Spatial and temporal coordination of signaling pathways in tissue differentiation: developmental atlas of protein expression during zebra finch beak maturation

Background: Morphogenesis depends on spatial and temporal coordination of signaling pathways, yet the colocalization of proteins across pathways remains poorly understood. Here we examine cellular and histological localization of regulatory proteins forming core craniofacial developmental pathways during beak morphogenesis of the zebra finch ( Taeniopygia guttata ). Results: We present an atlas of spatiotemporal coexpression of β-catenin, Bmp4, CaM, Dkk3, Fgf8, Ihh, Tgfβ2, and Wnt4 across embryonic stages HH29-42 revealing both established and novel patterns of expression. Overall, in the earliest stages (HH29-32), most proteins show broad and overlapping expression across epithelial and mesenchymal tissues. By stage HH36, expression becomes increasingly compartmentalized, with pronounced differentiation among tissue types. Notably, at later stages, proteins showed tissue-specific distributions in boundary versus core regions of chondrogenic and osteogenic domains indicating coordinated cross-pathway patterning during cartilage and bone formation. Conclusions: Osteogenesis in the zebra finch beak is organized by coordinated signaling between boundary-associated cells and differentiating cores, with cross-pathway feedback establishing bone and cartilage differentiation while maintaining boundaries. Our results corroborated core elements of craniofacial signaling dynamics, while revealing unexpected subcellular localization for several proteins that showed regulatory complexity not captured by prior transcript-level maps. This atlas provides a protein-level baseline for comparative and mechanistic studies of beak morphogenesis.