Characterizing phytoplankton communities in the absence of resource-based competition

A bstract Under most natural marine conditions, phytoplankton cells suspended in the water column are too distantly spaced for direct competition for resources to be a routine occurrence. Accordingly, resource-based competitive exclusion should be rare. In contrast, contemporary ecosystem models typically predict an exclusion of larger phytoplankton size classes under low-nutrient conditions, an outcome interpreted as reflecting the competitive advantage of small cells having much higher nutrient ‘affinities’ than larger cells. Here, we develop mechanistically-focused expressions for steady-state, nutrient-limited phytoplankton growth that are consistent with the discrete, distantly-spaced cells of natural populations. These expressions are then encompassed in an ecosystem model that sustains diversity across all size classes over the full range in nutrient concentrations observed in the ocean. In other words, our model does not exhibit resource-based competitive exclusion between size classes. We show that the basis for species exclusions in earlier models is not a reflection of size-dependent nutrient ‘affinities’, but rather a consequence of inappropriate descriptions of non-grazing phytoplankton mortality.