Vaccine-elicited and naturally elicited antibodies differ in their recognition of the HIV-1 fusion peptide

ABSTRACT Broadly neutralizing antibodies have been proposed as templates for HIV-vaccine design, but it has been unclear how similar vaccine-elicited antibodies are to their naturally elicited templates. To provide insight, here we compare the recognition of naturally elicited and vaccine-elicited antibodies targeting the HIV-1-fusion peptide, which comprises envelope (Env) residues 512-526, with the most common sequence being AVGIGAVFLGFLGAA. Naturally elicited antibodies bound peptides with negative-charge substitutions around residues 517-520 substantially better than the most common sequence, despite these substitutions rarely appearing in HIV; by contrast, vaccine-elicited antibodies were less tolerant of sequence variation, with no substitution of residues 512-516 showing increased binding. Molecular dynamics analysis and cryo-EM structure of the naturally elicited ACS202 antibody in complex with HIV-Env trimer with A517E suggested enhanced binding to result from electrostatic interactions with positively charged antibody residues. Overall, vaccine-elicited antibodies appeared to be more fully optimized to bind the most common fusion peptide sequence. HIGHLIGHTS Peptide substitution scan reveals naturally elicited antibodies against fusion peptide (FP) can bind select non-canonical FP sequences with high affinity. Peptide substitution scan data for FP antibodies correlates significantly with their differential selection indicating variation in binding relates to neutralization tolerance. Structure and energetic analysis of naturally elicited ACS202 with HIV-Env trimer reveals basis for improved recognition of A517E mutant. Atomic level interactions from MD simulation analysis corroborate trends observed with peptide substitutions. verall, peptide substitution scans reveal vaccine-elicited antibodies against FP to be less permissive to FP-sequence variability than naturally elicited antibodies.