Conclusion
The BRI ST-IV F c ohor t enables nov el r es ear c h in t o the pr edict or s and
c ons eq uen c es of AR T c once p tion, with comparison t o a na t ur ally c onceiv ed cohor t, the
second g ener a tion of the A von L ongitudinal S t udy of Par ent s and Childr en ( ALSP AC-G2).
List of Abb r evia tions: ART : as s is t ed r epr oductiv e t echnology , IVF: in vitr o f e rtiliz ation, ICSI:
intr a cyt oplasmic s per m injection, BCRM: Bris t ol Centr e f o r Repr oductive M edicine, EDT A:
E thylenediaminet et r aacetic acid, ACD : ac id citr at e de x t r ose, BMI: Body ma s s inde x
Key wo rds : in v itr o f er tiliz a tion, as si st ed r epr oduc t iv e t ec hnolog ies, longitudinal s tudy ,
pr egnanc y out c omes
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
4
Backgr ound
Inf er tility , as de fined by t he W orld Health Or g aniza tion (WHO), is the inabilit y t o achieve
pr egnanc y a f t er 12 months or mor e of r egula r , unpr otect ed se xual int erc our s e. It af f ec t s
r ough ly one in s ix c ouples globally , w it h lif etime pr ev alence es tima t es r anging fr om 4% t o
40%, d e p ending on r egional and me tho dological v ar iat ions (1). Althou g h mos t pr ev alenc e
da t a come s from h igh inc ome co u n tries, es tima t es fr o m low- t o mid dle -inc ome c oun tries
sug ge s t t hat r a tes ar e c ompar able (1). Be y ond it s biologic al implica tions , inf er tility has
pr of ound ps y chologic al and s ocial e ff ects , oft en leading t o emo tional dis tr ess, ment al health
challenges, and r educed pr oductivity (2).
Ass i s t ed r epr od uc t ive t echnologies (AR T) ar e eff ectiv e m edic al int erve n tions f or tr eat ment
of inf e r tility . AR T r e f e r s t o all int erv e n tions tha t in c lude t he in vitr o handling of bot h human
oocyt es and sper m or embry os f or the purp ose of r eprodu c t ion (3) . The most c ommonly
used f orms of AR T ar e in -vit ro f ertiliza t ion (IVF) an d IVF with In t r ac y t oplas mic sperm
injection (ICSI) . Pla ns f or dev elopin g the BRIST-IVF c ohor t beg an pr ior t o int ern a tiona l
gl os s ar i es clar i f yi ng t er ms f or i nf er t ilit y an d i t s t r ea t m en t . WE ha ve r et ai ned t he s t udy name
(BRI S T- IVF) and us e ART as a g ener al t erm f or IVF and ICSI in this paper .
Glo bally , AR T h a s r e sult ed in the b ir th of o ver 8 million individua ls, wit h the number of A R T
cy cle s c on tinuing t o rise in high inc o me c oun tr ies , wit h incr easin g u se in low- a n d middle-
inc ome c oun tries (4) . Iden tifying modifiable risk f a c t or s tha t inf lu enc e live birt h succes s and
of f spring a n d pa r ent al hea lth p os t concept io n is es sen tial f or impr o v ing tr ea tment e ff ic acy .
His t orically , r es ear c h o n f a c t or s as so c i a t ed wit h AR T out c omes has f o c u s ed on clinic a l f act or s
tha t ar e r outinely collect ed dur ing IVF tr eat me n t including ma t er na l ag e, r epr od uc t ive
his t ory a n d type of IVF tr ea tmen t (5, 6). However, incr ea sing evidence s ugge st s that ART
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
5
outcome s ar e als o in fluenced by mater nal and pa t ernal h ealth and lifestyle chara cteristic s .
For example, s t udies have demonstr a t ed that bot h ma tern a l and paternal s mo k ing are
asso ciated with r educed liv e birth rates following A R T (7, 8) and that o v erweigh t or o b es it y
in bot h th e fe ma le and ma le par tners is a sso ciated with r educed lik elihood of succes s in IV F
tr eatmen t ( 9, 10).
Higher body mass in dex ( BMI) ma y influence s uc ce ss of I VF treat me nt via met abolic
alterations t hat affect b oth oocyte and sperm q ualit y . In w o men, metabolic pro files in blood
have been shown to ass o ciate w it h the c o mposit ion o f the follic ular fluid ( FF ) , the
microenviro nm ent surr ounding th e matur in g ooc yt e (11). Stud ies in bot h animals and
humans have s ho w n that FF meta bo lit es ar e assoc iat ed wit h oocyte quality and with
pregnanc y ou tcome following ART (12, 13). Similarly, in males , metabolit e prof iles in both
serum and s emin al fluid have been s hown to r elate to male in fertility (14, 15).
Advancements in h igh t hroughput n uc lear magnet ic resonance (N MR) spec t ros c o p y now
allow prof iling o f over 200 c ir c ulat in g metabolites in blood s er um or pla sma ( 16). As s e s sin g
pre- tr eat men t and/ or in treat m ent metabolite prof iles may help ide nt ify biomar k er s
pred ictive of IVF s u c ce ss and un cover pot ential pathways for int ervention. A recent study of
400 w o men and their male par tners undergoing IV F tr eatment in Glasgo w, UK, identified
sev er al novel associations between s erum metabo lites and markers of ova r ian reserve and
sperm parameter s (17, 18) . Thes e f indings highlight the need for f urther r eplic at ion and
pros pective studies t o es t ablish met ab olic pr edic t ors of s ucce ss.
As liv e-birth suc ce ss r at es f ollowing AR T c on tinue t o impr ov e, gr eat er at t ention has been
placed on pot en tial per inat al and lo ng-t er m health ou t comes of AR T-c o nceived off spring.
Man y s tudies e xamining t hes e out comes ha v e been desc r iptiv e, f ocus ing e x clu s iv ely on A R T-
c onceiv ed individuals without c o mpar is on gr ou p s or u sing select ive pee r- bas ed
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
6
c omparisons. R e cen t r esults fr om a lar g e c ollabor at ion of b irth c ohor ts , wher e A R T and
na tur ally-c onceiv ed individuals wer e f ollowed -up ide n t ic ally f r om p regnanc y t o ear ly
adultho od f o und lit tle evidence tha t AR T c onc ep tion a f f ec t ed bo d y c omposition or
c ar diomet abo l ic health u p t o early adulth ood (19). These findings wer e further s uppo rt ed in
a lar g e U K elec t r onic health r ec or d s tu dy in whi ch bo th c on v en tional po pula tion a n aly ses ,
and w it hin sibling analy s es, w hich c on tr ols f or f amily level c onf ounding , s uc h a s par ent a l
inf ertility , f ound no a ssocia tion bet ween A R T concept ion and h o s pit al a d mis sion s f or
cir cula t ory dis ease s (20). Elec t r onic health r ec or d s tudies ha v e also be en used t o e xplor e
e ff ects of AR T c onception on perina t al ou t comes . R ec en t analyse s i nco rpor a t in g both
c on v en tio nal po pu la tion a n d with in siblin g c omparison s, support a caus al ef f ec t of fr esh-
embr yo A R T t r ans f er c ompa r ed t o na t ur al con c ept ion on an incr ea sed risk of small f or
g est at ional ag e, while fr o z en embry o tr ansf er incr eas ed the r i s k of la r g e f or ges t a tion a l a g e
c ompar ed t o natur al c onception. Bo th fr esh and fr o zen embry o tr a n sf er in c r ea sed th e risk of
pr et erm birth (21) . W h ile bir th c oho rt and electr on ic health rec or d st udie s p r ovide v a luable
insight s int o tr ea tm ent-r e la ted dif f er ences (e.g ., IVF vs. ICSI, f r esh v s . f r oz en embr yo
tr ansf er ), t hey c annot ev alua t e m or e det ailed tr e a tmen t v ariables , su c h a s ov arian
s timula tion pr ot oc ols . Furt hermo r e , elec t r onic healt h r ec or d st udies c annot e xplore
pot en tial molecular mechanisms un der lying AR T-r e la t ed out c omes . The BRIST-IVF co hort,
with its det ailed me t abolic and clinica l da t a, is well-positioned t o addr ess t hes e g a ps .
The Br is t ol IVF Stu d y ( BRIS T-IVF) wa s d es igned t o es t ablish a clinic al AR T co hort t o under t ak e
r esear ch o n th e pr ed ict io n and cau s es of live birt h succ e s s, pr egnan c y c omplic a tions and
perinat al out c omes. The initial r ec r uitmen t t ar g et wa s 1,20 0 coup le s or single women. This
was amende d as a r e sult of the COVID pandemic (det ails below )
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
7
The initial objectiv es (pr oposed in 2019) wer e t o :
1. Impr ove t he ac cur acy of pr edic t ion of live bi r th suc c es s with ART;
2. Identif y modifiable risk fa c t ors and mechanis m s that might be t ar gets for dev eloping
inter v entions (lif es t yle or c linical) that could improve rates of liv e bir th suc c es s;
3. Det ermin e the as so ciat ions of ART and different ART tr eat men t proto c ols o n fet al
epigenetic s ignal s ( s pecifically cor d-blood DN A Methylation and potentially his t one marks);
4. Det ermin e th e impac t o f ART and different A R T t reatment prot ocols on cardio-
metabo lic risk factor s (and their tr a jec t ories) in mot he rs, and part ners dur ing t he f i r s t 5
years after t reatmen t;
5. Det ermin e the impac t of ART and different AR T tr eatment p r otocols on maternal,
part ner and o ff s pr ing mental health.
Du e t o t he Covid-19 p ande mic, BRIST-IVF was clos ed f or a period o f 13 mon ths. It became
clear f ollowing the closur e, and t he e f f ect of the fir st clinic vis it s f or tr ea tment being online,
r a ther than in per s on onc e the A RT clinic r eopened, tha t it wa s unlik ely tha t t he initia l
r ecruit ment t ar g et would be met. As a r esult, t he st udy wa s c losed earlier than p lann ed as
part of the NIHR r esear ch and r ec over y r eset pr ogr amme (22). The spe c i fic imp a ct s of the
pandemic on s tudy oper a t io ns ar e su mmar ised in Bo x 1.
The objec t ives h av e been r ev ised t o r e flec t t he numb er of par ticipan ts r ecru it ed and the
dur a t ion o f f ollow-up and we will no w f oc u s on two br oad objectiv es :
1. To investigate deter minan ts of live bir th ra t es f ollowing ART. This will includ e
tr eatmen t f ac t ors (e.g. p rotocols) a nd biologic al measure s (e. g. N MR metabolite
measures).
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
8
2. To compar e pregnanc y and p e r inatal out c omes between ART pregnancies a n d non-
ART pr egnancies usin g the Avon Longitudinal Stud y of Parents and Childr en (ALSPAC)
G2 c oh ort ( 23) a s a comp aris o n group, and e xplor e the extent to which any of t hes e
differences ar e mediated by N MR met a b olites , plac ent al tis s ue D NA methy lat ion or
tr ans cript omic data.
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
9
Metho ds
Stud y R ec r uitme nt
W omen and their p a r tner s wer e r e cr uit ed fr om the Br ist ol C en tr e f or R eprodu c t ive Medic ine
(BCR M), wit h r ecruit men t occurr in g in two phase s due t o t he C O VID- 19 p andemic. The fir st
phase of r ec r uitment a t BCR M r an from 3 rd Sept embe r 2019 t o 27 th Mar ch 2020. The stud y
r eopen ed on 1 April 2021 and c onclu ded on 30 th June 2023.
T o be el igible t o t ak e part in t he s tu dy , par ticip a n t s had t o be a g ed 18 o r ov er and t o be
under g o in g or planning t o und e r go IVF or ICSI t r ea tment . T r ea tmen t cou ld in volv e use of
own or dono r g amet es ( eg gs or sper m) . Wher e t rea tm en t was undert ak en wit h a p a r tn er ,
both the woma n and th eir part ne r wer e requir ed to enr o ll t oget her t o pr ov ide con s en t f or
ac c es s t o BCRM medical no t es . Only pa tie n ts who had c onsen t ed t o r es ear ch c on t act via th e
Hu man Fer tiliza t ion and Embry ology Aut hority (HFE A) c onsen t t o disclo s ur e f orm wer e
eligible f or pa rt ic ipation ( cd-f orm-v10-16-oct ober-2019.pd f (hf ea.gov .uk )
) .
P art ic ipan t s wer e r ecruit ed prior t o e gg c ollection or fr o z en embry o tr an sf er as part of AR T
t r eat ment or f ol l owi ng a sc an a t 7 w e eks g est at i on c onf i rmi ng a vi abl e pr egnanc y . B ef or e t he
C OVID- 19 pandemic, r ecruit men t f ollowed a f ace-t o-f ace model, wher e pat ients r eceiv ed an
invit ation let t er and par t ic ipant inf or mat ion s heet by post bef or e their clinic v isit and pr ior t o
c ommencing dr ug pr ot oco ls. A r e s ear ch midwif e or nur s e obt ained wr it t en inf o rme d
c ons ent in per son.
P os t-pandemic, due t o r educed in -per son c linic v i sits , t he r ec r uitment pr oc es s shift ed t o
r emot e c onsen t. P a tients wer e con t act ed v ia email and t eleph one t o d iscuss stud y
part ic ipa t io n, and up t o two f ollow-up c alls wer e made by the r es ear ch t eam. P ar tic ipan t s
c ompl et ed onl i ne c onsen t f or ms i n con sul t a t io n wit h a r esear ch mi dwi f e or nu r se. A s par t of
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
10
enr ollme n t, pa r ticipants als o pr ovide d c onsent f or N HS medic al r ec or d link age t o f a cilita te
da t a c ollec t ion on pr egnancy and birth o ut c omes .
Quest ionnair e
P art ic ipan t s c omplet ed a bas eline ques tionnair e on pape r (pr e -C ov id) or o n line (post -Covid )
a t th e poin t o f recruitment. The ques tionnair e a sk ed about employmen t, e duc a tion, cur r ent
use of medication s , own and f amily his t ory of c ar diov as cular dis ease , smokin g , alcoho l us e
and phy s ic al ac t iv it y . A c opy of the quest ionnair e is pr ovided in t he Supple ment a r y mat e rial.
Baseline st udy m easur em en ts
Between Sept ember 2019 a n d Mar ch 2020 , s tud y measur es wer e c omplet ed a t the p oint of
r ecruit ment. F ollowing t he Apr il 20 21 r eopening , an appoin tment wa s made during the
c ons en t call f or the r esear ch t eam t o collect s tudy measur e s. A t th es e vis it s , par tic ipan t s had
heigh t, weigh t and bloo d pr es sur e measur ed and blood and u rine s amples t ak en . Saliv a
samples wer e sough t wher e part ic ip an t s wer e not able t o or d id no t wan t t o give a bloo d
sample. Wher e it was not p o ssible t o con duc t a s tud y vi s it, heigh t , weigh t and blood
pr essur e wer e obt ained fr om BCRM n ot es or self-r eported by t he participant.
Dat a c o l lect i o n fr om BC RM medical not es
F or each f e male und er going tr eatmen t, inf o rma tion on r epr oductiv e his t o r y inc luding
pr evious pr egnancie s and birt hs, p r evious f ertilit y tr e a tme n ts, dur a t ion and c aus e s of
inf ertility , antr al f ollicle c ount and ant i mulle rian hormone (AMH) lev el wa s pr ovided by the
part ic ipan t s and/o r ext r act ed f r o m their BC RM med ic al not es by t he r es ear c h midwiv es .
Inf or ma tion o n IVF or ICSI t r eatmen ts was e xtr ac t ed fr o m BCR M medic al r e c or ds , cov ering
both ongoing and prior tr eatmen t c y cles (f or those r ec r uit ed aft er t heir 7 - wee k sc an). Th e
e xtr act ed dat a in c luded tr e a tmen t type, dr ug r egimens, tr ea t me n t pr otoc ols, f ollic ulogr ams,
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
11
number of eg g s c ollect ed, sperm par amet er s , embry ologic al da t a and tr e a tment out co mes
(pr eg n ancy and bir th). T r ea t me n t infor ma tion was co llect ed f or part ic ipant s u p un til the 31 st
Mar c h 2024. Collection of inf orma tion on birt h ou t c omes f r om these tr ea t m en ts is st ill
ongoing.
Pr egn ancy f o l lo w u p
If participan ts became pr egnan t f ollowing AR T and h a d a v iable pr egnanc y c onfir med by
ultr as ound a t 7 week s g est a tion, t hey and t heir par tner s we r e in v it ed t o participa t e in th e
pr egnanc y f o llow up s tud y . In vit a tio ns wer e initia lly sen t by p ost but tr ansitioned t o email
f ollowing the C OVID-19 pandemic . Pr eg n a n t women wer e ask ed t o c omplet e an ear ly
pr egnanc y ques tionnair e (be f o r e 18 weeks g e st a tion), a lat e p r egnanc y q uest ionnair e (aft e r
28 week s g es t a tion) and a bir th ques tionnair e ( a r ound 2 week s aft er the b i r th of t he ir baby).
P art ner s wer e sen t one q uest io nnaire dur ing their partne r ’ s pr egnanc y a nd a ques tionnair e
aft er t h e bir th o f th e ir baby . Quest io nnair es c ollec t ed in f orma tion on p r egnanc y health,
subst a n c e u s e, f eelings and emotion s, pla n s and e xpect a tions f o r lab o ur a n d par e n thood
and birt h e x pe r iences . All pr e gna nc y and birt h quest ionna ir es ar e a vailab le in supplement a r y
ma t e r ial.
Pr egnan t women and their p a r tner s wer e als o in vit ed t o at t end a clinic at the U niv er sity of
Br is t ol du ring pr egnancy . A t th es e clinics, participan ts had a n thr opometry and blood
pr essur e mea sur ed a n d under t ook ph y sic al c apability and c ognitiv e t es ts. P art ic ipan t s wer e
a s k e d t o c o m pl e t e a n o nl i n e d i e t d i ary f o r 5 d a y s f o l l o w i n g t h e c l i n i c a n d t o w e a r an a ct i v i t y
monit or . At the clinic, participan ts ha d blood samples t ak en and pr egnan t women pr o v ided a
urine s amp le. Sa liv a samples wer e r eq uest ed wher e it wa s no t pos sible t o pr ovide a b lood
sample. Due t o C OVID-19 r estr ic t io ns, v ir tual vis its wer e imp leme n t ed f or a subset of
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
12
part ic ipan t s , during which an equip men t pack wa s p r ovided which enabled collection of a
subs et of the measur es fr om t he f ac e- t o -f ace clinic .
A t birth, cor d blood and plac en t a s amples, and measur emen ts of th e ba bies wer e co llect ed
wher e women d eliv er ed at pa r tic ipat ing hospit als (Univer s ity Hospit als Bris t ol and Wes t on
NHS F ounda tion T rus t (St Michael’ s), North Brist ol N HS T rust ( S outhmead Hos pit al) a nd Roy al
Unit ed Hos pit a ls B at h NHS Fou nda tion T ru st. W her e pos s ible, v ir tual pos t birth visits wer e
c onduct ed 7- 15 da y s aft er the birth of the baby t o c ollect ant hr opome tric inf o rma tion f or
both t he m other and baby .
All pr egnancy clinics , birth sample c ollec t ions and pos t bir th f ollow-up visit s wer e car ried out
by A von Longitudinal Study of Par ents and Childr en (ALSP AC) fieldwork er s us ing identic a l
pr ot oc ols as the ALSP AC second g ener a tion pregnanc y clin ics (2 3). Thi s harmoniz a tion allows
f or dir ec t comparis o ns between pr egnan c ie s c onceiv ed v ia AR T and n a tur ally c onceived
pr egnancies in f utur e analy se s .
Biological s am ples
Biologic al samples we r e co llect ed a t thr ee k ey ph as e s: baseline, d uring pr e gnanc y and a t the
time of bir th (Figur e 3) . At baseline , no n-f ast ing blood, u rine and saliva samples wer e
c ollec t ed f rom particip a n t s . Blood samples wer e c ollect ed in E th ylenediaminet et r aac et ic
acid (EDT A) tubes, cen trif ug ed with in 24 hour s t o s epar at e plas ma and whit e blo od cells (a
sour ce of DN A) and st ored at -80
o C wit hin 2 hour s of pr ocessing. Pla s ma w as st or ed in200µl
and 500µl aliquot s , while whit e bloo d c ells wer e st or ed in 1ml aliquot s . In it ial p r oces sin g f or
mos t s amples t ook place a t th e BC R M o r Univer sity of Br ist ol labor at ories a t Southmead
Hos pit al. All samples hav e sinc e been t r ans f erred f or long t er m st or ag e at Bris t ol Bio r es our c e
Labor a t ories (BB L ) .
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
13
F or an initial set of par ticipants, we also c ollec t ed a blood sample in acid c itr a t e de xtr os e
(ACD) t ubes f or the cr ea t ion o f immort a liz ed cell lines . Howev er , t his c ollec t ion was
discon t inued in Nov ember 2 021 due t o uncert a in ties r eg ar ding pr oces s ing f easibili t y during
the C OVID-19 pandemic.
A t th e pr egnanc y clinic , non-f a s ting blo od and ur ine sa mples wer e collect ed fr o m pr egnan t
women, while pa rt ner s wer e as k ed t o pr ov ide f asting blo od s amp les w h e r e possible. F or
these pr egnan cy clinic samples , cho les t er ol and gluc os e lev els wer e obt ained using P TS
panels® on a C ar dioChek® P A, and ha emoglobin le v els mea sur ed u s ing a H emo Cue® Hb 201+
s y s t em, within 90 min u t es of obt aining t he sample. Following th ese t e st s, EDT A plas ma ,
heparin plas ma, s er um and w h it e blood c ell samples wer e aliquo t ed out aft er ce n tr ifuging
and s t or ed a t - 80
o C.
Cor d blood EDT A b lo od samples and placen t as wer e collect ed a t particip a ting ho s pit als a t
the birt h o f the babies and wer e cou rier ed to t he Univer sit y of Br is t ol f or pr oces sin g and
s t or ag e. Be f o r e p la cen t a s wer e pr oc e s s ed p hot ogr aphs and measur em en t s wer e t ak en.
Placen t as wer e p r ocessed t o ma xim ise futur e us e by s t or in g small pieces i n a v ariety of wa y s
including , snap f r ee z ing , fixing in f ormalin and in R N A la t er s o lu tion. Placen t al membr ane
and c or d slice s wer e also st o r ed. Cor d blood was c en t rifug ed and s epar a t ed in to EDT A
plasma (aliq uot ed int o 200u l and 500u l) a n d w h it e blood cells, which wer e st or ed a t -80
O C
Us e of b iologic al samples
A t o t al o f 823 plasma samples wer e c ollect ed, co mprising 372 woman a t baselin e, 307
part ner s a t baseline, 57 woman dur ing pr egnan cy , 28 p artner s dur ing p r e gn a n cy and 59
of f spring co r d bloo d. T o dat e, N MR met abolit e q uantific a tion h a s b ee n c omplet ed on 200
samples t a k en at bas eline in the women and 167 t ak en a t b aseline fr om part ner s. Wit h the
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
14
c ompletion o f bio -sample collectio n ( s ee Figur e 1 f o r final numb er s ) , N MR met abolit e
quan tifica tion f o r all baseline sample s fr om wo man and part ner is schedul ed f o r c ompletion
in lat e 2025. Thes e da t a will be used t o in v est iga t e r es ear c h ques tions outlined in the
Planned Analy ses se ction, with comparis o ns ma d e t o the AL SP AC -G 2 c oho r t, which includes
equiv alent NMR met abo lit e a ssessme n ts during pr egnancy and in c or d blood.
The pr ot oc ol used in this s tud y f or pr eparing a n d st oring pla cen t al tiss u e i s iden t ical t o that
use in ALSP AC-G2 . We ar e curr en tly (Apr il 2025) pr ep a ring all 70 BRIST-IVF placen t a samples
and 70 ag e m a t ched ALSP A C-G2 placen t al s amp les f or of tr ans crip t omic and DNA
meth yla tion analyse s t o e xplor e diff e r en c es in t he s e biologic al mea sur es bet ween AR T and
na tur al c onception s .
Wit h fu tur e funding , additiona l analy se s a r e planned, inc lud in g s er um p r ot eomic analy se s
on baseline woman and part ner seru m s amples and mas s spe ctr ometry met abolit e pr o f iling
of baseline a nd pr egnancy urine sa m ples in women and the ir partner .
Dat a manag emen t
Dat a have been collected and stor ed using the Res ear c h Ele ctr onic Dat a Captur e (REDCAP)
software a nd wor kflow technolog y hosted at the U niversity of Bristol (24) . Res ear c h data i s
stored in a s epar ate filestore from p ersonal data and o nly t hree r es ear c her s hav e acce ss to
personal identifier s .
P a tien t in volvemen t
A pa tien t advis or y gr oup of people w ho h a d o r were under going IVF tr ea tmen t was set up in
early 2019 t o advise on the r elev ance , ac cept ability of s tudy pr oc e s s e s and document a t ion.
E thical appr oval
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
15
E thics a p pr ov al f or t he st ud y wa s obt ained f r om th e U K Na tional Healt h Ser vic e Sou th We s t-
Fr encha y R es ear ch E th ic s Commit t ee (IRAS pr o jec t ID 236773, Initial appr o val 10/7/ 201 9) .
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
16
R esults
Char ac t erist ic s of t he r ecrui t ed s am ple
Figur e 2 shows the f lo w of p articipan ts fr om initial s cr eening thr ough in vit a tion t o
re c r u i tm e n t .
Prior t o th e C OVID-19 pandemic , 2 1 3 cou ples or sin gle wo men wer e scr eened, while 2,225
wer e scr eened f ollowing r e sumpt ion of AR T s erv ice s. O f these 2,3 38 c oupl es / s in gle women,
1,214 met the s tudy ’ s eligibilit y crit eria, w it h 5 02 (4 1% ) suc c es sf ully r ecr uit ed. The f ina l
c ohort co mprises 5 02 women and 4 6 5 p a r tner s (4 45 women with a male p artner (89%), 20
women with a f emale par tne r (4%) and 37 women under going tr ea t ment wit hout a
part ner(7%)) . S ince r ecru it me n t one s ingle woman has with dr awn her c ons en t.
Char a ct er istics of t he r ec r uit ed wo men and t heir part ner s ar e shown in T ables 1 and 2.
Wher e same-se x co uple s wer e unde r g o in g r ecipr oc al IVF /IC SI, f or da t a c ollection p urposes
we c onsid er ed t he woman who wo uld c arry t he embr y o as the woma n under going
tr eatment. W omen under g o in g t r e atmen t had a mean ag e of 35.8 y ear s (SD = 4.4) a t
r ecruit ment and a mean BMI of 25.1 (SD = 4.4). The majority (92%) wer e of whit e et hnicity .
A t the time of r ecruit me n t, 251 women (50%) had ne v er been p r egnan t, a n d 374 (75%) had
not had a pr ev ious liv e birt h. Their p artner s had a mean ag e of 37.6 y ear s (SD = 5.8) and a
mean BMI of 26.8 (SD = 4.3), with 94% ident ifying as whit e.
T r ea tm en t cy c les and pr eg n an c y ou t c o mes
Amo ng the 501 c ouples and s ingle w omen who wer e s ucce s s fully r e cruit ed and r emained in
the s tudy , 12 (2%) wer e enr o lled following a c onfir m ed viable p r egnanc y a t a 7 - wee k
gest at ional s c an.
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
17
F or this s tudy , we de f ined a tr ea tmen t cy cle as an eg g co llection with or w it hout a fr es h
embr yo tr ansf er or a fr o z en embry o tr ans f er . Be t ween r ec r uitme n t and Mar ch 2024 , 490
women unde r went a t o t al o f 1,05 5 ART c y cle s . F ollow up time in the s tudy f or the 11 wome n
who wer e r ecruit ed but did n ot und er go an y r elev an t cy c les r ang ed fr om 1 1-23 mon t hs . Of
the 1,0 55 AR T cy cles, 1 25 wer e IVF (in 69 o f these the woman had a fresh embry o t r ans f er),
429 wer e ICSI (in 273 of these the wo man had a fr es h embry o tr ansf er ) an d 501 wer e fr o zen
embr yo t r ans f er s (s ee Figur e 3).
Of the 843 embry o tr ansf er s , 458 ( 54 %) r esult ed in a p ositiv e p r egnancy t es t, 378 (45%) in a
neg a tiv e pr egnancy t est and 7 out c omes wer e unkno wn. O f the 45 8 pr egnancie s, 96 wer e
biochemic al or end ed in a m is c arr iage pr ior t o the 7 -week s c an. T r ea tmen t inf or m a tio n
r eport ed in t his paper is t ak en fr om a da t a download on 15 Augus t 2024. R epor t ed numbe r s
ma y c h a n ge wher e t her e ar e up d at es t o clinic r ec or ds.
Pr egn ancy que s tio nnair es and cl in ic
F ollowing a pos it ive 7-week sc an c o nfirming a v iable p r egnancy , 305 wo men and , wher e
appr o priat e, t heir par tner s wer e in vit ed to par ticipat e in t he p r egnancy f ollow up st udy . O f
these 305 , 1 9 had t wo pr egnan cies r e sulting in a t o t al of 324 pr egnancie s o ver the c our se of
the st udy (see Figur e 4). In vit at ions wer e not iss u ed f or 38 p r egnancies due to clos ur e of
clinics f or t he Covid-19 pandem ic, lack of c onsent f or pr egnancy f ollow up, or the s tudy t eam
not be ing not ified o f the pr egnanc y .
Amo ng the 324 pr egnan c ies, part ic ipa t io n in pr egnancy f ollow-up wa s a s f ollows: 246 (76%)
pr egnancies r eturned a t least one pr egnanc y quest io nnair e, 23 3 pr eg n a n c ie s ha s a
c omplet ed bir t h quest io nnair e, 117 wome n (f or 119 pr egnan cies ) and 39 partn e r s
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
18
part ic ipa t ed in pr egnancy c linics a t the Univ er sit y of Bris tol and 70 placen t as and 58 c or d
blood samples wer e d onat ed.
Pr egn ancy and b i r th ou t come s
Da t a collection on p r egnancy out c omes f ollowing tr e a tme n ts is ongoing. We ar e co llecting
da t a f or all pr egnancies of st udy par tic ipan t s fr om BCR M me dical no t es. This inf o rma tion
includes pr egnancy out c ome (miscar riag e, st illbir th, ter min a tion of pr egna ncy , liv ebirt h ), se x
and birt h we ight of the baby .
Additionally , pr egnancy and b ir th ou t c omes ar e being r etriev ed fr o m o bst et ric r ec or ds f or
women who ha v e c onsen t ed t o ac ces s t o their NHS medical r ecor ds and ha ve giv en bir th at
loc al participa t ing hospit als. The s e NHS r ecor ds inc lude a nt ena t a l measures (height, weight,
blood pr es sur e, haemoglo bin), ho spit al admis sion s, diagno s es during p r eg nancy ( ges t a tional
hypert ens ion, pr e- ec lampsia , g e s t a tional diabet es), det ails of labour (how labour st art ed,
mode of d eliv e r y ) , child measur emen ts , APGAR s c or e and an y con g enit al ano malies
diagnosed a t bir th. W e an ticipa t e that we will have NHS c linic al dat a f or a ppr o xima tely 200
pr egnancies , a nd tha t these da t a will be av ailable f o r r es ear ch use b y the end of 2025.
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
19
D i sc u s si o n
Str ength s and Limit a tion s
BRIST-IVF i s a la r g e c linic al c ohor t of women and t h eir partner s under going ART , with
e xt ensiv e d e mogr aphic, lif es tyle, biologic a l s amp les and tr ea t m en t-r e la t ed inf or mation
a v a ilab le. W e h av e als o be en a ble t o f ollow u p the pr egnancies and bir ths via
ques tionnair es, c linic s and medical r ec or d link age. Impor t antly , pr egnancy da t a collection
f ollowed the same pr ot oc ols as the ALSP AC G2 (2 3), allowing f or d ir ec t comparisons
between A R T p r egnancies and na tur a lly c onceived p r egnancies .
Our s tudy c ohort c losely mirr o r s t he U K popula tion unde r going IVF tr ea t m en t, bo t h in t er ms
of a v er ag e ag e and f a mily t ype. In 2 0 21, t he a ver age a g e o f I VF pa tien t s in the UK wa s 36.0
y ear s , and 89% of women under going IVF had a male part n er , 4% had a f e male partner , an d
6% had no part ner(25) . The BRIST-IVF c ohort ha s a higher pr oportion of pa r t icipant s of whit e
ethnicity (92 % ) compar ed t o the UK a ver ag e f or IVF t r eatme n t in 2 020-2 1 (77%)(26).
Ho wev er , t his pr oport ion aligns wit h the et hnic compos it ion of t he South W e st r egion (9 3%
of r esidents ar e o f whit e e t hnicit y)(27).
Despit e these s tr eng t h s , limit a tion s in clude t he modes t r espon s e, with o nly 41 % of
women/ cou ples scr eened agr eeing t o p articipa t e. One imp ort ant r eas on f or the limit ed
r esear ch part ic ipa t io n wa s t he high p r op ortion of patient s ( 38% ) who did not co ns en t t o be
c on t act ed f or r esear ch when c ompleting t he HFE A f orm prior t o beginning tr eatme n t a t the
BCRM. This pr oport io n is s imilar t o findings fr om a s tudy c onduct ed a t a f ertility c en t r e in
nor thern England bet ween 2010 and 2019, wher e 47% of pa tien t s de clined t o pr ovid e
c ons ent f or c ont act r es ear ch (28) .
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
20
Whils t we ha ve near c omp let e dat a fr om baselin e qu es tionnair es and t r e a tmen t d a t a f r o m
BCRM medic al r ec or ds, only 76% of women in v it ed c on tribu t ed t o t he pregnanc y f ollow up
s tudy b y answering a quest ionnair e or a tt ending c linic. Howev e r , obst etric da t a will be
a v a ilable f or all wom en who consen t ed t o NHS medical r ec or d abst r action and deliv ered
within loc al partic ipa ting h os pit a ls. Add it ionally , bloo d and urine samples wer e f or the mos t
part t ak en aft er women had st art ed tr ea tment pr o t oc ols meaning th at biologic al meas ur es
e.g. met abolit es may be influenced by dru g s t ak en a s par t of t he I VF p r oc es s. However ,
det ailed inf or mation on t rea tm en t and drug pr o t oc ols ha s been collec t ed, allowing f or
appr o priat e adjus tment in analy ses .
Planned a n alyses
The BRIST-IV F s tudy will lev er age its ext ens iv e dat aset t o inv es tigat e s ev er al k ey r es ear c h
ques tions r ela t ed t o ART , met abo lic pr ofiling , and perina t al ou t come s. Spec ifically , we aim t o
addr ess the f ollowing:
1.
D o d i f f e r e n t A R T p r o t o c o l s i n f l u e n c e m e t a bo l i c p r o f i l e s ? T r e a t m e n t c o m p a r i s o n s t o
include:
a. Us e of IVF v s ICSI
b. Transfer o f frozen vs Fresh embr yo
2. Do metabo lic pr ofiles in fluence liv e birth s ucce ss and perinatal ou tcome s (small for
ges t ational age, la r ge for gestational age, pret erm bir t h)?
3. Do metabolic pr ofiles influence pregnanc y complications (mis carriage, h y per tensiv e
disorder s of pr egnancy, ge stational diabetes)?
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
21
4. Dep e n ding on the results fr om 1 to 3 a bov e we will explor e whe th e r v ar iat ion in
metabo lic pr ofiles in th os e u ndergoing ART mediate as soc iat ions between diff erent
ART appr oaches and pr egnan cy or p erinatal ou tcomes
5. Do metabo lic profiles differ be twe en p regnancies con ceived by ART and t hos e
conceiv ed nat urally?
6. Ar e the re differences in plac ent al t is sue DNA met hyla t ion and gene express ion
between AR T a n d natura lly conceived pr egnanc ies ?
7. Ar e t here differen c es in placental pa t hology bet ween bet w een AR T an d natur ally
conceiv ed pr egnan c ies?
T o addr ess que st ions 5 t o 7, we will use da t a f r om the ALSP AC G 2 c ohort (23) as a
c omparison gr o up of n at ur ally c once i v ed pr egnancies. Given tha t B RIST-IVF par ticip a n t s
wer e f o llowed up us ing id en tic a l clinic p r ot oc ols, labor at ory pr ocedur es, and pla cen t a l
tiss u e analy se s , this w ill allow f o r direct and meaningful c ompar is ons bet ween A R T and
non-AR T pr egnancies .
Conclusions
The BRIST-IVF s tudy , with its c ompr ehens iv e me t abolic, clinical, and b iologic al dat a, is
uniquely positioned t o addr ess s ome o f the lim it a t ions of birt h c ohor t and elec t r onic health
r ec or d s tudies in AR T r esear ch. B y in t egr at ing det ailed t rea tmen t inf o rma tion with
biospecimen analy s i s and pr egnancy f ollow-up, t he B RIST-IVF st udy off er s a valuable
r esour ce f or adv an c ing our under s t anding of the pr e d ict o r s a n d co n sequences of AR T
c onception, wit h impor t an t implic a tions f or optimizing f e r tility trea t m ents and impr ov ing
AR T pr egnanc y out comes .
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
22
De c lar a t ions
E thics appr oval and con sen t t o participa t e
All part ic ipant s pr ovided inf ormed c o nsent t o part icipa t e in the s tudy . E thic s appr ov al f or the
s tudy wa s obt ain ed fr o m the UK N a tion al Healt h Service Sout h W est - Fr enc h ay R e s ear c h
E thics Commit t e e ( IRAS pr oject ID 236773, Initial appr ov al 10/ 7/20 19) .
Consen t f or pub li ca tio n
Not applicable
A vailabil ity of da t a and ma t e rials
We ar e k een t o work w it h c ollabor a tor s and welco me enquir ie s f r om resea r c h er s who ar e
in t e r est ed in the m easur es we ha ve c ollect ed and h av e ideas f or r es ear c h q uest io ns be y ond
those list ed abov e. In fut ure, r esear cher s will be able t o app ly t o use anon ymised s u b s et s of
the da t a f or appr ov ed r es ear ch ques tions.
Comp eting in t er est s
The author s declar e that they ha v e no competing inter es ts.
Funding
This s tud y was f unded by the Eur op e an R esear ch Council under t h e Eur opean Union’ s
Ho rizon 2020 r esear ch and innov a tion pr ogr am ( gr an t agr eemen ts No 10 102156 6) and the
NIHR Biomedic a l R es ear c h Cen tr e a t Univ er sity Hos pit als Br ist ol N HS F ounda tion T rus t and
the Unive r s ity of Bris t ol. The W ellc o me T rus t and UK Medic al R esear ch Co uncil fund the
ALSP AC G 2 co hort and the c lin ic f ac ilities that we r e us ed in participan t f ollow-up
(02215/2 / 13 /2). A. T a n d D .A.L ar e suppor t ed by t he UK Medic al R esear ch C ouncil
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
23
(MC_U U_00032 /05). The views e xpr e s sed in this public a tion ar e those of the auth o r(s) and
not n ec es s ar ily t hos e of an y of the funder s , t he N HS, o r the Departmen t of Healt h and Socia l
Car e. None of t he funder s influenced the s tudy desi g n or analyse s.
Au thor s ’ con tr ibutio ns
DAL , V A, A T , SN, KAR designed the s t udy . A T , TK and J P manag ed da t a c ollection. SP and AG
desig ned a nd manag ed the biologic a l sample pr oces s ing . A J and PW pr ovided s cientific input
dur in g da t a co llection. A T a n a ly sed t he da t a and A T and DAL dr aft ed the ma n us cript . All
autho r s c ommen t ed on a dr aft o f the manus cript.
Acknowledg em en ts
We a r e v ery gr a t e ful t o the f ollowin g people f or their help w it h d a t a c olle c t ion: the t eam of
r esear ch midwiv es and nu r s es (Alis on Kirby , Naomi Mallinson, Annie Deacon, Mic h elle
Magg s, Ashleigh Pr omnitz , S o phie W ic kham, Vict or ia Car ey) a t N or th B rist ol NHS T rus t who
r ecruit ed par ticipan ts f or this s tud y , t he s t af f a t the Bris t ol Cen tr e f or Reprodu c t ive Medic ine
who f a cilit a t ed th is r esear ch , t he r esear ch midwiv es a t N o rth Bris t ol NHS T r ust , Univer s it y
Ho s pit als Bris t ol NHS F ounda t io n T r us t and The R o y al U nit ed Hospit als B at h NHS F ounda tion
T rus t who collect ed bir th samples and t he Children of t he 90s fieldwork ers who c ondu ct ed
the pregnanc y c linic s . We would a lso lik e t o thank the member s of t he p at ien t adv isory
gr oup who pr ovided valuable adv ice a n d f eedbac k on s tudy pr o c es ses and documen t a tion.
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
24
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
Figure 1. Biological samples collected for BRIST-IVF
Icon made by Freepik/DinosoftLabs from www.flaticon.com
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
Figure 2. Flowchart of study recruitment
26
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
Figure 4. Overview of treatment cycles in IVF/ICSI
Ovarian s tim ula t ion ai m s to s t i m ula te f o lli cles t o pr oduce mul t ip le ma ture oocy tes to be
r etrie ved v ia fol lic u l ar aspiration. Matu re oo c y tes ar e fer tilis ed in vitr o via IVF or I CSI and
su c c es sful fert il isation r es ult s in t he f orm ation of embry os. Embry o s of sufficient quality can
be tr a n s fer red into th e u terus wit hout freezing (f resh embr y o tr ansfer) or may be frozen
and stored for fut u re use. Frozen embry os can then be t haw ed and tr ansfer red into th e
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
28
uter us (fr oz en embr y o tr ans f e r ). F or each o v ar ia n stimulation c y cle, t here may be b oth a
fr es h embryo t ransfer and multiple f rozen embr y o transfer s . C ouple s /individuals ma y
under go multip le ovarian stimulation c ycle s . Icon made
by Freepik/cube29/Ba c k wood s /Sma shicons from www.flaticon. com .
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
Figure 4. Flowchart of the pregnancy follow up to date
29
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
30
T able 1. Char act er ist ic s of th e wo me n r ecruit ed t o t he st udy ( N=501)*
Mea n
( SD ) /N (% )/ M e d i a n (IQ R)
Ag e Y ea r s 35.8 (4. 4)
E thnicity Whit e
Other et hnic it y
461 (92 % )
38 (8%)
BM I Kg /m 2 (N=477) 25.1 (4. 4)
Smoking Never s mo k er
Fo r m e r s m oke r
371 (74 % )
129 (26 % )
Alc ohol use be f o r e
tr yi n g t o conceiv e
Never
Mon t hly or les s
2-4 times a mon th
>once a week
46 (9%)
135 (27 % )
156 (3 1% )
161 (32 % )
Number of t imes per
w eek doing
moder a te t o vigor ous
ex e r c i s e
0
1-2
3-4
5+
100 (20 % )
249 (5 0% )
122 (24 % )
29 (6%)
Has a degr ee
Ye s
No
376 (7 5% )
125 (25 % )
Pr evious pr egnan cies 0
1
2
3 or mo r e
251 (5 0% )
135 (27 % )
54 (11%)
61 (12%)
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
31
Pr evious live births 0
1 or mo r e
374 (7 5% )
127 (25 % )
An ti M ulle rian
Ho rmon e (A M H )
pmol/L ( N =479) 14.1 (7. 1 , 26 .0)
*1/502 w om a n withd r ew f r o m the s tud y . Mis s ing da t a f or eth n ic it y (N =2), BM I (N=24),
Smoking ( N=1), Alc ohol (N= 3 ), Ex er c i s e (N =2) , AMH (N =22 )
T able 2. Char act er ist ic s of th e partn e r s ( N =465)
M ea n ( SD ) / N(% )/ M ed i an (IQR)
Ag e Y ea r s 37.6 (5.8)
Se x Male
Fe m a l e
445 (96%)
20 (4%)
E thnicity Whit e
Other et hnic it y
433 (94%)
30 (6%)
BM I Kg /m 2 (N=422) 26.8 (4.3)
Smoking Never
Fo r m e r
C u rre nt
293 (63%)
164 (35%)
7 (2%)
Alc ohol use be f o r e
tr yi n g t o conceiv e
Never
Mon t hly or les s
2-4 times a mon th
>once a week
44 (10%)
91 (20%)
145 (32%)
181 (39%)
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
32
Number of t imes per
w eek doing
moder a te t o vigor ous
ex e r c i s e
0
1-2
3-4
5+
68 (15%)
158 (34%)
135 (29%)
102 (22%)
Has a degr ee
Ye s
No
284 (61%)
180 (39%)
Mis s ing da t a f o r ethnicity (N=2), BM I ( N =43), Smo king ( N=1), Alc ohol (N=4), Ex er ci s e (N=2)
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
33
Box 1. The impact of the Covid-19 pandemic on the BRIST-IVF Study
BRIS T-I VF wa s s u spend ed f o r 13 mon th s betw e e n Mar ch 2020 an d A pr il 2021 due t o Cov i d 19
r e str ic tio ns and s t a ff redeploy me n t . A s a r e sult , the st u dy wa s unabl e t o me et it s the initial
r ec r uit me nt t a r ge t and wa s clo sed e arli er than pl ann ed a s pa rt of the NIHR R e sea r c h and R ec ove ry
Re s e t P ro g ra m m e .
Pla nne d da t a col lection w a s aff ec t ed i n t he f ollowing wa y s :
• During th e clos ure p eriod i t was no t po s sibl e to t r a ck t h e tr e atmen t outcom e s of a ll
rec r ui ted par ticipa n ts in r ea l time a nd in vi t e particip a nt s t o preg na ncy follow up.
Howe ver, we have s till b een a bl e to c olle c t informa tion on p r eg nanc y outco m e s fr om
BCRM me dica l not es a nd fr om ob ste tr ic note s wher e par t i cipan ts h av e co n s ent e d t o
ac ces s t o N HS medic al r ec or d s .
• Redu ction in t he numbe r of fac e - to -fac e consul tati on s at t he B CRM during and a ft er the
pan demic mean t tha t the c on s ent pr oce s s moved f rom fa c e- to -f ace t o t e le phone
app ointme nt s a nd that s t ud y mea s ure s v isit s we re no longe r c arr i e d out on the d a te o f
rec r uit m e nt. Thi s me ant th at :
- Bi ologic al sample s w er e mo st l y c ollec te d af ter tr e a t m en t pro t oc ol s had b e en in itia te d.
- F ewer stu dy me asure s vis it s were com pleted , and mo re study mea sure s w ere se lf -
repor ted o r info rmati on was col l ected f r om fe rtili t y cen tre no te s .
• Pregn a ncy clini cs move d from face - t o- fa c e to vir tual visi t s for seve ra l month s a ft er t h e
stu dy reope ne d mean i ng that a mor e lim ited se t of me asure s we re coll ect ed f or s ome
partic ipan t s.
• Coll ec tion o f blood sample s for the purp os e of ma king immortal c ell li ne s wa s sto ppe d a s it
w as uncle a r wheth er th e se c ould be p r oc es sed f o ll owin g Covi d.
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
34
R ef er ence s
1. Inf er til ity pr ev alenc e es timat es, 1990- 2021. Genev a: W orld H ealth Or g aniza tion ,
2023.
2. Cousineau TM , D omar AD . P sy chologi cal impact of inf e r til ity . Best Pr a ct R es C l in
Ob st et G ynaec ol. 200 7;21(2):2 93- 308 .
3. F aus er BC. T o war ds t he glob a l c ov er a g e of a unif ied r egis try of IV F ou t co m es . R epr od
Biomed Online. 2019;38(2) :133-7.
4. V a y ena E, P et er son HB , Ad a m s on D , Ny gr en K G. Assist ed r epr o duc t ive t ec hn ologi es in
dev eloping cou n tr ies: ar e w e car ing y et ? F ert ili ty and st er ili ty . 20 0 9;92(2):4 13- 6.
5. Nel son SM, La wlor D A . Pr edicting li v e b i r th ou t com es aft er in vi t r o f e r ti lis a ti o n. BJOG
: an in t e rn ational journa l of obs t et r ics and gynae c olog y . 20 12;11 9(1 3):166 8 ; author r ep ly -9.
6. T emplet on A, M orris JK, P ar s lo w W . F ac t or s tha t af f ect ou t com e of in-v itr o
f ertili sa tion t r e a tme n t . L ancet. 1996 ; 348(9039):1 402- 6.
7. W a ylen AL , Met wally M, J one s G L , Wi lki n s on AJ , L edg er W L. E f f ects o f c i g ar et t e
smokin g u pon cl inic al out c omes of assist ed r epr od uc t ion: a met a-analy s is. Hum R epr od
Upda t e. 2009;15(1) :31-44.
8. Fuen t es A, Mun o z A, B a r nhart K, A r guello B , Diaz M, P omm er R. R ecen t cig a r et t e
smokin g an d a s sis t ed r epr oductiv e t e chnologies out c ome. F ertility and s t er ility .
2010;93(1 ): 89-95.
9. Rit t enber g V , Ses hadr i S, Sun k ar a S K, Sobalev a S, Ot eng-Ntim E, El-T ouk h y T . E f f ect of
body mas s inde x on IVF tr ea tmen t out c ome: an updat ed s ys t ema t ic r e view and met a-
analy s i s. R epr od Biom ed O nline. 2011;23( 4):421-39.
10. Campbell JM , L ane M , O w ens J A, Bak os HW . P a t er nal ob es ity neg a tiv ely a f f ects m a le
f ertili ty and assist ed r epr oduct i o n outc omes: a s y st em at ic r ev iew and met a -analysis. R ep r od
Biomed Online. 2015;31(5) :593-604.
11. McRae C , Sharm a V , Fisher J . Met abolit e Pr ofi ling in th e P ur suit of Bioma r k er s f o r IVF
Out c ome: The Ca se f or Met abolomics Studies. In t J R epr od Med. 2013;2 01 3:60316 7.
12. W allace M , Cot t ell E, Gibney MJ , M c A uliff e FM, W ingf ie ld M , Br ennan L. An
in v est i g a tion i n t o the r elat i o ns hip betw een the me t abolic pr ofil e o f f oll ic ular fluid, oocy t e
dev elopme n t a l pot en t ial, and impla n ta tion out c ome. F ert ili ty and s t erility . 2012;97(5) : 1078-
84 e1-8.
13. Ler oy JL , V anholder T , Delanghe JR, O psomer G , V an S o om A, Bols PE, et al. Met abolic
chang e s in f ollicular fluid of t h e domi nan t f oll icle in high-yielding d a ir y cow s early post
part um. Theriog enol ogy . 2004; 62(6) : 1131-43.
14. Qia o S, W u W , Chen M , T an g Q , Xia Y , Jia W , et al. Seminal p l asma met abo l omic s
appr o a ch f or the diagnosis of une xplained male inf er t il ity . P l o S one. 201 7; 1 2(8):e018111 5.
15. Cour an t F , An t ignac J P , M on t eau F , Le Bizec B. M et abolomics a s a p ot en tial new
appr o a ch f or in ves tig a ting human r ep r oductiv e disor der s. J Pr ot eome Res. 2013;12(6): 2 914-
20.
16. W u rtz P , K an g a s AJ , Soininen P , L awlor D , D a vey Smith G, Ala-K or pela M. Quan tita ti v e
Serum Nuclear Magn et i c R esonan ce M et abolomics i n Lar g e-Sc ale Epidemi ology: A Prim e r on
-Omic T e chnolog y . Americ an journ a l of ep i d em iology . 2017 .
17. Al Rashid K, T a ylor A , L um s den M A, G o ulding N, L aw lor D A, Nels o n S M . As socia tion
of th e seru m me t abolom ic pr o file b y nuclear magnet ic r es onan ce spec t r o s copy with sperm
par amet er s: a cr o s s-s e ction a l s tudy o f 325 men . F S S ci . 2020; 1(2):142-60.
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint
35
18. Al Rashid K, T a ylor A , L um s den M A, G o ulding N, L aw lor D A, Nels o n S M . As socia tion
of th e functional ov arian r eser v e with serum met a b olom ic p r ofiling by nuclear magnetic
r esonance s pectr o s c op y: a cr o ss-se ctional st udy of ~ 400 wo men. BMC m edic ine.
2020;18(1 ): 247.
19. Elhak eem A, T a ylor A E, Inskip H M, Huang J Y , Man sell T , R odr igue s C, et al. L ong-t er m
c ar diomet abo l ic health in peop le born aft er a ssist ed r epr oductiv e t echnology: a multi- coho rt
analy s i s. Eur opean heart journal. 2023;44( 16):14 64-73.
20. Sut clif f e AG, Pur k a y as tha M , Brison D R, Nel s on SM , R obert s SA, Lawl o r D A . G ener al
health in a c ohor t of c h i ldr en c onc eived aft e r as sist ed r epr od uc t ive t ec hno l ogy in t he U nit ed
King dom: a popu l a t i on-based r ec or d- l ink ag e st ud y . A m J Ob st et G ynec ol. 20 23;228(1):8 2 e1-
e17.
21. W e s tvik-Johar i K, R omunds t ad LB , L awlor D A, B er gh C, G is s ler M , Henningsen AA, et
al. Separ a ting par ent a l and tr ea t men t con tributions t o per inat al heal th aft e r fr e sh and
fr o zen embr y o tr ans f er in ass i s t ed r ep r oduction: A c ohor t st udy wi t h within -sibs h i p analy sis.
PLoS medici n e . 202 1; 18(6):e100 3683.
22. NIHR R esear ch and R ec over y P r ogr am me [A va ilable fr om:
h t t ps ://w w w .nihr .ac.u k/ r esear cher s/m a n a ging- r es ear c h -r ec ov ery .h tm
.
23. Law lor D A, Lew co c k M , R ena-Jones L , R ollings C , Y i p V , Smit h D , et al. The s e c ond
g ener a tion of The A v o n L o ngi t udinal Study of P ar en t s and Ch i ldr en (ALSP AC-G2): a co hort
pr of il e. W ellcom e Open R es. 2019;4 :3 6.
24. Har ris P A , T a ylor R, Thielk e R, P a y n e J , G onz ale z N , Conde JG . R es ear ch elec tr on i c da t a
c aptur e (R EDCap)- -a met ad a t a-driven methodo l o g y and w or k f low p r ocess f or pr ovi d i n g
tr ans la tional r esear ch inf or ma t ics sup por t. J B iomed Inf orm. 2009;42( 2):37 7-81.
25. HFE A. F er t ility trea t m en t 2022: pr el i minary tr end s and figur es . 2024.
26. HFE A. P r eli minary U K et hnicity st a t istic s f or IVF and D I t r ea tmen t, st or ag e, and
dona tion . 2 023.
27. O N S. The ethnic gr oup s of u sual r esi d en ts and h ous eho l d et hnic c omp os ition in
England and W ales , Cen s u s 2021 da t a .; 2022.
28. Mor ris C, R ymell R, Mascar en ha s M, Bh a n dari H. E th n ic and demo gr aphic v aria tion in
c ons en t ing f or r esear ch in the c on t e xt of f e rti lity tr e a tme n t . Hum F ertil ( Ca mb).
2022;25(3 ): 575-82.
. CC-BY 4.0 International licenseIt is made available under a
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 25, 2025. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.24.25326332doi: medRxiv preprint