Comparative Analysis of Molecular Identification and Wing Morphometrics of Forensically Important Blow Flies in China

Background: Correct species identification is the most crucial step in applying entomological evidence to estimate the postmortem interval (PMI) since death of decomposed corpses. Wing morphometrics have been proposed in species classification as an alternative method of traditional morphology and molecular approaches. However, so far, this method has not been applied to the identification of Chinese Calliphoridae and few studies compare the two identification methods. Methods: : We used landmark-based geometric morphometrics of wings to identify nine medically and forensically important blow fly species of China. 270 specimens representing nine species and eight genera were sampled, 18 landmarks on the right wing were measured and analyzed using canonical variates analysis and discriminant function analysis. Then, a cross-validation test was used to evaluate reliability of the method. Moreover, in order to further assess the validity of this method, molecular identification is used for comparative analysis. Eighty sequences of cytochrome c oxidase subunit I (COI) of Calliphoridae isolated from different countries were downloaded from Genbank, including the data previously submitted by our team. Results: : Different species and genera can be well separated through morphometric analysis with an overall classification accuracy of 80~100%, but discrimination between sexes was less effective. The results indicated that the discriminative efficiency of the two methods is almost identical. Conclusions: : Wing morphometrics can be used as a complementary method of molecular identification for the geographical location and gender identification of certain species as a simple and cheap method.