Results
Comparison of male cohorts
SNPs associated with bronchial asthma in the cohorts of men
Our analysis revealed four genetic variants in the introns of the TACR3,
ZNF257, FOXP1, and EGFR genes; their frequencies differ statistically
significantly (the p value being no higher than the significance level of
10 -4 ) in the cohorts of men with a verified diagnosis of BA and in
the cohort of apparently healthy men. These genetic variants are found
significantly more frequently in cohort 2A (more than fivefold)
( Table 1 ) than in cohort 4H.
The TACR3 gene that encodes tachykinin receptors and has an indirect effect on
the bronchial tone [15, 16] was found to carry the rs1461555098 deletion
(chr4:g.103629850_103629861del). According to our calculations, the relative
risk of developing BA in individuals carrying this deletion stands at 6.9,
while this parameter is normally equal to 1.0. The deletion rs1461555098
(chr4:g.103629850_103629861del) was detected in cohort 2A twice as frequently
as in cohort 4H.
The ZNF257 gene encoding the transcription factor (a zinc finger
motif-containing protein) was found to carry the genetic variant rs1199362453
(chr19:g.22076863T>C), which was encountered three times in cohort 2A but
was absent in cohort 4H.
The FOXP1 gene encoding the transcription factor and expressed in the proximal
airway epithelium [ 18 ] was found to
carry the genetic variant rs869106717 (chr3:g.71465326del), which was
encountered in cohort 2A 33.6 times more frequently than in cohort 4H. The
relative risk of developing BA in individuals carrying this mutation is 36.0.
In the EGFR gene that encodes the transmembrane receptor binding extracellular
ligands belonging to the epidermal growth factor group [ 19 ], the frequency of the genetic variant rs189649077
(chr7:g.55168296G>T) in cohort 2A was 143-fold higher compared to that in
cohort 4H. The relative risk of developing BA in individuals carrying this
mutation is 34.3.
Comparison of female cohorts
It was demonstrated that in the cohort of women with a confirmed diagnosis of
BA, five genetic variants were six times more frequent compared to the cohort
of apparently healthy women (the p value is no higher than the significance
level of 10-4). These genetic variants resided in the CYSLTR1, IL5RA, NRG1,
HDC, and DPP10 genes ( Table 2 ).
SNPs associated with bronchial asthma in the cohorts of women
The CYSLTR1 gene that encodes the protein affecting the secretion of
inflammatory mediators (leukotrienes) [ 16 , 20 ] was found to
carry the rs1923038536 (chrX:g.78306516G>A) variant, which was detected in
cohort 1A 45.8 times more frequently compared to cohort 3H. The relative risk
of developing BA in individuals carrying this mutation is 14.2.
T h e g e n e t i c va r i a n t r s 1 8 1 0 6 6 1 1 9 (chr3:g.3102851A>G)
was found in the IL5RA gene encoding the subunit of the heteromeric receptor of
interleukin 5, a cytokine that plays a crucial role in eosinophil
differentiation [ 21 ]; this variant
occurred in cohort 1A 36.6 times more frequently than in cohort 3H. The
relative risk of developing asthma in individuals carrying this mutation is
13.2.
T h e g e n e t i c va r i a n t r s 1 4 3 2 4 7 1 7 5 (chr8:g.32692193T>A)
was found in the NRG1 gene encoding mucin production by airway goblet cells
[ 22 ]; like the previous genetic variant,
it was found in cohort 1A 36.6 times more frequently than in cohort 3H. The
relative risk of developing BA in individuals carrying this mutation is also
13.2.
The HDC gene codes for the enzyme catalyzing histamine synthesis from
L-histidine [ 23 ]. The genetic variant
rs140597386 (chr15:g.50261726dup) was identified for this gene; it occurred in
cohort 1A 6.2 times more frequently than in cohort 3H. The relative risk of
developing BA in individuals carrying this mutation was 5.0.
T h e g e n e t i c va r i a n t r s 7 6 2 0 4 2 5 8 6 (chr2:g.115490670del)
was identified in the DPP10 gene encoding membrane-anchored serine protease
[ 16 ], which was found in cohort 1A 36.6
times more frequently than in cohort 3H. The relative risk of developing BA in
individuals carrying this mutation is 13.2.
T h e g e n e t i c v a r i a n t s r s 2 2 9 1 6 5 1 ( c h r 3 : g . 1 9 5 7 5
1 1 4 1 G > C ) a n d r s 1 2 1 9 2 4 4 9 8 6 (chr1:g.155189991T>C) of
the MUC1 and MUC4 genes occurred in women with asthma much less frequently than
in apparently healthy women. This means that the identified genetic variants
can be considered protective in individuals with BA [ 24 ]. The MUC1 and MUC4 genes encode mucins. The MUC1 gene is
responsible for the anti-inflammatory effect in patients with bronchial and
lung diseases. MUC4 exhibits a mediated effect on the proliferation of airway
epithelial cells [ 25 ]. The genetic
variant rs2291651 (chr3:g.195751141G>C) of the MUC4 gene in cohort 1A
occurred somewhat more rarely than in cohort 3H. The relative risk of
developing BA in individuals carrying this mutation is 0.5, while normally this
parameter is 1.0. This indicates that the risk of developing bronchial asthma
is down twofold in women carrying the genetic variant rs2291651. The relative
risk of developing BA in females carrying the genetic variant rs1219244986
(chr1:g.155189991T>C) is 0.2 (i.e., lower than 1), corresponding to the
fivefold reduction in the risk of developing the disease.
However, allowance should be made for the fact that the identified variants in
the MUC1 and MUC4 genes reside in GC-rich regions. This region negatively
affects sequencing quality and, therefore, the quality of the genetic variant
detection.
Discussion
We have analyzed the candidate genes potentially associated with BA. Eleven
polymorphisms whose frequency differs significantly in individuals diagnosed
with BA and those not diagnosed with the condition have been identified. Nine
of the identified genetic variants increase the risk of developing BA, while
two variants reduce it. These nine variants increase the risk of developing BA
at least fivefold. The identified variants are specific to the population of
Russia.
Arathimos et al. [ 26 ] reported that up
to 45% of females with bronchial asthma experience an aggravation of their
condition before their menstrual period. In 2020, the polymorphism rs2291651 in
the MUC4 gene was described to be an accompanying sign of endometriosis in
South Korean women [ 27 ]. The
relationship between the single nucleotide polymorphisms in the MUC1 and MUC4
genes and endometriosis risk was analyzed in this study. Screening identified
eight genetic variants of MUC4, including rs2291651, whose presence correlated
with the development of endometriosis. Women of childbearing age using oral
contraceptive pills tended to experience milder asthma attacks [ 28 ]. A number of studies [ 29 , 30 ]
also demonstrated that variations in the estradiol and progesterone levels
during the menstrual cycle affected the severity of bronchial asthma symptoms.
That means that when studying the genetic predisposition to a severe BA course
in women, one should pay particular attention to the genes associated with
female sex hormones.
In this study, we have analyzed 167 candidate genes associated with bronchial
asthma. These genes include HNMT, MS4A2, HRH1, HRH2, HRH3, HRH4, AOC1, and HDC,
which code for the histamine receptors that are involved in the regulation of
histamine release [ 16 , 23 , 31 ,
32 , 33 ].
The HDC gene encodes the enzyme histidine decarboxylase catalyzing histamine
formation from L-histidine; the HDC mRNA level is elevated in patients with
asthma [ 23 ];
the IL3, IL4, IL4R, IL5, IL9, IL13, IL17, IL21R, IL18, IL18R1, IL2RB, IL1RL1,
IL5RA, IL33, SCGB3A2, TNF, CCL11, IRAK3, CSF2, and TSLP genes encode the
cytokines involved in inflammation. Thus, IL5 stimulates eosinophil release
into the bloodstream, while IL5RA regulates their activity. Stimulation of the
airways with allergens increases the local IL5 concentration, which correlates
with the severity of airway eosinophilia, while IL4RA codes for the α
chain of the IL4 receptor, which can bind IL4 and IL13 to regulate the IgE
production [ 4 , 16 , 21 , 23 , 34 ,
35 , 36 , 37 , 38 , 39 ,
40 ];
the IL17F gene encodes the pro-inflammatory cytokine involved in
pathophysiological manifestations of asthma. In vivo and in vitro studies have
shown that IL17F is involved in the pathogenesis of allergic airway
inflammation [ 41 ];
the ADRB2 gene encodes the β2-adrenoceptors that play a crucial role in
airway contractility. β2-adrenoceptors act as a target for
β2-agonists exhibiting a marked bronchodilator and bronchoprotective
activity, which is important for assessing the effectiveness of BA therapy
[ 16 ];
the PLA2G7 gene encodes the platelet-activating factor acetylhydrolase. This
enzyme catalyzes the cleavage of PAF by hydrolyzing the acetyl group down to
biologically inactive products [ 31 ];
the ALOX5, CYSLTR1, CYSLTR2, and LTC4S genes encode the proteins that affect
the production of inflammatory mediators (leukotrienes), contributing to
various allergic and hypersensitivity reactions. It has been shown that altered
expression of some of these genes may cause bronchoconstriction of the airways
and hyperresponsiveness to bronchoconstricting agents such as histamine,
increased vascular permeability, edema, eosinophilia and neutrophilia, smooth
muscle cell proliferation, collagen deposition and fibrosis in different tissue
areas, mucin secretion by goblet cells, metaplasia of goblet cells, and
hypertrophic changes in the respiratory epithelium [ 16 , 20 , 42 ];
the PTGER2 and PTGDR genes encode prostaglandin receptors and are involved in
the pathogenesis of BA [ 16 , 43 ];
the TBX21 and TBX5 genes encode transcriptional activators; their expression is
downregulated in airway-resident T cells in asthma patients [ 16 , 44 ];
the STAT6 gene encodes the STAT family transcription factor; expression of this
gene is significantly upregulated in patients with severe BA [ 16 ];
the STAT3 gene encodes the STAT family transcription factor mediating the
cellular responses to interleukins and regulates the inflammatory response
[ 45 , 46 ];
the STAT4 gene encodes the STAT family transcription factor; expression of this
gene is downregulated in patients with BA [ 47 ];
the NPSR1 gene encodes the neuropeptide S receptor; the upregulated expression
of this gene in airway epithelium leads to the activation of matrix
metalloproteinases, which are involved in the pathogenesis of BA [ 16 , 48 ];
the TAC1, TACR2, TACR1, and TACR3 genes encode receptors for tachykinins, which
are found in sensory nerve endings, are activated by inflammatory mediators
(histamine, platelet-activating factor, and leukotrienes), and add the axon
reflex mechanism to the pathogenesis of asthma, thus leading to aggravation and
spread of the initial inflammation. Tachykinins affect the bronchial tone and
vascular permeability [ 16 ];
the CHI3L1 gene encodes the glycoprotein belonging to the glycoside hydrolase
family and contributes to the development of the Th2-type inflammatory response
[ 16 , 49 ];
the DENND1B gene encodes the protein interacting with tumor necrosis factor and
plays a crucial role in suppressing T-cell receptors on Th2 cells [ 50 , 51 ];
the ADAM33 gene codes for metalloprotease. ADAM33 is expressed by various types
of airway cells. ADAM33 expression is elevated in patients with BA; the
impaired function of this metalloprotease can be associated with bronchial
hyperresponsiveness and airway wall remodeling, thus contributing to early
manifestation of bronchial asthma [ 52 ];
the ORMDL1, ORMDL2, and ORMDL3 genes encode ORM-like proteins, the key
regulators of serine palmitoyltransferase, which catalyzes the first step of
sphingolipid biosynthesis. Sphingolipids play an important role in signal
transduction in response to stress and affect the mechanical properties of cell
membranes. Dysregulation of sphingolipid biosynthesis is associated with
several diseases, including allergies, inflammation, and asthma [ 53 , 54 ];
the VIP gene encodes the vasoactive intestinal peptide responsible for the
relaxation of smooth muscles [ 55 ];
the genes belonging to the NOS family encode nitric oxide synthases. Mutations
in the NOS1 gene reduce the nitric oxide concentration in non-eosinophilic
phenotype patients, which is a marker of bronchial asthma, and cause bronchial
hyperresponsiveness [ 56 , 57 , 58 ];
the ACE gene encodes angiotensin, which converts angiotensin I to the
vasoactive angiotensin II, and is involved in the pathogenesis of BA as it
causes proliferation and increases smooth muscle contractility, thus leading to
lung obstruction [ 59 ];
protein RAD50 encoded by the RAD50 gene is involved in double-strand DNA break
repair. It was shown in transgenic mice that the fragment of the
3’-terminus of this gene is the Th2 locus control region (LCR), which
regulates cytokine gene expression [ 60 ];
the PTAFR gene encodes the receptor for the platelet-activating factor, a
chemotactic phospholipid mediator exhibiting strong inflammatory, contractile,
and hypotensive activities with respect to smooth muscles. The PAF receptor is
involved in various pathological processes, such as allergies, asthma, septic
shock, arterial thrombosis, and inflammation [ 16 ];
the OPN3 gene encodes the G-protein-coupled receptor. Upregulated OPN3
expression was detected in bronchial epithelium and immune cells. Mutations in
the OPN3 gene increase the risk of bronchial asthma [ 20 , 61 ];
the GSDMB gene encodes the protein whose overexpression in bronchial epithelial
cells increases expression of the genes that are crucial for both airway
remodeling and airway hyperresponsiveness [ 16 , 62 ];
the PKN2 gene encodes serine/threonine-specific protein kinase and regulates
apical junction formation in human bronchial epithelium [ 63 ];
the PTK2 gene codes for tyrosine protein kinase and plays a crucial role in
airway hyperresponsiveness and airway remodeling [ 63 ];
the ALPP gene encodes the placental alkaline phosphatase catalyzing the
hydrolysis of phosphoric acid monoesters; the expression level of this gene is
associated with childhood asthma [ 63 ];
the PTEN gene encodes phosphatidylinositol-3,4,5- triphosphate-3-phosphatase
[ 20 ]. A low PTEN expression level is
considered to be among the independent factors of BA development [ 64 ];
the PRMT1 gene encodes an important epigenetic regulator, protein arginine
methyltransferase-1, which contributes to inflammation and airway remodeling in
patients with BA [ 65 ];
the HSPD1 gene encodes the heat shock protein that can modulate the immune and
inflammatory responses, be involved in pathogenesis, and/or be a risk factor or
a prognostic marker for several diseases, including BA [ 66 ];
the TLR2 and TLR4 genes encode proteins belonging to the Toll-like receptor
family, which are essential for pathogen recognition and activation of the
innate immune system. Some polymorphisms in these genes are associated with the
risk of developing BA [ 67 ];
the ZNF208, ZNF257, ZNF676, ZNF729, ZNF98, ZNF492, ZNF99, ZNF723, ZNF728,
ZNF730, and ZNF91 genes encode zinc finger proteins residing within the region
of the transcription factor cluster area and are associated with the
pathogenesis of BA [ 17 ];
the B4GALT1 gene encodes beta-1,4-galactosyltransferase and is associated with
the atopic phenotypes and inflammatory conditions [ 68 ];
the IGFBP3 gene codes for a protein binding insulin-like growth factor and
inhibits the specific physiological effects of asthma in an IGF-independent
manner [ 69 ];
genes belonging to the MUC family encode mucins. MUC7 codes for salivary mucin;
the frequency of the MUC7 allele with five tandem repeats is significantly
reduced in patients with asthma [ 20 ,
70 ]. During the late stages of bacterial
infection, MUC1 exhibits an anti-inflammatory activity in the airways, which is
initiated and mediated by inhibition of Toll-like receptor signaling [ 24 ]. Mucin MUC4 was identified as a
ligand-activating receptor tyrosine kinase, which modulates the proliferation
of airway epithelial cells in patients with asthma [ 25 ]; MUC19 is mainly expressed in the cells of submucous
glands in the trachea and salivary glands; in patients with allergic rhinitis
and chronic otitis media, this gene is expressed in the epithelium. MUC5AC is
expressed in the goblet cells of tracheal and bronchial epithelium. MUC5B is
also expressed in the submucosal epithelium and ducts and, to a lesser extent,
in the goblet cells of both tracheal and bronchiolar epithelium. Many
individuals with a confirmed diagnosis of bronchial asthma have elevated levels
of MUC5AC mRNA but reduced levels of MUC5B mRNA [ 71 ];
the NRG1 gene encodes the protein-inducing production of mucins MUC5AC and
MUC5B by human airway goblet cells, so its inhibition can be regarded as a
novel therapeutic approach to reducing mucus hypersecretion in patients with
respiratory diseases [ 22 ];
the DACT1, DACT2, and DACT3 genes code for the proteins involved in the
pathogenesis of BA. The tissue levels of DACT1, DACT2, and DACT3 mRNA are
significantly elevated in asthma patients [ 72 ];
the CYP genes encode the cytochrome proteins involved in the metabolism of many
drugs, including nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, oral anticoagulants and
angiotensin receptor blockers, as well as in the synthesis of cholesterol,
steroids, and other lipids [ 20 , 70 , 73 ,
74 , 75 , 76 , 77 ];
the CHML gene codes for Rab geranylgeranyltransferase regulating the
intracellular transport of membrane structures. Polymorphisms in this gene are
associated with the development of BA [ 61 ];
the GSTT2 and GSTP1 genes encode glutathione S-transferase theta 2 and
glutathione S-transferase P; polymorphisms in these genes may be risk factors
for BA [ 78 ];
the NAT2 gene codes for N-acetyltransferase 2; polymorphisms in this gene are
associated with the development of atopic asthma [ 79 ];
the PYHIN1 gene encodes the interferon-inducible HIN-200 protein, which is
involved in the production of proinflammatory cytokines in airway epithelial
cells [ 80 ];
the SMAD3 gene promoter is significantly hypermethylated in patients with BA
[ 81 ];
the PGAP3 gene encodes a glycosylphosphatidylinositol-specific phospholipase
predominantly residing in the Golgi apparatus. The PGAP3 and ORMDL3 proteins
can contribute to the development of BA [ 82 ];
the ERBB2 gene encodes the epidermal growth factor receptor tyrosine kinase.
The ERBB2 expression level in freshly isolated airway epithelium in asthma
patients is lower than that in healthy individuals [ 83 ];
the COL15A1 gene coding for the alpha chain of collagen type XV, a member of
the FACIT collagen family [ 16 ], is
involved in the metabolism of the drugs used to treat lung diseases [ 84 ];
the FOXP1 gene encodes the transcription factor belonging to the FOXO family,
which is expressed in the proximal airway epithelium of the lungs;
downregulated expression of FOXP1 inhibits early differentiation of secretory
cells [ 18 ];
the ACOT7 gene encodes a protein belonging to the acyl-coenzyme family; an
epigenome-wide association study revealed an association between the degree of
methylation and the development of bronchial asthma [ 85 ];
the MTHFR gene codes for the methyltetrahydrofolate reductase. Polymorphisms in
the MTHFR gene are associated with predisposition to bronchial asthma and
glucocorticoid responsiveness in humans [ 86 ];
the DICER1 gene encodes RNA helicase involved in cytokine production and signal
transduction in patients with BA [ 87 ];
the SERPINC1 gene encodes antithrombin III, which inhibits clotting factors;
variations in its level may induce thrombosis or pulmonary embolism [ 88 ];
the SYNM gene codes for an intermediate filament; there is a hypothesis that
the degree of methylation of this gene is associated with the development of BA
[ 89 ];
the GATA3 gene encodes a transcription factor belonging to the GATA family. The
GATA3 expression level in the airways is significantly increased in patients
with asthma. The increased GATA3 expression level correlates with changes in
IL5 expression and the development of bronchial hyperresponsiveness [ 90 ];
the FOXP3 gene encodes an activating transcription factor; the expression level
of this gene is downregulated in asthma patients [ 91 ];
the CCDC80, DAPK3, LOXL1, PROC, FUCA2, SP100, and ITCH genes encode proteins
associated with antigen presentation to T lymphocytes. The degree of
methylation of these genes was found to be increased in asthma patients [ 76 ];
the VDR gene codes for the vitamin D3 receptor. Genetic variants of the VDR
gene are often found in children with BA; their presence inversely correlates
with asthma severity [ 92 ];
the DPP10 gene encodes a membrane protein belonging to the serine protease
family. Mutations in this gene increase the risk of BA [ 16 , 93 ];
the genetic variants of the PHF11, SPP1, and PLAUR genes are associated with
elevated IgE levels [ 94 ];
the SLC22A5 gene encodes an organic cation transporter; its expression level in
the bronchial epithelium is reduced in asthma patients [ 95 ];
the EPHX1 gene codes for microsomal epoxide hydrolase. A high EPHX1 expression
level is associated with an increased risk of developing BA at any time in
one’s life [ 96 ];
the CTLA4 gene encodes one of the proteins from the immunoglobulin superfamily.
According to the meta-analysis data, some polymorphisms in this gene are risk
factors for developing BA [ 16 , 97 ];
the MMP9 gene encodes a matrix metalloprotease involved in local proteolysis of
the extracellular matrix, leukocyte migration, and airway remodeling [ 98 ];
the SOCS5 gene codes for a protein belonging to the family of cytokine
signaling inhibitors. The single-nucleotide polymorphisms identified in this
gene are associated with the development of BA [ 99 ];
the polymorphisms in the FCER2 gene encoding CD23 are associated with atopy,
higher risk of exacerbation in patients with asthma, and a high serum IgE level
[ 100 ];
the VEGFA gene encodes the heparin binding protein, one of the PDGF/VEGF growth
factors. An elevated expression level of this gene is detected in patients with
BA [ 101 ];
the ASB3 gene codes for the protein involved in smooth muscle cell
proliferation and muscle cell development. A genome-wide association study
revealed an association between polymorphisms in this gene and the development
of BA [ 102 ];
the CRISPLD2 gene encodes the secretory protein LCCL, which increases
glucocorticoid sensitivity and regulates the immune response [ 103 ];
according to a genome-wide association study, polymorphisms in the APOBEC3B,
APOBEC3C, and EDDM3B genes are associated with asthma exacerbations [ 104 ];
a whole-genome association study revealed an association between polymorphisms
in the BBS9 gene and the effectiveness of asthma treatment in children [ 105 ];
the PRKG1 gene encodes cGMP-dependent protein kinase, a key mediator of the
nitric oxide (NO)/cGMP signaling pathway, and contributes to smooth muscle
relaxation [ 16 ];
the DNAH5 gene codes for the dynein protein. The DNAH5 expression level in the
bronchial epithelium is reduced in asthma patients compared to that in the
control group [ 106 ];
the JAK1 and JAK2 genes encode the tyrosine kinases involved in the
inflammatory cytokine signaling pathways associated with a higher frequency of
asthma exacerbation and increased susceptibility to allergic sensitization and
environmental antigens [ 107 , 108 ];
the CHRNA1 and CHRNA3 genes code for nicotinic acetylcholine receptors.
Polymorphisms in these genes are considered to be genetic risk factors for
bronchial obstruction [ 109 ];
the TGF- β gene encodes a secreted ligand belonging to the
TGF-β protein superfamily. TGF-β isoforms play a role in the
regulation of airway inflammation and remodeling [ 110 ];
variants in the HHIP gene are associated with chronic obstructive pulmonary
disease [ 111 ];
the SOD3 gene encodes superoxide dismutase. The SOD3 expression level is
elevated in patients with BA, and some genetic variants of this gene affect the
distribution of extracellular superoxide dismutase in the lungs and reduce the
risk of manifesting BA symptoms [ 112 ];
the EGFR gene encodes a transmembrane receptor binding extracellular ligands
belonging to the epidermal growth factor group. Biopsy specimens from asthma
patients often contain regions of epithelial damage that are immunostained with
EGFR; an elevated EGFR expression level is also observed in the morphologically
intact epithelium of asthma patients [ 19 ];
the SLC11A1 gene codes for the divalent metal transporter protein carrying iron
and manganese. A number of studies have revealed an association between
polymorphisms in this gene and the development of lung diseases [ 113 ]; and
the ZPBP2 gene encodes a protein expressed in the bronchial glandular
epithelium. The degrees of methylation of this gene are different in healthy
individuals than they are in patients with BA [ 114 ].
Conclusions
The genetic variants of a number of genes identified in this study, which
increase and reduce the relative risk of developing BA, may facilitate early
diagnosis of bronchial asthma and accurate diagnosis-making in case of
ambiguity. In the long run, analysis of the samples collected from residents of
different regions will help assess the geographic distribution of the
risk-editing genetic variants and not only perform mapping of BA prevalence,
but also adequately allocate financial and material resources, as well as
qualified medical staff, across regions. Timely, including prenatal, detection
of individuals genetically predisposed to BA and accurate diagnosis-making will
improve the quality of medical care, reduce the rates of disability and death
due to bronchopulmonary events, and decrease the direct and indirect cost of
combatting bronchial asthma.
Experimental
Building the cohorts
The manifestation and course of BA is significantly different in men than it is
in women, which is largely due to the different contributions of reproductive
hormones to the pathogenesis of BA [ 7 ].
Therefore, our study participants were divided into cohorts according to such
factors as history of BA and sex.
The 7,303 study participants were allotted to four cohorts:
1A – women with a confirmed diagnosis of BA (mean age, 52 ± 10
years), n = 218;
2A – men with a confirmed diagnosis of BA (mean age, 41 ± 12 years),
n = 70;
3H – apparently healthy women without a history of BA or other diagnoses
with a similar clinical presentation (mean age, 52 ± 8 years), n = 4,015;
4H – apparently healthy men without a history of BA or other diagnoses
with a similar clinical presentation (mean age, 44 ± 6 years), n = 3,000.
An inclusion criterion for groups 1A and 2A was a history of bronchial asthma
in the anamnesis. Groups 3H and 4H contained visibly healthy men and women; the
exclusion criteria for these cohorts were medical records indicating that a
patient had a history of diseases whose symptoms were similar to manifestations
of BA, such as acute bronchitis, pulmonary emphysema, allergic rhinitis,
gastroesophageal reflux, tracheoesophageal fistula, congenital heart disease,
tracheomalacia and bronchomalacia, cystic fibrosis, primary ciliary dyskinesia,
bronchiectasis of other etiologies, tuberculosis, lung cancer, a vascular ring
anomaly, sarcoidosis, intrathoracic lymphadenopathy, bronchopulmonary
dysplasia, allergic bronchopulmonary aspergillosis, systemic anaphylaxis,
primary immunodeficiency, vocal cord dysfunction, psychogenic cough, and
affective respiratory paroxysms [ 8 ].
Biomaterial sampling and personal data of study participants
Samples from collections previously created by the Center for Strategic
Planning of FMBA of Russia were used in this study. In all cases, the data were
collected in full compliance with the procedural requirements: the following
respective data were included and verified for each donor: sex, age, region of
residence, nationality, past medical history, informed consent (signed by the
donor) for biomaterial sampling, handling, transportation, storage and personal
data use; proper procedures for sample (venous blood) collection, handling,
transportation, and storing was ensured, per the State Standard GOST
R53079 .4-2008.
All the specimens selected for the final study sample were checked to make sure
that the donor’s ID code and the information deciphered in that code were
unique. Furthermore, it was guaranteed that the biomaterial had no signs of
hemolysis or lipemia. The samples were transported under constant temperature
control.
Creating a candidate gene list
Over 150 genes associated with the development of BA have been reported thus
far. The following tentative gene groups are of special interest:
the atopy-related genes. These genes include IL4, IL5, IL13, IL4RA, CHI3L1,
RAD50, etc. and are responsible for the blood level of total and specific IgE,
as well as the development of allergic responses;
the genes related to bronchial hyperreactivity, including ADRB2, TNF, IL5, IL9,
NOS1, NPSR1, TAC1, TACR2, TACR1, TACR3, ADAM33, ACE, etc., being responsible
for bronchial hyperresponsiveness, which is tightly related to the blood IgE
level and inflammation;
the inflammation-related genes such as TNF, IL4, IL5, IL13, ORMDL3, SCGB3A2,
CCL11, IRAK3, CSF2, ALOX5, CYSLTR1, CYSLTR2, LTC4S, STAT3, STAT6, etc., being
responsible for the level of inflammatory mediators by their role in regulating
the immune response and behavior of inflammatory cells in body fluids [ 8 ].
A list comprising 167 candidate genes was created according to 107 references
to search for phenotype– genotype associations. The list of these genes,
with a brief description of the functions of the proteins encoded by them, is
provided in Discussion.
DNA isolation, construction of genomic libraries, and sequencing
DNA was isolated from whole blood samples using a MagAttract HMW DNA Kit
(Qiagen, Germany). The DNA isolation protocol was automated on the Tecan
Freedom EVO workstation (Tecan, Switzerland). The concentration and purity of
the isolated DNA were measured on a Tecan Infinite® F Nano Plus microplate
reader (Tecan, Switzerland).
The genomic libraries for sequencing were prepared using a Nextera DNA Flex kit
(Illumina, USA), in accordance with the manufacturer’s recommendations.
Each sample in the flow cell was labelled using indexes from the IDT-ILMN
Nextera DNA UD kit (Illumina, USA).
The concentrations of the genomic libraries were measured using a Tecan
Infinite® F Nano Plus spectrophotometer. The size of the genomic libraries
was determined on an Agilent TapeStation 4200 system using an Agilent DNA 1000
kit (Agilent, USA). The library pools consisting of 24 samples were combined on
a Tecan Freedom EVO robotic platform.
Genome-wide sequencing was performed on a NovaSeq 6000 sequencing system and a
S4 reagent kit (300 cycles) (Illumina, USA) for paired-end reads 2 × 150
bp.
Bioinformatic analysis of the whole-genome sequencing data
Demultiplication was performed at the first stage of the analysis of the
primary sequencing data. During this procedure, the initial reads of the
NovaSeq 6000 sequencing system was converted from the BCL format to the FASTQ
format using the Illumina bcl2fastq conversion software v2.20 [ 9 ]. The Illumina Sequencing Analysis Viewer
software v2.4.7 was employed to control the overall sequencing quality of the
entire cell [ 10 ]. The quality of
individual reads was controlled using the FastQC v0.11.9 bioinformatic tool
[ 11 ].
The final sample contained blood specimens that had undergone quality control
for such parameters as homogeneity of the nucleotide distribution in the reads
and GC composition.
Read alignment against a reference genome was performed at the second stage of
the bioinformatic analysis using the DRAGEN platform [ 12 ]. The GRCh38.d1.vd1 sequence was used as the reference
genome. Blood samples with average coverage over genome < ×30 were
excluded from the study.
The CrosscheckFingerprints software (Picard) [ 13 ] was used to check whether the sample contained any
duplicates. All duplicate specimens were excluded from the study.
Search for short genetic variations
The Strelka software was used to process VCF files and search for short genetic
variations (SNPs, indels up to 50 bp long) [ 14 ].
Finally, 380,564 short genetic variations were detected in 167 candidate genes
(7,303 samples); 253,628 of those were found more than once.
The procedure for searching for genetic variations whose frequency was
statistically significantly different in different cohorts was employed to
identify the polymorphisms associated with BA. The Fisher’s exact test
was used to determine the significance level of the differences.
The case with identical occurrence of the "zero" variant in all four cohorts
was assumed to be the null hypothesis. The significance level at which the null
hypothesis was rejected was set equal to 10-4. The calculations were performed
using the R programming language.
Introduction
Bronchial asthma (BA) is a chronic, recurrent disease whose pathogenesis is
associated with altered bronchial reactivity caused by both specific
immunological and nonspecific mechanisms. The major (essential) clinical sign
of BA involves choking episodes that result from bronchial spasm, mucus
hypersecretion, and edema of the bronchial mucosa
[ 1 ].
The WHO considers bronchial asthma to be among the most serious chronic,
non-communicable diseases. Most deaths due to BA occur in low- and
middle-income countries, which are characterized by insufficiently efficient
diagnosis and treatment capabilities for the disease, as well as the healthcare
system in general [ 2 ]. Up to 350 million
people worldwide currently have BA [ 1 ],
and this figure may increase to 450 million by 2025
[ 3 ].
According to official statistics, there are 1.3 million patients with BA in
Russia. This means that the prevalence of this disease in Russia is less than
1%, while the proportion of people with BA is less than 0.4% of all patients
with asthma worldwide. Meanwhile, the European Respiratory Society has
estimated the incidence of BA in a number of European countries at 5% among
adults and more than 7% among children. A trend towards growing rates of
disability and death due to BA is observed in many countries. Thus, the rate of
BA deaths in Great Britain has increased sevenfold over the past 20 years, and
two- to threefold, in North America. More than 5,000 people die due to BA in
the U.S. each year.
BA develops due to a number of factors, including the intensity of allergen
exposure, habitat destruction, overactive immune response, and individual
genetic features [ 3 ]. It has been
demonstrated that there is a 25% risk that a child whose parent suffers from
bronchial asthma also develop this disease. If both parents have asthma, the
risk increases to 50% [ 4 ]. Furthermore,
it has been proved that there exists an association between the increasing
incidence rate of BA and aggravated soil, air, and water contamination
[ 5 ].
In 2018, the direct expenses of the Russian healthcare system for BA treatment
amounted to ~ 8.5 billion rubles; two-thirds of this amount was spent on
hospital stays. Moreover, substantial funds are needed to cover temporary
disability leaves and disability payments
[ 6 ].
Early diagnosis and prevention of BA will make it possible
both to reduce these costs and the prevalence of bronchial asthma in Russia.
Text is read by the "Ask this paper" AI Q&A widget below.
Extraction quality varies by source — PMC NXML preserves structure
cleanly, OA-HTML may include some navigation residue, and OA-PDF can
have broken hyphenation. The publisher copy
(via DOI)
is the canonical version.