78 vs 15833.33 ± 259.27) p<0.02 was decreased. The number of esterous cycle
was similar in both groups.
Conclusion
PX can reduce the size of endometrial implants as well as leukocyte count.
Key Words: Endometriosis, Pentoxifylline, TNF-α, Anti TNF-α drugs, Infertility, Rat.
Introduction
Endometriosis is defined as ectopic growth of
endometrial stroma and glandular tissues (1,2).
Correspondence Author:
Dr Afsaneh Mohammadzade, Avesina infertility center,
Neyavaran street, next to shahrdari clinc, Tehran, Iran.
Email:
[email protected]
Although nearly three quarters of century have
been passed since the initial description of
endometriosis (3), our current understanding of the
etiology and pathphysiology of the disease has still
been remained unclear (1-4). After the first
description of the disease by Sampson in 1927
several different hypotheses have been suggested
to explain the mechanisms for the development of
Mohammadzadeh et al
Iranian Journal of Reproductive Medicine Vol.5. No.3. Summer 2007 90
endometriosis (4,5). However, Sampson’s theory
of retrograde menstruation has gained most
supportive evidence (4, 5). Retrograde
menstruation is the reflux of menses through
fallopian tubes toward the ectopic sites especially
in peritoneal cavity. There are some reports about
endometriosis in surgical incision in women who
have tolerated operation especially cesarean
section. It seems it is due to direct implantation of
viable endometrial cells into incision (4,5). These
findings support Sampson's theory as well (4, 5).
In addition,changes in cell-mediated immunity
related with endometriosis have been reported in
women, but the relevant data are inconsistent (2-5).
A reduction in proliferation of peripheral blood
lymphocytes in response to recognition of
endometrial antigens and cells has also been
reported (2-6).
It was shown that the ratio of T-helper to T-
suppressor cells is increased in the peripheral
blood of the affected women; on the contrary other
studies have indicated no remarkable differences in
peripheral lymphocytes profiles (4-7).On the other
hand, peritoneal macrophages have revealed an
increase in total number, concentration, and
activation status (8).
Tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF- α) is
regarded as one of the cytokines that has been
gained recent attention in the pathphysiology of
autoimmune diseases (9). TNF- α is a major
product of activated macrophages. It can activate
the inflammatory leukocytes which can lead to the
production of other pro inflammatory cytokines,
including interleukin-1 (IL-1), IL-6, and additional
TNF-α (9). TNF- α can stimulate endometrial cell
adhesion, as well as, induce matrix
metalloproteinases (MMPs) expression, both of
which are necessary events in the initial
development of endometriosis (10, 11).
Considering above mention facts, TNF- α has an
important role in endometriosis, therefore anti
TNF-α drugs may be proper drug for this disease.
PX reduces both the production and action of
cytokines such as TNF- α through the elevation of
intracellular cyclic AMP levels and subsequent
down regulation of cytoki ne production and action
(4, 5, 12).
PX is a member of Methylgezantine family
which inhibits Phosphodiesterase in platlets and
leads to the elevation of CAMP levels in them and
decreases the aggregation of them in circulation.
Therefore, it is useful in cerebrovascular diseases
(4, 5,13). PX can inhibit phosphodiesterase in
monocytes and macrophages and suppress
cytokineproduction specially TNF- α i n
macrophages (4,5,12,13).
In other immunological disease like sever
refractory rheumatoid arthritis (14), inflammatory
bowel disease (15), and recurrent aphthous
stomatitis (16), PX had a suppressive effect on
these diseases .Therefore , it seems that anti TNF-
α effect of this drug can be useful in treatment of
endometriosis. Based on several studies, rats are
good model for the study on endometriosis. They
don’t have menstrual cy cles and endometriosis
isn't induced in them spontaneously (17,18).
Steinleitner et al (1991) induced endometriosis
in female rats surgically and mentioned PX could
increase fertility rates in comparison with normal
saline (90% vs 2.3 %). They suggested that PX
could raise fertility rates in endometriosis in rats
(19). Nothnick et al (1994) reported that PX could
modulate rat endometriotic implant growth and
produce implant- specific proteins (ENDO-1&
ENDO-2) (20).
Balach et al (1997) reported that PX versus
placebo could improve fertility rates in women but
not significantly (21). Although in animal studies
(19, 20), PX could have a good effect on
endometriosis, but the human studies couldn’t be
able to show the significant changes in treated
group with PX (21, 22).
In order to determine the effect of PX on
endometriosis, we decided to do our study in
female rats. In this study, we induced
endometriosis in female rats surgically and
evaluated the effect of PX versus placebo on the
endometriosis.
The aims of this study were investigating : 1)
The effect of PX on the growth of endometrial
implants in female rats especially in different
places. 2)The effect of PX on leukocyte count in
serum, in order to determine the immune response
with this drug.
Materials and methods
Our randomized clinical trial study was done on
20 female rats’ sparauge- dwley (2 months old).
This study was performed in Avesina Research
Institute under support of Iranian Academic Center
for Education, Culture and Research (ACECR).
The rats were housed individually in hanging
cages. The facility was maintained on a 14-h light,
10-h darkness schedule. Female rats have 4- 5 days
estrous cycles (24). For evaluation of phases in
female rats we did vagi nal Pap smear daily (25).
Only those rats exhibited normal 4-5 day estrous
cycle were subjected to surgical induction of
Effect of pentoxifylline on the growth of endometrial implants
Iranian Journal of Reproductive Medicine Vol.5. No.3. Summer 2007 91
endometriosis. All of the ra ts had a file that the
processes were written in them step by step.
In proestrous phase or the phase of follicular
growth and peak estrogen secretion, rats were
anesthetized intra peritoneally (i.p) with 20 mg/ kg
ketamine hydrochloride. In first operation, the left
uterine horn and associated fat tissue were
removed. Left ovary was saved. The removed
uterine horn was cut longitudely and divided to 6
pieces (2×2mm). Then, endometrium was
separated from underling myometrium and 4
pieces were sutured with 4-0 round nylon to the
different parts of peritoneal cavity; 1 piece near
right kidney as right peritoneal implant, 1 piece
near mesanteric artery as left peritoneal implant
and 2 pieces in both ovaries (25). Then, 2 pieces of
endometrial implants were sutured in subcutaneous
of the rat’s skin as right and left subcutaneous
implants (25).
One hour after surgery, the animals could move
and after 4 hours, they fed regularly. Two days
later, they were put near the male rat for starting
their Estrous cycles (24,25). They were kept into
close consideration for 2 months. During this
period, 10-12 Esterous cycles were recorded for
each rat. Vaginal cytology was evaluated daily as
an indirect index of ovarian activity and
fortunately all of them had this normal Estrous
cycle.
Rats (n=20) were randomly assigned to two
groups; in treated group (n=10), PX (manufactured
by STADA, Ampoule, 100mg/5ml) in dose of
5mg/kg twice a day was administered
subcutaneously (s.c) and in control group (n=10)
normal saline as placebo was administered with the
same dose (19, 20).
In second laparotomy, which was done in
Proestrous phase too, at first we collected 5
milliliter of blood by heart puncture and sent to
laboratory for measuring the number of Leukocyte
count in serum. Then, the skin was cut and the
endometrial tissues removed and the abdominal
cavity was examined and all of our observations
about adhesions, cystic form ation, size and site of
implantation were recorded carefully. The
endometriotic implants in each animal were
measured (length x width) and the average size
(mm
2) for each place was calculated along with the
total implant mass (mm2; defined as the sum of the
size of all implants in the same places) (20). The
tissues were put in 10% formalin and sent to
laboratory for microscopic evaluation.
Endometriosis was confirmed by observation of
gland and stroma of endometrium in implants. The
surgeries were done by one surgeon and the slides
were evaluated by one pathologist blindly.
Statistical analysis
These data were analyzed by SPSS program (t-
test and Mann-Whitney for quantitive and Chi-
Square and if needed Fisher exact test for qualitive
variants). p<0.05 was considered as significant.
Results
Age, weight and size of implanted fragments
were similar in both groups. Daily pap smear
showed that the number of Esterous cycles was
similar in both groups.
The mean size of the implants in both groups is
shown in Table I. In treated group, the size of
implants in right subcutaneous (8.05 vs. 13.50mm)
p<0.01, left subcutaneous (7.64 vs. 14.00 mm)
p<0.01, right ovary (6.64 vs. 15.22mm) p<0.001
and left ovary (7.18 vs. 14.56 mm)p<0.005 were
significantly decreased. In right and left
peritoneum (8.59 vs. 12.83 and 8.59 vs. 12.83 mm)
p<0.09, the size of implants were decreased in
treated group compare with control group but this
was not significant.
In treated group the results indicate, the total
count of Leukocyte was less than control group
(5259.54± 178.78 vs. 15833 ± 259.27) p<0.02
(Table II). The number of Estorous cycle was
similar between two groups.
Table I. Comparison between the size of endometrial implants in both group, based on the site of implantation.
Mean size(mm) in two groups
Site
Control (n=10) Treated (n=10)
P
Right subcutaneous 13.50 8.05 0.01
Left subcutaneous 14.00 7.64 0.01
Right peritoneum 12.83 8.59 0.09
Left peritoneum 12.83 8.59 0.096
Right ovary 15.22 6.64 0.001
Left ovary 14.56 7.18 0.005
Mohammadzadeh et al
Iranian Journal of Reproductive Medicine Vol.5. No.3. Summer 2007 92
Table II. Comparison of pathological reports between two groups, based on the site of implantation.
Pathological report in two groups
Site
Control (n=10) Treated (n=10)
p
Right subcutaneous 0- / 10+ 6- / 4+ 0.003
Left subcutaneous 0- / 10+ 4- / 6+ 0.01
Right peritoneum 6- / 4+ 7- / 3+ 0.5
Left Peritoneum 6- / 4+ 6- / 4+ 0.5
Right Ovary 1- / 8+ 8- / 2+ 0.03
Left Ovary 3- / 8+ 7- / 2+ 0.00
- = No sign of endometriosis (stroma and gland of endometrium) in pathological report
+ = There are sign of endometriosis ( stroma and gland of endometrium )in pathological report
Discussion
Our findings showed that in treated group with
PX, the size of endometrial implants were smaller
than control group .This finding was similar to
Nothnick et al study (1994) who reported that PX
could modulate growth in endometriotic implant
rat and also rise in production process of implant-
specific proteins (ENDO-1& ENDO-2) (20).This is
different from our study because we studied the
size of endometrial fragments in different places
and compared it with the same places in control
group.
In treated group, the size of implants was
decreased significantly as follows: in right
subcutaneous, left subcut aneous, right ovary and
left ovary. In right and left peritoneum, the size of
implants was decreased in comparison with control
group but not significantly. These findings suggest
that the suppressive effect of PX was not similar in
all places. This might be valuable when we are
making decision for treatment of different types of
endometriosis.
At the time of our study, there were a few
studies on the effect of PX in female rats (19, 20)
and in human (21, 22).
Although in animal studies (19, 20),
Pentoxifylline could have a good effect on
endometriosis, the human studies (21, 22) couldn’t
be able to show the significant changes in treated
group with PX.
In treated group, the total count of Leukocytes
was decreased. These findings suggested that
endometriosis in rats was accompanied with
important changes in
Leukocyte count in serum
and PX could decrease the total count of
Leukocyte. It seems that alternation in immune
system in endometriosis which might be
accompanied with alternation in
Leukocyte count,
can suppress endometrial growth in rats. This
effect of PX was not evaluated in different studies
on rats (19-21). Therefore this finding is nearly
new and needs further studies for better evaluation.
In order to better understanding of the suppressive
effect of the PX, we suggest further studies on
natural killer (NK) cells and TNF- α during
treatment.
In our study, PX didn’t have any adverse effect on
menstrual cycles in treated group. This is an
important benefit in treatment with PX. Other
drugs suppress ovarian function and induce
hypoestrogenic state in women. Hot flash and
osteoporesis with these drugs can hurt women
(4,5). Based on our findings, under PX treatment,
ovaries can secret hormones, these symptoms
aren’t seen and fertility ability will be intact. These
findings are similar to Steinleitner et al study
(1991) findings. They induced endometriosis in
female rats through surgical process and noticed
that treatment with intra peritoneal PX in
comparison with normal saline could increase
fertility rates (90% vs. 2.3 %). They suggested that
PX could increase fertility rates in endometriosis in
rats (19).
In this study we didn’t allow the rats to get
pregnant. This effect can be evaluated with future
study.
Conclusion
PX can decrease the size of endometrial
implants especially in ovaries and subcutaneous
areas. In addition, significant reduction in
Leukocyte count was noticed after PX therapy.
References
1. Akanda VA, Hunt LP, Cahill DJ, Jenkins JM.
Differences in time to natural conception between
women with unexplained infertility and infertile
women with minor endometriosis. Hum Reprod 2004
;19:96-103.
Effect of pentoxifylline on the growth of endometrial implants
Iranian Journal of Reproductive Medicine Vol.5. No.3. Summer 2007 93
2. Denny E, Khan KS. Systematic reviews of qualitative
evidence. What are the experiences of women with
endometriosis. J Obstet Gynaecol 2006;26:501-506.
3. Tomassetti C, Meuleman C, Pexster SA, Mihalyi A,
Kyama C, Sima P, D’H ooghe TM. Endometriosis,
recurrent miscarriage and implantation failure : is there
an immunological link? Reprod Biomed Online
2006;13:58-64.
4. Berkkangolu M, Arici A. Immunology and
endometriosis . Am J Reprod.Immunol 2003;50:48-59.
5. Nothnick WB. Treating endometriosis as an autoimmune
disease. Fertil Steril 2001;76 :223-231.
6. Kyama.CM, Debrock S, Mw enda JM, D’Hooghe TM.
Potential involvement of the immune system in
development of endometriosis .Reprod Biol Endocrinol
2003;1:123-139.
7. Maeda N, Lzumiya C, Yamamoto Y, Yomamato Y,
Oguri H, Kusume T, Fukaya T. Increased killer
inhibitory receptor KIR2DL1 expression among natural
killer cells in women with pelvic endometriosis .Fertil
Steril 2002 ;77:297-302.
8. Gomez-Tores MJ, Acien P, Campos A, Velasco I.
Embriotoxicity of peritoneal fluid in women with
endometriosis: Its relation with cytokins and lymphocyte
population.Hum Reprod 2002 ;17: 777-781.
9. Richter O, Mallman P, Vanderven H, Krebs D. TNF- α
Secretion by Peritoneal m acrophages in endometriosis.
Zentralbl Gynakol 1998;120:332-336.
10. Jerzak M,Baranowski W,Rec hberger T, Gorski A.
Enhanced Tcell interactions with extracellular matrix
proteins in infertile women with endometriosis.
Immunol Lett 2002; 81:65-70.
11. Bruner KL, Matrstan IM, Rodgers WI, Gorstein F,
Osteen K. Suppression of matrix metalloproteinase
inhibits establishment of ectopic lesions by human tissue
in nude mice. J Clin Invest 1997; 99: 2851-2857.
12. Sullivan GW, Caper HT, Novick WJ Jr, Mandell GL.
Induction of the inflammatory action of IL1, TNF- α, on
neutrofil function by Pentoxifylline. Infect Immun. 1988
;56:1722-1729.
13. Ward A, Clissold SP. Pentoxifylline .A review of it’s
pharmacodynamic and pharmac okinetic properties and
it’s therapeutic efficacy. Drugs 1987;34:50-97.
14. Maksymowych WP, Avina-Zubeta A, Luong MH,
Kussel AS. An open study of pentoxifylline in the
treatment of sever refractory rheumatoid arthritis. J
Rheumatol 1995; 22:625-629.
15. Reimund JM, Bumont S, Muller CD, Kenny JS,
kedinger M, Bauman R, et al . In vitro effects of
pentoxifylline on inflammatory cytokine release in
patients with inflammatory bowel disease. Gut 1997 ;40:
475-480.
16. Thornhill MH, Baccaglini L, Theaker E, Pemberton MN.
A randomized Double-blind Placcebo-controlled of
Pentoxifylline for the treatment of Recurrent Aphthous
Stomatitis. Arch Dermatol 2007;143:463-470.
17. Vernon MW, Wilson EA. Studies on the surgical
induction of endometriosis in the rat. Fertil steril 1985
;44 :684-699.
18. Sharpe- Timms KL. Using rats as a research model for
the study of endometriosis. Ann NY Acad Sci 2002
;955:318-327.
19. Steinleitner A, Lambert H, Suarez M, Serpa N, Roy S.
Immunomodulation in the treat ment of endometriosis –
associated subfertility : use of Pentoxifylline to reverse
the inhibition of fertilization by surgically induced
endometriosis in a rodent model. Fertil Steril
1991;56:975-979.
20. Nothnick WB, Curry TE, Vernon MW.
Immunomodulation of rat endom etriotic implant growth
and protein production. AJRI 1994;31:151-162.
21. Balasch J, Creus M, Fa bregues F, Carmona F,
Martinez-Roman S, Manau D, Vanrell JA.
Pentoxifylline versus placebo in the treatment of
infertility associated with minimal or mild
endometriosis: a pilot randomi zed clinical trial. Hum
Reprod 1997;12:2046-2050.
22. Alborzi S, Ghotbi S, Pa rsanezhad ME, Dehbashi S,
Alborzi S, Alborzi M. Pentoxifylline therapy after
laparoscopic surgery for different stages of
endometriosis: a prospectiv e, double blind,randomized
placebo-controled study. J Minim Invasive Gynecol
2007;14:54-58.
23. Smith MG, Hau J, Hoosier GL. Handbook of laboratory
animal science, 2 nd ed , U.S.A, CRC press . 2003.p. 51-
62.
24. Waggie K. Manual of microbiologic monitoring of
laboratory animals, 2 nd ed , U.S.A, DIAN publishing.
1996:59-165.
25. Mohammadzadeh A, Heidari M, Soltan Ghoraii H,
Zarnani AH, Ghaffari Novin M, Akhondi MM
Mossavie Jarahi A, Mohamma dzadeh F. Induction of
endometriosis by implantati on of endometrial fragments
in female rats. IJRM 2006; 4:63-67.
Text is read by the "Ask this paper" AI Q&A widget below.
Extraction quality varies by source — PMC NXML preserves structure
cleanly, OA-HTML may include some navigation residue, and OA-PDF can
have broken hyphenation. The publisher copy
is the canonical version.