Flower visitor groups show differential responses to individual and plot-level chemodiversity with consequences for plant fitness

ABSTRACT Chemodiversity, the diversity of specialised metabolites, plays a crucial role in mediating interactions between plants and animals, including insect herbivores and mutualists. Chemodiversity can be observed at both the individual and the population level. However, the impacts of chemodiversity at these two levels on interactions between plants and floral visitors, mainly pollinators and floral herbivores (florivores), are only poorly understood. This study aimed to investigate the effects of chemodiversity at both individual and plot level on pollinators and florivores, examining their mutual interactions. To investigate these questions, we used individuals of the perennial Tanacetum vulgare differing in their terpenoid composition, representing so-called chemotypes. We planted individuals of five distinct chemotypes in a common garden design with homogeneous (five plants of the same chemotype) and heterogeneous (five different chemotypes) plots and observed flower visits in dependence of individual chemotype and plot type. Seeds were collected from a subset of plants and germination rates determined. Our findings revealed that chemodiversity at the plot level significantly influenced pollinator visitation, with more visits on plants of heterogeneous plots. We also observed marginally more pollinators on one of the chemotypes grown in homogeneous plots. In contrast, chemotype but not plot type had a significant effect on florivore visits. Pollinator and florivore species richness did not vary with plot type. Furthermore, a negative correlation was observed between pollinator and florivore visits in one year, suggesting competitive interactions between these two groups. Germination rates were positively correlated with pollinator visits and affected by chemotype but not by florivore visits or plot type. Synthesis. Our study emphasizes the significance of the scale at which different chemical profiles are perceived by flower visitors, potentially influencing the reproductive fitness of plants. Exploring the ecology of these visitors and the varying selection pressures they exert on floral chemistry can help elucidating the evolutionary processes that maintain chemodiversity in natural environments.