There and back again: the dynamic evolution of panarthropod germ cell specification mechanisms

Germ cells enable the reproduction of an organism and the continuity of its lineage. Across animals, these crucial cells are segregated from the soma at different times and places and via distinct mechanisms. Understanding the evolution of germ cell specification across animals is complicated by the difficulty of making meaningful comparisons of embryonic development between diverse animal species. Here, we characterize germ cell specification in Panarthropoda, an ancient clade that encompasses massive animal biodiversity, within which we can conduct meaningful comparative embryology. We amass data from centuries of studies describing the timing and mechanisms of germ cell formation, and apply ancestral state reconstruction to these data to propose novel hypotheses about the trajectory of evolution in this process. Furthermore, we speculate about the mechanisms underlying these evolutionary dynamics by considering the relationships among germ cell specification, concurrent developmental processes and the germ line gene network. Collectively, this Review derives new insights from a rich historical database of embryological observations, offering broad implications for understanding the evolution of metazoan germ cells.