Rectifying AI-generated protein structure ensembles for equilibrium using physics-based computations

Abstract Recently, a number of tools have been released that generate ensembles of protein structures based on artificial intelligence (AI) approaches. Although ensembles generated by the tools differ significantly, we demonstrate a computational path to harmonizing the various outputs under a stationary condition using two complementary physics-based approaches. In the first stage, the AI ensemble is used to seed a weighted ensemble (WE) simulation, promoting relaxation toward the steady state. In the second stage, trajectory segments generated by WE are reweighted to steady state using the recently developed RiteWeight (RW) algorithm. We applied this approach to generate an atomically-detailed equilibrium ensemble of unliganded adenylate kinase conformations, starting from ensembles produced by three AI tools: AFSample2, ESMFlow-PDB (trained from PDB structures), and ESMFlow-MD (trained from molecular dynamics simulation data). Dramatic differences in the AI-generated ensembles are largely erased during the WE-RW process, yielding a consistent description of the equilibrium ensemble for a given force field. Competing Interest Statement The authors have declared no competing interest. Footnotes ↵** zuckermd{at}ohsu.edu