Abstract
Tuberculosis is known to be one of the major disea ses, causing infertility in India.
The prevalence of tuberculosis causing infertility is different in different countries.
Established tubercle infection may cause irreversib le infertility, on many occasions as it may
affect all the reproductive organs. It also produce s lower pregnancy rate in Assisted
Reproductive Technology program as well. Tubercular bacillary infestation of the
endometrium that is mere presence of Mycobacterium Tuberculosis (MTB) bacilli on the
endometrial surface has been found to affect fertil ity as well. In this study, we have detected
Mycobacterium Tuberculosis (MTB) infestation of endometrium, causing implanta tion failure
or early embryonic rejection. In many cases of unex plained infertility, tubercular bacilli
infestation of endometrium, has come out to be the root cause of infertility. Association of
tubercular bacillary infestation and endometriosis is another cause of concern. Recurrent
abortions and ectopic pregnancy may be precipitated by the same genital pathology as well.
The presence of very small number of bacilli, which escapes detection by AFB smear, culture
or histology, may be detected by polymerase chain r eaction techniques. These bacillary
infections bring an inflammatory change in the endo metrium and produces harmful cytokines
which are responsible for implantation failure of micro abortion.
Keywords
MTB infestation, PCR study, unexplained infertilit y, recurrent pregnancy loss,
endometriosis
Introduction
Infertility is the commonest symptom associated wit h genital tuberculosis [1, 2] and
it seems to be an important under-diagnosed factor in infertility [3]. So for any
measure to cure infertility, tuberculosis must be e xcluded. The exact incidence of
female genital tuberculosis is not known partly bec ause more often the disease
remains silent and in addition, there are lack of r eliable confirmatory investigations.
The first reported case of gynaecological tuberculo sis was described by Morgagni in
1744. On making a post-mortem examination on a woma n aged 20 years, he found
the uterus and both tubes filled with caseous mater ial. Interest in the field of
gynaecological tuberculosis began to build up in th e early years of this century. The
most important early contributions were given by Be rkeley (1903), Daniel (1925),
Greenberg (1924), Jameson (1935), Murphy (1903, 190 4), Norris (1921) and
Williams (1894) [4]. Genital tuberculosis (TB) in f emales, is found in 0.75 to 1% of
gynaecological admissions in India with considerabl e variation from place to place.
The disease is responsible for 5% of all female pel vic infections and occurs in 10%
Al Ameen J Med. Sci, Volume 3, No.4, 2010 Gon Chowdhury R. et al
© 2010. Al Ameen Charitable Fund Trust, Bangalore 323
cases of pulmonary tuberculosis. Although most of t he affected belong to
reproductive age- group, the disease has been reported in post-menopausal females as
well. Lately, an increase in the trend of this dise ase has been reported, which may be
partly due to an overall rise in tuberculosis cases . The other contributory factors may
be HIV infection, as tuberculosis is the most commo n HIV-related opportunistic
infection in India [5]. However, the average world- wide incidence of female genital
tuberculosis in infertile population has been repor ted as 5-10% [6, 7], with the range
varying between <1% in USA and about 10% in India [ 8]. Incidence at our clinic is
9.6%. Incidence of infertility in genital tuberculo sis may vary between 40–75.6% [9,
10]. Infertility in genital tuberculosis may be due to various causes. The average
incidence of genital TB in infertility clinics worl dwide is 5-10%, and varies from
0.69% in Australia to 17.4% in India [11]. Tuberculosis may cause minimal damage
to the tube leading to ectopic pregnancy. Extensive damage may lead to complete
tubal occlusion [12]. Peri-tubal adhesions and tubo -ovarian mass have been found in
47.2% of cases [13]. Various grades of intrauterine adhesion (Asherman’s syndrome)
or non-receptive endometrium have been reported in association with genital
tuberculosis [14]. Although pulmonary TB (PTB) rema ins the commonest and the
most infectious type of TB, extra-pulmonary TB (EPTB) is becoming more prevalent
especially in young women throughout the world [15] . Female genital TB (FGTB),
being non-infectious, has been neglected by healthc are providers, but is an important
cause of both significant morbidity and short- and long-term sequelae for the affected
women [15, 16]. The incidence of active tuberculosi s in infected individuals is only
10% [17]. Depending on the virulence of organism an d immune response generated
by the host, the disease remains either active or b ecomes asymptomatic with latent
infection persisting for many years [18]. Latent in fected individuals contain dormant,
yet viable bacilli, which may re-activate when the host response becomes low, and as
a consequence, the disease may become active again. During the process of
reactivation, the bacilli induce immune modulation within the local tissues, which
mimics the process seen during infection. There is release of harmful cytokines like
IL2, TNF α and INF γ. The final effect will depend upon how strongly th e host tissue
(ovarian tissue and endometrium) can resist this tr auma [19]. If unable to resist,
immuno-modulatory impact will affect adversely, the endometrial receptivity. Once
the adverse impact has been established on the deli cate function of this reproductive
organ, the consequences may continue to persist; in fection subsequently remains
dormant or even cured. So for any measure to cure i nfertility, tuberculosis must be
excluded. Since physical symptoms are usually not p resent definitively, the disease
remains undiagnosed or specific investigations are not undertaken to rule out the
problem (Bateman et al, 1986) [20]. It is a pauci-b acillary form of disease of which
cultures and smears are often negative (Baum et al, 2001) [21]. The primary focus is
rarely found outside the genital tract (Sutherland 1985) [22]. Routine screening tests
for pulmonary tuberculosis like X-ray chest, tuberc ulin test and sputum examination
are usually negative (Schaetzing, 1986) [23]. With the above mentioned background
in mind this study was conducted employing a multip lex PCR, developed in our
laboratory to evaluate its effectivity in diagnosing genital tuberculosis among patients
attending infertility clinic and how far it can be implicated for infertility.
Al Ameen J Med. Sci, Volume 3, No.4, 2010 Gon Chowdhury R. et al
© 2010. Al Ameen Charitable Fund Trust, Bangalore 324
Materials and methods
517 cases having C/O unexplained infertility, Recur rent Spontaneous Abortions
(RSA) Ectopic Pregnancy and Mild Endometriosis were investigated by multiplex
PCR screening. Out of 517 cases, in 49 cases for th e detection of AFB smear by ZN
stain or culture of menstrual blood in LJ media, fo r the detection of tubercle bacilli
was performed, along with TB PCR study. In rest of the cases, only TB PCR study
was undertaken. Patients were advised to attend the clinic on d2 of period. Menstrual
flow was usually considerable on 2nd day of menstru al cycle and that confirms
proper menstrual flow. A sterile Cusco’s speculum w as introduced in the vagina
carefully, avoiding contamination/contact to skin. Menstrual blood was collected by
a 1cc/2cc sterile syringe and transferred to a ster ile vial containing normal saline.
Utmost care was taken to avoid contamination with s kin. On many occasions, the
skin may contain commensals mycobacteria.
Selection of Cases: Studies were undertaken in 517 cases. These cases w ere selected
from infertile patients in the following group:
Group A: 246 patients, who were apparently unexplained. The se cases were either
primarily normal, with tubal, ovulatory or seminal factor or after correction of the
above factors, they were sub-normal. The usual wai ting period for pregnancy to
occur often about one year, following they were declared normal.
Group B: 218 patients with GI to II endometriosis, without a ny anatomical distortion
of the pelvic organs, where good tubo-ovarian relat ion along with free Pouch of
Douglus (POD) was maintained. Here also, the waiting period for pregnancy to occur
was about one year, with or with out ovulation induction.
Group C: 46 patients with more than one spontaneous abortion (RSA)
Group D: 7 cases with previous Ectopic Pregnancy
Exclusion Criteria: Patients with previous history of anti-tubercular d rug (ATD)
intake were excluded from this study. For Group A, that is Unexplained Infertility, if
there was ovulatory factor, previous correction of the thyroid status and control of
prolactin level, followed by ovulation induction wi th oral agents like Clomifene or
Letrozole are included in the study. Any case which required ovulation induction
with Gonadotrophin, or cases where Clomifene or Let rozole failed in inducing
ovulation induction, were excluded. Cases with endo metriosis, having pelvic
adhesion, distorting tubo-ovarian relation, or abno rmal Pouch of Douglas, were
excluded from this study. For recurrent spontaneous abortions, where no
endocrinological, anatomical or immunological cause s were found, were included in
this study. Previous ectopic pregnancies, where def inite tubal defects were detected,
were excluded from the study.
Collection of Samples: After taking informed consent, the patients were ad vised to
attend the clinic on 2nd day of menstrual cycle. Me nstrual flow is usually
considerable on 2 nd day of menstrual cycle. In 49 of these cases, endom etrial biopsy
samples were collected by curetting the endometrial cavity by a small curette with or
without dilating the cervix under deep sedation or anaesthesia, in the pre-menstrual
phase of the same cycle. Menstrual fluid specimens were collected in three parts.
Al Ameen J Med. Sci, Volume 3, No.4, 2010 Gon Chowdhury R. et al
© 2010. Al Ameen Charitable Fund Trust, Bangalore 325
Endometrial specimens were aliqueted into three portions - one kept in normal saline
for microscopy and culture, one in formal saline fo r histopathology and one in lysis
buffer(50mmol/l KCl,10 mmol/lTrisHCl pH 8.3, 1.5 mm ol/l MgCl 2, 0.1% NonidetP-
40, 0.5%Tween-20) for extraction of DNA s for subse quent multiplex PCR study.
Similarly, three menstrual fluid specimens were tre ated like endometrial tissues. All
the clinical samples were screened with conventiona l microbiological tests such as
Ziehl–Neelsen acid fast staining for recording smea r-positivity, identification by
cultural isolation and biochemical tests. Lowenstei n–Jensen medium was used for
primary isolation. Tests to identify M. tuberculosis complex and NTM were: (i)
niacin test, (ii) catalase test, (iii) heat stable catalase test, (iv) pigment production
test, (v) Growth at 42–44 0C, (vi) aryl sulphatase test and (vii) state-of-the -art nucleic
acid amplification tools like a multiplex PCR techn ique. For culture, each specimen
was de-contaminated by N-acetyl-L-cysteine-sodium h ydroxide as per Kubica
(Kubica et al 1963) [24]. The processed sediment was cultured for more than six
weeks on two Lowenstein-Jensen medium slants at 37 0C. These culture slants were
inspected for growth every week. Positive cultures were further examined to confirm
the presence of M. tuberculosis.
Processing of Positive Mycobacterial culture for ex traction of Genomic DNA: One
loop of cultured Mycobacterium ,grown on Lowenstein-Jensen slants from menstrual
fluid and endometrial specimens was suspended in 50 0 µl of 1X TE buffer (10 mM
Tris-HCl, 1 mM EDTA, pH 7.5). The suspension was ly sed with 0.5% SDS and
proteins were digested with 0.5 mg of Proteinase-K/ ml for 15 minutes at 37° C
(Syun-Ichi et al. 1993) [25].
Processing of endometrial specimen for extraction o f genomic DNA: A portion of
endometrial specimen was collected in lysis buffer as described above. Sodium
dodecyl sulfate (SDS) and Proteinase-K were added t o final concentration of 1% and
0.1 mg/ ml respectively and incubated at 37° C for one hour. Subsequently, 5 mol/ L
NaCl and 10% Cetyl trimethyl ammonium bromide (CTAB ) and 0.7 mol/ L NaCl
were added and kept at 65° C for 10 minutes (Herrer a et al 1996)[26]. Mycobacterial
genomic DNAs from all the mycobacterial strains gro wn on culture and processed
endometrial tissues were extracted by addition of e qual volume of phenol-
chloroform-isoamyl alcohol (25:24:1, V/V/V) solutio ns. The aqueous phase was
transferred to another tube; DNAs were finally prec ipitated with 0.6 vol of isopropyl
alcohol and DNA pellets were collected by centrifug ation. The pellet was washed
with 70% ethanol, which was then dried and dissolve d in 30 µl TE buffer (pH 7.8)
and stored at -20° C for future use. The DNA concen tration was measured from OD
at 260 nm and run in 0.8% agarose gel with λHind III DNA molecular marker.
Multiplex PCR: Samples as described were screened by multiplex PCR system
developed in our laboratory (Bhattacharya et al 2003) [27] by modifying three
individual PCR (Pao et al 1990; Syun-Ichi et al. 1993; Kox et al 1994) [25, 28, 29]
to one reaction condition. The primer pairs are sel ected by following manner (i) Two
oligonucleotide primers derived from the sequence o f gene that codes for the 65 kDa
antigen of M. tuberculosis ; a pair of 24 base synthetic oligonucleotide (prim ers)
bracketing a 165-bp region of a gene codes for a 65 kDa antigen (Shinnick 1987).
Al Ameen J Med. Sci, Volume 3, No.4, 2010 Gon Chowdhury R. et al
© 2010. Al Ameen Charitable Fund Trust, Bangalore 326
Briefly, according to Pao et al 1990), from 5´ to 3´ ends CTA GGT CGG GAC GGT
GAG GCC AGG and CAT TGC GAA GTG ATT CCT CCG GAT. (i i) In this
reaction two genus-specific oligonucleotide primers (forward, 5´-AAG AGG AAG
GAG AGA GGG G-3´ and reverse, 5´-GTC GTT GAG GTT GA A CTC-3´) were
used based on nucleotide sequence of DNA gene of M.tuberculosis (Syun-Ichi et al.
1993) [25]. The amplification of the 365-bp (region between sequence position
1377–1741 of M. tuberculosis ) band has been observed in M..tuberculosis and M..
avium , but not in other species of mycobacteria.(iii)Two oligonucleotide primers
within IS 6110 insertion element, designated primer s Pt-8 (5´-GTG CGG AT GTC
GCA GAG AT-3´) and Pt-9 (5´-CTC GAT GCC CTC ACG GTT CA-3´), were used
for PCR, resulting in amplification of a 541-bp DNA fragment (Kox et al . 1994)
[29]. This IS 6110 insertion element is almost specific for M. tuberc ulosis complex .
These newly developed multiplex PCR using primers amplifying as described by
Pao et al 1990, Syun-Ichi et al 1993 and Kox et al 1994 [25, 28, 29], with the
following proposed composition of mixture and condi tion. The multiplex PCR was
carried out in a thermal cycler (GeneAmp 2400, Perk in-Elmer Cetus, USA) by
incubating 2-5 µl of chromosomal dna (approximately 0.2 – 0.4 ng wi th the
following components (50 µl total vol): 10 mM Tris-HCl ( pH 8.3), 50 mM KCl,
0.01% gelatin (w/v), 1.5 mM MgCl
2, 0.2 mM of each of the four deoxynucleoside
triphosphates (dATP, dCTP, dGTP, dTTP), 0.2 µM, 0.1 µM and 0.2 µM of primers
respectively used in the PCR 1, 2 and 3 and 1 unit of Taq polymerase (Perkin-Elmer
Cetus, USA). A positive amplified and negative con trol DNA s were run in each
experiment. The reaction mixture was first pre-incubated at 85° C for 5 minutes. The
amplification was performed for 40 cycles of 94° C for 1 minute, 55° C for 1 minute
and 72° C for 2 minutes. After the last cycle the s amples were incubated for 10
minutes at 72° C (final extension).
Analysis of PCR Products: Ten to fifteen µl of each PCR product was subjected to
electrophoresis with 2% and 2.5% agarose gel respec tively and the products were
visualized with Ethidium bromide. The length of th e PCR product was estimated by
pGEM or φX174/ Hae markers (Promega Corporation, Madison, Wisconsin, USA).
Results
It has been observed that among
517 cases, positive PCR was
found in 230 cases (%). After
treatment with anti-tubercular
drugs, 86 cases conceived. The
previous history and clinical
situations enhancing infertility
according to age distribution of patients undergoin g PCR studies are mentioned
(below) in Table 1.
Table 1
Age 40 Total
Cases 221 280 16 517
Unexplained infertility 101 143 2 246
Mild Endometriosis 96 112 10 218
Recurrent Abortion 22 24 0 46
Ectopic Pregnancy 2 1 4 7
Al Ameen J Med. Sci, Volume 3, No.4, 2010 Gon Chowdhury R. et al
© 2010. Al Ameen Charitable Fund Trust, Bangalore 327
The duration of infertility is also of
note, which is mentioned in Table 2:
Positive cases were subjected to
treatment by 3 drugs (Rifampicin, Ethambutal & Ison iazid) for 3 months, followed
by 2 drugs like Ethambutal & Isoniazid for 3 months . No subsequent PCR study was
performed as it is well known that, even dead bacte ria can give +ve TB PCR. The
study was also not done in patient history of previ ous ATD intake. The AFB smear
was positive in two cases. Bactec culture was posit ive in 15 cases but negative in 34
patients with PCR positive for tuberculosis.
Pregnancy Outcome: Pregnancy outcome is mentioned in following Table 3. Out of
230 PCR positive cases, 86 patients
conceived after treatment with ATD. The
completion of treatment to conception
interval was 3 to 12 months. Few patients
conceived during treatment. Result: 33
pregnancies were found in patients with
PCR negative study.
The pregnancy rate in post-treatment of +ve TB PCR cases were similar in
unexplained infertilities and mild endometriosis, and best in case of RSA.
Abortion rate was higher
in women conceived
during or immediately
after treatment with ATD.
Take-home-baby rate was
much high in women
conceived between six
months to one year, after completion of the treatme nt. These are mentioned in Table
4:
Discussion
The source of bacteria is mostly the environment. C olonization of MTB may be by
sexual or asexual mode. Asexual mode may be by haem atogenous spread to
endometrium, which ultimately remained dormant for long time, and most of bacteria
were shed out from others system. The bacteria after colonizing in endometrium may
proliferate or may remain dormant. They may be eliminated as well. Until and unless
the bacteria enter the internal body surface, it ca nnot be called infection. Mere
presence of bacteria on external body surface like skin, gut or endometrium, which is
connected easily to the external environment, shoul d be called infestation. The
question then arises, whether infestation is pathol ogical. The majority of the invaded
bacilli are arrested by the natural defense of the human body. Bacilli reaching the
endometrium are arrested by the macrophages. Severa l factors like the number and
virulence of the infecting bacilli, host factors, i ncluding genetic susceptibility, age,
immuno-competence, stress, nutrition and co-existing illness influence the outcome
Table 2
Duration 10 years
No. of cases 207 281 29
Table 3
PCR +ve Pregnancy
Total 230 86 (37.3%)
Unexplained Infertility 114 44 (38.5%)
Mild Endometriosis 96 33 (34.4%)
RSA 18 8 (44.4%)
Ectopic Pregnancy 2 1
Table 4
Cases Abortion Term
Pregnancy
Conception by 9 months of
initiation of the treatment
10 8 2
Conception after 9 months
of initiation of the treatment
76 1 75
Al Ameen J Med. Sci, Volume 3, No.4, 2010 Gon Chowdhury R. et al
© 2010. Al Ameen Charitable Fund Trust, Bangalore 328
of the infection. Tubercle bacilli do not contain o r secrete toxin. The exact basis of
their virulence is not understood, but seems to be related to their ability to survive
and multiply in macrophages. Various components of the bacillus have been shown
to possess different biological activities, which m ay influence the pathogenesis,
allergy and immunity in the infection. Humans are e vidently able to mount an
effective defense against the invaded bacteria, as only about a tenth of the infected
develop active tuberculosis. The only specific immu ne mechanism effective is the
cell mediated type. Humoral immunity appears to be irrelevant. The key cell is the
activated CD4+ helper T cell, which can develop along with two different paths – the
Th1 or Th2 cells, releasing cytokines such as interferon γ (gamma) interleukins 1 and
2, tumor necrosis factor α (TNF α) and others, exerting different biological effects .
Th1 dependent cytokines activate macrophages, resulting in protective immunity and
containment of the infection. Th2 cytokines induce delayed type hyper-sensitivity
(DTH), tissue destruction and progressive disease. The essential pathology in
tuberculosis is the production in infected tissues of a characteristic lesion, the
tubercle. This is an avascular granuloma, composed of a central zone containing
giant cells, with or without caseation, and a perip heral zone of lymphocytes and
fibroblasts. Tubercular lesions are primarily of two types – exudative and productive.
The exudative type is an acute inflammatory reactio n with accumulation of edema
fluid, polymorphonuclear leucocytes, and later of l ymphocytes and mononuclear
cells. This is typically seen when the bacilli are many and virulent and the host
response is more, in the nature of DTH than of prot ective immunity. The productive
type of lesion is predominantly cellular, associate d more with protective immunity
than DTH. Endometrium is the normal site where embr yo implants, to give rise to a
healthy intrauterine pregnancy. Endometrial part of implantation involves secretion
of several molecules or markers generated by hormon al, biochemical, genetic and
immunomodulatory changes within the endometrium its elf. Immuno-modulatory
changes are brought about by cytokines and growth f actors. They have a wide range
of family members. Cytokines consist of different m embers of interlukin family,
while the growth factors consist of VEGF (Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor),
TNF (Tumor Necrosis Factor), LIF (Leukemia Inhibiti ng Factor) etc. Some of these
cytokines and growth factors help in implantation, while others antagonize the
procedure. If immuno-modulatory response is favorab le, helpful cytokines and
growth factors will appear, and successful implanta tion will take place.
Immunologically, this is known as T helper 2 (Th2) response. On the other hand, if
harmful immuno-modulators develop, the response is said to be T helper 1 (Th1)
response, resulting in failure of implantation and pregnancy will not occur. In
successful implantation, the Th1 sub-set of cytokines, namely TNF α, IL2 of the CD4
cell line are down-regulated, where as the cytokine s of the Th2 sub-set are up-
regulated. Apart from T (Thymus) lymphocyte mediate d helpful or harmful
cytokines and growth factors, similar type of harmf ul or helpful antibodies may also
develop through immuno-modulation of B (Bone Marrow) lymphocytes. Helpful and
harmful antibodies are known as asymmetric and symm etric antibodies respectively.
Presence of MTB in the endometrium though paucibaci llary, which is otherwise
called MTB infestation, probably excites an inflamm atory process, may be mild,
Al Ameen J Med. Sci, Volume 3, No.4, 2010 Gon Chowdhury R. et al
© 2010. Al Ameen Charitable Fund Trust, Bangalore 329
which induces the production of adverse cytokines a nd antibodies, resulting in Th1
response. It is well known that for successful impl antation, Th2 bias is specifically
needed. Inflammatory environment in the endometrium may inhibit down-regulation
of Th1 bias, so also up-regulation of Th2 bias. Thi s leads to pre-ponderence of
harmful cytokines and antibodies of Th1 series in t he endometrium, making it non-
receptive to embryo, intending implantation. These cause, either so, are called
unexplained infertility, recurrent implantation fai lure or recurrent abortion.
Moreover, simple effort of Th1 response to mount up to Th2 bias may activate the
dormant bacilli, which activates inflammatory proce ss, further leading to more Th1
response, and thereby negative impact on implantati on. The improvement of
endometrial environment after treatment with ATD is evident by pregnancy rate in
positive TB PCR cases (86 out of 230 cases - 37.4%) . The period taken into account
for pregnancy to occur in these cases was one and a half year, from the completion of
the treatment, which is otherwise two years, from the initiation of the ATD treatment.
It has been observed, that the patients who conceiv ed during or immediately after
medical treatment by anti-tubercular drugs mostly a bort. Take-home-baby rate was
higher in patients who conceived later. This indica tes that, probably it takes longer
for the inflammatory process to subside, even after the bacilli are eliminated. In
many cases, probably some form of serious damage ma y happen, resulting in
permanent non-receptive endometrium. Sub-endothelia l blood flow may also be
affected by the presence of MTB in endometrium, as it may down-regulate VEGF
concentration. This may be other cause of implantat ion failure. Mild endometriosis
most often is not considered to be the cause of inf ertility. These patients are grouped
under unexplained infertility. In this study, mild to moderate endometriosis with
good tubo-ovarian relations suffering from infertil ity showed substantial TB PCR
positive cases. This raises a suspicion, whether en dometriosis and tubercular
bacillary invasion, either in the form of infestati on or infection are different spectra
of the same disorder of immuno-competence. Samples from endometrial aspirates,
endometrial biopsies and the fluid from the Pouch o f Douglas, from 25 women with
infertility, suspected to be suffering from genital TB on laparoscopic findings were
studied for the presence of the mpt64 gene of M. tu berculosis by Bhanu et al. [30].
Presence of M. tuberculosis DNA was detected in 56% of cases by PCR as compared
to 1.6% smear-positive and 3.2% culture-positive ca ses. PCR was positive in all
women with laparoscopic findings suggestive of TB, in 60% of those with probable
diagnosis, in 33% of those with incidental findings and even in one case with normal
laparoscopic findings [30]. Other authors have also observed PCR to be more
sensitive than histopathology and culture [31, 32]. Rozati et al. [33] observed PCR to
be positive in 43.1% of suspected cases of female g enital tuberculosis, in contrast to
5.2%, 7.8% and 11.5% detection rates with AFB stain ing, culture and
histopathology, respectively. Presence of at least 10,000 organisms/ ml in the sample
is required for microscopic detection of AFB. Cultu re is more sensitive, requiring as
little as 100 organisms/ ml, while PCR may be positive with only 1-10 organisms/ ml
[30]. However, PCR has its own disadvantages. It can give false-negative results, due
to contamination with heparin or to a high salt con centration of the specimen, which
may interfere with PCR results. As it cannot distin guish between live and dead
Al Ameen J Med. Sci, Volume 3, No.4, 2010 Gon Chowdhury R. et al
© 2010. Al Ameen Charitable Fund Trust, Bangalore 330
bacilli, there is a small risk of false-positive re sult [30]. In our series, we get a
positive PCR of 44.5% in this study, and contrast t o 30.06% in culture and 4.8% in
AFB smear, though the number of culture and smear p erformed were small. This
indicates that the detection of the presence of MTB bacilli is much more with PCR
study, with standard technique.
Conclusion
The influence of tubercle bacteria in fertility is well known, because tuberculosis of
the genital organs has long been accepted as an imp ortant cause of sterility in this
country. With increasing health consciousness, impr oved immunization status and
easy access to diagnose and treatment of tuberculos is have diminished the incidence
of frank tuberculosis. Tubercular bacterial invasio n to the uterus, in the form of
infestation, not infection, has been strongly recog nized in the present study. It has
also been found that mere presence of bacilli in th e endometrial layer affects fertility
status of women, as infertility or recurrent reprod uctive failure. Proper treatment
reverses the situation to great extent. The immunol ogical changes happening during
bacterial invasion may be associated with other imm uno-compromised disorders like
endometriosis. This requires a further structured s tudy, to come to a definite
Conclusion
about the disease.
References
1. Punnonen R., Kiilholma P., Meurman L. Female genita l tuberculosis and consequent
Infertility. Int J fertile 1983; 28:235-238
2. Nogales-Ortiz F.,Ildefonso T.,Nogales FF: The patho logy of genital tuberculosis. Obstet
Gynecol 1979; 53: 422-428
3. Oosthuizen AP., Wessels PH., Hefer JN: Tuberculosis of the female genital tract in
patients attending an infertility clinic . S Afr Med J 1990 ; 77(11):562-564
4. Sutherland Arthur M. Gynecological Tuberculosis, Pa st, Present and Future. Arch
Gyna¨k 1975; 218: 261-268
5. Steinbrook Robert. Tuberculosis and HIV in India. New Eng J Med 2007; 356(12): 1198-
1199
6. Deshmukh KK, Lopez JA, Naidu TAK, Gaurkhede MD. MV Place of laparoscopy in
pelvic tuberculosis in infertile women; Arch Gynecol 1985; 237:197-200
7. Chhabra S. Genital tuberculosis – a baffling diseas e; J Obstetr Gynecol India 1990;
40:569-73
8. Jindal UN. Genital tuberculosis: an important cause of Asherman’s syndrome in India;
International journal of tuberculosis and lung disease; 2006
9. Tripathi SM. Infertility and pregnancy outcome in f emale genital tuberculosis; Int J
Gynecol. Obstet. 2002; 76(2):159-63
10. Jahroni N, Parsanezhad ME, et. al. Female genital t uberculosis and infertility; Int. J.
Gynecol. Obstet 2001; 75(3):269-72
11. Schaefer G. Female genital tuberculosis. Clin Obstet Gynecol 1976; 19:223-239
12. Malik S; Genital tuberculosis and implantation in a ssisted reproduction; Reviews in
Gynecological Practice 2003;3: 160-164
13. de Vynck WE, Kruger TF, et. al; Genital tub. Associ ated with Female Infertility in West
Cape. S Afr Med J 1990; 77(12): 630-1
14. Sharma JB, Roy KK, Kumar S, Malhotra N, Chawla P. P rogress in Obstetrics &
Gynecology; edited by John S, Scang LT, Frank AC; 2 008
Al Ameen J Med. Sci, Volume 3, No.4, 2010 Gon Chowdhury R. et al
© 2010. Al Ameen Charitable Fund Trust, Bangalore 331
15. Kumar S. Female genital tuberculosis. In: Sharma SK , Mohan A. (eds) Tuberculosis, 1st
edn. Delhi: Jaypee; 2001; 311:324
16. Sharma JB. Female genital tuberculosis revisited. Obstet Gynecol Today 2007;XII:61-63
17. Stead WW. Pathogenesis of a first episode of chroni c pulmonary tuberculosis in man:
recrudescence of residuals of the primary infection or exogenous reinfection; Am Rev
Resp Dis 1967; 95:729-74
18. Stead WW, Kerby GR, et. al. The clinical spectrum o f primary tuberculosis in adults:
confusion with reinfection in the pathogenesis of c hronic tuberculosis. Ann Intern Med
1968; 68:731-45
19. Raghupathy R, Makhseed M, Azizieh F; Th1 and Th2 cy tokine profiles in successful
pregnancy and unexplained recurrent abortions; In: Gupta SK, editor. Reprod Immunol
1994; 14:149-57
20. Bateman BG, Nunley WC, Kitchen RE. Genital tubercul osis in reproductive-age women.
J Reprod Med 1986; 31: 287-290
21. Baum SE., Dooley DP., Wright J., Kost ER., Storey D F: Diagnosis of culture-negative
female genital tract tuberculosis with peritoneal i nvolvement by polymerase chain
reaction. J Reprod Med; 2001; 46 (10): 929-32
22. Sutherland AM. Tuberculosis of the female genital tract. Tubercle 1985; 66:79-83
23. Schaetzing A. Infeksies van die genitaletraktus. In :OdendaalHJ, ed.Ginekologie.
Kaapstad:Juta,1986:230-232
24. Kubica GP, Dye WE, Cohn.ML et al. Sputum digestion and decontamination with N-
acetyl-L-cysteine-sodium hydroxide for culture of m ycobacteria; Am Rev Respir Dis
1964; 89: 284-286
25. Syun-Ichi T, Okuzumi K, Ishiko H, Ken-ichi N, Ohkub o A, Nagai R. Genus specific
polymerase chain reaction for the Mycobacterial dna j gene and species-specific
oligonucleotideprobes . J Clin Microbiol 1993; 31: 446–450
26. Herrera EA, Perez O, Segovia M. Differentiation bet ween Mycobacterium tuberculosis
and Mycobacterium bovis by a multiplex polymerase r eaction; J Appl Bacteriol 1996;
80: 596–604
27. Bhattacharya B., Karak K, Ghosal AG, Roy A, Das S, Dandapat P, Khetawat D, Mondal
DM, Bhattacharya S, Chakrabarti S. Development of a new sensitive and efficient
multiplex polymerase chain reaction (PCR) for ident ification and differentiation of
different mycobacterial species; Tropical Medicine and International Health 2003; 8 (2):
150-157
28. Pao CC, Yen TS, Jinn-Bang Y et al. Detection and id entification of Mycobacterium
tuberculosis by DNA amplification; J Clin Microbiol 1988; 28: 1877–1880
29. Kox LLF, Rhienthong D, Medo Miranda N et al. A more reliable PCR for detection of
Mycobacterium tuberculosis in clinical samples; J Clin Microbiol 1994; 32: 672–678
30. Bhanu NV, Singh UB, Chakraborty M et al. Improved d iagnostic value of PCR in
diagnosis of female genital tuberculosis leading to infertility. J Med Microbiol ; 2005;
54:927-931
31. Jindal UN. An algorithmic approach to female genita l tuberculosis causing infertility; Int
J Tuberc Lung Dis 2006; 10: 1045-1050
32. Abebe M, Lakew M, Kidane D, Lakew Z, Kiros K, Harbo e M. Female genital
tuberculosis in Ethiopia. Int J Gynecol Obstet 2004; 84: 241-246
33. Rozati R, Sreenivasagari R, Rajeshwari CN. Evaluati on of women with infertility and
genital tuberculosis; J Obstet Gynecol India; 2006, 56: 423-426
*All correspondences to: Dr. Siddhartha Chatterjee, Calcutta Fertility Mission, Pushpanjali Apartment,
102C Ballygunge Place, Kolkata-700019 Phone No: 913 3 2281 2813; e-mail:
[email protected] ,
[email protected]
Text is read by the "Ask this paper" AI Q&A widget below.
Extraction quality varies by source — PMC NXML preserves structure
cleanly, OA-HTML may include some navigation residue, and OA-PDF can
have broken hyphenation. The publisher copy
is the canonical version.