Positive feedback promotes terrestrial emergence behaviour in an amphibious fish

Major ecological transitions such as the invasion of land by aquatic vertebrates have been hypothesised to be facilitated by positive feedback between habitat choice and phenotypic plasticity. We tested whether aquatic hypoxia, emergence behaviour, and plastic changes in gill surface area could create such a positive feedback loop and drive an amphibious fish to spend increasing amounts of time out of water. We found that terrestrially acclimated amphibious mangrove rivulus Kryptolebias marmoratus were more sensitive to, and less tolerant of, aquatic hypoxia relative to water-acclimated fish, which are necessary trade-offs for positive feedback to occur. Next, we acclimated fish to normoxic or hypoxic water with the opportunity to emerge for 7d to test the predictions that fish in hypoxic conditions should regularly leave water, reduce gill surface area, and become less hypoxia tolerant. Consistent with these predictions, fish in severe hypoxia spent almost 50% of the time out of water and coverage of the gill lamellae by an inter-lamellar cell mass almost doubled. Hypoxia acclimated fish were also more sensitive to acute aquatic hypoxia (emergence at higher oxygen levels), and lost equilibrium faster in hypoxic water compared to control fish. Thus, we show that a positive feedback loop develops in amphibious fish where emergence behaviour begets further emergence behaviour, driven by gill remodelling which reduces aquatic respiratory function. Such a scenario may explain how amphibious behaviour has repeatedly evolved in fishes that occupy hypoxic aquatic habitats despite the associated challenges of life on land.