Results
Characteristics of studied patients.
Data expressed as mean (SD), frequency
(percentage).
This was a prospective cohort study conducted on 100 women with
mean age was 41.3 years. A total of 50 (50%) of patients had dysmenorrhea, with
average VAS of (3.2 ± 3), (34%) had dyspareunia, with average VAS of
(1.4 ± 0.9), (85%) had Menorrhagia, with average VAS of (3.9 ± 1.9), and (18%)
had Defecation pain, with average VAS of (0.9 ± 0.01).
Hysteroscopic and histopathological data and drug
intervention.
Data expressed as mean (SD), frequency
(percentage).
Regarding Hysteroscopy data; 15 (15%) and 87 (87%) of patients had
hysteroscopic appearance suggestive of adenomyosis and fibroid, respectively.
Histopathology data; 15 (15%) and 85 (85%) of patients had adenomyosis, and
fibroid, respectively.
Characteristics of patients based on
histopathology.
Data expressed as mean (SD), frequency (percentage). P value was significant
if < 0.05.
* p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01.
Patients with adenomyosis had significantly longer duration of
symptoms. At baseline and during follow up as regard clinical data there was
significant differences between both groups with exception of menorrhagia at
baseline.
Hysteroscopy and intervention based on
histopathology.
Data expressed as mean (SD), frequency (percentage). P value was significant
if < 0.05.
* p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01.
There was significant difference between both groups as regard
hysteroscopic findings but both of them were comparable as regard drug
therapy.
Logistic regression model for the Factors affecting
different clinical data.
Other factors excluded from the model as ( P value > 0.1). OR: odds
ratio.
* p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01.
The decrease in age; and the increase in Adenomyosis in
hysteroscopy; had an independent effect on increasing the probability of
dysmenorrhea occurrence.
The decrease in age; and the increase in Gravidity, Duration of
symptoms and adenomyosis in hysteroscopy were predictors for dyspareunia
occurrence.
The decrease in duration of symptoms; and the increase in
adenomyosis in hysteroscopy were predictors of menorrhagia.
The increase in endometrial depth and adenomyosis in
hysteroscopy were predictors for defecation pain.
Roc-curve of hysteroscopy usage to predict
diagnosis.
ROC (Receiver operating characteristic), AUC; Area under
curve.
* p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01.
ROC curve of hysteroscopy usage (Adenomyosis).
ROC curve of hysteroscopy usage (Fibroid).
By using ROC-curve analysis hysteroscopy usage had 73.33%
sensitivity for prediction of adenomyosis and fibroid with 95.29% and 97.65%
specificity for prediction of adenomyosis and fibroid, respectively.
Role of Norethindrone in each diagnosis.
* p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01.
Both groups showed highly significant decrease in follow up
menorrhagia pain, in continuous norethindrone group.
Roc-curve of Norethindrone administration to predict follow
up obstetric data
ROC (Receiver operating characteristic), AUC; Area under
curve.
* p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01.
ROC curve of Norethindrone administration (Menorrhagia
pain).
By using ROC-curve analysis, norethindrone administration showed
non-significant predictive values regarding dysmenorrhea, dyspareunia and
defecation pain except for menorrhagia pain with AUC was 0.793.
Patients
This was a prospective study in the management of uterine leiomyoma and
adenomyosis. This study has been conducted in the Department of Obstetrics and
Gynecology, Ghamra Military Medical Hospital in Cairo.
The duration of the study was from January 2021 to January 2023.
Clinical assessment with complete history taking and systemic examination of 100
patients of reproductive age group was done and relevant findings were recorded with
informed consent.
In this study hysteroscopy was done in a minor operation theatre
under sedation to evaluate abnormal uterine bleeding and dysmenorrhea in the
reproductive age group women suspected of fibroid or adenomyosis.
Patients diagnosed by US who has submucous fibroid and adenomyosis
with age between 25 and 45 years old and Regular menstrual cycles before
administration of norethindrone.
Pregnancy and or breast-feeding women Patients with ovarian neoplasm, benign ovarian cyst
including endometrioma Pelvic inflammatory disease or other endocrine
disease
Pregnancy and or breast-feeding women
Patients with ovarian neoplasm, benign ovarian cyst
including endometrioma
Pelvic inflammatory disease or other endocrine
disease
All patients were subjected to full history taking and clinical
evaluation. Baseline blood tests included complete blood count, blood sugar,
blood urea, serum creatinine and blood grouping. Abdominal and pelvic ultrasound
and anesthetic fitness was obtained. Prophylactic antibiotics with third
generation cephalosporins were given in pre operative and post operative
period.
Hysteroscopy was done in the proliferative phase of the menstrual
cycle. The procedure was done with administration of short intravenous
anesthesia. It was done based on all standard guidelines The anterior lip of
cervix comes to view and is holded with the volelsellam. The hysteroscopy is
checked before introducing for the eye-piece, objective lens, clarity and then
introduced through the vagina, ectocervix and the endocervical canal. Any lesion
found was documented.
Illumination of the scope was provided by a high intensity cold
light source via a fibro optic cable and the procedure monitored through the
video monitor. Then the hysteroscope was introduced into the uterine
cavity.
The hysteroscopy was guided through the endocervical canal into the
uterine cavity under vision, The Ostia of the tubes examined, then the
endometrial surface was examined. All the surfaces of uterine cavity, that is
the anterior wall, posterior wall, and lateral walls were examined. The
appearance of the endometrium, color, any polyps, fibroid, hyperplasia and
vascularity noted.
The examination was considered complete when all parts were
visualized. If any difficulty in visualization due to blood clot was documented
then the procedure is considered as incomplete and failed. The hysteroscopic
findings was correlated with the histopathology results.
Two regimens were used by Norethindrone administration the 1st
regimen as continuous manner from day 5 to day 21 46 patients (46%). The 2nd
manner was the intermittent type from day 16 and for 10 days 54 patients (54%).
The choice between regimens depends on the clinical goal where continuous use is
better for menstrual suppression, while intermittent use is preferred for cycle
regulation or short-term symptom relief.
The main study variables were chronic pain, dysmenorrhea or pain
during uterine bleeding assessed using the visual analog scale (VAS) at baseline
and then after three months.
The study was conducted according to the principles of the
Declaration of Helsinki and was approved by the Hospital’s Ethics Committee
purpose of the study was explained to all participants, and written informed
consent was obtained. The study was approved by Assiut Faculty of Medicine,
Institutional Review Board (IRB No. 17200648, 2021). The study was explained to
all patients and only patients who were signing an informed consent were
participated in study. This study was registered on clinicaltrials.gov with
identifier: ( NCT05153928 ).
Data entry, processing and statistical analysis was carried out
using MedCalc ver. 20 (MedCalc, Ostend, Belgium). Mean, Standard deviation
(± SD) and range for parametric numerical data and compared with Student t test,
while Median and Inter-quartile range (IQR) for non-parametric numerical data
and compared by Mann Whiteny test. Frequency and percentage of non-numerical
data.
Student’s t test was used to assess the statistical significance of
the difference between two study group means. Chi-Square test was used to
examine the relationship between two qualitative variables. Logistic regression:
useful in the prediction of the presence or absence of an outcome based on a set
of independent variables.
The ROC Curve (receiver operating characteristic) provides a useful
way to evaluate the Sensitivity and specificity for quantitative Diagnostic
measures that categorize cases into one of two groups. Confidence interval was
kept at 95% and hence, P value was
significance if < 0.05.
Conclusion
The current study stated the important use of hysteroscopy in
management of abnormal uterine bleeding. Norethindrone looks a good alternative for
management of AUB cases. Future studies are warranted to assess these findings
particularly regarding the long-term effects and patient adherence to Norethindrone
treatment regimens.
Discussion
In the currents study, Roc-curve of hysteroscopy usage to predict
diagnosis; adenomyosis sensitivity was 73.33% and specificity 95.29% and fibroid
sensitivity was 73.33% and specificity was 97.65%. Two regimens were used by
Norethindrone administration the 1st regimen as continuous manner from day 5 to day
21 46 patients (46%). The 2nd manner was the intermittent type from day 16 and for
10 days 54 patients (54%). Both groups revealed; highly significant decrease in
follow up menorrhagia in continuous Norethindrone group ( P < 0.001).
By using ROC-curve analysis; Norethindrone administration predicted
decreased menorrhagia pain with fair (70%) accuracy; sensitivity 80% and specificity
81%.
Outpatient hysteroscopy as a mode of diagnostic modality for abnormal
uterine bleeding has gained popularity and is extremely encouraging. Its high
diagnostic reliability, less pain, minimally invasive, office procedure all these
make this diagnostic hysteroscopy an ideal method for diagnosis and also for follow
up of patients with endometrial hyperplasia 8 .
The review of the studies about hysteroscopy in abnormal uterine
bleeding and its meta-analysis showed that diagnostic hysteroscopy is accurate in
diagnosing intrauterine pathologies. It is highly sensitive and is useful
clinically. Moreover, when compared to other studies 9 – 11 .
Our review confirms that diagnostic hysteroscopy is safe and no
complication has been in our study. Technical failures and patient discomfort were
not reported in any of the patients included in our study. All the patients taken
for the study underwent hysteroscopy successfully.
Hysteroscopy, a minimally invasive technique, allows direct observation
of the endometrial thickness and color, the opening of the bilateral fallopian
tubes, uterine angles, cavity shape, and cervical canal. Despite its growing
popularity, hysteroscopy faces limitations in clinical practice, such as cost,
technical complexity, invasiveness, and patient tolerance 12 .
Ding et al. 13 demonstrated that combining transvaginal
ultrasound, enhanced by the K-means clustering color image segmentation algorithm,
with hysteroscopy significantly increased diagnostic sensitivity.In diagnosing AUB
caused by endometrial polyps, the concordance rates for hysteroscopy and
transvaginal ultrasound were 93.3% and 77.3%, respectively, with the difference
being statistically significant indicating hysteroscopy’s superior efficacy in
detecting endometrial polyps.
The concordance rates for diagnosing AUB caused by normal endometrium,
uterine leiomyoma, malignant transformation of the endometrium, adenomyosis,
atypical hyperplasia, benign hyperplasia, and other factors did not show a
statistically significant difference between the two
methods 14 – 16 .
This discrepancy from previous findings may be attributable to factors
such as small sample size. In diagnosing peri-menopausal AUB, transvaginal
ultrasound showed a sensitivity of 89.7%, a specificity of 66.7%, and a negative
predictive value of 46.7%. Hysteroscopy demonstrated higher sensitivity,
specificity, and negative predictive value of 94.8%, 76.2%, and 66.7%,
respectively 16 .
The combined diagnostic approach yielded sensitivity and specificity
rates of 97.4% and 81.0%, respectively, and a negative predictive value of 81.0%,
surpassing the individual use of transvaginal ultrasound and
hysteroscopy 17 .
The consistency between transvaginal ultrasound results and the
pathological diagnosis was moderate (Kappa 0.475), while hysteroscopy showed
substantial consistency (Kappa 0.669). The combined use of transvaginal ultrasound
and hysteroscopy presented a higher consistency with the pathological diagnosis
(Kappa 0.784), suggesting that this combined approach offers superior diagnostic
efficacy in the evaluation of peri-menopausal AUB 18 .
Bettocchi reported his experience with more than 11,000 hysteroscopic
procedures performed using the vaginoscopic technique, eliminating the use of a
speculum and a tenaculum. He found that as many as 99.1% of the patients reported no
discomfort related to the procedure. The mean pain score was significantly lower in
the group without the use of speculum 19 .
The current study had some limitations selection bias, being conducted
in single center and relatively small sample size. These make difficulty in
generalizability of such findings with need for further research.
Introduction
Up to one-third of women will experience abnormal uterine bleeding (AUB)
in their life, with irregularities most commonly occurring at menarche and
perimenopause. A normal menstrual cycle has a frequency of 24–38 days, lasts 7–9
days, with 5–80 millilitres of blood loss 1 .
Fibroids can either present as an asymptomatic incidental finding on
imaging, or symptomatically. Common symptoms include abnormal uterine bleeding,
pelvic pain, disruption of surrounding pelvic structures (bowel and bladder), and
back pain 2 .
Adenomyosis is a gynecologic condition characterized by ectopic
endometrial tissue within the uterine myometrium.The definitive treatment for women
who no longer desire pregnancy is hysterectomy, while a variety of other medical and
minimally invasive therapies are available for those who want to preserve fertility
or want to avoid more extensive surgery 3 .
Hysteroscopy is an essential diagnostic tool, particularly in cases
where transvaginal ultrasound findings are inconclusive or equivocal. This is
especially relevant in evaluating suspected FIGO type 0, 1, and 2 submucosal myomas,
where ultrasound may not clearly differentiate fibroids from endometrial polyps or
other intracavitary lesions.
Hysteroscopy allows for direct visualization of the uterine cavity,
providing definitive identification of the number, size, and precise location of
myomas relative to the endometrial surface. In cases where ultrasound raises
suspicion but does not confirm the diagnosis, hysteroscopy can clarify the pathology
and guide clinical decision-making, particularly when surgical planning or fertility
preservation is a concern 4 .
Similarly, in patients with suspected subendometrial or internal
myometrial adenomyosis and inconclusive imaging, hysteroscopy can offer additional
diagnostic insights. While it is not the primary modality for diagnosing
adenomyosis, it can reveal subtle endometrial surface irregularities, vascular
anomalies, or cystic changes that may reflect underlying
disease 4 .
These findings, when correlated with clinical symptoms and imaging, can
strengthen diagnostic confidence. Thus, hysteroscopy holds significant diagnostic
value as a second-line investigation when ultrasound does not provide definitive
answers, enhancing accuracy and helping tailor individualized management
strategies 5 .
Hysteroscopy is widely regarded as the gold standard for diagnosing and
treating intrauterine pathology and may be particularly beneficial for women with
infertility or recurrent pregnancy loss. While some guidelines and studies support
its use as a routine screening tool during infertility evaluation, others advise
limiting its use to cases with specific clinical
indications 6 .
The effectiveness of diagnostic or operative hysteroscopy in improving
reproductive outcomes—especially in women with unexplained subfertility or suspected
uterine cavity abnormalities, and in those undergoing IUI or IVF—remains uncertain,
highlighting the need for further high-quality research to clarify its role in
enhancing fertility outcomes 6 .
The role of norethindrone acetate (NA) offers promise as an effective
and well tolerated drug in the management of symptomatic adenomyosis. NA may be a
much cheaper alternative to other treatment options for adenomyosis, with fewer and
milder side effects 7 .
The choice between regimens depends on the clinical goal where
continuous use is better for menstrual suppression, while intermittent use is
preferred for cycle regulation or short-term symptom relief. Continuous use may lead
to more breakthrough bleeding initially, but better long-term control, whereas
intermittent use maintains cyclic bleeding {Kaldewey, 2021 #2786}.
The current study aimed to evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of
hysteroscopy in differentiating between uterine adenomyosis and fibroids. Also, to
compare between continuous versus intermittent administration of Norethindroneto
control both uterine adenoxmyosis and leiomymatosis.
Text is read by the "Ask this paper" AI Q&A widget below.
Extraction quality varies by source — PMC NXML preserves structure
cleanly, OA-HTML may include some navigation residue, and OA-PDF can
have broken hyphenation. The publisher copy
(via DOI)
is the canonical version.