Identification and Validation of a Previously Missed Mutational Signature in Colorectal Cancer

ABSTRACT Mutational signature analysis has greatly enhanced our understanding of the mutagenic processes found in cancer and normal tissues. As part of a recent study, we analyzed 802 treatment-naïve, microsatellite-stable colorectal cancers (CRC) and identified a de novo signature, SBS_D, which was conservatively decomposed into SBS18, a signature associated with reactive oxygen species. Here, we re-evaluate this decomposition and provide evidence that SBS_D represents a distinct mutational process from that of SBS18. Through an independent analysis of 2,616 whole-genome sequenced microsatellite-stable CRCs across three distinct cohorts, we demonstrate that SBS_D is consistently present at a similar prevalence, suggesting that this signature may have been previously overlooked. Using a naïve decomposition approach, we demonstrate that the pattern of SBS_D better aligns with signatures previously associated with deficiencies in DNA polymerase delta (POLD1) proofreading and mismatch repair. However, multiple lines of evidence, including the absence of pathogenic mutations in the exonuclease domain of POLD1 or in mismatch repair-associated genes, indicate that SBS_D is not driven by canonical defects in these DNA repair pathways. Overall, this study identifies a previously unrecognized mutational signature in microsatellite-stable CRC and proposes that its etiology may be linked to DNA repair infidelity emerging late in tumor development in samples without canonical defects in DNA repair pathways.