Intro
Successful reproduction requires sufficient energy and thus there is
dynamic communication between homeostatic signals and hypothalamic GnRH
function. The hypothalamic-pituitary-gonadal (HPG) axis is activated at puberty
after a period of dormancy during childhood, marking the acquisition of
reproductive capacity. At the apex of the HPG axis, kisspeptin neurons regulate
pulsatile secretion of gonadotropin-releasing hormone (GnRH) from GnRH neurons
into the hypophyseal portal circulation to stimulate pituitary gonadotrophs to
release gonadotropins: i.e., luteinizing hormone (LH) and follicle stimulating
hormone (FSH). In males, LH stimulates Leydig cells to produce testosterone,
whereas FSH acts on Sertoli cells to support spermatogenesis. In females, the
complex interplay between gonadotropins and sex-steroids are characteristic
features of the ovarian cycle, encompassing folliculogenesis, ovulation, and
luteal progesterone production.
Pioneering studies from Ernst Knobil were instrumental in establishing
that pulsatile secretion of the decapeptide GnRH is requisite for the
hypophysiotropic stimulation of pituitary gonadotrophs ( 1 ). In ovariectomized rhesus monkeys who were rendered GnRH
deficient by lesioning the hypothalamic arcuate nucleus, chronic constant
infusion of GnRH led to decline of serum gonadotropins, despite a brief initial
flare of gonadotropins. By contrast, intermittent pulsatile administration of
GnRH could stimulate gonadotropin secretion long-term. This concept was
subsequently translated to women with GnRH deficient states such as functional
hypothalamic amenorrhea (FHA) and hyperprolactinemia, whereby chronic
intermittent administration of GnRH was able to normalize serum gonadotropin
levels, restore menstrual cyclicity, and ovulation ( 2 , 3 ). The precise
synchrony between GnRH and LH pulses, and the lack of LH pulses not preceded by
GnRH pulses, confirmed the pulsatile nature of GnRH and in turn LH secretion
( 4 , 5 ). For many years, GnRH was believed to reside at the apex of the
HPG axis, but GnRH neurons lack receptors for peripheral signals to modulate the
HPG axis including estradiol (E2) or leptin receptors. Thus, the presence of the
‘GnRH pulse generator’, an upstream neuronal population that regulates GnRH
neuronal function and could integrate peripheral metabolic and sex-steroid
signals was posited.
In 2003, the seminal findings from two reports indicated that
inactivating variants of the kisspeptin receptor gene ( KISS1R )
led to congenital hypogonadotropic hypogonadism (CHH) and a failure of the HPG
axis ( 6 , 7 ). It was later discovered that these kisspeptin-expressing neurons
in the infundibular nucleus (arcuate nucleus in animals), co-express neurokinin
B (NKB), and regulate GnRH neuronal function, thus likely representing the ‘GnRH
pulse generator’. Kisspeptin and NKB are now established to be hypothalamic
neuropeptides that play a key role in regulating GnRH neuronal secretion.
In this review, we discuss the physiological roles of kisspeptin and NKB
across the reproductive lifespan including during puberty, menstrual cyclicity,
reproductive behavior, pregnancy, menopause, and bone homeostasis. We describe
how perturbations of these key physiological processes can result in disease
states, and we consider how kisspeptin and NKB could be exploited
therapeutically, for example during in vitro fertilization
(IVF), and the treatment for menopausal vasomotor symptoms.
Future
In addition to the future research directions highlighted in the
corresponding sections, we have included below some additional avenues for
kisspeptin and NKB research and considerations of clinical applications of compounds
targeting the kisspeptin/NKB pathways.
Kisspeptin presents significant diagnostic and therapeutic potential
that could revolutionize the fields of reproductive endocrinology, metabolic and
bone health. To date, current data have predominantly investigated subcutaneous
or intravenous routes of administration, which may hinder its development as a
diagnostic or therapeutic option. Exploring alternative administration methods,
such as intranasal administration, could present an alternative non-invasive
delivery route. Recent data in rodents have shown that up to 25% of the total
GnRH population resides within the olfactory bulb ( 432 ). These GnRH neurons express olfactory and vomeronasal
receptors activated by opposite-sex odors and maintain functional connections
with olfactory and vomeronasal structures. Thus, GnRH neurons are well-equipped
to detect and respond to social cues, such as pheromones, potentially impacting
mating behaviors. Indeed, chemogenetic activation of GnRH neurons in the
olfactory bulb of male mice increases the firing rate of GnRH neurons in the
preoptic area, stimulating downstream LH and testosterone production ( 432 ). These findings suggest that the
olfactory system could enable novel therapeutic approaches for modulating
reproductive and behavioral functions, potentially through intranasal kisspeptin
administration. Studies involving rodent and human intranasal kisspeptin-54
administration are currently underway, with promising preliminary results ( 433 ). In future, non-peptide agonists of
the kisspeptin receptor could enable additional non-invasive routes of
administration such as via the oral route.
As tachykinins and their receptors are expressed in multiple
extrahypothalamic tissues, antagonism of NKB action in the management of VMS
could have additional effects beyond its thermoregulatory role. For instance,
tachykinins are expressed within the enteric nervous system and within the
mucosa of the gastrointestinal tract, albeit with marked interspecies variation
( 434 ). Data from animal studies
demonstrated a role of tachykinins in gastrointestinal motility/peristalsis
regulation, secreto-motor response and in the modulation of gastrointestinal
inflammatory, immune, and sensory response. Thus, this has sparked interest in
its therapeutic potential in gastrointestinal disorders. Conversely, the NK3R
antagonist, Talnetant, did not demonstrate efficacy over placebo ( 435 ) in the control of irritable bowel
syndrome (IBS) related discomfort, which did not corroborate fully with
pre-clinical data. Moreover, Aprepitant and later Fosaprepitant (both NK1R
antagonists), have been approved by the FDA in the treatment of
chemotherapy-induced and postoperative emesis through its central actions on NK1
receptors ( 434 , 436 ). Overall, it will be informative to monitor for
extrahypothalamic effects of NK3R antagonists, as well as the combination of
NK3R and NK1R antagonists, currently being investigated in the management of
menopausal VMS in the Phase 3 trials.
Whilst vasomotor symptoms are the hallmark symptoms associated with the
perimenopause and early postmenopausal years; women may experience a number of
other symptoms that can negatively impact on quality of life. These include an
altered metabolic rate that can be associated with weight gain ( 437 ), cognitive impairment ( 438 ), and mood disturbances ( 439 ). The changes in hypothalamic
neuropeptide expression observed in post-mortem tissue from post-menopausal
women and ovariectomized animal models raise the question if kisspeptin or NKB
action contribute to these observed changes.
Rodent studies using global Kiss1r knockout models
have consistently demonstrated that adult female Kiss1r
knockout mice (at 18 weeks) exhibit an increase in body weight of up to 30%
compared to wild-type controls ( 440 – 442 ), comprising mainly
of increased adiposity ( 442 ). Notably,
kisspeptin's effects on body weight appear to be sexually dimorphic, as adult
male Kiss1r knockout mice show no significant changes in body
weight ( 440 , 442 ). Some of the weight changes have been attributed to
the hypogonadal state or inadequate sex-steroid replacement in
Kiss1r knockout mice. However following ovariectomy,
Kiss1r knockout mice had higher body weight, leptin levels,
and adiposity compared to ovariectomized control females with similar
sex-steroid milieu ( 440 , 442 ). Therefore, the effect of kisspeptin
on energy homeostasis is likely mediated through direct effects on energy
expenditure and indirectly through changes in reproductive hormone levels ( 440 , 442 ). In rats, a 25% gain in body weight was observed by three weeks
post-ovariectomy, however this increase in body weight was abolished following
selective ablation of the arcuate KNDy neurons ( 443 ). Furthermore, E2 replacement in control rats induced weight
loss, an effect lost in KNDy ablated rats, thus suggesting the essential role of
KNDy neurons in mediating the effects of E2 on body weight, at least in rats
( 443 ). However, at present
corroborating data in humans is lacking, and the long-term effects of NK3R
antagonism (which currently is entering clinical use for treatment of hot
flashes) on body weight will be of interest.
Kisspeptin and its receptor are expressed in critical brain regions
associated with memory and learning, including the amygdala and hippocampus
( 444 ). This anatomical localization
supports the proposed cognitive roles of kisspeptin signaling. Experimental
studies in mice suggest that stimulating kisspeptin signaling within the
hippocampus can enhance learning and memory and exert neuroprotective effects,
particularly concerning amyloid-β accumulation in the hippocampus, as observed
in preclinical models of Alzheimer's disease ( 445 ). Kisspeptin-13 has been shown to improve memory consolidation
in passive avoidance learning in male rodents ( 446 ) and enhance learning in zebrafish ( 447 ). Additionally, the administration of kisspeptin-13
via intracerebroventricular and intra-hippocampal routes in mice enhances memory
retention and facilitates the formation of object and location recognition
memory ( 448 ). These effects are
abolished by the kisspeptin receptor antagonist, kisspeptin-234, indicating that
kisspeptin signaling within the hippocampus is mediating these cognitive
benefits ( 448 ).
Furthermore, preclinical studies on kisspeptin have reported a range of
effects on anxiety, including anxiogenic ( 449 – 451 ), anxiolytic ( 452 , 453 ), and neutral outcomes ( 454 ). Central administration of kisspeptin to male rats also had no
effect on other stress-related behaviors, including locomotion, sleep, and
grooming ( 32 ). Acute administration of
intravenous kisspeptin in clinical studies involving healthy heterosexual men
( 261 ), as well as studies involving
men ( 267 ) and premenopausal women ( 264 ) with HSDD did not result in
significant changes in psychometric measures of anxiety or circulating cortisol
levels. In healthy men, kisspeptin administration led to reductions in negative
mood as assessed by psychometric testing, mirroring findings seen in rodents
( 455 ), and enhanced activity in
brain structures related to the reward system, such as the hippocampus,
amygdala, and cingulate, in response to sexual images ( 261 ). Collectively, the evidence in humans suggests that
kisspeptin might have antidepressant effects and a neutral impact on anxiety.
Therefore, beyond its potential use in addressing symptoms in postmenopausal
women, kisspeptin could potentially be used to treat patients experiencing mood
disorders and sexual dysfunction, which often co-exist. Preclinical data on the
NKB pathway on anxiety remains incongruous, with some studies suggesting
pro-anxiety effects ( 456 ) and others
indicating anxiolytic-like effects ( 457 , 458 ) in rodent models.
Regarding depression, the NK3R agonist, aminosenktide, has demonstrated
antidepressant activity in mice ( 459 ).
In conclusion, the potential roles of kisspeptin in modulating
cognition, mood, and body weight represent a promising area for future research.
A deeper understanding of these mechanisms may pave the way for targeted
therapies aimed at alleviating some of the most challenging symptoms of
menopause, as well as other psychosexual, mood, or cognitive conditions.
Puberty
Puberty is characterized by sexual maturation and acquisition of
reproductive capacity following activation of the HPG axis from its quiescent
prepubertal state ( 77 ). In most mammals,
during late prenatal or early postnatal life, a period of transient activation of
the HPG axis known as ‘ mini puberty ’ believed to be important for
priming reproductive organs is followed by period of relative quiescence until the
onset of puberty ( 77 , 78 ). The resurgence of pulsatile GnRH release is recognized as
the key neuroendocrine initiator central to the onset of puberty ( 79 ).
The re-awakening of the gonadotropic axis and attainment of reproductive
capacity during puberty involves the complex interplay of enhanced excitatory,
lowered inhibitory signals and permissive signals that integrate genetic,
environmental, and metabolic factors on GnRH neurons ( Figure 3 ). In recent years, through studies in patients with disordered
puberty i.e., precocious or delayed/absent puberty, key neuroendocrine players that
contribute to regulating hypothalamic function have enhanced our understanding of
the physiological regulation of puberty and the HPG axis.
FSH, follicle stimulating hormone; GnRH, gonadotropin-releasing hormone; LH,
luteinizing hormone; MKRN3, makorin RING finger protein 3; NKB, neurokinin B. Figure
created with BioRender.com .
Data from electrophysiological studies mark kisspeptin as one of the
most potent excitatory stimuli to GnRH neurons yet discovered ( 80 ). The proposed involvement of kisspeptin
in the timing of puberty onset was based on loss-of-function variants in
kisspeptin signaling leading to delayed or absent puberty, whilst
gain-of-function variants led to precocious puberty ( 6 , 7 , 19 , 22 , 23 ).
Expression of hypothalamic Kiss1 mRNA/kisspeptin
content in rodents and rhesus monkeys increases throughout the pubertal
transition ( 28 , 81 ). Intriguingly, whilst the number of
Kiss1 expressing cells increases by 7-fold in the RP3V,
Kiss1r expression on GnRH neurons appeared unaltered across
puberty ( 35 ) suggesting that increased
RP3V kisspeptin neuronal projection to GnRH neurons may contribute to
reactivation of GnRH neurons peripubertally. Indeed, appositions between
kisspeptin fibers and GnRH neuron somata was first apparent at postnatal day 25
and increased throughout pubertal development in rodents ( 37 ). Thus, kisspeptin appears to be an important instigator
of pubertal onset and reactivation of the HPG axis.
Central kisspeptin administration to prepubertal male and female rats
could induce GnRH release, increasing low prepubertal LH levels to adult levels
( 81 ). However, when compared to adult
mice with robust LH responses to kisspeptin, juvenile mice required higher doses
of kisspeptin stimulation to elicit an LH response ( 35 ). Likewise, electrophysiological studies have
demonstrated that GnRH neurons acquire sensitivity to the excitatory actions of
kisspeptin during the pubertal transition, with least GnRH neuron depolarization
seen in juvenile mice and maximum depolarization seen in adult mice ( 35 ). Functionally, chronic central
kisspeptin administration to prepubertal female rats resulted in a precocious
pubertal phenotype, evidenced by premature vaginal opening, increased uterine
weight, LH and E2 levels ( 82 ).
Conversely, central infusion of the kisspeptin antagonist, p234, to peripubertal
female rats led to a marked delay in pubertal timing with significantly delayed
vaginal opening, reduced ovarian and uterine weight ( 83 ). Similarly, kisspeptin-10 administration resulted in
significant LH and testosterone increase in boys at Tanner stage V and adult men
but not in boys at Tanner stages I-IV ( 84 ). Female adult rats demonstrated failure to sustain LH secretion
after 48hrs of chronic kisspeptin-10 infusion in keeping with desensitization
( 85 ). In contrast, at the time of
puberty, LH concentrations were persistently elevated even at 7 days after
constant kisspeptin-10 administration, suggesting persistent stimulation ( 85 ). All in all, increased numbers of
Kiss1 neurons and their projections to GnRH neurons,
enhanced excitatory action of kisspeptin and improved kisspeptin receptor
signaling efficiency across the pubertal transition provide further evidence for
kisspeptin’s role in the instigation and maintenance of puberty ( Figure 3 ).
In 2011, a series of toxin-based genetic studies achieved over 90%
targeted ablation of neurons expressing kisspeptin and kisspeptin receptors
( 86 ). In the absence of kisspeptin or
kisspeptin receptor expressing neurons, mice exhibited reduced ovarian size,
however these mice did not exhibit impaired pubertal maturation or fertility
suggesting that kisspeptin neurons are needed for full gonadal maturation but
may be dispensable with regards to the timing of puberty onset ( 86 ). By contrast, ablation of kisspeptin
expressing neurons in adult female mice led to acyclicity and infertility,
however this phenotype was not replicated by conditional ablation of kisspeptin
receptors ( 86 ). The authors concluded
that the phenotypic discrepancies between congenital and conditional ablation of
kisspeptin-expressing neurons may be due to developmental compensation; thus,
ablation of kisspeptin-expressing cell in adulthood appears to preclude
activation or formation of these alternative reproductive circuits ( 86 ). Furthermore, following ablation, the
remaining 7% of the GnRH neuronal population (i.e. the non-kisspeptin receptor
expressing GnRH population) was sufficient to mediate reproductive function
suggesting considerable redundancies in the HPG axis ( 86 ) consistent with prior data ( 87 ). Further exploration of the plasticity and redundancy
of the kisspeptin system in the reproductive axis demonstrated that a 95%
reduction in Kiss1 transcript levels in mice still allowed a
normal reproductive phenotype in male mice, whereas females are subfertile,
suggesting that females require higher levels of kisspeptin expression for
reproductive capacity ( 88 ). Recently,
using female global Kiss1 knockout rats with no gonadotropin
activity, reintroduction of kisspeptin to only 20% of arcuate KNDy neurons was
able to rescue folliculogenesis and pulsatile LH release ( 66 ). Therefore, akin to GnRH, the kisspeptin system
displays considerable redundancy with only a limited number of functional KNDy
cells required to generate sufficient LH pulses to maintain downstream
activation of the HPG axis, with this being greater in females than males.
NKB and dynorphin are neuropeptides co-expressed in arcuate KNDy
neurons. These neuropeptides act in a concerted auto/paracrine manner to
regulate the pulsatile GnRH release, and represent the ‘GnRH pulse generator’.
NKB, encoded by Tac2 in rodents and TAC3 in
humans, binds preferentially to the neurokinin 3 receptor (NK3R) encoded by
Tac3r in rodents and TACR3 in humans. In
2009, seminal papers reported that inactivating variants of
TAC3 and TACR3 led to hypogonadotropic
hypogonadism in humans ( 89 , 90 ) and in female mice ( 91 ), identifying the critical role of NKB
for normal pubertal timing.
Hypothalamic expression of Tac2 and
Tac3r mRNA increases progressively through postnatal ages
with maximal expression seen at time of puberty onset for Tac2 .
In contrast to Kiss1 , which demonstrates increased expression
within the RP3V postnatally until puberty with no discernible change within the
arcuate nucleus, Tac3r expression was significantly increased
within the arcuate ( 92 ). Central and
peripheral administration of NKB, and the NK3R agonist, senktide, have been
shown to stimulate GnRH neurons and downstream LH release in several mammalian
species, likely through inducing kisspeptin release ( 93 – 95 ). Senktide
could also stimulate LH release in pre-pubertal rodents and the amplitude of LH
response increased with advancing post-pubertal age ( 92 ). Conversely, chronic infusion of an NK3R antagonist
during puberty led to mildly decreased LH levels and delayed vaginal opening in
female mice ( 92 ).
However, unlike disruption in kisspeptin signaling, the reproductive
phenotype of deficient NKB signaling is notably milder. For instance, humans
harboring inactivating variants in TAC3/TACR3 , could
subsequently proceed to achieve HPG axis activation in adulthood, a phenomenon
termed ‘reversal’ ( 96 ). In rodent models,
Tac2 -/- knockout male mice exhibit no delay in
sexual maturation or fertility however, in contrast,
Tac2 -/- females had profound delays in sexual
maturation and initial abnormalities in estrous cycles which then recovered
during adulthood and these females were ultimately fertile ( 91 ). Tac3r null mice
demonstrated normal markers of sexual maturation, however males had lower
testicular weight and females had lower uterine and abnormal estrous cycles with
prolonged time spent in diestrus, nonetheless, these mice were fertile ( 97 ). Overall, this suggests that NKB
signaling is important in early sexual development and timing of puberty.
The tempo of puberty is orchestrated by the dynamic interactions between
genetic and environmental factors. As both puberty and reproduction are energy
demanding physiological processes, endogenous signals reflective of the body’s
energy availability are essential for successful reproduction and subsequent
lactation. Metabolic perturbations, both under- and over-nutrition, can affect
pubertal onset. Leptin, an anorexigenic adipokine secreted by white adipose
tissue reflective of total body energy stores ( 98 , 99 ), is a permissive
signal requisite for healthy GnRH neuronal function. Leptin has an unequivocal
role in puberty wherein leptin deficient mice and humans have absent puberty and
are infertile ( 100 ).
Changes in leptin levels reflective of energy availability are
postulated to impact on kisspeptin and NKB expression/function. Through
manipulating postnatal feeds, pubertal timing has been shown to be sensitive to
early nutritional availability. Overfeeding resulted in higher levels of leptin,
Kiss1 mRNA expression and earlier vaginal opening whilst
subnutrition led to lower levels of leptin and Kiss1 mRNA
paralleled by delayed vaginal opening ( 101 ). In prepubertal rats, chronic administration of kisspeptin was
sufficient to stimulate gonadotropin and estrogen secretion and restore vaginal
opening despite reductions in Kiss1 mRNA expression induced by
caloric restriction ( 102 ). Continuous
kisspeptin-10 infusion to underfed pubertal female rodents with marked
hypo-leptinemia significantly increased serum LH, uterine weight and restored
vaginal opening in >62% of the animals over a 7-day treatment period despite
no change in body weight ( 85 ). In
contrast, chronic leptin infusion, which led to further body weight reduction,
failed to persistently elevate gonadotropins and only rescued vaginal opening in
25% of animals ( 85 ) consolidating
kisspeptin’s key role in maturation of the HPG axis.
Likewise, rodent models subjected to caloric restriction, leading to
>25% reduction in body weight demonstrated decreased arcuate
Tac3r mRNA expression. LH response to senktide in caloric
restriction model was enhanced in comparison to age-matched controls fed
ad libitum , with some caloric restricted animals
demonstrating complete vaginal opening ( 91 ). These findings reaffirm the intricate links between metabolic
status and reproductive health mediated through kisspeptin and NKB
expression/function, culminating in the downstream effects on GnRH output and
the resultant reproductive phenotypes.
The effect of leptin on kisspeptin neurons is likely to be mediated
indirectly through an intermediary neuronal population as selective deletion of
leptin receptor from kisspeptin neurons ( 103 ) in mice had no effect on fertility. Arcuate agouti-related
peptide (AgRP) neurons, which co-express neuropeptide Y (NPY) and GABA; and
pro-opiomelanocortin (POMC) neurons which co-express cocaine- and
amphetamine-regulated transcript (CART), are likely candidates given their
abundant expression of leptin receptors as well as their well-recognized role in
energy homeostasis. In the hypoleptinemic state, orexigenic AgRP/NPY neurons are
hyperactivated ( 104 ), whilst
anorexigenic POMC neurons are suppressed ( 105 ).
The neuropeptides AgRP secreted by AgRP neurons, and alpha-melanocyte
stimulating hormone (α-MSH), the main secretory product of POMC neurons, are
respective antagonist and agonist of the melanocortin 3 receptor (MC3R) and
melanocortin 4 receptor (MC4R) ( 106 ).
These neuropeptides have been shown in vitro to act directly on
GnRH and kisspeptin neurons ( 106 ).
AgRP neurons form physical connections with arcuate and RP3V kisspeptin
neurons ( 107 ). In female mice lacking
leptin receptors, AgRP neuronal ablation was able to restore reproductive
function ( 108 ). Furthermore, selective
AgRP neuron-specific rescue of leptin receptors in leptin receptor null mice
could partially or fully restore reproductive function despite persisting
metabolic effects ( 109 ) thus
demonstrating AgRP neuron’s role in integrating the metabolic effects of leptin
and reproductive phenotype.
Neuroanatomically, POMC neurons send projections to GnRH cell bodies and
terminals ( 106 ) and immunoreactive α-MSH
fibers were identified in close apposition to Kiss1 cell bodies
of pubertal rats ( 110 ). Chronic MC3R and
MC4R blockade in peripubertal female rat induced significant suppression of
arcuate Kiss1 resulting in delayed puberty. Moreover, in
Kiss1r knockout rodent model, activation of MC3R and MC4R
failed to stimulate an LH response ( 111 ). These preclinical studies suggest that the α-MSH/melanocortin
system acts upstream and is dependent of kisspeptin to exert its effect on the
reproductive phenotype. In corroboration with preclinical data, a homozygous
loss of function variant in MC3R in humans was associated with reduced linear
growth, reduced lean mass, raised body mass index (BMI), and delayed puberty
( 112 , 113 ).
Epigenetic regulation governs gene expression through DNA methylation
and hydroxymethylation, post-translational modifications of histones, and
non-coding RNAs such as microRNAs (miRNA). DNA methyltransferases (DNMTs) and
ten-eleven translocation (TET) enzymes mediate DNA methylation and
demethylation, respectively ( 114 ). The
balance between methylated and demethylated DNA influences chromatin structure,
which in turn determines transcriptional activity through conformational changes
of chromatin ( 115 ). Histones are key
structures in nucleosomes, post-translational modifications of histones through
processes including acetylation, methylation, phosphorylation, ubiquitination
and sumoylation, can thereby influence transcriptional activity ( 114 ). For example, the role of epigenetic
silencers and activators in fine-tuning pubertal timing has been noted through
activation or repression of Kiss1 expression. Prepubertally
Kiss1 expression is low, in part due to expression of
Polycomb Group (PcG) epigenetic silencers, whereas during pubertal progression,
Kiss1 expression is enhanced following recruitment of
epigenetic activators, such as the Trithorax group to the promoter region of
Kiss1 ( 116 ). This
subsequently affects chromatin structure (i.e., epigenetic silencer induces
compaction whereas activator induces open conformation), which affects access of
the transcriptional machinery and thereby final Kiss1 gene
expression ( 116 ).
Specifically, within the PcG system, hypothalamic mRNA expressions of
Cbx7 and Eed , two PcG genes required for
PcG action, decrease at the initiation of puberty. Arcuate Kiss1 neurons
co-express both Cbx7 and Eed7 gene; indeed,
the increase in Kiss1 expression observed during the pubertal
transition was accompanied by eviction of EED from Kiss1
promoter, highlighting a putative mechanism of PcG mediated repression in the
regulation of pubertal timing ( 117 ).
Conversely, mixed-lineage leukemia 1 (MLL1) and 3 (MLL3), two members of the
Trithorax group, have been shown to counteract the repressive actions of PcG by
facilitating the configuration chromatin changes from repressive to permissive
by acting at the Kiss1 and Tac3 promoter
regions ( 118 ).
Epigenetic modifications also provide a potential link between
nutritional status and pubertal development. Sirtuin 1 (SIRT1), an
energy-sensing deacetylase, is abundantly expressed in arcuate/MBH Kiss1 neurons
( 119 ). Hypothalamic SIRT1 content
decreased during the pubertal transition, which coincided with increased
Kiss1 and Tac3 expression. Overnutrition
leads to earlier pubertal development in rodent models and is associated with a
reduction in SIRT1 and elevation of both Kiss1
and Tac3 expression; whilst the converse phenotypic and
expression profiles are observed in undernutrition; moreover, transgenic
overexpression of SIRT1 led to delayed pubertal maturation
( 119 ). Mechanistically SIRT1 have
been shown to repress Kiss1 expression through interaction with the PcG complex
at the Kiss1 promoter region and acts synergistically with EED
to induce a repressive chromatin configuration and thereby reduces
Kiss1 transcription ( 119 ).
Several hypothalamic zinc finger genes (ZNF) are downregulated in the
MBH during the juvenile-pubertal transition in monkeys. Notably
GATAD1 and ZNF573 overexpression delayed
pubertal onset and GATAD1 have been shown to repress KISS1 and
TAC3 promoter activity ( 120 ). Another zinc finger protein, initially termed zinc finger
protein 127 ( ZNF127 ), now renamed makorin RING finger protein 3
(MKRN3) is recognized as a puberty-suppressing factor acting upstream of GnRH
secretion encoded by the gene located in the Prader-Willi syndrome critical
region ( 121 ). MKRN3 belongs to a family
of E3 ubiquitin ligases involved in the ubiquitination process important in
regulation of protein degradation ( 121 ).
Whole-exome sequencing in patients from 15 families with central precocious
puberty demonstrated loss-of-function variants in MKRN3 ( 121 ). Moreover, in rodent models,
Mkrn3 mRNA was expressed in the arcuate nucleus with
heightened juvenile expression and with striking reduction immediately prior to
puberty ( 121 ). This pubertally regulated
transition was also replicated in female rats and rhesus monkeys irrespective of
the sex-steroid milieu ( 122 ).
MKRN3 is most strongly expressed in the ventromedial and
arcuate nuclei and colocalizes with arcuate kisspeptin-expressing neurons ( 122 ). Mechanistically, MKRN3 selectively
inhibits KISS1 and TAC3 promoter activity,
thereby inhibiting kisspeptin and NKB expression without affecting the promoter
region of PDYN (which encodes prodynorphin) ( 122 ). Lastly, MKRN3 represses
KISS1 and TAC3 gene promoter activities
through its action as an E3 ubiquitin ligase with reduced activity in pathogenic
variants affecting the RING finger domain of the protein ( 122 ) and may also target neuropeptides of Kiss1 neurons to
ubiquitination and degradation pathways ( 123 ). Kisspeptin therefore mediates the final common pathway
downstream of MKRN3 to determine pubertal timing.
Finally, non-coding mRNAs such as miRNAs, largely through translation
suppression or RNA degradation, have been shown to be important in the
regulation of puberty. The RNAase III enzyme, Dicer, is important in the final
step of mature miRNA biosynthesis. Selective inactivation of Dicer in GnRH
neurons led to central hypogonadism and failure of pubertal completion in mice
through involvement of miR-200/429 family and miR-155 ( 124 ). Likewise female mice engineered to lack miRNA
synthesis in Kiss1 neurons failed to complete puberty and
attain fertility ( 125 ).
Delayed puberty is defined as the absence of testicular enlargement
(testicular volume < 4ml, Tanner stage 2) in boys and breast development in
girls (Tanner stage 2) at an age that is 2 standard deviations later than the
population mean, traditionally defined as the age of 14 years in boys and 13
years in girls ( 126 ). Biochemically,
most boys (95%) and girls (75-85%) with delayed puberty will have low levels of
sex-steroids and inappropriately normal or low levels of gonadotropins
consistent with hypogonadotropic hypogonadism ( 127 ). Constitutional delay of growth and puberty (CDGP) is the most
common cause of delayed puberty, which affects 60-80% of boys and 30-55% of
girls with biochemical hypogonadotropic hypogonadism ( 127 ). CDGP represents a variant of the normal spectrum of
pubertal timing, and affected adolescents will proceed through puberty
spontaneously without treatment albeit delayed to their peers ( 126 – 129 ). An important but less common cause of delayed puberty with
similar presentation and biochemical profile to CDGP is CHH. CHH is caused by
genetic variants causing impaired hypothalamic GnRH neuronal migration or
function, affecting 10% of younger adolescent boys and 10-20% of girls ( 127 ). Whilst CDGP can usually be managed
conservatively, patients with CHH benefit from treatment with pubertal induction
to safeguard future reproductive, sexual, bone, metabolic and psychological
health ( 130 ). Timely and accurate
distinction between CDGP and CHH is challenging; due to the overlapping clinical
features, biochemical profiles and the absence of a ‘gold standard’ diagnostic
test ( 131 ).
Precocious puberty is defined as sex-hormone production or exposure
occurring earlier than that which is expected for gender, ethnicity and race;
typically with female preponderance ( 132 ). In girls, this is defined as the onset of breast development
before the age of 8 years and in boys as increased testicular volume (>4ml)
before the age of 9 years, accompanied by acceleration of linear growth and bone
age. Precocious puberty can be classified as GnRH-dependent or GnRH-independent
processes. GnRH-dependent or central precocious puberty (CPP) results from the
premature activation of the HPG axis by CNS abnormalities, whilst
GnRH-independent or peripheral precocious puberty results from the unregulated
gonadal production of sex-steroids ( 132 ).
The ability of kisspeptin to directly stimulate hypothalamic GnRH
release offers an opportunity to use it as a test to evaluate hypothalamic
function ( 133 – 136 ). Kisspeptin administration has been utilized as
an in vivo interrogator of the GnRH neuronal function in
CHH ( 133 – 136 ). As hypothalamic GnRH neuronal
migration/secretion/function is impaired in CHH, patients with CHH have
minimal gonadotropin response to kisspeptin ( 133 – 136 ).
Intravenous boluses of kisspeptin-10 or kisspeptin-54 result in lower LH
levels than in healthy controls in both adult and pediatric cohorts ( 133 – 136 ).
In adults, kisspeptin-54 led to maximal LH rise of 12.5 IU/L in
eugonadal men compared to 0.4 IU/L in men with CHH ( 135 ). When compared to a GnRH test, kisspeptin-54 more
accurately differentiated men with CHH from eugonadal men, with no overlap
between the two cohorts (area under receiver operating characteristic curve
(AUROC) kisspeptin-54: 1.0, 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.0–1.0; GnRH:
0.88, 95% CI 0.76–0.99) ( 135 ).
Within the CHH cohort, LH rises after kisspeptin-54 were also significantly
lower in those with anosmia as compared to normosmic patients. Likewise,
patients with CHH who had identified pathogenic/likely pathogenic variants
in CHH genes had even lower LH rises after kisspeptin compared to other men
with CHH ( 135 ). Furthermore, in a
small cohort of patients with sustained CHH reversal, response to
kisspeptin-10 was regained suggesting that a kisspeptin test could serve as
a useful test for current hypothalamic function ( 133 ).
In the pediatric cohort, the participants’ responses to
kisspeptin-10 could accurately predict those who later progressed through
puberty denoted “kisspeptin-responders (LH ≥ 0.8 mIU/mL)” compared to
“kisspeptin non-responders (LH ≤ 0.4 mIU/mL)” who did not progress through
puberty. Sensitivity and specificity for the kisspeptin-stimulation test
were both 100% (95% CI 74%-100%) which predicted outcomes more accurately
than previously described basal/stimulated hormonal markers and genetic
testing ( 136 ). Data from these
studies demonstrate the promise of a kisspeptin test of hypothalamic
function in the context of delayed puberty and warrant larger studies ( Figure 4 ).
The ability of kisspeptin to directly stimulate hypothalamic GnRH
release offers novel insight into the physiology of the hypothalamic GnRH
neuronal network. Exogenous kisspeptin was utilized in studies as an
in vivo interrogator of the GnRH neuronal function in
CHH and CDGP. Serum kisspeptin levels can distinguish between different
causes of CPP.
CDGP, constitutional delay of growth and puberty; CHH, congenital
hypogonadotropic hypogonadism; CPP, central precocious puberty; LH,
luteinizing hormone. Figure created with BioRender.com .
Serum kisspeptin levels were first measured as a potential marker of
precocious puberty in 2009 ( 137 ). In
girls with CPP, serum kisspeptin levels were found to be significantly
higher than in age-matched prepubertal controls (14.62 ± 10.2 pmol/l
vs 8.35 ± 2.98 pmol/l) ( 137 ), however there was some overlap between the two
groups. A recent systematic review and meta-analysis included 316 CPP
patients and 251 controls from 11 studies ( 138 ). Consistent with the first study ( 137 ), kisspeptin levels were found to be higher in the
CPP compared to controls; the bias-corrected standardized mean difference
(SMD) was 1.53 (95% CI 0.56-2.51) ( 138 ). Subgroup analyses showed a positive correlation between
serum kisspeptin and age in the CPP cohort, and an association between serum
kisspeptin levels and precocious thelarche ( 138 ). However, as noted previously there are overlaps between
the two cohorts. Kisspeptin levels could therefore complement current
diagnostic tools in precocious puberty ( Figure
4 ).
Menopause
Menopause marks the permanent cessation of menstruation and
reproductive capacity in women and is characterized by depletion of ovarian
follicles, reductions in sex-steroids and inhibin B levels. The loss of
inhibitory actions of sex-steroids and inhibin result in marked increase in GnRH
and downstream gonadotropin activity. As described in previous sections, KNDy
neurons are key intermediary neurons which mediate sex-steroid feedback on GnRH
neurons; thus, the hypoestrogenic state in menopause leads to increased KNDy
neuronal activity.
Evidence from animal studies, largely using ovariectomized models, has
furthered our understanding of the neuroendocrine changes in menopause.
Ovariectomized cynomolgus monkeys demonstrated marked neuronal hypertrophy and
increased NKB and kisspeptin gene expression in the arcuate nucleus ( 47 ). Similarly, increased KNDy neuronal
cell size was evident in ovariectomized mice ( 362 ). Estrogen replacement in these models was able to revert the
heightened NKB and kisspeptin gene expression and KNDy neuronal size to their
baseline levels ( 47 , 362 ). This indicated that the hypertrophic morphological
changes and alterations in KNDy gene expression specifically resulted from
estrogen withdrawal as opposed to being part of the ageing process ( 47 ).
Morphological changes observed within human hypothalamus post-menopause
were first described in 1966 ( 363 ).
Pioneering studies using postmortem hypothalamic tissues from postmenopausal
women demonstrated that ERα ( 364 ), NKB, substance P ( 365 ), and KISS1 mRNA ( 47 ) expressing neurons within the
infundibular nucleus were hypertrophic.
Importantly KISS1 and TAC3 mRNA
expression was increased, conversely prodynorphin mRNA
expression was reduced ( 48 ). This
expression profile suggests increased stimulatory action of kisspeptin and NKB
and reduced basal inhibitory action from dynorphin thus resulting in increased
KNDy neuronal activity and downstream GnRH and gonadotropin secretion following
menopause ( 48 ).
Vasomotor symptoms (VMS), a collective term to describe hot flashes and
sweats, are commonly experienced by over 75% of women during the menopausal
transition ( 366 ). The average duration
of symptoms is 7 years ( 367 ), but
symptoms last longer in a third of women, with 10% of women experiencing
symptoms for up to 12 years ( 368 ).
In rodent models, the tail functions as the primary heat exchange
organ, thus measurement of skin-tail temperature ( 369 ) was used as a model to portray cutaneous
vasodilation, the primary mechanism of hot flashes in humans ( 370 ). In ovariectomized rodents with low
E2 levels, the skin-tail temperature is increased to facilitate heat dissipation
( 371 ) and the temperature threshold
at which heat-defence mechanisms are activated is reduced ( 372 ); both mechanisms to facilitate heat exchange.
Ablation of KNDy neurons led to consistently decreased tail skin
vasodilatation supporting the role of KNDy neurons in modulation of body
temperature in rodents ( 369 ).
Anatomically, in preclinical models, arcuate KNDy neurons project to key
preoptic thermoregulatory areas including the median preoptic nucleus (MnPO) and
medial preoptic area (MPA) ( 370 ). The
MnPO and MPA integrate thermosensory information from warm-sensitive cutaneous
sensors and ultimately influence thermoeffectors such as autonomic cutaneous
vasodilation and cold-seeking behavior ( 370 ). Furthermore, NK3R expression has been demonstrated in the
MnPO. Taken together this intricate anatomical and functional connection between
the arcuate nucleus and preoptic area suggests that a possible mechanism
underlying the pathogenesis of hot flashes in menopause occur at the level of
the hypothalamus through increased NKB signaling ( 370 ) ( Figure 8 ).
Within the arcuate nucleus (analogous to the infundibular nucleus in
human), KNDy neurons have hypertrophic morphology compared to in the
premenopausal state. Due to the loss of negative feedback, there are
compensatory increments in the secretion of kisspeptin and NKB and reduced basal
inhibitory action from dynorphin. In preclinical models, KNDy neurons project to
the hypothalamic median preoptic nucleus (MnPO), which is important for
integration of thermosensory information from warm-sensitive cutaneous sensors,
mediation of efferent neural pathways controlling heat-defense effectors and
ultimately control of thermoeffectors such as autonomic cutaneous vasodilation
and cold-seeking behavior. NK3R are expressed by neurons within the MnPO and
arcuate nucleus. Thus, antagonism of these NK3Rs offers a novel therapeutic
option for the management of VMS.
E2, estradiol; GnRH, gonadotropin-releasing hormone; FSH, follicle
stimulating hormone; KNDy; kisspeptin, neurokinin, dynorphin; LH, luteinizing
hormone; MnPO, median preoptic nucleus; NK3R, neurokinin 3 receptor; PRG,
progesterone; VMS, vasomotor symptoms. Figure created with BioRender.com .
Focal microinfusion of a selective NK3R agonist, senktide, into the
hypothalamic MnPO resulted in a rapid, dose-dependent reduction in core
temperature ( 373 ). Additionally,
administration of NK3R agonist increased skin-tail temperature and reduced core
temperature in mice, in keeping with heat dissipation effector activation ( 374 ) these effects are particularly
pronounced in hypoestrogenic states e.g. post-ovariectomy ( 375 ). Furthermore, administration of a neurokinin receptor
antagonist cocktail (with affinity for NK1R, NK2R and NK3R) into the MnPO
prevented the increase in skin-tail temperature heat dissipation response in
mice ( 375 ). These findings highlight
that the NKB/NK3R/NK1R signaling pathway plays a key role in the pathogenesis of
hot flashes, and therefore antagonizing the action of NKB in these signaling
pathways is delivering a novel therapeutic avenue for VMS ( 376 ).
Some studies have shown that there is a close temporal relationship
between the onset of VMS and LH pulsatile secretions ( 377 ), and significant positive correlations between skin
temperature measurements and circulating LH levels ( 378 ), however data to support this notion is sparse with
small number of subjects included. Women with previous hypophysectomy and FHA
with low circulating concentrations of serum gonadotropins challenged this dogma
and provided clinical evidence for the uncoupling of LH pulses from the onset of
VMS ( 379 ). Women with isolated
gonadotropin deficiency (representative of defective GnRH secretion or
function), experienced similar rates of hot flashes compared to postmenopausal
women thus suggesting that alteration of GnRH synthesis and/or release is not
involved in the generation of hot flashes ( 380 ). Indeed, blinded deconvolution and Bayesian spectrum analysis
demonstrated no clear association between LH pulse and hot flashes interval and
challenged the long-held dogma regarding the synchronicity of hot flashes and LH
pulses ( 381 ). Finally, women affected by
FHA (representative of dysfunctional neurotransmitter input to GnRH neurons),
despite marked hypoestrogenism, reported no symptoms resembling hot flashes
( 380 ). These findings substantiate
the hypothesis that menopausal VMS occurs secondary to estrogen withdrawal and
is mediated through functional changes of estrogen-sensitive afferent
intermediary neurons such as KNDy neurons that provide input and regulate GnRH
neuronal secretion.
To evaluate the contribution of NKB/NK3R pathway in reproduction,
peripheral intravenous NKB infusion was administered to healthy men and
premenopausal women during the follicular phase ( 382 ). In healthy men and women, NKB infusions did not
significantly alter downstream serum gonadotropin or sex-steroid levels compared
to vehicle ( 383 ). In addition,
co-administration of kisspeptin-54 and NKB resulted in significantly lower
increases in gonadotropins compared with kisspeptin alone or when kisspeptin-54
and naltrexone were co-administered ( 384 ). Intriguingly at higher doses, three subjects experienced a hot
sensation and appeared flushed with mild increased in heart rate which stopped
promptly following cessation of NKB infusion. Indeed, this was the first
observation providing direct evidence of NKB stimulation and induction of hot
flashes in humans and ignited interests in antagonizing this pathway as a
potential treatment for menopausal hot flashes.
Following the above study, the ability of NKB to elicit hot flash-like
episodes was tested in premenopausal women. Intravenous NKB induced hot flashes,
both subjectively and objectively (mean heart rate, skin temperature and skin
conductance increased by similar magnitudes to changes observed during natural
menopausal flashes) ( 382 ). Meta-analysis
of three genome-wide association studies (GWAS) of postmenopausal women of
European American, African American, and Hispanic American descent identified 14
single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) associated with VMS ( 385 ). Intriguingly, these SNPs were all
located on chromosome 4 in the TACR3 locus, which suggested
that genetic variation in TACR3 may contribute to an increased
risk of VMS ( 385 ). Collectively, these
data provided functional and genetic evidence to support the pivotal role of NKB
signaling as a mediator of menopausal flushing and sparked interests in
antagonism of the NKB through the use of NK3R antagonists to alleviate VMS
( 376 ).
Substance P is the endogenous ligand that activates NK1R ( 365 ). Central infusion of substance P in
mice led to sleep disturbance, an effect blocked by NK1R antagonist
pre-treatment ( 386 ). Similarly,
intravenous infusion of substance P in healthy men led to worsened mood,
increased rapid eye movement (REM) latency, and disturbed sleeping patterns
( 387 ). Furthermore, substance P
infusion caused hot flashes ( 388 ) and
NK1R has been demonstrated to facilitate heat dissipation through active
vasodilatation ( 389 ). Therefore, NK1R
antagonism may offer beneficial effects not only on the control of VMS but could
also improve sleep quality which is frequently disrupted following
menopause.
To date, four novel neurokinin receptor antagonists that target the
NK3R and NK1R have been evaluated in human clinical trials; Pavinetant
(MLE4901), Fezolinetant (ESN364), Elinzanetant (NT-814) and SJX-653.
The first proof-of-concept trial of NK3R antagonism in postmenopausal
women affected by hot flashes was published in 2017 ( 390 ). MLE4901 (Pavinetant) was administered to 28 healthy
post-menopausal women aged 40-62 years who experienced ≥7 hot flushes per day in
a phase 2, randomized, double-blinded, placebo-controlled, crossover trial
( 390 ). MLE4901 resulted in a
significant reduction in the number and frequency of hot flashes with 45%
reduction in subjective report of hot flashes, 41% and 58% reduction in the
severity and interference of weekly hot flashes respectively compared to placebo
( 390 ). The positive symptomatic
relief was appreciable from the second day of treatment ( 391 , 392 ) thus
highlighting the potential to induce rapid relief for VMS.
The effects of MLE4901 on LH pulse profile appeared to be heterogenous
with one report describing no significant changes in the number of LH pulses but
MLE4901 interestingly increased LH pulse amplitude, and improved orderliness of
LH pulses, compared to placebo ( 390 ).
Conversely in another report, MLE4901 treatment for 7 days resulted in reduction
in basal LH secretion with an overall suppressive effect of LH secretion ( 391 ). No change in E2 ( 390 ) or FSH ( 391 ) levels were observed. Changes in hypothalamic GnRH
pulse release were postulated to account for reductions in LH pulses following
administration of NK3R antagonists and that this could independently suppress
VMS. Due to a rise in transaminase levels up to 6x upper limit of normal
associated with MLE4901 treatment its development has subsequently been
discontinued although other NK3R antagonists have emerged.
Fezolinetant (ESN364) is a selective and reversible antagonist of NK3R.
Twice daily Fezolinetant significantly reduced total VMS scores, frequency of
moderate/severe VMS and led to a 93% reduction in VMS frequency from baseline to
week 12 vs 46% with placebo ( 393 ). At 3hrs post Fezolinetant dose (during peak drug levels),
plasma LH levels decreased by 49.8% vs 16.4% with placebo
relative to baseline consistent with the proposed mechanism of action of KNDy
neuron inhibition ( 393 ). No effect on
E2, FSH and sex hormone binding globulin (SHBG) levels were observed ( 393 ).
SKYLIGHT 1, 2 and 4 are phase 3 multicenter trials of Fezolinetant
treatment that resulted in significant reduction in VMS frequency and severity
compared to placebo ( 394 ) with
beneficial effects maintained for 52-weeks ( 395 ). Interestingly, the MOONLIGHT trial, conducted in Asian women
across 48 Asian countries demonstrated no significant difference in
moderate-severe VMS frequency and severity with Fezolinetant use compared to
placebo ( 396 ). This may be due to
genetic differences and environmental influences.
There were no significant changes from baseline endometrial thickness
between Fezolinetant and placebo-treated participants, and no effect on bone
health after a year of treatment ( 397 ).
Notably, hepatic safety profile was assessed in participants with relevant
hepatic risk factors such as obesity and non-alcoholic fatty liver disease, and
there were no evidence of liver function impairment or liver-associated
symptoms, including no Hy's law cases to indicate drug-induced liver injury
following Fezolinetant use ( 397 ).
Elinzanetant is a dual NK1R and NK3R antagonist. Given its dual
NK1R/NK3R antagonism it has the potential to decrease GnRH pulse frequency by
blocking the effects of endogenous substance P and NKB on the reproductive axis,
as the cognate receptors for substance P and NKB are NK1R and NK3R respectively
( 226 ). Although NK1R has been
proposed to contribute to the pathogenesis of VMS, the predominant action on VMS
associated with Elinzanetant is likely to be mediated via NK3R antagonism as
NK1R antagonism alone is unlikely to fully alleviate VMS but may provide
additional benefits on sleep and anxiolytic effects in postmenopausal women
( 398 ). Higher dose regimens of
Elinzanetant were associated with significant reductions in VMS frequency
(150mg: 84% reduction, 300mg: 66% reduction, placebo: 37% reduction) and in
night-time awakening due to night sweats (150mg: 81% reduction, 300mg: 63%
reduction, placebo: 32% reduction) at the end of the 14 day period ( 399 ) with significant improvements in
sleep and quality of life with return to baseline 4 weeks after discontinuation
of treatment ( 400 ). The OASIS 1 and 2
trials evaluated the efficacy and safety of Elinzanetant 120mg for the treatment
of VMS. Elinzanetant use resulted in significant reductions in VMS frequency
(55-67% reduction) and severity, evident by 4 weeks of treatment. Furthermore,
Elinzanetant improved menopause-related quality of life and reduced sleep
disturbances by the end of 12 weeks. ( 401 ).
SJX-653 resulted in a reversible suppression (up to 70%) of
gonadotropins and testosterone after a single oral dose (dose range 0.5-90mg) in
healthy men aged 18-45 years ( 402 ). As
other NK3R antagonists after achieving similar reductions in LH and testosterone
in men have subsequently been shown to demonstrate reduction in menopausal hot
flushes, this led to the extrapolation that SJX-653 may be an effective
treatment of menopausal hot flushes ( 402 ). Subsequently, this prompted a phase 2 trial to assess the efficacy
of SJX-653 in postmenopausal women with moderate to severe VMS ( 403 ). However, as the primary outcome of
safe and efficacious treatment of VMS was not met, the trial was terminated
early and its further development since discontinued ( 403 ).
Data from animal models and post-mortem hypothalamic studies from
postmenopausal subjects paved our understanding of the role of the NKB pathway
in the pathogenesis of VMS. Antagonism of the NKB pathway resulted in rapid and
sustained relief of VMS and improvements in sleep quality, and overall markers
of quality of life. Antagonism of the NKB pathway demonstrates clear
effectiveness for the management of menopausal hot flushes and is likely to
provide an effective, non-hormonal treatment strategy for the management of VMS.
Recently in 2023, the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has approved
Fezolinetant for use to reduce the frequency and severity of post-menopausal hot
flashes marking the first translational application of therapeutic agent
targeting the NKB pathway ( 376 ).
Pregnancy
The process of embryo implantation and placentation are tightly
coordinated both temporally and spatially; indeed, dysregulation of trophoblast
invasion underlies the pathogenesis of multiple pregnancy-related disorders.
Several factors secreted by the feto-placental unit contribute to the autocrine
and paracrine regulation of trophoblast invasion. Kisspeptin, originally
identified as a metastasis suppressor in various types of cancer called
‘metastin’, has emerged as a key player in implantation and placentation.
During pregnancy, the placenta is the predominant source of circulating
kisspeptin. Once the blastocyst penetrates the endometrium, the trophoblastic
stem cells form into an inner layer of undifferentiated cytotrophoblasts, and an
outer layer of terminally differentiated syncytiotrophoblasts by fusion of
non-migratory villous cytotrophoblasts ( 274 ). The extravillous cytotrophoblasts eventually differentiate
into the placental bed, responsible for the migration of the embryo into the
decidua through degradation of extracellular matrix proteins, and the
endovascular trophoblasts, responsible for the uterine spiral artery remodeling
( 274 ). KISS1 is
expressed in syncytiotrophoblasts, but KISS1R is expressed by
both cytotrophoblasts and syncytiotrophoblasts ( 274 ). KISS1R is expressed at higher levels in first
trimester trophoblasts than in trophoblasts from the placenta at term, inferring
the importance of kisspeptin signaling in implantation and placentation ( 275 ).
Interactions between kisspeptin and cell adhesion molecules promote
embryo attachment to the endometrium and upregulate leukemia-inhibitory factor
(LIF) to promote stromal decidualization ( 274 ). Kisspeptin inhibits placental trophoblast cell migration to
regulate implantation and placentation; preventing excessive trophoblastic
invasion of the endometrium ( 275 – 277 ). Mechanistically kisspeptin directly
activates the ERK1/2 signaling pathway to increase cell adhesion and inhibit
first trimester trophoblast cell migration as well as through downregulation of
matrix metalloproteinase (MMP) system which inhibits extracellular matrix
breakdown ( 276 , 277 ). Kisspeptin-10 stimulated intracellular
Ca 2+ release in primary trophoblasts of the early placenta and
subsequently inhibited trophoblast migration, suggesting that this form is the
physiological activator of kisspeptin receptor in the human placenta ( 275 ). Several studies suggest that
kisspeptin may restrain trophoblastic growth by acting as a placental
pro-apoptotic agent in a dose-dependent manner ( 278 – 280 ). Kisspeptin is also
implicated in uterine spiral artery remodeling and regulating angiogenesis
required for placentation, with VEGF-A expression from human placental
trophoblasts being downregulated by kisspeptin ( 274 , 276 , 281 – 283 ).
Furthermore, kisspeptin appears to be important in regulating maternal
immune tolerance and thus preventing rejection of the developing fetus.
In vitro studies have demonstrated that there is increased
differentiation of naïve human CD4+ lymphocytes into adaptive T-regulatory cells
and when incubated with kisspeptin-54 at levels similar to those during
pregnancy, with inhibition of T-helper 17 lymphocytes induction ( 284 , 285 ). Natural killer cells also specialize into a regulatory subtype
with reduced cytotoxic activity against fetal cells when incubated with
kisspeptin-54 ( 286 ). Kisspeptin-54
concentrations in pregnancy also reduce the functional activity of neutrophils
and increase the functional activity of monocytes; potentially to also
facilitate the development of immune tolerance to the fetus whilst balancing the
need for maternal immunity ( 287 ) ( Figure 7 ).
Kisspeptin has emerged as a promising biomarker to predict several
adverse pregnancy complications. Circulating kisspeptin levels increase linearly
in healthy pregnancy but are reduced in miscarriage during early pregnancy.
Kisspeptin levels are reduced in ectopic pregnancy, fetal growth restriction,
gestational diabetes and early onset pre-eclampsia. Kisspeptin levels are raised
in pre-eclampsia during the later stages of pregnancy and gestational
trophoblastic neoplasia. Figure created with BioRender.com .
Plasma kisspeptin levels increase linearly and dramatically during a
healthy pregnancy with gestational age, being over 200-fold greater in the third
trimester of pregnancy than in non-pregnant women and returning to non-pregnant
levels soon after birth ( 288 – 290 ). Circulating kisspeptin levels in
healthy pregnancy are influenced by several variables; advanced maternal and
gestational age increase circulating kisspeptin levels, whilst Afro-Caribbean
ethnicity, smoking, and high BMI were all associated with lower circulating
kisspeptin levels during pregnancy ( 291 ).
Gestational or pregnancy-induced hypertension is defined as
hypertension (systolic blood pressure ≥140 mmHg and/or diastolic blood
pressure ≥90 mmHg) that occurs after 20-week gestation ( 292 ). Pre-eclampsia occurs when
gestational hypertension is accompanied by proteinuria, maternal
end-organ or utero-placental dysfunction ( 292 ). Early onset pre-eclampsia is attributed to
poor placentation and impaired uterine spiral arteries remodeling
leading to disruption in placental perfusion, whilst late onset
pre-eclampsia occurs when the placenta outgrows the uterine circulatory
capacity leading to placental malperfusion ( 293 ). Both etiologies result in placental hypoxic
stress, however fetal growth restriction (FGR) is more associated with
early onset pre-eclampsia given the longer duration of dysfunctional
uteroplacental perfusion ( 293 ).
KISS1 expression was increased in the placenta
of pre-eclamptic pregnancies according to several reports ( 294 – 297 ). Placental KISS1 expression
inhibits trophoblast invasion and angiogenesis with resulting defective
remodeling of the uterine spiral arteries, inferring a role in the
pathophysiology of pre-eclampsia ( 298 ). Conversely, there have also been reports of reduced
kisspeptin expression in pre-eclamptic placentae ( 299 ). However, KISS1R expression
has also been found to be increased in pre-eclampsia compared to normal
healthy pregnancy and this may facilitate increased functional activity
of kisspeptin in pre-eclampsia ( 299 ).
Varying levels of circulating kisspeptin have been reported in
hypertensive disorders of pregnancy according to the subtype, severity,
and timing of onset. Most studies report reduced kisspeptin levels in
gestational hypertension compared to normotensive pregnancy with levels
declining further with severe disease and in pre-eclampsia ( 294 , 300 – 306 ),
which may reflect reduced placental mass ( 303 , 304 ).
Correspondingly, both circulating kisspeptin levels and placental mass
are lower in early onset pre-eclampsia compared to late onset
pre-eclampsia ( 303 , 307 , 308 ).
FGR describes both intra-uterine growth restriction (fetal
weight <10 th centile for gestational age with abnormal
umbilical artery doppler flow) and small for gestational age (delivery
weight <10 th centile for gestational age) ( 309 , 310 ). FGR is postulated to be the result of
abnormal trophoblast invasion and spiral artery remodeling leading to
deprivation of adequate oxygen supply to the placenta ( 311 , 312 ). Ischemic injury from this inadequate oxygen
supply leads to generation of reactive oxygen species, subsequent
apoptosis, and restriction of placental and fetal growth ( 311 , 312 ). As kisspeptin has been implicated in
regulating trophoblast invasion and spiral artery remodeling, kisspeptin
levels have been demonstrated to be lower in FGR across all three
trimesters compared to healthy pregnancy ( 300 , 308 , 313 , 314 ) and may contribute to the
pathophysiology of FGR. The low circulating kisspeptin levels in FGR may
be representative of the low placental mass.
However, recently kisspeptin levels have been demonstrated to
bear no association to the severity of pre-eclampsia and are increased
in hypertensive disorders of pregnancy during the third trimester ( 308 ). Likewise, another study
found that plasma kisspeptin was higher in late-onset pre-eclampsia
(>34 weeks gestational age) than in gestation-matched controls, but
this was not observed for early-onset pre-eclampsia (≤34 weeks
gestational age) ( 315 ).
Discrepancies between the findings of existing studies may be attributed
to confounding variables such as BMI and gestational age as well as the
complexities of different disorder subsets as well as analytical issues
( 308 ). These would need to
be considered in future larger observational studies to address these
inconsistencies, assessing each subset of hypertensive disorders of
pregnancy and pre-eclampsia separately throughout pregnancy and using
robust assays.
Similarly, the placenta has also been shown to express high
levels of TAC3 ( 316 ) particularly in the outer syncytiotrophoblast layer
( 317 ), facilitating
secretion of NKB into the maternal circulation ( 318 ). NKB is also present in cord blood ( 318 ), consistent with a potential
role in the physiology of feto-placental circulation. High dose NKB
infusion in female rats increased uterine weight by 37%; moreover, NKB
levels correlated with nitric oxide metabolites, with higher circulating
levels observed in women with pre-eclampsia and IUGR ( 319 ). Therefore, suggesting that
NKB, together with locally secreted metabolites such as nitric oxide,
could be important in the hemodynamic adaptation during pregnancy to
ensure adequate fetal blood supply. As pre-eclampsia is a disorder of
trophoblastic invasion, NKB is postulated to be a potential biomarker of
pre-eclampsia, with plasma NKB concentrations becoming detectable by the
ninth week of gestation ( 320 ).
NKB plasma concentrations are low and increase throughout normotensive
pregnancies, with highest concentrations at term before reducing
postpartum, consistent with NKB being reflective of placental mass
( 319 , 321 ). In contrast, pre-eclamptic women demonstrate
a significantly higher level of plasma NKB and NKB placental expression
during the third trimester ( 319 , 322 – 325 ). NKB, as a marker, appears
unique to pre-eclampsia and has no demonstrated association with other
hypertensive disorders ( 326 ).
However, whether plasma NKB levels have predictive value in early
pregnancy for subsequent pre-eclampsia development needs to be clarified
with further longitudinal studies.
Gestational trophoblastic disease (GTD) is characterized by
abnormal proliferation of placental tissue, including premalignant
complete or partial hydatid moles and malignant gestational
trophoblastic neoplasia (GTN). GTN is the result of malignant lesions
( 327 ) that arise from
placental villous and extravillous trophoblasts, comprising
choriocarcinoma, invasive mole, placental site trophoblastic tumor and
epithelioid trophoblastic tumor ( 328 ). Serum β-hCG levels are utilized for the diagnosis,
staging and prognostication of GTN ( 328 , 329 ).
KISS1 and KISS1R expression are
reduced in choriocarcinoma cells compared to healthy placentae and
benign hydatidiform molar pregnancies ( 330 ). Reduced KISS1/KISS1R signaling locally may
mechanistically result in dysregulation of the placentation process thus
facilitating trophoblastic invasion in GTN, and so could have diagnostic
utility in distinguishing metastatic from non-metastatic forms of GTD
( 289 ). Conversely,
circulating kisspeptin levels are elevated in GTN compared to healthy
pregnancy likely as a reflection of the increased malignant
trophoblastic mass in GTN ( 289 ),
with levels significantly declining post-chemotherapy.
Miscarriage is the spontaneous loss of an intrauterine
pregnancy before 24 weeks of completed gestation ( 331 ). Establishing the diagnosis of miscarriage
can be challenging, and pregnancy can be failing for some time before
pregnancy loss is conclusively confirmed. This prolonged phase of
uncertainty and the need for serial investigations poses significant
psychological burden ( 331 , 332 ).
Plasma kisspeptin levels, corrected for gestational age, are
reduced by 60-79% in pregnancies that ended with miscarriage compared to
healthy pregnancies ( 291 , 333 – 337 ). Likewise, trophoblastic kisspeptin
expression was lower in pregnancies that ended with miscarriage compared
to those seen following elective termination of pregnancy ( 338 ). Plasma kisspeptin levels can
reflect the type of miscarriage, with lower levels reported in complete
miscarriage compared to incomplete or missed miscarriage ( 291 ).
The diagnostic performance of kisspeptin in identifying cases
of miscarriage remains high into the late first trimester (>8 weeks
gestation), unlike the alternative biomarker β-human chorionic
gonadotropin (β-hCG) ( 291 ).
Previous studies in women undergoing assisted reproduction showed that
β-hCG levels were a better predictor of pregnancy outcome than
kisspeptin levels in early first trimester ( 339 , 340 ).
These findings may be attributed to the very early gestation at which
kisspeptin levels were being measured (12-21 days after embryo
transfer); indeed, the performance of kisspeptin for predicting
miscarriage improves with gestation ( 291 , 339 , 340 ). A combination approach,
utilizing both plasma kisspeptin and β-hCG levels can provide a higher
diagnostic accuracy of miscarriage at all gestations (AUCROC 0.92, 95%
CI 0.89-0.95) ( 291 , 334 , 336 ).
Ectopic pregnancy refers to an embryo implanting and developing
outside of the uterine cavity most commonly in the fallopian tubes and
therefore poses the risk of potentially life-threatening complication of
tubal rupture ( 341 ). Ectopic
pregnancy is currently diagnosed using ultrasonographic evaluation and
serialized serum β-hCG level measurements ( 342 , 343 ).
However, about 1 in 5 extra-uterine pregnancies have a β-hCG rise in
keeping with an intra-uterine pregnancy. Furthermore, a viable
intra-uterine pregnancy may not be visualized on ultrasound if β-hCG
levels are less than 1000 IU/L ( 342 ). Kisspeptin has been investigated as a potential
biomarker of ectopic pregnancy. Kisspeptin levels are lower in ectopic
pregnancy than healthy pregnancy but are higher than the levels seen in
miscarriage ( 344 ). Lower
circulating kisspeptin levels at early gestational ages can challenge
detection and therefore, larger studies are needed to determine the
utility of kisspeptin for diagnosing ectopic pregnancy at early
gestational ages.
Gestational diabetes mellitus (GDM) affects 20% of pregnancies
worldwide ( 345 ). During
pregnancy there is a physiological increase in maternal insulin
resistance to provide glucose to the developing fetus; GDM occurs when
maternal pancreatic β-cells fail to adapt to this demand ( 346 , 347 ).
In vitro and in vivo studies
have revealed various physiological effects of kisspeptin in
glucose-dependent pancreatic β-cell regulation. Kisspeptin-10,
kisspeptin-13 and kisspeptin-54 all potentiate glucose-stimulated
insulin secretion (GSIS) in mouse and human islet cells in
vitro ( 348 – 351 ). At lower glucose
concentrations (2.8-11.1 mmol/L) kisspeptin-13 and kisspeptin-54
paradoxically demonstrate a dose-dependent inhibition of insulin
secretion in mouse islets, an effect not seen at higher glucose
concentrations ( 352 ).
Kisspeptin-54 has also been shown to increase GSIS in
vivo when administered to healthy men following an
intravenous glucose tolerance test ( 353 ). In addition, chronic administration of kisspeptin-10
to non-pregnant mice potentiated GSIS and improved glucose tolerance
( 354 ). These data suggest
that kisspeptin can enhance GSIS and glucose tolerance in the context of
hyperglycemia.
Indeed Kiss1r -null female mice demonstrated
impaired glucose tolerance, hyperlipidemia, and weight gain ( 355 ). β-cell specific
Kiss1r knockout and pharmacological inhibition of
Kiss1r causes reduced β-cell proliferation compared
to what is expected in murine pregnancy, thus reducing GSIS and
impairing glucose tolerance ( 354 ). Nonetheless β-cell mass is not reduced to pre-pregnancy
levels, suggesting that kisspeptin mediated pathways are not the sole
signal to drive β-cell proliferation during pregnancy ( 354 ).
In GDM, human placental KISS1 and
KISS1R expression is elevated in the third
trimester ( 356 , 357 ), however, circulating
kisspeptin levels are either reduced ( 301 , 354 ) or not
significantly altered ( 308 , 358 ). Significant positive
correlations between kisspeptin and AUC plasma insulin levels following
an oral glucose tolerance test, glucose-stimulated insulin levels, and
β-cell secretory function have been demonstrated in the third trimester.
However, no significant correlations were observed between plasma
kisspeptin and fasting plasma insulin or markers of insulin resistance
( 354 ). This suggests that
the described positive correlation between kisspeptin and
glucose-stimulated insulin levels are not attributable to higher
circulating glucose levels or altered insulin resistance ( 354 ). In this study, women with
GDM also had significantly lower plasma kisspeptin levels than women
without GDM ( 354 ) thus
implicating a role for kisspeptin in the adaptive response to glucose
homeostasis during pregnancy.
Preterm birth is defined as births before 37 completed weeks of
gestation ( 359 ). Kisspeptin may
play a role in preterm birth and has been proposed to initiate labor
through increased oxytocin neuronal firing rates in pregnant rats ( 360 ). Circulating kisspeptin
levels, adjusted for gestation, are higher in pregnancies affected by
preterm birth than in controls during the late-first trimester ( 308 ). The adjusted odds of preterm
birth are increased by 20% (95% CI, 1-42%) for every 1 nmol/L increase
in plasma kisspeptin ( 308 ).
Placental KISS1 mRNA expression is increased in preterm
placentae than in term placentae, placentae from with term vaginal
delivery having a higher KISS1 mRNA expression than
term cesarean delivery ( 361 ).
This implicates increased placental kisspeptin expression in the
induction of labor. However, no differences have been found in the third
trimester in circulating kisspeptin levels between pregnancies reaching
term and preterm birth ( 308 , 361 ). Further
studies are needed to evaluate if there are any differences in
kisspeptin levels preceding onset of labor.
Kisspeptin
The gene encoding kisspeptin, KISS1 , and its transcript
was first identified in 1996 through subtractive hybridization of micro-cell
mediated transfer in melanoma and breast cancer cell lines as a
metastasis-suppressor gene ( 8 – 10 ). The original complementary DNA (cDNA)
designation, Ki SS 1 , combined the
nomenclature for putative S uppressor
S equences and paid homage to Hershey, Pennsylvania,
where the gene was first discovered ( 10 )
and where the famous chocolate ‘ kisses ’ are produced. Using
fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH), the KISS1 gene was
mapped to the long arm of chromosome 1 (1q32-q41), consisting of four exons with
two 5’ untranslated exons and two partially translated exons ( 11 ).
The cognate receptor for kisspeptin was discovered in an entirely
unrelated context. Discovered in 1999, the cDNA clone encoding a G-protein
coupled receptor, GPR54 in rats was noted to bear resemblance (40-50%) to the
galanin receptor gene family ( 12 ). This
gene mapped to chromosome 19q13.3 and had an open reading frame of 1191 base
pair encoding a receptor consisting of 396 amino acids ( 12 ). In 2001, three separate groups working on orphan
G-protein coupled receptors confirmed the human ortholog of the rat GPR54.
Initially named hOT7T175 ( 13 ), AXOR12
( 14 ) or GPR54 ( 15 ) the mRNA consisted of five coding exons, interrupted by
4 introns, and encodes a 398 amino acid protein in humans (cf. 396 amino acid in
rats). In congruence with other G-protein coupled receptors, GPR54, now known as
the kisspeptin receptor, has 7 hydrophobic putative transmembrane domains.
Kisspeptin peptide was confirmed to be the cognate ligand of the GPR54 receptor
( 14 ) using peptides from human
placental isolates ( 13 , 15 ).
KISS1 encodes the 145 amino acid prepolypeptide now
known as kisspeptin (previously termed metastin), which undergoes proteolytic
cleavage into N-terminally truncated segments including kisspeptin-54,
kisspeptin-14, kisspeptin-13 and kisspeptin-10; the suffix denoting their
respective amino acid length ( 15 , 16 ). All native kisspeptin isoforms share a
common C-terminal decapeptide equivalent to kisspeptin-10 including an
Arg-Phe-NH 2 motif characteristic of the RF-amide peptide family
( 13 – 15 ) ( Figure 1 ). In binding- and
functional-assays, kisspeptin-10 resulted in the highest potency in kisspeptin
receptor activation, but the un-amidated C-terminal form had only very weak
activity, indicating that the amidated RF-amide moiety of the C-terminal portion
is required for binding and subsequent activation of the kisspeptin receptor
( 13 – 15 ). The kisspeptin receptor demonstrated selective activation by
kisspeptin peptides, as other RF-amide peptides including neuropeptide FF and
AF, RF-amide-like peptide-1 and 3 and prolactin-releasing peptide failed to
activate the kisspeptin receptor ( 14 , 16 ).
The pivotal role of kisspeptin in reproductive physiology emerged in
2003 following two landmark papers reporting that inactivating variants in the
GPR54 gene, now commonly known as the kisspeptin receptor (encoded by
KISS1R gene in humans and Kiss1r in
non-humans ( 17 )), caused congenital
hypogonadotropic hypogonadism (CHH) in human ( 6 , 7 ). Moreover, phenocopies
were also achieved in mouse Kiss1r knockout models ( 18 ). In 2012, an inactivating variant in
the gene encoding kisspeptin ( KISS1 in humans,
Kiss1 in non-humans ( 17 )) was shown to also result in failure of pubertal initiation
( 19 ). Similarly, a
Kiss1 knockout mouse model also demonstrated lack of
puberty, gonadal failure and infertility, albeit the phenotype was less severe
than Kiss1r knockout models ( 20 , 21 ). By contrast,
activating variants of both KISS1 ( 22 ) and KISS1R ( 23 ) resulted in central precocious puberty (CPP). These
rare cases and concordant animal models consolidated kisspeptin’s essential role
as a regulator of the HPG axis.
As expected, kisspeptin-10 could not elicit an LH response in
Kiss1r knockout models, however in these models, GnRH
neuronal migration, GnRH synthesis and pituitary responsiveness to GnRH were
preserved ( 7 , 21 ). Exogenous kisspeptin administration has since been
demonstrated to stimulate gonadotropin secretion across multiple mammalian
species through various administration modalities including both central
(intracerebroventricular) and peripheral routes (intravenous, intraperitoneal
and subcutaneous) ( 24 – 31 ). Moreover, kisspeptin had a direct
effect on GnRH neurons in hypothalamic explants ex vivo ( 32 ). Mechanistically, kisspeptin’s ability
to stimulate gonadotropin release is dependent on GnRH secretion, indeed
administration of GnRH antagonist blocked its effect on gonadotropin secretion
in animal models ( 24 – 26 ). Anatomically, kisspeptin
immunoreactive fibers are in close apposition with GnRH neurons ( 30 , 33 , 34 ) and ~90% of GnRH
neurons express Kiss1r mRNA in both juvenile and adult mice
( 24 , 35 ). Functionally, kisspeptin induced c-Fos expression in 86% of
GnRH neurons ( 25 ), moreover
electrophysiological studies demonstrated that kisspeptin directly depolarized
GnRH neurons in murine brain slices ( 36 ).
Altogether, these data suggest that kisspeptin acts upstream of GnRH and
regulates GnRH neuronal function.
Kisspeptin-expressing neurons are largely distributed in two discrete
hypothalamic nuclei: the arcuate (analogous to the infundibular nuclei in
primates) and the anteroventral periventricular nucleus (AVPV) in the rostral
hypothalamus, the latter extending into the preoptic periventricular nucleus
(PeN) collectively termed the rostral periventricular area of the third
ventricle (RP3V) ( 37 ). The RP3V neuronal
population has female-dominant kisspeptin expression with a 10-fold sex
difference, whilst the arcuate nucleus does not exhibit any discernible sexual
dimorphism in rodents ( 37 ) ( Figure 2 ).
Arcuate k isspeptin neurons co-express
N KB and dy norphin collectively
known as KNDy neurons; NKB stimulates whereas dynorphin inhibits kisspeptin
release. These KNDy neurons (right panel) exhibit episodic activity that induce
pulsatile GnRH, and in turn LH secretion, and are recognized to be the ‘GnRH
pulse generator’ (at least in rodents). These arcuate kisspeptin expressing
neurons are susceptible to E2 mediated negative feedback. By contrast, RP3V
kisspeptin neurons (left panel) induce an LH surge through E2 mediated positive
feedback to induce ovulation in females.
E2 receptors are associated with or embedded in the plasma membrane, E2
receptors are also located in the cytoplasm or the nucleus of target cells.
However, within the limit of the schematic nature, this graphical depiction may
not have fully captured this complex expression pattern.
AVPV, anteroventral periventricular nucleus; FSH, follicle stimulating
hormone; GnRH, gonadotropin-releasing hormone; KNDy, kisspeptin, neurokinin B
and dynorphin; LH, luteinizing hormone; PeN, periventricular nucleus; RP3V,
rostral periventricular area of the third ventricle. Figure created with
BioRender.com .
Arcuate k isspeptin neurons co-express
neurotransmitters including N KB and
dy norphin, and are thus termed ‘KNDy neurons’ ( 38 ). This expression pattern is highly
conserved across various mammalian species including ewe ( 38 ), mouse ( 39 ), rat
( 40 ) and goat ( 41 ). In addition to appositions to GnRH neurons,
interconnected networks of reciprocal KNDy-KNDy connections are capable of
modulating and eliciting synchronized neuronal firing. KNDy neurons do not
express Kiss1r but do express the NKB receptor (NK3R) and
κ -opioid receptor. Whilst
dynorphin/ κ -opioid receptor agonist abrogated the slow
excitatory postsynaptic potential, blockade of κ-opioid was able to revert this
( 42 ). By contrast, NKB and neurokinin
3 receptor agonist evoked stimulation of arcuate kisspeptin neurons ( 42 ). The regulation of KNDy neurons
therefore occurs in an autocrine/paracrine manner with stimulatory NKB and
inhibitory dynorphin signaling, whilst kisspeptin acts predominantly on
downstream GnRH neurons ( 42 ). Indeed,
administration of exogenous kisspeptin in patients with an inactivating variant
of NKB signaling could restore LH pulse frequency, thus signifying the
functional hierarchy in that NKB signaling functions upstream of kisspeptin
( 43 ). Interestingly, continuous
infusions of kisspeptin can result in generation of pulsatile LH secretion in
various species including in women with FHA ( 43 – 46 ). This could be due to
kisspeptin amplifying and revealing previously undetectable low volume pulses
that had still been generated by the GnRH pulse generator. Additionally, data
suggests that GnRH neurons possess inherent pulsatility that could contribute to
this curious clinical observation. Moreover, conflicting theories on the GnRH
pulse generator are described further below.
The first systematic study in humans utilized hybridization
histochemistry and computer-assisted microscopy to quantify and localize
kisspeptin-expressing neurons in postmortem hypothalamic tissues ( 47 ). KISS1 gene
transcripts were identified predominantly within the hypothalamic infundibular
nucleus (analogous to arcuate nucleus). KNDy neurons were demonstrated in the
infundibular nucleus of post-mortem tissues from women ( 48 ) but the lack of colocalization in young men ( 49 ) suggests that age, sex and species
differences may contribute to this variation. Moreover, the medial hypothalamic
sections did not demonstrate a population of KISS1 neurons in
the RP3V as described in rodent models, although labeled neurons were noted to
scatter sparsely within the medial preoptic area ( 47 ). Further immunohistochemical studies from postmortem
human hypothalamic tissue corroborated these earlier findings, demonstrating
that highest numbers of kisspeptin-54 immunoreactive cell bodies resided in the
infundibular nucleus ( 50 ). Kisspeptin
cell bodies were also observed in the rostral periventricular zone in female
hypothalami and were hypothesized to anatomically represent the kisspeptin
neurons of the RP3V observed in rodents, although the precise function of this
neuronal population in human remains unclear ( 50 ). Recently, highly specific pre-prokisspeptin antibody-based
immunohistochemical and immunofluorescent techniques enabled visualization of
immunoreactive cell bodies in rostral hypothalamic sections in humans. These
cell bodies were devoid of NKB, substance P, and cocaine and
amphetamine-regulated transcript (CART) ( 51 ). Unlike kisspeptin neurons in the rodent RP3V, these kisspeptin
neurons did not express neurotransmitters such as enkephalins, galanin and
tyrosine hydroxylase ( 51 ). The
identification of kisspeptin neurons in the human rostral hypothalamus and
positive estrogenic regulation of this neuronal population challenge the
paradigm that positive estrogen feedback is restricted to the mediobasal
hypothalamus in primates ( 51 ).
The concept of the ‘GnRH pulse generator’ was coined in the 1980s,
positing that pulsatile LH secretion is controlled by a hypothalamic pulse
generator that regulates GnRH neurons. Selective lesioning of the arcuate
nucleus resulted in cessation of gonadotropin secretion whilst function of the
basal thyroid, adrenocortical, and growth hormone axes were preserved ( 52 ). By comparison, complete
deafferentation of the mediobasal hypothalamus (MBH) with sparing of the arcuate
nucleus did not impact the pulsatile rhythm of gonadotropins in rats ( 53 ) or monkeys ( 54 ), and the positive feedback action of E2 on gonadotropin
release was also preserved. Early electrophysiological studies recorded from the
vicinity of the arcuate nucleus provided evidence that multiunit electrical
activity (MUA) volleys were invariably associated with initiation of LH
secretion ( 55 ). These anatomical and
electrophysiological studies therefore suggested that the arcuate region was the
primary structure mediating the hypothalamic control of gonadotropin secretion
in the rhesus monkey and suggested that the pulse generator exists in this area,
thus initially named the ‘arcuate oscillator’.
Whether the pulse generator was inherent within GnRH neurons or whether
this was mediated extrinsically via afferent neurons located in the arcuate
nucleus was debated at the time. Evidence for the concept that the pulsatility
was intrinsic to GnRH neurons stem largely from in vitro
immortalized ( 56 ) and subsequently
embryonic GnRH cell lines (rhesus monkeys ( 57 ); rats ( 58 ); sheep ( 59 ); mouse ( 60 )). These cell lines demonstrated GnRH pulsatility profile and
interpulse frequency reminiscent of those observed in castrated rodents
suggesting that synchronization could be mediated cell-to-cell or through a
diffusible mediator in a paracrine manner. However, the diffuse localization of
GnRH perikarya in vivo questions the applicability and
translatability of these findings. Furthermore, the ability of isolated median
eminence explants devoid of GnRH cell bodies to also elicit GnRH pulsatility,
suggests that synchronization between GnRH cell bodies may not be necessary to
synchronize pulsatile GnRH secretion ( 61 ).
Variation in the frequency of pulsatile GnRH secretion leads to
differential LH and FSH secretion ( 62 , 63 ). In the early
follicular phase, low amplitude pulses occur approximately every 1-1.5hrs, with
transitions to high amplitude pulses every 3-4hrs during most of the luteal
phase ( 61 ). This variation is purported
to be secondary to homeostatic cues including E2. E2 predominantly exerts its
action via estrogen receptor-alpha (ERα), however, as GnRH neurons lack ERα as
well as androgen and progesterone receptors, sex-steroid feedback is therefore
likely mediated indirectly via an intermediary neuronal population ( 64 ). Together this evidence suggests that
the GnRH pulse generator is likely to be extrinsic to the GnRH neurons.
In 2017, optogenetic approaches captured near-perfect correlation
between pulsatile LH secretion (proxy of GnRH secretion) and brief repetitive
episodes of elevated calcium within the arcuate neuronal population ( 65 ). Selective activation and inhibition of
these arcuate KNDy neurons could stimulate and suppress pulsatile LH secretion
respectively, thus providing functional evidence that arcuate KNDy neurons are
indeed the GnRH pulse generator, at least in rodents ( 65 ). Recently, fiber photometry and in
vivo calcium recordings of KNDy cells demonstrated that
synchronized activity of KNDy cells preceded LH pulses ( 66 ). Studies of KNDy cellular activity at a single-cell
level provided the required granularity to reveal that synchronized episodes in
KNDy cells occur in a predictable temporal order with ‘leader cells’ capable of
initiating episodic LH pulses ( 67 ). The
tight temporal relationship between LH and corresponding synchronized KNDy cell
activity in rodent studies supports the hypothesis that KNDy neurons are
important components of the GnRH pulse generator.
GnRH neurons have a bipolar morphology consisting of the soma and
proximal dendrites with few dendritic processes possessing blended dendritic-
and axonal-like properties termed ‘dendrons’ ( 68 ). Morphologically, these dendrons are interconnected, receive
shared inputs from afferent neurons, with KNDy neurons forming appositions at
the distal dendrons to enable synchronized GnRH secretion into the portal
vasculature ( 69 ). Surprisingly, using
expansion microscopy it was shown that unlike the classical synapses observed
between KNDy neurons, GnRH somata and proximal dendrites; KNDy neurons make
non-synaptic appositions with GnRH neuronal dendrons and activate them via
short-distance volume transmission ( 69 ).
Through selective inhibition of proximal and distal GnRH neuronal dendritic
compartments, recent chemogenetic studies demonstrated that the distal dendritic
zones are important during both pulsatile secretion and generation of GnRH/LH
surge, whilst the soma-proximal dendritic compartment appears to be critical for
the generation of the GnRH/LH surge ( 70 ).
In addition to the hypothalamic kisspeptin neuronal populations,
Kiss1/KISS1 mRNA was also detected in several areas of the
central nervous system (CNS) (including the pituitary gland, basal ganglia,
amygdala, substantia nigra and hippocampus), the placenta, pancreas, and bone.
KISS1R mRNA is expressed in similar regions as
KISS1 mRNA, abundantly expressed in the placenta, pituitary
gland, spinal cord, and pancreas with lower expression in extrahypothalamic
brain regions and various tissues such as the stomach and small intestine ( 14 , 15 ).
Whilst the hypothalamic action of kisspeptin is well recognized, the
expression of kisspeptin receptor and its cognate ligand in the pituitary
suggests a potential direct action of kisspeptin at the level of the pituitary
gland. Specifically, the expression of Kiss1 and
Kiss1r in the pituitary is differentially regulated by the
sex-steroid milieu; Kiss1 expression decreased following
ovariectomy but pre-treatment with E2 was able to prevent this, whilst
Kiss1r expression increased following ovariectomy, but this
effect was also negated with E2 treatment ( 71 ). In rhesus monkeys, kisspeptin-positive cells were observed in
the intermediate and anterior lobe of the pituitary gland ( 72 ) and push-pull perfusate samples from the median
eminence of pubertal monkeys indicate significant kisspeptin increments in
association with GnRH ( 73 ). Similarly,
the presence of kisspeptin in the ovine hypophysial portal blood also supported
a potential role of kisspeptin on the anterior pituitary gland ( 74 ).
Despite the anatomical and functional evidence for possible direct
action of kisspeptin at the level of the pituitary, the importance of the
anterior pituitary in mediating kisspeptin action remains contestable. For
example, even though low levels of kisspeptin are detected in the hypophysial
portal circulation, no temporal rise in kisspeptin levels were seen with the
E2-induced GnRH/LH surge in ewes ( 74 ).
Surgical disconnection of the hypothalamic-pituitary unit abolished the LH rise
following kisspeptin stimulation ( 74 )
similar to that observed following pre-treatment with GnRH antagonists ( 24 , 35 ). Most recently selective Kiss1r knockout in the
pituitary gonadotrophs using a PKiRKO mouse model which achieved an 88% and 64%
reduction in Kiss1r mRNA in the pituitary of male and female
mice, respectively, have been used to delineate the contribution of the
pituitary kisspeptin signaling ( 75 ).
Phenotypically there were no differences in pubertal timing, gonadal weight and
basal gonadotropin levels observed in the PKiRKO models, which although do not
negate the potential direct pituitary actions of kisspeptin, suggests that
kisspeptin signaling at the level of the pituitary does not play a major role in
the control of the HPG axis( 75 ).
Finally, reproductive tissues including the ovaries express
kisspeptin/KISS1R and NKB/NK3R locally, and their putative roles will be further
described in the subsequent section. Altogether, these findings strongly
suggested the potential involvement of the kisspeptin system in the control of
diverse physiological systems ( 76 ), which
are explored further in the relevant subsequent sections below.
Conclusions
Since the key physiological roles of kisspeptin and NKB in reproduction
came to light in 2003, developments in pre-clinical and translational research have
significantly advanced our understanding of the contributions of these two
neuropeptides to the functioning of the HPG axis. The unique position of kisspeptin
and NKB within the hypothalamic neuroendocrine circuitry has garnered significant
interest for their potential applications in diagnosing and treating pubertal and
reproductive disorders. Kisspeptin holds promise in distinguishing the causes of
delayed puberty, while measurement of serum kisspeptin levels can aid in diagnosing
precocious puberty and serve as marker for risk-stratification of pregnancy
complications. Kisspeptin-based therapeutic avenues encompass various possibilities,
including the restoration of pulsatile GnRH secretion in hypogonadal disorders like
CHH, FHA, and hyperprolactinemia. Additionally, kisspeptin may serve as a safer
oocyte maturation trigger in IVF treatment and offer a treatment option for
distressing low sexual desire in HSDD.
Similarly, antagonism of the NKB pathway has emerged as a potential
therapeutic target for uterine disorders including uterine fibroids and
endometriosis, and for PCOS given their ability to reversibly suppress, but not
abolish, the HPG axis. Most significantly, within the last year, we have seen the
bench to bedside translation of NK3R antagonist, Fezolinetant, for treatment of hot
flashes in menopause.
Despite the impressive advancements over the past two decades ( Figure 10 ) and the successful translation of the
first-in-class NK3R antagonist, the reproductive biology of kisspeptin and NKB
remains an intriguing research area with exciting potential therapeutic discoveries.
The rapid technological advancements in optogenetics, fiber photometry and
in vivo recordings of KNDy neuronal activity in freely moving
animals have provided detailed insights into KNDy neurons at a cellular level. The
identification of kisspeptin neurons in the human rostral hypothalamus and the
positive estrogenic regulation of this neuronal population challenge long-held views
regarding estrogen feedback in humans. Advancements in genetics and epigenetics have
revealed novel silencers and activators that fine-tune pubertal timing through
activation or repression of kisspeptin gene expression. Additionally, the
integration of metabolic homeostatic cues and the involvement of afferent,
intermediary neurons have deepened our understanding of the intricate connections
between metabolic states and the HPG axis, which hold broader physiological
implications beyond reproductive physiology.
In the field of reproductive endocrinology, significant unmet treatment
challenges persist including therapeutic options for hypogonadotropic hypogonadism
(FHA). There is also a pressing need for oocyte maturation trigger with favorable
OHSS safety profile and new osteoporosis treatments. Addressing and understanding
the distressing low sexual desire as seen in HSDD remains a challenge, while ongoing
development and evaluation of different NK3R antagonists in menopausal hot flashes
will provide data on their long-term safety and efficacy profile in different
patient groups. These challenges are driving ongoing translational research efforts,
particularly focusing on the kisspeptin and NKB pathways, paving the way for more
advancements in the years to come.
Reproduction
Following pubertal transition and attainment of reproductive capacity,
maintenance of the reactivated HPG axis function is indispensable for fertility and
successful reproduction. Key physiological processes in the menstrual cycle such as
folliculogenesis and ovulation are tightly regulated by intricate negative and
positive feedback mechanisms in response to sex-steroids (and other signals) with
patterns of GnRH and subsequent LH release varying during different phases of the
menstrual cycle. During follicular development, pulsatile GnRH secretion is
modulated by negative feedback from circulating E2 with LH pulses occurring
approximately every hour, whilst during the preovulatory stage, high E2
concentrations exert positive feedback to result in the mid-cycle LH surge and
ovulation following which LH pulse frequency progressively lengthens to every 2 to
4hrs during the luteal phase ( 61 ).
The activity of kisspeptin neurons varies throughout the menstrual cycle
modulated by E2 levels. Whilst both the arcuate KNDy neurons and RP3V kisspeptin
neurons express receptors for sex-steroids including estrogen receptor alpha (ERα)
( 139 ), progesterone ( 140 ) and androgen receptors ( 141 ) these two kisspeptin-expressing neuronal
populations are associated with disparate functions. During the majority of the
follicular and luteal phases, E2 exerts negative feedback and inhibits arcuate KNDy
neurons, thus plays a role in the maintenance of pulsatile GnRH secretion. In the
late follicular phase, high E2 stimulates RP3V kisspeptin neurons through positive
feedback resulting in the GnRH/LH surge responsible for ovulation. This was
supported by the differential regulation effects of E2 on RP3V
Kiss1 gene expression (stimulatory) and arcuate
Kiss1 expression (inhibitory) ( 142 – 144 ). Correspondingly, as
the GnRH/LH surge, which is essential for ovulation, occurs exclusively in females,
RP3V kisspeptin neurons demonstrate marked sexual dimorphism with increased
Kiss1 in females compared to males. During the luteal phase,
progesterone from corpora lutea acts to slow pulsatile GnRH and LH secretion.
Following exogenous progesterone administration, the ovine Kiss1
mRNA expression is reduced ( 145 ) whilst
Pdyn mRNA expression is increased ( 146 ), thus supporting the potential role of KNDy neurons in
mediating this homeostatic-negative feedback to regulate GnRH and LH pulse
generation. This putative role was recently investigated using mice with conditional
progesterone receptor deletion from KNDy neurons which demonstrated that whilst
females have significantly fewer pups, there were no observable effects on estrous
cyclicity, LH pulse parameters, or the ability of exogenous progesterone to mediate
LH suppression ( 147 ). Thus, the loss of
progesterone receptor from arcuate KNDy neurons (89% knockout) is insufficient to
disrupt negative feedback regulation of GnRH pulses in female mice, suggesting that
the small number of remaining KNDy neurons may be sufficient or indeed that other
cells may be implicated to regulate GnRH pulse generation ( 147 ).
In premenopausal women, the gonadotropin response to exogenous kisspeptin is
dependent on the endogenous sex-steroid milieu. During most phases of the cycle, the
LH response to kisspeptin is modest and less than that in eugonadal men
(27,44,148–150). In healthy adult men, a 90 minute infusion of kisspeptin-54
(4pmol/kg·min) led to mean stimulated LH of 10.8 ± 1.5 IU/L vs 4.2
± 0.5 IU/L following saline control ( 27 ).
Similarly, an infusion of kisspeptin-10 (4μg/kg·hr) led to a robust rise in LH from
a mean of 5.4 ± 0.7 to 20.8 ± 4.9 IU/L ( 44 ).
In females, a subcutaneous bolus of kisspeptin-54 increased plasma LH compared with
saline in all phases of the cycle, however the greatest LH rise was seen in the
preovulatory and least in the follicular phase (mean increase in LH over baseline in
follicular phase: 0.12 ± 0.17 IU/L; preovulatory phase: 20.64 ± 2.91 IU/L and luteal
phase: 2.17 ± 0.79 IU/L) ( 29 ). This
differential response is also evident following kisspeptin-10, where during the
follicular phase, no rise in serum gonadotropins was observed, whereas in contrast
during the preovulatory phase, serum LH and FSH were elevated after an intravenous
bolus of kisspeptin-10 (10 nmol/kg) with a mean LH area-under-the-curve (AUC)
increase of 30.3 ± 7.7 h·IU/L) ( 149 ). The
incremental LH response to kisspeptin solely in the late follicular/preovulatory
phase of the menstrual cycle evidences the role for kisspeptin in the preovulatory
positive estrogenic drive to GnRH/LH secretion ( 29 , 31 , 45 , 149 , 151 , 152 ).
In ovariectomized mice, during an LH surge induced with exogenous
gonadal steroids, ~30% of RP3V kisspeptin neurons expressed c-Fos compared to
none in non-surging controls ( 153 ).
Notably, there was a strong correlation between the percentage of c-Fos-positive
kisspeptin neurons and the percentage of c-Fos-positive GnRH neurons ( 153 ). The LH surge was absent in
Kiss1 ( 154 ) and
Kiss1r knockout rodent models with low functional
c-Fos-GnRH activity ( 154 ). Moreover,
continuous intracerebroventricular injection of a kisspeptin receptor antagonist
prevented the preovulatory LH surge in adult cycling female rats in the
proestrus phase and in the sheep ( 83 , 155 ). Thus, kisspeptin
signaling is essential for GnRH neuronal activation that initiates
ovulation.
To investigate the role of kisspeptin in the physiological positive
estrogen feedback that induces the ovulatory LH surge in women ( 156 ), exogenous estrogen was administered
to achieve sufficient plasma E2 levels to induce ovulation. Treatment with
exogenous estrogen for 32hrs increased serum E2 and serum LH at 48hrs, which
continued to be elevated at 72hrs. Kisspeptin-10 infusion was able to stimulate
LH secretion with the degree of LH rise proportional to serum E2 concentrations
at the start of the infusion ( 156 ).
Congruous with preclinical data, kisspeptin appears to be a key component of the
preovulatory LH surge through direct GnRH stimulation.
The potential role of locally expressed kisspeptin, NKB and their
cognate receptors in the ovaries is increasingly recognized. Within the ovaries
NKB/NK3R and kisspeptin/KISS1R is expressed in the uterus, ovary, oviduct ( 157 ) and within ovarian granulosa cells
( 158 ). Studies using
Kiss1r haplo-insufficient mice model led to premature
ovarian insufficiency, progressive loss of developing follicles despite
preserved gonadotropin levels thus substantiating the importance of direct
kisspeptin signaling in the ovaries ( 159 ). In vitro applications of kisspeptin and NKB in
follicular cells induced expression of steroidogenic enzymes ( 160 ), local growth factors to regulate
ovarian cells’ viability, proliferation, apoptosis, and hormone release ( 161 ). The NKB/NK3R and kisspeptin/KISS1R
system may therefore be important in the autocrine/paracrine regulation of
follicular development, oocyte maturation, ovulation and ovarian steroidogenesis
( 162 ). In women with PCOS,
expression studies demonstrated upregulation of KISS1 and
KISS1R ( 163 ) and
downregulation of NK3R mRNA ( 160 ) in granulosa cells compared to eumenorrheic controls. Further
understanding of the physiology of NKB/NK3R and kisspeptin/KISS1R systems in the
ovary may therefore advance our knowledge of the pathogenesis of ovulatory and
reproductive disorders.
Ovulatory disorders are common causes of oligo/amenorrhea and
subfertility. The International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics (FIGO)
guidelines primarily classifies ovulatory disorders into four groups: Type I:
Hypothalamic; Type II: Pituitary; Type III: Ovarian and Type IV: polycystic
ovary syndrome (PCOS) ( 164 ). With the
exception of Type III: Ovarian, the other causes of ovulatory disorders involve
the neuroendocrine control of GnRH function.
Functional hypothalamic amenorrhea (FHA) is one of the most common
causes of amenorrhea and ovulatory dysfunction being present in 53% and 72% of
primary and secondary amenorrhea, respectively ( 165 ). FHA is characterized by low body-weight, excessive exercise,
and stress, on a background of genetic susceptibility. The resultant reduced
energy availability associated with hypoleptinemia, results in reduced GnRH
neuronal function and a top-down disruption of the HPG axis with detrimental
impact on fertility, bone, and cardiovascular health ( 166 ).
Caloric restriction models are frequently employed to evaluate the
impact of low body weight and hypoleptinemia on reproductive phenotypes. Under
chronic undernutrition, gonadally intact female mice experienced rapid weight
loss, cessation of estrus cyclicity, a significant decrease in uterine/ovarian
weight and number of corpora lutea. Kiss1 mRNA expression in
the arcuate and RP3V nucleus were reduced resulting in marked suppression of
pulsatile LH secretion and E2-induced LH surge ( 167 ). As discussed above, the effect of low circulating leptin
levels on the reproductive axis in FHA is likely mediated through intermediary
neurons including AgRP/NPY and POMC/CART neurons that abundantly express LepR as
well as insulin receptor and growth hormone secretagogue receptor ( 168 – 171 ), which are cognate receptors for leptin, insulin, and ghrelin,
respectively. These metabolic hormones are major endocrine signals of energy
reserves. In addition to their key roles as gatekeepers of pubertal development
these neurons also integrate and finetune the metabolic hormones’ permissive
signals for healthy cyclicity and ovulation. For example, chemogenetic
activation of AgRP neurons disrupts rodent estrus cyclicity, increases duration
of diestrus phase and time to conception ( 107 ) as well as decreasing LH secretion post-gonadectomy ( 172 ), mimicking the FHA phenotype.
PCOS affects 2-13% of reproductive age women and is traditionally
diagnosed based on the presence of 2 of the following 3 criteria: (i) menstrual
irregularity, (ii) hyperandrogenism (clinical or biochemical) and (iii)
polycystic ovarian morphology ( 173 ).
PCOS is characterized by elevated LH pulse frequency, androgen excess, which
causes impaired suppression of GnRH secretion in response to sex-steroid induced
negative feedback ( 174 ). The raised LH
to FSH ratio (due to increased GnRH pulsatility) gives rise to the reproductive
phenotypes through stimulation of androgen secretion from thecal cells and
preovulatory follicle arrest. In PCOS, impaired negative feedback to E2 and
progesterone indicates neuroendocrine disruption which impair the ability of
steroid hormones to restrain GnRH/LH pulse frequency ( 175 ). Indeed, antagonizing the androgen receptor could
restore sensitivity to sex-steroid mediated feedback ( 176 ). The lack of androgen receptors on GnRH neurons
implies involvement of afferent intermediary neurons such as
kisspeptin-expressing neurons. A prenatal androgen-treated mouse model of PCOS
demonstrated elevated androgen receptor gene expression in KNDy cells whilst
significant reductions in progesterone receptor and dynorphin gene expression
were observed suggesting impaired negative feedback to KNDy cells ( 141 ). Furthermore, synaptic inputs from
hypothalamic regions sensitive to sex-steroids to KNDy neurons were reduced
( 141 ).
As the pathogenesis underlying both FHA and PCOS involve neuroendocrine
dysregulation of GnRH pulsatility and ovulation; the kisspeptin/NKB system, with
its key physiological role as the GnRH pulse generator, has therefore emerged as
a prime neuronal population to integrate internal homeostatic factors to
fine-tune the final neuronal output ( Figure
5 ). Considerable research in the clinical application of kisspeptin
and NKB has therefore been undertaken as detailed below.
CHH, congenital hypogonadotropic hypogonadism; FHA, functional
hypothalamic amenorrhea; GnRH, gonadotropin-releasing hormone; LH, luteinizing
hormone; NKB, neurokinin B; NK3R, neurokinin 3 receptor; PCOS, polycystic ovary
syndrome. Figure created with BioRender.com .
Assessment of circulating kisspeptin levels may have diagnostic
utility and be used to differentiate ovulatory disorders. Circulating
kisspeptin levels are lower in women with FHA, particularly in those with a
reduced LH, compared to healthy women on days 11-13 of the menstrual cycle
( 177 , 178 ). In keeping with this, kisspeptin levels also
negatively correlated with physical activity ( 179 ). Conversely, a meta-analysis of 12 studies
reported that circulating kisspeptin levels were higher in women with PCOS
than in healthy controls with a pooled AUC of 0.835 and pooled odds ratio
(OR) of 13.71 when differentiating women with PCOS from BMI-matched controls
( 180 ). A further case-control
study also demonstrated that PCOS was associated with increased kisspeptin
levels ( 181 ). However, at present
the challenges of accurately detecting low serum kisspeptin levels using
current assays limit its potential clinical use.
The ability of kisspeptin to directly stimulate GnRH secretion
enables its potential use as a diagnostic test to interrogate hypothalamic
GnRH neuronal functioning. Men with CHH demonstrated a reduced LH and FSH
response to an intravenous bolus of kisspeptin-54 compared to eugonadal men
( 135 ). A subcutaneous bolus of
kisspeptin-54 stimulates a greater rise in LH in women with FHA compared to
eumenorrheic controls ( 182 ). The
kisspeptin receptor agonist, MVT-602, demonstrated a similar degree of LH
increase in both healthy women and those with PCOS, but an augmented and
expedited rise in women with FHA ( 152 ). These differential responses offer the possibility of
kisspeptin being utilized as a diagnostic test to differentiate between
ovulatory disorders pending further studies.
Kisspeptin could have therapeutic utility for functional
hypogonadal disorders with hypothalamic dysfunction such as FHA given
its ability to directly stimulate the hypothalamus. FHA is characterized
by a loss of the physiological pulsatile release pattern of GnRH and LH
subsequently leading to reduced folliculogenesis, low E2 production and
anovulation ( 183 ). The
recommended first-line treatment for FHA following lifestyle
modification is pulsatile GnRH pump therapy to replace the lack of
pulsatile GnRH release in FHA, but limited availability of these pumps
precludes its clinical utility ( 31 , 166 , 184 ). Estrogen supplementation
provides symptomatic relief and benefits to bone mineral density (BMD)
but does not address fertility issues ( 31 , 184 ).
Furthermore, the use of clomiphene citrate, a selective estrogen
receptor modulator, which reduces the E2 mediated negative feedback to
increase endogenous gonadotropin secretion, often has limited effect due
to the inherently hypoestrogenic state associated with FHA ( 31 , 184 ). Recombinant leptin treatment is also not desirable for
use in women with FHA as it can cause weight loss ( 99 , 166 ).
Kisspeptin-54 administration can increase LH pulsatility in women with
FHA even when administered in a non-pulsatile manner with a greater LH
rise than in healthy women ( 31 , 182 ). Indeed, the
response to kisspeptin is increased in FHA, which could be by a
compensatory increase in the kisspeptin receptor, as observed in
caloric-restricted rodent models ( 102 ). However, chronic administration protocols are required
to facilitate its therapeutic use in FHA.
Chronic administration of twice daily kisspeptin-54 in FHA
resulted in tachyphylaxis, with the LH response to kisspeptin-54 being
significantly diminished by day 14 of administration ( 182 ). This phenomenon is
hypothesized to be secondary to kisspeptin receptor desensitization,
with response to GnRH maintained after kisspeptin treatment,
demonstrating intact pituitary response ( 182 ). Tachyphylaxis with chronic kisspeptin
administration has been demonstrated across several species and is more
likely to occur with frequent and high dose administration ( 185 ). Tachyphylaxis also appears
to be influenced by sensitivity to kisspeptin, with the same dosing
schedule used in women with FHA, not inducing tachyphylaxis during the
follicular phase of healthy women when they are less sensitive to
kisspeptin ( 29 , 149 ). Extending the dosing
interval of kisspeptin-54 to twice weekly enabled persistent LH
stimulation over 8 weeks of treatment, although menstrual cyclicity was
not restored ( 186 ). Thus, an
intermediate dosing regimen between twice daily and twice weekly could
be required for this indication.
Continuous infusion of kisspeptin could provide an alternative
method for administration for chronic stimulation in women with FHA.
Administration of kisspeptin-54 to women with FHA via continuous
intravenous infusion over 8 hours led to a dose-dependent increase in
mean LH and FSH levels, with an intermediate dose having the greatest
effect on LH pulsatility ( 187 ).
Thus, continuous administration of kisspeptin at lower doses could
maintain LH pulsatility but avoid causing desensitization. However,
studies utilising chronic continuous kisspeptin administration to
identify the optimal dose to achieve stimulation persistently in this
population are still required.
Kisspeptin receptor agonists also provide a potential
therapeutic option in FHA. MVT-602 (previously known as TAK-448) was
developed through modification of kisspeptin-10 to form a nonapeptide
that has increased stability, water solubility, and potency ( 152 ). MVT-602 has a similar
pharmacokinetic profile to kisspeptin-54, with a half-life after
subcutaneous injection of 1.5hrs, however in healthy women in the
follicular phase it caused a more sustained rise in LH ( 152 ). When administered to women
with FHA, MVT-602 resulted in an advanced LH response compared with
healthy women with a greater rise in FSH than in the follicular phase of
healthy women ( 152 ). MVT-602
administration has exhibited tachyphylaxis when given as a high-dose
subcutaneous infusion in men ( 188 ). However, the response to a single subcutaneous bolus
of MVT-602 in women with FHA was sustained for 48hrs and could
facilitate infrequent low-dose bolus chronic administration protocols
for FHA treatment to mitigate against tachyphylaxis ( 152 ). Further studies are needed
to evaluate whether low dose intermittent administration of MVT-602 can
achieve persistent stimulation and therefore be appropriate for a
chronic administration protocol, especially given its increased potency
( 152 ).
Kisspeptin could also have a therapeutic role in other causes of
functional hypogonadism due to hypothalamic dysfunction such as
hyperprolactinemia. Hyperprolactinemia results in hypogonadotropic
hypogonadism through suppression of kisspeptin afferents to GnRH neurons
resulting in reduced GnRH/LH pulse frequency and amplitude ( 189 – 191 ). An intravenous infusion of kisspeptin-10 for
12hrs significantly increased LH, FSH and E2 levels, and increased LH
pulsatility in women with chronic hyperprolactinemia-induced
hypogonadotropic amenorrhea with cabergoline-resistant
microprolactinomas ( 190 ).
Likewise, repeated intravenous bolus administration of kisspeptin-10
also increased LH levels in women with hyperprolactinemia ( 189 ). This may offer a treatment
option to restore ovarian function in cases of hyperprolactinemia where
dopamine agonists are ineffective or not tolerated and pituitary surgery
is not an option. However, kisspeptin administration would not be
expected to affect prolactinoma size, and safety of restoring ovulation
should be carefully considered by the multidisciplinary team.
Current treatment strategies for PCOS target specific symptoms
rather than the underlying pathophysiological process. PCOS is
characterized by an abnormally increased GnRH pulse frequency, which is
reflected by LH predominant secretion with arrested follicle development
resulting from the relative FSH deficiency ( 192 ). This increased LH promotes ovarian
hyperandrogenism, which in turn reduces sex-steroid negative feedback to
hypothalamic kisspeptin neurons, to further drive increased LH
secretion, establishing a vicious cycle. When kisspeptin-10 was
administered to women with PCOS, the response was LH predominant,
demonstrating a positive association with pre-treatment E2 concentration
but with little FSH response ( 193 ). However, following pre-treatment for 1 week with an
oral neurokinin-3 receptor antagonist an FSH response was observed
following kisspeptin-10 administration with a maintained LH response.
Neurokinin-3 receptor antagonist administration reduced FSH and LH
secretion and LH pulse frequency, which could facilitate the
differential response to kisspeptin-10 observed and help restore
folliculogenesis ( 193 ). The
kisspeptin receptor agonist MVT-602 may also provide a promising
alternative option. When administered to women with PCOS, MVT-602 causes
both an LH and FSH rise to a similar degree as healthy women in the
follicular phase, and could be used to trigger ovulation during
ovulation induction cycles pending further studies ( 152 ).
The efficacy of chronic administration of kisspeptin to
oligo/anovulatory women with PCOS has been investigated. Twice daily
subcutaneous kisspeptin-54 for 3 weeks resulted in an overall small rise
in LH, but no rise in FSH ( 194 ).
Furthermore, only 2 women with oligo/anovulatory PCOS subsequently
ovulated. A similar finding was demonstrated using rodent models of PCOS
where in anovulatory rats with neonatal androgen exposure, a bolus of
kisspeptin-54 resulted in marked LH and FSH responses and rescued
ovulation. However, in post-weaning androgenized rats with persistently
raised androgen levels, the LH response to kisspeptin-54 was blunted and
there was no resulting ovulation ( 194 ). This study evidences the variability of endocrine
profile in women with PCOS and how it will likely influence the
subsequent response to kisspeptin. Therefore, an individualized approach
is required when approaching the management of patients with PCOS.
NKB antagonism has also been an area of interest in PCOS treatment.
Women with PCOS with inactivating variants of genes encoding for NKB or its
receptor, have low baseline LH and LH pulsatility ( 89 , 90 ). However,
mouse models with absent NKB signaling can still generate LH pulses ( 195 ). Thus, antagonism of NKB action could
target the pathophysiological process underlying the increased LH secretion and
hyperandrogenism observed in PCOS through normalization of GnRH pulsatility.
Women with PCOS who received the oral neurokinin-3 receptor antagonist MLE4901
at 80mg/day had a 52% baseline-adjusted reduction in the AUC of LH, a 79%
reduction in basal LH secretion, and an LH pulse decrease of 3.6 pulses/8hrs
after 7 days of treatment compared to placebo ( 196 ). Furthermore, total testosterone and free testosterone levels
were reduced by 29% and 19% respectively ( 196 ). A subsequent study administered MLE4901 at 40mg twice daily to
women with PCOS and showed a reduction in LH secretion (from 6.5 to 4.0 IU/L),
as well as in LH pulse frequency and FSH levels compared to placebo ( 193 ). Another neurokinin-3 receptor
antagonist, Fezolinetant, has also been trialed in women with PCOS at dose of
60mg and 180mg for 12 weeks, causing reduced LH, FSH, total testosterone levels
and LH:FSH ratio in a dose-dependent manner ( 197 ). No changes were observed in E2 and progesterone levels,
endometrial thickness, follicle development, or menstrual cycle irregularity in
this study.
Subfertility affects 1 in 6 couples and is defined as the inability to
conceive following 12 months of regular unprotected sexual intercourse ( 198 ). In vitro
fertilization (IVF) is one of the main treatment options for infertility, with a
4-5% annual increase per year in the number of IVF cycles undertaken in the UK
( 199 ). During IVF,
supraphysiological doses of FSH are used to induce multi-follicular growth in
the ovaries. Premature ovulation is prevented by administration of competitive
GnRH antagonist or by chronic administration of GnRH agonist (short
vs long protocol respectively). Once the follicles reach a
size threshold of 17-18mm, LH receptor agonism is provided to induce oocyte
maturation (resumption of the first meiotic division and luteinization of
granulosa cells) and ovulation. Human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) or GnRH
agonists are usually used in current clinical practice to provide this LH
receptor agonism ( 200 ).
The physiological LH surge during the natural menstrual cycle has a mean
duration of 48hrs with three phases; firstly a short ascending phase lasting
14hrs, secondly a peak plateau phase reaching an average amplitude of 56.5 IU/L
with a standard deviation of 23.4 (range 25-114 IU/L) ( 201 ) lasting 14hrs, and lastly a long descending phase of
20hrs ( 202 ). Kisspeptin has been shown
to induce an amplitude of LH rise more in keeping with that of the physiological
mid-cycle LH surge compared to either hCG or GnRH agonists ( 203 – 205 ). The peak LH level following a kisspeptin-54 trigger was 41.4
IU/L at 4hrs post-administration ( 206 , 207 ). The kisspeptin
receptor agonist, MVT-602, has recently been characterized in healthy women and
in women with reproductive disorders ( 152 ). In the healthy follicular phase, the amplitude of LH rise was
similar to that after kisspeptin-54, however the duration was markedly prolonged
compared to kisspeptin-54 (time of peak LH: MVT-602 21-22hrs vs
kisspeptin-54 4.7hrs) leading to a more than four-fold increase in the area
under the curve of the LH exposure ( 152 ). In a minimal stimulation cycle, the mean increase in LH from
baseline was 82.4 IU/L at ~25hrs following administration of 3 μg MVT-602 and
remained elevated to >15 IU/L for 33hrs ( 208 ). Thus, MVT-602 appears to induce an LH profile that is most
similar to that of the endogenous LH surge. In contrast, GnRH agonist trigger
results in a supraphysiological peak LH level of 140.4 IU/L at 4hrs
post-administration, and hCG levels peak ~24hrs post administration at 121.0
IU/L ( Figure 6 ) ( 207 ). Therefore, kisspeptin appears to be a promising
alternative agent providing a more physiological LH profile for induction of
oocyte maturation in IVF protocols.
Kisspeptin/MVT-602 acts at the level of the hypothalamus to stimulate
kisspeptin receptors on GnRH neurons leading to GnRH release. Kisspeptin induces
a peak LH rise of ~45 IU/L at ~5hrs, returning to pre-trigger levels at
12-14hrs. MVT-602 induces a peak rise in LH of similar amplitude to that of
kisspeptin-54, however the duration of the LH rise was markedly prolonged, with
peak LH occurring at ~21-22hrs. GnRHa acts at the level of the anterior
pituitary gonadotrophs to stimulate endogenous LH and FSH secretion. GnRHa
induces a peak LH level of 140.4 IU/L at 4-6hrs after administration.
hCG and rLH act at the level of the ovary, directly on LH receptors. A
subcutaneous bolus of hCG results in a peak hCG level of 121.0 IU/L at 24hrs
after administration.
GnRHa, gonadotropin-releasing hormone agonist; hCG, human chorionic
gonadotropin; LH, luteinizing hormone; rLH, recombinant luteinizing hormone.
Figure created with BioRender.com .
Indeed, kisspeptin-54 was used as a trigger for oocyte maturation in a
proof-of-concept study in 2014 ( 203 ). A
single subcutaneous bolus injection of kisspeptin-54 (dose-range between 1.6 and
12.8 nmol/kg) in 53 women with infertility undergoing a GnRH antagonist
co-treated IVF cycle ( 203 ). This
resulted in the successful retrieval of at least one mature oocyte in 51 of 53
women (96.2%), one embryo for implantation in 49 of 53 women (92.5%), and the
birth of 12 healthy babies ( 203 ).
A major complication of established protocols using hCG as the oocyte
maturation trigger is the risk of ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome (OHSS),
which can be life-threatening with severe forms occurring in 2-6% of IVF cycles
( 209 – 211 ). This can be attributed to the prolonged duration of
action of exogenously administered hCG lasting ~10 days ( 212 ). OHSS occurs due to excessive ovarian stimulation
causing release of vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) and increased
vascular permeability, resulting in fluid shifts from the intravascular to the
third space compartments ( 209 ). This can
lead to ascites, pleural effusions, and renal failure ( 209 ). Current strategies employed in IVF practice to
reduce OHSS risk include the use of GnRH antagonist protocol to prevent
premature ovulation during ovarian stimulation and the use of a GnRH agonist to
trigger final oocyte maturation, however these techniques can have unwanted
effects on efficacy, such as lengthening the time to pregnancy, or increasing
the risk of late pregnancy complications such as pre-eclampsia ( 209 ).
Kisspeptin-54 was investigated as an oocyte maturation trigger in women
at high risk of OHSS defined as total antral follicle count of >23 or serum
AMH level ≥40 pmol/L ( 204 ). In 60 women
at high risk of OHSS, kisspeptin safely induced oocyte maturation with no cases
of moderate, severe, or critical OHSS ( 204 ). A single subcutaneous bolus of kisspeptin-54 (dose range
3.2-12.8 nmol/kg) resulted in oocyte maturation in 95% of women and this rate
increased in a dose-dependent manner: 53% at 3.2 nmol/kg, 86% at 6.4 nmol/kg and
9.6 nmol/kg, and 121% at 12.8 nmol/kg ( 204 ). Embryo formation occurred in 90% of women with resulting
biochemical pregnancy, clinical pregnancy, and live birth rates per transfer of
63%, 53%, and 45% respectively ( 204 ). In
a single-center retrospective study, the risk of OHSS was markedly increased
with hCG (OR 33.6; CI, 12.6-89.5) or a GnRH agonist (OR 3.6; CI 1.8-7.1) than
kisspeptin-54 ( 213 ).
Even though the amplitude of LH exposure induced by kisspeptin-54 (~45
IU/L) is similar to that of the physiological midcycle LH surge (56.5 IU/L); the
duration of LH exposure induced by kisspeptin-54 is shorter than the triphasic
physiological LH surge. To determine if the duration of LH-exposure impacts on
IVF outcomes, 62 women at high risk of OHSS were randomized to receive either
one or two doses of kisspeptin-54 to trigger oocyte maturation ( 205 ). This second dose of kisspeptin-54
induced further LH secretion at 4hrs after the second injection, providing a
‘rescue’ response in those who had a lower LH rise following the first
kisspeptin-54 dose ( 205 ). This prolonged
LH-exposure improved the number of women achieving at least 60% oocyte yield
(71% vs 45%), implantation rates (37% vs 23%),
and live birth rates (39% vs 19%) compared to those receiving a
single dose ( 205 ). Importantly, this
prolonged LH exposure did not cause an increase in clinically significant OHSS
in these high-risk women ( 205 ). Besides
its shorter duration of action, kisspeptin also appears to have direct action on
ovarian kisspeptin receptors to suppress VEGF release which may contribute to
the reduction in the incidence of OHSS ( 204 ).
Live birth rate per embryo transfer following all kisspeptin doses
tested appears to be at least comparable to currently used triggers: 32%
(51/160) ( 200 ) and up to 45% (23/51)
( 204 ) in high responders with
contemporaneous live birth rate per transfer in women <35 years treated with
fresh embryo transfer being 32.8% ( 214 ).
Thus, a prospective comparison of the safety and efficacy of kisspeptin against
current agents is warranted.
Endometriosis and uterine fibroids are common disorders affecting women
of reproductive age and are leading causes of pelvic pain, abnormal uterine
bleeding, and subfertility ( 215 , 216 ). Early age of menarche and short
menstrual length are both associated with development of uterine fibroids and
endometriosis ( 215 , 216 ) consistent with prolonged endometrial and myometrial
exposure to estrogen being an important factor in the pathogenesis of these
disorders ( 215 , 216 ). Lowering E2 levels to between 110 to 184 pmol/L has
been recommended as being effective in reducing the symptoms of uterine fibroids
and endometriosis ( 217 , 218 ). GnRH modulators are able to suppress
estrogen levels by shutting down the HPG axis top-down and are currently
validated treatment for both conditions on this basis ( 219 , 220 ). However,
these agents typically induce lower E2 and require add back sex-steroid
replacement to avoid the associated adverse effects ( 221 , 222 ). NKB
receptor antagonists could potentially be dosed to reduce E2 levels into the
recommended therapeutic range sufficient to moderate endometriosis and uterine
fibroid development without the adverse effects of undetectable E2 levels.
Several NKB receptor antagonists have demonstrated the ability to reduce
LH secretion whilst preserving FSH secretion. The NK3R antagonist MLE4901 (also
known as AZD4901, formerly AZD2624) reduced basal LH secretion in healthy women
without affecting the LH pulse frequency during the early-mid follicular phase
and delayed the LH surge by 7 days, whilst FSH secretion was unaffected ( 223 ). MLE4901 has also been shown to
reduce E2 secretion, endometrial thickness and folliculogenesis during the
follicular phase ( 224 ). Another NK3R
antagonist, Fezolinetant (ESN364), also led to a dose-dependent reduction in
serum LH and delayed the LH surge in healthy women, with no significant effect
on FSH ( 225 ). Fezolinetant subsequently
caused a dose-dependent delay to the rise in serum E2 levels during the
follicular phase, but the serum E2 trough level remained above the 110 pmol/L, a
threshold considered significant for inducing menopause-like symptoms ( 225 ). The dual neurokinin 1, 3 receptor
antagonist Elinzanetant induced a trend towards a dose-dependent reduction in
serum LH when administered once daily to healthy women for 21 days with no
safety concerns or issues with tolerance ( 226 ). Elinzanetant also caused a dose-dependent reduction in serum
E2 and progesterone levels, with 120mg/day causing a median reduction in serum
E2 to 141 pmol/L, which is within the recommended range to effectively treat
uterine disorders ( 226 ). Furthermore,
the 120mg Elinzanetant dose increased the menstrual cycle length by a median of
7 days. This suggests that NKB antagonism may provide a novel therapeutic
approach, and further study is required to evaluate its use in uterine
disorders.
Reproductive
Skeletal homeostasis in mammals refers to the dynamic equilibrium
whereby bone formation and bone resorption are meticulously balanced to maintain
stable and optimal bone mass. This equilibrium is essential for promoting growth
and ensuring the skeleton’s resilience to mechanical stressors and thereby
preventing fractures. Skeletal homeostasis is achieved by the process of bone
remodeling which comprises two essential components; osteoclastic bone
resorption and osteoblastic bone formation.
Osteoclasts are specialized cells that differentiate from hematopoietic
stem cells under the control of receptor activator of nuclear factor kappa beta
ligand (RANKL) signaling and are responsible for resorbing old or damaged bone
tissue. Enzymatic activity during bone resorption releases fragments of type 1
collagen, including C-terminal telopeptide of type 1 collagen (CTX) and
N-terminal telopeptide of type 1 collagen (NTX), into the bloodstream, serving
as measurable biochemical markers of bone resorption. On the other hand,
osteoblasts differentiate from mesenchymal stem cells, and are the bone forming
cells involved in new bone matrix synthesis and mineralization to achieve bone
strengthening and facilitate microdamage repair. Osteoblasts release proteins
including osteocalcin and cleavage fragments from type 1 procollagen synthesis,
such as procollagen type 1 N-terminal propeptide (P1NP), which can be detected
in the circulation as biochemical markers of bone formation. Similarly, bone
specific iso-enzymes such as alkaline phosphatase (B-ALP) are released by
osteoblasts to aid bone mineralization and are also measured as markers of bone
formation. Once mineralization is complete, a proportion of mature osteoblasts
differentiate into osteocytes, which reside within the mineralized bone.
Osteocytes secrete important hormones and chemicals that regulate bone
remodeling, including fibroblast growth factor-23 (FGF23; phosphate regulating
hormone), RANKL and sclerostin (an antagonist of the osteoblast activator, Wnt).
Osteocytes may also act as sensory cells, translating mechanical cues into
signals that stimulate bone formation ( 404 ).
Bone remodeling is orchestrated by the coordinated action of hormones,
such as parathyroid hormone (PTH), vitamin D, growth hormone, insulin-like
growth factor-1, sex-steroids and adequate nutrients ( 405 ). Crucially, there exists a well-established
connection between the HPG axis and bone health. Bone expresses receptors for
the action of several reproductive hormones ( 405 ), with the predominant action from testosterone and estrogen
( 406 ). One of the main secondary
causes of skeletal disease such as osteoporosis are reproductive disorders
causing sex-steroid deficiency in women and men. Physiologically, androgens
influence bone health by directly binding to androgen receptors on bone or
indirectly through aromatization to estrogen ( 406 ). Estrogen suppresses osteoclast formation and resorption
activity, partly through antagonistic effects on the RANKL pathway ( 407 ). Furthermore, estrogen induces
secretion of semaphoring-3A from osteocytes, a protein that also reduces bone
resorption and increases bone formation ( 408 ) and exerts anti-apoptotic effects on osteoblasts ( 409 ). Therefore, in the absence of
adequate levels of sex-steroids, there is significant bone compromise. Indeed,
following menopause, a decline in circulating estrogen enhances bone resorption,
which is followed by a lesser increase in bone formation due to coupling,
resulting in a net loss of bone ( 410 )
such that during early menopause there is up to a 100% increase in bone turnover
( 411 ). The significance of estrogen
deficiency is also highlighted in eumenorrheic (eugonadal) women with anorexia
nervosa exhibiting higher BMD than amenorrheic (hypogonadal) women with lower
estrogen levels (T-score -1.2 in eumenorrheic vs -2.3 in
amenorrhoeic women) ( 412 ). Whilst
optimal sex-steroids are indispensable for bone health, disruptions to the
normal process of bone remodeling can occur even in the presence of normal
circulating sex-steroid levels. This is evidenced by peri-menopausal women
experiencing declines in BMD ( 413 ) and
women with prolactin-secreting adenomas exhibiting a higher prevalence of
fractures, despite a normal sex-steroid milieu ( 414 ). Additionally, women with anorexia nervosa suffer bone
consequences due to disturbances in leptin, IGF-1, and cortisol, even in the
absence of amenorrhea (and thereby intact sex-steroid levels) ( 415 ).
Emerging evidence suggests that kisspeptin is also a significant player
in bone homeostasis. Individuals with loss of function KISS1R
variants demonstrated delayed bone maturation in the absence of kisspeptin
signaling ( 6 ). This finding first marked
the potential involvement of kisspeptin in bone homeostasis ( 6 ). Similarly, CPP from
KISS1R gain of function variant was associated with
accelerated growth and skeletal maturation ( 23 ). Admittedly due to the observed significant alterations in sex
hormones associated with these conditions (hypogonadotropic hypogonadism or
precocious puberty), it is not possible to assert a direct relationship between
kisspeptin itself and the observed effects on bone; nonetheless these
observations contributed to the interest in the potential role of kisspeptin in
bone homeostasis.
The link between kisspeptin and bone homeostasis is increasingly
evident, following studies demonstrating significant
Kiss1/KISS1 and Kiss1r/KISS1R expression
on key cells involved in bone homeostasis, suggesting possible direct effects of
kisspeptin on bone.
KISS1R has been identified as one of the
hypoxia-inducible genes in the osteoclast microarray ( 416 ). In fact, in humans, KISS1R mRNA
is expressed throughout the process of osteoclastogenesis in
vitro , at multiple differentiation stages, ranging from the
CD14-monocyte stage to mature osteoclast stage ( 417 ).
The osteoanabolic effects of kisspeptin have been demonstrated
predominantly in in vitro studies in cultured cell lines or
osteoprogenitor cells. Using cDNA microarray technology,
KISS1 gene was first identified in osteosarcoma U-2
cell lines in 2003 ( 418 ). Further
expression studies in osteosarcoma cell lines, commonly used as osteoblastic
model, confirmed moderate KISS1 mRNA and protein expression
in U-2 cell lines, weak expression in Saos-2 cell lines, and absent
expression in MG-63 cell lines ( 419 ). KISS1 mRNA expression was most notable in
immortalized human fetal osteoblastic cells transformed by expression of
SV40 large T antigen (hFOB1.19) ( 419 ). Interestingly, weaker KISS1 expression was
associated with greater invasive capability in an osteosarcoma cell line
in vitro , whilst in osteosarcoma elevated KISS1
in vivo was associated with relapse or early metastasis ( 419 ). Low level heterogeneous
expression of KISS1 was also detected in primary
mesenchymal stem cells (MSC) and MSC-derived osteoprogenitor cells
(undifferentiated osteoblastic cells) from healthy donors ( 420 ). Furthermore,
Kiss1 and Kiss1r are expressed in
canine osteosarcoma cell lines (COS, POS) ( 421 ). Application of kisspeptin to these cell lines increases
COS proliferation and expression of bone remodeling factors, such as RANKL
and specific serotonin (5HT) receptor (HTR2a) ( 421 ).
Expanding upon these expression profiles, in vitro
data in rodents has recently confirmed kisspeptin’s involvement in
osteoblast differentiation. Kisspeptin-10 induced a dose-dependent
upregulation of early osteogenic factors mRNA and protein expression such as
distal-less homeobox 5 (Dlx5), runt-related transcription factor 2 (Runx2)
and ALP, known to be important in osteoblast differentiation in murine
fibroblastic mesenchymal stem cell–like osteoblast cell lines (C3H10T1/2)
( 422 ). As kisspeptin-10 only
exerts its effects in Kiss1r expressing cells, this
provided evidence that these effects occur via Kiss1r
expressed on C3H10T/2 cells ( 422 ).
In rodents, bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) that belong to the
transforming growth factor-β superfamily, appear to mediate the
osteoanabolic effects of kisspeptin-10 through the activation of
transcription factors including NFATc4 (in osteoblasts and the embryonic
kidney) ( 422 ) and Sp1 (in the
embryonic kidney) ( 423 ). The BMPs
implicated in this pathway to date are BMP-2 ( 422 – 424 ) and
BMP-7 ( 423 ). Therefore, kisspeptin,
at least in vitro , may act as an autocrine growth factor
with pro-proliferative effects on bone ( 421 ).
Further pivotal data on the direct effects of kisspeptin on human
bone metabolism have emerged more recently. Immortalized human mesenchymal
stem cells (hMSC-TERT4) were incubated with kisspeptin-54 for 7 days, to
evaluate the effects on osteoblastogenesis ( 417 ). This led to an increase in ALP activity, a surrogate for
osteoblast activity, by 41%, therefore suggesting enhancement of
osteoblastogenesis in this human cell line. Kisspeptin addition to mature
osteoblasts did not alter ALP activity, thereby suggesting selective effects
on osteoblast precursors ( 417 ).
During bone resorption assays, infusion of kisspeptin with
osteoclast monocultures revealed potent antiresorptive effects. Microscopic
evaluation of the percentage of eroded surface per bone surface demonstrated
a dose-dependent effect ranging from 29.6-48.1% reflective of inhibition of
osteoclast activity. Kisspeptin exhibited similar effects in
osteoblast/osteoclast co-cultures, which represents a more realistic
in vivo bone remodeling environment, with suppressive
effects ranging from 26.2% to 53.4% ( 417 ). To translate kisspeptin’s positive effects on bone
homeostasis observed in vitro , a tentative indirect
comparison with established osteoporosis treatments revealed that
kisspeptin’s osteoanabolic effects compare favorably with those of
teriparatide ( 425 ), and its
osteoclastic effects with zoledronic acid ( 426 ). To date, no studies have explored whether kisspeptin
signaling occurs in osteocytes.
The identification of kisspeptin and its receptor expression in
bone, coupled with compelling findings that identify kisspeptin’s role in
promoting osteoblastogenesis and inhibiting osteoclastic activity in
vitro , spurred additional research. Further exploration has
provided better insights into kisspeptin’s role in the bone in
vivo , suggesting promising applications for translational
research in addressing disorders of skeletal homeostasis, including
osteoporosis of various etiologies.
In both male and female (intact or gonadectomized) rodents, chronic
administration of 17β-estradiol has been shown to increase trabecular bone
mass through ERα. Intriguingly, the action via hypothalamic ERα seems to
have the opposite effect on bone ( 427 ). Ablation of ERα in the medial basal hypothalamus (MBH) in
Esr1Nkx2-1Cre models, results in a robust bone phenotype characterized by
increased BMD in trabecular and cortical bones. Stereotaxic-guided ablation
of ERα specifically in the arcuate nucleus (ERαKOARC), mirrored the
significant increases in BMD observed exhibiting an impressive up to 700%
increase in trabecular bone mass and an 80% increase in bone volume/total
volume (BV/TV) in female mice. Importantly, these effects manifest
independently of alterations in food intake and other circulating hormones
known to have osteoanabolic effects, such as leptin, thyroxine, LH, FSH,
testosterone and estrogen. Crucially, even after ovariectomy, female mice
subjected to ERαKOARC still demonstrate a 50% increase in BMD, suggesting
the presence of an intact brain-bone circuit irrespective of the sex-steroid
milieu ( 427 ). This finding holds
significance, suggesting a potential therapeutic avenue for addressing bone
mass loss in women due to menopause or other estrogen deficient states.
Similarly, striking increases in bone mass were observed in female mice when
ERα was stereotactically ablated in arcuate Kiss1-expressing cells
(Esr1Kiss1-Cre) using a Kiss1-Cre-GFP knock-in allele. These sexually
dimorphic effects appeared to be independent of high E2 levels. A BV/TV
increase of approximately 88% at the distal femur, along with similar
changes in the L5 vertebra and the cortical bone mass, were also observed.
Importantly, ERα ablation in POMC expressing neurons (Esr1POMC-Cre), which
share a common lineage with most Kiss1 neurons, did not
lead to skeletal improvements ( 427 ).
Collectively, these findings suggest that a female-specific brain-to-bone
pathway is mediated by a subset of Kiss1 neurons.
Furthermore, transcriptional profiling demonstrated that the observed
effects were mediated via BMP signaling and enhanced osteoblast
differentiation ( 427 ). This aligns
with previous in vitro findings on the mechanism of action
of kisspeptin in the bone.
A recent study utilized parabiosis and bone transplant methods to
reveal that a circulating factor, identified as Cellular Communication
Network Factor 3 (CCN3), accounts for the high bone mass observed
specifically in females, after the deletion of ERα from arcuate Kiss1
neurons in the Esr1NKx2-1 Cre model ( 428 ). CCN3’s osteoanabolic effects were demonstrated in
vitro in mouse and human skeletal stem cells (SSCs) when
administered at low concentrations, as well as in vivo in
gain-of-function and loss-of-function studies. Importantly, CCN3 is
co-expressed with kisspeptin in arcuate KNDy neurons, but its expression in
arcuate Kiss1 neurons was only significantly increased in both
estrogen-depleted lactating females and lactating dams. In lactating dams,
removal of pups (forced weaning) led to reduction in CCN3 expression, thus
suggesting that CCN3’s bone-promoting property lessens with cessation of
lactation ( 428 ). Further studies
that will help elucidate its interaction with kisspeptin, and how this might
be utilized in post-menopausal bone loss and osteoporosis, are warranted.
While the exact underlying mechanisms, beyond CCN3, that promote the high
mass bone phenotype in Esr1Nkx2-1Cre, Esr1Kiss1-Cre, and ERαKOARC female
mice remain undetermined, the findings of the aforementioned studies further
implicate the involvement of Kiss1-Kiss1r signaling in skeletal homeostasis,
here demonstrated in lactating mice ( 427 ). This complex neuro-skeletal circuit may have evolved as an
energy conserving mechanism during periods of negative energy balance to
regulate metabolic demands of the bone and to preserve reproductive
capacity. While these findings imply a potential link, they do not confirm a
direct bone effect attributed to peripheral kisspeptin signaling. In
addition to offering deeper insights into the physiology of skeletal
homeostasis and the pathophysiology of skeletal disorders, these findings
suggest the possibility of pharmacologically targeting kisspeptin pathways
in humans to improve bone health.
Moreover, a recent study in mice has shown results implicating
kisspeptin-10 signaling as a negative osteoclast modulator, thereby
conferring bone protective effects. The resorptive effects of osteoclasts
rely on the phosphorylation and activation of Src kinase. In
vitro kisspeptin-10 dose-dependently upregulated the expression
of a phosphatase (Dusp18), which phosphorylates and inactivates Src.
In vivo , both whole-body
( Kiss1 − / − ,
Gpr54 − / − ,
Dusp18 − / − ) and osteoclast
conditional knockout ( Kiss1 cKO, Gpr54
cKO) mice exhibited bone loss and osteoclast hyperactivation ( 429 ). These effects were paralleled by
increased osteoblast differentiation in the
Kiss1 − / − and
Gpr54 − / − models. The
observed phenomenon may be attributed to a mechanism known as 'bone
coupling', wherein the activation of osteoclasts is reliant on cytokines
derived from osteoblasts, such as M-CSF and RANKL. Moreover, in
ovariectomized mice, both intravenous injections of kisspeptin-10 and
bone-targeting kisspeptin-10 ((DSS)*6-Kp-10) administered twice weekly for
two months exhibited bone-protective effects ( 429 ). The bone-targeting (DSS)*6-Kp-10 was designed
using six repetitive sequences of the amino acids aspartate, serine, and
serine, ensuring an effective bone surface-targeting delivery system ( 430 ). Indeed, the bone-protective
effects of (DSS)*6-Kp-10 were far superior compared to those receiving
equivalent doses of kisspeptin-10, as determined by Von Kossa staining and
parameters of trabecular bone analysis. This difference was observed despite
similar gonadotropin levels. Treatment with a higher dose of bone-targeted
(DSS)*6-Kp-10 led to increased bone mass in both ovariectomized and
gonad-intact mice, as shown using micro-CT analysis, and TRAP staining
revealed suppressed osteoclast activation in both groups, supported by
measurements of osteoclast parameters. Collectively, these data suggest that
the kisspeptin-10/Gpr54 signaling axis plays a bone-protective role and
improves bone health both in vitro and in vivo by mechanisms which include
inhibiting osteoclastic bone resorption ( Figure 9 ). Kisspeptin-10 could, therefore, be utilized as a
potent therapeutic target for the treatment of osteoclast-associated bone
loss, such as age-related osteoporosis ( 429 ).
BALP, bone alkaline phosphatase; CTX, C-terminal telopeptide of
type I collagen; E2, estradiol; FSH, follicle stimulating hormone; INH,
inhibin; KO, knock-out; MSC, mesenchymal stem cells; NTX, N-terminal
telopeptide of type I collagen; OVX, ovariectomized; P1NP, procollagen type
1 N-terminal propeptide; P1CP; carboxy-terminal propeptide of type 1
procollagen; PRL, prolactin; RANK; receptor activator of nuclear factor
kappa-B; RANKL, receptor activator of nuclear factor kappa-B ligand; T,
testosterone; TRAP, tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase. Figure created with
BioRender.com .
The only study to demonstrate that kisspeptin’s in
vitro effects on bone metabolism could be translated into humans
was performed recently ( 417 ). When
intravenous kisspeptin-54 was administered to 26 healthy men over 90 minutes, it
elicited a 20.3% rise in total osteocalcin and a 24% rise in carboxylated
osteocalcin levels, compared to placebo. Carboxylated osteocalcin is the
predominant form of osteocalcin involved in bone remodeling. Therefore, this
acute rise following only 90 minutes of kisspeptin and in the absence of any
sex-hormone changes, suggests potent positive bone effects of kisspeptin
in vivo . In contrast to the in vitro
findings where kisspeptin incubation with mature osteoblasts did not increase
ALP, the observed osteocalcin rise suggests effects on more mature osteoblasts
in vivo ( 417 ). The
short infusion of kisspeptin-54 elicited no discernible impact on bone
resorption (CTX) potentially due to the short (90 minute) exposure to
kisspeptin. To potentially observe significant alterations in bone turnover
markers, it is plausible that sustained administration of kisspeptin-54 or its
receptor analogues, TAK448/MVT602, may translate the suppression of osteoclast
activity seen in vitro and in non-human in
vivo studies. Further investigations with extended exposure periods
and continuous administration may reveal the full spectrum of kisspeptin’s
impact on bone turnover. All in all, these findings indicate that acute
administration of kisspeptin may have direct beneficial effects on skeletal
homeostasis in humans (likely via KISS1R on mature osteoblasts), independent of
effects on downstream sex-steroids.
Kisspeptin emerges as a promising therapeutic option for preventing and
treating skeletal complications associated with conditions characterized by
sex-steroid deficiency, such as hypogonadotropic hypogonadism, POI, and
menopause. In women experiencing FHA, BMD is significantly reduced at various
skeletal sites, in both trabecular and cortical bone ( 415 ). This decline in BMD correlates with an increased
risk of stress fractures, extending beyond the effects of estrogen deficiency
( 415 ). Notably, reduced kisspeptin
signaling is a recognized factor in FHA as described previously. Kisspeptin’s
favorable safety profile, along with its potential to restore menstrual
cyclicity and potentially ovulation in women with FHA, positions it as a
competitive agent for both bone, menstrual health, and fertility in FHA. This
advantage is particularly noteworthy as it may aid bone health without the
associated side-effects and risks associated with HRT ( 415 ). Alternatives to HRT for bone health in these women
are limited. Leptin levels are reduced in FHA and although subcutaneous
metreleptin over two years was associated with 4-6% BMD gain in the lumbar spine
in exercising women, it was also associated with 3% weight loss which has
therefore dampened its viability for FHA treatment ( 431 ). By contrast, current evidence in humans does not
suggest an association between kisspeptin administration and weight loss.
Further studies investigating the impact of kisspeptin signaling on the bone in
cases of osteoporosis, particularly in women with FHA or menopause are eagerly
anticipated. Further exploration is warranted to assess its viability as a
prospective therapeutic target for clinical conditions related to bone
metabolism such as osteoporosis, where current treatments have
contraindications, frequently cause side-effects and are limited in
duration.
Text is read by the "Ask this paper" AI Q&A widget below.
Extraction quality varies by source — PMC NXML preserves structure
cleanly, OA-HTML may include some navigation residue, and OA-PDF can
have broken hyphenation. The publisher copy
(via DOI)
is the canonical version.