Dynamic phenotypic heterogeneity generated by delayed genetic oscillations

ABSTRACT Eukaryotes and prokaryotes exploit the ability of genetically identical cells to exhibit different phenotypes in order to enhance their survival. However, the mechanisms by which cells transition from one phenotype to another remain unclear. Canonical models of this dynamic posit that molecular fluctuations provide the noise that drives the cell out of one stable state and into another. Stochastic processes generated by canonical models should, therefore, be good descriptors of phenotype dynamics and between-state transitions should become more likely at greater noise amplitude, for instance at higher extracellular temperatures. To test these predictions, we observed temporal expression dynamics of the promoter of a flagellum gene, fliC , in a microfluidic device using Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium and green fluorescent protein (GFP). Our observations show that while cells can exhibit multistable phenotypes, including stable fliC -OFF and fliC -ON states characterised by low and high GFP levels, respectively, between-state transitions can exhibit oscillatory dynamics whose return statistics do not conform to canonical theories. For example, here the fliC -ON state was more frequent following a temperature increase. To better understand our data we developed different dynamical frameworks to predict fliC expression data. We conclude that a stochastic dynamical system tailored to the genetic network of fliC is better suited to our data than prior theories where dynamical features, like oscillations and pulsing, are driven by inevitable delays in the post-translational regulation of fliC . Thus, while transcriptional noise promotes phenotypic heterogeneity, as we show here, regular features like oscillatory heterogeneity can result from delays that fundamental molecular processes impose upon a cell’s gene regulatory architecture.