Brain functional segregation, handedness and cognition in situs inversus totalis: a replication study

Situs inversus totalis (SIT) is a rare congenital anomaly in which the arrangement of the visceral organs is completely left-right mirrored. A previous study by our lab suggests that SIT (N = 15) pairs with more heterogeneous asymmetrical brain organization and increased left-handedness. In addition, visceral reversal paired with poorer cognitive performance, especially when hemisphere organization was atypical. The current study sought to replicate these findings in a larger sample. We scanned 23 volunteers with SIT as well as an equal number of controls with usual organ arrangement, and determined their hemisphere dominance for two left hemisphere functions (language and manual praxis) and two right hemisphere functions (spatial attention and face recognition). Effects of situs inversus etiology were explored by pooling data from the original cohort with the replication sample. Our results reveal the expected population dominance for each of the cognitive functions in SIT, albeit they were less pronounced – but not significantly so – compared to controls. Unusual patterns of hemispheric crowding and mirror-reversal of functional brain organization was observed more often in SIT (48%) than in the controls (30%), but this difference also did not reach statistical significance. However, left-handedness was found to be significantly more common in SIT (24%) than in the overall population (10.6%). Finally, cognitive ability was not associated with organ situs or hemisphere organization. Taken together, our data adds to the growing evidence that the determinants of visceral and neural asymmetries are largely independent from one another and that complete situs inversus does not co-occur with an obligatory transposition of the brain’s functional architecture. There nevertheless might be instances in which (genetic) factors simultaneously cause complete visceral reversal and atypical brain laterality, particularly in asyndromal cases of situs inversus.