Mutations in an intracellular vestibule that bifurcates from the pore of ClC-1 chloride ion channels affect anion permeation

The ubiquitous CLC protein superfamily consists of channels, that permit passive diffusion of Cl ions across biological membranes, and pumps, that can actively transport Cl ions against their electrochemical gradient; yet, puzzlingly, both types share a strongly conserved Cl ion transport pathway comprised of three consecutive binding sites. This raises the question; how does the same pathway support passive diffusion in CLC channels and active transport in CLC pumps? Based on high-resolution structural data current theories suggest that subtle structural differences in the conserved pathway allow CLC channels to ‘leak’ Cl ions. A recent cryo-electron microscopy structure of the human ClC-1 channel does not show occupancy of the central Cl ion binding site but reveals a wide intracellular vestibule that bifurcates from the conserved pathway in this region. Here we show that replacing residues that line the ClC-1 intracellular vestibule with the corresponding residues of CLC pumps resulted in interactions between permeating anions at neighbouring binding sites and altered anion selectivity. Removing the side chain of a strictly conserved tyrosine residue, that coordinates Cl ion at the central binding site of CLC pumps, removed multi-ion behaviour in ClC-1 mutants. In contrast, removing the side chain of a highly conserved glutamate residue that transiently occupies Cl ion binding sites, as part of the transport mechanism of CLC pumps and the mechanism that opens and closes CLC channels, only partially removed multi-ion behaviour in ClC-1 mutants. Our findings show that structural differences between CLC channels and pumps, outside of the conserved Cl ion transport pathway, fundamentally affect anion permeation in ClC-1 channels. Summary Some CLC proteins are passive Cl - channels while others are active Cl - pumps but, paradoxically, both share a conserved, canonical, Cl - permeation pathway. Here Bennetts, Morton and Parker show that ‘pump-like’ mutations in a poorly conserved region, located remotely from the canonical pathway, affect anion permeation in human ClC-1 channels.