Heatwave winners and losers: cryptic coral holobionts differ in thermal tolerance

Abstract Extreme climatic events are reshaping ecosystems worldwide as individual organisms vary markedly in their ability to withstand these disturbances. Deciphering patterns of persistence on local scales is therefore critical for predicting biodiversity trajectories under intensifying climate extremes. In this study, we examined variation in thermal stress responses among individuals of the coral Stylophora pistillata species complex during a heatwave at Heron Island Reef, Australia. More than half of the focal coral colonies died on the reef, and survival of coral fragments maintained under ex situ common thermal stress conditions was significantly correlated with the survival of their source colony. This demonstrates that survival differences result largely from biological factors rather than differential thermal exposure across reef habitats. Under common garden conditions, we observed striking differences in bleaching severity and survival times among three sympatric cryptic taxa and their highly host-specific symbiont community. Within the most locally common taxon, corals from historically warmer and more seasonally variable reef habitats seem more susceptible to bleaching, contrary to expectations. Together, these results reveal how biological differences among cryptic taxa and among individuals can shape coral responses during a heatwave and advance our understanding of coral vulnerability in a rapidly warming world. Competing Interest Statement The authors have declared no competing interest.