A Reevaluation of the Effect of Dietary Restriction on Different Recombinant Inbred (RI) Lines of Male and Female Mice

Dietary restriction (DR) was reported to either have no effect or reduced the lifespan of the majority of the 41-recombinant inbred (RI)-lines studied (Liao et al., 2010). In an appropriately power longevity study (n > 30 mice/group), we measured the lifespan of the four RI-lines (115-RI, 97-RI, 98-RI, and 107-RI) that were reported to have the greatest decrease in lifespan when fed 40% DR. DR increased the median lifespan of female and male 115-RI mice and female 97-RI and 107-RI mice. DR had little effect (less than 4%) on the median lifespan of female and male 98-RI mice and male 97-RI mice and reduced the lifespan of male 107-RI mice over 20%. While our study was unable to replicate the effect of DR on the lifespan of the RI-mice (except male 107-RI mice) reported by Liao et al. (2010), we found that the genotype of a mouse had a major impact on the effect of DR on lifespan, with the effect of DR ranging from a 50% increase to a 22% decrease. No correlation was observed between the changes in either body composition or glucose tolerance induced by DR and the changes observed in lifespan of the four RI-lines of male and female mice. These four RI-lines of mice give the research community a unique resource where investigators for the first time can study the anti-aging mechanism of DR by comparing mice in which DR increases lifespan to mice where DR has either no effect or reduces lifespan. Graphical Abstract Brief Abstract In this study we reevaluate the effect of the genotype and sex of the recombinant inbred strains of mice on their response to dietary restriction. Out of the eight lines studied, half of the groups showed an increase in lifespan when the diet was restricted by 40% and the other half either did not respond or showed a decrease in lifespan. The recombinant inbred lines used in this study are potentially important resource for aging research to identify pathways and understand the mechanism involved in the anti-aging action of DR.