Resolving the oak tree of life: comparing RADseq and whole genome resequencing methods for oak phylogenetics

Abstract Forest trees pose numerous potential challenges to phylogenomic inference. Their large effective population sizes and relatively long generation times lead to deep allele coalescence and consequently incomplete lineage sorting (ILS), which biases inferences of divergence times toward older ages and introduces gene tree discordance. Deep phylogenetic divergences, reaching back into the Paleocene, introduce reference-mapping biases. Introgression—the movement of genes between lineages—may result in different phylogenies being inferred depending on which individuals are included in analysis, even if the plurality of the genome favors the divergence history unaffected by introgression. These factors influence phylogenetic inference across the Tree of Life but are particularly prevalent in forest trees. Oaks (Quercus) are notable for all three influences. In addition, our knowledge of the oak phylogeny is currently based strongly on restriction site associated DNA sequencing (RADseq) datasets published over the past decade, which may introduce additional sources of uncertainty. In this chapter, we analyze a 322-species RADseq dataset and genome resequencing data from across the genus to address sources of uncertainty in our understanding of the global oak phylogeny, which we hope will serve as a model for other research groups working on comparable woody plant groups. Competing Interest Statement The authors have declared no competing interest. Footnotes ahipp{at}mortonarb.org, kalthaus{at}mortonarb.org, efuller{at}mortonarb.org, mhahn{at}mortonarb.org, dlarson{at}ed.ac.uk, rmohn{at}mortonarb.org, baosheng.wang{at}scbg.ac.cn, pmanos{at}duke.edu