The impact of COVID passport mandates on the number of cases of and hospitalizations with COVID-19 in the UK: a difference-in-differences analysis

Summary Background Mandatory COVID-19 certification was introduced at different times in the four countries of the UK. We aimed to study the effect of this intervention on the incidence of cases and hospital admissions. Methods The main outcome was the weekly averaged incidence of COVID-19 confirmed cases and hospital admissions. We performed Negative Binomial Segmented Regression (NBSR) and Autoregressive Integrated Moving Average (ARIMA) analyses for the four countries (England, Northern Ireland, Scotland and Wales), and fitted Difference-in-Differences (DiD) models to compare the latter three to England, where COVID-19 certification was imposed the latest. Findings NBSR methods suggested COVID-19 certification led to a decrease in the incidence of cases in Northern Ireland, but not in hospitalizations. In Wales, they also caused a decrease in the incidence of cases but not in hospital admissions. In Scotland, we observed a decrease in both cases and admissions. ARIMA models confirmed these results. The DiD model showed that the intervention decreased the incidence of COVID compared to England in all countries except Wales, in October. Then, the incidence rate of cases already had a decreasing tendency, as well as in England, hence a particular impact of Covid Passport was less obvious. In Wales, the model coefficients were 2.2 (95% CI -6.24,10.70) for cases and -0.144 (95% CI -0.248, -0.039) for admissions in October and -7.75 (95% CI -13.1, -2.46) for cases and -0.169 (95% CI-0.308, -0.031) for admissions in November. In Northern Ireland, -10.1 (95% CI -18.4, -1.79) for cases and -0.269 (95% CI -0.385, -0.153) for admissions. In Scotland they were 7.91 (95% CI 4.46,11.4) for cases and -0.097 (95% CI - 0.219,0.024) for admissions. Interpretation The introduction of mandatory certificates decreased cases in all countries except in England. Differences on concomitant measures, on vaccination uptake or Omicron variant prevalence could explain this discrepancy.