Abstract
Background: Continuous advancements in interventional and diagnostic radiological techniques are
mandatory to meet the increasing demands of patients and health care professionals. This thesis aims to
contribute to the development of more effective interventional and diagnostic radiological methods for pelvic
diseases. Ultimately, these advancements can lead to improved patient outcomes, optimised treatment
strategies, and enhanced precision in diagnosing and managing conditions affecting the uterus and prostate.
Aim: The overarching aim of this thesis is to investigate both interventional and diagnostic radiological
Methods
for pelvic diseases, and specifically for the uterus and the prostate. Specifically, we aim to address the
feasibility, usability and effectiveness of a new degradable starch microsphere (DSM) intended for use in
transarterial embolisation of the uterus and prostate (papers I and II), and prostate MRI features with
applications on estimations of tumour aggressiveness and prostate volume (papers III and IV).
Methods
The experimental trial of papers I and II was performed on sheep that underwent transarterial uterine
artery embolisation with either a DSM or a permanent commercially available permanent sphere, trisacryl gelatine
microspheres (TGMS) in a blinded randomised controlled trial. Two weeks after embolisation, a follow-up
angiogram was performed to assess recanalisation, and thereafter the animals were euthanised, and organs
were collected for histopathology. The primary outcome measures were the occurrence of recanalisation of the
embolised arteries and the presence of ischaemic changes in the embolised organs. Papers III and IV were
retrospective cohort studies of men diagnosed with prostate cancer who had an MRI prior to prostatectomy. In
paper III, we evaluated the correlation of absolute tumour apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC) and ADC ratios
with pathology-based tumour aggressiveness in terms of ISUP grade group according to the International Society
of Urological Pathology five-grade scale. Two experienced radiologists, independently from each other, measured
the ADC values of 98 men that met the inclusion criteria. In paper IV, 124 men from the same main cohort as in
paper III were included. Different MRI-based and ultrasound-based methods, including one machine learning
MRI-based method for prostate volume, were compared to two different gold standards: weight volume from
pathology and volume from manual planimetry, by an experienced radiologist on MRI.
Results
The ischaemic effect according to histopathology of the DSM in papers I and II was comparable
with the commercially available market-leading equivalent. A significantly higher number of recanalised vessels
were found in the DSM group as well as less vasculitis of the embolised arteries and a similar ischaemic effect
of the embolised organs. In paper III, no correlation was seen between ADC and ISUP grade and no benefit of
using ADC ratio over absolute ADC was found. The interrater reliability was substantial to almost perfect for all
variables analysed. In paper IV we found that the machine learning software was more stringent than manual
Methods
in calculating prostate volume, and no systematic error was found.
Conclusion
Our study showcases the efficacy of embolisation using the new DSM, offering potential for
recanalisation and blood flow restoration. Moreover, embolisation with DSM demonstrates comparable tissue
effects to TGMS with less vascular inflammation and enhanced recanalisation. Our findings also challenge
previous assumptions by revealing no correlation between ADC metrics and ISUP grade, while affirming the
reliability of deep learning algorithms for prostate volume assessment. These insights underscore the evolving
landscape of interventional procedures and imaging techniques that will shape future clinical practices.
Key words: Embolization, uterine fibroid, benign prostate hyperplaisa, magnetic resonance imaging, prostate
neoplasms, deep learning, diffusion weighted imaging
Supplementary bibliographical information
Language English Number of pages: 105
ISSN and key title: 1652-8220 Lund University, Faculty of Medicine Doctoral Dissertation Series 2024:82
ISBN: 978-91-8021-577-0
Recipient’s notes Price Security classification
I, the undersigned, being the copyright owner of the abstract of the above-mentioned dissertation, hereby
grant to all reference sources permission to publish and disseminate the abstract of the above-mentioned
dissertation.
Signature Date 2024-04-22
Novel radiological approaches for
diagnosis and treatment of diseases
in the pelvic region
Applications in the uterus and the prostate
Johan Bengtsson, M.D.
Coverphoto by Gustav Sundström/Midjourney.com
Copyright pp 1-105 Johan Bengtsson, MD
Paper 1 © Acta Radiologica, SAGE Publications Inc
Paper 2 © Acta Radiologica, SAGE Publications Inc
Paper 3 © by the authours (Open access at Frontiers in Oncology)
Paper 4 © by the authours (Open access at Springer Nature)
Faculty of Medicine Department
Department of Clinical Sciences Lund
Department of Diagnostic Radiology
Lund University, Sweden
ISBN 978-91-8021-577-0
ISSN 1652-8220
Lund University, Faculty of Medicine Doctoral Dissertation Series 2024:82
Printed in Sweden by Media-Tryck, Lund University
Lund 2024
Kommer ti
d, kommer råd!
Table of Contents
Abstract
................................................................................................................... 8
Populärvetenskaplig sammanfattning ................................................................ 10
List of papers ................................................................................................ 12
Papers not included in the thesis .................................................................. 13
Thesis at a glance .................................................................................................. 14
Abbreviations ............................................................................................... 15
Introduction
and aims .......................................................................................... 16
The specific aims of the studies presented in the papers ............................. 17
Transarterial embolisation .................................................................................. 18
History .......................................................................................................... 18
Embolisation materials ................................................................................. 20
Histological and immunological effects ....................................................... 23
Uterine fibroma and treatment ..................................................................... 26
Benign prostate hyperplasia ......................................................................... 33
Prostate cancer ...................................................................................................... 39
The prostate .................................................................................................. 39
Epidemiology and risk factors ...................................................................... 40
Diagnostics of prostate cancer ...................................................................... 43
Magnetic resonance imaging ............................................................................... 47
Background
and routine use of MRI ............................................................ 47
Sequences ..................................................................................................... 48
The role of MRI in the diagnosis of prostate cancer .................................... 53
Artificial intelligence and prostate MRI ............................................................. 57
Machine learning .......................................................................................... 58
Neural network ............................................................................................. 58
AI in radiology ............................................................................................. 59
Material and methods
.......................................................................................... 64
Statistical methods used in the papers. ......................................................... 64
Cohorts and study design ............................................................................. 67
Ethics ............................................................................................................ 71
Results
.................................................................................................................... 74
Paper I .......................................................................................................... 74
Paper II ......................................................................................................... 76
Paper III ........................................................................................................ 79
Paper IV ....................................................................................................... 81
Discussion
.............................................................................................................. 82
Papers I and II .............................................................................................. 82
Paper III ........................................................................................................ 84
Paper IV ....................................................................................................... 85
Conclusions
........................................................................................................... 87
Future perspectives .............................................................................................. 88
Acknowledgements
............................................................................................... 90
References
............................................................................................................. 94
8
Abstract
Background
Continuous advancements in interventional and diagnostic radiological techniques
are mandatory to meet the increasing demands of patients and health care
professionals. This thesis aims to contribut e to the development of more effective
interventional and diagnostic radiological methods for pelvic diseases. Ultimately,
these advancements can lead to improved patient outcomes, optimised treatment
strategies, and enhanced precision in diagnosing and managing conditions affecting
the uterus and prostate.
Aim
The overarching aim of this thesis is to investigate both interventional and
diagnostic radiological methods for pelvic diseases, and specifically for the uterus
and the prostate. Specifically, we aim to address the feasibility, usability, and
effectiveness of a new degradable st arch microsphere intended for use in
transarterial embolisation of the uterus a nd prostate (papers I and II), and prostate
MRI features with applications on estim ations of tumour aggressiveness and
prostate volume (papers III and IV).
Methods
The experimental trial of papers I a nd II was performed on sheep that underwent
transarterial uterine artery embolisation with either a degradable starch microsphere
(DSM) or a permanent commercially available permanent sphere, trisacryl gelatine
microspheres (TGMS) in a blinded randomi sed controlled trial. Two weeks after
embolisation, a follow-up angiogram w as performed to assess recanalisation, and
thereafter the animals were euthani sed, and organs were collected for
histopathology. The primary outcome measures were the occurrence of
recanalisation of the embolised arteries and the presence of ischaemic changes in
the embolised organs. Papers III and IV were retrospective cohort studies of men
diagnosed with prostate cancer who had an MRI prior to prostatectomy. In paper
III, we evaluated the correlation of absolu te tumour apparent diffusion coefficient
(ADC) and ADC ratios with pathology-b ased tumour aggressiveness in terms of
9
ISUP grade group according to the International Society of Urological Pathology
five-grade scale. Two experienced radi ologists, independen tly from each other,
measured the ADC values of 98 men that met the inclusion criteria.
In paper IV, 124 men from the same main cohort as in paper III were included.
Different MRI-based and ultrasound-b ased methods, including one machine
learning MRI-based method for prostate volume, were compared to two different
gold standards: weight volume from pathology and volume from manual
planimetry, by an experienced radiologist on MRI.
Results
The ischaemic effect according to histopathology of the DSM in papers I and II was
comparable with the commercially av ailable market-leading equivalent. A
significantly higher number of recanalised vessels were found in the DSM group as
well as less vasculitis of the embolised arteries and a similar ischaemic effect of the
embolised organs.
In paper III, no correlation was seen between ADC and ISUP grade and no benefit
of using ADC ratio over absolute ADC was found. The interrater reliability was
substantial to almost perfect for all variables analysed.
In paper IV we found that the machine l earning software was more stringent than
manual methods in calculating prostate volume, and no systematic error was found.
Conclusions
In conclusion, our study showcases the e fficacy of embolisation using the new
DSM, offering potential for recanalisati on and blood flow restoration. Moreover,
embolisation with DSM demonstrates comparable tissue effects to TGMS with less
vascular inflammation and enhanced recana lisation. Our findings also challenge
previous assumptions by revealing no co rrelation between ADC metrics and ISUP
grade, while affirming the reliability of deep learning algorithms for prostate
volume assessment. These insights under score the evolving landscape of
interventional procedures and imaging tec hniques that will shape future clinical
practices.
10
Populärvetenskaplig sammanfattning
Med radiologi, dvs olika bilddiagnos tiska metoder som vanlig röntgen,
datortomografi, magnetkameraundersökni ng (MR) och ultraljud kan vi
diagnosticera en mängd olika tillstånd. Alla metoder har sina fördelar och nackdelar
och vi inom radiologin strävar hela tiden att förbättra metoderna och hur vi tolkar
bilderna. Vårt mål är att hitta sjukdomar tidigt och sätta rätt diagnos för att kunna
erbjuda tidig behandling som kan innebära bot eller lindring. Däremot vill vi inte
hitta onödiga fynd i bilderna som kan orsaka onödiga och felaktiga behandlingar.
Fynd och misstolkning av harmlösa tillstå nd leder ofta till oro för patienterna och
eventuellt onödiga ytterligare undersökninga r och provtagningar och i värsta fall
behandlingar som i sig är förenade med risker.
Vi kan även använda röntgenteknik till a tt guida behandling av olika tillstånd, så
kallad interventionell radiologi. Med hjälp av katetrar, som vi för in i blodkärl kan
vi med ledning av röntgen leta oss fram till olika organ i kroppen, till exempel
hjärna, hjärta, lungor, lever, njurar, liv moder och prostata. Här kan vi göra olika
behandlingar som annars skulle innebära att man behövde operera. Dessa ingrepp
kan ersätta många större ope rationer och ofta kan patie nten gå hem redan samma
dag med endast ett plåster på huden där vi förde in katetern. Dessa behandlingar
kallar vi för minimalinvasiva.
I arbete I och II undersökte vi en ny typ av sfär, dvs en sorts kula, mindre än 1
millimeter stor som kan sprutas in i kr oppen via kateter för att behandla olika
tillstånd i kroppen. Ett exempel kan vara muskelknutor i livmodern, så kallade
myom. Dessa är mycket vanliga och kan ibland orsaka problem, speciellt om de blir
stora eller väldigt många. Dessa kan opereras men kan även behandlas med
interventionell radiologi då de små sfärerna vi sprutar in täpper till blodkärlen till
muskelknutorna som blir utan blod och syre och därmed dör och krymper ihop.
Vanligtvis använder man sig av sfärer av plast som stannar kvar i kroppen resten av
livet. Vi tror att sfärer som bryts ner efter några dagar är väl så bra för ändamålet.
Vem vill ha kvar sfärerna när de väl har fullgjort sitt syfte? Vi har därför testat att
jämföra sfärerna på får (tackor) som vi behandlat med antingen de nedbrytbara
sfärerna eller plastsfärer. Vi kunde konsta tera att båda sfärerna åstadkom ungefär
samma effekt men att de nedbrytbara sfärerna till största delen hade försvunnit efter
två veckor. Alla undersökningar gjorde vi på tackorna medan de var sövda och de
fick gott om smärtlindrande mediciner. De hade tillsyn av djurvårdare och veterinär.
11
Vi tror att dessa sfärer kan användas även för behandling i människor, vilket kan
visas i framtida forskning.
Arbetena III och IV handlar om diagnostik med MR för prostatacancer. Det finns
olika sätt att ta reda på om en patient har prostatacancer. Ett av dessa innebär att
man tar ett vävnadsprov då man sticker i prostatan via ändtarmen. Detta kan ge svar
på frågan om cancer finns, men cancern kan också missas och förbli oupptäckt. För
att lyckas bättre tar man många vävnadspr over. Detta kan i vissa fall ge oönskade
sidoeffekter som blödningar eller blodförgiftning. På senare år görs i stället MR-
undersökning och om man hittar en misstänkt cancer gör man vävnadsprov, annars
låter man bli. På så vis behöver färre män genomgå vävnadsprov och således
undvika riskerna med provtagningen. Dessu tom vet man var i prostata man skall
sticka.
Detta ställer dock höga krav på MR-und ersökningen och vår tolkning av bilderna.
Vi vill ju inte hitta förnedringar i prosta ta som kanske inte är cancer och som man
sticker i onödan, å andra sidan vill vi inte misstolka något för en snäll förändring
som i själva verket är cancer. I arbete III och IV jämför vi olika MR-bilder på män
som genomgått MR av prostata och sedan opererat bort prostatan på grund av
cancer. Vi gör olika mätningar på MR-bilderna och jämför med vad patologen hittat
vid mikroskopisk undersökning av den utopererade prostatan. Vi har även undersökt
om artificiell intelligens (AI) kan hjälpa till i bedömningen av bi lderna genom att
räkna ut hur stor volym prostatan har ge nom analys av MR-bilderna. Det har vi
sedan jämfört med resultaten som röntge nläkaren kommit fram till och hur stor
prostatan i själva verket var när den opererats ut. Det visar sig att AI var minst lika
bra som vi röntgenläkare på detta. Och betydligt snabbare.
Förhoppningsvis kan resultaten i avhandlingen hjälpa till att föra forskningen framåt
både inom interventionell och diagnostisk radiologi.
Johan Bengtsson
Dalby 2024-04-22
12
List of papers
Paper I
Bengtsson J, Cwikiel W, Sundgren PC, Karlstam E, Gavier-Widen D, Keussen I.
The effects of uterine artery embolization with a new degradable microsphere in an
experimental study. Acta Radiologica. 2017;58(11):1334-41.
Paper II
Keussen I, Bengtsson J, Gavier-Widen D, Karlstam E. Uterine artery embolization
in a sheep model: biodegradable versus non-degradable microspheres. Acta
Radiologica. 2018;59(10):1210-7.
Paper III
Bengtsson J, Thimansson E, Baubeta E, Zackrisson S, Sundgren PC, Bjartell A,
Flondell-Site D. Correlation between ADC, ADC ratio, and Gleason Grade group
in prostate cancer patients undergoing radical prostatectomy: Retrospective
multicenter study with different MRI scanners. Front Oncol. 2023; 13:1079040.
Paper IV
Thimansson E , Bengtsson J , Baubeta E, Engman J, Flondell-Site D, Bjartell A,
Zackrisson S. Publisher Correction: Deep learning algorithm performs similarly to
radiologists in the assessment of prostate volume on MRI. Eur Radiol.
2023;33(4):3004.
13
Papers not included in the thesis
Alterbeck M, Thimansson E, Bengtsson J, Baubeta E, Zackrisson S, Bolejko A, et
al. A pilot study of an organised population-based testing programme for prostate
cancer. BJU Int. 2024;133(1):87-95.
Eriksson S, Bengtsson J, Torén W, Lätt J, Andersson R, Sturesson C. Changes in
apparent diffusion coefficient and pat hological response in colorectal liver
metastases after preoperative chemotherapy. Acta Radiologica. 2023;64(1):51-7.
Alterbeck M, Jarbur E, Thimansson E, Wallstrom J, Bengtsson J, Bjork-Eriksson
T, et al. Designing and Implementing a Population-based Organised Prostate Cancer
Testing Programme. Eur Urol Focus. 2022;8(6):1568-74.
Asp M, Malander S, Bengtsson J , Sartor H, Kannisto P. Prognostic value of
peritoneal cancer index after complete Cytoreductive surgery in advanced ovarian
cancer. Anticancer research. 2022;42(5):2541-51.
Asp M, Malander S, Wallengren N-O, Pudaric S, Bengtsson J, Sartor H, Kannisto
P. The role of computed tomography in the assessment of tumour extent and the risk
of residual disease after upfront surgery in advanced ovarian cancer (AOC).
Archives of Gynecology and Obstetrics. 2022;306(4):1235-43.
Grigoriadis A, Imeen Ringe K, Bengtsson J, Baubeta E, Forsman C, Korsavidou-
Hult N, et al. Development of a prognostic MRCP-score (DiStrict) for individuals
with large-duct primary sclerosing cholangitis. JHEP Rep. 2022;4(12):100595.
14
Thesis at a glance
Study Question Method Results and Conclusions
I Can a new degradable
starch microsphere (DSM)
be used for transarterial
embolisation? Will it be
degraded in vivo, and will
it cause intended
ischaemia?
Uterine artery embolisation
with DSM was performed
on 6 ewes. Follow-up
angiography and
histopathological
evaluation were
performed.
Five successful
embolisations were
performed. Ischaemic
changes of the embolised
organs were observed,
histologically and
macroscopically. DSM was
partly degraded.
II How does the DSM
perform compared to the
market-leading permanent
sphere (TGMS) in terms of
manageability, local tissue
effect, side effects and
recanalisation of the
embolised vessels.
Blinded study. 22 ewes
were embolised with DSM
or TGMS. 2 week-follow-
up with angiography,
blood samples, clinical
data, degree of
recanalisation,
macroscopical and
histological evaluation.
Successful procedures in
all animals. Significantly
more recanalisation in the
DSM group. Similar effect
on tissue. Fewer vascular
changes in the DSM group.
III Is there a correlation
between apparent
diffusion coefficient (ADC),
ADC ratio,
and Gleason Grade group
in prostate cancer patients
undergoing radical
prostatectomy?
Retrospective cohort study
evaluating the correlation
between ADC metrics and
histopathological results
on patients operated with
prostatectomy for prostate
cancer.
In contrast to previously
published single-centre
studies, no correlation
between ADC, ADC ratio
and tumour aggressiveness
was found in this
multicentre study.
IV Can a commercially
available AI model assess
the prostate volume from
MRI on
a par with today´s gold
standard radiologist
dependent method using a
clinical dataset?
Retrospective agreement
study comparing
radiologist ellipsoid
formula with AI model.
Expert manual radiologist
planimetry and specimen
weight volume as
Reference
standards.
The AI model demonstrates
comparable performance to
radiologists in evaluating
prostate volume on MR
imaging. This has the
potential to free up
radiologists for more
intricate tasks.
15
Abbreviations
ADC Apparent Diffusion Coefficient
BPH Benign Prostate Hyperplasia
CT Computerized Tomography
CZ Central Zone
DRE Digital Rectal Examination
DHT Dihydrotestosterone
DSM Degradable Starch Microsphere
DWI Diffusion Weighted Imaging
HCC Hepatocellular Carcinoma
ISUP International Society of Urological Pathology
LUTS Lower Urinary Tract Symptoms
MRI Magnetic Resonance Imaging
PCa/csPCa Prostate Cancer/clinically significant PCa
PES Post Embolization Syndrome
PI-RADS Prostate Imaging Reporting & Data System
PSA Prostate Specific Antigen
PSAD Prostate Specific Antigen Density
PVA Polyvinyl Alcohol
PZ Peripheral Zone
RALP Robot Assisted Laparoscopic Prostatectomy
TACE Transarterial Chemoembolization
TARE Transarterial Radiotherapy
TGMS Trisacryl Gelatine Microspheres
TRUS Transrectal Ultrasound
TURP Transurethral resection of the prostate
TZ Transitional Zone
UFE/UAE Uterine Fibroid Embolization/Uterine Artery Embolization
16
Introduction
and aims
The relationship between interventional ra diology and diagnostic radiology has
been a cornerstone in the evolution of modern medical imaging and interventions.
The two disciplines have developed hand in hand, each driving the advancements
of the other. Both the diagnostic and interventional branches offer minimally
invasive procedures to achieve their resp ective goals. Before the discovery of X-
rays, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), and ultrasound, all diagnostics were
associated with more invasive and l ess accurate methods. The same goes for
interventional procedures, where the a lternative would be open surgery. The
advancement of both disciplines continues, and new landmarks can be achieved,
further facilitated by machine learning. In the future, radiology might be able to
offer precise non-invasive histology and treatments for more complex conditions
with the use of catheters.
This relationship is reflected in this thesis, which consists of two parts. Papers I and
II deal with interventional radiology and the development of a new biocompatible
degradable microsphere for interventional procedures. The intention was to use the
product for embolisation of benign and mali gnant tumours in the liver, uterus, and
prostate.
The second part of the thesis deals with MRI diagnostics of prostate cancer. The
modern approach in a prostate cancer wor kup, MRI first, means that the result of
the MRI determines whether to perform biopsies or not. Prostate cancer can be
indolent and harmless, and detection of these tumours yields anxiety, high costs for
the health system, and unnecessary biopsies with potential life-threatening side
effects. On the other hand, tumours can be aggressive and early metastasising. Early
detection is crucial to be able to treat the tumour in time and to offer a possible cure.
Hence, we must balance overdiagnosis with underdiagnosis. More powerful MRI
sequences are being developed to increase specificity. Machine learning and
radiomics have further improved diagnosti cs. Papers III and IV in this thesis
investigate different diagnostic aspects of prostate MRI.
The overarching aim of this thesis is to investigate both interventional and
diagnostic radiological approaches for pe lvic diseases, and specifically for the
uterus and the prostate.
17
The specific aims of the studies presented in the papers
were:
I. To evaluate in vivo degradation, local tissue effects, and possible
recanalisation following intra-arterial deposition of a new, degradable
starch microsphere (DSM), in a short-term experimental pilot study.
II. To compare the local tissue effects, po ssible side effects, and extent of
recanalisation following uterine ar tery embolisation, using either
degradable or non-degradable microspheres in a sheep model.
III. To investigate the correlation between ADC and ADC ratio compared to
tumour aggressiveness determined by a histopathological examination after
radical prostatectomy.
IV. To assess whether a deep learning algorithm can replace manual methods
for calculating prostate volume.
18
Transarterial embolisation
History
One of the most important landmarks in the history of interventional radiology was
the introduction of the Seldinger technique by the Swedish radiologist, Dr. Sven-
Ingvar Seldinger. Dr Seldinger was born in Mora, Dalecaria, Sweden 1921. In 1950,
he was working as a substitute physician in the radiology department of the new
Karolinska Hospital in Soln a, Sweden. He was assisting Dr. Åke Lindbom with
angiographic procedures for his thesis 1. He realised that there was a need for an
improved method for percutaneous access. Dr. Seldinger´s family had run a
mechanical workshop for generations and were considered technical geniuses. With
his interest in fine mechanics, he made several attempts to find a more precise and
less harmful procedure for vascular access. Af ter several failures, he had a Eureka
moment when he found himself sitting, di sappointed with a needle, a wire, and a
catheter. He suddenly realised how to use these objects!
Needle in – wire in – needle off – catheter on wire – catheter in – catheter advance
– wire off (Fig. 1).
This moment was later described by Dr. Seldinger as “a severe attack of common
sense”. It was presented at the Congress of the Northern Association of Medical
Radiology in Helsinki in 1952 and published in Acta Radiologica in 19532.
19
Figure 1
Dr Seldinger´s drawing explaining stepwise the Seldinger Technique. From the original publication
19532. With permission from Sage.
A decade later, the man known as the father of interventional radiology, Dr. Charles
Dotter, took the use of catheters beyond diagnostics when he started using the
catheters for treatments. He described a pr ocedure for treating patients with lower
extremity claudication. Under fluoroscopi c control, a 0.1-inch tapered Teflon
dilatation catheter was slipped over a guidewire and advanced to enlarge the lumen
of a stenosis in the femoral or popliteal artery. Eleven patients were treated with the
procedure, later called the percutaneous transluminal angioplasty technique (PTA)
or the Dotter technique. Half of the patients improved markedly, and four
amputations were avoided3.
Dr. Andreas Gruentzig in Zürich invented the first PTA balloon catheter, a rigid,
sausage-shaped device which he and his wife Michaela manufactured on their
kitchen table. The first patient was treated with the device in 1974 for intermittent
claudication caused by superficial femoral ar tery stenosis. Eventually, a modified
PTA catheter was used for the coronary arteries in 1975
4, 5.
The first endovascular treatment for haemorrhage was performed by Dr. Josef Rösch
and Dr. Charles Dotter on a 43-year-old woman with diabetes, chronic alcoholism,
and liver failure. She presented with a bl eeding peptic ulcer which was confirmed
with angiography. Selective epinephrine injection through the diagnostic catheter
gained only temporary haemostasis. Howe ver, with a 2-cc autologous blood clot
injected through the catheter, a permanent 4 cm thrombus was formed and hence,
complete haemostasis was achieved 6. This procedure, called Transarterial
20
Embolisation (TAE), has since undergone re finement in terms of techniques and
Materials
and is now used to treat a wi de range of conditions such as bleeding,
varices, and benign or malignant tumours.
Interventional radiology is a branch speciality of medical radiology. The European
Society of Cardiovascular Radiology and Interventional Radiology (ESCVIR) and
the European College of Angiography (ECA) were both founded in 1976. In 1985,
these two societies were merged, and the Cardiovascular and Interventional
Radiological Society of Europe (CIRSE) was formed 7. It now has 4200 members
organised in 24 national societies. CIRCE is the largest of the subspeciality
radiological societies in Europe. The Swedish Society for Interventional Radiology
is called the Seldinger Society of Va scular and Interventional Radiology
(Seldingersällskapet) to honour Dr. Sven-Ingvar Seldinger.
Embolisation materials
Various embolisation materials are curren tly available, all used for a common
purpose: the obstruction of blood flow. These materials are categorised based on
their specific properties, intended applica tions, and mechanisms of action, falling
into classifications as medical devices, medicinal products, or combination
products. The European Medicines Agency (EMA), a decentralised agency within
the European Union, assumes respons ibility for the scientific evaluation,
supervision, and safety monitoring of bot h medicines and medical devices. In the
United States, the equivalent regulatory authority is the Food and Drug
Administration (FDA).
The categorisation of a product hinges on its mode of action. If the product primarily
exerts its effect through physical means, such as the blockage of an artery, it is likely
to be classified as a medical device. Conversely, if the action involves a
pharmacological effect, it falls into the category of medicinal products. Within
Europe, medical devices are stratified into four main classes (Classes I, IIa, IIb, III)
based on risk level, ranging from low to high. The majority of embolisation
Materials
align with Classes IIa to III. The delineation of these classifications is
outlined in the European Union’s Medical Devices Regulation (MDR).
Types of embolisation materials
Particles
A broad spectrum of embolisation particl es is commercially available, each
designed for specific therapeutic applicati ons. The particles can be natural, i.e.
gelatine particles, or synthetic. They can have irregular shapes with a wide size
range or can be precisely calibrated in both shape and size8. The smaller the particle,
21
the more peripheral occlusion and more pronounced ischaemia will be achieved.
Most particles are used for embolisation only, while others can be loaded with
cytotoxic drugs which will be eluted from the particles at the target. The beads can
also be loaded with radioactivity for similar targeted tumour delivery9. While most
particles must be mixed with contrast media to be visible on fluoroscopy, some
particles are inherently radiopaque. Tem porary particles can be used when re-
intervention in the same vessel is anticipated or when only a short period of
ischaemia is needed
10-12.
PVA (polyvinyl alcohol) particles were firs t used in household sponges, and the
Material
is biocompatible. It has been u sed for embolisation of gastrointestinal
bleeding, and embolisation of uterine fibr oids and of arteriovenous malformations
These particles are available in sizes ranging from 100 µm to 1100 µm. Upon
injection, these particles aggregate and adhere to the intima of the vessel wall,
leading to the formation of a thrombus. This process induces inflammation and
necrosis of the vessel wall. Despite th e permanent nature of the material,
recanalisation can occur either thro ugh angiogenesis within the thrombus
13 or
through transarterial exclusion of the material from the vessel lumen 14. PVA tends
to aggregate in the delivery catheters, which may occlude. The unpredictable size
of the aggregates may cause an unpredictable level of embolisation in terms of the
size of the occluded vessel. The use of PVA is therefore associated with a relatively
high rate of complication and failure15-17.
Gelatine sponge (Gelfoam, Pfizer) particles are extracted from porcine skin.
Gelfoam is also available as sheets which can be cut into smaller pieces and mixed
with contrast and saline to form an in jectable slurry solution. Gelatine sponge
induces a clotting reaction, and a thrombus is formed. It is considered a temporary
material; however, it causes a very strong inflammatory reaction and a subsequent
proliferation of the intimal tissue w ith narrowing and eventually permanent
occlusion. Gelfoam is used for gast rointestinal haemorrhage control and
preoperative embolisation. It used to be the most used material for uterine fibroid
embolisation (UFE).
Calibrated microspheres have been developed to achieve a more controlled level
of occlusion. The spheres are available in different sizes, ranging from 50 µm to
1300 µm (figure 2). They have uniform physical properties such as size, buoyancy
and rigidity and elastic recovery
11. Tris-acryl gelatine microspheres (TGMS) and
Polyzene-F coated hydrogel particles are commonly used permanent spheres often
used for embolisation of benign prostate hyperplasia (BPH) and UFE. Degradable
calibrated spheres are also available. 50 µm starch microspheres degrade within an
hour and are used for embolisation of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC).
Hydrophobic poly(lactic-co-glycolic acid) ( PLGA) spheres, coated with collagen,
have a degradation time extending over several months
18, 19.
22
Figure 2
Degradable Starch Microspheres (DSM) 500-700 µm, 19 hours after uterine artery embolisation. No
macroscopic evidence of degradation. The uterine artery is cut open (white arrows). Source: Author.
Coils
In contrast to embolisation agents wh ich allow peripheral embolisation, like
particles or liquids, coils are mainly u sed in medium- to large-sized arteries.
Constructed from diverse metal alloys, coils can be either bare or coated with
various materials, such as wool strand s or hydrogel, aiming to enhance packing
density and improve occlusion effectiveness. The primary utility of coils lies in the
treatment of aneurysms and haemorrhage injuries20.
Liquids
Other embolisation materials depend on the patient’s own coagulation system, while
liquid materials are inherently occlusive. Some of these materials can also reach
very peripheral areas, beyond the reach of catheters 20, 21 . When the material is
injected, it undergoes various reactions, such as polymerisation 22, to solidify. The
most common agent is ethanol, which quickly denatures proteins, destroys the
endothelium, and leads to permanent vessel occlusion. Ethanol can be used for the
treatment of kidney cancer and arteriovenous malformations
23, 24. Embolisation with
acrylic glue has many applications, but it polymerises quickly and may therefore be
difficult to control, carrying a risk of a ttachment to the catheter. Several modern
adhesive-like materials are more easily manageable.
23
Other devices
Balloons can be used for temporary occlus ion of larger vessels. Plugs of various
kinds are used for the occlusion of larger vessels and can have a diameter of up to a
few centimetres.
The optimal embolisation device
Since the first embolisation with autologous blood in the early 1970s, there has been
an accelerating development of various em bolisation materials. In 2007, Laurant
delineated characteristics an ideal embolisation sphere should possess 12. A parallel
depiction of the optimal embolisation material was presented by Dr. Wang et al. in
202020. The product should be made of bioe ngineered material and be non-toxic,
capable of being injected through any catheter without preparation. After achieving
its embolisation effect, the material s hould degrade to avoid undesired chronic
inflammation and allow repeated interven tion in the same vessel. The material
should be visible under fluoroscopy as well as on computed tomography (CT) and
MRI. Additionally, the material should be ab le to be loaded with various drugs for
local effect
19. These features inspired the writing of the first two papers in the thesis.
Histological and immunological effects
The desired outcome of most interventions involving embolisation is to achieve a
temporary or permanent cessation of blood flow in the target organ or tissue,
subsequently, resulting in ischaemia. This will inevitably initiate tissue reactions.
The body responds to the event by attempting to restore blood flow and heal the
incurred damage. In addition to the effects on the embolised target organ, the vessel
containing the embolisation material is also affected
10, 14 . Acute and chronic
reactions arise here as well, with the purpose of restoring conditions to normal14.
Vascular changes
Certain embolisation materials induce more vascular tissue reactions than others.
Among these are alcohol, where the damage that arises is the desired reaction
leading to vessel occlusion. Gelatine sponge also produces a significant local
vascular reaction. However, the local vascular reaction is considerably milder when
using calibrated microspheres, such as TGMS, for embolisation.
The acute reaction that occurs involv es inflammation with infiltration of
neutrophilic granulocytes and macrophages in and around the vascular wall. Both
the induced inflammation and the response to the embolisation material itself cause
damage to the endothelium, with subse quent degeneration or necrosis of the
vascular wall. Depending on whether the embolisation material is degradable or not,
24
subacute to chronic changes occur. Subacute changes manifest with the initiation of
subintimal deposition of loose connective tissue, resulting in narrowing of the
vascular lumen (figure 3A). Non-degradable/long-lasting material also initiates a
foreign body reaction in the vessel wall (figure 3B) 10. The inflammatory response
plays a central role in the subsequent remodelling of the vessels, mediated by
metalloproteinases (MMPs) and cytokines (TNF-alpha, IL-2, and IL-6)25.
Figure 3
(A). Histological photograph of the uterus of a sheep embolised with degradable starch microsphere.
The artery in the endometrium shows subintimal deposition of loose connective tissues (arrows), with
mild to moderate narrowing of the arterial lumen. Haematoxylin and eosin staining. Bar 100 µm. (B)
Histological photograph of the uterus of a sheep embolised with TGMS. Spherules in the lumen of
arteries of the myometrium, associated vascular lesions characterised by infiltration of macrophages
and multinucleated giant cells of foreign body type (arrows), ingrowth of fibroblasts/fibrosis around
intra-arterial spherules. Spherules and the surrounding inflammatory reaction completely obstruct the
arterial lumina. Haematoxylin and eosin staining. Bar 120 µm. Inset: higher magnification of vascular
lesions. Source: Author.
In cases where permanent or more long-las ting embolisation materials have been
used, such as PVA particles, new, thin, and tortuous vessels can form to partially
restore blood flow13. This process, known as angiogenesis or neovascularisation, is
stimulated by various angiogenic cytokin es, such as Vascular Endothelial Growth
Factor (VEGF), which can be expressed by endothelial cells, smooth muscle cells
in the vessels, and macrophages26.
In a long-term animal study, sheep underwent uterine artery embolisation with
TGMS or PVA. Approximately two years af ter the embolisation, a majority of the
embolisation material had exited the vascular lumen and migrated entirely or
partially (transvascularly) through the v ascular wall. The larger aggregates of the
embolisation material were predominantly located in the intima and media, while
the smaller ones were also found outside the vessel. Persistent damage to the internal
and external elastic lamina of the vessel wall was evident. The embolisation material
remained relatively intact but some times had become calcified. A chronic
inflammatory reaction, with fibrosis and infiltration of multinucleated foreign body
25
cells, was present in close association with the aggregated embolisation material.
The vessels were partially re-canalised but clearly exhibited luminal narrowing14.
Tissue effects
Different tissues and organs respond differe ntly to ischaemia. Tissues also have
varying abilities to tolerate ischaemia and restore blood flow, thereby preserving
function. This variability is influenced, for example, by the tissue’s dependence on
oxygen or how rapidly collateral blood flow can be recruited. The liver, for instance,
can tolerate nearly complete loss of arte rial blood flow due to the presence of a
parallel portal flow that immediately compensates for the loss. The uterus
demonstrates a good ability to recruit collateral vessels from the ovaries and
adjacent organs if blood flow through the uterine arteries ceases. Skeletal muscle at
rest can withstand several hours of ischaemia, while the brain and cardiac muscle
sustain damage within minutes.
Within minutes of ischaemia, cardiac muscle cells and cell membranes begin to be
damaged. Consequently, cells swell, an d contractability diminishes. After a few
hours, inflammatory cells start to accumula te, and if ischaemia persists, cell death
occurs. Similar effects, albeit not as rapid, occur in other organs.
One of the body’s fastest and most effec tive ways to restore blood flow is by
recruiting new vessels from nearby vascular territories. This occurs, for example, in
the brain during acute stroke
27, and if the blood flow to th e spleen is cut off, blood
can reach the spleen throu gh vessels in the stomach wall. These rapid changes are
stimulated by decreased post-stenotic pressure and a decrease in oxygen levels.
Chronic inflammation and angiogenesi s are interconnected phenomena that
frequently coexist. Hypoxia serves as a common trigger for both processes 26.
Hypoxic conditions prompt the accumulati on of macrophages and other immune
cells, which produce cascades of cytokines (MMP and VEGF) that stimulate the
formation of new blood vessels (figure 4) 26. This function is particularly effective
in tumours, whose growth partly re lies on angiogenesis and overexpression of
proangiogenic factors 28. In the context of tumour embolisation, following
transarterial chemoembolisation (TACE) of HCC, rapidly growing and new
tortuous vessels develop as a response to the sudden ischaemia.
26
Figure 4
Cross-link between chronic inflammation and angiogenesis. Growth, factors, cytokines and proteases
are secreted by the inflammatory cells. Degradation of the extracellular matrix (ECM) and growth of
endothelial cells (EC) are induced. The inflammation is enhanced by angiogenesis which provides
cytokines, nutrients and oxygen and enables chemotaxis of inflammatory cells. The loop further
enhances both angiogenesis and inflammation26. SMC – smooth muscle cell. Source: Author.
Finally, it is important to point out th at angiogenesis is not only a phenomenon
involved in pathology but also in the gr owing organism and in regeneration of
tissues29.
Uterine fibroma and treatment
Background
Uterine leiomyoma or uterine fibroma is the most common tumour type in
gynaecological organs. The prevalence is hi gh but challenging to study as most
uterine fibroids remain asymptomatic. The prevalence increases with age. Various
numbers are reported, ranging from 40% in women aged over 40 years30 to 80% in
women aged 50 years 31. A study using ultrasound in premenopausal women
reported a prevalence of 62%32. In contrast, only 5.4% of 335 Swedish women were
found to have fibroids on ultrasound33. In a study involving 95,061 premenopausal
nurses in the USA, a higher annual incidence was observed for black women
compared to white women, with rates of 30.9 per 1000 and 8.9 per 1000,
respectively
34.
27
The mortality of uterine fibroids is nearly negligible, while the morbidity is obvious.
Different figures are reported here as we ll, with 20-40% of women experiencing
symptoms from their uterine fibroids35. Uterine fibroids are the most common cause
of hysterectomy worldwide and the second most common gynaecological surgery
after caesarean section
36, 37.
The most significant and widely reported risk factor for developing fibroids is race,
with black women having a significantly higher risk. In general, both oestrogen and
progesterone are risk factors for the development of fibroids
38. This means, for
example, that fibroids grow in the early stages of pregnancy, and their growth halts
after menopause. Other risk factors include advanced age, heredity, hypertension,
nulliparity, early menarche, late menopause, overweight, vitamin D deficiency, and
exposure to various chemicals, including alcohol and tobacco. Injectable
contraceptives containing medroxyprogesterone acetate (MPA), a synthetic
progestin, have a protective effect. Oral contraceptive pills in younger years increase
the risk of developing fibroids, while th e use of oral contraceptives later in life
decreases the risk
38, 39.
The clinical symptoms depend on the size and location of the fibroids. The most
common symptom is pain. Abnormal bleedi ng and unusually heavy or prolonged
menstruation (menorrhagia) as well as bleeding between regular menstrual periods
(metrorrhagia) can also occur. Other sympto ms may be related to pregnancy, such
as implantation issues, premature delivery, and miscarriage. Difficulties during
childbirth and urinary incontinence may also occur
40, 41.
The role of uterine fibroids in infertility is a subject of debate. When other causes
of infertility are ruled out, fibroids are f ound in 1-2% of women. However, meta-
analyses suggest that fibroids do indeed have an impact on fertility, with the primary
cause believed to be their effect on uterin e contractility and, consequently, embryo
migration. In particular, submucosal fibroids have a negative impact on
implantation, pregnancy, and the incidence of miscarriages 42. Intramural fibroids
have a significantly lesser effect, and all studies indicate that subserosal fibroids do
not affect fertility at all43, unless they are large and located near the fallopian tubes.
Although the extent of fibroid impact on fertility is not fully established, fibroids
are often treated with the aim of increasing the chances of a successful pregnancy38.
Classification
Uterine fibroids are monoclonal tumours that arise from smooth muscle, such as the
myometrium. They are often well-defined and can occur at various locations in the
uterus, including the cervix and parametrium. Fibroids are classified based on their
location (figure 5). Subserosal and submucosal fibroids may also be pedunculated.
Intramural fibroids can have more or less contact with the endometrium and are
classified accordingly.
28
Figure 5
Diagram describing the uterine fibroid classification system. Organised according to the location
between the submucosal (0 – 2), intramural (3 – 5), and subserosal (6 – 7) layers of the uterus.
Subtype ‘8’ is not illustrated and denotes ‘other’ location e.g. cervical fibroid. Image courtesy of Sachi
Hapugoda, Radiopaedia.org, rID: 62908
Treatment options
Various treatment options are available for uterine fibroids. The choice of treatment
is dependent on the number and the location of the fibroids, as well as the woman’s
desire to conceive. Surgical treatment is by far the most common approach, as
indicated by a dataset from the Unite d States based on insurance claims.
Hysterectomy was the predominant treatme nt, accounting for 82.2%, followed by
myomectomy at 14.7%. Only 3.1% underwent uterine fibroid embolisation44.
Surgery
The definitive cure for fibroids is hyster ectomy, with the clear consequence that
future pregnancy is precluded. Other su rgical methods include uterus-preserving
myomectomy, which can be performed e ither hysteroscopically, laparoscopically,
or through open surgery (laparotomy). During myomectomy, the tumours are
29
enucleated. Hysteroscopic myomectomy is best suited for intramural fibroids, while
subserosal fibroids require abdominal surg ery. Like all surgeries, these procedures
carry risks of complications such as bleed ing, infections, and scar tissue formation
(synechiae or adhesions). Injuries to adjacent organs such as the bladder, bowel, and
ureters can also occur. Laparoscopic myomectomy reported 9.1% minor and 2%
major complications45.
The cumulative five-year recu rrence risk after resection of multiple fibroids was
74%, compared to only 11% after resection of a single fibroid38.
Pharmacological therapy
Pharmacological treatment of fibroids focuses on the inhibition of female sex
hormones, primarily progesterone. The treatment is not curative but can sometimes
alleviate symptoms and improve quality of life. Often, pharmacological treatment
serves as a palliative measure until surgery becomes a consideration. In cases of
bleeding issues, tranexamic acid or horm onal intrauterine devices may be used.
Newer treatments targeting genetic and receptor levels are under development
36, 39.
High-intensity focused ultrasound
HIFU is sometimes used with MRI guid ance and hence referred to as MRgFUS.
Local treatment with high-frequency ultrasound can be applied to smaller fibroids.
It is considered suitable for women w ho wish to preserve fertility. Highlighted
advantages include the ability to perform th e treatment on an outpatient basis and
its association with very few complications 46. HIFU appears to be more effective
than myomectomy in terms of quality of life (QoL). In a meta-study, symptom
recurrence was lower compared to myomect omy, but the re-intervention rate was
slightly higher47, 48.
Uterine artery embolisation
Uterine artery embolisation (UAE) or Uterine fibroid embolisation (UFE) are
synonymous terms for the same treatment.
Embolisation is a uterus-preserving altern ative to surgery in the treatment of
symptomatic fibroids. Its best effect is observed in reducing menorrhagia, where
over 90% experience a reduction in bleeding. While the desire for pregnancy is not
an absolute contraindication, many consid er myomectomy to be a better treatment
option for women who want this. There is an increased risk of miscarriage,
premature birth, and lower birth weight after embolisation. However, several studies
report completely normal pregnancies.
30
Gynaecological examination, including ultrasound, should be conducted before
treatment to exclude other causes for the symptoms. Any signs of malignancy, such
as sarcomas, should result in further investigation and use of a treatment other than
embolisation. Pedunculated and very large fibroids are better suited for surgery49, 50.
However, a very large uterus with a signi ficant number of smaller fibroids may be
suitable for embolisation. MRI should be performed before and after the
embolisation51. Absolute contraindications for UFE are pregnancy and suspicion of
malignancy, while renal failure, coagulopa thy, and contrast allergy are relative
contraindications. Vascular mapping with CT or MRI prior to the intervention is not
routinely performed.
Vascular anatomy of the uterus
The uterine artery is a branch of the anteri or division of the internal iliac artery. It
turns medially across the pelvic floor at the base of the broad ligament towards the
uterine cervix. It crosses the ureter ante riorly, then ascends along the side of the
uterus. At the superolateral angle of the ut erus, it turns laterally and runs along the
uterine tube and terminates by dividing into two branches, the tubal branch, and the
ovarian branch. Those terminal branch es will anastomose with two corresponding
arteries from the ovarian artery. The branches will supply the tube and ovary
respectively. Branches from the ovarian and uterine artery will form the periovarian
arcade from which numeral arterial twig s will enter the mesovarium forming a
plexus in the ovarium medulla (figure 6A).
The first branch from the uterine artery is the ureteral branch (not shown in the
figure). Close to the cervix and the lateral fornix of the vagina, the vaginal and the
vaginal branches arise. Along the side of the uterus body, the uterine artery gives
off arcade branches which run transversely on the anterior and posterior surfaces of
the uterus and anastomoses with their c ontralateral counterparts along the midline.
At the superolateral angle of the uterus, branches to the fundus arise (figure 6A).
The ovarian arteries often arise from the a bdominal aorta, below the renal arteries.
They have a typical corkscrew appearance
51.
31
Figure 6
(A) Anatomy of the arterial supply of the uterus, cervix and ovaries. (B) A transverse section of the
uterus including a uterine fibroma. Large bilateral feeding arteries supply the fibroma, however without
the same network of radial branches as the normal tissue which makes the fibroma more vulnerable to
ischaemia. (A) The image is in the public domain. (B) Reprinted with permission from Radiographics51.
Several variations of the vasculature have been described in the literature and must
be taken into account during the procedure 52, 53 . Awareness of the anastomoses
described above is important to optimise the result and to minimise adverse side
effects and complications. The utero-ov arian anastomoses are identified in 10-
30%
52, 54. The diameter of the anastomoses is usually less than 500 µm.
The fibroids are often supplied from both sides and usually with enlarged feeding
vessels. However, compared to the normal ut erine tissue, the fibroids have a more
primitive vascularisation and are supplied by small centripetal arteries (figure 6B).
Therefore, the fibroids are more vulnerable to ischaemia. In some cases, especially
in women with prior pelvic surgery, fi broids can be supplied from the ovarian
arteries52.
Embolic material
For a successful outcome in both the short and long term, the most crucial factor is
achieving total ischaemia of the fibroid. Recurrence growth occurs from the non-
infarcted parts of the fibroid 55. Fibroids embolised with particles reach more
peripheral areas than coils and glue, resulti ng in better infarction. No differences
have been observed when using smaller particles (<500µm) or larger particles (500-
700µm) in randomised controlled trials. Although smaller particles are theoretically
more effective, they pose greater risks as they can more easily pass into other organs
and cause ischaemic damage, of non-target embolisation, such as the ovaries. If
angiography reveals anastomoses to the ovaries, larger spheres should be used (700
– 900 µm). In most of the studies comp aring the effectiveness of TGMS and PVA
particles, no difference was seen in the short or long-term results 56-60; however, a
systematic review by Jiang et al. found an overall better outcome for TGMS at six
32
and twelve months post-embolisation for quality of life, symptom relief, fibroid and
uterus volume as well as infarction rate 60. The most common material for UFE in
Sweden today is PVA particles (350-500µm) and TGMS (500-700µm)61.
Procedure
Preprocedural consultation with an anaest hesiologist for adequate analgesia is
recommended. Typically, the procedure can be performed under local anaesthesia,
but in some cases, epidural anaesthesia or sedation may be considered. Antiemetics
and mild sedation are recommended.
Transarterial access is obtained through retrograde puncture of the common femoral
artery. Subsequently, a catheter is advan ced over the aortic bifurcation to the
contralateral common iliac artery. After catheterising the internal iliac artery, a
subtraction angiography is performed as a roadmap for further catheterisation. The
uterine artery has a typical U-shaped appearance. Usually, a co-axial microcatheter
is required for further selective catheterisation. It is preferable to position the tip of
the catheter peripherally to the origin of the ureteral and cervical branches unless
there are fibroids in the cervix that need treatment. The treatment can now be
initiated at this site. Care should be taken to ensure that the microcatheter is not
occluded, and it should be regularly flushed with saline. As the flow stops due to
embolisation, additional attention to reflux is required, as it may inadvertently cause
undesired embolisation to other locations . After achieving stagnant flow, a few
minutes should be allowed, followed by a careful angiography with hand injection
to potentially replenish with more particl es. Once the procedure is completed, the
same procedure is performed on the other side, either through the same femoral
access and ipsilateral approach or with a new puncture on the other side. An
alternative is simultaneous treatment from both sides using two access sites, which
can reduce the amount of ionising radiation. After completing the procedure, the
catheters and introducers are removed
61, 62.
Post-procedural management
Pain relief with oral analgesics is usually sufficient, however, sometimes an epidural
anaesthesia is required. Post-embolisation syndrome (PES) may occur and may
require additional treatment, such as an tibiotics. PES is a frequently observed
phenomenon, occurring in appr oximately 40% of patients within the initial week
following UFE for the treatment of leiomyomas. PES is characterised by the
manifestation of pelvic pain, low-grade fever, nausea, vomiting, reduced appetite,
and general discomfort during the early stages of post-procedural recovery.
Although the exact underlying causes of PES remain largely unknown, it is believed
to stem from an inflammatory response caused by the ischaemia and necrosis of the
tumour and uterine tissues
63.
33
Complications
Large intracavitary or intramural fibroids with submucosal contact can be expelled.
This typically occurs between three week s to six months after the treatment and
manifests as severe menstrual-like cramps and bleeding or discharge. Other possible
complications include infection, pulmonary embolism, mis-embolisation, injury to
the myometrium, or loss of ovarian function62.
Results
Both menorrhagia and bulk symptoms improve in 80-95% of patients. Re-
intervention is needed in approximately 5-10% of cases within a year due to the lack
of effect. Long-term results show similar results as surgery 64. For women desiring
pregnancy, most indications suggest that myomectomy is a better treatment, at least
during the first two years65.
Benign prostate hyperplasia
Background
With increasing age, the formation of sm all benign adenomas occurs within the
transition zone of the prostate. These adenomas consist of glandular epithelial tissue,
smooth muscle, and connective tissue; th erefore, the term “stromo-glandular
hyperplasia” is used. The adenomas can proliferate and result in BPH. This process
may commence in certain individuals as early as in their thirties. By the time the
eighties are reached, approximately 90% of all men exhibit microscopic
hyperplasia. As the prostate gland enlarges, it can cause obstructive symptoms. The
affected individual then experiences the characteristic manifestations of BPH,
known as lower urinary tract symptoms (LUTS). The growth of glandular cells is
dependent upon functioning testes where the androgens, including testosterone, are
produced by the Leydig cells. It is released into the bloodstream and enters the cells
by diffusion. Testosterone is converted w ithin the prostate by the enzyme 5-alpha
reductase to dihydrotestosterone (DHT), which exhibits much higher affinity to the
androgen receptor in the prostate compared to testosterone. DHT attaches to the
androgen receptors and stimulates the growth of cells in the transition zone of the
prostate. This process is necessary for normal gland development as well as the
growth which leads to hyperplasia. In hyperplasia development, there is an
imbalance; the rate of formation of new cells is faster than the rate of cell death.
Consequently, prostate hyperplasia is char acterised by a dysfunction in apoptosis,
wherein cells do not undergo normal programmed cell death at the expected rate.
Regarding testosterone, it is a well-known fact that eunuchs and men castrated
before puberty have an atrophic prostate and do not develop BPH
66.
34
Genetic factors may play a role in BPH development as well as obesity. BPH is
more commonly seen in certain ethnic groups, such as African Americans. A
sedentary lifestyle and type 2 diabetes also contribute to an increased risk of BPH67.
LUTS and BPH are highly prevalent. A Swedish population study revealed that over
30% of more than 2,000 randomly selected men from across the country had an
international prostate symptom score (IPSS) of 8 or higher, while over 10% had an
IPSS of 15 or higher. One-third of me n with LUTS reported a significant negative
impact on their quality of life
68.
There are different methods for diagnosing BPH and LUTS, such as patient history
and basic examination, which includes palpation of the prostate, a urine dipstick, and
checks of prostate-specific antigen (PSA), and creatinine levels. The urologist
usually performs a transrectal ultrasound of the prostate. The International Prostate
Symptom Score is the most used tool. It is a validated, self-administered
questionnaire. The output is a score between 0 and 35 where 0 is asymptomatic and
35 is severely symptomatic
66. Further evaluation may include uroflowmetry and
post-void residual. MRI is usually not a part of the workup unless suspicion of cancer.
Treatment
The American Urological Association describes a wide range of treatment options.
Depending on the severity of the symp toms and associated symptoms and
conditions, different options are recommended66.
Medical therapy is often the first line option regardless of severity. Monotherapy or
combination of drugs. If the cause of LUTS is a prostate gland size over 40 ml, 5-
alpha reductase inhibitors can reduce gl and size and decrease symptoms. Alpha-
receptor blockers relax smooth muscle in th e prostate gland and the bladder neck,
thereby increasing urine flow. The advantages of alpha-receptor blockers lie in their
prompt efficacy, evident within a few days, irrespective of prostate size.
Anticholinergics/muscarinic receptor inhib itors may be considered for storage
symptoms. The risk of urinary retentio n caused by anticholinergic treatment is
exaggerated but not entirely negligible. In such cases, selective beta-3-adrenoceptor
agonists can be tested. They enhance th e storage phase of the bladder with an
equivalent clinical effect to anticholinergic treatment, yet with a somewhat more
favourable side effect profile. Phosp hodiesterase type 5 (PDE5) inhibitors,
commonly known as Sildenafil, lead to in creased levels of cGMP, which exerts a
relaxing effect on smooth muscle, includi ng the prostate. For patients with
combined LUTS and erectile dysfunction, this may serve as an alternative
66.
Surgery is indicated for patients with impa ired renal function, urinary retention,
gross haematuria due to BPH or recurren ce of bladder stones. Total prostatectomy
should only be performed on very large glands. Transurethral resection of the
prostate (TURP) or transurethral incision of the prostate (TUIP) are smaller
35
interventions. TURP is the most common su rgery for BPH. Prostatic urethral lift 69
or adenoma enucleation are other options. Several other local, often transurethral
therapies, using laser, heat, ultrasound, microwave, water vapour70 and stenting can
be effective alternatives.
Most surgery must be performed under general anaesthesia and requires
postoperative hospitalisation. Side effects of surgical interventions range from acute
events related to the surgery itself, i.e. bleeding or infection. After prostatectomy,
there is a risk of incontinence and sexual dysfunction. Retrograde ejaculation is
common after TURP.
A relatively new treatment option is Prostate Artery Embolisation (PAE)
66, 71.
Prostate artery embolisation
In 1976, Mitchell et al. treated four men with severe haematuria from the bladder or
prostate with bilateral embolisation of the internal iliac arteries 72. The benefit of
PAE was first described by DeMeritt in 2000 73. He performed a unilateral
embolisation of the inferior vesical artery with PVA (150-250µm) for treating
haematuria due to BPH. One year later the IPSS score was improved from 24 to 13
and the volume of the gland was reduced by 40%. Carnevale et al. successfully
treated two men with acute BPH-related urinary obstruction with PAE in 2010. The
embolisation was performed with calib rated microspheres, TGMS (300-500µm)
74
with symptom relief at the six-month follow-up. A year later, Pisco et al.75 presented
a case series of 15 patients who underw ent PAE. Significant improvement was
achieved in most patients, however one pa tient required surgical resection of the
urinary bladder because of ischaemia 75. Over the years, PAE has now become a
treatment option for BPH worldwide.
Several papers, including review articles, have been published on the topic. PAE is
often compared to TURP. Carnevale conc luded that TURP and PAE yield similar
symptom improvement. However, TURP has better urodynamics but more adverse
events76. Similar results were found in a Cochrane review by Jung et al. in 2023 77.
The same article did not find any significan t differences in major or minor adverse
events or differences in QoL/IPSS betw een the two groups. However, PAE has a
shorter hospital stay after the treatment and a lower frequency of ejaculatory
disorders but a higher re-treatment rate than TURP. The UK-ROPE trial was
performed by the British Society of Interv entional Radiologists and by the British
Association of Urological Surgeons. Th e results indicated that PAE provided a
clinically and statistically significant improvement in symptoms and QoL, although
some of these improvements were greater in the TURP arm. The safety pro file and
quicker return to normal life were advantages for the PAE group
78.
Low rates of side effects and complications after PAE are reported. Most post-
procedural events are temporary and incl ude dysuria, haematuria, rectal bleeding,
36
hematospermia, urinary retention and in fection. Inflammation after embolisation
secondary to ischaemia is an expected side effect. PES may require additional
treatment with antibiotics or percutaneous drainage in the case of abscess formation.
There is a risk, however low, for urethral stricture secondary to ischaemia. Non-
target embolisation of the rectum, urinary bladder, seminal vesicles, and penis have
been described79, 80.
Prostate artery embolisation
Preprocedural CT angiography is performed to map the arterial anatomy, especially
the origin of the inferior vesical artery (IVA) (prostate artery), and to identify
troublesome anastomoses. MRI angiography is an alternative for mapping but is not
as good as CT angiography. MRI is better for assessing the prostate gland and can
be used to detect malignancy and for volumetry. Usually, CT, MRI and ultrasound
are performed prior to the treatment. As the procedure progresses, Cone Beam CT
(CBCT) should be performed to evaluate the anatomy and treatment.
Anatomy
Similar to the uterine artery, the IVA arises from the anterior division of the internal
iliac artery (figure 7). The branches arising from the common trunk of the iliac artery
are (internal pudendal, middle rectal, obturator, inferior vesical, superior vesical).
The acronym PROVISO (O for ipsilateral oblique view) is used to memorise the
branches. However, there are many anatom ical variants. In the figure below the
inferior and superior vesical arteries originate from a common trunk (figure 7B).
Figure 7
(A, B) Arterial anatomy of the prostate gland. (A) shows a coronal view with the access for the
intervention from the contralateral side. (B) shows an ipsilateral oblique view of the internal iliac artery
branches. In this case, the inferior and superior vesical arteries originate from a common trunk which is
an anatomic variant. IIA – internal iliac artery, SVA – superior vesical artery. IVA – inferior vesical
artery, OBT – obturator artery, MR – middle rectal artery, IPA – internal pudendal artery. Reprinted with
permission from Radiographics79
37
Embolisation procedure
In a similar manner to UAE, the iliac in ternal artery is catheterised. The
PERFECTED technique (proximal embolisati on first, then embolise distal) should
be used. When the microcatheter has been placed in the proximal IVA and a
vasodilator has been injected through the catheter, it is further advanced distal to the
collateral branches supplying nearby organs. After another aliquot of vasodilator,
the embolisation commences with a diluted solution of calibrated microspheres. The
size of the spheres is important. Smaller spheres penetrate more distally and yield a
better ischaemia but have a greater risk of non-target embolisation. Spheres of
different sizes can also be combined. Usually, spheres sized 100-300µm or 300-
500µm are used.
When stasis has been achieve d and verified with angiography the microcatheter is
advanced into the intraprostatic branch es for additional embolisation. Another 30-
100% of spheres can usually be delivered. After a final angiography, the procedure
is repeated on the contralateral side. Catheters and wires are removed. A haemostatic
device can be used. Usually, the patient can be discharged on the same day.
Postoperative pain management is provided with oral analgesics
79.
Tumour embolisation
Tumour embolisation is often performed in the liver but can also be carried out in
other organs, such as the kidneys and l ungs. The embolisation material may be
loaded with cytostatic drugs in chemoe mbolisation (TACE) or with radioactive
isotopes in radioembolisation (TARE). In TACE, the ischaemic effect is combined
with the effect of the active substance. When only the embolic material is used, the
procedure is referred to as transarterial embolisation or bland embolisation. The
therapy’s usual purpose is palliation, but it is sometimes employed as a bridge to
transplantation or partial liver resection.
The liver has a parallel blood supply, with approximately 2/3 of the normal liver
parenchyma being supplied by the portal system and the rest by the arterial system,
while tumours are entirely supplied by the arterial system. This means tumours are
more vulnerable to embolisation of the hepatic artery. A prerequisite for treating the
liver with TACE is that the portal system is patent; otherwise, ischaemia would
severely affect the healthy liver pare nchyma, especially with non-selective
treatment
81. In the case of TARE, the ischaemic effect is less pronounced, and this
procedure can be performed also when the portal vein is non-patent.
Since TAE and TACE are performed to induce ischaemia, they work best on
hypervascular tumours, i.e., tumours w ith high perfusion and a high demand for
oxygen. In the liver, this primarily involves HCC and metastases from
neuroendocrine tumours, such as carcinoi ds, which often produce multiple large
liver metastases. Treatment often occurs non-selectively, treating an entire liver lobe
38
at a time rather than the individual metastasis selectively. However, the trend is now
towards a more selective approach. Before embolisation begins, any shunts to the
venous system must be mapped and avoided. If the tumour load is extensive, the
treatment can be painful and may require general anaesthesia, but in most cases, it
can be performed with sedation and intravenous pain relief. In the case of carcinoid
metastases, the treatment may induce a hormone release from metastases, leading
to a so-called carcinoid crisis. Therefore, premedication, including somatostatin
analogues, is required. TAE is performed with small particles, such as PVA 45-150
µm, but other materials such as starch s pheres or Lipiodol emulsions may be used.
Serious complications occur in 10% of cases, including acute liver and kidney
failure, carcinoid crisis, and bleeding ulcers. Sepsis and liver abscesses may also
occur. PES occurs in 90% of cases
61.
The most common indication for embolisati on of the liver is HCC. HCC is often
hypervascular and can be treated with TACE as well as TAE.
TACE can be performed as conventional TACE (cTACE) with Lipiodol emulsion
as the carrier of the active drug, or as DEB-TACE with drug-eluted beads as the
carrier. For HCC, doxorubicin is the active drug82. TACE can also be performed for
colorectal metastases, using ir inotecan as the active substance 83. These metastases
are usually hypovascular and the embolisation effect itself is not sufficient and must
be combined with an active drug. The prac tical procedure is more or less the same
as described above. However, a more sel ective approach is usually adopted,
reducing the risk of liver damage. Since selective treatment minimises the effect on
the normal liver parenchyma, portal vein thrombosis is not an absolute
contraindication. Subsequent PES and systematic reactions to cytostatic drugs may
occur.
In recent years, a few studies have been published on PAE for the treatment of
prostate cancer
84. DEB-PACE of the prostate was described in 2022 by Guan, Wang
and Zhang. Epirubicin-loaded beads showed promising results in treating advanced
prostate cancer. No further conclusions could be drawn from this small study85. The
role of PAE and PACE regarding oncological outcomes must be assessed further.
39
Prostate cancer
The prostate
The prostate gland is a walnut-sized, fibr omuscular accessory glandular organ that
surrounds the prostatic urethra. The base of the prostate is located at the neck of the
bladder. Its apex rests on the urogenital diaphragm. The anterior surface is separated
from the symphysis by retropubic fat, and th e posterior surface lies adjacent to the
rectum and Denonvilliers', a part of the meso rectal fascia. The in ferolateral part is
close to the levator ani. The two seminal vesicles are located posterolaterally and
connect with the vas deferens, forming th e ejaculatory ducts that pass through the
prostate and join the urethra at the verumontanum, also known as the seminal
colliculus. The seminal vesicles produce most of the seminal fluid, containing
substances such as fructose and enzymes.
The external sphincter is located below the apex and consists of an outer layer of
horseshoe-shaped striated muscle and an i nner circular layer of smooth muscle
surrounding the urethra. The prostate consists of four histologically distinct zones
(figure 8).
Figure 8.
Gross anatomy of the prostate and its lobes. In benign prostate hyperplasia, the transition zone becomes
enlarged at the expense of the other zones. Reprinted with permission from Springer Verlag86.
40
The transition zone (TZ) constitutes approximately 5% of a young boy’s prostate
and consists of paired lobes on either side of the proximal urethra. The TZ is located
between the other three zones and is sepa rated from them by the so-called surgical
capsule. It is the TZ that undergoes growth in cases of benign prostatic hyperplasia
and can, in extreme cases, account for al most 100% of the prostate, reaching
volumes of 200-300 ml. 10-20% of malignancies arise in the TZ.
The central zone (CZ) comprises about a quarter of the prostate’s volume. It is
pyramid-shaped, situated dorsally, and surrounds the ejaculatory ducts. The CZ
narrows downward. Pathology in the CZ is uncommon, with approximately 5% of
malignancies originating here.
The peripheral zone (PZ) constitutes 70% of the prostate’s volume, but as the TZ
grows with age, the proportion decreases. The PZ is located dorsally, laterally, and
apically. Ventral and cranial, it transitions into the anterior fibromuscular stroma.
About 70% of malignancies have their origin in the PZ. The PZ has a close
relationship with the dorsolateral neurovascu lar pedicles, which can be early sites
of invasion by cancer from the PZ.
Finally, there is the anterior fibromuscular stroma (AFMS), which makes up one-
third of the prostate but contains no glandul ar tissue. Basally, it transitions into the
detrusor muscle and internal sphincter. Ap ically, it transitions into striated muscle
in the external sphincter.
Epidemiology and risk factors
Prostate cancer is the most common form of cancer in men, with its incidence
varying worldwide. It is highest among Afro-Americans in the United States and
the Caribbean, followed by Caucasians in the United States and Scandinavia, while
it is lowest in Southeast Asia. In Fr ench Guadeloupe, the prevalence is 184 per
100,000 men, whereas the corresponding figu re in Sweden is 100 per 100,000
men87.
In Sweden, the number of newly dia gnosed cases doubled between 1990 and 2024
(figure 9). This increase is attributed to the introduction of PSA testing and other
diagnostic procedures, leading to the detection of more low-grade and indolent
tumours. One in five Swedish men is di agnosed with prostate cancer during his
lifetime
88. The age-standardised incidence trends are depicted in figure 9.
41
Figure 9.
Age-standardised incidence and mortality per 100,000 men in Sweden, 1970-2020. Age-standardised
according to the age distribution in the NORDCAN population in the year 200088.
Prostate cancer is strongly age dependent. The disease rarely occurs before the age
of 50 and almost never before the ag e of 40. Increased diagnostic activity has
resulted in a decrease in the median age at diagnosis from 74 to 69 years during the
period 1995-2005.
Prostate cancer is the most common cau se of cancer-related death among Swedish
men. In 2018, 5.3% of men died of prosta te cancer (PCa). Half of those who die
from PCa are over 82 years old, and 75% are over 75 years old.
A clear downward trend is observed in all age groups, with a 50% reduction in men
under 75 years of age over the past 15 years (figure 10). However, the number of
Swedish men dying from the disease has remained relatively unchanged over the
past 10 years, as the population of elderly men has increased (figure 9).
42
Figure 10.
The number of deaths from prostate cancer per 100,000 among men younger than 75 years in Sweden
during the years 1998-202188.
In the year 2021, approximately 125,000 men in Sweden were living with diagnosed
prostate cancer89-91, which is three times more than 20 years ago (figure 11). This
increase can be attributed partly to the growing population of elderly men, partly to
earlier diagnosis of prostate cancer in comp arison to previous years, and partly to
improved treatment enabling men with advanced prostate cancer to live longer.
43
Figure 11.
The number of men living with a diagnosis of prostate cancer per year from 1980 to 2020. (NVP)
The Western lifestyle, including obesity and a high consumption of dairy products,
may increase the risk of prostate cancer 91, 92 . Chronic inflammation and tobacco
smoking may also play a role in the development of the disease 93. Heredity is
another significant factor, with sons and brothers of individuals with prostate cancer
having higher risks, particularly if multiple family members are affected. Two
genes, BRCA2 and HOXB13, have been identified as increasing the risk of prostate
cancer
94, 95.
Diagnostics of prostate cancer
Prostate-specific antigen
Prostate-specific antigen is an enzyme produced in the glandular epithelium of the
prostate and is secreted in high concentrations into seminal fluid, where it liquefies
the gel surrounding sperm
96, 97. PSA is predominantly produced in the prostate, and
its production is stimulated by testoster one and DHT. The normal level of PSA in
the blood is <3 µg/L, but it is age-depe ndent. The concentration is approximately
one millionth of the concentration in seminal fluid. PSA in the blood leaks from
prostate cells, and leakage increases when there is damage to cell membranes, as
seen in conditions such as prostate cancer, inflammation, BPH, urinary retention,
renal failure, and mechanical stimulation su ch as palpation. Other factors affecting
44
PSA levels in the blood include medica tions, such as 5-alpha-reductase inhibitors,
and consideration of these factors is essential in the assessment.
Prostate cancer cells produce less PSA per cell than normal prostate cells, and PSA
production decreases with dedifferentiation. Therefore, a poorly differentiated
prostate cancer may be locally advanced and metastatic even with low PSA values.
In the blood, PSA exists both in a free form and bound to alpha-1-antichymotrypsin
and alpha-2-macroglobulin, the latter of which is not detected in routine blood tests.
The ratio between free and total PSA in the blood can provide additional
information. A low ratio suggests maligna ncy, while a high ratio suggests BPH.
Since PSA values are largely related to th e amount of prostate tissue and thus the
number of prostate cells, even healthy cells in a large, benign prostate with BPH can
Result
in a high value. Therefore, PSA de nsity is a more valuable measure than
absolute PSA. To calculate density, knowledge of the prostate’s volume is required.
Different treatment plans use different thr eshold values, often set at 0.1 µg/L/cm³.
Another factor to consider is the change in PSA value over time, where a rapid
change raises the suspicion of cancer
96-101.
Digital rectal examination
The digital rectal examination (DRE) is always included in the examination of men
with LUTS or elevated PSA levels. Since onl y the dorsal parts of the prostate can
be palpated, the majority of the prostate cannot be assessed, leading to a significant
proportion of cancers being overlooked. The combination of DRE with PSA and
biopsy has a specificity and sensitivity of less than 60%
101.
Transrectal ultrasound and biopsy
Transrectal ultrasound (TRUS) is routinely performed by urologists. TRUS is a
valuable diagnostic tool in urology, providing detailed images of the prostate gland
and surrounding structures to aid in the diagnosis and management of various
prostate-related conditions. It is used to calculate the volume of the gland and to
detect pathology. TRUS also serves as a guide for biopsies (figure 13A). Biopsies
can be targeted towards a specific lesion (targeted) or conducted on 10-12
standardised locations (systematic). In systematic biopsies, the focus is primarily on
sampling the dorsal parts of the prostate. To enhance the precision of targeted
biopsies, various fusion techniques, such as with MRI, can be employed. Cognitive
fusion means the urologist localising the lesion on MRI and then, based on this
information, determining approximately where the biopsy should be taken. Other
more resource-intensive biopsy techniques include transperineal biopsies or MRI-
guided biopsies, so-called in-bore biopsies. While these techniques have their
advantages, they have not proven to be superior to simpler methods
102.
45
Magnetic resonance tomography
MRI is now a cornerstone in PCa diagnosis. It will be described more thoroughly
separately in the thesis.
Histology
The Gleason grading system was developed by Donald F. Gleason in 1966103 and is
still used in a modified form for grading prostatic adenocarcinoma 104. Gleason
identified five different histological pattern s, grades 1 to 5 (well-differentiated to
anaplastic/poorly differentiated) (figure 12). Previously, the two most common
patterns were indicated as a sum, ranging from 2 to 10. Since 2005, the score is
reported by first specifying the most prevalent pattern followed by the pattern with
the highest grade, possibly 3+4.
Figure 12
The Gleason grading system. Public Domain,
https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=440437
46
There is significant interobserver variability among pathologists 105, 106 , which is
troublesome as it affects risk assessment a nd treatment decisions. In 2014, the
International Society of Urological Pathology (ISUP) agreed on a new grading
system based on the Gleason Scores 107. The different Gleason score combinations
were grouped into five ISUP groups to provide a more straightforward and clinically
relevant classification of cancer aggressiveness (table 1). The system helps patients
and clinicians understand the severity of the disease and make informed treatment
decisions.
Table 1
The International Society of Urological Pathology (ISUP) grade groups
ISUP Grade group Gleason Score Gleason Pattern
1 <6 <3+3
2 7 3+4
3 7 4+3
4 8 4+4, 3+5, 5+3
5 9 or 10 4+5, 5+4, 5+5
Figure 13
(A) TRUS 18G biopsy from the right anterior aspect of the TZ, Gleason 4+3 (ISUP 3). (B). Whole
mount surgical specimen from the same patient. Image courtesy Kevin Sandeman, Skåne University
Hospital, Malmö. Department of Clinical Pathology.
Risk groups and treatment
The risk groups are divided into four categories: very low risk, low risk,
intermediate risk, and high risk. These groups are based on PSA level, Gleason
score, and cT stage. The cT stage is determined by the DRE according to the TNM
8 classification 88. The choice of treatment depends on the risk group, possible
metastases, patient wishes, symptoms, a nd remaining life expectancy. In short,
treatment options include active surveilla nce, hormonal therapy, chemotherapy,
radiotherapy, surgery, or combinations of these.
47
Magnetic resonance imaging
Background
and routine use of MRI
In 1973, Paul L. Lauterbur and Sir Pete r Mansfield were awarded the Nobel Prize
for their discoveries in the field of magnetic resonance. The first MRI of the prostate
was demonstrated and published by Steyn and Smith in 1982 (figure 14). Twenty-
five patients were examined on a prototype 0.04-T scanner. They concluded that the
images were comparable to first-generation CT scans108.
Figure 14.
The first MRI of a prostate from a 0.04T scanner from 1982108. Reprinted with permission from Wiley
compared to a modern 3T T2W image from our clinical routine.
In addition to field strength, the image quality depends on the receiver coil. A review
article in 2002 stated that endorectal coils improved staging performance 109.
Endorectal coils have been widely used, however, nowadays MRI is performed with
external phased array body coils. Another passing trend was the use of MRI
spectroscopy, a technique for chemical analysis and evaluation of the concentration
of different metabolites such as citrate and choline 110. The added value and
specificity were low, and the technique has been abandoned in standard MRI
imaging.
Today, there is a wide consensus about how to perform an MRI prostate
examination. Imaging guidelines are based on prostate imaging reporting and data
system (PI-RADS) version 2.1, developed by the American College of Radiology.
48
Multiparametric MRI (mpMRI) consist of T2-weighted (T2W), diffusion-weighted
imaging (DWI), and dynamic T1-weighted sequences (DCE)111.
An increasingly popular approach is to perform the examination without the use of
a contrast agent, referred to as bipara metric MRI (bpMRI), and it is now the
predominant protocol in Sweden 88. In addition to avoiding the administration of
contrast, which requires intravenous access and elevates the risk of side effects, this
approach significantly shortens the scan time and lowers the costs. Contrast-
enhanced sequences are therefore reserv ed for specific circumstances, such as
follow-up after focal therapy, where diffusion-weighted sequences cannot be
performed, or in the presence of artefacts from metal, typically hip prostheses.
Sequences
T1-weighted imaging
T1-weighted imaging (T1W) is a term used in MRI to describe an imaging technique
that provides contrast based on differences in the T1 relaxation time of tissues. The
T1 relaxation time is related to the time it takes for the hydrogen protons connected
to water in a tissue to realign with the external magnetic field after being disturbed.
In prostate imaging, T1-weighted imag es are used to detect haemorrhage and
delineate the borders of the prostate. The T1 property of the tissue can be enhanced
by intravenous injection of a contrast me dium, i.e. Gadolinium, and the procedure
is then referred to as dynamic contrast enhancement (DCE). T1-weighted sequences
are usually only obtained in the axial plane in prostate imaging.
T2-weighted imaging
T2-weighted imaging provides contrast based on the differences in the T2 relaxation
time of tissues. The T2 relaxation time is related to the time it takes for the protons
in a tissue to lose the tran sverse magnetisation component after being perturbed.
Fluid has a high signal on T2-weighted im aging, hence, urine and cysts appear
bright on these sequences. The PZ of a young man’s prostate has a high density of
glandular structures and is therefore also relatively bright on T2. In contrast, a
prostate tumour is usually dark. In routine clinical prostate imaging, the sequence is
obtained in at least two planes. It is u sed for detecting tumours in the TZ and for
discerning the zonal anatomy, as well as to evaluate extraprostatic tumour growth
(EPE) and seminal vesicle involvement (SVI).
49
Diffusion-weighted imaging
DWI imaging is a particularly important se quence in Prostatic MRI. Hence, it will
be described in more detail in the following section.
Principles of diffusion
DWI exploits the random motion of wate r molecules. In a completely free
environment, molecules move freely and randomly, which is known as Brownian
motion or free diffusion. This phenomenon was named after the botanist Robert
Brown, who observed the movement of plan t spores immersed in water. In 1905
Einstein used the model when he tried to prove the existence of the atom
112, 113
Within tissue, water molecules are infl uenced by various components such as cell
membranes and organelles (figure 15A). De pending on tissue properties, such as
cell density, this affects water molecules to varying extents. Tissues exhibiting this
characteristic impeded diffusion, occu rring in conditions such as tumours,
abscesses, fibrosis, lymphatic tissue, and cytotoxic oedema114.
Figure. 15
(A) The image shows water molecules inside cells (red dots) and between cells (green dots). The
movements of two molecules in respective locations are represented by the black traces. The water
molecules between cells can travel far but are slowed down by obstacles; this is referred to as hindered
diffusion. Water molecules that are trapped inside cells have a limited range of motion, hence, this is
called restricted diffusion. Standard diffusion imaging cannot distinguish the two from each other, but
both kinds are related to a lower apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC) compared to free diffusion. (B)
Mean square displacement of particles that experience free diffusion (black line), hindered diffusion
(blue line) and restricted diffusion (red line). Note that the lines are parallel at short diffusion times.
The mobility of water molecules can be described in the graph above (figure 15B).
Initially, all water molecules move with equal ease, but after a few milliseconds, the
surroundings exert varying degrees of influence.
50
Measurement of diffusion-weighted imaging
The most common DWI sequence is a spin echo with echo-planar imaging (EPI)
readout. The spin echo is created by a 90° radiofrequency (RF) excitation pulse
followed by a 180° RF refocusing pulse. The diffusion encoding is usually
performed with two identical pulsed field gr adients applied on either side of the
refocusing pulse (figure 16).
Figure 16.
The Diffusion Weighted Imaging (DWI) pulse sequence consists of two gradient pulses with a
magnitude (G) and duration (δ) separated by a time (Δ). The gyromagnetic ratio (γ) varies by atomic
species. For 1H it is 42.58. The b-value can be calculated as b = γ² G² δ² (Δ−δ/3). Adapted from
Szczepankiewicz, Filip115.
The first gradient pulse induces a position-dependent phase shift for all spins within
a voxel, and the second pulse restores the phase change. For stationary particles, the
second gradient perfectly rewinds the phase shift created by the first gradient and
the signal loss is minimal. This is the s cenario, for instance, in a densely packed
cellular environment with restricted diffusion. Conversely, in a tissue with relatively
free diffusion, water molecules move a c onsiderable distance during and between
the two gradients, and the phase is not rest ored, i.e., not rephased. This results in
signal attenuation that is proportional to the diffusivity of water molecules.
b-value
The b-value describes the strength of the diffusion weighting and is calculated from
the gradient amplitude, duration, and ti me between gradients. The most common
way to vary the b-value is by adjusting the gradient amplitude (figure 17).
51
Figure. 17
Pulse sequences with high (top) and low (bottom) b- value. In this case, modulated by changing the
amplitude of the diffusion gradient (G) and keeping the rest of the parameters unchanged. Adapted from
Filip Szczepankiewicz115.
A b-value of 0, indicates no gradient applie d, and the image is a fat-saturated T2-
weighted image, similar to magnetic re sonance cholangiopancreatography. Since
the movement of water molecules is restri cted in dense cellular tissues, the signal
loss will be less than the signal loss for water molecules in a tissue that allows more
mobility. Thus, the signal loss will be lower for dense cellular tissues at high b-
values compared to cell-poor tissues. However, it is important to note that there is
always some signal loss at high b-values, but its magnitude varies depending on the
extent of disruption caused by the gradient compared to the amount that has been
restored by the second gradient.
Quantification of apparent diffusion coefficient
Diffusion-weighted imaging can be used to quantify the apparent diffusion
coefficient (ADC). This is done by measuring the signal at multiple b-values and
fitting an exponential function to the signa l. This fit serves to estimate the non-
diffusion-weighted signal as well as the diffusivity. To visualise how this works, we
can plot the logarithm of the signal as a function of the b-value, in which the slope
of the line will represent the diffusivity (Fig 18).
52
Figure 18
The slope of the curve represents the diffusivity (D) or apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC). This
depends on how freely water molecules can move within the tissue. The maximum diffusivity at body
temperature is 3000 µm²/s, and values close to this may be present in urine. Normal tissue in the
prostate peripheral zone (PZ) ranges between 1300-1800 µm²/s, while a tumour in the PZ may have a
diffusivity of 500-1000 µm²/s.
T2 shine through
In a tissue with long T2 in a T2W image, such as a cyst, the signal may be relatively
high even at high b-values, despite the signal loss from diffusion gradients. One
might be misled into thinking that the hi gh signal indicates restricted diffusion. By
comparing the signal at high and low b-values and calculating the ADC, a cyst will
exhibit a high ADC, whereas a tumour would have a low ADC.
Which b-values should be used, and which should not
To calculate the ADC, a minimum of two unique b-values are required. To obtain
representative values, these points should be widely spaced, for example, at b=100
s/mm² and b=800 s/mm². Additional intermed iate b-values can be used, but they
extend the examination time.
At low b-values, approximately b < 200 s/mm², there is interference from the motion
of blood in the capillaries. The motion of capillary blood causes a fast reduction of
the signal which can be mistaken for fast diffusion or cause an overestimation of the
ADC. To avoid this, b-values less than 200 s/mm2 are not recommended. This
phenomenon is known as Intravoxe l Incoherent Motion (IVIM)
116 and can be
exploited in situations where perfusion estimation in a tissue is desired (figure 19A).
At higher b-values, the diffusion-weighted signal is largely suppressed, leaving
mostly noise in the signal. This noise is thereby relatively high compared to the
remaining true signal. As noise becomes mo re prominent compared to the signal,
the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) decreases, in other words, there is low precision in
the signal. Close to the noise floor, the accu racy of the signal deteriorates. A lower
53
SNR can affect the accuracy and reliab ility of ADC measurements, leading to
increased variability in the calculated ADC values. This positive signal bias leads
to an inaccurate, low ADC (figure 19b).
Figure 19
(A) The contribution of perfusion which gives an incorrect apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC) when
using a b-value of zero. (B)The bias of using a high b-value. Courtesy of Filip Szczepankiewicz.
The role of MRI in the diagnosis of prostate cancer
Prostate cancer exhibits a spectrum ranging from benign, asymptomatic, low-grade
tumours to highly aggressive ones. It is cr ucial, therefore, that diagnostic methods
can accurately identify the tumours. Over diagnosis of harmless tumours leads to
unnecessary anxiety, investigations, treat ments, and consequently, resource
wastage. On the other hand, underdiagnosis results in the failure to detect and treat
dangerous tumours in a timely manner. Therefore, diagnostic approaches need to be
as specific as possible. This contrasts w ith many other tumour types, where early
detection is generally beneficial.
In addition to previously discussed met hods, more complex analyses, such as the
Stockholm 3 test, have been introduced. This test combines biomarkers, genetic
factors, and clinical variables w ith the aim of increasing specificity
117. The
traditional diagnostic pathway involved PSA, DRE, and subsequent biopsies. This
approach led to both over- and under-diagnosis, especially as the ventral parts of the
prostate could not be adequately examin ed. A more modern approach is the MRI
pathway or MRI first strategy. In this a pproach, patients with suspected prostate
cancer, often based on symptoms or elevated PSA levels, undergo an initial MRI.
The results of this MRI, combined with other information, determine the subsequent
54
diagnostic pathway. The procedure, when presented in the PRECISION study 118
demonstrated the detection of more si gnificant tumours and fewer insignificant
tumours, with a reduction in the number of biopsies performed. Similar results were
reported in a Cochrane review in 2019119. The findings from these and several other
studies form the basis for current guidelines, both nationally and internationally,
such as EAU-ESUR
88, 120.
PI-RADS
The requirements for a structured assessment of prostate MRI have increased. A
structured system for the assessment and reporting of MRI has been developed by
the American College of Radiology (ACR). The Prostate Imaging – Reporting and
Data System (PI-RADS), first version, was published in 2012, and the latest version,
PI-RADS 2.1, was published in 2019111. The document provides detailed guidelines
on how the examination should be conducted, interpreted, and reported.
The assessment, resulting in a score between 1 and 5, indicates the likelihood of
clinically significant cancer, i.e., cancer that potentially requires treatment (table 2).
Table 2.
PI-RADS v.2.1 Assessment Categories111
PI-RADS score Likelihood Description
PI-RADS 1 Very low Clinically significant cancer is highly unlikely to be present
PI-RADS 2 Low Clinically significant cancer is unlikely to be present
PI-RADS 3 Intermediate The presence of clinically significant cancer is equivocal
PI-RADS 4 High Clinically significant cancer is likely to be present
PI-RADS 5 Very high Clinically significant cancer is highly likely to be present
Depending on whether the assessment pertains to a lesion in the PZ or TZ different
parameters are weighted differently. In the PZ, DWI/ADC is crucial, while T2-
weighted imaging is the most significant sequence in the TZ. The DWI/ADC scores
are described in table 3. The description of DWI/ADC is subjective, and terms like
‘hyperintense’ or ‘markedly hyperintense’ are used without further specification.
This poses the risk of individual and progressively shifting assessments.
55
Table 3
The role of DWI/ADC in the interpretation of Prostate MRI, ver. PI-RADS 2.1111
Score Description
1 No abnormality (i.e., normal) on ADC and high b-value DWI
2 Linear/wedge-shaped hypointense on ADC and/or linear/wedge-shaped
hyperintense on high b-value DWI
3 Focal (discrete and different from the background) hypointense on ADC and/or focal
hyperintense on high b-value DWI; may be markedly hypointense on ADC or
markedly hyperintense on high b-value DWI, but not both.
4 Focal markedly hypointense on ADC and markedly hyperintense on high b-value
DWI; <1.5cm in greatest dimension
5 Same as 4 but ≥1.5cm in greatest dimension or definite extraprostatic
extension/invasive behaviour
ADC threshold and ADC ratio
Based on knowledge of diffusion and ADC, it is understood that cell-dense tissues
exhibit lower ADC values. Often, a more malignant tumour is denser in cellular
composition than a less malignant one. This relationship is utilised in various
contexts. In studies on liver metastases befo re and after neoadjuvant therapy, an
increase in ADC value is considered a sign of tumour response. Cui et al. found a
relationship between tumor response by size with increase in ADC121 and Donati et
al. found a linear correlation between tumour regression grade and ADC 122.
However, in a multicenter study, Eriksson et al. did not find any significant
correlation between TRG and ADC
123.
In prostate diagnostics, ADC values are employed to differentiate between PI-
RADS 3 and PI-RADS 4/5. Many radiologists have developed an intuitive sense for
when a value is pathological on their scanner.
Several studies in the field have attemp ted to identify a threshold value, and
although consensus is lacking, ACR in PI-RADS version 2.1 suggests 750-900
µm²/sec for lesions in the PZ. It is noted, however, that there is a significant overlap
with other conditions. In a review base d on 1633 patients, the pooled mean was
1100 µm²/sec for Gleason 5 and 6 (ISUP 1) and 860 µm²/sec for Gleason ≥7. They
proposed 750 µm²/sec as a threshold for significant cancer124.
Several technical factors influence the ADC value, such as the b-values used, the
Method
for calculating ADC, scanner field strength, and patient characteristics 125.
When examining images from different cen tres, it is evident that ADC varies
considerably between different scanners and hospitals. However, a Danish study on
ADC values in phantoms on different scanners showed robust ADC values126.
In an attempt to normalise potential differences between various conditions that might
affect the ADC value, different types of ratios have been used. Calculating the ratio
of ADC values between lesions and adjacent tissues could yield a more comparable
value. Several studies suggest that this is better than absolute ADC values, while
56
others show the opposite. However, Woo et al. suggest that errors are added rather
than normalised127. For example, they state that even healthy prostate tissue can vary
among individuals, especially due to age, and hence, is an unreliable dominator in the
equation. DeCobelli et al. are on a similar track, suggesting that seemingly healthy
prostate tissue may be influenced by tumour infiltration and fibrosis128.
In Paper III of this thesis, we investigate these relationships in a study that includes
MRI scanners from different vendors, diffe rent field strengths, and different
protocols125.
PSA density and prostate volume
The PSA level in blood is proportional to the volume of the prostate. A benign
enlarged prostate produces more PSA than a benign small prostate. Hence, an
elevated PSA does not always mean malignancy. To overcome this, the PSA density
(PSAD) is used. It is calculated as a ra tio between PSA (µg/l) and the prostate
volume (mm
3)88, 129 . Different cut-offs are used, usually 0.10 or 0.15 ng/mL 2. A
higher value raises the suspicion of cancer.
The volume of the prostate can be obtai ned by different methods. From TRUS or
MRI three orthogonal diameters can be measured. The ellipsoid formula is
calculated by multiplication of length x width x depth x π/6. This method comes
with a high degree of variation. It is cha llenging to find the correct positions of the
measurements, especially in the apex wh ich can be difficult to delineate. The
Method
does not consider an asymmetry of the gland and there is no consensus on
how to include the median lobe in volum e. A more accurate but much more time-
consuming method is manual planimetry (segmentation), used primarily for
radiotherapy planning and for targeted fusion biopsies
130. The border of the prostate
is delineated on transverse MRI images, every 3-5 mm. Software reformats the areas
to a 3D volume (figure 20). In recent year s, more automated AI-assisted software
has become available for the purpose. Pape r IV in this thesis evaluates a deep
learning-based system for volume assessment of prostate volume on MRI131.
Fig 20.
The borders of the prostate are contoured manually on axial images (blue), in this case, a suspicious
tumour is also contoured (turquoise). The software builds a coronal and a sagittal as well as a 3D
reconstruction (not shown). These can be used for targeted fusion biopsies. The volume is also presented
by the software. Image courtesy of Kjartan Thorarinsson, Skåne University Hospital, Malmö, Sweden.
57
Artificial intelligence and prostate
MRI
Artificial means not natural, i.e., it is not biological. A fundamental aspect of
intelligence is the ability to learn from experience and thereby develop one’s
thinking. In essence, AI is a constructed system that takes in information, identifies
it, makes decisions, and learns from experience.
A way to visualise the mutual relationship and hierarchy of different fields of AI is
presented in figure 21 and will be discussed further in this chapter.
A typical computer program processes information based on rules programmed by
humans. A regular computer program solves the task but does not gain experience.
AI constructs its own rules based on the information it handles and can improve its
Results
by adjusting the rules. This is achieved through machine learning.
Previously, different systems were specific to each task, but this is changing with
neural networks. A distinction arises when AI can transfer knowledge from one task
to another.
Figure 21
The relationship of the main concepts in AI. Source: Author.
58
Machine learning
Machine learning is divided into three ma in categories: supervised, unsupervised
and reinforcement learning 132. Supervised learning is the most common type in
medical imaging research, humans act as guides, teaching the algorithm what
Conclusions
it should reach. Data needs to be labelled with ground truth from human
experts. Unsupervised learning is what one might call classical AI. The concept
relates to computer learning on its own without human guidance. An example of
this is generative learning. The third category, reinforcement learning involves the
system learning through feedback from hum ans, with correct conclusions being
reinforced while incorrect ones are suppressed
130, 133.
Neural network
The old self-regulating AI systems were long considered superior to neural
networks, and it was believed that the idea of networks worked best in theory.
However, thanks to new algorithms, larg er volumes of training data, and more
computational power, neural networks have taken the lead. Just like the neurons in
the brain, the smallest components of the neural network handle a simple function,
but when interconnected with billions of other neurons, it can manage highly
complex tasks. Neural networks, like othe r AI systems, create their own rules
through machine learning. What is revolutionary about neural networks is not only
their ability to handle even more complex information than previous AI systems but
also that the same system can be trained for various tasks.
A neural network consists of three layers : an input layer, a hidden layer, and an
output layer. A deep neural network consis ts of two or more hidden layers (figure
22). The more layers, the higher the capab ility to handle complex tasks. A neural
network is usually referred to as a black box; we observe how information flows,
but we do not comprehend what is happe ning inside the box. However, we can
discern the relationship between the information the network receives and what it
produces. A common application of deep ne ural networks is pattern recognition,
employed, for example, in radiology. The key to the system’s high performance is
its ability to break down complex patterns into a series of simpler patterns.
59
Figure. 22
A deep neural network consists of two or more hidden layers. The more layers, the higher the ability to
handle complex tasks. Source: Author.
AI in radiology
In radiology and deep learning, primar ily two types of networks are used:
Convolutional neural networks (CNN) and generative adversarial networks (GAN)
(figure 21). The structures of the two are different, and so are their applications. To
some extent, they go hand in hand. GAN c onsists of two neural networks that can
be based on different architectures. Understanding the nuanced differences between
CNNs and GANs is crucial for leveraging th eir combined potential effectively in
radiology applications.
Convolutional neural networks
Convolution is a mathematical operation that involves combining two functions to
create a third. In this context, it means a pplying filters on the input data to extract
various patterns from the image or data. Th ese filters are used to identify features
that may be useful for solving the current problem, such as edges, shapes, or textures
in an image. Examples of applications include image classification, object detection,
and segmentation.
Analysing an MRI image of the prostate to assign a PI-RADS score is a step-by-
step process that is a typical application for CNNs, as described in figure 23. The
process involves, in brief, preprocessing the images from the MRI scanner (orange
part) so that desired images are available and spatially consistent with each other.
This step also includes segmenting the pr ostate from the rest of the image. The
segmented area then undergoes further analysis. Next, processing occurs in the CNN
(turquoise part). First, a candidate heatma p is generated, representing what the
60
network perceives as abnormal, which may also include false positive changes. This
can serve as initial guidance for the radiologist to identify potential pathology areas.
Then, in the subsequent step, a sub-vol ume-based false positive reduction network
operates by eliminating false positives. Fi nally, another sub-volume-based scoring
network assigns the PI-RADS categories.
Figure 23.
The workflow from image acquisition to generated report. Adapted from Siemens Healthcare134.
61
Generative adversarial networks
GAN consists of two neural networks that are trained by competing against each
other. In radiology, GAN is used for various purposes, including image
enhancement, such as improving contrast or reducing noise in images. Thanks to
GAN, lower radiation doses can be used in CT scans, and MRI scan times can be
shortened. GAN can also generate images that can be used to train CNNs.
GAN consists of two components, or neural networks: a generator, which generates
an image that resembles a real image, and a discriminator, which receives images
from the generator as well as real images from reality. The generator aims to create
as realistic images as possible to deceive th e discriminator, which in turn strives to
become better and better by learning to classify each image as either real or created
by the generator. During training, the two networks compete against each other
(adversarial) and thus push each other to improve. Eventually, when GAN has been
trained for a sufficient period, the generator can produce data that is so realistic that
it is difficult to distinguish it from real data
135. This process can be likened to a
counterfeiting operation becoming more sk illed as the police become better at
distinguishing counterfeit bills from genuine ones.
Training and validation of machine learning
For AI to perform well, neural networks mu st be trained for specific tasks. During
training, the CNN model is fed with a large number of examples of data along with
their corresponding labels or classifications. The model adjusts its internal
parameters gradually. The more varied a nd representative training data used, the
better the model becomes at generalising and handling new, unseen data correctly.
Training data should be representative of th e conditions the model is expected to
encounter during usage, and it is important that it covers the relevant domain for the
problem the model is intended to solve. If the training data lacks diversity of
examples, the algorithm may become biased.
Developers of AI algorithms therefore st rive to obtain quality-controlled datasets,
which can be obtained from medical databases, open datasets, or through
collaboration with clinical institutions. Wh en validating an algorithm, it is crucial
that the training data is separated from the t est data. Otherwise, there is a risk that
the algorithm will “memorise” the specific t est cases, leading to an overestimation
of its performance.
Most commercial AI models are locked once they have been trained by the
developer and reach the market, but some models use continuous feedback systems
to continually improve. This can occur through user feedback, but also through the
integration of various databases such as patient records and treatment summaries.
62
Before AI models reach the market, it is crucial that they undergo validation. This
can be done in various ways. Commonly, studies compare them with previously
unseen data to investigate whether their performance allows for generalizability
across new data and different populations.
To perform validation of an AI model, access to ground truth or a reference standard,
also known as a gold standard, is essential. This ground truth or gold standard
represents the most reliable and accurate in formation about what the AI model is
trying to predict or identify.
In the case of medical image analysis, such as MRI prostate diagnostics, the gold
standard could be an expert assessment by a radiologist. This expert evaluation is
considered the “truth” against which the model is compared during validation.
Certification
Software that may impact patient outcomes is considered a medical device and
needs to conform to certain safety standard s. The CE mark indicates conformity to
those standards and allows the sale and clinical use of the product within Europe.
There are different classes from low risk (class I) to high risk (class III), i.e. the
same classes as for other medical devices, e.g. embolisation materials. Class I can
be obtained through self-certifications whereas class II requires an external audit by
a notified body. Since May 2021 the MDR have come into effect and have replaced
the former Medical Devices Directive (MDD). Products marked under the former
MDD may be sold until May 2024, if not expired or major changes have been made
to the product. Software for clinical use is classified by the FDA in a similar manner;
most software for medical devices is cl ass IIb according to the MDR and class II
according to the FDA
136.
Leeuwen et al. have listed all commercially available software products for medical
imaging in a database 136, 137 . For every software product, the scientific papers
evaluating the algorithm are listed. Every paper is scored based on the Fryback and
Thornbury Efficacy table (model of efficacy) 138. A paper which is scored grade I
demonstrates the technical efficacy, wh ich basically demonstrates whether the
software product does what it is supposed to do. The highest grade is 6 and is given
to a paper that demonstrates that the software product has an impact on society with
economic analysis. Papers given a score of 5 demonstrate the software’s impact on
patient outcomes (table 4).
63
Table 4
Hierarchical model of efficacy to assess the contribution of AI software to the diagnostic imaging process,
adapted from Fryback and Thornbury (1991)136, 138
Explanation Typical measures
Level 1t Technical efficacy Repr oducibility, inter software agreement,
error rate
Level 1c Potential clinical efficacy Co rrelation to alternative methods, potential
predictive value
Level 2 Diagnostic accuracy efficacy St andalone sensitivity, specificity, AUC
(ROC), Dice score
Level 3 Diagnostic thinking efficacy Radi ologist performance with/without AI,
change in judgement
Level 4 Therapeutic efficacy Effect on treatment or follow-up examinations
Level 5 Patient outcome efficacy Effe ct on QoL, morbidity, or survival
Level 6 Societal efficacy Effect on costs and quality-adjusted life years.
To date, six AI software products for prostate MRI have been CE marked and three
are FDA-approved. No software product has been subject to published peer-
reviewed papers showing a level of efficacy more than grade 4 (Table 5). In 2021,
the level of efficacy for 239 peer-reviewed publications for the 100 CE marked AI
software products of the entire field of ra diology only found four papers showing
efficacy level 6 and nine publications of level 5. The latter were all conducted on
the same software for cardiac imaging. Less than half of the publications were made
independent from the vendors and almost a ll were retrospective in study design.
More than two-thirds of the publications were single-centre studies.
Table 5
The six current CE- and FDA-approved AI software products for prostate MRI. The total number of peer-
reviewed papers for each software product and their level of efficacy137. (*) Refers to paper IV in this thesis.
Vendor
CE
(MDR) FDA
Peer-reviewed
papers
Efficacy (evidence) level
1 t/c 2 3 4 5 6
Deephealth
(Saige prostate)
IIb II 4 1 2 1
JLK Inc (JPC-
01K)
I
(MDD)
- 0
Lucida Medical
(Prostate
Intelligence)
IIb - 0
Mediaire
(medprostate)
IIb - 0
Quibim (QP-
Prostate)
IIb II 1 1
Siemens
Healthineers (AI-
Rad companion
prostate)
IIb II 3 1 2*
64
Material and methods
Statistical methods used in the papers.
Chi-2 test and Fisher’s exact test
The chi-square test or Fisher’s exact test can be used to determine whether there is
a significant association between categorical variables. The latter is particularly
useful when the sample size is small and the assumptions required for the chi-square
test are not met (e.g., expected cell freque ncies are less than five). In paper II,
Fisher’s exact test was used for evalua ting whether recanalisation occurred or not
for the two different spheres
139.
T-test
A t-test is used to determine if there is a significant difference between the means
of two groups. The data should be normally distributed, especially for a small
sample size, with fewer than 30 observations per group. An independent samples t-
test is used to determine if the means of two independent groups differ from each
other, for example, to find if the weight loss is different in two groups that had
different treatments. A paired samples t-test is used on one group tested twice. For
example, if there is weight loss before and after a treatment. The t-test provides a p-
value. If the p-value is less than a chosen significance level (commonly 0.05), then
the null hypothesis is rejected, suggesti ng that there is a significant difference
between the groups. Independent and paired T-tests are used in paper II to evaluate
the differences between the groups. A paired t-test was used in paper IV to compare
the mean differences between measu rements made by experienced and
inexperienced radiologists.
Spearman’s rank correlation coefficient
Spearman’s rank correlation coefficient (denoted by ρ or rs) quantifies the strength
of association between two variables. The Spearman correlation is utilised for
nonparametric variables that may not vary linearly with each other, whereas a
similar test, Pearson correlation, is used for two continuous variables that vary
linearly with each other. Spearman, which employs a ranking of variables, is thus
65
less sensitive to outliers. Spearman is more suitable for ordinal data (i.e., ordinal
variables like Gleason Score or PI-RADS). The coefficient is reported between -1
and 1, where -1 and 1 indicate perfect co rrelation, while 0 signifies a completely
random distribution with no correlation between variables. Negative values indicate
an inverse correlation. In paper 3, this method was employed to assess the
correlation between ISUP grading groups and ADC metrics.
ICC
The Intraclass Correlation Coefficient (ICC) is a statistical metric utilised to
evaluate the consistency or reliability of measurements taken by multiple raters. It
assesses the level of agreement among di fferent raters or between repeated
measurements by the same rater. ICC prov es particularly valuable when dealing
with continuous or ordinal data. Its valu es range from 0 to 1, with higher values
indicating stronger agreement or reliability among raters. Interpretation of ICC
values can vary depending on the study’s context; however, typically, values above
0.75 are deemed excellent, values falling between 0.40 and 0.75 denote fair to good
agreement, and values below 0.40 suggest poor agreement (Koo, 2016). ICC serves
for assessing interrater reliability, which re presents the variation between two or
more raters conducting the same measuremen ts. Moreover, different types of ICC
exist, such as test-retest reliability and intra-rater reliability. There are
approximately ten different methods to co mpute ICC, contingent upon the type of
data and the number of raters involved.
In summary, ICC is employed to evaluate interrater reliability (ranging from 0 to 1)
and should not be confused with Spear man’s Rank Correlation Coefficient (for
nonparametric variables) and Pearson’s Correlation Coefficient (for parametric
variables), both of which quantify the associ ation between variables (-1 to +1). In
paper 3, ICC was used to assess interrater reliability for ADC values, while in paper
4, it was employed for evaluating prostate volume using the ellipsoid formula.
Bland-Altman plot
A Bland-Altman plot, like ICC, is us ed to assess the agreement between two
measurements or methods. While ICC gi ves a value for the agreement, Bland-
Altman gives a graphical visualisation of the agreement (figure 24). It is a graphical
Method
that plots the difference between the two measurements against their mean
value. A central line represents the mean of the differences between the two
measurements and thus indicates if there is any systematic error (bias) between
them. If the line lies close to or on zero, it indicates that there is little to no systematic
difference between the measurements. Ofte n, 95% limits of agreement (average
difference ± 1.95 standard deviations of the difference) are provided as upper and
lower horizontal lines. These are also referred to as lines of critical difference.
66
A symmetrical spread near the central line suggests good agreement, while values
far from the central line indicate poorer agreement. Values that tend to deviate more
from the central line as they increase suggest that measurement error increases with
larger values.
In papers 3 and 4, Bland- Altman plots are utilised to visualise measurements of
ADC and prostate volume between readers or methods.
Figure 24.
Bland-Altman plot. The black horizontal line is the mean of differences (central line) which is close to
the zero line (black dotted line), hence there is no systematic error. Measurements between the blue
lines are within 98% CI. The values of the three lines are noted in the square. Source: Author.
Receiver operating characteristic curves
A receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve is a graphical plot illustrating the
diagnostic ability of a binary classification system as its discrimination threshold is
varied. It is commonly used in binary cl assification to evaluate the performance of
a classifier by plotting the true positive rate (sensitivity) against the false positive
rate (1 – specificity) at different threshold values (figure 25).
Put simply, the ROC curve shows how well a test can determine whether a patient
has a disease (e.g., clinically significant prostate cancer) or not. A perfect test would
have an ROC curve passing through the upper left corner, indicating high sensitivity
(true positive rate) and a low false positive rate across all threshold values.
Conversely, a test with no ability to distinguish between diseased and healthy
individuals would have an ROC curve resembling the diagonal line (45-degree line),
indicating random guessing.
67
The area under the ROC curve (AUC) is often used as a summary measure of a test's
performance, where values closer to 1 indicate better performance and values
around 0.5 indicate performance no better than random guessing (figure 25).
Figure. 25.
Example of a receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve. The curve plots the true positive rate
against the false positive rate at each threshold setting. The area under the curve (AUC) is a measure
of test performance. A value closer to 1 indicates better performance and a value around 0.5 indicates
performance no better than chance. Source: Author.
ROC curves were used in paper 3 to ev aluate how well ADC metrics performed in
distinguishing between clinically significant and insignificant prostate cancer.
Cohorts and study design
Paper I
The study was a feasibility study. Seven adu lt Texel female sheep were used. The
ewes were aged five to six years, and a ll had previous pregnancies. They were
housed under strict conditions according to regulations for animals in research.
Unilateral embolisation of the uterine artery was performed, and a follow-up
angiography was done at different time intervals (0-65 hours later) for each animal
followed by euthanisation. The degree of occlusion and recanalisation was assigned
a number between 0-4 according to an adapted Emboscore (table 6).
68
Paper II
The study was a blinded randomised controlled trial (RCT). Twenty-two Texel
female sheep were used. They were aged 4-6 years and had a history of pregnancies.
Body weight was 54 to 82 kg. They were divided into a study group and a control
group. They were housed under conditions regulated by the authorities and had a
free supply of food and water. The experimental animals were under the supervision
of laboratory animal caretakers and a ve terinarian. Between the two interventions
they returned to the nearby pen. Before th e radiological interventions started, the
ewes were artificially cycled. On day -15, 20 mg flugestone acetate (Chronogest®)
sponge was inserted into the vagina. The animals were transferred to the laboratory
on day -3. On day -1, 500 IE gonadotropin (Folligon®) was administered with an
intramuscular injection.
All radiological procedures were performed under general anaesthesia.
On day 0 angiography followed by unilate ral embolisation of the uterus was
performed. None of the interventionists or other present staff knew if the study
sphere or control sphere had been used . The two different spheres had the same
macroscopic appearance. On day 14 an other angiography was performed, and the
degree of recanalisation was assessed by Em boscore. Thereafter, the animals were
euthanised and different organs were collected and fixed in formalin for
macroscopic and histopathological analyses which were performed by a pathologist,
certified by the European College of Veterinary Pathology. The euthanasia was
performed while the animals were still under anaesthesia with an overdose of iv
pentobarbital.
Papers III and IV
Both studies were retrospective multicentr e studies. The cohort consisted of men
that underwent Robot-Assisted Laparosc opic Prostatectomy (RALP) in Malmö,
Sweden, in 2018 with an MRI of the prostate within one year prior to the surgery
(figure 26).
69
Figure 26.
Cohorts for papers III and IV. Source: Author.
In paper III the largest tumour per patient was selected and designated as the index
tumour. ADC measurements were perfo rmed of the index tumour, of the
corresponding contralateral region, of the normal PZ, and of the urine by two
experienced radiologists independently (figure 27).
70
Figure 27
Tumour map from a pathology specimen and placement of ROIs in the ADC map from Paper III. (A)
Tumour map with a large tumour in the right peripheral zone (blue border) with a 37 mm extraprostatic
extension (red line). (B), Circular ROI in the tumour and in contralateral non-tumorous tissue. (C),
Circular ROI drawn in non-tumorous PZ and (D), circular ROI in the urinary bladder. Source. Author125
In paper IV the volume of the prostate was measured with eight different methods,
of which two were used as reference standards: manual planimetry by an
experienced radiologist on MRI (MPE) and weight volume of the surgically
removed specimen (SW). The other six me thods used were ellipsoid formula
performed by two radiologists on MRI ( EF1, EF2) and by a urologist on TRUS
(TRUS), by inexperienced radiologist MRI planimetry (MPU), by ellipsoid formula
on the surgically removed specimen (SD) and finally by an AI model on MRI (DL).
The AI model was a proprietary available product (AI-Rad Companion Prostate MR
VVA20A_HF02, Siemens Healthcare AG). The algorithm had not previously been
exposed on the dataset.
71
Ethics
Approvals
Papers 1 and 2
The experiments were approved by the Animal Ethics Committee in Lund/Malmö
with reference number M339-12.
The study was conducted in compliance with the principles of Good Laboratory
Practice Standards as outlined in the OECD Principles of Good Laboratory Practice
(as revised in 1997), ENV/MC/CHEM(1998)17 (OECD 1998). This study complied
with all applicable sections of the Act a nd the associated Codes of Practice for the
Housing and Care of Animals used in Scientific Procedures and the Humane Killing
of Animals under Schedule 1 of the Act, issued under section 21 of the Act140.
The number of animals used was the minimu m consistent with scientific integrity
and regulatory acceptability. Consideration was given to the welfare of individual
animals in terms of the number and extent of procedures carried out on each animal.
The rationale for using sheep as a research animal is twofold. Firstly, the vascular
anatomy of the uterus is similar to that in humans
53. Secondly, the blood level of α-
amylase, which degrades the degradable st arch microsphere (DSM), is similar to
that in humans. Additionally, the sheep ut erus is bicornuate, meaning that its
contralateral side is not affected by the embolisation and can therefore be used as a
reference.
Papers 3 and 4
The local ethics review committee at Lund University approved the studies in Papers
I-III (entry no. 2014-886). The Swedish Et hical Review Authority approved an
addendum for Papers I-III (entry no. 2019-0 3674) and also approved the study in
Paper IV (2020-03923 and 2021-06647-02).
Research on animals
In Sweden, animal experiments are primarily regulated by the Animal Welfare Act
(Djurskyddslagen) and the Animal Welfare Ordinance (Djurskyddsförordningen)141.
These laws establish guidelines for the use of animals in research and experiments
to ensure their welfare a nd minimise suffering. In addition, there are ethical
principles and guidelines that researchers must follow when applying for permits to
conduct animal experiments.
72
3R
The 3R concept was introduced by William Russell and Rex Burch in 1957 142.
Today, the 3R principles are embodied in both Swedish and European legislation
for using animals in research. Consequently, anyone who uses animals for scientific
purposes must implement the 3Rs in their work. The 3R stands for Replace, Reduce,
and Refine.
Replace refers to experiments that can replace live animals with alternative methods
that do not involve using live animals, such as computer modelling, artificial organs,
or cell cultures.
Reduce refers to experiments where the same knowledge and quality of data can be
achieved by using fewer research animals than before. It can also mean obtaining
more information from the same animal without increasing their suffering.
Refine means ensuring laboratory animals experience as little pain, suffering,
discomfort, and anxiety as possible compared to previous similar studies. Refine
also implies improving animal welfare and providing laboratory animals with a
better quality of life through measures such as enriched environment and larger
spaces.
Ethical aspects of the studies
In papers I and II we applied all three 3R aspects. Alternatives to animal studies
were considered, however, no other way to answer the endpoints was found. The
number of animals needed for achieving a useful result was also taken into
consideration; a smaller number would likely have led to non-significant results. A
larger number would have been unnecessary for the stated endpoints. As far as we
could see, the animals did not suffer durin g the trial and all interventions were
performed to minimise suffering. It is however an undeniable fact that the trial was
performed at the cost of the life of the sheep. Unfortunately, as far as we know, the
development of this sphere did not proc eed beyond our two studies. This might be
considered as a failure and as indicating potentially unnecessary use and suffering
of the animals. However, the knowledge gained from the studies will contribute to
the research field.
Both papers III and IV were retrospective cohort studies. Participants were offered
the opportunity of opting out, which one man did. All patient data were protected
and anonymised during the whole process and no individual data was pointed out,
nor did we find any incidental findings or other concerning findings in the images.
AI in general and in medical imaging in particular requires several ethical
considerations. The complexity of AI models, such as deep learning networks, often
hinders the interpretability of their decision-making processes. This lack of
transparency poses challenges for both patients and clinicians in understanding how
73
the AI arrives at a particular diagnosis or treatment recommendation. Establishing
Methods
to make AI systems more in terpretable and providing transparent
explanations for their outputs is crucia l to gain trust and acceptance from the
medical community. Privacy and data secur ity also raise ethical dilemmas in the
context of AI in prostate MRI. Patient data used for training AI algorithms must be
anonymised and adequately protected to maintain confidentiality. Additionally,
obtaining informed consent from patients fo r the use of their data is essential.
Furthermore, the impact of AI on the role of healthcare professionals requires
careful consideration. While AI can assi st radiologists in detecting abnormalities
and making accurate diagnoses, there is concern about the potential displacement of
radiologists’ expertise and the loss of the human touch in patient care. Ensuring that
AI is used as a supportive tool, augmen ting healthcare professionals’ skills rather
than replacing them, is important. The im pact of the AI-delivered output on the
radiologist is not negligible, this is cal led automation bias and must be taken into
consideration when developing a workflow which combines machine learning with
manual assessment. By proactively addr essing these issues, we can harness the
potential of AI to improve diagnostic accuracy and patient outcomes while
upholding ethical principles and standards in healthcare.
In the context of using AI algorithms for objective data analysis, such as
segmentation for volume assessment, the dow nsides are negligible, and the time
saved for the radiologist is of great value.
74
Results
Paper I
Seven sheep were included in the study. However, the first sheep died during the
Introduction
of anaesthesia, and the second could not undergo embolisation due to
an intimal dissection of the uterine arte ry. The remaining five ewes successfully
underwent embolisation with DSM 500-70 0µm and achieved a post-embolisation
Emboscore of 3, which was in line with the intended intervention (figure 28A, B).
Table 6.
Emboscore, adapted from Stampfl et al.143
Emboscore Description
0 No angiographically visible signs of occlusion
1 Reduction of parenchymal staini ng of the dependent territory
2 Reduction of parenchymal staining and occlusion of the supplying artery
3 Reduction of parenchymal staining and occlusion of the supplying artery and
occlusion of the feeding artery downstream of the catheter-tip
4 Overembolization (embolizat ion of the adjacent branches)
During the observation period, no signs of malaise or discomfort were noted.
Follow-up angiography (figure 28C) was performed at 19, 20, 28, 49, and 65 hours.
Partial recanalisation was noted in three of the animals. Spheres were found at the
intended locations along with vasculitis and inflammation and necrosis of the target
organs (figure 29B). The DSM showed different stages of degradation (figure 29A),
but no conclusion could be made regarding degradation time in vivo.
75
Figure 28
Angiogram before (A), immediately after embolisation (B) and at follow-up (C). Emboscore 3, hence no
recanalisation. Source: Author. Reprinted with permission from Acta Radiologica, Sage Publications
Inc10.
Figure 29.
Histopathological specimen, haematoxylin and eosin stain. (A) shows a partly degraded DSM
(degradable starch microsphere) (arrow) in the artery lumen. Surrounding necrotising inflammation with
presence of neutrophils. (B) Endometrium of the embolised side 65 hours post-intervention. Severe
oedema in the interstitial tissue (black arrow) and the uterine glands are necrotic (white arrow). Source:
Author. Reprinted with permission from Acta Radiologica, Sage Publications Inc10.
No histological changes were found in other examined organs (ovaries, liver kidney,
spleen, and skeletal muscle). However, PAS-positive material was found in the
Kupffer cells of the liver and macrophages in the red pulp of the spleen in all
animals, except for the one that could not be embolised.
Macroscopic evaluation revealed swelling and discolouration on the embolised side,
but not on the contralateral side (fig 30) . The ovaries were not affected on either
side. A small battery of blood samples was collected before and after embolisation,
as well as before follow-up. A significant ri se in aspartate aminotransferase levels
was noted, with a somewhat less pronounced increase in alanine aminotransferase.
76
Figure 30.
Macroscopic photo of the uterus (A); note that the embolised side (*) is swollen and reddish. (B)
Transverse pieces of the right and left uterine horn of the same uterus show bleeding in the lumen and
swelling of the tissue. Source: Author. Reprinted with permission from Acta Radiologica, Sage
Publications Inc10.
Conclusion
The study proves that embolisation can be performed with the new DSM and that
degradation occurs in vivo. This allows for recanalisation and possible restoration
of blood flow to the target organ.
Paper II
Eleven ewes were successfully embolised with the study sphere (DSM) and 11 with
the control sphere (TGMS) until complete stasis was achieved, in keeping with
Emboscore 3. No difference in procedure time, volume of spheres, or adverse events
between the groups was noted. Follow -up angiography after two weeks was
successful in all animals and showed recana lisation in nine of 11 animals in the
DSM group and in two of 11 in the TGMS group (figure 31).
77
Figure 31.
Digital subtraction angiography of one sheep in each group with evidence of recanalisation in the
degradable starch microsphere (DSM) specimen (c) but not in the trisacryl gelatine microspheres
(TGMS) (f) at follow-up. Source: Author. Reprinted with permission from Acta Radiologica, Sage
Publications Inc144.
On postmortem palpation during surgical removal of organs, the uterine arteries
were hard and enlarged on the embolised side in the TGMS group (figure 32 a,b).
In contrast, they were smooth and had a similar appearance compared to the
contralateral side in 10 of 11 animals in the DSM group (figure 32 c,d).
Histopathological examination revealed degraded spheres in two out of 11 animals
in the DSM group, while intact spheres were found in all animals in the TGMS
group. Peripheral vascular changes were more pronounced in the TGMS group but
were also present in both groups. In the TGMS group, the changes were
characterised by chronic, foreign body type inflammation centred around the
spheres, resulting in complete obstruction of the lumen. In the DSM group, the
inflammation was mild to moderate, and sub-intimal loose connective tissue caused
a mild narrowing of the lumen.
78
Figure 32.
(a, b). Uterus from ewe in the trisacryl gelatine microspheres group and (c, d) from the degradable
starch microsphere group. No macroscopical differences were noted between the two. However, the
uterine arteries were indurated in the TGMS group and spheres were visible. Source: Author. Reprinted
with permission from Acta Radiologica, Sage Publications Inc144.
The reactions in the endometrium were si milar in both groups with fibrosis and
endometrial atrophy, which were not found on the non-embolised side.
A large battery of blood samples was collected, and only AST and ALT showed
changes 24 hours after embolisation. However, there was no difference between the
groups. At follow-up, all tests were back to normal. It is worth mentioning that the
mean weight loss in the DSM group was 2.9 kg, compared to 1.5 kg in the TGMS
group during the two-week period. However, this difference was not significant. No
signs of discomfort were noted apart from this.
79
Statistics
The statistics reported in the original paper were limited and some additional
analyses follow.
The number of recanalised objects in the tw o different groups (t wo of 11 in the
TGMS group and nine of 11 in the DSM gr oup) were analysed with Fisher´s exact
test. There was a significant difference between the groups (p<0.01).
The weight loss in the DSM group of 2.9 kg was statistically significant (p<0.05)
but not the weight loss of 1.5 kg in the TGMS group. The mean weight loss between
the groups was not statistically significan t. These analyses were performed with t-
tests.
There was no difference in the volume of spheres needed to achieve complete statis
of the uterine arteries between the groups . Nor were there any differences in the
clinical chemistry blood samples.
The number of research objects needed to get significant power was estimated to be
ten in each group. There was one spare obj ect in each group in case of a failed
intervention. A smaller number, for example six objects in each group, would have
been too small to find a significant difference between the two groups if one object
differed from the other five in the group. Hence the estimation of 22 animals was
reasonable.
Conclusion
Embolisation with DSM achieved similar tissue effects as TGMS in the target organ;
however, it resulted in less vascular inflammation and a higher degree of
recanalisation. There was no difference in adverse events.
Paper III
The cohort consisted of 98 men who ha d undergone RALP with an MRI of the
prostate one year prior to the surgery. All men had PCa, ISUP 2 or higher. The
agreement in the ADC measurements betw een the two radiologists was nearly
perfect, with an ICC of 0.8 for the tumour, 0.82 for the contralateral region, 0.96 for
urine, and substantial for the normal PZ, ICC = 0.75. The measurements were
visualised in a Bland-Altman plot, and no systematic errors were detected.
The majority (69.4%) of the index tum ours were located in the PZ, while the
remaining (30.6%) were in the TZ. 61.2% of the patients were examined using a 3T
scanner, and the remaining 38.8% were exam ined using a 1.5T scanner. A total of
eight different scanners were utilised.
80
The mean value of ADC for malignancy was significantly lower than that for
healthy prostate tissue. However, no co rrelation was observed between absolute
ADC values or different ADC ratios (A DC of tumour relative to healthy
contralateral area, healthy PZ, or urine) in relation to ISUP grade. Additionally, no
correlation was found based on localisation in the PZ or TZ, or examination at 1.5T
or 3T. This is visualised in a box-and-whisker plot, Fig 33. In an ROC curve, an
AUC close to 0.5 was noted for the method’s ability to distinguish ISUP 2 from
ISUP 3-5, suggesting it is no better than chance.
Figure 33
Box-and-whisker plots of apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC) metrics for tumours stratified by ISUP
grade. (*) Normal represents the absolute ADC value of the normal-appearing tissue in the
contralateral position of the index lesion. Source: Author125
Conclusion
In contrast to previous research in the field, we found no correlation between ADC
metrics and ISUP grade in this multicen tre, multi-scanner retrospective study.
However, the agreement between read ers regarding ADC values was good to
excellent.
81
Paper IV
The initial cohort was the same as in paper 3. However, due to other requirements,
the number of excluded patients was smalle r (figure 26) The final cohort consisted
of 124 patients who had undergone RALP with an MRI of the prostate within one
year prior to the surgery. The same eight scanners described in paper III were used.
Compared to SW as the reference standa rd, the mean difference and limits of
agreement were lower for DL than for EF1 and EF2, indicating higher accuracy for
DL (figure 34). There was a tendency for DL and EF to underestimate the volume
of large prostate volumes (figure 34). The ICC between the EF1 and EF2 was
excellent (0.95).
Figure 34.
Bland-Altman plots comparing (a) expert manual planimetry (MPE) as reference standard with Deep
learning (DL) and MRI Ellipsoid formula (EF1 and EF2). In (b) the volume based on specimen weight
(SW) serves as a reference standard and is compared to the same methods as in (a), DL, EF1 and
EF2. The dotted blue line is the zero line, and the solid lines show the mean difference for each pair.
The dashed lines represent the limits of agreement, mean difference ± 1.96DS. The closer the solid
lines are to the zero line the more accurate the method, and the smaller the distance between the
upper and lower dashed lines the more consistent the measurements. Source: Author131.
Conclusion
A deep learning algorithm is at least as good as manual methods based on images
for assessing prostate volume.
82
Discussion
Papers I and II
The purpose of the first two papers was to evaluate whether the new DSM could be
used for embolisation and, if so, how we ll it performed compared to the market-
leading sphere, TGMS. The main endpoints were of radiological and
histopathological character. Secondary endpoints were toxicological, product
safety, and usability and have not been included in the papers.
Smaller DSM (50 µm) from the same supplier has been commercially available for
many years; hence, the material itself has been tested and approved for toxicology.
Nevertheless, the new size of the spher es and the new intended indications require
new documentation and trials for medical device registration.
Our conclusions were that the spheres caused an ischaemic effect and that
degradation in vivo occurred. However, the exact time for restoration of blood flow
is unknown and could not be estimated mo re accurately than between three days
and two weeks. We do not know which de gradation time is optimal, and it is
probably different for different purposes. To get a more exact estimation of the
degradation time a much larger set of research animals would be needed, which
would be euthanised at different time intervals from embolisation. Another method
would be repeated angiographies or contrast-enhanced MRI.
Similar studies on degradable spheres have been performed. The intended
degradation time varies from less than an hour up to six months. There is no proof
that degradable materials entail any benefits. However, several possible advantages
have been proposed by us and other authors
12, 18, 145. The most common statement is
that once the goal of embolisation has been reached, the material is no longer
needed. We also know that a few hours of ischaemia are enough to irreversibly harm
most tissues. This is the most often used theoretical rationale for why degradable
Materials
should be as good as permanent materials. Maclean evaluated the UFE
Results
of six different embolisation materials, for example TGMS, PVA and a new
gelatine-based bioresorbable calibrated sphere (Gel-Bead) which degrades in 12
weeks. Gel-Bead had similar outcomes in terms of fibroid infarction
146.
Foreign materials cause tissue reactions, often chronic. Some materials are more
inert, like stents and replaced joints, and cause less inflammation, while others cause
more aggressive inflammation.
83
Another advantage of degradable material is that it minimises the expression of
VEGF which is induced by ischaemia. El evated VEGF in pl asma has been shown
to persist for up to one month after prolonged ischaemia following embolisation. A
rise was noted even with fast degrading mi crospheres but at lower levels than with
permanent material147. Up-regulation of VEGF plasma levels after TACE has been
shown to be a negative prognostic factor, not only for tumour response rate but also
for progression-free survival, being associated with a higher incidence of local
tumour recurrence and distant metastases148. Furthermore, it may be responsible for
a more aggressive HCC behaviour leading to infiltrative or metastatic change and
for the development of collateral tumour feeders, inducing TACE resistance149.
In PAE, repeated interventions are less likely to be performed, and such patients are
less likely to express concern about a permanent material. When it comes to young
women who might consider embolisation for their uterine fibroid, the psychological
aspect of having a permanent material injected might be a reason to choose
alternative treatments. We know from research that pregnancy-associated
complications occur more frequently in women who get pregnant post-UFE. One
reason that has been proposed is impa ired vascular regulation because of the
bilateral occluded uterine arteries. The recruited anastomotic vessels do not have the
same ability to adapt to the new higher demand for blood flow required during
pregnancy. Therefore, a degradable bioc ompatible, calibrated s phere could be the
perfect device of choice in these cases; however, this is yet to be proved
146. So far,
though, it has not been shown that there is a correlation between occluded or
impaired uterine arteries and fertility issues.
Strengths and weaknesses of the studies
The design of these two studies demonstrates suitability for the intended endpoints,
although certain enhancements could have been implemented. The statistical
analysis presented in the papers is limit ed, with a more comprehensive statistical
report available in the non-public Preclinical report. Supplementary statistical data
for Paper II has been included within the r esults chapter of this thesis. It should be
noted that the Emboscore, as a qualitative variable, lacks objectivity, thus an
Objective
quantification of blood flow would be preferable. In Paper II, conducting
an additional angiography within the two-week interval would have provided a more
accurate estimate of degradation time and r estoration of blood flow. Furthermore,
including a larger number of study subjects would yield insights into the acute and
chronic development of inflammation and perfusion, along with the ability to
investigate the effects of using spheres of different sizes. The use of repeated
contrast-enhanced MRI could also be considered to assess the progression of
ischaemia and restoration of blood flow. Unfortunately, an animal model enabling
embolisation under pathological conditions is currently unavailable. However, with
the results from the conducted studies, in conjunction with prior toxicology and
84
safety studies, the subsequent step should involve human studies, preferably
employing blinded randomised controlled trials combined with MRI.
Several strengths of these studies should be acknowledged. Despite the seemingly
simplistic design of the initial study (paper I), it yielded significant knowledge and
successfully addressed the stated endpoints. The occurrence of an unintended failed
embolisation in one sheep provided an ideal control subject. The design of the
second study was notably well-constructed in various aspects. All individuals
involved in the study groups were blinded until the completion of all analyses. The
interventions and associated analyses exhibited a high success rate. The animals did
not appear to experience significant suffering. The stated endpoints were adequately
addressed. Moreover, the findings of these studies offer opportunities for future
advancements and research of the DSM.
Paper III
In clinical routines, radiologists use ADC values with different cut-offs. A
commonly used argument for this is that they consider themselves calibrated to their
specific scanner. Another commonly used application is to perform a cognitive
calibration of a specific scanner or study by drawing a region of interest for ADC in
the urine or muscular tissue, and with the help of this value, correcting the value of
the tumour.
Möller et al. evaluated the variability of ADC measurements across different
vendors and MRI protocols on a phantom and found no clinically relevant
differences
126. This is not in line with our results. A stratified analysis of the ADC
values of the urine in our dataset varied from 1200 – 3300 × 10 −6 mm2/s. Prostate
and tumour tissue had a smaller, but considerable variation as well.
Since most previous studies were conduc ted under relatively uniform conditions,
we wanted to perform a study with patien t data from various hospitals, examined
with different scanners and sequences, hence under heterogene ous and realistic
conditions.
Our results indicate that the method is entirely random with an AUC close to 0.5 for
distinguishing ISUP (1-)2 from ISUP 3-5. The truth likely lies somewhere between
our results and others. Some methodological weaknesses in our material should be
mentioned. The number of subjects was rela tively small, so some stratifications
contained only a few patients and could not be analysed separately. In addition, the
Material
did not include patients with ISUP 1, which would have added extra weight
to the ISUP 1-2 group in the statistics. ISUP 1 is usually defined as low-grade
tumours and the patients are usually treated with active surveillance, according to
most treatment guidelines
88, did not undergo RALP.
85
In the compilation of scanning parameters, it emerged that several scanners used b-
values that were incorrect and resulted in incorrect ADC values. Using the ratio
technique is considered by many as a way for erroneous variables to cancel each
other out, but this is unlikely to be the case. Earlier in the thesis, it is described that
errors are rather increased, adding further noise to the data, resulting in even more
uncertain values. There is a mathematical relationship that describes how errors
increase when making a ratio between two measurements. This concept is often
referred to as error propagation or uncertainty propagation and can be approximated
by using a formula. For exam ple, if both measurements have an error of 50%, the
uncertainty in the resulting ratio will be around 70% of the ratio’s value150, 151. This
is probably the main rationale for why th e application of the ratio or normalising
ADC does not work.
Despite this, the use of the ADC ratio h as been shown to be useful by some
authors152-155, while others did not see any additional value in it127, 156.
Krauss et al. were able to show that completely different variables such as PI-RADS
and PSA/PSAD could predict the risk of csPCa with an AUC of 0.80 – 0.82, and no
additional value in adding radiomics-based information ADC information
157.
Our conclusion is that ADC values should be used with caution in the assessment
of prostate cancer and that the ADC ratio does not add any value.
Paper IV
Previous studies have evaluated the assessment of prostate volume using
experimental deep learning algorithms against various reference standards, yielding
Results
consistent with our studies
130, 131, 158-163 . Strengths of our study were its
distinct approach, where we evaluate d a commercially available AI model on
diversified multicentre MRI data without pre-adjustment, and that all 124 prostates
could be assessed by the software.
Previous studies have used various statistical methods for correlation 130, 159 and
overlay measures 158, 160 . We emphasised Bland-Altman plots because we believe
that the method comparison was better visualised with this measure by showing all
data points. Despite our attempts to mimic a real clinical situation, our dataset has
its limitations, as there was a dominant manufacturer in our health region and some
of the participating centres were numerica lly dominant in terms of the number of
prostate MRIs performed.
It is well established that there is vari ation between different readers, and we
highlight this from several perspectives. We demonstrated slightly lower agreement
between experienced and inexperienced radiologists performing manual planimetry,
but the precision remained good. We showed good agreement between two
86
experienced radiologists using the ellipsoid formula measure, in line with previous
studies164, 165.
An important but time-consuming step in the assessment of prostate MRI is volume
calculation, which is the basis for PSAD, wh ich in turn forms the basis for further
workup and treatment. Our results can contribute to better understanding of how AI
models can be integrated into the workflow for efficient patient selection and better
utilisation of radiology resources. We feel that we are confident in using the volume
tools in our daily workflow.
87
Conclusions
In conclusion, our study showcases the e fficacy of embolisation using the new
DSM, offering potential for recanalisati on and improved blood fl ow restoration.
Moreover, embolisation with DSM demonstrates comparable tissue effects to
TGMS, with fewer vascular inflammati ons and enhanced recanalisation. Our
findings also challenge previous assumpti ons by revealing no co rrelation between
ADC metrics and ISUP grade, while affi rming the reliability of deep learning
algorithms for prostate volume assessment. These insights underscore the evolving
landscape of interventional procedures a nd imaging techniques which will shape
future clinical practices.
88
Future perspectives
The development of embolisation materials continues at an unabated pace. Since we
commenced our trials with DSM, numerous calibrated spheres have emerged in the
market. Further advancements have been made towards the creation of the ideal
sphere, with many studies focusing on the smaller variant of our sphere, now also
produced as drug-eluting beads for HCC treatment. For many indications, I believe
that bioabsorbable spheres will dominate in the future, especially in oncological
conditions where the ischaemic effect needs to be combined with the effect of local
cytostatic drug. I also hope to see studies on uterine embolisation using
bioabsorbable spheres, assessing if they will result in fewer adverse effects on future
pregnancies compared to permanent ma terials. Presumably, PAE for benign
prostatic hyperplasia will continue to be performed using permanent spheres. At our
institution, we are setting up a trial fo r comparing degradable with permanent
spheres in DEB-TACE for HCC.
Local treatment of prostate cancer now includes cryotherapy and HIFU, both of
which will soon be available at Skåne Univ ersity Hospital. Initially, treatment will
be conducted within the framework of studies, with MRI being central to
radiological follow-up. Some studies have been published regarding the treatment
of prostate cancer using drug-eluting bead s for PAE, generating interest at our
institution in initiating a similar study. Progress is also being made in prostate cancer
diagnosis using MRI, with new machine-l earning applications emerging at a high
rate. It is evident that assistance with contouring for volumetric determination works
well and can already be used clinically. Several software suites also make diagnostic
assessments with high sensitivity. However, specificity remains generally low, and
improvements are needed, specifically in prostate diagnostics.
There is a wealth of hidden informa tion in our MRI images, and valuable
information can be extracted. Significant pr ogress is likely to be made soon, and I
am pleased that our clinic has an AI department to enable our participation and to
benefit from developments in this field. Our colleagues in the MRI Physics Group
at the Department of Medical Radiation Physics of Lund University are running
several studies. One project focuses on functional MRI diagnostics and
histopathology. Other projects utilise advanced diffusion methods that incorporate,
for example, IVIM for the assessment of perfusion and hypoxia. Another novel
Method
is diffusional variance decom position (DIVIDE) which employs non-
89
conventional diffusion encoding to provid e considerably more information about
the examined tissue than simply measuring ADC166.
The diagnostic accuracy of new imaging t echniques requires validation, preferably
by histopathological verification. In collaboration with Sandgren et al 167 we are
setting up a study in which the fresh surgical prostate specimen will be placed in a
tailor-made mold for ex vivo MRI which will enable perfect matching with the
subsequent histology and the preoperative in vivo MRI and hence allowing us to
evaluate the accuracy of new MRI sequences.
In conclusion, there is a substantial amount of information to be obtained from MRI
technology beyond what is currently utilised in clinical routine. With the assistance
of these projects, we can move a step closer to MRI-based biomarkers and non-
invasive MRI-based histology. With con tinued enhancements in diagnostic
accuracy, we anticipate further decrease in unnecessary biopsies and overdiagnosis,
coupled with better early detection and treatment of aggressive prostate cancer.
I am grateful for the opportunity to be involved in this exciting development.
90
Acknowledgements
Jag vill uttrycka min tacksamhet till alla er som hjälpt mig på vägen under mina
doktorandstudier, både professionellt och personligt.
Min huvudhandledare, Pia Sundgren som under många år tålmodigt stöttat mig och
alltid lyssnat på mig. Tack för att du ställt lagom mycket krav, du har
fingertoppskänsla. Det tog sina år, men nu är det snart gjort.
Sophia Zackrisson , min bihandledare som anslöt när min forskning ändrade
inriktning. Tack, du har verkligen en stor del i det här till slut gick vägen. Tänk att
du till och med hälsade på mig i Sydney!
Inger Keussen, min vän och handledare under första halvan av det här arbetet. Jag
vet hur mycket tid och engagemang du gav mig. Vilken tur att den där stolpen i
Tokyo var vadderad!
Min rumskompis och handledare, Erik Baubeta-Fridh. Tack för att du anslöt till mitt
team, din snabba hjärna och dina kreativa tankar har varit till stor hjälp. Jag ser fram
emot fortsatt forskning tillsammans.
Despina Flondell-Sité , urolog och handledare. Din energi och entusiasm är
underbar. Tack för hjälp med alla kliniska data och goda idéer.
Wojciech Cwikiel, du förtjänar ett av de största tacken för genomförandet av första
halvan av avhandlingen. Din erfarenhe t, känsla och e ngagemang kan inte
överskattas. Tack för att du fick mig intresserad av intervention och gav mig chansen
att börja forska. Våra äventyr med sfärerna är oförglömliga.
Magdalena Häggström, min gamla rumskompis och bästa kollega. Principfast som
få och alltid med en åsikt. Du sätter färg på tillvaron. Det är inte kul att du är så långt
borta.
Mina nuvarande och tidigare chefer på B ild och Funktion som genom åren varit
flexibla och gett mig utrymme att forska. Tack till Sophia Zachrisson , Carin
Cronberg, Daisy Lee och Peter Hochbergs.
Tack till Annika Törling-Ring , Ulrika Andersson och Kajsa Trens
forskningsadministratörer, för att ni haft kol l på all formalia. Och jag är ledsen för
att ni behövt påminna mig så många gånger.
91
Erik Thimansson , vän och medförfattare. Tillsam mans sätter vi Skåne på MR
prostatakartan. Vi har så mycket på gång.
Carina Bursjöö och Mårten Forssén för ovärderlig hjälp med fåren.
Eric Sandrup, Eddie Thordarson, Peter Fyhr och övriga på Magle Life Sciences.
Det var ett nöja att lära känna er.
Karl Thulin och Anders Forslid på BMC, in vivo lab, som bidrog med professionell
hjälp med fåren.
Dolores Gavier-Widén och Erika Karlstam på Statens Veterinärmedicinska Anstalt
i Uppsala. Vilken tur att vi fann varandra. Det har varit ett sant nöje att arbeta med
er! Det hade inte blivit något utan er insats.
Anita Brinck och Kristina Olausson , röntgensjuksköterskor på interventionslab.
Tack för all hjälp med kontrast, katetrar och ledare.
Jacob Engellau för goda råd och bra samtal.
MR-fysiker Jimmy Lätt för hjälp med b-värden och ADC.
MR-fysiker Filip Szczepankiewicz för allt du lärt mig om diffusion och för att du
läst och gett mig feed-back. Jag ser verkligen fram emot våra kommande projekt.
Anders Bjartell, Thomas Jiborn, Ymir Saemundsson, Max Alterbeck, Jacob Ingvar.
Det är alltid ett nöje att arbeta med Urologer!
Tack till Anna-Carin Börjedahl. koordinator för OPT, Anetta Bolekjo ,
forskningssjuksköterska i OPT-teamet och Anna Holst , sekreterare på Malmö
Cancer Center.
Wiveka Rosenqvist för att du skötte alla faktur or och transaktioner i samband med
försöken i studie 1 och 2.
Kevin Sandeman, ett ankare på patologen med ett aldrig sinande driv, du är positiv
till allt. Jag hoppas vi kommer samarbeta mycket framöver.
Jakob Swanberg, Hans Lindgren och Mateusz Krasun, interventionsradiologer som
så generöst delat med sig av sina erfarenheter om embolisering.
Hanna Sartor , min one-stop-shop! Du är alltid lika energisk och sarkastisk, det
älskar jag.
Sam Eriksson, kollega på gastro. Tack för att jag fick vara med på dina lever-ADC.
Du är en stjärna, en vän och ett ankare på röntgen.
Kristin Johnson, stugkompis och kollega som kommer lämna ett stort tomrum efter
sig men som kommer tillbaka ännu starkare och bättre. Lycka till i Belgien.
Anni Gålne, kollega, padelpartner och cykelsä llskap. Det är alltid bra samtal med
dig. Oavsett vad det gäller.
92
Anna Kahn, som jag kamperat ihop med så många år. Jag hoppas vi kommer göra
det igen någon gång.
Gustav Sundström som generöst hjälpt mig med designen av framsidan.
Kjartan Thorarinsson som steppat in som prostataankare och Johanna Berg som ser
till att MR-standarden på SUS håller världsklass. Jonatan Engman, medförfattare
och mycket erfaren uroradiolog. Sonja Pudaric och Nils-Olof Wallengren som
introducerade mig till MR Prostata.
Nuvarande och före detta ko lleger på röntgen i Lund oc h Malmö, som har arbetat
så jag kunnat forska. Ni är otroligt viktiga för mig.
Röntgensjuksköterskor och undersköterskor på röntgen i Lund. Ni gör att fantastiskt
arbete.
Alla kolleger och vänner på TMC för att ni gjorde äventyren i Australien så bra. Ett
extra tack till Hans Billing , Eva Bornell , Aleksandra Garbacz , Fausto Labruto ,
Daniel Gierhake-Stahlhoven , Cathrine Lefort , Odd och Lisa Runeborg , Ida och
Niklas Wingenfeldt. Ida, vad skulle jag göra utan dig?
Alla kolleger och vänner på DDA/Teleconsult. Ni är så många som varit viktiga och
som gjorde året på Bali så bra. Karl Isacsson, du var livsviktig. Jonas Nilsson och
Emma Ulfsdottir , Krister och Helene Askaner , Daisy Lee med Alvaro , Mansour
Grand, Istvan Herzfeldt, Katarina och Johan Degerman, Axel Tjörnstrand, Signe
Norgren och Olof Huldt, Siri Bårdskär, Hala Mehrez, Gitte Leger och Martin Leger,
Genta Banushi och Agus Dharsana.
Karin Åstrand, Mattias och Mia Hjort, Jakob Svensson, Tobias och Ingrid Schölin,
Jonas och Katrin Lindhe-Persson , Dariusz Slusarczyk . Gamla kompisgänget,
Jesper, Fredrik, Thomas, Pär och Olof. Hit räknas även Jenny som kommit med
goda språkliga tips. Ni är alla vänne r och kolleger från förr och nu som inte
kategoriserats någon annanstans men som är och har varit ytterst viktiga för mig,
alla på sitt sätt.
Mina föräldrar, Lena Wargren och Kalle Bengtsson. Mina systrar, Emma Bengtsson
och Matilda Hedén med familjer. Sara Elvermåhr och Ulla-Britt Elversson.
Sist, och viktigast av alla, min älskade fru Jessica Elversson och våra fina barn. Ella,
Ludvig och Märta. Ni är verkligen bäst. Jag älskar er!
93
94
References
1. Lindbom A. Arteriosclerosis and arterial thrombosis in the lower limb; a
roentgenological study. Acta radiologica Supplementum. 1950;80:1-80.
2. Seldinger S. Catheter replacement of the needle in percutaneous arteriography; a new
technique. Acta Radiologica. 1953:368-76.
3. Dotter CT, Judkins MP. Transluminal Treatment of Arteriosclerotic Obstruction.
Circulation. 1964;30(5):654-70.
4. Bollinger, Schlumpf. Andreas Grüntzigs Ballon-Katheter zur Angioplastie von
peripheren Arterien (PTA) ist 25 Jahre alt. Vasa. 1999;28(1):58-64.
5. Grüntzig A, Hopff H. Perkutane Rekanalisation chronischer arterieller Verschlüsse
mit einem neuen Dilatationskatheter. DMW-Deutsche Medizinische Wochenschrift.
1974;99(49):2502-5.
6. Rösch J, Dotter CT, Brown MJ. Selective arterial embolization: a new method for
control of acute gastrointestinal bleeding. Radiology. 1972;102(2):303-6.
7. Kumar A, Ouriel K. Handbook of Endovascular interventions: Springer Science &
Business Media; 2012.
8. Sheth RA, Sabir S, Krishnamurthy S, Avery RK, Zhang YS, Khademhosseini A,
Oklu R. Endovascular Embolization by Transcatheter Delivery of Particles: Past,
Present, and Future. J Funct Biomater. 2017;8(2).
9. Lewandowski RJ, Sato KT, Atassi B, Ryu RK, Nemcek AA, Kulik L, et al.
Radioembolization with 90 Y microspheres: angiographic and technical
considerations. Cardiovascular and interventional radiology. 2007;30:571-92.
10. Bengtsson J, Cwikiel W, Sundgren PC, Karlstam E, Gavier-Widen D, Keussen I. The
effects of uterine artery embolization with a new degradable microsphere in an
experimental study. Acta Radiol. 2017;58(11):1334-41.
11. Doucet J, Kiri L, O’Connell K, Kehoe S, Lewandowski RJ, Liu DM, et al. Advances
in degradable embolic microspheres: a state of the art review. Journal of functional
biomaterials. 2018;9(1):14.
12. Laurent A. Microspheres and nonspheri cal particles for embolization. Tech Vasc
Interv Radiol. 2007;10(4):248-56.
13. Davidson GS, Terbrugge KG. Histologic long-term follow-up after embolization
with polyvinyl alcohol particles. American journal of neuroradiology.
1995;16(4):843-6.
14. Laurent A, Wassef M, Namur J, Martal J, Labarre D, Pelage JP. Recanalization and
particle exclusion after embolization of uterine arteries in sheep: a long-term study.
Fertil Steril. 2009;91(3):884-92.
95
15. Carli D, Sluzewski M, Beute G, Va n Rooij W. Complications of particle
embolization of meningiomas: frequency, risk factors, and outcome. American
journal of neuroradiology. 2010;31(1):152-4.
16. Duvnjak S, Ravn P, Green A, Andersen PE. Uterine fibroid embolization with
acrylamido polyvinyl microspheres: prospective 12-month clinical and MRI follow-
up study. Acta Radiol. 2017;58(8):952-8.
17. Spies JB, Allison S, Flick P, Cramp M, Bruno J, Jha RC, Ascher SA. Spherical
polyvinyl alcohol versus tris-acryl gelatin microspheres for uterine artery
embolization for leiomyomas: results of a limited randomized comparative study.
Journal of Vascular and Interventional Radiology. 2005;16(11):1431-7.
18. Owen RJ, Nation PN, Polakowski R, Biliske JA, Tiege PB, Griffith IJ. A preclinical
study of the safety and efficacy of Occlusin 500 Artificial Embolization Device in
sheep. Cardiovasc Intervent Radiol. 2012;35(3):636-44.
19. Lee S, Ghosh A, Xiao N, Gordon AC, Heidarpour N, Funaki B, Lewandowski RJ,
editors. Embolic Agents: Particles. Seminars in Interventional Radiology; 2023:
Thieme Medical Publishers, Inc. 333 Seventh Avenue, 18th Floor, New York,
NY ….
20. Wang CY, Hu J, Sheth RA, Oklu R. Emerging embolic agents in endovascular
embolization: an overview. Progress in Biomedical Engineering. 2020;2(1):012003.
21. Medsinge A, Zajko A, Orons P, Amesur N, Santos E. A case-based approach to
common embolization agents used in vascular interventional radiology. American
Journal of Roentgenology. 2014;203(4):699-708.
22. Jordan O, Doelker E, Rufenacht DA. Biomat erials used in injectable implants (liquid
embolics) for percutaneous filling of vascular spaces. Cardiovasc Intervent Radiol.
2005;28(5):561-9.
23. Fan XD, Su LX, Zheng JW, Zheng LZ, Zhang ZY. Ethanol embolization of
arteriovenous malformations of the mandible. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol.
2009;30(6):1178-83.
24. Maxwell NJ, Saleem Amer N, Rogers E, Kiely D, Sweeney P, Brady AP. Renal
artery embolisation in the palliative treatment of renal carcinoma. Br J Radiol.
2007;80(950):96-102.
25. Maeda N, Verret V, Moine L, Bedouet L, Louguet S, Servais E, et al. Targeting and
recanalization after embolization with calibrated resorbable microspheres versus
hand-cut gelatin sponge particles in a porcine kidney model. J Vasc Interv Radiol.
2013;24(9):1391-8.
26. Costa C, Incio J, Soares R. Angiogenesis and chronic inflammation: cause or
consequence? Angiogenesis. 2007;10(3):149-66.
27. Malhotra K, Liebeskind DS. Collaterals in ischemic stroke. Brain Hemorrhages.
2020;1(1):6-12.
28. Dong H, Yang D, Hu Y, Song X. Recent advances in smart nanoplatforms for tumor
non-interventional embolization therapy. J Nanobiotechnology. 2022;20(1):337.
29. Seiler C. The human coronary collateral circulation. Heart. 2003;89(11):1352-7.
96
30. Mr H. Smooth muscle neoplasms. Surgical pathology of the uterine corpus.
1980:468-529.
31. Baird DD, Dunson DB, Hill MC, Cousins D, Schectman JM. High cumulative
incidence of uterine leiomyoma in black and white women: ultrasound evidence. Am
J Obstet Gynecol. 2003;188(1):100-7.
32. Baird D, Schectman J, Dixon D, Sandle r D, Hill M, editors. African Americans at
higher risk than whites for uterine fibroids: Ultrasound evidence. American journal
of epidemiology; 1998: JOHNS HOPKINS UNIV SCHOOL HYGIENE PUB
HEALTH 111 MARKET PLACE, STE 840 ….
33. Borgfeldt C, Aandolf E. Transvaginal ultrasonographic findings in the uterus and the
endometrium: low prevalence of leiomyoma in a random sample of women age 25-
40 years. Acta obstetricia et gynecologica Scandinavica. 2000;79(3):202-7.
34. Marshall LM, Spiegelman D, Barbieri RL , Goldman MB, Manson JE, Colditz GA, et
al. Variation in the incidence of uterine leiomyoma among premenopausal women by
age and race. Obstetrics & Gynecology. 1997;90(6):967-73.
35. Chavez NF, Stewart EA. Medical treatment of uterine fibroids. Clinical Obstetrics
and Gynecology. 2001;44(2):372-84.
36. Vilos GA, Allaire C, Laberge PY, Leyland N, Special C. The management of uterine
leiomyomas. J Obstet Gynaecol Can. 2015;37(2):157-78.
37. Cardozo ER, Clark AD, Banks NK, Henne MB, Stegmann BJ, Segars JH. The
estimated annual cost of uterine leiomyomata in the United States. American journal
of obstetrics and gynecology. 2012;206(3):211. e1-. e9.
38. Metwally M, Li T-C. Modern Management of Uterine Fibroids: Cambridge
University Press; 2020.
39. Yang Q, Ciebiera M, Bariani MV, Ali M, Elkafas H, Boyer TG, Al-Hendy A.
Comprehensive Review of Uterine Fibroids: Developmental Origin, Pathogenesis,
and Treatment. Endocr Rev. 2022;43(4):678-719.
40. Cook H, Ezzati M, Segars JH, McCarthy D. The impact of uterine leiomyomas on
reproductive outcomes. Minerva ginecologica. 2010;62(3):225.
41. Laughlin SK, Stewart EA. Uterine leiom yomas: individualizing the approach to a
heterogeneous condition. Obstetrics and gynecology. 2011;117(2 Pt 1):396.
42. Carranza-Mamane B, Havelock J, He mmings R, Reproductive E, Infertility C,
Special C. The management of uterine fibroids in women with otherwise unexplained
infertility. J Obstet Gynaecol Can. 2015;37(3):277-85.
43. Pritts EA, Parker WH, Olive DL. Fibroi ds and infertility: an updated systematic
review of the evidence. Fertility and sterility. 2009;91(4):1215-23.
44. Borah BJ, Yao X, Laughlin-Tommaso SK, Heien HC, Stewart EA. Comparative
Effectiveness of Uterine Leiomyoma Procedures Using a Large Insurance Claims
Database. Obstet Gynecol. 2017;130(5):1047-56.
45. Sizzi O, Rossetti A, Malzoni M, Minelli L, La Grotta F, Soranna L, et al. Italian
multicenter study on complications of laparoscopic myomectomy. J Minim Invasive
Gynecol. 2007;14(4):453-62.
97
46. Patel N, Chaudhari K, Patel D, Joshi J. High-Intensity Focused Ultrasound Ablation
of Uterine Fibroids: A Review. Cureus. 2023;15(9):e44680.
47. Capezzuoli T, Aslan B, Vannuccini S, Or landi G, La Torre F, Sorbi F, et al.
Recurrence of Uterine Fibroids After Conservative Surgery or Radiological
Procedures: a Narrative Review. Reprod Sci. 2023.
48. Liu L, Wang T, Lei B. High-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU) ablation versus
surgical interventions for the treatment of symptomatic uterine fibroids: a meta-
analysis. Eur Radiol. 2022;32(2):1195-204.
49. Spies JB, Roth AR, Jha RC, Gomez-Jorge J, Levy EB, Chang TC, Ascher SA.
Leiomyomata treated with uterine artery embolization: factors associated with
successful symptom and imaging outcome. Radiology. 2002;222(1):45-52.
50. Andrews RT, Spies JB, Sacks D, Worthington-Kirsch RL, Niedzwiecki GA, Marx
MV, et al. Patient care and uterine artery embolization for leiomyomata. Journal of
vascular and interventional radiology: JVIR. 2004;15(2 Pt 1):115-20.
51. Bulman JC, Ascher SM, Spies JB. Current concepts in uterine fibroid embolization.
Radiographics. 2012;32(6):1735-50.
52. Pelage J-P, Cazejust J, Pluot E, Dref OL, Laurent A, Spies JB, et al. Uterine fibroid
vascularization and clinical relevance to uterine fibroid embolization. Radiographics.
2005;25(suppl_1):S99-S117.
53. Pelage J-P, Le Dref O, Soyer P, Jacob D, Kardache M, Dahan H, et al. Arterial
anatomy of the female genital tract: variations and relevance to transcatheter
embolization of the uterus. AJR American journal of roentgenology.
1999;172(4):989-94.
54. Razavi MK, Wolanske KA, Hwang GL, Sz e DY, Kee ST, Dake MD. Angiographic
classification of ovarian artery–to–uterine artery anastomoses: initial observations in
uterine fibroid embolization. Radiology. 2002;224(3):707-12.
55. Pelage J-P, Guaou NG, Jha RC, Ascher SM, Spies JB. Uterine fibroid tumors: long-
term MR imaging outcome after embolization. Radiology. 2004;230(3):803-9.
56. Expert Panel on Interventional R, Knu ttinen MG, Stark G, Hohenwalter EJ, Bradley
LD, Braun AR, et al. ACR Appropriateness Criteria((R)) Radiologic Management of
Uterine Leiomyomas. J Am Coll Radiol. 2018;15(5S):S160-S70.
57. Badiani B, Chiumente M, Messori A. Ulipristal acetate for pre-operative
management of uterine fibroids: Modeling outcomes and costs. Eur J Obstet Gynecol
Reprod Biol. 2018;222:84-8.
58. Fonseca MCM, Castro R, Machado M, Conte T, Girao M. Uterine Artery
Embolization and Surgical Methods for the Treatment of Symptomatic Uterine
Leiomyomas: A Systemic Review and Meta-analysis Followed by Indirect Treatment
Comparison. Clin Ther. 2017;39(7):1438-55 e2.
59. Donnez J, Dolmans MM. Uterine fibroid ma nagement: from the present to the future.
Hum Reprod Update. 2016;22(6):665-86.
60. Jiang W, Shen Z, Luo H, Hu X, Zhu X. Comparison of polyvinyl alcohol and tris-
acryl gelatin microsphere materials in embolization for symptomatic leiomyomas: a
systematic review. Minim Invasive Ther Allied Technol. 2016;25(6):289-300.
98
61. Falkenberg M DM. Endovaskulär intervention : en praktisk vägledning. 1. uppl. ed:
Studentlitteratur; 2014.
62. Kandarpa K M. Handbook of interventional radiologic procedures. 5. ed: Wolters
Kluwer; 2016.
63. Ganguli S, Faintuch S, Salazar GM, Rabkin DJ. Postembolization syndrome: changes
in white blood cell counts immediately after uterine artery embolization. Journal of
Vascular and Interventional Radiology. 2008;19(3):443-5.
64. Investigators R. Uterine-artery emboliza tion versus surgery for symptomatic uterine
fibroids. New England Journal of Medicine. 2007;356(4):360-70.
65. Mara M, Maskova J, Fucikova Z, Kuzel D, Belsan T, Sosna O. Midterm clinical and
first reproductive results of a randomized controlled trial comparing uterine fibroid
embolization and myomectomy. Cardiovascular and interventional radiology.
2008;31:73-85.
66. Sandhu JS, Bixler BR, Dahm P, Go ueli R, Kirkby E, Stoffel JT, Wilt TJ.
Management of lower urinary tract symptoms attributed to benign prostatic
hyperplasia (BPH): AUA guideline amendment 2023. The Journal of Urology.
2024;211(1):11-9.
67. Patel ND, Parsons JK. Epidemiology and etiology of benign prostatic hyperplasia
and bladder outlet obstruction. Indian J Urol. 2014;30(2):170-6.
68. Stranne J, Damber JE, Fall M, Hammarsten J, Knutson T, Peeker R. One-third of the
Swedish male population over 50 years of age suffers from lower urinary tract
symptoms. Scand J Urol Nephrol. 2009;43(3):199-205.
69. Page T, Veeratterapillay R, Keltie K, Burn J, Sims A. Prostatic urethral lift (UroLift):
a real-world analysis of outcomes using hospital episodes statistics. BMC Urol.
2021;21(1):55.
70. Miller LE, Chughtai B, McVary K, Go nzalez RR, Rojanasarot S, DeRouen K,
Bhattacharyya S. Water vapor thermal therapy for lower urinary tract symptoms
secondary to benign prostatic hyperplasia: Systematic review and meta-analysis.
Medicine (Baltimore). 2020;99(30):e21365.
71. Naidu SG, Narayanan H, Saini G, Segaran N, Alzubaidi SJ, Patel IJ, Oklu R. Prostate
Artery Embolization-Review of Indications, Patient Selection, Techniques and
Results. J Clin Med. 2021;10(21).
72. Mitchell ME, Waltman AC, Athanasoulis CA, Kerr Jr WS, Dretler SP. Control of
massive prostatic bleeding with angiographic techniques. The Journal of Urology.
1976;115(6):692-5.
73. DeMeritt JS, Elmasri FF, Esposito MP, Ro senberg GS. Relief of benign prostatic
hyperplasia-related bladder outlet obstruction after transarterial polyvinyl alcohol
prostate embolization. J Vasc Interv Radiol. 2000;11(6):767-70.
74. Carnevale FC, Antunes AA, da Motta Leal Filho JM, de Oliveira Cerri LM, Baroni
RH, Marcelino AS, et al. Prostatic artery embolization as a primary treatment for
benign prostatic hyperplasia: preliminary results in two patients. Cardiovasc
Intervent Radiol. 2010;33(2):355-61.
99
75. Pisco JM, Pinheiro LC, Bilhim T, Duarte M, Mendes JR, Oliveira AG. Prostatic
arterial embolization to treat benign prostatic hyperplasia. J Vasc Interv Radiol.
2011;22(1):11-9; quiz 20.
76. Carnevale FC, Iscaife A, Yoshinaga EM, Moreira AM, Antunes AA, Srougi M.
Transurethral Resection of the Prostate (TURP) Versus Original and PErFecTED
Prostate Artery Embolization (PAE) Due to Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia (BPH):
Preliminary Results of a Single Center, Prospective, Urodynamic-Controlled
Analysis. Cardiovasc Intervent Radiol. 2016;39(1):44-52.
77. Jung JH, McCutcheon KA, Borofsky M, Young S, Golzarian J, Kim MH, et al.
Prostatic arterial embolization for the treatment of lower urinary tract symptoms in
men with benign prostatic hyperplasia. Cochrane Database Syst Rev.
2022;3(3):CD012867.
78. Ray AF, Powell J, Speakman MJ, Longford NT, DasGupta R, Bryant T, et al.
Efficacy and safety of prostate artery embolization for benign prostatic hyperplasia:
an observational study and propensity-matched comparison with transurethral
resection of the prostate (the UK-ROPE study). BJU Int. 2018;122(2):270-82.
79. Dias US, Jr., de Moura MRL, Viana PCC, de Assis AM, Marcelino ASZ, Moreira
AM, et al. Prostatic Artery Embolization: Indications, Preparation, Techniques,
Imaging Evaluation, Reporting, and Complications. Radiographics. 2021;41(5):1509-
30.
80. Chung E. Penile Glans Necrosis Following Prostatic Artery Embolization for Benign
Prostatic Hyperplasia: Case Series and Review of Current Literature. World J Mens
Health. 2023;41(2):396-402.
81. Clift AK, Thomas R, Frilling A. Develo pments in interventional management of
hepatic metastases from neuroendocrine tumours. Best Pract Res Clin Endocrinol
Metab. 2023;37(5):101798.
82. Ayyub J, Dabhi KN, Gohil NV, Tanveer N, Hussein S, Pingili S, et al. Evaluation of
the Safety and Efficacy of Conventional Transarterial Chemoembolization (cTACE)
and Drug-Eluting Bead (DEB)-TACE in the Management of Unresectable
Hepatocellular Carcinoma: A Systematic Review. Cureus. 2023;15(7):e41943.
83. Leigh N, Sanford DE. Colorectal liver metastases: Resect, ablate, or embolize.
Seminars in Colon and Rectal Surgery. 2023;34(3).
84. Burkhardt O, Abt D, Engeler D, Schmid HP, Mullhaupt G, Zumstein V. Prostatic
Artery Embolization in Patients with Prostate Cancer: A Systematic Review. Eur
Urol Focus. 2023.
85. Guan Y, Wang W, Zhang T, Liao L, Chen J, Zhang Z, et al. Epirubicin-loaded beads
transarterial prostatic arterial chemoembolization is a promising treatment for
advanced prostate cancer with lower urinary tract obstruction or hematuria-a case
series report. Transl Androl Urol. 2022;11(4):480-94.
86. Vilanova JC, Catalá V, Algaba F, Lauc irica O. Atlas of Multiparametric Prostate
MRI. Springer. 2018;10:978-3.
87. Cancer IAfRo. Global cancer observatory Lyon, France: International Agency for
Research on Cancer; [cited 2024].
100
88. Regionala cancercentrum i samverka n. Prostatacancer: Nationellt vårdprogram
[Internet]. Stockholm: Regionala cancercentrum i samverkan; 2023 [cited 2024 Feb
6]. Available from:
https://kunskapsbanken.cancercentrum.se/globalassets/cancerdiagnoser/prostatacance
r/vardprogram/nvp-prostatacancer2.pdf.
89. Engholm G, Ferlay J, Christensen N, Bray F, Gjerstorff ML, Klint Å, et al.
NORDCAN–a Nordic tool for cancer information, planning, quality control and
research. Acta oncologica. 2010;49(5):725-36.
90. Engholm G, Storm H, Ferlay J, Christensen N, Johannesen T, Klint Å, et al.
NORDCAN: cancer incidence, mortality, prevalence and survival in the Nordic
countries. 2012.
91. Häggström C, Stocks T, Ulmert D, Bj ørge T, Ulmer H, Hallmans G, et al.
Prospective study on metabolic factors and risk of prostate cancer. Cancer.
2012;118(24):6199-206.
92. Mandair D, Rossi RE, Pericleous M, Whyand T, Caplin ME. Prostate cancer and the
influence of dietary factors and supplements: a systematic review. Nutrition &
metabolism. 2014;11(1):1-11.
93. Moreira DM, Aronson WJ, Terris MK, Kane CJ, Amling CL, Cooperberg MR, et al.
Cigarette smoking is associated with an increased risk of biochemical disease
recurrence, metastasis, castration-resistant prostate cancer, and mortality after radical
prostatectomy: results from the SEARCH database. Cancer. 2014;120(2):197-204.
94. Alanee SR, Glogowski EA, Schrader KA, Ea stham JA, Offit K. Clinical features and
management of BRCA1 and BRCA2-associated prostate cancer. Front Biosci (Elite
Ed). 2014;6:15-30.
95. Akbari MR, Wallis CJ, Toi A, Trachten berg J, Sun P, Narod SA, Nam RK. The
impact of a BRCA2 mutation on mortality from screen-detected prostate cancer. Br J
Cancer. 2014;111(6):1238-40.
96. Theodorsson E, Berggren Söderlund M. Laurells Klinisk kemi i praktisk medicin:
Studentlitteratur AB; 2018.
97. Wang M, Valenzuela L, Murphy G, Chu T. Purification of a human prostate specific
antigen. Investigative urology. 1979;17(2):159-63.
98. Benson MC, Whang IS, Pantuck A, Ring K, Kaplan SA, Olsson CA, Cooner WH.
Prostate specific antigen density: a means of distinguishing benign prostatic
hypertrophy and prostate cancer. The Journal of urology. 1992;147(3):815-6.
99. Vickers AJ, Savage C, O'Brien MF, Lilja H. Systematic review of pretreatment
prostate-specific antigen velocity and doubling time as predictors for prostate cancer.
Journal of Clinical Oncology. 2009;27(3):398.
100. Nordström T, Akre O, Aly M, Grönberg H, Eklund M. Prostate-specific antigen
(PSA) density in the diagnostic algorithm of prostate cancer. Prostate cancer and
prostatic diseases. 2018;21(1):57-63.
101. Naji L, Randhawa H, Sohani Z, Dennis B, Lautenbach D, Kavanagh O, et al. Digital
rectal examination for prostate cancer screening in primary care: a systematic review
and meta-analysis. The Annals of Family Medicine. 2018;16(2):149-54.
101
102. Kasivisvanathan V, Dufour R, Mo ore CM, Ahmed HU, Abd-Alazeez M, Charman
SC, et al. Transperineal magnetic resonance image targeted prostate biopsy versus
transperineal template prostate biopsy in the detection of clinically significant
prostate cancer. The Journal of urology. 2013;189(3):860-6.
103. Gleason DF. Classification of prostatic carcinomas. Cancer Chemother Rep.
1966;50:125-8.
104. Egevad L, Algaba F, Berney D, Boccon ‐Gibod L, Griffiths D, Lopez‐Beltran A, et al.
Handling and reporting of radical prostatectomy specimens in Europe: a web‐based
survey by the European Network of Uropathology (ENUP). Histopathology.
2008;53(3):333-9.
105. Persson J, Wilderäng U, Jiborn T, Wiklund PN, Damber J-E, Hugosson J, et al.
Interobserver variability in the pathological assessment of radical prostatectomy
specimens: findings of the Laparoscopic Prostatectomy Robot Open (LAPPRO)
study. Scandinavian journal of urology. 2014;48(2):160-7.
106. Egevad L, Ahmad AS, Algaba F, Berney DM, Boccon ‐Gibod L, Compérat E, et al.
Standardization of Gleason grading among 337 European pathologists.
Histopathology. 2013;62(2):247-56.
107. Epstein JI, Egevad L, Amin MB, Dela hunt B, Srigley JR, Humphrey PA, Committee
G. The 2014 International Society of Urological Pathology (ISUP) consensus
conference on Gleason grading of prostatic carcinoma: definition of grading patterns
and proposal for a new grading system. The American journal of surgical pathology.
2016;40(2):244-52.
108. Steyn JH, Smith FW. Nuclear magnetic resonance imaging of the prostate. Br J Urol.
1982;54(6):726-8.
109. Engelbrecht MR, Jager GJ, Laheij RJ, Verbeek AL, van Lier HJ, Barentsz JO. Local
staging of prostate cancer using magnetic resonance imaging: a meta-analysis. Eur
Radiol. 2002;12(9):2294-302.
110. Verma S, Rajesh A, Futterer JJ, Turkbey B, Scheenen TW, Pang Y, et al. Prostate
MRI and 3D MR spectroscopy: how we do it. AJR Am J Roentgenol.
2010;194(6):1414-26.
111. Turkbey B, Rosenkrantz AB, Haider MA, Padhani AR, Villeirs G, Macura KJ, et al.
Prostate imaging reporting and data system version 2.1: 2019 update of prostate
imaging reporting and data system version 2. European urology. 2019;76(3):340-51.
112. Einstein A. Über die von der molekularkinetischen Theorie der Wärme geforderte
Bewegung von in ruhenden Flüssigkeiten suspendierten Teilchen. Annalen der
physik. 1905;4.
113. Renn J. Einstein's invention of Brownian motion. Annalen der Physik. 2005;517:23-
37.
114. Le Bihan D. Apparent diffusion coefficient and beyond: what diffusion MR imaging
can tell us about tissue structure. Radiological Society of North America, Inc.; 2013.
p. 318-22.
115. Szczepankiewicz F, editor Workshop on Diffusion MRI: From Research to Clinic.
Sequence Design & Contrast Mechanisms. ISMRM; 2022; Amsterdam, Netherlands.
116. Le Bihan D. What can we see with IVIM MRI? Neuroimage. 2019;187:56-67.
102
117. Gronberg H, Adolfsson J, Aly M, Nordstrom T, Wiklund P, Brandberg Y, et al.
Prostate cancer screening in men aged 50-69 years (STHLM3): a prospective
population-based diagnostic study. Lancet Oncol. 2015;16(16):1667-76.
118. Kasivisvanathan V, Rannikko AS, Borghi M, Panebianco V, Mynderse LA, Vaarala
MH, et al. MRI-Targeted or Standard Biopsy for Prostate-Cancer Diagnosis. New
England Journal of Medicine. 2018;378(19):1767-77.
119. Drost FH, Osses DF, Nieboer D, Steyerberg EW, Bangma CH, Roobol MJ, Schoots
IG. Prostate MRI, with or without MRI-targeted biopsy, and systematic biopsy for
detecting prostate cancer. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2019;4(4):CD012663.
120. Mottet N, Van den Bergh R, Briers E, Cornford P, De Santis M, Fanti S, et al. Eau-
Eanm-Estro-Esur-Siog Guidelines On Prostate Cancer. Eur Assoc Urol. 2020:1-182.
121. Cui Y, Zhang X-P, Sun Y-S, Tang L, Shen L. Apparent diffusion coefficient:
potential imaging biomarker for prediction and early detection of response to
chemotherapy in hepatic metastases. Radiology. 2008;248(3):894-900.
122. Donati F, Boraschi P, P acciardi F, Cervelli R, Castagna M, Urbani L, et al. 3T
diffusion-weighted MRI in the response assessment of colorectal liver metastases
after chemotherapy: Correlation between ADC value and histological tumour
regression grading. European journal of radiology. 2017;91:57-65.
123. Eriksson S, Bengtsson J, Torén W, Lätt J, Andersson R, Sturesson C. Changes in
apparent diffusion coefficient and pathological response in colorectal liver metastases
after preoperative chemotherapy. Acta Radiologica. 2023;64(1):51-7.
124. Meyer H-J, Wienke A, Surov A. Discrimination between clinical significant and
insignificant prostate cancer with apparent diffusion coefficient–a systematic review
and meta analysis. BMC cancer. 2020;20:1-11.
125. Bengtsson J, Thimansson E, Baubeta E, Zackrisson S, Sundgren PC, Bjartell A,
Flondell-Site D. Correlation between ADC, ADC ratio, and Gleason Grade group in
prostate cancer patients undergoing radical prostatectomy: Retrospective multicenter
study with different MRI scanners. Front Oncol. 2023;13:1079040.
126. Moller JM, Boesen L, Hansen AE, Kettle s K, Logager V. Quantification of cross-
vendor variation in ADC measurements in vendor-specific prostate MRI-protocols.
Eur J Radiol. 2023;165:110942.
127. Woo S, Kim SY, Cho JY, Kim SH. Preoperative Evaluation of Prostate Cancer
Aggressiveness: Using ADC and ADC Ratio in Determining Gleason Score. AJR
Am J Roentgenol. 2016;207(1):114-20.
128. De Cobelli F, Ravelli S, Esposito A, Gi ganti F, Gallina A, Montorsi F, Del Maschio
A. Apparent diffusion coefficient value and ratio as noninvasive potential biomarkers
to predict prostate cancer grading: comparison with prostate biopsy and radical
prostatectomy specimen. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2015;204(3):550-7.
129. Schoots IG, Padhani AR. Risk ‐adapted biopsy decision based on prostate magnetic
resonance imaging and prostate‐specific antigen density for enhanced biopsy
avoidance in first prostate cancer diagnostic evaluation. BJU international.
2021;127(2):175.
130. Turkbey B, Haider MA. Deep learning-b ased artificial intelligence applications in
prostate MRI: brief summary. Br J Radiol. 2022;95(1131):20210563.
103
131. Thimansson E, Bengtsson J, Baubeta E, Engman J, Flondell-Site D, Bjartell A,
Zackrisson S. Deep learning algorithm performs similarly to radiologists in the
assessment of prostate volume on MRI. Eur Radiol. 2023;33(4):2519-28.
132. Zhang Z, Sejdic E. Radiological images and machine learning: Trends, perspectives,
and prospects. Comput Biol Med. 2019;108:354-70.
133. Najjar R. Redefining Radiology: A Revi ew of Artificial Intelligence Integration in
Medical Imaging. Diagnostics (Basel). 2023;13(17).
134. Winkel DJ, Grimm R, Benkert T, Kiefer B, Boll DT. A Fully Automated, End-to-
End Prostate MRI Workflow Solution Incorporating Dot, Ultrashort Biparametric
Imaging and Deep-Learning-based Detection, Classification, and Reporting.
Magnetom Flash. 2020:78-83.
135. Wolterink JM, Mukhopadhyay A, Leiner T, Vogl TJ, Bucher AM, Isgum I.
Generative Adversarial Networks: A Primer for Radiologists. Radiographics.
2021;41(3):840-57.
136. van Leeuwen KG, Schalekamp S, Rutten M, van Ginneken B, de Rooij M. Artificial
intelligence in radiology: 100 commercially available products and their scientific
evidence. Eur Radiol. 2021;31(6):3797-804.
137. van Leeuwen KG, Romeijn S. HealthAIre gister Utrecht, The Netherlands: Romion
Health; [cited 2024 Feb 28]. Available from: www.HealthAIregister.com.
138. Fryback DG, Thornbury JR. The efficacy of diagnostic imaging. Medical decision
making. 1991;11(2):88-94.
139. Björk J. Praktisk statistik för medicin och hälsa: Liber; 2011.
140. Commission E. Directive 2010/63/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council
of 22 September 2010 on the protection of animals used for scientific purposes. Off J
Eur Union. 2010;50:33-79.
141. Djurskyddslag (2018:1192) Stockholm: Landsbygds- och infrastrukturdepartementet
RSL; [cited 2024 Feb 6]. Available from: https://www.riksdagen.se/sv/dokument-
och-lagar/dokument/svensk-forfattningssamling/djurskyddslag-20181192_sfs-2018-
1192/.
142. Russell WMS, Burch RL. The principles of humane experimental technique:
Methuen; 1959.
143. Stampfl S, Stampfl U, Rehnitz C, Sc hnabel P, Satzl S, Christoph P, et al.
Experimental evaluation of early and long-term effects of microparticle embolization
in two different mini-pig models. Part I: kidney. Cardiovasc Intervent Radiol.
2007;30(2):257-67.
144. Keussen I, Bengtsson J, Gavier-Widen D, Karlstam E. Uterine artery embolization in
a sheep model: biodegradable versus non-degradable microspheres. Acta Radiol.
2018;59(10):1210-7.
145. Verret V, Pelage JP, Wassef M, Louguet S, Servais E, Bedouet L, et al. A novel
resorbable embolization microsphere for transient uterine artery occlusion: a
comparative study with trisacryl-gelatin microspheres in the sheep model. J Vasc
Interv Radiol. 2014;25(11):1759-66.
104
146. Maclean D, Vigneswaran G, Bryant T, Modi S, Hacking N. A retrospective cohort
study comparing a novel, spherical, resorbable particle against five established
embolic agents for uterine fibroid embolisation. Clin Radiol. 2021;76(6):452-7.
147. Rozzanigo U, Gatti F, Luppi G, Costa L, Petralia B, Pravadelli C, et al.
Chemoembolization with Degradable Starch Microspheres (DSM-TACE): expanding
indications in HCC multidisciplinary tumor board. Hepatoma Research. 2023;9.
148. Sergio A, Cristofori C, Cardin R, Pivetta G, Ragazzi R, Baldan A, et al.
Transcatheter arterial chemoembolization (TACE) in hepatocellular carcinoma
(HCC): the role of angiogenesis and invasiveness. Official journal of the American
College of Gastroenterology| ACG. 2008;103(4):914-21.
149. Chegai F, Orlacchio A, Merolla S, M onti S, Mannelli L. Intermediate hepatocellular
carcinoma: the role of transarterial therapy. Hepatic oncology. 2015;2(4):399-408.
150. Taylor JR, Thompson W. An introduction to error analysis: the study of uncertainties
in physical measurements: Springer; 1982.
151. Glen S. StatisicsHowTo.com [Internet] . Jacksonville [cited 2024]. Available from:
https://www.statisticshowto.com/statistics-basics/error-propagation/#multiplication.
152. Barrett T, Priest AN, Lawrence EM, Goldman DA, Warren AY, Gnanapragasam VJ,
et al. Ratio of Tumor to Normal Prostate Tissue Apparent Diffusion Coefficient as a
Method
for Quantifying DWI of the Prostate. AJR Am J Roentgenol.
2015;205(6):W585-93.
153. Boesen L, Chabanova E, Logager V, Balslev I, Thomsen HS. Apparent diffusion
coefficient ratio correlates significantly with prostate cancer gleason score at final
pathology. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2015;42(2):446-53.
154. Lebovici A, Sfrangeu SA, Feier D, Caraiani C, Lucan C, Suciu M, et al. Evaluation
of the normal-to-diseased apparent diffusion coefficient ratio as an indicator of
prostate cancer aggressiveness. BMC medical imaging. 2014;14(1):1-7.
155. Litjens GJ, Hambrock T, Hulsbergen–v an de Kaa C, Barentsz JO, Huisman HJ.
Interpatient variation in normal peripheral zone apparent diffusion coefficient: effect
on the prediction of prostate cancer aggressiveness. Radiology. 2012;265(1):260-6.
156. Rosenkrantz AB, Kopec M, Kong X, Me lamed J, Dakwar G, Babb JS, Taouli B.
Prostate cancer vs. post-biopsy hemorrhage: diagnosis with T2- and diffusion-
weighted imaging. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2010;31(6):1387-94.
157. Krauss W, Frey J, Heydorn Lagerlof J, Liden M, Thunberg P. Radiomics from
multisite MRI and clinical data to predict clinically significant prostate cancer. Acta
Radiol. 2023:2841851231216555.
158. Lee DK, Sung DJ, Kim CS, Heo Y, Lee JY, Park BJ, Kim MJ. Three-Dimensional
Convolutional Neural Network for Prostate MRI Segmentation and Comparison of
Prostate Volume Measurements by Use of Artificial Neural Network and Ellipsoid
Formula. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2020;214(6):1229-38.
159. Bulman JC, Toth R, Patel AD, Bloch BN, McMahon CJ, Ngo L, et al. Automated
computer-derived prostate volumes from MR imaging data: comparison with
radiologist-derived MR imaging and pathologic specimen volumes. Radiology.
2012;262(1):144-51.
105
160. Cuocolo R, Cipullo MB, Stanzione A, Ugga L, Romeo V, Radice L, et al. Machine
learning applications in prostate cancer magnetic resonance imaging. Eur Radiol
Exp. 2019;3(1):35.
161. Mazaheri Y, Goldman DA, Di Paolo PL, Akin O, Hricak H. Comparison of prostate
volume measured by endorectal coil MRI to prostate specimen volume and mass
after radical prostatectomy. Academic radiology. 2015;22(5):556-62.
162. Salvaggio G, Comelli A, Portoghese M, Cu taia G, Cannella R, Vernuccio F, et al.
Deep learning network for segmentation of the prostate gland with median lobe
enlargement in T2-weighted MR images: comparison with manual segmentation
method. Current problems in diagnostic radiology. 2022;51(3):328-33.
163. Lee DK, Sung DJ, Kim C-S, Heo Y, Lee JY, Park BJ, Kim MJ. Three-dimensional
convolutional neural network for prostate MRI segmentation and comparison of
prostate volume measurements by use of artificial neural network and ellipsoid
formula. American Journal of Roentgenology. 2020;214(6):1229-38.
164. Bezinque A, Moriarity A, Farrell C, Peabody H, Noyes SL, Lane BR. Determination
of prostate volume: a comparison of contemporary methods. Academic radiology.
2018;25(12):1582-7.
165. Ghafoor S, Becker AS, Woo S, Andrieu PIC, Stocker D, Gangai N, et al. Comparison
of PI-RADS versions 2.0 and 2.1 for MRI-based calculation of the prostate volume.
Academic Radiology. 2021;28(11):1548-56.
166. Szczepankiewicz F, van Westen D, Englund E, Westin CF, Stahlberg F, Latt J, et al.
The link between diffusion MRI and tumor heterogeneity: Mapping cell eccentricity
and density by diffusional variance decomposition (DIVIDE). Neuroimage.
2016;142:522-32.
167. Sandgren K, Nilsson E, Keeratijarut Lindberg A, Strandberg S, Blomqvist L, Bergh
A, et al. Registration of histopathology to magnetic resonance imaging of prostate
cancer. Phys Imaging Radiat Oncol. 2021;18:19-25.
Diagnostic Radiology
Department of Clinical Sciences, Lund
Lund University, Faculty of Medicine
Doctoral Dissertation Series 2024:82
ISBN 978-91-8021-577-0
ISSN 1652-8220
About the author
JOHAN BENGTSSON, M.D., is a
consultant radiologist currently affiliated
with Skåne University Hospital, Sweden.
Johan began his journey into specialised
medicine with interventional radiology
during the early years of his career,
coinciding with the inception of this
thesis. Over time, Johan shifted his
focus to diagnostic radiology, refining
his expertise in abdominal, urological,
and gynecological imaging utilising
cutting-edge CT and MRI technologies.
The culmination of his experiences in
these distinct branches sub-specialties
is portrayed in this thesis, reflecting his
commitment to advancing the field.
9 789180 215770 NORDIC SWAN ECOLABEL 3041 0903Printed by Media-Tryck, Lund 2024
Text is read by the "Ask this paper" AI Q&A widget below.
Extraction quality varies by source — PMC NXML preserves structure
cleanly, OA-HTML may include some navigation residue, and OA-PDF can
have broken hyphenation. The publisher copy
is the canonical version.