Parallel ecological and evolutionary responses to selection in a natural bacterial community

Evolution can occur over ecological timescales, suggesting a potentially important role for rapid evolution in shaping community trait distributions. However, evidence of concordant eco-evolutionary dynamics often comes from in vitro studies of highly simplified communities, and measures of ecological and evolutionary dynamics are rarely directly comparable. Here, we quantified how ecological species sorting and rapid evolution simultaneously shape community trait distributions by tracking within and between-species changes in a key trait in a complex bacterial community. We focused on the production of siderophores; bacteria use these costly secreted metabolites to scavenge poorly soluble iron and to detoxify environments polluted with toxic non-ferrous metals. We found that responses to copper-imposed selection within and between species were ultimately the same – intermediate siderophore levels were favored – and occurred over similar timescales. Despite being a social trait, this level of siderophore production was selected regardless of whether species evolved in isolation or in a community context. Our study suggests that evolutionary selection can play a pivotal role in shaping community trait distributions within natural, highly complex, bacterial communities. Furthermore, trait evolution may not always be qualitatively affected by interactions with other community members. Significance Bacterial communities possess remarkable taxonomic and metabolic diversity and play a key role in nearly every biogeochemical process on Earth. Rapid evolution (occurring over ecological time scales) can in principle shape these processes, yet we have little understanding of its importance in natural communities. Here, we quantified how the production of metal-detoxifying siderophores is driven by species compositional changes and evolution in a compost community in response to copper stress. We found that siderophore production converged at intermediate levels, with evolutionary and ecological changes occurring at similar rates. Understanding how ecological and evolutionary processes contribute to shaping trait distributions will improve our ability to predict ecosystem responses to global change, and aid in the engineering of microbial consortia.