Results
From December 14, 2020 through October 31, 2021, VAERS received a total of 603,786 reports after receipt of any COVID-19 vaccine; 3,462 of these reports involved pregnant persons: 1,831 (52.9%) after BNT162b2, 1,350 (39.0%) after mRNA-1273, 275 (7.9%) after Ad26. COV2. S and 6 had unknown manufacturer. Medical records were obtained for 713 (20.6%) of 3,462 reports. Characteristics of pregnancy reports into VAERS can be seen in Table 1
. Six-hundred twenty-one (17.9%) reports were coded as serious, including eight maternal deaths. Most COVID-19 vaccines were reported as administered during the first (1,040; 45.5%) or second trimester of pregnancy (727; 31.8%). The most frequent pregnancy-specific AEs reported following any COVID-19 vaccine administration ( Table 2
) were spontaneous abortion (SAB) in 878 women (25.4%), vaginal bleeding in 101 (2.9%), premature delivery in 76 (2.2%) and stillbirth in 62 (1.8%). Most (81.3%; 490/603) SABs with gestational age data were reported to occur at < 12 weeks’ gestation and in 338/859 (39.3%) the pregnant person was 35 years of age or older. Among 849 SAB reports with onset interval information (onset interval is the period of time from vaccination to presentation of symptoms/signs of the adverse event), the onset interval was 0–3 days in 26.4%, 4–7 days in 12.0%, 8–14 days in 15.5%, and ≥ 15 days in 46.1% Table 1 Characteristics of VAERS reports received following COVID-19 vaccines in pregnant persons, United States, December 14, 2020-October 31, 2021. Characteristic All vaccines a BNT162b2 Vaccine mRNA-1273 Vaccine Ad26.COV2.S Vaccine Total reports 3,462 1,831 1,350 275 Maternal age in years, median (IQR) b 33 (30–36) 33 (30–36) 33 (30–36) 33 (30–36) Reports with maternal, age ≥ 35 years b , n (%) 1,233 (36.3) 660 (36.0) 477 (35.3) 95 (34.5) Interval from vaccination to adverse event in days, median (IQR) c 2 (0–15) 2 (0–17) 2 (0–14) 1 (0–11) Gestational age in weeks at time of vaccination, median (IQR) d 15.0 (7–26) 16 (6–27) 14 (7–25) 18 (9–28) Reports of serious adverse events, n (%) e 621 (17.9) 359 (19.6) 217 (16.1) 42 (15.3) Type of reporter, N (%) Patient/parent 2,213 (63.9) 1,116 (61.0) 920 (68.1) 176 (64.0) Provider 747 (21.6) 401 (21.9) 296 (21.9) 46 (16.7) Other 157 (4.5) 83 (4.5) 60 (4.4) 14 (5.1) Manufacturer 345 (10.0) 231 (12.6) 74 (5.5) 39 (14.2) Trimester of pregnancy at time of vaccination, N (%) 2,288 c 1,268 851 167 First (0 – 13 weeks) 1,040 (45.5) 567 (44.7) 413 (48.5) 60 (35.9) Second (14 – 27 weeks) 727 (31.8) 396 (31.2) 271 (31.8) 59 (35.3) Third (>= 28 weeks) 520 (22.7) 304 (24.0) 167 (19.6) 48 (28.7) IQR (interquartile range). a Brand unknown in 6 reports; b Maternal age unknown in 69 reports. c Onset i nterval unknown for 106 reports with adverse events d Gestational age at time of vaccination is unknown for 1,174 reports. e A report is defined as serious when one of the following is reported: death, life-threatening illness, hospitalization or prolongation of hospitalization, permanent disability, a congenital anomaly [12] Table 2 Reported pregnancy-specific and infant adverse events (AEs) † in pregnant persons following receipt of COVID-19 vaccines, VAERS, December 2020-October 2021. Adverse events† All vaccines BNT162b2 Vaccine mRNA-1273 Vaccine Ad26.COV2.S Vaccine Total reports 3,462 1,831 1,350 275 N (%) Pregnancy specific‡ 1,377 (39.8) 783 (42.8) 506 (37.5) 84 (30.5) Spontaneous abortion (<20 weeks gestation) 878 (25.4) 479 (26.2) 341 (25.3) 55 (20.0) Vaginal bleeding 101 (2.9) 59 (3.2) 36 (2.7) 6 (2.2) Preterm delivery (<37 weeks) 76 (2.2) 48 (2.6) 25 (1.9) 3 (1.1) Stillbirth (≥20 weeks gestation ) 62 (1.8) 38 (2.1) 20 (1.5) 4 (1.5) Premature rupture of membranes 25 (0.7) 17 (0.9) 8 (0.6) 0 Placental abnormalities 34 (1.0) 17 (0.9) 13(1.0) 4 (1.5) Preeclampsia/gestational hypertension 43 (1.2) 20 (1.1) 13 (1.0) 9 (3.3) Ectopic/molar pregnancy 17 (0.5) 9 (0.5) 6 (0.4) 2 (0.7) Gestational diabetes 15 (0.4) 10 (0.5) 4 (0.3) 1 (0.4) Maternal deaths 8 (0.2) 6 (0.3) 2 (0.1) 0 Other a 91 (2.6) 59 (3.2) 27 (2.0) 5 (1.8) Infant† 108 (3.1) 64 (3.5) 40 (3.0) 4 (1.5) Neonatal death 12 (0.3) 9 (0.5) 1 (0.07) 2 (0.7) Birth defects 26 (0.8) 11 (0.6) 15 (1.1) 0 Infant in intensive care unit (diverse abnormalities) 21 (0.6) 10 (0.5) 10 (0.7) 1 (0.4) b Other infant conditions 49 (1.4) 34 (1.9) 14 (1.0) 1 (0.4) †Adverse events are not mutually exclusive; ‡Percentages for pregnancy and infant conditions calculated using total pregnancy reports. a For other pregnancy-specific: Delivery (29), contractions (18), fetal growth restriction (11), amniotic fluid anomalies/polyhydramnios (9), decreased fetal movement (7), elective ab (5), subchorionic hematoma/hemorrhage (7), chromosomal abnormalities (7), unviable pregnancy (3), bleeding (2),and one each report of: shortened cervix, gestational thrombocytopenia/fever/chills/fetal heart rate deceleration, fetal loss, cervical insufficiency, umbilical cord prolapse, facial numbness/thrombus in placenta, fetal tachycardia, HCG testing, rupture of membranes, twin pregnancy, increased fetal movement, chorioamnionitis, postpartum, small for gestational age, fetal hypokinesia, rash/urticaria/vaginal birth of normal infant, postpartum hemorrhage, single umbilical artery, induced high blood pressure, conjoined twins, irregular heartbeat, fetal death/high blood pressure, twin pregnancy, fetal development disorder, prelabor rupture of membranes/breech presentation/post-partum hemorrhage, hydrops/termination of pregnancy, rupture of membranes, meconium stained fluid, uncomplicated pregnancy/term infant, false labor/fetal evaluation, term baby, uterine inversion/ mastitis/endometriosis, marginal cord insertion b Other infant conditions include: preterm infant (5), low birth weight (4), fetal hydrops (3), premature closure of ductus arteriosus (2), healthy infant (2), large for gestational age, preterm infant/injured brain tissue, fetal tachycardia, infant seizures/ischemic brain injury, eroded skin lower legs, sub-amniotic hematoma/neonatal pneumonia, stopped lactating, laryngomalacia, baby brain not developing well, hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy, fetal arrhythmia, hypoglycemia in infant, small for gestational age, respiratory distress/suspected spontaneous gastrointestinal perforation, cardiac abnormalities, normal delivery, LBW/infant with low blood glucose/high bilirubin, seizure, jaundice, neonatal disorder, bell’s palsy infant, brain hemorrhage in fetus, platelet disorder in infant-bruise easily, hypertension/unilateral auditory neuropathy, pleural effusion in fetus, nummular eczema in infant
Characteristics of VAERS reports received following COVID-19 vaccines in pregnant persons, United States, December 14, 2020-October 31, 2021.
IQR (interquartile range).
Brand unknown in 6 reports;
Maternal age unknown in 69 reports.
Onset i nterval unknown for 106 reports with adverse events
Gestational age at time of vaccination is unknown for 1,174 reports.
A report is defined as serious when one of the following is reported: death, life-threatening illness, hospitalization or prolongation of hospitalization, permanent disability, a congenital anomaly [12]
Reported pregnancy-specific and infant adverse events (AEs) † in pregnant persons following receipt of COVID-19 vaccines, VAERS, December 2020-October 2021.
†Adverse events are not mutually exclusive; ‡Percentages for pregnancy and infant conditions calculated using total pregnancy reports. a For other pregnancy-specific: Delivery (29), contractions (18), fetal growth restriction (11), amniotic fluid anomalies/polyhydramnios (9), decreased fetal movement (7), elective ab (5), subchorionic hematoma/hemorrhage (7), chromosomal abnormalities (7), unviable pregnancy (3), bleeding (2),and one each report of: shortened cervix, gestational thrombocytopenia/fever/chills/fetal heart rate deceleration, fetal loss, cervical insufficiency, umbilical cord prolapse, facial numbness/thrombus in placenta, fetal tachycardia, HCG testing, rupture of membranes, twin pregnancy, increased fetal movement, chorioamnionitis, postpartum, small for gestational age, fetal hypokinesia, rash/urticaria/vaginal birth of normal infant, postpartum hemorrhage, single umbilical artery, induced high blood pressure, conjoined twins, irregular heartbeat, fetal death/high blood pressure, twin pregnancy, fetal development disorder, prelabor rupture of membranes/breech presentation/post-partum hemorrhage, hydrops/termination of pregnancy, rupture of membranes, meconium stained fluid, uncomplicated pregnancy/term infant, false labor/fetal evaluation, term baby, uterine inversion/ mastitis/endometriosis, marginal cord insertion
b Other infant conditions include: preterm infant (5), low birth weight (4), fetal hydrops (3), premature closure of ductus arteriosus (2), healthy infant (2), large for gestational age, preterm infant/injured brain tissue, fetal tachycardia, infant seizures/ischemic brain injury, eroded skin lower legs, sub-amniotic hematoma/neonatal pneumonia, stopped lactating, laryngomalacia, baby brain not developing well, hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy, fetal arrhythmia, hypoglycemia in infant, small for gestational age, respiratory distress/suspected spontaneous gastrointestinal perforation, cardiac abnormalities, normal delivery, LBW/infant with low blood glucose/high bilirubin, seizure, jaundice, neonatal disorder, bell’s palsy infant, brain hemorrhage in fetus, platelet disorder in infant-bruise easily, hypertension/unilateral auditory neuropathy, pleural effusion in fetus, nummular eczema in infant
Eight maternal deaths were reported. Cause of death could be ascertained through medical record review in four reports: pulmonary embolism (case 1), amniotic fluid embolism (case 2), eclampsia with peripartum cardiomyopathy (case 3), and acute cerebellar intraparenchymal hemorrhage secondary to severe persistent thrombocytopenia due to acute myelogenus leukemia (case 4). In two other cases (cases #5-#6) the patients experienced sudden clinical deterioration leading to death and in one of them, amniotic fluid embolism, a rare but acute life-threatening complication of childbirth [26] , was suspected as the event leading to death. No medical records were available for two reports (cases #7-#8), and the information in the VAERS reports was very limited. A brief description of each report is available in supplementary Table S1.
The most common non-pregnancy specific AEs were injection site and systemic reactions ( Table 3
), irrespective of type of vaccine or brand. Among pre-specified conditions of interest, 17 reports of Bell’s palsy or facial paralysis were reported but only two could be verified through medical record review. Eleven were after BNT162b2 and 6 after mRNA-1273. Median onset interval was 7 days (range, 0-70 days). Three reports were serious. One report of Guillain Barré Syndrome – Miller Fisher variant was reported and verified in a woman at 27 weeks’ gestation expecting her first child, 3 weeks after receiving the Ad26.COV2.S vaccine. This patient was hospitalized for 5 days and by the time of discharge she was significantly improved and fetal surveillance did not show findings of concern. A second report of Guillain Barre Syndrome (GBS) after mRNA-1273 was reported but could not be verified as no medical records were available. Ten reports of anaphylaxis or possible anaphylaxis were reported. Two were verified by review of medical records. Eight patients had recovered but no information was available for other two. Four reports of myocarditis and one report of pericarditis that met CDC’s case definition for myopericarditis [27] were reported to VAERS. For myocarditis, two reports were after BNT162b2, one report after mRNA-1273 and one after Ad26.COV2.S. The one report of pericarditis was after mRNA-1273. All 5 patients recovered. Table 3 Most common MedDRA codes after COVID-19 vaccines, combined and by brand, among non-pregnancy specific reports (1,611), VAERS, December 2020 – October 2021† All vaccine brands (N = 2,002) n BNT162b2 vaccine (N = 1,006) n mRNA-1273 vaccine (N = 809) n Ad26.COV2.S vaccine (N = 185) n Headache 434 (21.7) Headache 211 21.0% Headache 160 (19.8) Pyrexia 77 (41.6) Fatigue 422 (21.1) Fatigue 209 20.8% Fatigue 155 (19.2) Chills 70 (37.8) Pyrexia 381 (19.0) Chills 159 15.8% Pyrexia 152 (18.8) Headache 63 (34.1) Chills 369 (18.4) Pain 153 15.2% Pain 145 (17.9) Fatigue 58 (31.4) Pain 342 (17.1) Pyrexia 152 15.1% Chills 139 (17.2) Pain 43 (23.2) Nausea 299 (14.9) Nausea 143 14.2% Pain in extremity 123 (15.2) Nausea 36 (19.4) Pain in extremity 266 (13.3) Dizziness 122 12.1% Nausea 120 (14.8) Myalgia 24 (12.9) Dizziness 225 (11.2) Pain in extremity 122 12.1% Injection site erythema 88 (10.9) Pain in extremity 21 (11.4) Injection site pain 186 (9.3) Vomiting 85 8.5% Injection site pain 87 (10.8) Vomiting 18 (9.7) Vomiting 165 (8.2) Injection site pain 84 8.4% Dizziness 86 (10.6) Dizziness 17 (9.2) † MedDRA codes are not mutually exclusive meaning one report may have several MedDRA codes 872 reports from vaccine manufacturers (not included in tables above) were received in large batches over a short period of time and were not manually reviewed. Automated analysis revealed the most common adverse events from this group were: pain in extremity (83;9.5%), headache (58;6.7%), fatigue (50; 5.7%), chills (38; 4.4%), injection site pain (38;4.4%), myalgia (38; 4.4%), fever (37; 4.2%), pain (34; 3.9%) nausea (27; 3.1%), dizziness (19; 2.2%), and spontaneous abortion (18; 2.1%)
Most common MedDRA codes after COVID-19 vaccines, combined and by brand, among non-pregnancy specific reports (1,611), VAERS, December 2020 – October 2021†
† MedDRA codes are not mutually exclusive meaning one report may have several MedDRA codes
872 reports from vaccine manufacturers (not included in tables above) were received in large batches over a short period of time and were not manually reviewed. Automated analysis revealed the most common adverse events from this group were: pain in extremity (83;9.5%), headache (58;6.7%), fatigue (50; 5.7%), chills (38; 4.4%), injection site pain (38;4.4%), myalgia (38; 4.4%), fever (37; 4.2%), pain (34; 3.9%) nausea (27; 3.1%), dizziness (19; 2.2%), and spontaneous abortion (18; 2.1%)
Fifty-eight reports of SARS-CoV-2 infection after COVID-19 vaccination in pregnant persons were reported to VAERS. Fourteen were coded as serious but for reasons unrelated to COVID-19 infection (e.g., elevated blood pressure, scheduled cesarean section). Twenty were asymptomatic, 25 were symptomatic and 13 did not indicate if the patient presented symptoms. Thirty-eight SARS CoV-2 infections were after BNT162b2, twelve after mRNA-1273, 7 after Ad26.COV2.S vaccine, and one of unknown brand.
One hundred seven infant conditions were reported which included 12 neonatal deaths (Table S2). Medical records noting the cause of death were available for three reports which included prematurity. One of these reports has been described before [14] . Thirty-three reports described a major birth defect or chromosomal abnormality. Eighteen and fifteen infants with birth defects were reported for BNT162b2 and mRNA-1273 vaccines, respectively. In 16 reports the vaccine was administered during the first trimester. Supplementary table S3 shows the specific birth defects by brand of COVID-19 vaccine.
Disproportionality analysis of COVID-19 vaccines did not reveal an elevated EB05 (>2) for any MedDRA PTs among pregnancy reports reported to VAERS.
Using published [25] vaccination coverage data for COVID-19 vaccines, we estimated that the crude reporting rate of stillbirths is 17.3 reports per 100,000 stillbirths and live births, for preterm deliveries 21.4 reports per 100,000 live births, for maternal deaths 2.3 per 100,000 live births, and for neonatal deaths 3.4 per 100,000 live births (Table S4). All crude reporting rates were below published background rates for these conditions [28] , [29] , [30] .
Material
VAERS is a national passive vaccine safety surveillance system, implemented in 1990 and co-administered by the CDC and the FDA that receives spontaneous reports of adverse events (AEs) from healthcare providers, vaccine recipients, manufacturers, and other reporters following vaccination [16] . Vaccine manufacturers are required, by law, to report AEs that come to their attention, and healthcare providers are required to report AEs that are considered a contraindication to further doses of vaccine and those specified in the VAERS table of reportable events following vaccination [16] . VAERS data are monitored in real time to detect new, unusual, or rare vaccine AEs as well as increases in known AEs.
Signs and symptoms of AEs reported to VAERS are coded by trained personnel and entered into a database using the Medical Dictionary for Regulatory Activities (MedDRA), a clinically validated, internationally standardized medical terminology [17] . A VAERS report may be assigned one or more MedDRA preferred terms (PT). A PT is a distinct descriptor for a symptom, sign, disease, diagnosis, therapeutic indication, investigation, surgical, or medical procedure, or medical, social, or family history characteristic [17] . Reports are further classified as serious as per the U.S. Code of Federal Regulations if one of the following is reported: death, life-threatening illness, hospitalization or prolongation of hospitalization, permanent disability, or a congenital anomaly [18] . Methods used to analyze and categorize pregnancy reports in VAERS have been described previously [19] .
We identified U.S. reports of pregnant persons who received COVID-19 vaccine and who reported an AE to VAERS by using a pregnancy-status question in the VAERS form, specific MedDRA codes, and a text-string search of the symptom field in the VAERS form. Medical records were requested for all serious reports. Physicians (PM, CO) manually reviewed all VAERS reports to distinguish pregnancy from non-pregnancy reports. Obstetricians reviewed medical records of case-reports containing more specialized pregnancy information (CO, EC). Reports indicating that COVID-19 vaccination was administered prior to the last menstrual period or during the post-partum period were excluded. When more than one AE was reported for the same person, we selected what we believed was the primary clinical event of concern after medical review. If the report described an AE in the pregnant person and their fetus or infant, we considered this a single report but treated AEs as separate. AEs were classified as pregnancy-specific (e.g., spontaneous abortion, stillbirth), non-pregnancy specific (e.g., local or systemic reaction), infant or neonatal (e.g., birth defect), or as certain pre-specified conditions of special interest (e.g., anaphylaxis, SARS-CoV-2 infection after COVID-19 vaccination).
We calculated frequencies of the most common MedDRA coding terms, demographic and selected pregnancy and fetal outcomes, and reporting rates for selected outcomes using SAS version 9.3 (SAS Institute, Cary, NC).
We used empirical Bayesian (EB) data mining to identify AEs that were reported more frequently than expected following COVID-19 vaccines compared to other vaccines in VAERS. We also identified COVID-19 vaccine-adverse event combinations that were reported more frequently than expected among pregnant women aged 16–54 years [20] . We conducted the analyses using the Multi-Item Gamma Poisson Shrinker (MGPS) algorithm [20] , [21] in Oracle’s Empirica™ Signal System. The main statistical scores computed were EBGM, EB05, EB95, representing the empirical Bayes geometric mean and the 90% confidence interval. We used published criteria to identify AEs that were reported at least twice as frequently as would be expected following a COVID-19 vaccine (i.e., lower bound of the 90% confidence interval surrounding the EB geometric mean [EB05] > 2) [21] .
We used national vital statistics data on monthly live births and fetal deaths to calculate rates. To account for the study period of interest, we applied a proportion of 0.58 to December birth and fetal death values as vaccines were only available for a portion of December. To estimate the number of live births, we used national provisional counts by month for 2020 and 2021 [22] . We estimate 3,173,387 live births occurred in the United States during our study period. Fetal death microdata from 2019 was used to determine monthly fetal deaths [23] . Consistent with National Center for Health Statistic methods [24] we included fetal deaths of 20 weeks’ gestation or more as determined by obstetric estimate, among women 15–44 years, excluding foreign residents, for December 2020 through October 2021. Approximately 18,945 stillbirths occurred during the study period. We then applied COVID-19 vaccination coverage rates for women receiving vaccination during pregnancy by month. A vaccination coverage of 2.6% was applied to monthly live births and stillbirths for December 2020, January 2021, and February 2021 as only cumulative data were available [25] . Based on weekly vaccination coverage data available for April through October 2021, a monthly average was applied to live births and stillbirths occurring these months providing the number of live births and stillbirths that occurred where a COVID-19 vaccine may have been received during pregnancy [25] . The rate of stillbirths was calculated monthly by dividing the number of stillbirths observed by the total number of stillbirths and live births that occurred where a vaccine may have been received during pregnancy. The rate of preterm births was calculated by dividing the number of preterm births observed by live births where a vaccine may have been received. Similarly, the maternal and infant mortality rate after COVID-19 vaccination was calculated by dividing the number of maternal or infant deaths observed by live birth. See supplementary material
Because VAERS is a routine public health surveillance program that does not meet the definition of research, it is not subject to Institutional Review Board review and informed consent requirements.