Cost-effectiveness of gamete intrafallopian transfer in comparison with induction of ovulation with gonadotropins in the treatment of female infertility: a clinical trial

OBJECTIVE: To compare the cost-effectiveness of gamete intrafallopian transfer (GIFT) with that of conventional infertility treatment in couples with female infertility, excluding tubal factors. DESIGN: Patients were randomly divided in two groups: receiving GIFT or conventional infertility treatment. For a period of 2 years, GIFT was compared with conventional infertility treatment in couples with endometriosis, anovulation, idiopathic infertility, cervical mucus factor, female immunologic factor, or multifactorial causes of infertility in a randomized clinical trial. SETTING: The study was performed in the Unit for Human Reproduction, Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Faculty of Medicine, University of the Orange Free State, Bloemfontein, Republic of South Africa. PATIENTS: One hundred seventy-four successive couples with female infertility were selected for the study. All couples were from the higher socioeconomic bracket. INTERVENTIONS: One group received GIFT and the other received conventional infertility treatment consisting of induction of ovulation with gonadotropins followed by intrauterine artificial insemination or normal intercourse. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The results were stratified according to the specific cause of infertility. Outcome was measured by the success rate per treatment cycle, as well as the cost per pregnancy. RESULTS: Overall, GIFT proved to be successful in 26.7% of treatment cycles compared with 9.7% with conventional therapy. CONCLUSIONS: After careful analysis, the authors came to the conclusion that GIFT is more cost-effective than conventional infertility treatment in patients with endometriosis and anovulation. In patients with idiopathic infertility, immunologic infertility, a cervical mucus factor, and multifactorial infertility, induction of ovulation followed by intrauterine artificial insemination or normal intercourse proved to be more cost-effective.