Attentional propagation of conceptual information in the human brain

preprint OA: gold CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0
📄 Open PDF Full text JSON View at publisher

Abstract

The visual environment is complicated, and humans and other animals accordingly prioritise some sources of information over others through the deployment of spatial attention. We presume that attention has the ultimate purpose of guiding the abstraction of information from perceptual experience in the development of concepts and categories. However, neuroscientific investigation has focussed closely on identification of the systems and algorithms that support attentional control, or that instantiate the effect of attention on sensation and perception. Much less is known about how attention impacts the acquisition and activation of high-level information in the brain. Here, we use machine learning of EEG and concurrently-recorded EEG/MRI to temporally and anatomically characterise the neural network that abstracts from attended perceptual information to activate and construct semantic and conceptual representations. We find that the trial-wise amplitude of N2pc - an ERP component closely linked to selective attention - predicts the rapid emergence of information about semantic categories in EEG. Similar analysis of EEG/MRI shows that N2pc predicts MRI-derived category information in a network including VMPFC, posterior parietal cortex, and anterior insula. These brain areas appear critically involved in the attention-mediated translation of perceptual information to concepts, semantics, and action plans.
Full text 105,957 characters · extracted from oa-pdf · 4 sections · click to expand

Introduction

The v is u al env iro nment con ta in s m ore in forma tion th an w e are a ble t o ev alua te. To ac t adaptiv ely, we p r ioriti s e s ome inf ormati on s ourc e s o v er othe r s u s ing a se t o f mec hani sm s colle ctivel y re fer r e d to a s selective attention ( De simon e & Du nca n, 1995; Egeth & Ya n t i s , 1 997) . Ea r ly work charac te r i sed att entio n in no w-famou s met aphor s , s u g ges ting a s p otlig ht o r fil ter t ha t act s in re tinot opic s p ace t o enhanc e sen s ation a nd perc eption (Pos n er, S nyder , & Davids on, 19 80; Br oadbe nt , 1 958). Guid ed by the s e id ea s, neu ro scie n t i f i c inv e stig ation has foc u s s ed c lo s e ly on iden ti fica tio n of the sys t e m s a nd algorithm s th at impa ct se nsory cort ex (Maun sell , 2015; D e simon e & D unc an, 19 9 5; Rey nold s & H e eger , 200 9) and on cha rac t eriz a tion o f the brain n e t w ork s t h a t con trol t he se m ec hani sms (U ng erl eide r, 200 0; C o rbe tta , P a tel , & S h uman, 2 008; Hüer, S a xena , & Tr e ue , 202 4). The e me rgent model sugg e st s tha t stra tegi c selec t i on b egi ns w ith the de riv ation o f schem a s a nd templa te s fr om conc eptual a nd s emantic knowl edg e. Th es e are s tored in wo r k ing mem or y at f ro ntal brain si te s and tr a n s la ted t h r oug h t he f ron tal ey e field s and po s te rior pa rie ta l cor tex into bia s es of s e n s o ry activi t y (De s imo ne & Dunc an , 1 995; Mille r & C o h e n, 2001). .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint 4 Res earch o n the n europhy s i ology o f at t e nt i on ha s thu s focu s s ed clo se ly on how conc ept s and ca tegori e s are u s ed to g uide se ns atio n a nd percep tion. In contr a st, ou r unde rs t a nding of th e r e ver se infer enc e - of h ow att entio n sup por ts th e activ ation and con struc tion o f c oncep t s - i s r elative ly poo r. Tha t is, we k now that a t t entio n plays a k ey r ol e in in forma t i on gath ering and th e g enera tion a nd ac tivation o f high-l ev el k nowled ge (Go tt l i eb, Oud eye r , Lope s , & Ba rane s , 201 3; Bu zs ák i, 201 9 ). And , whi le ther e is d eb a te abo ut th e d egr ee t o w hich conc epts a r e grou nded i n s e n s o r imotor system s (Bar sa lou, 20 16) , we know that t he sema ntic r e pre sen tati on s tha t eme r g e in fr ont al a nd tempo ral co r tex ab strac t fr o m pe rceptu a l exp er i en ce ( F re edman, Ri e senhub er, Pog gio, & M iller, 2 001; Rig o tt i et al . , 2013, Fairha ll & C aramaz z a , 2013; A c unzo, Low , & Fai rha ll, 202 2) . We p re s u m e that a tt enti on se rves the pu rpo se o f ac tiva ting and c on s t ructing th e s e conc ep tual repr es ent atio ns t o sup por t po s t - perce p tual c ognitio n, but we k now l ittle of how t hi s un fol d s i n th e brain . To a ddre ss thi s, in the curre nt p aper w e i denti fy and c harac teri s e neu ral rep r e s en ta t io ns o f abs tr a c ted i n f o r ma t io n th at vary a s a fu n ction of the qual i ty of a tt entio na l s e lec ti on. This a pproac h has b ee n ado pte d i n earli er w ork. Fo r e xampl e, re s u l ts s how tha t the s em a ntic c a tegory of a vi s ua l st i mulu s i s enco de d in pa t te rn s of fMR I a c t i vity in ventral a nd do r s a l visu al cort ex (Hax by et a l. , 200 1; Jeong & Xu , 2016 ) a nd tha t th e se r epre se nt a t i on s v ary a s a func tion o f the i r beha vi our a l relev anc e , co ns i st ent with a n e ff ec t o f at t e n t i on (Se idl , Pe ele n & Kastne r, 2 012; Hic key & P e e len, 2 015; Barbar o, P e el en, & Hic key, 2018) . How ev er, thi s pa tt ern ha s la rge ly bee n id enti fie d in brain are a s that a re l ikely to enc ode vi s ua l f ea ture s , makin g it unc lear th at it r efl ec t s a n e f fec t on categ o r y informa tion rath er tha n on perc e ptio n of the v is ua l fe atu re s tha t happ en t o b e sh ared ac r oss ca tegory ex ample s ( Brac ci & Op de B e ec k, 2016; Wat son, H artl ey, & An drew s , 2 0 14; Ric e, Wa t son, Hartl ey, & And rew s, 20 14). To c ircumv en t thi s i s s ue, a s e p ara te r e s e a rch li ne ha s emplo yed mul t i - moda l stimul i tha t ac tivat e th e same con c ept - for exa mple, b y pre sen ting a n ima ge of an a ppl e a nd the w or d ‘a pple ’ . This h as id en t i fi e d ca t e gory informa tion in ar ea s tha t do no t car ry perc eptu al signal s , such a s an teri or t emporal a n d pr efron t a l co rtex (Rigo tti et al ., 2013; Bind er et al . , 2009; Fa irhall & Ca rama z za , 201 3; Acunzo , L ow, & Fa irh all, 2 022) . Howev er, the rol e o f a tt e n t i on in t he ac tivation o r c ons t ruc t i on o f the s e rep re s e n t a t i on s rema i ns uncl e ar . As a r e sult , the re ar e hol e s i n ou r unde rs t a nding o f t he n eural me ch ani s ms that s upport in for m a tion ga t he r i ng . We pr e sume th at in forma tion s el ecte d thro ugh t he d eploy ment o f a tte ntion a ctiva t e s or co nstruct s ne ural r epre s ent ation s o f co n cept s and c at egorie s , but w e hav e no t ve r ifi ed thi s, and w e do no t k now w here in the brai n thi s tak e s pla ce . A r e a ll s uch high-lev el repr e sen t ation s s en s i tiv e to att entio n, o r i s th e e f fe ct o f at tent ion l im ited to di scr et e brai n n etwork s? A nd what doe s t his me a n for ou r under s t a nding o f t h e func tiona li t y of the se area s? H e re, we u se no vel me tho dology and .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint Fi g ure 2 – Res ul ts fro m E EG. a.) E RP res ult s fr om Ex perim e n t 1. Th e N 2 pc is evi den t a s a neg a ti vit y in t he p ost erior wavef o r m record ed o v er cort ex c ontr a l at e ral to a n at te n d e d s ti mul us. Th e bl ue b ox ide n tifi e s a 1 2 5 ms in te r val c e n tere d o n t he cro ss -co ndit io nal pea k of t he N2pc . T he t o pogra p h ical p lo t ref l ect s th e vol ta g e diff ere nc e b e t w een co nditi o ns w hen th e tar g e t w a s i n t he l e ft ve rs u s rig ht v is ua l fi eld; t he N2 pc ex press es a s a ne g a ti vi ty i n t he le f t he m is p here bu t a p o s it iv i ty i n t he ri ght hemis p h ere du e t o t he s ubt ra c tion. Con tralatera l an d i psil a tera l E RP s r e fl ect me a n s ig na l acros s t he 2 s ets o f 3 lat e ral and po steri or electro des ide n tifi e d in th e to p og r ap h y b y la r ger m ar k er. b.) I ps ilateral- m i n us-co ntralat eral dif fe r ence w a ves fro m E xperi m e nt 1 . T h e N2 p c is e vi d ent as n e g a t iv e def l ect io n b e gin ni ng a ro un d 1 7 5 ms pos t-s ti mul us. Sha din g here a n d in o t her p a n e ls in di c a t es b o ots tra ppe d SE M. c.) T i m e-res olve d c l a ss i f ic a ti o n of th e tar ge t a nd dis tract or o bject c ate go r y in Ex peri m e nt 1 . A s t here were 4 c l ass e s , c h a nc e perfor ma nce w as 2 5% . d.) ERP re s u l ts fr o m E x pe ri me nt 2. T hes e reflect s ig nal at t he lat e ral pos t e ri or electr od es i den tified in w hit e i n t h e t opo gra phy pres en ted i n pa n el A . e. ) Ipsi la t eral- m i n us-co ntra la t eral di ffe r ence w a ve s fro m Ex peri men t 2 . f.) T i me -r e s o l v e d clas sificati on of t a r ge t a nd di s t r a c to r o bj e c t ca te go ry in E xpe r i m ent 2 . .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint 6 ana lys e s t o iden ti fy the e f fect o f a tten tio n o n informa tion a b out th e s e man tic cat ego r y of visu al st i muli . Our appro ac h relie s on i d enti fica tio n of tr i al -by -tri al c ovaria nce b e t w e en a wel l- ch aracte ri sed EEG i nd ex of spati a l at ten ti on – t he N 2 pc (L uck & Hilly ard, 1994 ) – a nd an inde pen den t mea s u re o f seman tic ca tego ry informa ti on derived u s in g mac hine l e arning o f ne uroimagi ng data . Ex periment 1 e mploy s hig h-d en s i t y EEG i n the iden tific ation o f thi s in form ation to a llow f o r p rec is e tempor al r e solu tion . Experime nt 2 empl oy s conc ur r ently -r ec o rded EE G a nd MRI to provi de pr eci se s p at i a l lo c a li z a t i on.

Results

Par tic ipant s in bo th ex perim ent s ( n = 44, n = 31 ) were a ske d to compl e te th e sam e ta sk w ithout movi ng their ey e s. Thi s inv olved r ep or tin g , via butt o n pr ess , the c a tegory o f a ta rg et obje ct (Fig 1a) that ap pe a red a t a cued loca tio n (Fig 1b ), whil e ign or in g a se t of n on- targ et s th at i nc luded v isually deg r a ded o bjec t s a nd a sing le r ecog niz a b le di strac tor . Objec ts we re sel ec ted from a s e t of image s that w ere visu ally hete rogen e ou s within ea ch c atego ry. Pa rticipa nts c omple ted th e t a s k quick ly (E 1: 1076 ms , 185 SD ; E2: 108 8 ms, 240 SD ) a nd ac curate ly (E1: 87 .6%, 1 0.6 S D ; E 2: 89.9% , 7.0 S D). In bo t h expe rime nts , w e mea sur ed the q u ality of a tten t i o nal proc e ssing u s ing th e N2pc c omponen t of th e v is u al ev ent -rel at ed pot enti al (ER P ; Lu ck & Hilly ard, 1994 ). The N2pc emerg es ov e r po s t erior co r tex contr ala te r a l to th e loc ati on of a n att ended ob jec t (L uck, G i rel li, Mc Dermo t t, & Fo rd, 199 7; Hick ey, Di Lollo, & Mc D o nald , 20 09). I t in c r e a s e s i n amplit ude a s circu m s tanc e s r e quire a g r e a te r inv es tm ent o f at t e n t i on al re sou rce s (B ri sson, R obi ta ille, & Jolic o eur, 200 7; R a shal et a l. & Bo ehler , 2022 ) and is the re fore u s ed a s an index o f the d epth o f a t t entio n al proce ssing (L u ck , Gir e lli, McDermo tt , & For d, 1997 ; Luc k & Ford, 1 998). We tr ack ed th e em er g e nce of ca t e gory i nforma tion in th e brain u s in g lin ea r di s c r iminant a naly si s (LDA ) to c la ssi fy neuroimag ing da ta . We tr a in ed mode l s t o cla s si fy the obj ec t c at e gory of the t a r g e t or dis tr a c tor ba s ed on no r ma l ise d pa tte r ns o f evoke d bra in a ctivity , s ub sequ e nt l y te st i ng th e se model s o n r e t a ined d a t a to cal cula te mo del c las s i fi ca tion a cc ur a cy. Measuring attentional selec t ion and ca t e gory inform ation in E EG In e ach experim en t a l tr i al , the targe t obj ect c ould a ppe ar t o the l e ft or rig h t o f a c e ntral fixa t io n mark or directly ab ove or below it ; when t he ta rget wa s pr es ent ed la te r a lly, t he s i n gle rec ognizabl e dist r a ct or wa s pre se nte d on the ve rtica l, and v ice versa (Fig 1b). Thi s de s ig n wa s a do pt e d a s stimul i on the ver tical meridi an of the vis ual fi el d ini t i ally crea te a ctivi ty of equ al magni tude in both c or t i cal hemi s ph er es , and th er e fo r e a tt e nt i on al s elec tion of t he se stimuli d oe s no t g e nera te th e l at eraliz ed .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint Fi g ure 3 – a .) Anal y s i s of E E G da ta i n Ex peri men t 1 . Trials were re p eat edl y pa r t i t io ned i n t o trai nin g a nd t est s e ts . Cl a s s ificati on a c curacy a nd mean N 2p c am pl i t ud e w ere m e as ured f or each tes t s et, re s ulti n g i n t wo de pen den t me a sure s ( ide ntif i e d in b o l d). b.) Ana l ys is o f M RI a nd E EG da ta i n Ex p eri ment 2. T he i m a gin g mo dalit ie s w e re lin ked d u r in g tr i al partit io n i n g , suc h th at t he sa m e trials a p p ear i n bo th MRI a nd E E G trai nin g an d tes t set s . T hi s res ul te d i n t h r e e de pen de n t m ea s u res (i den tifi e d i n b ol d ). c.) To li nk EE G and MRI res ult s in Ex peri m e nt 2 w e correlat ed M R I cla ssifica ti o n acc u racy wit h N 2 pc am p l it u d e o b s e r ved ac ross t h e set o f 1 1 4 0 s a m plin g it eratio ns. This occ u r re d f or e ac h s e a rc hl i g ht s ph ere. .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint 8 EEG v oltage unde rlying N 2 pc (Woo dman & L uck , 2003). By pre se nting stimuli on t he ve r tic al w e we r e able to i s ola t e th e N2pc elici t e d exc lusively by t he ta r g e t or di st r ac to r ( Hic ke y , McDonald , & The euwe s, 200 6; Hick ey, Di L ollo , & Mc Dona ld, 200 9) . The N 2p c eme r g ed p rominen tly in both e xperiment s (Fig s. 2 a, 2d ) a nd wa s la r g er in amp litude for targe t s than r eco gnizabl e di s tr actor s (Fig s 2b, 2e ). I t wa s p rec ed ed b y earli e r , po s i tiv e-p olari ty l ate ral vol t a ge tha t re flec t s a n imbal ance in s en s o r y activ i ty betw ee n the v i s u al hemi s ph ere s. In o ur st i mulu s di spl ays, ther e i s a dif fe r e nce i n the c omplexi t y and spa tia l f r e qu ency of t he c omplet e objec t, pr es ent ed on on e s i d e of the scr e en, and th e un rec ognis able deg rade d o bjec t , pr esen ted on the ot her (Fi g 1b). T hi s kind of imbal an ce c r e ate s s ho rt -la tenc y lat eral i t y in the vis ual E RP (i e. P P N; Pome r l e au e t al . , 2014). The in s en sitivity of thi s e f f e ct to th e be haviou ral r e l eva nc e of t h e evok ing st i mulu s di sting ui she s it fr om t h e s ub seq ue nt N 2pc . Targe t and di s tr a ct or ca te gory info rmati on was iden ti fie d in th e E EG u s i ng cl assi fi c ation an aly si s. Fo r eac h s ample in th e epo ch ed d at a, an LDA model was t r a ine d on r e sul t s ob ser v ed i n a ~85 ms wi ndow c entred on that ob serva tio n. A c ros s- fold v alida t i on scheme – d e scribed fu r the r bel ow – wa s empl oyed to t e st the model in ea ch of th es e w indowe d s a mple s, gen e r a t i ng a t im e -cou rse o f cl assi fic atio n ac curac y. A s ill u s t rat ed in F i gure 2c , w hen the targe t a ppe are d la te r a lly, t he cat eg or y co uld be rel ia bly cla ssi fied from ap p r ox imately 215 m s po st - s timul u s in Expe r im e nt 1 (Fig 2c) and from 240 ms i n Expe r i men t 2 (Fi g 2f ). Di strac to r c la s s i fica tion al so emerged in Ex p erimen t 1, thoug h later a nd with red uc ed ma gnitud e a nd e x t e nt . Import antly, we d e s ig ne d the e xperimen ts such th at c la s s i fic atio n of objec t c at egory could not lev erage the EEG va r ia nc e under pinning N 2 pc. In all c la s s i fi catio n a naly se s, mode l creation and va lidation wer e ba sed o n se ts o f trial s th at con t a i n the sam e nu mber s o f rel e vant v ehicl es , t o ol s , food s, a nd animal s, a nd r oughly the sam e numbe r o f le ft - and righ t-l a t e ral ized sti muli within each of the se ca t e gori e s. The loca tion o f th e objec t – and t h u s the l ate rality o f t h e N 2 pc i n left o r r i ght vi sual co r tex – provi de d no i nfo r ma t i on abou t i ts ca t e gory . Coupling varianc e in N2p c to varianc e in EE G -de r iv ed ca t eg or y infor mation We le ver aged nat ural va r i a nce in th e qua lity of a tten tion al s elec t i on to ide nti fy cova r i ance in N2pc and categ o r y cla ssi fica tio n ac curac y. Thi s v arianc e stem s in par t from chang e s in p artici pan t vi gilanc e, ta sk e ngage men t, and f a t i gue, bu t a l s o r e flec t s confu si on a nd th e mis all oc ation o f att entio n to di s t racto r obje ct s. O ur ex pe ctation wa s th at wh en the qua li ty of a tt e ntiona l d eploy ment to the targe t w a s high, t hi s w ould c au se emerge nce o f in for m a tion ab out th e at t e nded obje ct in th e neural s ig nal . .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint F ig u r e 4 – Lin ki n g N2 p c and EE G ca t e g o ry i n fo r m at io n in E xp e r im ent 1 . a . ) Wi thi n -pa r t i c i pa nt r e su l ts f r om 3 exam p l e p art icip ants . A c ro ss th e 1 1 40 s ampl i ng it e ra ti ons , th e ta r get- el icit ed N 2pc o bs erved in a gi v e n s am pl e pre di c ts tar g e t clas sifica tio n acc u racy in t ha t s a m ple. b .) Lin ea r fi t of tar ge t - e licit e d N 2 pc a nd t arget c l ass i f i c ati on acc ura c y f or e ac h pa rt i c ipan t, w i t h me a n re la ti o n sh i p i de nt i fi ed i n red. c.) Lin e ar fi t of di stract or- elicited N 2pc and t a rg et cl a s sif icatio n a c curacy f or ea c h part icip a n t, wit h m ean re l at io n s hip i d e ntif i e d i n re d . To te st t h i s, w e iter ativ ely re s ample d th e data i n a boo t strap r o u t in e, bu ildi ng c las s i fic atio n mode l s and me a s uring th e N2pc i n eac h in s t a nce ( F ig. 3 a) . For e a ch pa r tic ip ant, targe t - la te r al and di stract or - later al tri al s we r e s e p ara ted in to 20 chunk s , e ach con taini ng an e qual nu mbe r of t r ia l s where t he cla ssi fied ob jec t wa s a food , v ehicl e, ani ma l, or tool . T he c hunk s were a ll oca t e d r epea tedly into two s ub se t s. The l a rger s e t – con sti tuting 17 chunk s or 8 5% of trial s – w a s u s e d to trai n a c las s i fic atio n model tha t i den tifi ed th e ta r g e t cat eg or y . The smal l er s e t – con sti tut i ng t he rem ai ning 3 chunk s or 15% of t ria l s – wa s u sed bo th t o te s t the model and to me a s ure the ta r g e t- o r dist ractor -elic ited N2 p c . For eac h o f the targe t- la te r a l and di s tr actor - lat eral con dition s , we iter at ed thi s pr oces s o f s a mpling and mode l build ing 114 0 time s, r efl ectin g all possible combin a tion s o f 3 chu nks ta ken fr om 20 . The cla ssi fica t i o n ac curacy illus tra ted in F igur es 2c and 2 f re flec ts the mea n of the se v alue s ac r o s s itera tion s and sub se quen tly pa r tic ip ant s . In ea ch ite rati on we me a s ur ed t h e N 2 pc as mea n volt ag e in a 125 ms inte r v al c entr ed at the p e ak (a s ide nt i fi ed from da ta c ollap se d a cro ss ite ration s , c ondition s , and pa r tic ip ant s; 173 – 298 m s) . We me a s ur ed me an cl a ssi fic atio n ac curac y in t hi s same in ter v al, r e s ulting in pa i r e d s e ts of 11 40 N2pc a nd cl assific ation ac cu rac y va lues for eac h a naly s i s a nd .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint 10 partic ipan t. As illu s tr a t e d in Fi gur e 4a, wi thin- par tic ipant r e s u lts c ommonly show e d a r e lati on ship betwe e n targ et -elic i ted N2pc and targe t c las s i fi catio n a cc ur a cy, with ne ga tive-v ol tage N 2pc ampl itude p redic ting an impr ovemen t in targe t cl a s si fic a tion. Th e mean r e l atio ns h ip is plot ted in Fi gure 4b a long side r e sult s from e ach o f t he 44 pa rtic ipant s . One int erpr et ation o f th is p at tern i s th at robu s t a t t entio n al s elec t i on o f the targe t – r e fl ect ed i n large r ta r g e t - e licite d N 2p c – c au sed the E EG t o carry more in fo r m ation about the t a r g et ca teg o r y . Howev er, an a l tern ative i s th at bo th N2p c and ta r g e t info rmatio n c ovaried a s a fu nction of partic ipan t ar ou sal or t a sk en gage men t without an y more di rec t r e la tion ship . W e c onducted a secon d analy s i s to pro be thi s al t e r na t i ve . Here, w e r elat ed t a r g et in form ation to d ist r a cto r- elici te d rath er tha n targ et -el ici ted N2pc . If the N 2pc and c ategory in for m a tion bro adly cov ary, this a na lysi s should id e nti fy the sam e rel a tion s h ip a s desc ribed ab ove. H ow eve r, a s i llu st r ate d in Fig ur e 4c, t h e mag nitude o f di str actor - elic ited N2pc i n f act predi c ted a d ecrea s e i n targ et cl a ssifi c ation ac curac y. We u sed hie r a r c hica l lin e ar mod elli ng of trial -w ise EEG and m odel as s e ssment to sta t i s t ic ally ev aluat e the s e pa tter ns (Hicke y, Grign oli o , Muna singhe , & Ac unzo, unde r revie w) . An ini t i al mod e l of cl assi fic atio n ac curac y in cluded a single ra ndom ef fec t fo r the p er -par t i cipa n t i nte r c ept . Thi s w a s improve d by a dding a fixe d e ff ect – condition – tha t i den tifi ed if the ta r g et or di st r ac tor wa s being cl assi fied ( along side a co rre spo nding r a n dom ef fec t f o r the pe r-pa rtic ipant slop e; Barr , Levy , She epe r s , & T ily, 2 013; A IC -874 6). Th e model w as further imp rov ed by adding a fix ed ef f ec t fo r N2pc ampl itude (and cor r e s pond i ng random e ff ect; AIC -702 ) and th e i nt e r a ctio n of t he se fac t ors (an d co r re spond ing r a ndom e f fec t: AI C -896 ). (eq 1 . ) cla s sifica t io n _acc uracy ~ N2pc * c o ndition + (N2pc * c on dition| p art i cip an t) ANOVA an a lysi s o f thi s mod el ide nti fi ed an inter action o f condition and N2pc (F(1 , 4 2.6) = 1 3.72 , p < 0.00 1), r efl ecting a signi f i can t di ff erenc e in t he s l ope o f th e l inea r fi t s illus trated in Fi gures 4b an d 4 c. Fol low-up mo de lling exa mined th e r el a ti ons h ip b etwe e n N2pc a nd ca t e gory in for mation s epa r a te ly for e ac h of the c ondi tion s. (eq 2 . ) cla s sifica t io n _acc uracy ~ N2pc + ( N2pc | partici p ant ) Targe t-e licit ed N 2p c r elia bly predi c ted i mprov ed targ et c la s s ific ation (F ( 1 , 41.6) = 5.366, p = 0.0 26 ), but di stra ctor -e lici t e d N 2 pc reli ably pre di cted de gra ded t arge t clas si fica tion (F (1, 42.0 ) = 6.13 0, p = 0.01 7). N o pat te r n was id en t i fi ed in se pa rate a naly s i s o f di st r a cto r- elici te d N 2 pc a nd dis t rac t or cl assi fic atio n ac curac y (F s<1 ). .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint Fi g ure 5 – Res ul ts fro m MRI cla s sifi c a t i o n. a.) S ea r chl igh t an a l ysi s i den tif y i n g t he loca ti on o f ta r ge t an d dis tract o r i nfor m at io n . T a rg et a n d dis tract o r c a te go r y i n f orm atio n e m erg e wi t h p art icul ar s treng t h in t he asp ects of occip it a l a n d pos te r ior t emp oral lo be s a ss oc i ate d w it h t he ve n tr al v i su al st ream . b.) V o x els iden tifi ed here ref le c t cl us ters ex pressi n g m or e i nfo r mat ion abo u t t h e target t han abo u t t he d istract or. I n b ot h pa n e ls t he lar g es t c lust ers e me r ge i n ve n tral v i s ual c ortex; o ther clu ster locat io ns are i d e n tified. OFC – orbi t ofro n t al cort ex; I P L – i n feri or parie ta l l obe; S PL – s up erior p arie t al l o be ; IFG – i n feri or fro n t al gyru s; T P J – tem poral pariet a l j unct io n. T he lef t h e mi s ph ere i s re prese n t ed on t h e l eft here a n d i n s u b sequ ent f ig ures . .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint 12 Res ult s from E xperimen t 1 d emon stra te t h at the qual i t y of a tt entio nal s el ec tion o f t he targe t, refl ec t e d in targ et -eli cit ed N2pc , p redic ts an increa se i n t he ta rget c a tego ry infor matio n carri ed b y EEG in the same 125 ms t i me pe riod. I n contra s t , mi salloc a tion o f at ten tion to the distrac t o r , refl ec t e d in dis trac tor -elic i ted N2 pc, re su lted i n degr ade d t arge t ca t e go ry inform a tion. Measuring ca t e gory infor mat ion in uni mod al fMR I In E xperiment 2 par ticipa n ts c omplet ed t he s am e ta s k whi le EEG a nd fMR I were c onc ur ren tly record ed (Fig. 3b ). W e beg an an a lysi s wit h ide nt i fi cati on o f ca teg or y in forma tion i n t h e unimoda l fMRI signal . We es t i mat ed single -tr ial fM RI r e spon s e s us i n g the GLM singl e toolb o x (P r in ce, Ch are s t, Kurz a wski, P yle s, Tarr, & Kay , 2022) a nd i denti fie d ca t e gory in forma tion in brai n s pac e usi ng spa tial se archli ght s a nd L DA c la s s ifi ca tion . I n thi s analy ti c app r oa ch , a sph ere is d efi ned a r ou nd eac h vox el and clas si fica t i o n i s conduc te d ba sed on t he pa tte rn o f ac t i vity ob serve d in the su bse t o f vox els wi t hi n thi s volume (Kr i eg e skort e, G oebb el, & Ba nde ttini, 200 6 ). Se a r c hligh t sph er es ha d a diame t e r of 7 v oxel s (14 mm) an d c las si fie r s w ere t r a ined a nd te sted u s in g 4- fold c ro ss -valid ation . Thi s iden t i fi ed an ov erlappi ng se t of b rain a re a s t hat c on tain ed info rmati on abo u t both t h e ta rget a nd the di st racto r, alo ng s i d e a mo r e limit ed s et o f are a s tha t e xclu s iv ely cont aine d in f ormation a b out one of t h e s e t w o objec t s (F ig . 5a ) . Brain area s e xpr e s si ng categ or y in forma tion f o r both t arge t a nd dist r a ct or incl uded v en tr a l vi sual cor tex; in f e r i or a nd sup erior p arie tal lobul e s (I PL /SPL ) ; and pre - motor, mo tor, a nd soma t o s en sory co r t e x . Target i nfo r ma t i on al so eme r g ed in th e lef t inf erio r fro nt a l gy r us (I FG ), bi la ter al orbit of ront al c or t ex (O F C), a nd p r e cun eu s / cin gula te c or t e x; dist r a ct or informa tion ext ended fr om t he I PL into t he lef t t emporal -pa r i e t a l junc tion (T PJ ). Sta t i s tica l ana ly si s iden t i fi ed that the bil a te r a l LOC , IP L /SPL , lef t IFG , le ft OF C, po steri or c ingula te, an d le ft b a s a l gang lia (BG ) all re li ably contain e d more in fo rmat ion about the t arge t than di strac t or (F ig . 4b). N o a r e a relia bly c ont ained more info rmati on ab o ut t he di s t rac tor t h a n th e targ et. Coupling varianc e in N2p c to varianc e in MRI -derived category inf o rmation In E xperiment 1 we u sed a r e s a mpling ap proach to id enti fy within- par tici pant co v arianc e in inde pend ent me a sure s d erive d f r om EEG . In E xperiment 2 , we u sed a s imilar a pp roa ch to l ink va r i ance in mea s ur e s derive d fr om the t wo ima ging modalitie s (F igur e 2c ). For ea c h partic ipan t, t rial s we r e agai n s e p ara ted int o 20 chunk s o f e qual s iz e, w ith 17 c hunks as s i gn ed to the traini ng se t and 3 ch unks to the t e st se t. Th i s proc e ss o f sa mpli ng and model bu ilding was it era ted 114 0 times for e ac h of th e ~ 2.1 x 10 5 sea rchli ght s ph e r e s . In e ac h of th e se it era tion s, t he N2pc wa s me asu red in t h e te st se t a s mean v olt age acro s s a 125 m s in te rva l c entred at t he pe a k (a s iden tifi e d f r o m data c ollap sed ac r o ss i ter atio ns , condi t i o ns, and par tic ip ant s ; 189 – 315 ms ). Thi s ge ne r a te d a pa i red set o f 1140 .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint Fi g ure 6 - Lin k i n g N2 pc a n d MRI ca te gory i nfo rma ti o n in E x perim e n t 2. R es ul ts i l l ustra te b rain r egi ons w here targ e t c ate g o r y i n for ma ti o n is p red icte d b y t arget -e lici te d N 2 pc a mpli t u d e. Ti me -c o urs e i nse ts s ho w t h e tim e - resol ved correlati on f or ea c h M RI cl u s t er. Si gnificant t im e cl ust ers are in dicat e d b y bl ac k li nes b el ow t he x- a x is an d s ha din g r e fl ects b o ots tra ppe d SE M. L o c atio n an d t im e-c o urse for a.) th e Inf erior Pariet a l L o bule clu s ter, b.) th e Ins ul a / P u ta m e n / Glo b us P al lid us cl ust e r, a n d c.) t h e V e n tro me d i al Prefro n t a l C ort ex / O rbi t ofro n tal Cortex clu ster. .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint 14 N2pc and c las s i fic a tion ac curac y v alue s f or eac h sea rchli ght s p he re. We ca lcul a te d the F i s he r- tran sforme d Pe ar s o n cor rela tion for e ach o f t h e se set s , ins er t i ng the r e sulting v al ues in to a new brain volume at the loc a tion o f ea ch se ar ch light c entre . A s i llu stra ted i n Fig ur e 6, t his iden ti fie d 3 cl us t er s wher e targ e t-el ici ted N 2pc ampl i tude pr edic te d MRI -de rived t a r g et ca teg or y informa tion . This inc luded a c lu ster in the le ft IPL / an gula r g yrus ext endin g into the SPL (92 vox els; Fig. 6a ), a cl us t er th at spann ed t h e putam en, globu s pall idu s, in sul a, a nd an te rior t empor al l obe in the r i ght hemi s ph er e (8 4 vox els, Fig . 6b), an d a c lus t er th at spann e d th e bila te r a l ven trom e dia l pre fron tal co r tex and orbi to fron tal c or t e x ( VMP FC / OFC; 16 3 vox els , Fig . 6c). We int erpr et t he se r e s ul ts a s demo n stra ting that i nc rea singly robu st a tten tion al s elec t i on of t he targe t – r e fle c ted in t a r g e t- elici te d N 2 pc ov er occ ipital c or t e x – cau sed the em erg enc e of c onc eptu al informa tion in t he ide n t i fi ed bra in a r e a s . H ow ever, a s i n Exp er i ment 1, the a l ter n ative i s tha t N2pc and categ o r y informa tion br oad ly c ovari ed as a func tion o f oth er varia bl e s a s s oc i ated to par tic ipan t sta te , like arou s al. W e ag ain c onduc te d a c ontr ol analy s i s to te st t h i s , rel ating t arg et c at egory informa tion to di s tr ac t or -e lic ited r ath er t han ta r g e t-e licit ed N 2p c . We c r e at ed 3 r egi ons o f int er est (RO Is) th at de s c r i be d th e c lu s te r s illus tra t e d in F igure 6, c alc ul ate d c las s i f i ca tion a cc ur a cy us in g the entir e s et o f vo xels wi t hi n eac h o f the s e ROI s , a nd u s ed our 114 0 -f o l d techni q ue t o relat e t hi s informa tion to t he N 2 pc. Th i s sh ow ed th at th e rela tio n s hip b etwe en t a r g et cat eg or y informa tion a nd targe t- elic it ed N2pc was signi fic antly gre ater than t he re la t i o nshi p be twee n t arge t ca t e go ry informa tion and di s tr a c tor -elici t e d N 2 pc in all 3 RO I s ( IPL / SPL: p = 0.005 ; ins ula: p = 0.027; V M P F C / OFC: p < 0.001) . D i st ract or -elic it ed N2pc i n fact pr edi ct ed a r e d uction i n MR I- deriv ed targ e t cat ego r y informa tion in t he V MPF C / OFC, much a s e me r g ed in analy s i s of uni m odal E EG r e sult s fr o m Ex periment 1 (p = 0 .019 ; oth er a rea s p s > 0.230 ). We c onduct ed whole -brai n analy s e s to r ela te dis t rac t o r-el ici ted N2 pc to varia nc e i n target o r dist r a ct or inf orma tion, bu t fa il ed to id en tify any se t o f vox els whe re th e se r ela t i o n s hip s survive d sta t i s t ic al c or r ec t i on . Analy s i s of di s tract or- elic ite d N2pc a nd di st r a cto r info rmati on ba sed on ROI s defin e d f r o m r e s ul ts illu stra ted in F igur e 6 also faile d t o iden ti fy sig nific an t re sult s . The a b s e nce o f relia bl e ef fec ts inv olvin g dist r a cto r info r mation may in pa r t r ef le ct t he limi te d magni t u de an d sc op e of thi s in forma tion i n th e MR I data (Fig. 5 ). Coupling varianc e in la t e r al EEG to varia nc e in fMRI-derived category informa t io n: time-c ours e To thi s poi nt , we ha ve foc u ssed o n the N 2pc me asu r ed a t a fix ed la t e ncy. H ow eve r, l at erali ty i n the EEG e merge s bo th be for e and a fte r t h e N 2 pc; a s di sc uss ed ab ove, e arly la te r a li ty emerge s a s a func t i o n of s e n sory activ it y , but al so a s a product o f stimulu s nove l ty (V erleg e r , ve l Grejew s ka , & .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint Fi g ure 7 – L i n k ing N 2pc a n d M RI vox el act iv at i o n in Exp e r i m ent 2. Res ult s i llust rate brai n r e gi o n s w h ere ta r g e t- elicited N 2pc a m pl i t u de is pre di c t ed b y vox e l acti v i ty. a.) Locat ion of t he t hre e i d e n tifi e d clus ters: Left Inf erior Parie t al L o b u le / An g u lar Gy r us / T emp oro parieta l J u ncti on , Left M i d dl e Fro n t al G y r us / Fro ntal Eye Fi e l d, an d Bil a tera l Dors ome d i al S u p eri or F ro n tal G yrus. b .) Time-res olved corr e la tion f or eac h MRI cl ust er. Sign ifica nt tim e c lus t e rs a re in dicat ed b y bl a c k l ines b e l o w t he x -a x i s an d s hadi ng reflect s bo ots tr app ed SEM. Ja s k owski, 2 012) and di s tr ac t or supp re ssi on ( Hic key , Di Lol lo, & McD onald, 2009; S awa ki & Luc k, 2010; Wea ver , va n Zoes t, & H i cke y, 201 9). La ter l at er a li ty ha s be e n cl osely link ed to the e ncoding and ma inten anc e o f s t i muli in visu al w ork ing me mor y (Vogel & Mac hizawa, 2004 ) . We e xpand e d our analy s i s t o ex plore the ro le o f pre - and p os t-N 2p c EE G l at er a li ty in t h e con trol o f c once ptu al enco ding in t he br ain. F o r each o f th e RO Is g en era ted from r e sults il lu s t rat ed in Fi gure 6, we r e la ted varian ce in eac h la ter al E EG sa mple t o va r i ance in MRI - d erive d t arge t ca t e go ry inf ormation . This genera ted a time - co urse o f th e r el ation shi p betwe e n lat eral occ ipit al EE G a nd M RI- d erive d ta r g e t categ or y inf orma tion f or ea ch R OI . The s e a r e illu stra te d in F igure 6. In the I P L , th e rel a t i on s hi p betwe en EEG later ali t y and t arge t c atego ry inform atio n emerge d very quick ly a nd su s tain e d (Fig . 6a) . Th e pre - N2 pc rela t io nship may refl e ct di strac to r s u ppre s s i on th at guides sel ec tive pr oc e ssing of th e comp l ete objec t ra ther t ha n t he deg ra ded obje ct in the contrala te ral visu al he mifi eld ( Wea ve r, va n Zoes t, & H ic key , 2017; H i cke y, Bert az olli, P o llici no , & Barbar o, 201 9) . The po st - N 2 pc r ela tion s hip, in con t ra s t, i s like ly to in dex th e m ai ntenanc e of v i s ua l working memory repre se nta tion s o f th e targe t i n po s t erior p a r ie t a l cor tex (Luria, Ba laban , Awh, & Vogel, 2018 ). In con tra st, i n th e VM P F C a nd insula c lu s t e rs, the r ela t i on s hip be twe en EEG lat erali ty and MRI - de riv ed ta rget in forma tion i s rel a tively discr et e to t he la t e ncy inte rval of t he N 2 pc ( Fi gs. 6b, 6c). T he s e r e s ul ts sugge st t hat the speci fi c selec t i ve proc e ss es in dex ed in N2pc ar e c los e ly li nked t o the pro paga t i on of targe t c at egory in f o r mation t o t h e s e are as . .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint 16 Coupling varianc e in EEG indice s of attentional selec tion to varianc e in fMRI vo xel ac tivity In the t e xt abov e we have id enti fied a rel ation ship b e t w ee n N2pc ampli t ud e and t he emergenc e of MRI -derive d ca teg o ry informa tion . This a naly s i s w a s de s i gned t o i den tify th e e f f e ct of N2pc on the propag at ion o f c atego ry in f o r ma t i on d eri ved fr om visu al s timuli. H ow eve r, th e dat a also of fe r an opport unity to i d enti fy how N2pc i s pr ed ic ted by univa r i at e vox el ac tivity. Our analy s i s of the r el a tion s hi p be twee n univa r i at e fMR I and N 2pc wa s c once p t u a lly s imi lar to ou r ana lysi s o f multiva r i a t e fMR I and N2pc . C hunke d per -pa rticipa n t r e s ul t s were e xhaus tive ly parti tioned in to s ub se t s of 3 an d 17 . In e ach of th e re s u l t i ng 114 0 te s t se t s , th e N2 pc w as mea sur ed in a 125 ms w indow around it s pe ak and mea n ac t i vity w as cal cul a t e d fo r each o f the ~2 .1 x 10 5 vox els in c orte x and s ubc o rt e x. Th i s g ene rate d pa ire d se ts o f 11 40 N2pc and ac tiv ation value s for eac h vo xel. For eac h p artici p ant, we cal c ulated t h e Fi she r- tra n s fo rmed P e ar s o n c orr e l ation for ea ch of th e se pai re d s e ts , in ser ting the v alu es into a new br a in vo lume at e ach v oxel lo ca t i on. As illu s tr a t e d in Fi gur e 7a, t h i s i de nti fied 3 voxe l clu s ter s whe re v arianc e in targe t - eli cited N2pc ampl itude p redic te d varia nce in vox el ac t ivation : th e middle fr on ta l gyrus (MF G; 3 77 v oxel s ), t he I PL ex t e nding i nt o t h e TP J (486 voxe l s ), an d t he dor somedi a l sup er i or front al gyrus (d mSFG; 29 6 vox els ). The se a r e a s are la rgel y inde p enden t of t hos e ide n t i f i ed in c orre spondi ng ana ly si s of categ o r y informa tion . Signi f i can t re sul t s emerg ed i n the I PL in both a naly se s , but th e c lu st e rs did n o t overla p, wi t h N 2pc predic t ing ac tivation in vox el s ante rior and la te ral to tho se id en t i fi ed in a nalysi s o f ca tegory in forma tion . As in an a lysi s o f cat eg or y info rmatio n, w e ex amine d th e rela tion ship b e t w e en di stract or -elic it ed N2pc and vox el a ctivi t y as a c on tr ol . Who le-b rain a naly si s did no t i denti fy an y brai n a r e a wh ere th e dist r a ct or - e lici te d N 2 pc pr edic te d vox el a ctivi t y aft er s ta ti stica l co rrec tion . W h en we defin ed RO Is bas ed on t h e re s ul ts fr om whol e-b rain a na lysi s illu st r a te d in Fi gure 7, t he re was no signi fi cant relati on ship b e tween di stract or -elic it ed N2pc and mea n vox el a ctivity in the s e ar ea s, a nd th e relati on ship be tween ta r g e t - el icit ed N 2p c and voxe l ac t i vity w as s ig ni fica ntly gre a t e r t ha n th e relati on ship b e tween di stract or -elic it ed N2pc and v oxel activi t y (I PL: p = 0. 007; d mSFG: p < 0 .001; MFG: p = 0 .007). Coupling varianc e in EEG indice s of attentional selec tion to varianc e in fMRI v oxel ac tivity: time- cou r se As in an a lysi s o f cat eg or y info rmatio n, w e ex panded ou r analy s i s to t e st th e powe r o f pre - an d po st - N2pc EEG late rality to predic t uni varia te v oxel activ ity. As illu s tra ted in F igur e 7b, a rela tion ship betwe e n lat eral EEG and voxe l ac t i vity e m er g e s soone r i n IPL th an in MF G, t ho ug h both e ff ec t s a re in the 17 5 - 350 m s in t e rv al wh er e t he N2p c c an e merge. Bo th l e ft I PL a nd le ft MFG hav e bee n clo sely .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint 17 link ed to th e e xtrac tion o f sema n t i c c ont ent during r ead ing ( Wu, Ho, & Ch en, 201 2; Rue ckl et al ., 2015 ; Binder e t a l. , 2009 ), and l e f t a nd ri ght IPL and MF G have r ol e s in the o rien t ation and reori enta tion o f spa tia l at ten tion (Co rbe t ta & Sc hulman , 2 002; Co rbe tta , P a tel, & Sch ulman, 2 008). One int erpr et ation o f th is finding i s tha t the eme rge nce o f I PL a nd MFG r efl ec t co ntrol in th e depl oyment o f a t ten tion for e xt racti on o f sema ntic in forma tio n . The r e la tion ship be tw een la t e ral EEG an d activ ity in the dmSFG , in contr as t , em e rges from very early , inc luding lat enc ie s t h a t pre cede sti mulus on se t. Amo ng othe r func tion s, thi s por t i on o f medi al fron tal lob e contai n s e ye fie l d s a nd ha s b een a ssoc ia ted w ith fixation moni toring, i ncludi ng during smoo th pur s ui t e ye mov ement s (Amiez & P e t rid e s , 2 009) . In th e curren t re s ul t s, trial s with e ye move ment s sub stan tivel y prece d ing s timulus on s et wer e n ot exc luded from a n alysi s; t he a s s oc ia tion of ac tivity in th e dmSFG with E EG la te rali ty underlying the N2pc may refl ec t ocul o motor cont rol suppo rt i ng ori ent ation of th e eye s t o the fi xation m ark or in ma in ten anc e o f the e y es a t tha t loc ation . Similarly , lat er a s socia tion o f d mS F G w ith EEG la te r a li ty in t he N 2 pc a nd post- N2pc inte rval may reflec t the involv eme nt o f thi s brai n a r e a in th e inhibiti on of s a cca d ic mo vement s to co ve rtly att ended loca t io n s. Dis c us sion We le ver aged nat ural va r i a bility in the q ua lity of a t t entio n al selec t i on t o identi fy t he t emporal a nd ana t o mic c har acte ri stic s of the a t t entio n -me dia ted pr opag a tion o f c oncep t u a l inf ormation i n the huma n brain. In Experime nt 1, we find th at th e a mplitud e of targe t - el icit ed N 2pc , an index of s pa t i al att entio n, p r ed i ct s t ha t t h e evok ed EE G s igna l wi ll ca r ry more info rmation a bout t he s emantic ca tegory o f a n at tend ed o bject (Fi gure 4 b). T hi s r e la tion ship emerge s qu ickl y, w ith atte ntion - medi ate d ca t e go ry informa tion emergin g in the sam e 173 - 298 ms window u sed in me as u reme n t o f the N2pc . The mi s a l loca t i o n of a tt enti on to ta sk -irr eleva n t stimul i, re flec t e d in di s tr a ct or -elici te d N2pc, pr e dic t s a reduc t i on in th e quali ty of t a r g et ca teg ory in forma tion i n th e sa me interv al (Fig ure 4c ). Though the se r e s ul t s are c o r rel a tion al, the p att er n s t rongly s u gge s ts tha t a tt ention a l s elec t i on of the t arget rapi dly c au se s eme rgenc e o f c ategory i n f o r ma t io n in bra in activ ity. Ex periment 1 l eave s unc le ar th e degr ee t o w hich t he ob ser v ed rela tion s hip be twe en N 2pc and ca tegory in forma tio n r e fl ect s low-l e vel p er c ep tual encodi ng. Tha t i s , ou r machi ne lea r ni ng app roa ch to the d e r iv ati on of c a tego ry informa tion co uld rely on the r epr es ent ation of low - and mi d-level v is u a l fe at u r es t h at ar e s ha re d b y e x a m p le s of a g iv e n ca te g o r y , a n d t h is p oss i b il ity i s n o t e nt i re l y addre s sed by our u se of a vi s ual ly he ter o ge nous stimuli se t. For exa mple , a tten tio na l s elec t i o n of an ima ge of a vehic le ma y c au se r epre se nta t io n of the surfa c e c harac te r i s tic ‘metalli c ’ more of ten tha n .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint 18 is th e c a s e f or any o t h e r i mage ca tego r y i n the e xperim ent s. Thi s wo uld provid e o pportuni ty fo r the cl assi fier to le ver age th e emerge nce o f b r a in ac tivity a ssocia t e d with t he pe rcepti on of thi s vi sual fea tur e to pr obab ili st i c all y infe r targ et c a tegory. Str o nge r at ten tional acc e ntua tio n of thi s br ain ac tivity c ould i n thi s way improve catego ry cla ssifica t i on . One goa l o f Ex periment 2 w a s th ere fo r e t o cla r i fy the co ntributi on o f visual p er c e ption i n th e relati on ship b e tween a tten t i o n and c at e gory i nfor m a tion. Initia l anal y s i s o f unim odal fM R I iden tifi ed a n etwork o f brai n a rea s whe re cat ego r y informa tion w a s grea te r fo r t a r g et s th an for di s t rac tor s (Fig 4b). T hi s pr om ine ntly i nclude d bila te ral ventr al v is u al c ortex , alon g s i d e small er c lu s t er s in bi la ter al inferi or pa rie ta l lobule / sulc us (I PL/SPL ), lef t inf erior fron tal gy r u s (I F G), l e ft o r bi t o fron tal cor tex (OF C), l ef t ba sal gang lia, a nd bila teral p o s t erio r c ingula t e gyru s ( PC ). The se re sul t s t he r e f o r e inclu de asp ec ts o f oc cipi t a l and p oste rior pa rie ta l cortex tha t a r e strongly a s s oc iat ed w ith the re pre s enta tion of v is u a l fe atu re s and t ran sla tion o f v is u a l informa tion to mot o r c on trol (Konen & Kastn er, 2008 ; Freud, Plaut , & B ehrmann , 2016), a long si de ba s al gang lia struc tur es tha t m ay ha ve a r o le in v i sual perce p tion ( Ding, 2 023) . Howev er, al s o e v ident are a se t o f le ft - l a ter alized a rea s i nc luding IFG and VMP FC / OFC , a long side b il ate ral P C, th a t are no t put ativ ely v is u al in n ature , bu t hav e been impli cated in ea rlie r w ork as c on taining a bstrac t s em a ntic re pre s enta tion s ( Binde r et a l., 2009 ) . Furthe r ana ly si s iden tifi ed 3 brain a rea s w here tri al-wi se v ari anc e in t arge t - el icite d N 2pc ampl itude predic te d th e qua lity o f ta rget c a tegory i nfor m a tion : the l e ft I PL /SPL ; a n ins ula -c e ntr e d cl u ster in t he right he mi s phe r e incl uding po rtion s o f th e puta men and globu s pall idu s ; a nd a bil ater al VM PF C- ce ntred clus ter extendi ng int o me dial O F C (F igur e 5). The s e are al l node s in t h e ‘ se mantic n e t w ork’ iden t i fi ed from larg e- sca l e met a- an alysi s of f MRI s tu di e s o f sema ntic r epre s ent ati on (Bind e r e t al., 2009 ). The po rtion o f I PL/SPL identi fie d i n this a na lysi s w a s phy sica lly clos e to th e pos terio r pari etal cl us t er ide n t i f i ed in a n alysi s o f unimo dal fMRI , a s de ta iled a b ove, b ut wa s s l ightly posteri or wi t h no ove r l ap, em e r g ing primaril y in th e angula r gyrus. Cat egory inf ormati on in thi s ar ea expres se d a relati on ship w ith ERP l ate rality o ver muc h of 500 m s f oll owing stimulu s on se t, inc luding time perio ds befo re a nd a f ter N 2 pc. Ac tivity i n thi s po r tion o f th e parie tal lob e i s imp lica t e d in the c ont r o l o f vi s ual at ten tion (Bi sley & Goldb erg, 2010 ; Ca b eza, Ciaram e lli, & M o scovi t c h, 201 2 ) but al so in t he retri eval and r epre s ent ation o f e pi s o di c ( Se stie ri, S hulman, & Co rbe tta , 2 017; Wa gn er , Shann o n, Khan , & B uckne r , 2005) an d s e ma ntic i nf or ma t i on (Bind er e t a l., 200 9 ). In lin e wit h other rec en t theory ( Humphrey s, L ambon Ral ph, & Si m ons , 2021) , our t ent ativ e ac coun t i s tha t thi s a spec t of IPL / SPL is a hu b in the compa r i son o f v isu al c haract eri stic s o f th e at tend ed stimul us t o c atego ry templa t e s re tri eved from memory, i n thi s way acting a s an imp or t ant w ay sta tion in t he at ten tion - medi ate d cl assi fic a tion and ab s t rac tion o f vi s ua l inp ut. .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint 19 Inte rpre ta tion o f the c lu s t e r cen tr ed on t he r i ght in sula i s fu nda men tally chal lengi n g bec aus e of the bread th of fun cti onal r ol e s a ssoci at ed with t hi s a rea (Udd in et al. , 2017; G a squoin e , 2014). A co mpelling pos s ibi li ty, how ever , i s that t his r efl ec ts th e role o f in sula a n d s u rroun ding brain ti s s ue in the ‘ sali e nce ne twork’, a s e t o f br a in a re as impl ica ted in th e id en tifica tion o f hom eo sta tic rel e vanc e and behav iour al impo r t anc e (Se el ey e t al ., 2 007). The s a li enc e ne twork i s thou gh t t o guide t h e flow of inf orma tion t h roug h oth er br ain ne t w or k s in t he suppor t o f at ten tional proc e ssing and o ther co gnitive oper ation s (Men on & U d din , 2 010 ) . U nl ike I PL/SPL , ca teg ory info rmatio n i n insula co r rela t e d di scr et ely with ERP lat erali ty in the la te ncy of the N2pc, i mplica t i ng th e N2pc s p e cific ally in the pr o p agatio n of in forma tion to thi s area . The eme r g ence o f at ten tion -media ted cat eg or y informa tion in t his clu s ter s ug ge sts a rol e for th e in sula a nd surroundi ng ti ssu e i n t he proce ssing o f abs tr a c ted ob jec t info rmatio n t o guide e valu ation o f beh aviou ral r e leva nce a nd t he prepa ra tion o f a co gnitive r e s pon s e, po s sibly in the c on te xt of c ur ren t pa rtic ipan t s ta te and ta sk motivation . The clust er cen tre d on VMP F C is the la r g est of the 3, ha s the st r on ge st rel a tion s hi p with N2pc , and uniqu ely sh ows a link t o b ot h ta r g e t-e lici t e d and di stract or -elic it ed N2pc, with tar get c atego ry informa tion red ucing in thi s ar ea a s a f un ction o f t he mi s-d eployme n t of a tt enti on to the di s tract or. As with the i n s ula , thi s cor tica l are a h a s b een a s socia ted with ex ten s i ve fu nc t i on ality (St alnak er , Cooc h, & Sch oenb aum, 2015). Promin e n t is the ide a t ha t it car rie s inf orma tion a b out th e ab stra cted ec onomic utility o f g ood s and a cti on s - t he ‘c ommon c ur renc y’ hy po the si s (L evy & Gli mche r, 20 12; Pad oa -Sch iop pa & Cone n, 2017). T hi s kin d of s ign al is n ec e ssary in ec on omica lly n or ma t i ve mod el s of le a r n ing an d dec i s ion maki ng to all ow the u t il i ty of di spa rat e g ood s and ou tco mes to be dir ec t ly co mpared. H owe ver, ou r re sul ts sh ow th e emergenc e of a t t enti on-m ed iat ed c at e gory in f o r ma t i on in this are a w hen c atego rie s do no t e xplic itl y di ff e r i n val ue. Thi s i s in line w ith th e kn own inv olve ment of thi s a rea in s e man tic s (Bind e r e t al. , 20 09), but i s dif fic ul t to re solv e w it h th e n otion th at t he c or e re spon s ib ili ty of thi s br ain ar ea i s to r epr ese nt valu e ab strac ted from c on t e xt and stimuli . Rece n t model s o f OF C / VM PF C functi on s ugg est that th is b rain reg ion ma y be b etter d e sc r ibe d a s invo lved in the de rivation o f ta s k s t ate f rom d i s pa r a t e attribu te s of en vironmen tal objec ts and contex t (Pe ll eti er & F ellow s , 2 021; Kle in -Flüg ge, Bong ioanni , & Ru shw orth, 2 022) and in t he e stabli shm ent o f co gnitive maps o f t ask spac e (H a yden & Niv, 2 021; Niv, 2019; Schuc k, Ca i, Wil s on, & N i v, 201 6). The cu r ren t re sul ts a r e e a sily des c ribed in thi s th eor etic al c on text: s tr ong at ten tion al sel e ction o f a beha viourall y -re leva nt vi sual ob jec t le ad s t o t he ac tiv ation o f a cog nitive ma p in OFC / VM PFC t h a t inc ludes in fo rmation a bout the targe t ob je ct ca t e gory an d i t s a s s ocia te d re s po nse . W he n a tt entio n is mis- deploy ed to th e di str actor , ta rget in f ormation in thi s cog nitive ma p i s degrad e d. As no ted a bov e, a motiva tion for E xperi ment 2 was t o addr e s s t he po s s ibi li ty tha t the r ela t i on s hi p betwe e n N2pc and c at egory in forma t i o n identi fied in r e s u lts from Ex perimen t 1 w as drive n by the .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint 20 enc oding of vi sual f e a tur e s . In t h i s c on te xt, one dat a pa tter n i n Expe r i ment 2 i s n otable for i ts abs enc e. We do n o t see t ha t t h e N2pc r o bus tly predic t s MR I -de r iv ed c a tego ry i nfo r ma t i on in v i s ua l co r tex . Thi s null findi ng is , o f cour s e, am bi guous, bu t sugge st s th at ou r e xperime nta l de sign w a s succ e ss ful in ident ifying inf ormati on a b s t racted fr om the visu al f e atu r e s th at c har acteri s ed the st i mulu s. That i s, ou r s timulu s se t wa s vis uall y hete roge nou s, with few low - or mi d -level vis ual fea tur es tha t coul d be c on s i s t ently u s ed t o inf er ca te gory memb ership . As a res ul t, c atego riza tion relied on a s et o f idi o s y ncratic di agno stic fea ture s for e a ch i mage - for e xampl e , cl assi fic ati on of a cu pcak e as food r eli ed o n a dif fe rent set of fe at ur e s t han did c la ssific a tion o f a co urge t t e a s f ood. Bec au se a tt ention ac ted o n a varyi ng se t of rel ev ant fea tur e s fo r e ach image , a tt e ntional sel ec tion did not cau se c on s i s t ent ac c en t ua t i on o f a pa r tic ula r s et o f f ea ture s , and th ere fo r e di d not pro duce a co ns i st ent p at tern o f ac tivi ty i n visual cor tex that c oul d be leve ra ged by the c la ssi f ier to i mpr ov e perf ormanc e . In t his , re sul t s fr om Ex periment 2 pr ov ide some r ea ssura nce t h a t fi ndings f rom unimod al EE G a naly si s in E xperiment 1 ar e not drive n entir ely by the re pre s enta ti on of v isu al fea tur es . Import antly, thi s d o e s n ot imply t ha t t h e att entio n-me diat ed r e p r e s e nta tion s th at w e identify in pos ter i or pari et al c ortex , insul a, and pr ef rontal c o rt e x ar e ne ce s s a r i ly amo dal or i nst anti ate d inde pend ent o f sen so r i moto r sy st em s ( M a hon & Car amazz a , 2009). The r ela tio n s hip be tween N 2pc and categ o r y informa tion w e ide n t i fy is n ot a s imple r e fl ec tion o f at t e n t i onal ef fec ts o n visual fea tur es , but i s lik ely to c on tain sema n t i c fea ture s that a re g r ou nd ed in sen so rimo tor sys tem s, inc luding informa tion ab o ut t h e s pe ci fic motor re spon se a ssocia t e d with e ach cat egory (Bar sal ou, 2020 ). The pa t te rn w e ide n t i f y - tha t at te ntional e f fect s on p erc ep tual r epr es ent at ions in la ter al oc cipital cort ex pr e dict s t h e quali t y of pe rce ption -a bs t rac ted in forma tion e lsew he re in t he b rain - is ve r y much in line with mod er n acc ount s of ground ed s eman t ic repr e sen tati on ( C hen, Lambon Ralph , & Roger s, 2017 ; M a rtin, 2016) . In a dditi on to ou r ide nti fica tion o f at ten ti on-medi at ed pr op aga tion o f s ema n tic in fo r ma t i on , re s ul ts from Ex perimen t 2 prov ided t he op po r tu nity to iden tify br a i n s t ruc ture s wh ere N2 pc am plitude predic te d unimoda l fMRI ac t i vatio n. Thi s identi fie s a se t of b rai n ar ea s inc luding le ft MF G (incl uding the le f t fron tal eye fie ld s; Balda uf & De si mone, 2 014), le f t IP L ex te nding i nto TP J, and bilat eral dmSF G (Figur e 7 ). All of the se a rea s ha ve doc umented role s i n a tten tion al c ontr ol. As no ted ab ov e, the F EF a nd I PL are co re nod es in the fro ntopari et al netwo rk imp lementing s t rat e gic atten tional co nt rol, and the b roa d er MF G and la t e ra l pos t e r io r pa r i etal c o r tex have be en impl ic ated in th e u s e of at ten tion for seman tic ex t r ac tion . Si milarly, dmSFG c ont ain s eye fi eld s and play s a rol e in s acc adic co nt rol . This s ug ge sts t hat a c tivity in the s e area s ma y be i nvolv ed in th e e s t abl i s h me nt and inst anti ation o f a tten t io n al c ontrol, s uc h that their ac tivation ca us e s an i ncre a se i n N2pc ampli t u de . .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint 21 This a ccou nt i s r ei nfo r c ed by th e temp or al pa t t ern o f th e r e la tion ship b etwe en d mSF G and N2pc , and betwe en I PL a nd N2pc, wher e la te r a l ity in t he ERP pr ec eding t h e N 2 pc w indo w pr e dict s activ ity in the se a r e a s (F ig 7b ) . In c oncl us i on , we t r ac k the i mpact o f spa tia l at ten tion on the s pr ead o f conc eptu a l i nfor ma t i on in the huma n br ain. Our re sul ts de mon stra t e the tim e-c o ur s e o f thi s p ropa gati on of i nfor m a tion and iden t i fy thre e key brain st r u ctur e s c arryi ng abstrac te d, a tte ntion -medi a te d info r mation: the la ter al pos ter i or pari et al c ortex , the a n t e rio r i n sula , and t h e ventr omedia l pr e fron t a l co rt ex . The e mergenc e of la te r a l p os t e rior pa r i e t a l co r t ex in thi s con t e xt i s clos ely in li ne wi t h pr i o r re s ear ch on spa tial att entio n, b ut the iden ti fic atio n of in sula and VM PFC i s un expe cted a n d, a s a re sul t, co n s tr ain s and gui des f u nctio nal int erpre ta t i on o f th e se s t ructur e s in broa d er con tex ts. Thi s brai n network interve n e s b etw een p e r c ept ion a nd ac t i on, tr a ns l a ting v is u a l inf ormati on to c onc e pt u al kn owledg e and action pla ns .

Methods

Human participants All pa r tic ip ant s wer e r ec rui ted from t he Unive rsity of Bi r min gham c ommunity, pro vided writte n inform ed c ons ent , rep orte d normal o r c o r rec t ed -to -no r ma l vision , and rep ort ed n o h istory of neurolog ica l o r psychi a tr ic di sord er s . All demograph ic s col lect ed from e xperime n tal par ticipa n ts a r e repor ted an d r e sul ts ca n be ex pect ed t o general i se t o t h e Europ ean popul ation fr om w hich t h e sampl e was t aken . Expe r i m ental p roce du re s w ere app rov ed by t he Un iver s i t y o f B irmingh am ST EM ethic s c ommitt ee a nd the C HBH H e al th a nd Safe ty c ommitte e. Experiment 1 Forty- nine pa rticipa n t s w ere r ecrui ted. T wo w ere ex cluded f r om analy s is d ue t o e xc es s ive eye move ment ar te fact s in th e EEG ( r e jecti o n of >40% of tr i al s), t w o we re exc luded a s re sul t s s how ed no co ns i st ent evi dence o f a ta rget -eli ci ted N 2pc (ie. in t h e 1140 ite r a t i o ns e mploye d f or cla ssi fica t io n, the la t e ra l targ et -elic it ed signal s how ed c ontr a la te ral po sitive p olari ty more o ft e n than neg a tive pola r i t y ; p er -par t i cipa n t p < 0.0 5, bin omia l te st), and a sing le p artic ip ant wa s e xcl uded due to low ac curac y in t a s k p er for ma nce ( < 70% a cc ur a cy; f i nal sampl e of 44; a ge mea n = 21 . 8, st d = 2.7; 2 3 femal e; 3 le f t -han d ed) . The experim e nt too k approx imately 2.5 ho ur s, inc luding EE G prepa rati on, ta sk traini ng , break s, a n d debri ef , a nd pa rticip an ts w e re co mpen sa te d at £10 / h ou r. .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint 22 Experiment 2 Thirty-ni n e par ticip ant s w e re rec ruit ed. T wo pa r tic ipan t s were exc luded from an a l ysis du e to ex ces s i ve ey e mov emen t ar te fac ts in t he EEG (rejecti on of >40% of t r i al s), 4 partic i pant s were ex clude d due to i ncompl e te data c oll ec t i on due to tec hnic al i s s u e s o r e quipmen t fail ure , and 2 partic ipan t s were ex clude d due t o l ow ac curac y i n tas k pe rf ormance (<70% acc ura cy ; final s ampl e o f 31; age me an=23 . 2, s td =3 .8; 19 fe male ; 3 left -han ded ). T he ex pe riment took a pp roximatel y 4 h ours, inc luding EEG prepar ation , M RI s c re enin g, t a s k tr a ining, b r ea k s, and d e br i ef, and p art ic ipan t s we r e co mpens at ed at £15 /hour . Experimental task Par tic ipant s in bo th ex perim ent s pe rf orme d a v is ua l sea rch ta sk a nd a r epe t i t i on detect ion t a s k in interl ea ved bl ock s (4 bl ock s of 12 8 t r i al s for e ach t a s k with c ount erb alanc ed o rde r). Compl e tion o f the v is u a l s earch ta sk took longe r - app ro xima t e ly 75% of the e xper iment du rati on - and on ly thi s ta sk is t rea ted in t he curr ent p ape r. In e ach experim en t a l tr i al , pa rtic ipant s w ere a s ke d to rep ort t he s e ma ntic c at egor y of a targe t obj ect (Fig 1a) th at a pp ear ed in a c ued loc a tion an d to ignor e a di st r ac tor o bject tha t a pp eared i n a n un- cu ed loc ation (Fi g 1b). Each trial b egan with a fixati on di s p lay on white b ack groun d (1550 – 1850 ms , randomly s elec ted f r om a unif orm di strib ution) tha t co nt a in ed 4 grey c ircle s (E1: 5 .7° vis ual angle ; E2: 4.2° ) direc tly abov e and b elow (E 1 : 7. 4° vi s ua l a ngl e; E2: 5.2 °) a c entra l fixa t i o n mark. T he fix ati on mark was repl ac ed by the l et ter ‘ R’ or ‘ G’ (135 0 – 165 0 ms), whic h indi ca ted t he red or gre en c olor o f the c ircle id enti fying the t arge t in t he s u bse que n t sea r c h a rray. I n the se arch a rra y , imag es o f co mplete obje c t s appe ared withi n the tw o circ les that h ad red o r g r e en c ol or. The ob ject s were tool s, veh icle s, a nimal s, or food s, a nd we re s elec t e d fr o m an ima ge se t co nt a i ning equal n umber s o f eac h c atego ry (E1 : 160 ob ject s in to tal; E 2: 120 objects ; Fig . 1a) tak en from th e B OSS dat aba se (Brod eur, Dionn e- Do s t i e, M ontre uil, & Le page, 2010) o r ope n o nline image re po sitorie s . Ima ge ex amples w e r e s e lec ted from e ach c ateg ory r a ndomly without r epla cem ent un til the se t was ex haus t e d and the proc e s s re s et. Th e oth er t w o ci r c le s in th e d i s pl ay c ontai ned u nr e cogni s abl e morphed ver s io n s o f th e sam e imag e se t (Stojan oski & Cu sac k, 201 4; max dis t or ti on 16 0, ns t e p s 4 , itera tion 9 ), s el ec ted i n a simila r m ann er . The s ea r c h arr ay su s t a ined for 60 0 m s a nd the ne xt tr i al beg an eith er i mmedia tely a ft er re s p on se or a f t e r 1 800 ms . The expe r ime n tal ta sk w a s t o id enti fy, v ia righ t hand r e spon s e , whic h obje ct ca t e gory ap pear ed in the c ued c ircle . Two of t h e cat eg or i e s we re a s s o ciat ed with inde x fing er r e s p on se an d the o the rs wi t h middle fi nge r re s p on se, with th e ma pping o f cat eg or y to r espon se c oun terb a lan ced a cro ss partic ipan t s . I n Ex periment 1 r e spon se w as ma d e via a s tanda rd k eyboard ; i n Expe r i men t 2 re spon s e .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint 23 wa s v ia a n MRI -compa t i ble bu tto n box . The r e spon s e a s s o ciat ed with th e ta rge t o bject w as alwa y s oppo site to th at a s socia t e d with the d i s t r actor obje c t. The expe r ime n t began with v erb al ins tr u c tion s and pa rtic ipan t s s u b seque n t l y c ompleted traini ng until the y ac hi eve d ~80% ac curac y, wh ich rarely to ok l onger th an a s in gle bl ock o f t ri a ls. In Ex periment 2 tr aini ng took p lace out s id e of th e sca nn er. Eac h expe r i men tal blo ck w as compo sed o f 128 t ria l s i n random o rder , w ith eac h t r i a l refl ec ting one combi n ation o f c ue c olo r, target and dist r a ct or cat eg ory, and ta r g e t and di s t ra ctor po siti on. In Experim e nt 1, st i muli we r e pre sen ted via a 59.5 cm x 33.5 cm L CD monitor a t 60 H z and a dis tance o f 60 c m. In Experimen t 2 , s timul i we re pre sen ted vi a a P roPi XX projec tor a t 1 00 Hz v iewe d via a mirror mount ed on th e sc anne r h e ad c oil. The expe r ime n tal proc e dur e relie d on th e P sychT oolbox 3 toolbox (Bra inar d, 199 7) for M a tl ab 2017 a. Data acquisition and preprocessing: Experiment 1 Ele ctrophy siologi cal da ta wa s a cquir ed fr om sint ere d Ag / Ag Cl elec t rod e s at 1 kHz using a Bio s emi Activ eTwo amplifie r . EEG wa s c ollec te d f r o m 128 e lectr ode s fi tte d in a n ela s tic c a p a t equidi s tant enc ephal ic sit e s, horizonta l elec t r ooc ulo gram (H EOG ) wa s c ollec te d from 2 ele ct ro de s locat ed 1 cm later al to t h e ex terna l ca n t hi o f the l ef t a n d r i ght eye , ver tic al el e ctro oculog r a m ( VEOG) w a s co llec t e d fr om 2 el ec tr o d e s i mmediat el y abov e and below th e right ey e, and unu se d re fere nce signal s w er e col lect ed f r om 2 elec trode s pla ced over th e le ft a nd right ma stoi d pr oc ess e s. EEG w a s re sampled o ffli ne t o 200 H z, dig itally fil te red wi t h s ym metr ic Hamming wind owed fin it e -impul s e re spon s e ke rnel s (h igh-pa ss a t 0.0 5 Hz , - 6 dB at 0.02 5 Hz ; lo w -pa s s a t 45 Hz , - 6 d B at 50. 6 Hz ) , ref ere nce d to the av e rage o f encep h alic cha nnel s, and b a sel ined o n t he 200 m s interva l pr ece ding st i mulu s on se t. N oi sy channe l s wer e vi s u a lly id enti fied a nd in ter pola ted u sing sph e r i cal splin e interp ola t i o n. In depe n den t compo nen t a nal ys i s ( IC A) o f c ombined EEG and E O G d ata wa s us ed to iden t i fy data v ari anc e re s u l t i ng f rom ey e movem ent s . T r i al s with ey e mov ement s i n the 500 ms interva l follow ing s timulu s on se t were r e mov ed from ana ly si s and t he I CA compo nen ts re fl ec t i ng ey e arte fac ts we r e s ub seq uen t ly remove d f rom t h e dat a. Data acquisition and preprocessing: Experiment 2 MRI Whole -bra in s c a nning employ ed a 3 T Sie mens Pr i s ma MR I s c an ner a n d 64 c hanne l head-c oi l. Fun ctional da ta w a s a cqui red u s in g an e c ho pl anar ima ging (EPI) se quence wit h 57 axi al slice s of 84 x 84 v oxel s , fi e ld- of -view (FO V ) 210 mm x 210 mm, slice thick ne ss 2.5 mm, sl ice ga p 0 mm, repeti tion time (T R) 1.5 s , ec ho tim e (TE) 35 ms , flip a ngle (F A ) 71°, mul ti-b and acc ele ra tion fa ctor 3. S t ruc t u ral data wa s ac quir ed u sing a T1-we ight ed MPRA GE s eque nc e wi t h 208 a xial s li ce s o f 257 x 257 vo x els, .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint 24 FOV 256 mm x 2 56 mm, slic e thic knes s 1 mm, slic e gap 0 mm, T R 2 s, TE 2 .03 ms, FA 8 ° . Fo r co r rec t i on of o the r imag e s , a fi el d map w as acq ui r e d u sing a doubl e- ec ho sequ enc e with 3 6 ax ial slice s o f 6 4 x 6 4 vox els, FOV 192 m m x 192 mm, slic e thic kne s s 3 .75 mm, s lic e ga p 0 mm, TR 400 m s , TE 1 4 .92 ms, TE 2 7. 38 ms, FA 45 ° . Fo ur -le ad vectorc ard iogram ( VC G ) was r ec or d e d in the sc a nner from el ec tr o d e s i n a stan dard c he st m on t a ge. VC G w a s r ec or ded a t MRI cloc k s pe ed (5 kHz ) an d wa s synch r oni sed with thi s s i gnal. MRI ima ge s were co rr e c ted for he a d mo veme nt, f ield m ap inhomo ge neity , a nd sl ic e-acqu i s i tion dela y (u sing the middl e s lic e a s re fe renc e ) bef ore b ein g normali se d to M on tr eal Ne ur ol ogic al Ins titu t e (M N I) spac e, int erpol ate d t o 2m m isot r opi c v oxel s iz e, a nd s p a tially s mo o the d u s i ng an iso tr op ic G au s s i an ke r n e l (6mm full widt h ha lf max imum). G ene ral l inea r mode l a nal ysi s ( GLM) o f the f MRI time- s erie s d ata r eli ed o n the G L M sing le t oolbox ( Prince, Cha re st, Kur za w ks i , Pyl e, Tar r, & Kay , 2022 ) . G L M s in gle id en ti fie s hemody n amic kernel fu nc tion s, d erive s nui sanc e regre s s o rs , and ch oose s an optimal ridg e regul a r i sa tion shrinka ge fr ac t i on for eac h vox el to produ c e an e s tima te o f single -t rial voxe l-wi se b eta value s . T o ali g n EPI v olumes wi t h t he on se t o f visua l s timulatio n , th e EPI time s eri es wa s up - sample d to 6.7 Hz (15 0 ms per im age ) prior to li ne ar model ling using sha pe - pre serving piece wi se cu bic i n t e r p ol ati on (a s imple men ted in th e tse rie sin terp .m f unc t i on inc luded in knk utils to olbox; http s: / /gi thub. com /cvnl ab/knkutil s ). An al ys i s w a s con stra ined to v oxels out side o f the brai n stem, the ven tricle s , a n d the c e rebellum . EEG Ele ctrophy siologi cal da ta wa s a cquir ed in the sc an ne r fr om s in ter ed Ag /AgCl el ec trode s u sing a Brain Produc t s Brain Amp MR amplifi er . EE G was c ollec ted fr om 63 ele c trod e s f i t t ed in a Brai n Cap MR I- co mpatible el a st i c c ap a t ex tend ed 1 0/ 2 0 ence phalic sit e s a nd singl e-l e ad el e ctr o cardiog r a m (ECG ) wa s rec o rded from an e lect rode l oca ted o n the bac k 10 cm c auda l to th e top o f th e sho uld er a nd 5 cm t o the le ft o f th e s pine . All dat a acqui s iti on was a t MR I c lock s p e ed (5 k H z) and sync hroniz ed wi t h this s i gnal . Pre proc e s s ing bega n with c or r e ction for M R gradi en t ar tif act s u s i ng Br ainVi sion A na lyzer 2 (v 2.2). Gradi ent trigge rs sen t by the s c a nner we re used a s t i me ma rke rs f or ar tif act trai ns and co nt i nuou s ar t i fa ct s wer e c or r ec ted u sin g templ at e sub t rac tion ba s ed on a sliding averag e of 21 TR interva l s (w i th ba selin e corr ection ). The EEG w as s ub sequ e nt l y dow n s am pled to 250 H z an d co r rec te d f or cardio ba lli stic ( CB ) a rte fac t s . T he CB c orrec tio n alg orith m s e mi -au to matica lly det ect s pea ks fr om h ear tbea t signal s. In t he 124 e xperiment al block s analy z ed ( 4 for eac h of 31 partic ipan t s ) , t he s ig nal qu a lity a nd av ail abi lity of h e artbe a t s ig nal s varie d: V CG w as u sed for co r rec t i on in 52 block s , ECG wa s u sed in 48 bloc ks, and the r e m aining 24 blo cks r elie d on a h e ar t - bea t I CA compon e nt d erived f rom th e EEG. A run ning averag e o f 21 bea t s was u s e d to gen era te a templa t e and the a rti fac t tim e del ay w a s automa tic ally e s tima t e d u sing a 40 s in te rval. Sub sequ ent .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint 25 dig it a l fil tering, b a selining , noi sy c hann el interp olati on, I CA, a nd tri al r ej ecti on p ara mete r s w ere a s desc ribed for Experime n t 1. The ave rag e number o f i nt e r pol a ted c hann el s wa s 0 .2 9 and t he numbe r of ind ep ende nt c ompone nt s rem oved was 2.0 . The mea n numb er o f c orr e c t tr i al epo ch s contai ni ng ex ces s i ve noi s e o r e ye mov emen t s was 2 7 ( S D = 26) , a nd th e me an numb er o f i ncorrec t trial s wa s 5 2 trial s (S D = 36 ) , leav ing a r ou n d 433 trial s per pa rtic ipan t fo r ana ly si s ( S D = 41). Quantification and statistical analyses Classification of EEG In bo t h expe rime nts , mac hine -le a rning c las s i fi cati on o f mul ticha nnel EE G d ata r eli ed on LDA a nd cros s- fold vali dati on. A s no ted a bo ve, EE G clas si fica tio n reli ed on te mpora l s earch l ights d efin ed ac r o ss a w indow of ~85 m s (17 s ampl e s i n Exp er i ment 1; 21 sa mple s in Ex perime nt 2). T r i a ls we re not av erag ed pr i or to cla s s i fic ation . For c l assi fic ati on of b oth EE G and M RI, e ach d ata f ea ture in t he training s e t (ie . voltag e a t one EEG c h ann el or a ctiva ti on o f one v oxel ) wa s z-sc o r e d acros s obs ervati on s. The mean a nd s t a nd ard de v iation v alue s deriv e d fro m normali sa tio n of th e t rai ning s et we r e r e t a in ed a nd u s e d in no rmal i s a t i o n of th e te s t set . In Experiment 1 , we ad opt ed a valid ati on scheme in c la s s i fic atio n of EE G t h at invol v ed pa r ti tionin g of trial s int o 20 chunk s , w ith 3 a nd 17 c hun ks ex hau st i vely alloc a ted in to t raini ng set s a nd t e s t se t s over 1140 itera tion s. I n Ex periment 2, trial s w ere pa rti tioned i n t o 10 ch unks , with 2 an d 8 chunk s ex haus t i vely alloc at ed into te st and t r ain i ng set s o ve r 45 iter atio ns . In bo th expe r i m ent s , th e cl assi fic atio n re sul ts re fle ct me an acc ura cy over itera tion s and pa rticipa n ts (Fi gur es 2c a nd 2 f) . Stati s tica l s i gnific anc e r e f l ect s a naly s i s o f be t w een -pa rtic ipa nt va r i anc e us i ng cl us t er- ba sed co r rec t i on over tim e with c luster d e fi nin g thre shold a t p < 0.05 and c lu ster signi f i canc e at p < 0.05 (Mari s & Oo s t e nveld, 2007 ). Cond iti onal di f f e renc e s in c la ss i fic a tion l a tencie s a r e directly interp re table , but th e ab solu te v alue s sh ould be int er p ret ed with c are a s the filte ring of EEG and u s e of t emporal s e a r c hligh ts mea nt t h a t the cla ssi fier h ad acc e ss to EE G da ta r ecorde d up to ~50 ms later than the nomina l la tenc y. Coupling variance in N2pc to variance in EEG-derived category information As d esc ribed i n th e re s u l ts secti on, we c o upled N 2pc ampl itu de t o EEG-d eriv ed t ar get c atego ry informa tion u s ing an i tera tiv e re sa mplin g approac h. Thi s ga r ne r ed 1140 v alue pai rs con taini ng mea n N2pc amplitude a nd mea n cla ssi fica t i on ac curac y for e ac h partic ip ant . The r e l atio nship b etw ee n the se va r i a ble s wa s an aly sed u sing mixed linear mo delli ng as implem e nte d in the fi t l me .m func t i o n for Ma tlab ( sta ti s tic s t o ol box R20 22a) . In mixed linear mod elling , r estric ted maxim um like lihood w as use d for va r i a nce e stima t i o n, Akai ke in fo rmation cri teri on (A IC ) wa s us ed f or mod e l co mpari s on , an d ANOVA d eriv atio ns employ ed Sa tt erthw ai t e app roxim ation s o f degr ee s o f fr eed o m. .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint 26 Classification of MRI As in an a lysi s o f EEG, mac hine -l e arning c l as s i fic ati on of MRI r e s u lt s labe lled th e ta rge t or di strac tor ca tegory in indivi dual t rial s u sing L DA an d c r o ss -fo ld va lidati on. S e archl ight sph er es wer e co nstrain ed when b ound by t h e edge o f brain spac e and the mea n sph er e v olume w as 111.8 voxe l s . Cla s sifica t io n wa s c omple ted u sing t w o va lidation s c h eme s. In the fir st, 4- fold c r o s s-v alida t i o n was empl oyed to g en era te t he re sul t s illu st r a ted in Fig ure 5 . S ub s e qu ently, 1 140- fold c r os s - v alida t i on wa s u sed to i den tify c ovaria nc e i n MRI cl a ssi fic ati on and N 2pc . Mean M RI cla ssific a t i on r esul ts f or 4- fold a nd 1140 - f ol d cla s si fica t i on wer e ver y simila r . Stati s tica l anal y s i s of cla s si ficati on r e sul t s employ ed t- te st s of se archli ght cla ssi fica t i on ac cur ac y ag ains t a null o f cha nce pe r fo rmanc e . Re sult s we re c lu ste r c orre cte d for mul tipl e comp arison s w it h a cl us t er de fin ing th re shold o f p < 0.001 a n d cl us t er signific anc e at p < 0 .05 (Ma ri s & O os tenve ld , 2007 ). Sta ti st i cal con tra st s of targe t v ers us di strac to r cla ssi fica tion acc uracy re lie d on s im ilar parame t e rs, bu t w ith t-t e st s c on tra sting r e s ult s from th e two a naly se s . Coupling variance in N2pc to variance in MRI-derived semantic category information Identi fic a tion o f th e r e la tion ship b etw e e n N2pc amplitude a nd MRI -de rive d ta rge t ca t e go ry i n f o r m at i o n f o ll o w e d t he s am e a nal y t i c s ch e m a as in an a ly s is of EEG fr o m Ex p er im en t 1 , w it h t he adde d dimen sion o f s e a r c hlight l oca tion . Stati stic al a naly si s of re sult s from t his an al ysi s e mploye d one- tai l ed t -te st s o f correl ation valu e s a gains t a nul l hypoth e si s of z ero . Re sult s w ere cl u s t er co r rec te d f or multipl e c ompari son s with a clust er de fining th r e s hol d of p < 0 . 001 an d clus ter signific anc e at p < 0.05. In ROI a n alysi s , region s we re de fined b a se d on re sul ts fr om se archl ight a na lysi s ill ustra ted in Fi gure 6. We appli ed our 1140 -f old c las si fica tio n t e chnique to th e vox el pa t t ern e xt r a ct e d from ea ch o f the se R OI s , gen era ting 1140 v alue p air s c ontainin g mean N 2p c and mean c la s s i f i c ation acc ura cy for eac h ROI . Fi s her - tran sform ed Pe ar s on co rrela tion s we re calc ulat ed fo r e ach R O I a nd re s u lts for e ac h ROI wer e sta tis t i call y a s s e ssed u sing a pe rmutati on te s t with 50 k iter atio ns . Sta ti s tica l anal y s i s of time-c o urse r e sult s within e a ch c lus t e r rel ied on t emp or a l cl u ster co rrec t i on with a clust er -de fining thre s ho ld of p < 0 .05 a nd clu ste r signi fic a nce at p < 0.05 . Coupling variance in N2pc to variance in MRI voxel activity Identi fic a tion o f th e r e la tion ship b etw e e n N2pc amplitude a nd vox el a ctivi t y follo we d muc h the same sche m a as d e scribed immedi a te ly ab ove but a sse s s ing vox el ac tivity r a the r tha n s e a r c hlig ht cl assi fic atio n ac curac y. I n R O I ana ly s i s, r e gion s w er e de fine d ba s ed on re sul t s illu s t ra ted in Fig ure 7 . Stati s tica l anal y s i s of the s e re sul ts r e lied on t he s a me p ermut ation te st s d e s c r i bed abov e, an d .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint 27 sta t i s t ic al ana ly si s of time-c our se r e s u lts relie d on c lu ster c orrec ti on wi t h t h e sa me parame t e r s desc ribed ab ove .

References

Acun z o, D . J ., Low, D . M ., & F airhal l , S. L . (2022 ). De ep neur al netwo rks r evea l t opi c-l evel repr ese nt ation s o f s en ten ce s in me di al p ref ront al c orte x, la t e r a l an teri or t empora l l obe, precu neu s , and a ngular g yru s . Neur oIma g e, 251 , 11900 5. Amiez, C ., & Pe trid es , M. (200 9). Anat omic al orga niz a t io n o f the ey e fie ld s in t he h uman a nd non - huma n primat e fr ontal c o r tex . Progr e s s i n neurobiol o gy, 8 9(2), 220 -230 . Bald au f, D ., & De s imo n e, R. (201 4) . Neu ra l mec hani sms o f objec t-ba sed at t e n t i on . Sc ienc e, 344(6 182), 424 -4 27. Barbar o, L ., P ee l en, M . V. , & Hic key , C . (2 017). V alenc e , not u tili t y , und erlie s r ew a r d - d riv en prioriti z a ti on in hum an vi s ion . Jo ur na l o f Neuro s c i enc e, 37(43 ) , 10438 -10 450. Barr, D. J ., L evy, R., Sc he epe rs, C ., & Ti ly, H. J. (201 3). R andom e ffe ct s s tr uctur e fo r con f i r ma t o r y hyp ot he s i s t es t i ng: Ke e p it max imal. Jou r nal of memory and la nguage , 68(3 ), 2 55 - 278. Bar salou , L . W. (2016 ) . O n s tayi ng groun de d and a voidin g quix otic de a d end s. P syc honomic bulletin & r e view , 23, 1122 -1142. Binde r , J . R ., D esa i, R. H ., G rave s , W . W. , & Con a nt , L. L . (2009 ) . W he re i s t he se mantic s y st em? A critic al rev iew a nd me ta -an aly si s o f 120 f unc tional ne uroimagi ng st u di e s . C ere bral c or tex , 19(12 ) , 2767 -279 6. Bisl ey, J. W ., & G old b erg, M . E. (2010) . At tenti on, int enti on , and pr iori ty in the par ie t a l lob e. An nual revie w of ne ur o sci enc e, 33, 1-21 . Bracc i, S ., & de B eec k, H. O . (201 6 ). Di sso ci ation s and a s socia tio n s be t w een sh ape and c atego ry repr ese nt ation s in the two vi sual pa t hw a ys. Jo urnal o f Neu r o sci e nce, 36(2 ), 432 - 4 44. Braina rd, D. H . ( 1 997 ). The p s y chophy s i cs to olbox. Spa tial visio n, 1 0(4 ), 433-436 . Bris son, B . , Robit aill e, N., & Jolic œu r, P . (2 007). S t i mulu s in ten s i t y a ff ect s th e la te n cy b ut not the ampl itude o f th e N2pc . Neuro r e p or t , 18 (1 5), 1627 - 1 630. Broadb en t , D . E. (1958) . Pe rcepti on and co mmunica t i on. New Y or k , Pe rga mon P r ess . Brodeu r, M. B ., D i onne - Do s ti e, E., M ontr euil, T ., & Lepa ge, M . (20 10) . The Bank o f S tandard ized Stimul i (B O S S), a new s et o f 480 norma ti ve photo s o f o bject s to b e us ed a s v is u a l st i muli in co gnitive r e s e a r c h. PloS one , 5 (5) , e1077 3 . Buzsá ki, G. (201 9) . The brai n fr o m in side out. Ox ford Unive rsity Pr e s s . Cabe za, R. , Cia rame lli, E., & Mo s c ovi tch, M . (2012) . Cog ni tive cont ributio ns of t he ve nt ral pari et al co r tex : an i n t e gra tive th eor etic al a cco un t . Trend s in c ognitive s c ie nc e s , 16(6 ), 338 -3 52. Chen, L. , L ambon Ralph, M . A . , & Ro g er s , T . T. (20 17). A uni fie d model o f human s emantic kno wledg e and it s di sord er s . Na t u re h uman be ha vio ur, 1(3 ), 0039. Corb et ta, M ., & Shu lma n, G . L . (2002) . Co ntr ol o f goal -di r e c ted an d stimul u s -d rive n att ention in the brain. Natu re r ev iews ne uro scie nc e, 3 (3 ), 201-215 . Corb et ta, M ., P a tel , G. , & Shulm an , G. L. (2008). T he reor ient ing sy stem o f th e h u man brain: f rom env ironmen t to th eory o f mi nd. N euron , 58(3), 306 -324. Corb et ta, M ., P a tel , G. , & Shulm an , G. L. (2008). T he reor ient ing sy stem o f th e h u man brain: f rom env ironmen t to th eory o f mi nd. N euron , 58(3), 306 -324. De simone , R., & Dunc an, J . (19 95) . Ne ura l Mec hani sms o f Sel e ctive V i s ua l A tt e n t io n. Annual R eview of N euro s c ienc e, 18, 193–22 2. Ding, L. (202 3) . Co ntrib ution s o f th e Ba sa l Gang lia to Vi sual P erce ptua l Deci sion s . Annual Revie w o f Vi sion S cienc e , 9, 385-407. Ege t h , H. E., & Yan t i s , S . (1997 ). V i sual at tenti on: Cont rol, r epre s ent ation , an d tim e c ourse. Annu al revie w of p syc hology , 48(1) , 2 69-297. .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint 28 Fa irhall, S . L., & Ca ra mazz a, A . (2013 ). B r ain r e gion s th at r epre se nt amod al conc e ptual k nowled ge . Journa l of Neuro sci e nce, 33(25 ), 105 52 -1 0558. Freed man , D . J. , Rie s en h uber , M., Pog gio , T. , & Mi ll er, E. K . (2001 ). Ca te gorica l r ep r e s en ta t i o n of vi s ual s timul i in th e pr im a te pr ef r o nta l cortex . Sc ie nce , 291(55 02 ), 312-31 6 . Ga squoin e, P . G. (2014) . Con tribu tion s o f the i n s ula t o cog nition and emotion . N e urop sycho logy revie w, 24 , 77-87. Got t l ieb, J., Oudey e r , P . Y., Lope s, M ., & Baran e s, A. ( 2 013). Inf orma tion -s eeki ng, c ur i os i ty , and att entio n: c omputa tion al and ne u r a l me c hanism s . Tr end s in co gnitive s c ienc e s , 1 7(11), 585 - 593. Haxby , J. V. , Gobbi n i, M. I., Fu rey, M. L., I shai , A., Sc ho uten , J. L . , & Piet rini, P . (20 01). Di s t ribu ted and ove r l apping r e p r e s enta tion s o f fac e s and obje cts in ve n t ral tempor al c or t ex . Sc ien c e, 293(5 539), 242 5-2430 . Hayde n, B. Y. , & Niv , Y. (202 1). The ca s e ag ains t econo mic v alue s in th e or b i t o fro ntal cort ex (or any where e l s e in the br ain ). Beh avi or a l N euro s c ienc e, 135(2 ), 192. Hick ey, C ., & Pe elen , M. V . (2015 ). Neura l mecha nism s o f i ncentiv e sali enc e in na t ur a li st i c huma n vi s ion. N e uron, 85(3 ), 512 - 5 18 . Hick ey, C ., Di Lo llo , V ., & Mc Dona l d, J . J. ( 2009 ) . Elec trophy sio logic al ind ice s o f ta r get a nd di strac to r proce ssing i n visual se arc h. Journ al of c o gnitiv e neuro scie nce, 21(4 ), 760 -77 5. Hick ey, C ., G r ig nolio, D., Mu na s i nghe, V. , & Ac unz o, D . (unde r review ) . U s ing N2pc v ariabili t y to probe func tion ality : Line ar mixe d modell i ng of trial EEG and be havio u r . Hick ey, C ., Mc Donal d , J. J., & Theeuw e s , J. (2006 ). Elec trophy siol ogica l ev ide nce o f the c ap ture of vi s ual at ten tion . Jou rnal o f cogni t i ve ne u r osci ence, 18 (4), 604 - 6 13. Hick ey, C ., P olli cino, D., B erta z zoli , G. , & Barbar o, L . (2019 ). U l tra fa st o bjec t de tec tion i n nat urali st ic vi s ion r e li e s on ult raf a st di s t rac tor suppr es s io n. Jo ur n al o f C og nitive N euro scie nc e, 3 1(10) , 1563 -1572. Hüer, J ., S axena , P ., & Tr eue, S . (202 4) . P athwa y- s e l ectiv e op togen e t i c s reve al s th e fun cti onal ana t o my of top –dow n at ten tional modul ation in th e ma caque vi sual cor tex. P roc e eding s o f the Na tion al Acade my o f S cienc e s, 121(3 ), e230451 1121. Humphreys , G. F ., Ralp h, M . A . L., & S imo ns, J. S. (20 21). A unify ing a ccou nt of ang ula r gyrus co nt ribu tion s to ep i s odi c an d s e man tic c ognition . Tr end s in Neu ro s c ienc e s, 44(6) , 452 - 4 63. Jeong , S . K., & X u, Y. (20 16 ). B ehav ior ally r e leva n t ab s tr ac t objec t i d enti ty repr e se ntati on in the huma n parie tal cor tex. Jo urnal o f Ne ur o s ci ence , 36(5 ), 16 07-1619 . Klei n-Flügg e, M . C ., Bongio a nni, A ., & Ru shwor th, M. F . (2022 ). Me di al and orb it a l fron tal c or t ex in dec isi on-maki ng and f l exibl e b eha vior. N euron, 110 (17 ), 2743 -277 0. Kriege s k or t e, N., G o eb el , R., & Band ettin i , P. (200 6 ). I nfo rmati on-b a sed func tion al brai n mapping . Proce eding s of the N ation a l Aca demy o f S cie nce s, 103 ( 1 0 ), 3863-38 68. Le vy, D . J . , & Gli mche r, P . W . ( 2 012) . The root o f all v alue : a neur al common curre ncy for choic e. Curr ent opi nion in neu robio logy, 22(6 ), 1 027 - 1 038. Lu ck, S. J., & F ord, M . A . (1998). On th e r ole of s el ectiv e a tt entio n in visual pe rc ep tion. Proc e eding s of th e Na tiona l Ac ad emy of S cie nc e s, 95( 3), 825-830. Lu ck, S. J., & Hilly a rd, S. A . ( 1 994 ). El ect ro physiolog ical cor rela te s o f f eatu re a n alys is during v isua l se arch. P s y chophy s iol ogy, 3 1(3), 291 -30 8 . Lu ck, S. J., Gi relli , M ., Mc Dermo tt, M. T., & F or d, M . A . (1997) . Br id ging th e gap be t w een mo nkey neurophy s iol ogy a nd huma n p ercep tion : An ambig uity re solu tion th eory o f visual sel ec tive att entio n. C o gnitive p s y cholog y, 33 (1), 6 4-87. Lu r ia , R., B a laban , H ., Awh, E. , & Vog el, E . K. (2016 ). The c ontra lat eral d e lay a ctivi ty as a ne ura l mea s u re o f v is u al wo r k ing me mor y . Neu ros c i enc e & Biobeh av ioral R ev iews, 62 , 1 00-108 . Mahon, B . Z., & Caram a z za, A. (2 009 ). C o nc ept s a nd ca te gori es : A cog nitive n euro ps y cholog ica l per spec tiv e. Annu al r e view o f psycho log y, 60, 27-51 . Mari s, E., & Oo stenv eld , R. (2007 ). N onp arame tric sta ti stical t e s ting o f EEG- and MEG-d ata . J o u r na l o f neuro scie nc e me t h o ds, 1 64(1) , 177-1 90. .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint 29 Martin , A. (201 6). GRAP ES— G roundi ng repre s enta tion s in ac ti on, pe rce pti on, and emotion sys t e m s : How ob ject prope rti es and c at egorie s a r e r ep re sen ted i n th e human bra in. P syc h onomic bull etin & r ev iew , 23, 97 9 -990. Maun sell, J . H . (2015). Neu ronal mecha ni s m s of v i s ua l a tte ntion . Annu a l revie w of v is i on s c i enc e, 1, 373-39 1. Menon, V., & U ddin , L. Q . (201 0 ). Sal i enc y , switchi ng, at ten tion a nd co n t rol : a ne t work model of insula fun cti on. B rain s truc tur e an d fu nct ion, 214, 65 5-667. Mille r , E. K. , & C ohe n , J. D. (2001 ). A n int egrative t he o r y of pre fr onta l c or t ex func tion. A nnual r ev iew of neu ro scie nce , 24(1) , 167-2 02. Niv, Y . (2019). Le arning ta s k - s t ate r epr e s enta tion s. Natu r e ne uro s c ienc e, 22(10 ) , 1544-155 3. Pado a -Sch iop pa, C . , & C on en, K. E. (2017). Orbito fro nt a l co rtex : a n eu r a l circ ui t fo r econom ic dec isi on s . Neuron , 96(4) , 736-7 54. Pel le tie r, G ., & F ello w s , L. K. (2021) . Vi e wing or b it o fron tal cor tex c ontrib ution s t o decisi on-ma king through th e l en s o f objec t rec ogni t io n . B ehav ioral N euro s c i enc e, 135 (2 ), 182. Pome r l e au, V. J., F o rt i e r-Gau thie r, U. , C o r rive au, I ., D e ll'Acq ua, R ., & Jolic œur , P. ( 2014). Col our - speci fi c dif fe renc e s in a tt enti onal depl oy ment fo r equilu min ant pop -ou t c olour s: Eviden ce from la ter ali sed po ten tial s. In te rnat ional Jour n a l of Psyc hophy siol og y, 91(3), 194 - 205. Po sner , M. I ., Snyde r , C . R., & David son , B. J . (1980) . At ten tion an d the de tec t i on of signal s. J ournal of ex perim ental p s y cholog y: G ene ral, 10 9(2), 16 0. Princ e, J. S ., Ch are s t , I. , Kurz a w ski, J. W., P yle s, J . A., T a rr , M. J., & Kay, K . N . (2022 ). Impr ov ing the ac curac y of singl e -t ri al fMR I re s p on se e st imate s u sing GL Msingl e. Eli f e , 11, e 7759 9. Rash al, E., S e nou ssi, M ., San tandr ea , E. , Be n- H am ed, S ., Maca lu so, E., Chel azzi, L ., & Boehl er, C . N. (2022 ) . An EEG s t ud y of the c ombine d ef fect s o f to p-d own a nd bot tom- up at ten ti onal sel ec t i on und er va r y ing ta sk di fficul ty. P sy chophy s i ology, 59(6 ), e1 4002. Rey nold s, J . H., & H ee ge r, D . J . (2009 ). The no r ma liz a t i on mod el of a tt entio n. N eur on, 61(2) , 168- 185. Ric e, G. E., W a tson, D. M. , Har tley , T., & Andrew s, T. J. (2014 ). L ow-l ev el im age pr ope r t ie s of v i s ua l objec t s p r ed ic t pat ter ns o f ne ural r e spon se ac r o s s categ o r y - s el ective r egion s of th e v entr a l vi s ual pa thwa y. Jou rnal o f N eu ro scie nce , 34(26), 883 7-8844 . Rigo t ti, M., Ba rak, O., Wa rden , M. R. , Wa ng, X. J., D aw , N. D., Mill er, E. K., & Fu si, S . (2013) . T he importanc e of mix ed selec tivity i n comp lex c ognitiv e ta sks . N a t u r e , 497(7451 ), 585-590 . Ruec kl, J . G ., Paz-Alo n so, P . M., M olf e se, P. J., Kuo, W . J. , Bi ck, A . , F ro s t, S . J. , .. . & F r os t, R . (201 5) . Univer sal brai n s i gna tur e of pr ofic i ent r e ading : Evide nce f r om fou r c ontra s ting la ngu ages . Proce eding s of the N ation a l Aca demy o f S cie nce s, 112 ( 5 0 ), 15510 - 1 5515. Sa wak i, R., & Lu ck, S. J. (201 0 ). Captu re v e rsu s s u ppre s sion o f a tt ention b y salie nt singl e t o n s : Ele ctrophy siologi cal evid e nce f or an au to matic att end -to - m e s i gnal . A t ten tion, Per ception, & Psyc hophy sic s, 72(6 ), 1455-147 0 . Sc huck , N. W., Cai, M . B. , Wil son, R . C . , & Niv , Y. (201 6). Human o rbit of ront al c or t ex repre s e nts a co gnitive map of st ate sp ace . Ne ur o n, 91 (6), 14 02 -1412. Se eley, W. W . , Meno n, V ., S cha tzberg, A. F ., Kel ler , J., Glove r, G. H ., K enna , H., . . . & Gr eic iu s , M. D. (2007 ) . D i ssocia ble in trin sic conn ec tivity n etwork s f or s al ienc e proce s s i ng and exe c utive co nt rol . J o u r na l o f neur osci e nce, 27 (9), 2 349-2 356. Se idl, K. N., P eelen , M. V., & Ka st n e r , S. ( 2012 ) . N e ur a l evi d ence f or di s tr ac t e r s up pre s s ion during vi s ual s e a r c h in r e al -world sce n e s . Jou r n a l of N euro s c ie nc e, 32(34 ), 11812-11 819 . Se stie ri, C ., Shulma n, G. L. , & C o r be tt a, M. (2017) . The cont ributi on o f t he huma n p osteri or pari eta l co r tex to e pis odic memory. N atur e Rev ie ws Neu ro s c ienc e , 18(3 ), 183-192. Stoja no s k i, B. , & Cu sack , R. (201 4 ). Time t o wav e good-by e to pha s e scr amb ling: C rea t i ng co nt roll ed scrambl e d imag e s u sing dif feomo rphic tra nsform ation s . Jou rnal o f v ision , 14(12 ), 6-6. Uddin, L . Q., Nomi, J . S. , Hé ber t -S erop ian , B. , Gh az i r i, J . , & Bo uch er, O . (2017 ) . St ru cture and fun cti on of th e hu man in sula . J o urna l of Clin ical Ne ur op hy s i ology , 34(4 ), 30 0-306 . .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint 30 Ungerleid er , S . K. A . L. G . (20 00 ). Mech a n ism s of v i sual a tte ntion i n the huma n cor tex. Annua l rev iew of neu ro scie nce , 23(1) , 315-3 41. Verl ege r, R., ve l G r a jew ska, B. Ż., & Ja śko wski , P. (201 2) . Time-c ou rse o f hemi sphe ric pr e fe ren ce f or proce ssing c ontra lat eral r ele van t sh ape s : P1pc , N1pc, N 2p c, N3pc. Advanc e s in c o gnitive psych ology, 8(1 ), 19. Voge l, E. K. , & Ma chi zawa , M. G. (2004). N eur al activ ity predic t s in dividua l dif fe re nc es in vi sual work ing mem or y ca pacity . Na tur e , 428(6 984 ) , 748-751 . Wagne r , A . D. , Shan n on, B . J. , Ka hn, I. , & Buc kner, R. L. (200 5) . Pari et al lobe c on tr i bu t i on s to e pi s od ic memory r e t r iev al. T re nd s i n cog nitive sci ence s, 9(9 ), 445-453 . Wat s on , D. M ., Ha rt l ey, T . , & A n d r e w s , T. J. (201 4) . P att ern s o f r e sp on se to v i s ua l s c en e s are l inke d to the l ow -leve l p rope rtie s o f th e imag e. Neuro Image , 99, 4 02 -410. Weav er, M. D ., va n Zoe st , W., & H ic key , C. (20 17 ). A tempor al de p endenc y a ccou n t of a tte ntio nal inhi bition in o culomo tor c on t rol . N e u r oI ma ge, 1 47, 880 - 8 94. Woodman, G . F. , & Luc k, S . J . (2003 ). Seri al deploy ment o f a tte ntion du ring visual se arc h. Journ al of Ex perimental P s y chol og y: Human P e r c ep tion a nd P er forma nce , 29(1 ), 1 21. Wu, C . Y ., Ho, M . H. R. , & C hen, S . H. A . ( 201 2). A met a- ana ly si s of fMR I studie s o n Chine se orthogr aphic , phon ol ogica l, and s em an ti c proc essing . N e u r oi mage, 63 (1), 381 -3 9 1. .CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made The copyright holder for this preprint (whichthis version posted May 29, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.29.596408doi: bioRxiv preprint

Text is read by the "Ask this paper" AI Q&A widget below. Extraction quality varies by source — PMC NXML preserves structure cleanly, OA-HTML may include some navigation residue, and OA-PDF can have broken hyphenation. The publisher copy (via DOI) is the canonical version.

My notes (saved in your browser only)

Ask this paper AI returns verbatim quotes from the full text · source: oa-pdf

Answers must be backed by verbatim quotes from this paper's full text. Hallucinated quotes are dropped automatically; if no verbatim passage answers the question, we say so. How this works

Citation neighborhood (no data yet)

We don't have any in-corpus citations linked to this paper yet. This is a recent paper (2024) — citers typically take a year or two to land, and the OpenAlex reference graph may still be filling in.

Source provenance

europepmc
last seen: 2026-05-20T01:45:00.602351+00:00
unpaywall
last seen: 2026-05-21T05:10:58.409756+00:00
License: CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0